insanefangirl I think the editing made the song not as good as it could have been. The extra autotune felt like they were trying to polish gold but scratched it instead. :( I still enjoy the song though and listen to it everyday xD
Hal Rollins thats.... a peerfect way to say it ..... i was thinking ever since i watched the mv for the first time that something was wrong ...... this song isnt polished enough .. its not with the girls ... its the song production itself .... it all makes since ..... *enlightened*
Jessica Evans I have to disagree. Miniskirt, Short Hair and Like a cat are way better than Heart Attack for me. I feel like this song is so loud and messy I just can't enjoy it.
Leila BB I think Miniskirt, Short Hair, and Like a Cat were the bad songs. They couldn't even sing them well live. Like a cat was the worst one I think. And the promotion was like a brothel or some sort.
@@jenesaiis yeah they all do, hyeojong stands out bc she is tall and the visual and choa with her big eyes and western features and cute hair style. She is definitely the one who stands out bc she comes off as the leader and vocals are stellar
@@nico-cd9fx look it up 2012 is considered 3rd generation by most people, EXO also debuted in 2012 and is also considered 3rd gen 1st gen is mid 1990’s-2004 2nd is 2005-2011 3rd is 2012-2018 4th is 2019-present
Hyejeong and Choa! I love Choa's new hair color and hairstyle. She looks like a character from Final Fantasy. (; Also everyone worked really hard on their diets. I hope they are healthy.
Why are AOA's backing tracks always so loud? I want to be able to hear them properly :( either way I love this comeback and they all look like theyre having heaps of fun.
I was watching the live stream of mcountdown and everyones was super loud... AOA deserve to have their backtrack lowered bc they can actually sing well while performing:/
dani rdz That channel overdoes it probably to make AOA look bad. If you watch the single fancams PlayMnet posts, they are CLEARLY singing live, you can hear them over the backing vocals.
They all look so pretty and stunning. The song is really catchy and it just gets better with each comeback~ Hyejeong's body though *drools* seriously my body goals ♥♥
sometimes i wish i could go back to the time i didnt know about everything that happened with them... they were the aces of kpop... theit scandal was one of the saddest
I'm sorry but Mina's waist really scares me, I just hope that she is naturally thin and that she didn't went on an extreme diet to become like this.. Cause it just feels like she's gonna break into two pieces anytime soon
***** Nothing officially, but I worry she's on an unhealthy diet. Of course, she could be naturally thin, nothing wrong with that. I'm just concerned because I know the crazy diets idols are forced to follow. :(
Ugh watching this live again no wonder mina is skinny. Shes been suffering depression and mental suicide inside due to jimin for 10 years during promotions. This bullying needs to be stopped. Jimin is so faked
@@fdscrl6016 as much as that makes sense, her mental state had to have had an effect on her body. I mean, it was so bad at that time she tried hurting herself.
@대장 I know she literally a bish but you its better to just shush you mouth its making it worse if you giving her hate comments its no nice she just have to learn how to be nice
Does anyone notice when the other girls have their solo, a lot of people cheer, but when Yuna starts singing, it's quiet? Like, bruh, Yuna is so talented and beautiful! ❤️
this a great comeback..they have generated a great momentum since "Confused" follow by "Miniskirt" to this "Heart Attack"..the momentum is there and they pick up where they left it with "Like a Cat"..nice job FNC..
I hope people stop judging Mina's body. Just when it hurts people when you call them fat, it hurts when you call them skinny. Please stop commenting on PEOPLES BODIES. I know you're worried about her but it hurts her even more when you comment things like she's unhealthy or "get help Mina". " Feed Mins ". It's so disrespectful!!
Finally someone was talking about hyejeong because people are just talking about other members is not fair you're treating hyejeong like she's not in the group you guys are not
+M Rizky Nugraha I don't think it has to do with being underage, because a lot of younger girl groups show their stomach (and way more), so it might be that she's not "skinny" enough to wear crop tops (which is a totally lie).
If Jimin not bully Mina,Mina will not leave AOA they will be perfect and Jimin not getting hate. I'm a fan of AOA back then,when I heard that Jimin bullying Mina,Choa left AOA and Mina also leave AOA. I'm not hating AOA but lose interest because kind of disapointed also bcs Mina left AOA. MINA IS MY BIAS,STAY STRONG OUR MINA
mina so cute XD i always got goose bumps when choa appears in close up, she rules the close up. every member does, but her is just asdfdggdf thats a really loud scream on seolhyun's part. i cant blame them tho XD and jimin "hey" adlibs!! indeed the hey fairy
I'm no longer a stan of this group because of the whole scandal that happened, but it sucks to know that we thought that jimin was a good leader but in reality she was just a bully, no ammount of sorry's will ever cure the damage she caused mina for over 10 years, we love you mina!
@@dreamermingue have you known what jimin did?she's a bully and such a fake person she's a plastic and that's why i hate her mina didn't deserve to be bullied by jimin
@@yoshi3464 They prolly meant that we should just stop hating on Jimin and give love to Mina. People really be giving her the attention she wanted nowadays, it's getting annoying. Why can't y'all just ignore Jimin and let it go. Supporting Mina instead of wasting time on Jimin. Jimin with her attitude prolly doesn't give a f### and she's not sorry. Y'all really need to ignore her so her career will be over once and for all. They weren't supporting Jimin too. I think you took their comment in the wrong way, just saying.
Everyone is cute but HYEJEONG IS BAE I just can't even,always Mina is not one of my fave but is body goal tbh And am I the only who thinks seolhyun looks like snsd Seohyun+jungkook lol Anyways love them
+Princess M-sushi looking closely to seolhyun's pics, yes i do see some sort of similarity, overall but not very specific....i saw someone say that it's her smile that's similar to jungkook's but idk for me not so much....lol
The reason why i like this song is because of Choa's "wanjeon banhae banhae beoryeosseoyo budeureoun moksorie banhae banhae beoryeosseoyo nan tteollyeo" I cant stop listening to this song!!!!
I see all the performances and... I feel really sed.... I feel like they try not to show Mina.... Like she just a dancer... And not a part of the group..
Mina and Yuna was so cute there...also jimin...also choa...also...............all of them soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cute....my fav bias are mina and yuna♥
Just please guys what happened between Mina and jimin stays between them it isn’t are business Yelling at jimin won’t help What happens to jimin doesn’t give you a pass to be rude. And please stop flooding the comments with the drama This is about the performance not about the drama 2:58 is my favorite part
The fanboys going nuts.. esp. when it's Seolhyun's parts.. haha Yuna.. so pretty!! :) I really like her with red hair! xD Choa.. I don't think I'll EVER get tired of her short blonde hair.. I know some people say she should get a new look.. but tbh I'm so used to her like this now.. always our lovely sexy angel! :3 And I gotta say that Mina looks adorable! in here! For a moment she reminded me of Juniel with that hairstyle haha! Too cute! :) Fighting, AOA!!!
![[AOA - Bingle Bangle] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 180531 EP.572](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gNwvVGptZz8/mqdefault.jpg)
![[AOA - Bingle Bangle] Comeback Stage | M COUNTDOWN 180531 EP.572](/img/tr.png)
![[HOT] AOA - Heart Attack, 에이오에이 - 심쿵해, Show Music core 20150704](/img/1.gif)
Honestly this is such a great comeback. One of their catchiest songs yet.
i know right!^^ some people said this comeback is AOA's worst one,but i don't agree with them._. but of course everybode has their own opinions
Maria Gomez Agree. However there were a lot of unnecessary and unpolished parts. Brave Brothers aren't doing great songs recently.
insanefangirl I think the editing made the song not as good as it could have been. The extra autotune felt like they were trying to polish gold but scratched it instead. :( I still enjoy the song though and listen to it everyday xD
Hal Rollins thats.... a peerfect way to say it ..... i was thinking ever since i watched the mv for the first time that something was wrong ...... this song isnt polished enough .. its not with the girls ... its the song production itself .... it all makes since ..... *enlightened*
Maria Gomez I agree.
Am I the only one who has loved Yuna since i began to get to know AOA? I haven't seen any comments concerning her so far...
i... i like Yuna...
+slinkyatrest I hate yuna
+Sophie Wang I love you when I first saw your avatar, LOL
+Sophie Wang Yuna is the best
Well yuna is my second favorite member,cuz yuna is just.....special(Innocent sexynes)
Who else is watching this in 2019 cuz they miss them
me 😢
Choa so much!
Me :(
2020 😢
THEY MISS THEM!! WHAT A GREAT PRHRASE IN YOUR SENTENCE!!
One of the few groups that literally gets better and better with each release.. Every song tops the last 💙😭
Jessica Evans I have to disagree. Miniskirt, Short Hair and Like a cat are way better than Heart Attack for me. I feel like this song is so loud and messy I just can't enjoy it.
Leila BB i think you're right ! :) Like a cat was an amazing song !!!!
Leila BB I think Miniskirt, Short Hair, and Like a Cat were the bad songs. They couldn't even sing them well live. Like a cat was the worst one I think. And the promotion was like a brothel or some sort.
Cookie Master lol so that's why they are a trending group ouch it hurts right?
I thought this and short hair were really good. Like a Cat got old really quickly and was kind of boring.
For their cute concepts i think choa carries them out the most, and for their sexier ones, hyejong stands out
I think this one is more sexy than cute. Could be my asian kink tho. Or the outfits. Or Choas voice.
I agree with both of you lol.
But don't they all stand out? They're all so unique and give unique vibes compared to other kpop girl group members/bands.
@@jenesaiis yeah they all do, hyeojong stands out bc she is tall and the visual and choa with her big eyes and western features and cute hair style. She is definitely the one who stands out bc she comes off as the leader and vocals are stellar
@@jenesaiis I think choa stood out the most because of her voice
Mina's waist is like the size of my thigh.
beICONickk Her waist is 17.9 inches. My arms are just under 17.
Mi O yes @0:51
Lol ikr!
Her waist is only 17.9 inches
My thighs 20 inches! So her waist is literally smaller than my thigh
@IDGAF HOE I dont think bullying made her waist small..she doesnt look manulorish or anything
any choa bias there
.....present......
Meee
Me
+Irish Flores me me meeeee!!
meee
Irish Flores
>right here
AOA is one of the best groups from 2nd gen. and you can't deny it
They’re 3rd gen tho
@@rawrdrey they debuted in 2012 they're 2nd gen
@@nico-cd9fx look it up 2012 is considered 3rd generation by most people, EXO also debuted in 2012 and is also considered 3rd gen
1st gen is mid 1990’s-2004
2nd is 2005-2011
3rd is 2012-2018
4th is 2019-present
@@rawrdrey 4th Gen started in 2017, Dreamcatcher and G idle are considered 4th Gen
@@nico-cd9fx EXO debuted before AOA and they are 3rd gen
choa looks so stunning TT__TT i can't even
Ikr? As always
POWMMMMMMMMM like a Barbie doll I swear. Blond, slim and tall and not to forget the sparkling pink clothes
Back after 6 years and still can’t get over this 😭😭❤️❤️
sameee
Same 😭😭😭😭😭
such a hype song!!
Aoa에서 애초에 설현은 관심 없었고 초아밖에 몰랐던 사람인데 민아가 뭐 예쁘겠어 했는데 맴버 하나하나 세세하게 보니까 진짜 민아 역대급 미모네 ㄷㄷㄷ 이렇게 예뻤던 걸 몰라준게 미안함
에이오에이언니들심쿵해엠카공연보실분모이기
나는 설현만 알았음ㅋㅋ
그뭔십
어쩌라고
She’s manipulative, but pretty. But manipulative and pretty just don’t match!
Hyejeong and Choa! I love Choa's new hair color and hairstyle. She looks like a character from Final Fantasy. (; Also everyone worked really hard on their diets. I hope they are healthy.
Mina part so cute
Why are AOA's backing tracks always so loud? I want to be able to hear them properly :( either way I love this comeback and they all look like theyre having heaps of fun.
ChunjisEyes Watch the Show Champion performance, you can hear them loudly ^^
ChunjisEyes I heard Jimin live pretty loudly at the end lol, and I think i heard Mina live too
I was watching the live stream of mcountdown and everyones was super loud... AOA deserve to have their backtrack lowered bc they can actually sing well while performing:/
I subscribed to this channel that takes off the background music and only leaves their voice but they are lip singing. :(
dani rdz That channel overdoes it probably to make AOA look bad. If you watch the single fancams PlayMnet posts, they are CLEARLY singing live, you can hear them over the backing vocals.
They all look so pretty and stunning. The song is really catchy and it just gets better with each comeback~ Hyejeong's body though *drools* seriously my body goals ♥♥
honestly im falling in love seeing Choa . She so attractive
It's sad with what happened and is happening to AOA right now
I cant be the only one noticing that Choa looked very pretty in this comeback right?
I feel tired for ChoA's throat lol
에이오에이언니들심쿵해엠카공연보실분모이기
Everything started to fall after ChoA leave the group. She was just to perfect, the vacuum was never properly filled 😭💔
Mina so prettyyyyyy, and did choa eat their cd?shes so goooood
HyeJeong is one of those idols no one pays any attention to, but that is ridiculously good looking.
sometimes i wish i could go back to the time i didnt know about everything that happened with them... they were the aces of kpop... theit scandal was one of the saddest
I'd still put this up against any number of billion times viewed k-idol videos. Angels they most certainly are 🤗. Everyone, have a lovely day! 👋🥰
I'm sorry but Mina's waist really scares me, I just hope that she is naturally thin and that she didn't went on an extreme diet to become like this.. Cause it just feels like she's gonna break into two pieces anytime soon
dont worry she is just naturally short and has a small figure she is like the other members in fact she and seol eats the most out of the members
your comment is actually very rude
@@user-sw8ft1fs4f I'm sorry but what's rude here?
아마 아이돌중 설현보다 예쁜사람은 없을듯 ㄹㅇ
블랙핑크 지수
레드벨벳 아이린
에이오에이 설현이 걸그룹 3대 미녀 같음
뭔소리 장원영이 제일 이쁨
@@채채-d1b she looks like a child/teenager.
장원영 까리나 설윤이 설현보다 더 이쁘지만 설현은 까무잡 건강미인 스타일이라 결이 다른듯 ㅉ😂
please feed mina.... :(
kim haru I really hope she's okay. :( We love you MinA~
Berry Punch hope she is ok? Is something wrong with her?
***** Nothing officially, but I worry she's on an unhealthy diet. Of course, she could be naturally thin, nothing wrong with that. I'm just concerned because I know the crazy diets idols are forced to follow. :(
Berry Punch That is true, well hopefully she is ok
Haha dont worry .. mina currently become a MC it called "gourmet road" she must be eat a lot
Seolhyun and Mina are so pretty 😍😍
Ugh watching this live again no wonder mina is skinny. Shes been suffering depression and mental suicide inside due to jimin for 10 years during promotions. This bullying needs to be stopped. Jimin is so faked
TaketwoStepX0 “Fake”.
What a hypocrite lol so because someone is skinny they must be mentally ill? I love Mina but ??? these type of comments assuming stuff are not good
@@fdscrl6016 as much as that makes sense, her mental state had to have had an effect on her body. I mean, it was so bad at that time she tried hurting herself.
@대장 I know she literally a bish but you its better to just shush you mouth its making it worse if you giving her hate comments its no nice she just have to learn how to be nice
Well everyone kept talking about that these days
So l don't wanted to talk about it anymore
Their outfit in this performance reminds me of SNSD Oh! a lot. I miss Kpop 2010-2011.
Yesss
Thuy Trang AOA made it come back ^.^
i like the outfit
not every pink is for snsd 😐
Mariam Safwan it's not about the color.
Does anyone notice when the other girls have their solo, a lot of people cheer, but when Yuna starts singing, it's quiet? Like, bruh, Yuna is so talented and beautiful! ❤️
this a great comeback..they have generated a great momentum since "Confused" follow by "Miniskirt" to this "Heart Attack"..the momentum is there and they pick up where they left it with "Like a Cat"..nice job FNC..
im not even an aoa fan but when i listen to every song of them a nostalgia comes 😭
高校受験の勉強の時ずっと聴いて元気を貰ってた曲です.
8 years later this song still slaps
Here for Jimin!!!
AoA fighting!!!!
"Palapala Palyeoseoyo" the part that got me HOOKED!!!!!!!!!!
It's actually "banhae banhae beoreyeosseo" ikr that part is really catchy idk why
insanefangirl doesn't B change to P sometimes though? and now i can't sing it to myself and get it to fit lol
Koreans can pronounce them both at the same time lol (B and P)
jajjangsoo Then I guess its another obstacle for me while im learning korean along with R/L
Guys I am Korean and it is actually
'Ban-hae ban-hae beo-ryeo-sseo-yo'
#WeLoveYouKwonMina
This song has something of everything, it's definitely their best.
I really miss these girls
설현 초아 진짜 미쳤다
I'm bias Hyejeong but in this vid, Mina so pretty
Jimin looks like she's so happy JAD is having so much fun omg I love her
Seolhyun is so beautiful !! ^_^
Mina is sooooo pretty !! AOA fighting!!
listen in 2024❤
I hope people stop judging Mina's body. Just when it hurts people when you call them fat, it hurts when you call them skinny. Please stop commenting on PEOPLES BODIES. I know you're worried about her but it hurts her even more when you comment things like she's unhealthy or "get help Mina". " Feed Mins ". It's so disrespectful!!
HYEJEONG!!! 😍😍😍
I have yet to hear or see any k-pop girl better than AOA.
AOA FIGHTING
HYEJEONGGGGGGGGGGGGG
Hyejeong queen
❤️
Finally someone was talking about hyejeong because people are just talking about other members is not fair you're treating hyejeong like she's not in the group you guys are not
설현 진짜 개이쁘다
I love how this is a fun comeback have fun aoa!!!
LOVE Choa's new hair
Yuna, Hyejeong, and Mina.
Choa and Mina>>>>
Why is Chanmi often hide her tummy all time, but in here she show it. Her waist maybe not as small as the rest, but at least she's in shape here
underage situation (i think?) haha even in AOA summer photobook they only chanmi not there.
+M Rizky Nugraha I don't think it has to do with being underage, because a lot of younger girl groups show their stomach (and way more), so it might be that she's not "skinny" enough to wear crop tops (which is a totally lie).
it was GG (SNSD) who really got me into KPOP but it was this group and this song who did everything that mattered.
ChoA looks so sweet oh my heart ㅠㅠ
Choa is so beautiful and professional
OMG Mina‘s so beautiful！！！
❤❤Choa❤❤Mina❤❤
It was shocked that Jimin bullied Mina. I still can't accept that is true. My AOA, my childhood.
AOA is such a great group but sadly they didnt active anymore!
확실히 다르긴 하네 이때 민아는 표정 부터가 다르다 빙글뱅글때랑은 확연히 다름
Minaaaa 💓💓💓💓💓
If Jimin not bully Mina,Mina will not leave AOA they will be perfect and Jimin not getting hate. I'm a fan of AOA back then,when I heard that Jimin bullying Mina,Choa left AOA and Mina also leave AOA. I'm not hating AOA but lose interest because kind of disapointed also bcs Mina left AOA. MINA IS MY BIAS,STAY STRONG OUR MINA
What if Mina never spoke up? Jimin would have been still smiling like this adorably.
Mina did the right thing
I am just watching mina she so pretty
is it funny when your bias from both AOA and BTS are Jimin? Park Jimin and Shin Jimin?
same
Hahahahaha same!!
lmao SAME
Hmm
i want to ask now. Have you read or know the news about Shim Jim in bullying Kwon Mina so bad?
Do you still stanning her?
mina so cute XD
i always got goose bumps when choa appears in close up, she rules the close up. every member does, but her is just asdfdggdf
thats a really loud scream on seolhyun's part. i cant blame them tho XD
and jimin "hey" adlibs!! indeed the hey fairy
I'm no longer a stan of this group because of the whole scandal that happened, but it sucks to know that we thought that jimin was a good leader but in reality she was just a bully, no ammount of sorry's will ever cure the damage she caused mina for over 10 years, we love you mina!
JIMIN LOOKS SO CUTE😍😍😍
jimin is so smiley in this performance, it's too cute 😭💓 oh i miss them so much
I’m so sorry, I’m too late for this amazing track.
me watching this:
Jimin: appeared
me: quit youtube
YODA TZUYU stop being rude
@@dreamermingue have you known what jimin did?she's a bully and such a fake person she's a plastic and that's why i hate her mina didn't deserve to be bullied by jimin
@@dreamermingue well, Jimin is trash
@@yoshi3464 They prolly meant that we should just stop hating on Jimin and give love to Mina. People really be giving her the attention she wanted nowadays, it's getting annoying. Why can't y'all just ignore Jimin and let it go. Supporting Mina instead of wasting time on Jimin. Jimin with her attitude prolly doesn't give a f### and she's not sorry. Y'all really need to ignore her so her career will be over once and for all. They weren't supporting Jimin too. I think you took their comment in the wrong way, just saying.
😐 stupid
Awww the memories!!!! This was the first Kpop song I learned the choreo to🥹😍🥰
miss you AoA
Everyone is cute but HYEJEONG IS BAE I just can't even,always
Mina is not one of my fave but is body goal tbh
And am I the only who thinks seolhyun looks like snsd Seohyun+jungkook lol
Anyways love them
What's her similarity with jungkook? I think I'm the only one who doesn't notice.....
I don't know, I just think they got a little something alike but I don't know what
+Princess M-sushi looking closely to seolhyun's pics, yes i do see some sort of similarity, overall but not very specific....i saw someone say that it's her smile that's similar to jungkook's but idk for me not so much....lol
+Princess M-sushi ok call me weird but i finally saw their similarity. It really is their smile lmao
+Princess M-sushi ok call me weird but i finally saw their similarity. It really is their smile lmao
Mina🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
The reason why i like this song is because of Choa's "wanjeon banhae banhae beoryeosseoyo
budeureoun moksorie
banhae banhae beoryeosseoyo
nan tteollyeo" I cant stop listening to this song!!!!
I see all the performances and... I feel really sed.... I feel like they try not to show Mina.... Like she just a dancer... And not a part of the group..
Mina and Yuna was so cute there...also jimin...also choa...also...............all of them soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo cute....my fav bias are mina and yuna♥
I can relate, my favourites too~
can ya’ll stop shitting on every AOA video talking about jimin pls. appreciate the other girls and ignore jimin.
Just please guys what happened between Mina and jimin stays between them it isn’t are business
Yelling at jimin won’t help
What happens to jimin doesn’t give you a pass to be rude.
And please stop flooding the comments with the drama This is about the performance not about the drama
2:58 is my favorite part
That's my favorite part too
Mina is just soooo prettyyyy :xxxx
0:22 the ppl scream as soon as she walks to the front, lol they crazy bout her just like me
Who's here after watching Mina's fancam?
I can now see why Heechul is so jealous with these girls lol Bcos they are sooo beautiful! *O*
I know alot of idol who can pull off a short hair,but Choa is ultimately the only idol for who is really perfect for short white colored hair
Mina is wrecking my bias list.
2:00 OMG did you see how'd jimin drop it in the back? daaamn girl XD
am i the only one who thinks that Choa is really really pretty and attractive? >.
My goshh I really love this comeback!! Song, concept, outfits, everything!!
The fanboys going nuts.. esp. when it's Seolhyun's parts.. haha
Yuna.. so pretty!! :) I really like her with red hair! xD
Choa.. I don't think I'll EVER get tired of her short blonde hair.. I know some people say she should get a new look.. but tbh I'm so used to her like this now.. always our lovely sexy angel! :3
And I gotta say that Mina looks adorable! in here! For a moment she reminded me of Juniel with that hairstyle haha! Too cute! :)
Fighting, AOA!!!
Kyattchan i though were fan girls not boys
I love ChoA
ChoA is so pretty OMFG 😭❤️❤️❤️
kind off topic but is m countdown the most famous korean music show? they always seem to have the coolest stages and all
nope, inkigayo is the most coolest comeback stage for idols 😊
Mnet is the most famous and most known music show. But Ingikayo has the best stages ^^
The song is get better when it's live