WINNERS & LOSERS: Grading EACH Club’s FULL Transfer Window!
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- SUBSCRIBE ➡ bit.ly/Sub2Thom...
Today I'm ranking each Premier League club's full transfer window. Including: Liverpool after signing Chiesa, Man Utd with Ugarte, Arsenal if Coman joins, Chelsea, Man City, Villa, Newcastle, Ipswich & loads more!
I'm aware the window still has time to run, guys. But I have no time this weekend or early next week to make any videos - so hope you understand :)
Surely it'd make more sense doing this vid at the end of the window
Man's gotta make content 😊
You’d think 🤣
@@deogratiasamanya172 The point is that the content would have been better after tomorrow...
He's going to do it, this video it's just about farming views
More likely done so more content can be made. Like a similar video ranking every club's deadline day. Obvious no?
If you don't have any time to make the video after the window closes why not wait until next weekend when there's an international break, why the rush?, the window is still open and tomorrow is the most crucial day of them all, so for me this video is completely pointless!
If we include acquiring Hurzeler as head coach, Brighton goes to easily best summer/window for me
Finally they've smashed their piggy bank 🤑
Let’s gooo as a Brighton fan can’t wait for the whole season what a window
As a Newcastle fan we were fighting relegation 3 years ago and have come an awful long way since. Although I am disappointed by the incomings, managing to keep Gordon, Isak and Bruno is a massive plus for this window as all three are hard to replace - people don't realise we are struggling for CL quality players because most don't want to come to us, we can't even compete with Chelsea or Man Utd right now. I would love a RW and CB but even if we don't add anyone I would give our window a C+. We avoided a PSR breach, kept our best players and should have money in the bank to try again next window.
In fairness, the Saudi money helps
exactly. I think that Tonali coming back to the Prem is gonna be pretty big - fresh like a new signing given his one year ban from football. Also defense is only gonna get more solid - Burn is looking stronger this season as well as Hall and Livramrbto (w Trippier as a wonderful back-up). Even though there weren’t any new signings, I feel like current players getting used to the system and having game time means Newcastle should have a strong season.
Yes I Newcastle have had some PSR issues but i think the Club and Broad have played on them a tad and think with what happen last season in Europe and Eddy Howe being linked England job I think some of the trust as gone that he the manage to take Newcastel forward, so i think they held back on spending money this summer. Also they the fact? i know that Newcastle fans don't like this point but when top players are looking to where there going play and live the North East is not high on the list compared to London, Manchester and even Liverpool
Sterling on the thumbnail was just lazy lol. Talking about Sterling at Man United & Kingsley Conan at Arsenal? Could've just waited until the window was closed to make the video
The window isn't even over? And Salah, Trent and VVD contracts doesn't have anything to do with our transfer window, they can get fixed at any point during the season.
Obvious bias from a United fan. We haven't bought many players because we don't need to buy many players. Jurgen left our squad in excellent condition.
@@garymaidman625but you still have no dm and have been rejected by 4 now
C is still fair, not like we did anything that amazing this window
@@tord2354 not really arguing the rank, C is fair, could even be lower, but doing a «Full transfer window» video before the window is over is a bit odd. And the contracts doesn’t have anything to do with what rank we should have for the transfer window, so just irrelevant for him to make that point talking about our transfer window
Guehi and Andersen vital to Glasner’s back 3. In reality, Guehi didn’t play once in a back 3 for Glasner last season… yes our squad is in a worse position, but losing Andersen for good money for Lacroix who is younger and cheaper is a good move imo, especially as he’s worked with Glasner before. Improving our squad and losing Olise was gonna always be an impossible task
When did "he's worked with the manager before..." become a metric? 🤔
happy with the signings of mamardashillvi and chiesa, however we haven't sorted the main issues
So so lazy with the Crystal Palace piece. Guehi played under Glasner twice last season, so to say their relationship in a back 3 was so key is just completely incorrect. The back 3 was Richards Anderson and Ward/Clyne for the majority of our campaign under Glasner
Guehi is not leaving. Why you acting like he left?
As a Newcastle fan I think we’ve had a mare…. Why have we wasted four weeks trying to sign a hugely inflated CH who plays on the left when we need a right sided CH…. Looks really bad on Paul Mitchell…. Unless we do a Paul Daniels over the next 36 hours we can kiss goodbye to the top four….
Don’t think the Ashworth move helped you guys either…
Agree with everything you’ve said apart from how it looks on Mitchel. This isn’t his window the issues we have had are down to other changes at senior management level and not getting him in quickly enough. Very poor window as things stand.
Couldn’t agree more tbh I think Howe’s been profiting off form for a while and the signings have been mid except for Isak botman of which botman can barely stay on the field. But going forward I don’t think he’s the guy to take us there and I don’t know whose the next guy to come in to do that
Didn't you get those goodbyes out of your system last season?
Brother Guehi can play on the right it’s not that deep 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He’s right footed.
Palace take is dreadful, palaces purple patch was without the combination of guehi and Anderson (guehi being injured) Anderson for 30mil is a profit considering we signed him for 20mil, with defensive cover from riad and lacroix, guehi is staying no doubt, keeping eze and guehi is massive, olise was always gonna go with that release clause, but bringing in Kamada on a free, sarr for 12 mil and nketiah for 30 is great business, yes he’s still relativiily unproven but whenever he’s played he’s been amazing for arsenal, window isn’t done either with potential for cover at the lwb role with gosens linked, we are defo stronger than we were last seasons and I think the boys long term will prove that
Kingsley coman to arsenal would be insane.
Erm, it's not over yet 👀
Arsenal’s window isn’t an A. Merino and Calafiori doesn’t improve them that much
not many do tho and minor increases and depth for versatility is so important. remembering dealing with. the low block last season bringing good dribblers and aerial threats is a huge plus.
Myth that Guehi was that important to palace. Their best form last season came when he was on the bench after his injury
Ipswich in A+ is a stretch imo
Forest in B is wild, forests depth has grown incredibly and its only going to get better assuming a striker comes through the door.
Finally some positivity towards Southampton from one of my favourite creators👍🏻 I do still think we need a more creative player out wide but the youngsters like Tyler dibling and Sam amo ameyew do look good just hope it’s not too much for them.
Love the video, agree with the Arsenal take!
65M for Solanke is a highway robbery for Bournemouth. A+
Not at all there’s not many decent strikers around, so 65 is the standard value for a proven striker right now
@@upthealbion there are SO many strikers around.
Osimhen, Vlahovic, Evanilson, Gimenez, Brobbey, Gyokeres, Guirassy, Sesko, Openda, Dovbyk, Sorloth, Alvarez, David, Undav, Lookman, Joao Pedro, Cunha.
Most of these players are either younger with more potential or done it for multiple seasons unlike Solanke. Or have more to their game then Solanke other then being a target man. Oh and most won’t cost more the 50M. The ones that do are straight up better
@@wayneverhoff2790 the problem with almost every player u named is they aren’t premier league proven - solanke is and as much as you will say he’s a one season wonder he’s been around in the premier league for a while and that experience is invaluable.
@@wayneverhoff2790 also a lot of those players you named would cost around 50m if not a little over so 65 may be a little steep but it’s really not as bad as you’re making out
@@upthealbion I don’t think he’s worth more then 35M
Pretty certain Man Utd had the best window, alot of players out, good incomings, 100mil in sales, addressed many issues, without a doubt our best window post Fergie regardless off what happens in the season, very happy with it.
You spent big money on a CB who is injured.
@@garymaidman625 a very good, very young cb who got injured after we paid it, he wont start even if he wasnt injured, one for the future
@@paolochella1623 he won't start? He's better than Maguire and Martinez is constantly injured. You still have Rashford on the books, as well as Sancho and Casemiro, not to mention Antony. So, a pretty poor window.
I get that United got rid of a lot of players but the loss in value is astronomical, big spending and little return! Also selling McTominay feels like a mistake
@@Aesirion 100 mil in sales? Thats the best united have done in many years, also they got rid of alot of pretty terrible players, they also saved + - 15% on wages, in order to move forward these types of losses are neccessary, the majority of the players sold are hard to sell for a high amount with their current wages so they have to suck it up and take the loss, agreed on Scott but id rather have Ugarte than Scott
How can you rank a FULL window before it even closes?
Arsenal keeps pushing away good goalkeepers. Martinez, Leno, Ramsdel etc
Raya is sensational. They'll be fine!
@@joethomlinson_Sensational is perhaps going a bit far. He is very good, but he isn't as good as Allison, who is sensational.
@@garymaidman625 Allison is world-class and Raya is sensational especially on his debut , he won the golden glove!
Newcastle fans… Guehi looking unlikely now! What is going on lads?! 😮😮
Paul Mitchell and co have been negligent this transfer window. Truly terrible management of the club. Actually feels Mike Ashleyesque
They bought plenty of keepers though.
u need an ad blocker big dawg
Chelsea throwing money at everyone and everything shouldnt justify an A. Regardless of the quality of their incomings.
Making this video before deadline day is like ranking every team's season 3 matchdays from the end halfway through a title race and a relegation battle.
I didn't have any other time to do it! :)
I think it's one of Fulham's best transfer windows in a long long time at least A tier
Joao Palhinha dropped it for me, but yeah agreed overally positive.
No way Chelsea is an A, players are good but the way it’s been conducted is a nonsense. Seemingly no depth/succession planning, tons of dishonesty and lack of class in how the transfers have been handled, and still plenty of youth player overspends.
Players good enough B is probably rate, but personally couldn’t give it an A as it stands.
Spurs being below the rest of the big 6 is honestly hilarious, complete recency bias because the rest have just gotten deals over the line. I’d say In every video uo until now you have rated Spurs signings as A tier
Agreed, but in those videos I still said where's the 6 and the fullback?
@@joethomlinson_ it’s hardly realistic to think a 6 is a need when we have biss bentancur and have just spent 40m on gray also. Gray can also play as right back cover and the idea seems to be for Spence to be backup on both flanks too. I do agree that cover for udogie is a big need however so a lcb/lb hybrid would be perfect to cover Micky also
Chelsea are legitimately worse than before the window, hilarious review
Everton have 4/5 possible right backs Coleman Patterson Dixon god forbid Young and Garner can play there but we only have 1 left back
Another nice video from the man Joe
Thanks!
Liverpool fans joined the chat😂😂
The correct pronunciation for Tim Iroegbunam is with a silent G Joe (I-roe-bunam). Great vid as always !
No one cares
I'll check it out!
@@wayneverhoff2790you care enough to comment. Correct pronunciation of a name is better than a poor take on Solanke only being worth £35M.
@@garymaidman625ig to you lol
I think Liverpool do very well every year or 2 to get the best amount of money out of players that were never really involved
Liverpool at c is a pony opinion personally liverpool do not need a cdm gravonbirch and McAllister can play there and don’t forget endo also sending Bajcetic on loan to get game time to come back because he had an injury last season will end up being like a new signing so for me it’s an A plus amazing profit for van den berg and carvalho
Crystal Palace C bruh
Olise was obviously gonna go
Andersen was gonna get replaced by Chad Riad- injured rn But they still have Clyne Ward and that Wolfsburg guy pretty good
Ayew wouldn’t get a lot of game time
And Nketiah along side Mateta bro
Cooked-I’d atleast give a B
Spurs did an A+ job on departures. Really cleared out the squad. Definitely think Tottenham are an A. Probably a low A but just don’t think they’re a B
This is a flip on Chelsea since the ranking transfers video
Only by one space and a different metric!
@@joethomlinson_ fair enough
Giving city and united same grade is insane. Gundogan is good by 33 and savinho was basically a return loan as they own Girona. United improved squad 50%+ 😂😂 this fella had too many drinkies before filming this
Bro just wasted about three minutes of my life
Liverpool got Chiesa and Masvi.
Sold 70m worth of players
E should be at least C tier
Making this video before the transfer window has closed is… interesting
Not got any time the rest of this week 😅
@@joethomlinson_ Fair. It was a great watch as always
City signs a talented winger and an old dog: A
Liverpool signs a talented winger and a Allison replacement: C
Nice
😂
But Liverpool literally got no cb depth. They seriously need to buy one fast
@@tobey4354 Van Dijk, Quansah, Konate and Gomez, Philipps at a push What do you mean?
@@edrahimovic Konate injury prone van dijk past his prime quansah gomez decent at best.
If you think you can push for title charge and ucl with that defence then I got news for you
@@tobey4354 well you clearly forgot about that one CB that you didn't mention that sprays 60 yard passes like nothing, the other one that ragdolls attackers like they aren't there, the youngster that's allready better than 90% of the CB's in the league... oh wait, you mentioned them, just chose to ignore how great they could be, by displaying how shit they could be.... truth lies somewhere in the middle mate and thus we're fine with going for league and champo, because of a key player gets injured, you're unlucky, you can't "buy" for that scenario...
Do this kind of video after the end of the transfer window
Can you do a seperate video on Bayern, Dortmund, Psg, Juve, Inter, Milan, Roma, Barca, Atletico...?
Nice idea! Next week?
@@joethomlinson_ would listen to you talk about any team from any country brotha
West Ham or Newcastle should’ve went for Ramsdale IMO, more so to replace their current starters long term. If Southampton get relegated then Aaron’s stock drops massively & idk if he gets another chance again at a club of that level smh.
Areloa is pretty solid no? As is Pope if he returns fit and firing?
We still need a LB, even if its a Reguillon type because we cannot trust Shaw to be fit and Ten Hag clearly doesn´t trust Amass yet. If Mazraoui gets injured, wich he can, we´re in trouble.
why not wait until after deadline day?
Joe, are you wearing a Fulham jacket in the thumbnail?
Chelsea can’t be an A no chance.. yes they have signed a lot of decent players but all fighting for the same position and the sancho one just wasn’t necessary.. they needed a cb and striker not an influx of more wingers
*ARSENAL FANS DREAMING OF A STRIKER UNITE!!*
Imagine judging a transfer window on contract extensions… oh dear Joe
I think if spurs can get a LCB and a proper DM this window it will be an incredible window. If is the big word though
We aren’t getting a dm there is none aswell as the fact we have biss and just spent 40m on gray
Arsenal is NOT an A! Last year we needed more and better depth in the attack/midfield and now it has literally become WORSE depth
Great stuff
But so much more could change on D day, a bit too early
Could it? Not too many moves would change my opinion. Especially panic signings this late!
Spot on about southampton, let’s hope we stay up lmao
And Ipswich
Or all of them tbf
Chelsea is an F for sure, no method, Just pure American madness. Brighton is full of future Premier league flops.
Too harsh!
@@joethomlinson_ The Brighton part is a bit harsh, I admit.
@@Drunken_Master This is by far the best Brighton squade of all time.
Really really bad to put chelsea at A... tjeir A-window would be to only get rid of 10 players and be happy with that. A+ would be that and a great forward. Why arent you taking consideration inti that the manager will have 30 players that want to play now for half a year?
Deserved F for us and its all Eddie Howes fault
Same tier as Everton? That’s criminal
Ipswich, Brighton and Bournemouth top 3
Liverpool is an F and Chelsea is a C
Bournemouth C? What a rubbish
een-cop-yay is how u say hincapie
Some of the pronunciations are messing with my head
Joe LOVES Tim!!
I think Crystal palace moved up
lol man u is 4-6 players away from a full ajax under ten hag squad
How will almiron wearing black and white change if he goes to fulham ? 22:20
Haha! Great point...
Hopefully you'll learn not how to do this going forward.
Well done for trying
Who is here knowing this punk won't appear for his job , when his stupid side loses , 5-0 or 7-0 to liverpool
I think B is spot on for Spurs - think we ticked a lot of boxes - a versatile defender who could play fullback and CB would have been good but with Dragusin and some other players being able to play other positions I think we will be alright
Love it!
Arsenal D
Why would you make a video about transfer window when it had not finished you mug 😂
weird timing
B for Brentford?! 🤮 bro you gotta be more harsh
I would say £80m+ on 3 players is an alright window for them!
@@joethomlinson_ not really needle movers. Also not being able to sell Toney hurts.
I just think it’s the the definition of C or D window.
I’m sorry but Chelsea have not had an ‘A’ window, much closer to F due to them not upgrading the starting XI in any major way nor have they fixed their forward line issues.
Just classic Chelsea spending money on players they don’t need.
City easily done the best business again. Proper club
Clueless re palace. It was a fantastic window