From Season 1 - 3 **spoilers if you haven't watched Season 3 finale** Song: Stay by Katja Petri (originally by HURTS) Disclaimer: Homeland belongs to Showtime and Fox 21
Carrie was a person who could convince hin to go to Iran, and she immediately did that despite the fact that it was obvious that he would never come back. Carrie is responsible for his death
@@srallulrich No - Carrie's extraction plan for him worked against all the odds. They were waiting at the safe house to be rescued but were then betrayed by the new head of CIA who didn't want Brodie to return to the US.
@@dianastevenson131 Truth... In the season finale, Saul promised Carrie that he would have her and Brody extracted from Iran immediately after Brody completed his objectives. However, Javadi believed that the capture and execution of Brody would give further credence to the plot. Unbeknownst to Saul, Dar informs Lockhart and gets approval from the president to take command of the CIA 11 hours before he is to be confirmed. Lockhart gives the orders to Javadi to have Brody arrested and publicly executed.
@@Arakko-i7h Yes that's what happened. My point is it wasn't Carrie's fault that he didn't come back - she was bringing him back but she was betrayed and overruled, as she so often is.
"Love never lets a person be the same. When love arises, all wisdom disappears." - Pure truth. 02:14 Carrie is a maniac? NO... Because a part of her feels bad for the pain and torture he was put through. She recognizes the fact that he served his country dutifully until his capture, and that he really was subjected to inhumane treatment. He was subjected to it for years at a stretch. This is bound to leave even the strongest of men psychologically scarred for life. In Brody’s case he was broken and Abu Nazir took advantage of his psychological state and groomed him into a terrorist. Thankfully Brody did not blow up the suicide vest, and listened to his daughter, which highlights the fact that there is still some humanity left in him. It shows the audience that he’s not a cold-blooded killer but rather a misguided and emotionally damaged man who just needs to be brought back on the right path. Carrie sees this, and as a result feels sympathy for him. Brody: “This was love. You and me.” Carrie: “But it’s not goodbye.” Brody: “Okay” Carrie: “You don’t believe me?” Brody: “However it hurts the least.” Carrie: “Oh my God, why do I feel like this?” Brody: “Because you gave it up to me.” Carrie: “Completely.” Brody: “Goodbye love” Beautiful analysis on Brody :) He is not a terrorist. He is a person with a broken spirit. They broke his mind, yes, but he was also a victim of "destiny" or fate. He fell in love with Issa. This broke his heart. Nicholas Brody is Dorothy's 3 companions: he lost his heart with the death of Issa (Tin-Man), he lost his mind (after 8 years torture and redemption) and he lost his soul with his actions (Lion). 00:48 Brody: "i liked you Carrie" Carrie: " i LOVED YOU" Killing people isn't a solution... well nothing justifies the Vice President for killing all those innocent children either, an eye for a eye. This VP was Actually an asshole I am not saying assholes deserve to die but Brody was a true man compare to him. I am glad this show contains such controversy as killing civilians while chasing terrorists and also breaking civil rights and even human rights. There is never Just an evil and good in War (there is an exception Nazis, fascists, communists and imperial ''nazi'' Japan who were true and pure evil) Now nowadays the situation is way more complicated.
"he really was subjected to inhumane treatment" it was all but inhuman treatment. They played with the human feelings and made him servant of their cause through human emotions.
@@fabienlouvel5536 In part. For FIVE years he was tortured in a colossal way to be dismantled. After that, for 2.5 years it was brainwashed with drops of 'love'.
In hindsight, their time in the cabin was some of the most peaceful and beautiful time that they got to spend together. Their story was very tragic but i feel the writers overdid it. Good thing is he rests in peace
I had a mix of feelings regarding this season, I thought the beginning of the season was inferior to the previous seasons, but the final episodes paid off a lot. I thought the plot involving Dana was unnecessary, she tried to kill herself and ran away with a boyfriend she met at the clinic where she was hospitalized, until I understand the question, she revolted with her father, because she believed he was responsible for the attack to the CIA, unfortunately they gave a very big focus to the character, which ended up not being so interesting. It's amazing how much Claire Danes can overcome each season, her acting is really believable, she really makes us believe in Carrie's bipolarity. I was disgusted when Saul told the press about her bipolarity and her involvement with Brody, which culminated in her being hospitalized again, as she had stopped taking her medication. It was distressing to see Brody in Caracas, all the difficulties he went through in trying to escape and all the suffering he had to survive. I found the plot about Javadi interesting, the fact that he financed the attack on the CIA and was laundering money from his own country, so he became a spy for the CIA to stay alive and collaborate with the plan to kill Akbari, an Iranian leader. back from Brody, being part of the mission to kill Akbari, the character needed redemption for everything he had been through and for being accused of the attack on the CIA, and even his death was justified, since he died as a hero and maybe that get Dana to forgive him for everything that happened (even if she no longer appears on the show, the feeling is that he would deserve family forgiveness). Even though I was saddened by his death, I think the character fulfilled his role within the series and the star painted by Carrie at the memorial symbolizing Brody was a tribute and a very goodbye for him. I believe that next season will be very interesting, with the question of Carrie being working in Kabul and having a daughter Franny, and the question remains as to what she will do in relation to motherhood, since she is achieving what she wants professionally, and does not know how to act in relation to your personal life. I have expectations that the next season will be even better and more engaging. The scene where Carrie... Making a star on the honoree's wall is incredibly sad, a farewell to everything she went through with Brody, a "thank you", even if discreet and silent. We have seen that the character only grows, she is by far one of the most complex and interesting characters we have ever seen. 3x01 Tin Man Is Down - ★★★★ 3x02 Uh... Oh... Ah... - ★★★ 3x03 Tower of David - ★★ 3x04 Game On - ★★★ 3x05 The Yoga Play - ★★★★ 3x06 Still Positive - ★★★ 3x07 Gerontion - ★★★★ 3x08 A Red Wheelbarrow - ★★★★ 3x09 One Last Thing - ★★★ 3x10 Good Night - ★★★★ 3x11 Big Man in Tehrân - ★★★★ ★★★★ ★★ 3x12 The Star - ★★★★★★★★ ★★
Agree, the first half of season 3 was not great, but the second half was quite good, especially the last few episodes. I recently rewatched Homeland and I like the first half a little bit more now as I was able to pay more attention to the plot and understood it more.
@@ceciliapereira2267c Que legal. então deve ter percebido que além do família e Franny, a agente nunca teve uma conexão real além da Brody, Quinn e Saul.
I just watched this series season 1 to season 4 and I won't continue to watch it because Brody is dead just like billions I stopped watching it after bobby X was gone
Damian's character on Billions is also gone?!? Wow, that's like if Homeland didn't have Carrie anymore. Why is he gone? Is he dead or something? I tried to watch Billions, but I got bored. I was thinking of maybe giving it another chance, but if Bobby Axelrod won't be present until the end, I don't see the point anymore.
![Lucy & Josh - Their Full Story [The Hating Game]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EN9k_JgEaE8/mqdefault.jpg)
I cryed, it hurts....a lot....
I miss they together, really hurts :(
Me too
I gave up the series because they killed Brody. However, I continued the series again because of Quinn..But it appears Quinn is going to die too..
Kui Pan They kill all the good people. I hate the writers
Ahahahahahaa he does. Right in the fucking point
It is sobering. The CIA was so cruel to him. If i were Carrie, I could never work for the director and the state who betrayed his loyalty.
Carrie was a person who could convince hin to go to Iran, and she immediately did that despite the fact that it was obvious that he would never come back. Carrie is responsible for his death
@@srallulrich No - Carrie's extraction plan for him worked against all the odds. They were waiting at the safe house to be rescued but were then betrayed by the new head of CIA who didn't want Brodie to return to the US.
@@dianastevenson131 Carrie first sent him there
@@dianastevenson131 Truth... In the season finale, Saul promised Carrie that he would have her and Brody extracted from Iran immediately after Brody completed his objectives. However, Javadi believed that the capture and execution of Brody would give further credence to the plot. Unbeknownst to Saul, Dar informs Lockhart and gets approval from the president to take command of the CIA 11 hours before he is to be confirmed. Lockhart gives the orders to Javadi to have Brody arrested and publicly executed.
@@Arakko-i7h Yes that's what happened. My point is it wasn't Carrie's fault that he didn't come back - she was bringing him back but she was betrayed and overruled, as she so often is.
I cry so hard I miss when they’re together
"Love never lets a person be the same. When love arises, all wisdom disappears." - Pure truth.
02:14 Carrie is a maniac? NO... Because a part of her feels bad for the pain and torture he was put through. She recognizes the fact that he served his country dutifully until his capture, and that he really was subjected to inhumane treatment. He was subjected to it for years at a stretch. This is bound to leave even the strongest of men psychologically scarred for life. In Brody’s case he was broken and Abu Nazir took advantage of his psychological state and groomed him into a terrorist.
Thankfully Brody did not blow up the suicide vest, and listened to his daughter, which highlights the fact that there is still some humanity left in him. It shows the audience that he’s not a cold-blooded killer but rather a misguided and emotionally damaged man who just needs to be brought back on the right path. Carrie sees this, and as a result feels sympathy for him.
Brody: “This was love. You and me.”
Carrie: “But it’s not goodbye.”
Brody: “Okay”
Carrie: “You don’t believe me?”
Brody: “However it hurts the least.”
Carrie: “Oh my God, why do I feel like this?”
Brody: “Because you gave it up to me.”
Carrie: “Completely.”
Brody: “Goodbye love”
Beautiful analysis on Brody :)
He is not a terrorist. He is a person with a broken spirit. They broke his mind, yes, but he was also a victim of "destiny" or fate. He fell in love with Issa. This broke his heart.
Nicholas Brody is Dorothy's 3 companions: he lost his heart with the death of Issa (Tin-Man), he lost his mind (after 8 years torture and redemption) and he lost his soul with his actions (Lion).
00:48 Brody: "i liked you Carrie" Carrie: " i LOVED YOU"
Killing people isn't a solution... well nothing justifies the Vice President for killing all those innocent children either, an eye for a eye.
This VP was Actually an asshole I am not saying assholes deserve to die but Brody was a true man compare to him. I am glad this show contains such controversy as killing civilians while chasing terrorists and also breaking civil rights and even human rights. There is never Just an evil and good in War (there is an exception Nazis, fascists, communists and imperial ''nazi'' Japan who were true and pure evil) Now nowadays the situation is way more complicated.
Wow! I just read this comment and it could totally be a fifteen minute video that analyses this series. Honestly! I am really amazed!
@@leazribi8388
Wow for you too! I'm really happy to help!
"he really was subjected to inhumane treatment" it was all but inhuman treatment. They played with the human feelings and made him servant of their cause through human emotions.
@@fabienlouvel5536 In part. For FIVE years he was tortured in a colossal way to be dismantled. After that, for 2.5 years it was brainwashed with drops of 'love'.
Damián lewis sin ti Homeland no era lo mismo !!!!!!!!! Éxitos desde Argentina ❤
Mejor volví a ver las temporadas 1, 2 y 3
Super sad if they wont bring him back :(
Do u think they'll bring him back? Because i do this season they throw so much shade that i thought maybe his going to appear on screen anytime.
how ? :D i mean he is hanged and dead af
I love Brody ❤️
Just finished season 3
God I'm not ok for real 😭
Broady❤
They really do have CHEMISTRY
The show was never the same after they killed broady off.
In hindsight, their time in the cabin was some of the most peaceful and beautiful time that they got to spend together. Their story was very tragic but i feel the writers overdid it. Good thing is he rests in peace
ตามมาจากกระทู้ข้างนอก อยากให้คู่นี้ได้คบกันจริงๆ สงสารพี่แก(โบรดี้) นึกถึงคำพูดนึงที่พี่แกระบายให้แครี่ฟัง "ตอนนี้ผมได้ตัดความสัมพันธ์ของทุกฝ่ายเรียบร้อยแล้ว" มันสะเทือนใจมาก
ติดตามเหมือนกันคะ ชอบมาก ตอนนี้ ซีซั่น 8 อยากดูมากเลย ชอบhomeland
I had a mix of feelings regarding this season, I thought the beginning of the season was inferior to the previous seasons, but the final episodes paid off a lot.
I thought the plot involving Dana was unnecessary, she tried to kill herself and ran away with a boyfriend she met at the clinic where she was hospitalized, until I understand the question, she revolted with her father, because she believed he was responsible for the attack to the CIA, unfortunately they gave a very big focus to the character, which ended up not being so interesting.
It's amazing how much Claire Danes can overcome each season, her acting is really believable, she really makes us believe in Carrie's bipolarity. I was disgusted when Saul told the press about her bipolarity and her involvement with Brody, which culminated in her being hospitalized again, as she had stopped taking her medication.
It was distressing to see Brody in Caracas, all the difficulties he went through in trying to escape and all the suffering he had to survive.
I found the plot about Javadi interesting, the fact that he financed the attack on the CIA and was laundering money from his own country, so he became a spy for the CIA to stay alive and collaborate with the plan to kill Akbari, an Iranian leader. back from Brody, being part of the mission to kill Akbari, the character needed redemption for everything he had been through and for being accused of the attack on the CIA, and even his death was justified, since he died as a hero and maybe that get Dana to forgive him for everything that happened (even if she no longer appears on the show, the feeling is that he would deserve family forgiveness).
Even though I was saddened by his death, I think the character fulfilled his role within the series and the star painted by Carrie at the memorial symbolizing Brody was a tribute and a very goodbye for him. I believe that next season will be very interesting, with the question of Carrie being working in Kabul and having a daughter Franny, and the question remains as to what she will do in relation to motherhood, since she is achieving what she wants professionally, and does not know how to act in relation to your personal life.
I have expectations that the next season will be even better and more engaging.
The scene where Carrie... Making a star on the honoree's wall is incredibly sad, a farewell to everything she went through with Brody, a "thank you", even if discreet and silent.
We have seen that the character only grows, she is by far one of the most complex and interesting characters we have ever seen.
3x01 Tin Man Is Down - ★★★★
3x02 Uh... Oh... Ah... - ★★★
3x03 Tower of David - ★★
3x04 Game On - ★★★
3x05 The Yoga Play - ★★★★
3x06 Still Positive - ★★★
3x07 Gerontion - ★★★★
3x08 A Red Wheelbarrow - ★★★★
3x09 One Last Thing - ★★★
3x10 Good Night - ★★★★
3x11 Big Man in Tehrân - ★★★★
★★★★
★★
3x12 The Star - ★★★★★★★★
★★
Agree, the first half of season 3 was not great, but the second half was quite good, especially the last few episodes. I recently rewatched Homeland and I like the first half a little bit more now as I was able to pay more attention to the plot and understood it more.
Só agora comecei a vera série, conclui a terceira temporada mas a morte de Brodie retira- me a vontade de ver o resto. Foi mau demais.
Pode ver. pensa que é uma nova serie sobre saul e carrie.
@@Arakko-i7h acabei por ver tudo. Adorei.
@@ceciliapereira2267c Que legal. então deve ter percebido que além do família e Franny, a agente nunca teve uma conexão real além da Brody, Quinn e Saul.
I just watched this series season 1 to season 4 and I won't continue to watch it because Brody is dead just like billions I stopped watching it after bobby X was gone
Damian's character on Billions is also gone?!? Wow, that's like if Homeland didn't have Carrie anymore. Why is he gone? Is he dead or something? I tried to watch Billions, but I got bored. I was thinking of maybe giving it another chance, but if Bobby Axelrod won't be present until the end, I don't see the point anymore.
stay by whom