Excellent Documentary on what a Taboo subject i come from Belfast & was born in 1967 so i witnessed alot of ' The Troubles' it was a War thankfully over now but the disappeared need to be found & given back to their loved ones only then can the War really be over!
I grew up in Cork 1969-1990, we saw the troubles on tv, but there was no issues between protestants and catholic's where I lived, no talk of any of these stories in the video, this is my first time hearing any of this!
@@TheScouseassassin I watched the 2 part program on RTE player when it was originally aired, but isn't RUclips great🙂? Every time you rewatch a program you might see/hear something you didn't pick up on the first time.
As I was watching this documentary it was interrupted by Eric Cantona doing an advert for William Hill bookmakers. For those who dont know William Hill was a young Black & Tan stationed in Cork during the Irish War of Independence. According to local historians he was well liked by the local people.
Any chance of exploring the dark side of unionists and the tories and how many people disappeared under their watch or how about just getting them to own up to the atrocities they are responsible for
I think on sheer numbers and "atrocities" committed? The Republican terrorists win hands down. You cannot avoid blame by shifting a narrative onto the opposite side.
@Jon I'd rethink what you've just said no one is passing any blame, but at least the republican side owns up to 99% of it sometimes even before before it happens the other side though still deny how deep the hatred and collusion really went and let's not forget one simple undisputed fact here the republican side didn't start this the English and and the unionist that followed did never forget that I suggest you go read up on your history mo chara it goes way back before the troubles or 1916 way way back
Britian will never allow themselves to be seen as the monsters they really are. From India to Ireland to Africa. They'll hide all their crimes on humanity.
@@BullcutterHe has no agenda and tells the truth. His grand uncle is young Irish patriot and martyr Kevin Barry who was hanged by the British in November 1920.
Sing sing looked pretty grim ☹️Ned Maloney seems to be quite pleased of his achievements .. sad to think at that age you haven’t a place in heaven ..still I suppose you get what u deserve in the end ...
One of the best documentaries I’ve ever seen on the IRA and the invasion of Ireland. Boy those guys were absolutely ruthless. I’ve never heard of Sing Sing prison in Cork,but it’s definitely on the bucket list to see when I go over to Cork next. Where is the bog/forest where they executed all those people?
It's not a prison, it's a vault illegally used for the incarceration, torture and subsequent murders of people the IRA believed were spies! Not somewhere any normal individual should want to see in my opinion!
John Roche Hello.the post you have sent me.I am somewhat surprised,as I have no recollection of sending you any post regarding Ireland and the I.R.A. I am really at a loss on this score. Regards.
My sincere apologies. Could you please tell what my post consisted of. I am replying to several people and obviously sent it to you by mistake. Once again sorry for the misunderstanding.
Does anybody know the names of the two tans in Sing Sing at the end of part 1. My great uncle Bertie and comrade were abducted by the IRA in November 1920. They were subsequently executed. Their bodies were never returned at the end of the war of independence. Re-listening to Jim Fitzgerald retailing of the story, he mentions that the two were picked up at Emmett Place. This is consistent with the official narrative. The portrayal does appear to be of Bertram Agnew and Lionel Mitchell.
M8 get in touch with the bloke in the programme for info his names on screen at start or might have an email address in Documentary credits etc all you can do is ask i hope you get answers as they should all be returned or found & properly buried as they don't get a taste of what no War & then Peace feels like
@@seanohare5488 oh! Were the bodies that were returned to their families innocent? The IRA members who also committed atrocities of Irish civilians did not do it for Ireland. As a kid who didn't pay attention in history class I always thought Michael Collins was killed by the British. Can you imagine the shock and disillusionment I felt when I found he was killed after the British left? And by his own! Getting a body back depended on who you were, and obviously the British families who get their son/husband's body returned had more to offer those particular IRA members in return, than the Irish families they looked down on. I'm not saying I would be any different, who knows for sure what they would do in the same circumstance.
O' Halpin is a relative of young Irish patriot Kevin Barry who was hanged by the British authorities at the age of 18. I would love to see a documentary about the 3 Catholic clergymen that were murdered by the Auxiliaries. Fr Michael Griffith in Co.Galway in November 1920 who thought he was visiting a sick member of his parish after being called but it was a deliberate trap by the Auxiliaries. Also Canon Magner who was over 70 and was killed in cold blood by an Auxiliary in Co.Cork in December 1920 and in the same incident this Auxiliary also killed an Irishman in his 20's but would be considered "Special Needs" in today's parlance. Then there was Fr James O' Callaghan who was killed in Co.Cork in June 1921.
A lot of these may have been personal vendettas and revenge killings. And apparently that 15 year old boy was killed for just being English. That was a good enough reason to kill him by IRA standards just like those teenage drummer boys.
Patrick Deasy an IRA Volunteer(aged 16) was KIA in the Kilmichael Ambush Co.Cork on 28th November 1920. Kevin Barry was an IRA Volunteer who was hanged by the British authorities at the age of 18 for taking part in an ambush in Dublin City on 22nd September 1920 which left 3 soldiers dead from the Duke Of Wellington Regiment including a 15 year old 2 weeks short of his 16th birthday. On 31st May 1921 in Youghal,Co Cork the IRA using an IED ambushed the band of the Hampshire Regiment which left 7 soldiers dead including 3 teenagers(aged 14 to 16) and over 20 wounded. Then there was the 3 bandboys of the Manchester Regiment who were abducted and killed in Co.Cork in June 1921 who were also young teenagers. Several Irish civilian teenagers were killed by Crown Forces during the conflict. The Crown Forces and in particular the Auxiliaries murdered 3 Catholic Priests including Canon Magner who was over 70 years of age. The historian who made this documentary is Eunan O'Halpin and is a relative of young Irish patriot Kevin Barry who along with another 9 IRA men were given State Funerals in tbe Republic of Ireland in the early 2000's.
There was a young teenager in Co.Galway aged 14 who used to travel around with the Crown Forces and point out the homes of Republican sympathisers which were later burned down. This teenager's name was William Joyce and would be better known as an adult as Lord Haw Haw who worked in Germany in the propaganda department under Gobbels during WW2 . As you know he was captured by the British and hanged for treason. He literally tried to save his neck by pointing out his service to the Crown during the Irish War of Independence.
Another gombeen historian who believe wars can be fought, won and lost, without atrocities and civilian casualties. There are no clean wars. War, and those engaged in prosecuting it, is a barbaric affair. War brings out the worst excesses in humans, be they military or administrators of that war. The warfare in Ireland of 1918 to 1922 wasn't special. Neither were the atrocities on all sides. They were typical of wars of independence across Europe and the world, included among them Finland's independence and subsequent civil war. Ireland, under Gaelic laws and rule, existed for over 1,700 years before the Act of Union with Britain. Lots of wars, local and wider, between Gaelic tribal dynasties through the centuries. Wars against the Norse, the Franco Normans, and later the Sasanach (Germanic Angles and Saxons, later to evolve in to the English). There's no doubt millions died in the collective of these wars, in battle, "collateral" deaths, persecution and famine. You will hear crickets among most historians in Ireland about this 1,600 year plus period in Irish history. There seems to be an obsession with Irish independence and the "blood lust" of those who fought an enemy to win that freedom. These same historians seem to have no issues with Irishmen involved in wars and civilian atrocities wearing the uniform of the British crown. After all, orders are orders, and refusal to obey orders subject to military discipline and consequences. It is unfortunate that many historians in Ireland, like Eunan O'Halpin, approach worthy subjects like this one with a baked-in, politically motivated agenda rather than an open and neutral mind that followed the facts and understood the barbarity that is war in all its forms.
I totally agree 0 halpin is disgraceful he can't even Honor his great uncle's killed as it's men including the 18;year old kevin Barry hanged by the bloody Brits kevin Barry is in a famous song sung by popular singers like leornard Cohen and Paul Robeson
What? Wait, about the missing? Should their remains be returned for burial to their families or not? I stupidly thought that that's what this video was about😕
Totally agree apart from being horrific war is childish at best insane. Why people expect rules of behaviour as if it was some condonable sport or something never fails to amaze me.
It wasn't an Anglo Irish war, it was an insurgency, of which Britain has faced many in its empires decline and unlike dictatorship's, walk away when it becomes too costly for them, rather than take the very extreme measures necessary to suppress a population. Those poor people were clandestinely killed and removed from their families, purely for sectarian ideology, legitimising it, by calling it a war is not appropriate. Ulster has taken on many forms in its extremely long and proud history, at the moment historical sectarian decisions have reduced it to six counties, but it is still Ulster and will always be. Maybe someday even reverting back to its Ulster name, flag and original size, who knows, maybe to even more than nine counties. Ireland has always been divided, that’s the Irish way, historically much more than today, the concept of unification was actually brought to Ireland by the British, as part of their expansionist colonial campaign, totally planned, implemented and managed by their local administrator, Dublin. Dublin learnt well, it still pursues a British agenda. Rewriting history to suit an expansionist narrative, exaggerating historical events, justifying proxy incursions, ethnic cleansing, genocide, providing safe havens and proxy violence, is unfortunately not uncommon in Ireland. The Republic of Ireland have totally rewritten and sanitised, not only Dublin's part in Irish history, but also foolishly inserted a part of this fictionalised version of history, into their constitution and national anthem. As evidence for all to see and verify for themselves how Dublin abuses history. "A Nation Once Again" or “reunification” are fictional, concepts, fantasy, nonsense statements, as there was never a sovereign Southern Irish government that governed Ulster, now called Northern Ireland. Ulster or Britain have been the only two historical rulers of Ulster. Ulster was independent kingdom before being subdued and ruled by the British, conquered centuries after our Southern Irish neighbours. “A Nation Once Again” for Ulster, now unfortunately called Northern Ireland, would be independence, should it eventually decide to split with the UK. Definitely not the disaster that unification or this historically abused phrase “A New Ireland” inflicted on the counties Donegal, Cavan, Monaghan and literally the whole west coast of Ireland, incessantly promoted by the Republic of Ireland and their Northern Irish proxies. Used frequently as a justification for proxy violence and disruption in Northern Ireland and to distract our Southern Irish neighbours from the performance of historically abysmal Irish Republican governments.
The presenter repeatedly states that many inocent civilians were wrongly excited by the IRA, why then has he presented literally zero evidence of this aledged fact? There is the horrific reality that children were killed, the three drummer boys, and the English civilian 15year old. These killings are shocking, although one of the drummer boys was old enough to bear arms so could arguably be discounted from the sad total. Other than these cases all others so far outlined in this episode for either uniformed members of British Crown forces, or spy's and informers way beyond any reasonable doubt. It detracts from the argument that there was so much obvious injustice and thoughtless unfair killing if in the 40 odd minutes of each episode you cannot present credible and factual testimony to support the hypothesis that this was anything but an anomaly.
I have great admiration for those that fight for themselves and the ability to control their own destiny. Nevertheless, I nothing but scorn and anger for the Irish Troubles and the insidious way they destroyed so many families! It always seemed to me that too many people were killed for just trying to live their lives on their own terms by people who demanded that all give in to their demands!
and how many lives did the british destroy , and for how many hundreds of years , not just in Ireland but all over the world . in such a war this can be expected , its not pretty its just the realities of war under operation. funny these say nothing about what the black and tans did in those times . only one side being told here
@@schroderingerscat I don’t disagree with you. However, my comment relates to the Irish on Irish violence which is really Protestant versus Catholic violence. That is what is so nonsensical to me. Whatever your beliefs may be, one Christian group fighting another because of the relatively minor difference in their beliefs is beyond stupid, it is inhumane.
@@allaneisner4729 it's not about their religion, it's nationalist against Loyalist, you can have either religion on both sides. The Loyalists don't want to be ruled from Dublin. But the majority of the people just want to live in peace, sadly no one ever listens to the majority!
Is it wrong for families to want the remains of their relatives returned for burial? How come some British remains were returned while Irish remains are still missing?
As like all violent revolutions , tragedies are going to occur . But the reality of this one, is that 800 years of British injustice. How many innocent Irish were killed by the British in those 800 years?…. Millions killed in the potato famine alone.! Never forget
I wonder what the motivation of the pro-British Irish was ... were they endeared to the British thru something akin to patriotism ? ...or were rewards offered for information ? ... should have included this in your otherwise very good documentary
Jack, you need to read a lot more about the History of Ulster, then you understand why there are people who value their union with the UK. It has alot to do with religion.
Are you aware there was hundreds of Irish Great War veterans in the IRA during the Irish War of Independence 1919-1921 including 5 who were decorated for bravery one of which was a VC recipient? The Director of Training for the IRA at GHQ in Dublin was Emmet Dalton who while serving with the 9th Bn Royal Dublin Fusiliers was awarded the Military Cross for bravery at Guinchy in September 1916 during the latter stages of the Battle of the Somme. The most successful IRA Field Commander in the conflict was Tom Barry who served with the Royal Field Artillery with the rank of Bombardier and saw service in the Middle East theatre during WW1. He was part of the relief force who failed to break the siege at Kut,Mesopotamia(modern day Iraq) when British General Townsend and his garrison was besieged.
Soo anglo-occupants was tortured and beaten to death! they tasted their own medicine. What’s the problem here? The only problem here is existing of Anglia nowadays. But this is a temporary issue
An excellent documentary by a thoroughly humane & decent academic.
I can't remember who said "Even winning a war has a terrible price", but it seems to be true, as this film makes clear.
Excellent Documentary on what a Taboo subject i come from Belfast & was born in 1967 so i witnessed alot of ' The Troubles' it was a War thankfully over now but the disappeared need to be found & given back to their loved ones only then can the War really be over!
I grew up in Cork 1969-1990, we saw the troubles on tv, but there was no issues between protestants and catholic's where I lived, no talk of any of these stories in the video, this is my first time hearing any of this!
@@TheScouseassassin I watched the 2 part program on RTE player when it was originally aired, but isn't RUclips great🙂? Every time you rewatch a program you might see/hear something you didn't pick up on the first time.
Paranoia always reigns in such times.
Definitely
As I was watching this documentary it was interrupted by Eric Cantona doing an advert for William Hill bookmakers. For those who dont know William Hill was a young Black & Tan stationed in Cork during the Irish War of Independence. According to local historians he was well liked by the local people.
A dirty war. May God bless all involved.
Any chance of exploring the dark side of unionists and the tories and how many people disappeared under their watch or how about just getting them to own up to the atrocities they are responsible for
I think on sheer numbers and "atrocities" committed? The Republican terrorists win hands down. You cannot avoid blame by shifting a narrative onto the opposite side.
@Jon I'd rethink what you've just said no one is passing any blame, but at least the republican side owns up to 99% of it sometimes even before before it happens the other side though still deny how deep the hatred and collusion really went and let's not forget one simple undisputed fact here the republican side didn't start this the English and and the unionist that followed did never forget that I suggest you go read up on your history mo chara it goes way back before the troubles or 1916 way way back
Nobody is stopping you.
Britian will never allow themselves to be seen as the monsters they really are. From India to Ireland to Africa. They'll hide all their crimes on humanity.
@Murphy I know they will, but as long as the rest of the world knows that's fine by me, let the brits keep lying to themselves
Very interesting and being presented by an academic!
An academic who has an agenda
@soc3263 What is his agenda? Do you have proof for your claim?
@@soc3263 For the truth of the brutality of civil war to come out perhaps. What's your agenda then?
@@BullcutterHe has no agenda and tells the truth. His grand uncle is young Irish patriot and martyr Kevin Barry who was hanged by the British in November 1920.
@@johnroche7541 You've replied to the wrong person!
John Roche. Hi there.I deleted the post I sent you about the Irish incident.Thank you for your kindness.
Terbaik sahabat terima kasih perkongsian video nya.semoga terus sukses dan terus bersemangat 👍👍💪
Asek2 jos
Excellent
The minute you cited Peter Hart your credibility went out the window
Definitely 0 halpin not once quotes historians of Cork john borgonovo Barry Keane Jim Lane
Remember O'Halpin is a relative of IRA Volunteer Kevin Barry who was at the age of 18 hanged by the British authorities.
Sing sing looked pretty grim ☹️Ned Maloney seems to be quite pleased of his achievements .. sad to think at that age you haven’t a place in heaven ..still I suppose you get what u deserve in the end ...
One of the best documentaries I’ve ever seen on the IRA and the invasion of Ireland. Boy those guys were absolutely ruthless. I’ve never heard of Sing Sing prison in Cork,but it’s definitely on the bucket list to see when I go over to Cork next. Where is the bog/forest where they executed all those people?
It's not a prison, it's a vault illegally used for the incarceration, torture and subsequent murders of people the IRA believed were spies! Not somewhere any normal individual should want to see in my opinion!
Its not a prison,its just a little dissused old vault in a graveyard.
Sing Sing was just a nick name.
Wait until you hear what the Brits did
John Roche Hello.the post you have sent me.I am somewhat surprised,as I have no recollection of sending you any post regarding Ireland and the I.R.A. I am really at a loss on this score. Regards.
My sincere apologies. Could you please tell what my post consisted of. I am replying to several people and obviously sent it to you by mistake. Once again sorry for the misunderstanding.
John Roche. How come I received your post,when I have made no post regarding anything to do with Irish problems.
Similar case of a supposed british spy murdered and buried in a field to the west of the village of duniry east galway
Of course, nobody will talk, because they were afraid , it was ingrained in their dand a, it followed them through their families and their jobs.
Does anybody know the names of the two tans in Sing Sing at the end of part 1. My great uncle Bertie and comrade were abducted by the IRA in November 1920. They were subsequently executed. Their bodies were never returned at the end of the war of independence.
Re-listening to Jim Fitzgerald retailing of the story, he mentions that the two were picked up at Emmett Place. This is consistent with the official narrative. The portrayal does appear to be of Bertram Agnew and Lionel Mitchell.
M8 get in touch with the bloke in the programme for info his names on screen at start or might have an email address in Documentary credits etc all you can do is ask i hope you get answers as they should all be returned or found & properly buried as they don't get a taste of what no War & then Peace feels like
Hopefully your dirty crumpet stuffer pig of a great uncle stays buried unmarked you disgusting brit
They were auxiliaries who had committed numerous atrocities of Irish civilians at the time
@@seanohare5488 oh! Were the bodies that were returned to their families innocent? The IRA members who also committed atrocities of Irish civilians did not do it for Ireland. As a kid who didn't pay attention in history class I always thought Michael Collins was killed by the British. Can you imagine the shock and disillusionment I felt when I found he was killed after the British left? And by his own! Getting a body back depended on who you were, and obviously the British families who get their son/husband's body returned had more to offer those particular IRA members in return, than the Irish families they looked down on. I'm not saying I would be any different, who knows for sure what they would do in the same circumstance.
@@barbaramacdonagh299 Very important comment you've made.
my relatives were repeatedly attacked by uk forces late sixties to early 80s . bloody Sunday never to be forgotten.
now lets do one over the black and tans and the crown and its ruthless dealings ....... cant wait to see the other side of it told
Yes this narrator historian 0 halpin is obviously bias to say the least
O' Halpin is a relative of young Irish patriot Kevin Barry who was hanged by the British authorities at the age of 18. I would love to see a documentary about the 3 Catholic clergymen that were murdered by the Auxiliaries. Fr Michael Griffith in Co.Galway in November 1920 who thought he was visiting a sick member of his parish after being called but it was a deliberate trap by the Auxiliaries. Also Canon Magner who was over 70 and was killed in cold blood by an Auxiliary in Co.Cork in December 1920 and in the same incident this Auxiliary also killed an Irishman in his 20's but would be considered "Special Needs" in today's parlance. Then there was Fr James O' Callaghan who was killed in Co.Cork in June 1921.
A lot of these may have been personal vendettas and revenge killings. And apparently that 15 year old boy was killed for just being English. That was a good enough reason to kill him by IRA standards just like those teenage drummer boys.
Patrick Deasy an IRA Volunteer(aged 16) was KIA in the Kilmichael Ambush Co.Cork on 28th November 1920. Kevin Barry was an IRA Volunteer who was hanged by the British authorities at the age of 18 for taking part in an ambush in Dublin City on 22nd September 1920 which left 3 soldiers dead from the Duke Of Wellington Regiment including a 15 year old 2 weeks short of his 16th birthday. On 31st May 1921 in Youghal,Co Cork the IRA using an IED ambushed the band of the Hampshire Regiment which left 7 soldiers dead including 3 teenagers(aged 14 to 16) and over 20 wounded. Then there was the 3 bandboys of the Manchester Regiment who were abducted and killed in Co.Cork in June 1921 who were also young teenagers. Several Irish civilian teenagers were killed by Crown Forces during the conflict. The Crown Forces and in particular the Auxiliaries murdered 3 Catholic Priests including Canon Magner who was over 70 years of age. The historian who made this documentary is Eunan O'Halpin and is a relative of young Irish patriot Kevin Barry who along with another 9 IRA men were given State Funerals in tbe Republic of Ireland in the early 2000's.
There was a young teenager in Co.Galway aged 14 who used to travel around with the Crown Forces and point out the homes of Republican sympathisers which were later burned down. This teenager's name was William Joyce and would be better known as an adult as Lord Haw Haw who worked in Germany in the propaganda department under Gobbels during WW2 . As you know he was captured by the British and hanged for treason. He literally tried to save his neck by pointing out his service to the Crown during the Irish War of Independence.
Well got a compromise imho didn't fully win until 1940s.
True
Win? No one died to achieve a 26 count settlement?
Another gombeen historian who believe wars can be fought, won and lost, without atrocities and civilian casualties. There are no clean wars. War, and those engaged in prosecuting it, is a barbaric affair. War brings out the worst excesses in humans, be they military or administrators of that war. The warfare in Ireland of 1918 to 1922 wasn't special. Neither were the atrocities on all sides. They were typical of wars of independence across Europe and the world, included among them Finland's independence and subsequent civil war. Ireland, under Gaelic laws and rule, existed for over 1,700 years before the Act of Union with Britain. Lots of wars, local and wider, between Gaelic tribal dynasties through the centuries. Wars against the Norse, the Franco Normans, and later the Sasanach (Germanic Angles and Saxons, later to evolve in to the English). There's no doubt millions died in the collective of these wars, in battle, "collateral" deaths, persecution and famine. You will hear crickets among most historians in Ireland about this 1,600 year plus period in Irish history. There seems to be an obsession with Irish independence and the "blood lust" of those who fought an enemy to win that freedom. These same historians seem to have no issues with Irishmen involved in wars and civilian atrocities wearing the uniform of the British crown. After all, orders are orders, and refusal to obey orders subject to military discipline and consequences. It is unfortunate that many historians in Ireland, like Eunan O'Halpin, approach worthy subjects like this one with a baked-in, politically motivated agenda rather than an open and neutral mind that followed the facts and understood the barbarity that is war in all its forms.
Easily the best and most concise summation of the video and it's content/context in this abysmal reply thread.
Can you explain why you consider the targeting of individual civilians, without evidence to be acceptable?
I totally agree 0 halpin is disgraceful he can't even Honor his great uncle's killed as it's men including the 18;year old kevin Barry hanged by the bloody Brits kevin Barry is in a famous song sung by popular singers like leornard Cohen and Paul Robeson
What? Wait, about the missing? Should their remains be returned for burial to their families or not? I stupidly thought that that's what this video was about😕
Totally agree apart from being horrific war is childish at best insane. Why people expect rules of behaviour as if it was some condonable sport or something never fails to amaze me.
7:30
2:31 David Coulthard and hugh Laurie?
It wasn't an Anglo Irish war, it was an insurgency, of which Britain has faced many in its empires decline and unlike dictatorship's, walk away when it becomes too costly for them, rather than take the very extreme measures necessary to suppress a population.
Those poor people were clandestinely killed and removed from their families, purely for sectarian ideology, legitimising it, by calling it a war is not appropriate.
Ulster has taken on many forms in its extremely long and proud history, at the moment historical sectarian decisions have reduced it to six counties, but it is still Ulster and will always be. Maybe someday even reverting back to its Ulster name, flag and original size, who knows, maybe to even more than nine counties. Ireland has always been divided, that’s the Irish way, historically much more than today, the concept of unification was actually brought to Ireland by the British, as part of their expansionist colonial campaign, totally planned, implemented and managed by their local administrator, Dublin. Dublin learnt well, it still pursues a British agenda. Rewriting history to suit an expansionist narrative, exaggerating historical events, justifying proxy incursions, ethnic cleansing, genocide, providing safe havens and proxy violence, is unfortunately not uncommon in Ireland.
The Republic of Ireland have totally rewritten and sanitised, not only Dublin's part in Irish history, but also foolishly inserted a part of this fictionalised version of history, into their constitution and national anthem. As evidence for all to see and verify for themselves how Dublin abuses history. "A Nation Once Again" or “reunification” are fictional, concepts, fantasy, nonsense statements, as there was never a sovereign Southern Irish government that governed Ulster, now called Northern Ireland. Ulster or Britain have been the only two historical rulers of Ulster. Ulster was independent kingdom before being subdued and ruled by the British, conquered centuries after our Southern Irish neighbours.
“A Nation Once Again” for Ulster, now unfortunately called Northern Ireland, would be independence, should it eventually decide to split with the UK.
Definitely not the disaster that unification or this historically abused phrase “A New Ireland” inflicted on the counties Donegal, Cavan, Monaghan and literally the whole west coast of Ireland, incessantly promoted by the Republic of Ireland and their Northern Irish proxies.
Used frequently as a justification for proxy violence and disruption in Northern Ireland and to distract our Southern Irish neighbours from the performance of historically abysmal Irish Republican governments.
The presenter repeatedly states that many inocent civilians were wrongly excited by the IRA, why then has he presented literally zero evidence of this aledged fact?
There is the horrific reality that children were killed, the three drummer boys, and the English civilian 15year old.
These killings are shocking, although one of the drummer boys was old enough to bear arms so could arguably be discounted from the sad total.
Other than these cases all others so far outlined in this episode for either uniformed members of British Crown forces, or spy's and informers way beyond any reasonable doubt.
It detracts from the argument that there was so much obvious injustice and thoughtless unfair killing if in the 40 odd minutes of each episode you cannot present credible and factual testimony to support the hypothesis that this was anything but an anomaly.
I have great admiration for those that fight for themselves and the ability to control their own destiny. Nevertheless, I nothing but scorn and anger for the Irish Troubles and the insidious way they destroyed so many families! It always seemed to me that too many people were killed for just trying to live their lives on their own terms by people who demanded that all give in to their demands!
and how many lives did the british destroy , and for how many hundreds of years , not just in Ireland but all over the world . in such a war this can be expected , its not pretty its just the realities of war under operation. funny these say nothing about what the black and tans did in those times . only one side being told here
@@schroderingerscat I don’t disagree with you. However, my comment relates to the Irish on Irish violence which is really Protestant versus Catholic violence. That is what is so nonsensical to me. Whatever your beliefs may be, one Christian group fighting another because of the relatively minor difference in their beliefs is beyond stupid, it is inhumane.
@@allaneisner4729 it's not about their religion, it's nationalist against Loyalist, you can have either religion on both sides. The Loyalists don't want to be ruled from Dublin. But the majority of the people just want to live in peace, sadly no one ever listens to the majority!
its not now and never was about religion the as the brittish government well know
the majoroty of brittish people in 1945 also just wanted peace thankfully churchill thought differently
Bang out of order
Why not just put Cromwell on Irishmen doing Britain’s work TAL
God Save the King
Ireland forever Ireland for the Irish
🤣🤣🤣🤣
As you can see by the comments section mr 0 halpin your narration the majority of them is not favourable and that's me included
And now, with immigration, native Irish are about to become a minority in their own country in 30 years...
Brits and Protestants out... Africans and Arabs welcome.
And the blue Peter badge for the most silliest comment goes to rand korp well done 👏
@@punchy1325 Enlighten me as to why it is the "most silliest"
@Rand Korp there's no enlightening you. Unfortunately, people like you never see what's staring them in the face
@@punchy1325 So why not just answer his question?
Within 2 minutes you know it’s going to be biased.
So you won't have listened to how his ancestors were IRA commanders? He's interested in this, the IRA, because it's his family history.
Definitely
Is it wrong for families to want the remains of their relatives returned for burial? How come some British remains were returned while Irish remains are still missing?
What about the 3 Irish Catholic clergymen murdered by the Auxiliaries?
As like all violent revolutions , tragedies are going to occur . But the reality of this one, is that 800 years of British injustice. How many innocent Irish were killed by the British in those 800 years?…. Millions killed in the potato famine alone.! Never forget
Off subject, they’re COLLAPSING the US $$$ get your CASH OUT NOW!
I wonder what the motivation of the pro-British Irish was ... were they endeared to the British thru something akin to patriotism ? ...or were rewards offered for information ? ... should have included this in your otherwise very good documentary
They weren't and aren't Irish. They were mostly Scots who were planted there by the British and given the land taken from the Irish Catholics.
I think you mean the pro British British. Ireland had been a part of Britain for 400 years.
If you don't understand the whole history than you're better off not making stupid assumptions! Go read some books instead.
@@TheScouseassassin Agreed, It's up there with asking what a Church is.
Jack, you need to read a lot more about the History of Ulster, then you understand why there are people who value their union with the UK. It has alot to do with religion.
And the ira still trying to indict our soldiers for doing their duty.hypocrits.
Are you aware there was hundreds of Irish Great War veterans in the IRA during the Irish War of Independence 1919-1921 including 5 who were decorated for bravery one of which was a VC recipient? The Director of Training for the IRA at GHQ in Dublin was Emmet Dalton who while serving with the 9th Bn Royal Dublin Fusiliers was awarded the Military Cross for bravery at Guinchy in September 1916 during the latter stages of the Battle of the Somme. The most successful IRA Field Commander in the conflict was Tom Barry who served with the Royal Field Artillery with the rank of Bombardier and saw service in the Middle East theatre during WW1. He was part of the relief force who failed to break the siege at Kut,Mesopotamia(modern day Iraq) when British General Townsend and his garrison was besieged.
Up the UDF
Soo anglo-occupants was tortured and beaten to death! they tasted their own medicine. What’s the problem here? The only problem here is existing of Anglia nowadays. But this is a temporary issue
Considering immigration levels and the low Irish birth rate, Ireland is going to be under outside occupation again very soon...
Really ? the last few hundred years indicate otherwise.
@@adampeters9861aliens
🇮🇪
Ireland for the Irish and leave the tyrannical demonic EU
Pure British propaganda
So, you don't think the missing should be returned to their families for burial?
This historian is the grand nephew of young IRA martyr Kevin Barry.
What about the 3 Catholic clergymen murdered by the Auxiliaries?
@@johnroche7541 Any discussion of Irish history descends into whataboutery at some point.
Is he going to fly away by flapping his ears. 🤣🤣🤣
Exactly!...What's with all the big floppy ears!
Comment on the UKRAINE please
No
Proof of being a moron. !