Decoding One Nation, One Election: What It Means For India
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 24 янв 2025
- #onenationoneelection #pmmodi #assemblyelection #bjp #loksabha
The BJP’s push for 'One Nation, One Election' aims to synchronize Lok Sabha and State Assembly elections nationwide, promising reduced costs and improved efficiency. While advocates emphasize convenience, reduced electoral expenditure, and higher voter turnout, critics, including the Congress and regional parties, call it impractical due to legal, constitutional, and logistical challenges. This detailed explainer unpacks the history, challenges, and potential impacts of simultaneous elections on governance, regional issues, and electoral strategies. Explore the debate and what it means for India's democracy.
#wintersession #parliamentwintersession2024 #bjpvscongress #rahulgandhi #soniagandhi
-----------------------
Thank You for watching! Do not forget to Like | Comment | Share
-----------------------
About the channel
Watch us for the best news and views on business, stock markets, crypto currencies, consumer technology, the world of real estate, bullion, automobiles, start-ups and unicorns and personal finance. Business Today TV will also bring you all you need to know about mutual funds, insurance, loans and pension plans among others.
Follow us at:
Website: www.businessto...
WhatsApp: whatsapp.com/channel/0029Va4Hd309hXFCqY62yD2I
Facebook: / businesstoday
twitter: / business_today
Instagram: / business_today
Only bjp has guts to take hard decision.
Congress view every decision in vote bank view comparatively to bjp.
From Aadhar to CAA to NRC to New Parliament to One Nation One Election.. All these were Congress Era Ideas submitted by panel, when Congress was in Power.
@@hindurashtra63 only on paper lol they had 60 years to make them into the system why they dont did it ?
@@hindurashtra63 ideas are meaningless if you can`t implement it. these ideas can be imagined by inspiration or copy . but succesfully implementing it takes guts.....
Every time BJP tried to implement but congress stopped it by all means and idea wasn't brought by congress ...it was a situation and decision by EC long back@@hindurashtra63
just after thought. one nation one election... so one nation one caste, one nation one gothra, one nation one language, one nation one tax, one nation one id . all of this for saving poll expenditure sounds absurd on back of npa waivers doled out to corporates is mockery.
One nation one election strongly recommended, as it will do not hamper education of students in schools.
Really this sector is affected badly with multiple elections in a year
Most of our leaders spend 2-3 month on election promotion on year which is very time consuming. They should use this time on governance.
When ever eletion happens developmental polices are out on hold. I
Also it's very expensive for the govt to hold election 2,3 times a year.
One narion one eletion is a very good initiative. Congress will of course oppose it but once they win eletion through it they will come through
Modi scared of congress
@Silvia_1990 very good reply ,it would be very idiotic of me to wish a well constructive reply from a pappu ass licker.
You people have a brain iq of a dolphin ,which is why you are still slaving to a single family.
Not exactly, modi ji not have 2/3rd to pass the bill.. NDA needs approval of opponents that's it... He don't need to scare to anybody 😊@@Silvia_1990
@@Traveller1997 country will split .. minority will have no power.. States should be diverse and compete among them for quick dev..
If they want to save money then they should stop corruption
Hasn't corruption dropped by a significant number? Get some facts checked buddy.
@chaitanyasabharwal72003 buddy I think you live in social media packed up in your home. Did you forget Current adani's bribery case. No action or no investigation. Both congress and BJP are guilty
But what is your argument against one election? Even the initial elections were simultaneously held.
@@chaitanyasabharwal72003 yeah u guys rich now
This is actually efficient for the country as a whole. Good for business, investments don't have to wait. Policies can be made faster.
End of Democracy in India 😢
Last year election commission spent nearly 1 lakh crore for elections for 1.3 million polling booths 8000+ candidates for polling officer per day salary 250 per day including food and residing officer salary 250 per day to cut down these expenses the bill is needed
@Kumar80304 Expenses will go down if BJP stops horse trading MLAs and toppling rightfully elected governments. State and union governments are totally different machineries and do not need or benefit from a single election. This is what happens when fascists govern 🤷
@@TNadu4946 BJP also started as 3 mla seat party initially it growed step by step from mla to cm to pm they do know the rules very well projects and government offices are pending with files are halting due to election campaign busy schedule this type of election gives equal weightage to parties and vote percent will increase
@Kumar80304 please tell me what would happen if a government (state or union) falls before completing it's 5 year term? Will the entire country face election again?
@@TNadu4946 every state has its own governor according to the constitution when CM DIES OR state government falls governor takes charge until new cm is appointed most state cm completing 5 year term except kejirwal who gone to jail in few his party member took charge as cm
One Nation One Election has lot of advantages, but will be interesting to see how Modi implements it as it has disadvantages too
Congress called UPI payment impractical in the past.
And also Demonization & 15-Lakh
Welcome 🎉
Great decision, nhi to all government office don't do any work they only say that elction hai baad me aana, this is the good move by our best PM shri narendra modi ji 😊
they should make it a 4 year term then
ONE NATION ONE ELECTION
ONE NATION ONE BURIAL GROUND
Whether BJP has got guts to get ONOP bill passed or it takes a u turn like Farm bill, CAA, NRC, WAQF bills😂😂
Caa was implemented successfully 😅😅😅
Nrc and waqf will be very soon implemented. Mullas will be kicked out from India 😅😅😅
they will bring WAQF abolition bill 💪
Caa is successful waqf will be brought onop is need of the nation , farm bill is withdrawn yes , but it will make a comeback .
One Nation One Pressmeet
Yes, An American styled debate between Presidents (PM in our case) would be nice, All on the same Podium.
@@hindurashtra63 Fir to Pappu bhaag jaayegaa😂
one nation one caste, gothra language,tax,media,Adani business more to follow.
This is good move
While the One Nation, One Election proposal offers advantages like cost savings and efficiency, it also brings with it numerous disadvantages. These include potential harm to regional party representation, constitutional challenges, voter fatigue, political instability, logistical hurdles, and the risk of overshadowing local issues in favor of national concerns. The balance between simplifying the election process and maintaining democratic diversity across India is a key point of debate.
one nation one election se hme nuksaan hi hai kyuki chunav aate he janta se jude kaam jaldi jaldi hone lagte hai aur agar ek baar election hoga to unhe ek he baar janta ka kaam karna padega
ONE INDIA
ONE NATION
ONE ELECTION
JAI HIND 🇮🇳 🙏
The Opposition claim that the One Nation One Election subsumes regional issues to the federal ones effectively undermines federalism of the country sounds rather esoteric and does not find resonance with the elector on the street. It seems to have the same gravitas as the Adani issue. The I.N.D.I.A. Alliance have a hard sell.
Now, politicians can conveniently forget people for 4 years and 9 months!
Huh... As if your leader is Kejriwal
Lol as if they cared before, at least it will save a hell of a money
@@sharatk4511 the money saved will be used by these corrupt politicians for their own needs
@@NuggetLvr4vr it's a cycle India can never be rid of corruption, reservation, castism not because of politicians but majority of citizens are itself fked up
@@NuggetLvr4vr As if the corruption is never present in previous system.
All corrupted parties opposed 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
CPI (corruption ratings) after BJP power has been increased
@balamuruganramakrishnan3020 yes, because now we are getting true informations, before we dont get real facts. BJP exposed many details that Indians believed true for more than 2 or 4 decades or even more. No matter who opposes BJP, I am happy to serve my India and especially under BJP.
@@aronman123 nice i respect your opinion, btw where are you from ?
notes taken for the civil exams. Thank you.
This is Great motion should be passed and even Congress should not oppose this.we really waste all our 5years term on elections. If we care abt development then we should end this everyday election process and support one election one nation
This is not a good change
Change the term for power to 4 years instead of 5 yrs with simultaneous elections. All lower level elections @ panchayat levels, shall be done through an Internet platform. Even the Loksaba elections can migrate to an Internet platform too.
Internet platform😂, bro people are doubting EVMs and you are saying about Google forms. They can be easily changed.
Present situation is not favour of any party sir because lot of time available sir some people are taken decision before polling oneday one month some are polling situation watching after 2pm voting purpose they will be to polling booth sir intelligence agencies report favour or not two or four surveys are complusory sir
Simultaneous elecions :
Pros :
- Money is Greatly saved during Election process
- Many Local Political Parties now have a Chance to become a National Party
- State / Central Govts can focus on Long Term Polciies instead of monthly elections
Cons :
- More Chance of Corruption and Vote Rigging because lesser time frame
- Smaller Indian States might feel ignored
- More Manpower and Police requiredduring Elections, Harder to manage Peace
Also a lot of money can be saved in MP/MLA *horse trading* 😄. Abhi, 300 cr mein 2 MP ke sath 1 MLA free milega (combo offer to make double engine govt.)
Even if many parties get chance. At the end of the day only two parties are able to dominate.
One nation One election One hack ez
😂
Oh, is that how congress got 99 seats in the last election?
This EVM hack argument has no ground. Those machines are guarded by the military in a secures area till the results day.
Oh, is that how congress got 99 seats during the last election?
This EVM hack thing won't run anymore, not all people are senseless.
I don't understand why opposition is not supporting it. With most of their black money caught, atleast they can still do large scale campaign with less money. 🤔
In my view, there should be one election month, may be APRIL every year.
1.all the elections of a year from jan to dec should be done in APRIL.
2. For 2024 m' rashtra, haryana. Jnk., jharkhand., odisha, andhra all states should carry out election in APRIL.
Similarly, for 2025 delhi bengal, bihar all in APRIL.
For 2023,r'sthan, mp, cg, Himachal, karnataka all in APR.
3..national general election should be done after every five years in APRIL with some states.
4..In this way, we'll get a system where we'll know that all the elections of a year will be done in APRIL like one IPL SEASON EVERY YEAR.
5..GOVTS FALLING BW MAY TO OCT
after 6 month in oct ECI will review the status of states who went to election in apr.
If some state govts out of 28 states falls in these 6 months they should go to elections in oct.
6..So oct will be month for SPECIAL ELECTION if any state govts fall in bw apr to oct.
Note; these oct govts will complete their term in oct five yrs later, but there their terms will be reduced by 6 months so as to be remain in synchronisation wilth other states.
This way if all the states going to polls in a yr in any month will go to polls in apr by reducing some months from their term.
7..GOVT FALLING BW NOV TO MARCH
if state govts falls in bw nov to march , presidential rule should be imposed on them until our next yrs season, that is APRIL MONTH.
8..THIS WAY APRIL will become election month of every yr.
AND OCT will be month for SPECIAL ELECTION in case any govt falls.
9.. Now since all state elections and panchayti election got synchronised for every every year. Let's talk about national polls.
10.. National elections should also be done in APRIL OF EVERY YEAR.
IF UNION GOVT FALLS BW MAY TO DEC we cannot wait for next apr because it will be loss for nation.
We should try to adjust national elections with states elections. That is either in APR OR OCT.
362 ayes in Lok Sabha & 167 in Rajya Sabha , not possible . bill will fail.
What if goverment loses majority in middle ? Impractical
Amaithunallathinai seovathe nammothiji
There can be one nation one election but according to me one more thing should be added to it and that is elections should not be held according to a five year plan but according to a four year plan.
Good
🙏🙏
oneNation-one Tax
one Nation-one petrolPrice
oneNation-onestate
oneNation-one Relegion
one Nation one culture
one Nation - one pM
oneNation-one Language
All wil bring by BJP to avoid and Spoil the Divorcity of India
it will be very tough to Bharath Matha
Last year election commission spent nearly 1 lakh crore for elections for 1.3 million polling booths 8000+ candidates for polling officer per day salary 250 per day including food and residing officer salary 250 per day to cut down these expenses the bill is needed
Divorcity 😂
@@OBCgenz 😂
@@OBCgenz Most probably intentional. Divorce+Diversity=Divorcity
Very very great step.
Hey akshata nandagopal you should have put india today logo? Shameless rajdeep sardesai
Here's the reformed made simple.
Modi can't go running from state to state seaming #indu Khatre mein hain.
And the cost of mlas are going up because of bad economy management. Cheaper to buy them in bulk instead of election by election
Shortened further the bjp wants to make our democracy sasta aur bikao
It's a good idea, but it should be implemented by the person who has the will to care for the people or the nation! Otherwise, more Adanies will be born again!
Tell me how?
Therre is absolutely nothing wrong with Ambani and Adani. They are a natural result of Capitalist Society.
You rather prefer Beggars and poverty whio are result of Failed Socialism ?
NOW NEXT
ONE NATION ONE EDUCATION
Actually, we do need to set a similar standard for the education across all states (atleast for the STEM and Finance/Economics courses)
Next election BJP 400+
Congress against hai toh acha hi hoga😅
All thiefs are opposing it.
Obvisously this will not go through with the current status of opposition and their strength in both houses
One national one Pappu
One Adani one modi😅
Need of hour
Abolished wakf board..
I absolutely support this move , we can not waste tax payers money .. even richest county us follows this I don’t know y we r not
One nation one EVM setting bill
By now its a meme, EVM is blamed by Losers who can't win elections.
Congress won in Karnataka, Telangana, Kashmir and Kerala. Surprisingly, No EVM Hacking reported in these States.. LOL. Shameless COngress, always blame something for their Failures. BJP never blamed Congress for EVMs, They accepted defeat gracefully.
Cry today cry tomorrow...
True
Is that how congress got 99 seats during the last election?
This EVM compromise conspiracy won't work anymore. People aren't dumb.
Till now Hon'ble
Modi Ji
remained successful and beneficent to uninfluenced people.
hope for the best
KhanCross also says "ONE Person - One Wife" isn't advisable & feasible.
LORDSHIPS will DANCE
Fascist Theocracy