Who Was Stokely Carmichael? with Paul Berman

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 окт 2024

Комментарии • 26

  • @benqurayza7872
    @benqurayza7872 День назад +8

    No Harvard or Columbia student can credibly claim s/he doesn't know which river and which sea.

    • @wadetisthammer3612
      @wadetisthammer3612 День назад +4

      Don't underestimate the ignorance of some of these students. It's possible to be very smart in one area but be profoundly ignorant in another.

    • @willard39
      @willard39 День назад +2

      I disagree. These kids are supporting a narrative and that alone. That requires a dedication to intellectual laziness or outright disregard for facts.

    • @francisjo3
      @francisjo3 День назад +2

      @@wadetisthammer3612 More than possible, I daresay it's commonplace!

  • @Tewhill357
    @Tewhill357 День назад +2

    A hard distinction between Good SC and Bad SC seems to rely on magical thinking.

  • @ef2718
    @ef2718 День назад +4

    Zionism is the independent existence of Jews in Jewdea.
    The first leader to lead the Israelis back to independent living in Zion was Prophet Moses AS, he was the first Zionist leader.

  • @megsley
    @megsley День назад +1

    oh god for a moment i was like "the heel manager from AEW?!"
    nope thats stokely hathaway lol

  • @PecosChico
    @PecosChico День назад +2

    How far is it from chanting the slogans to acting them out?

    • @Behave_New_1984
      @Behave_New_1984 День назад +2

      It's no difference anymore. The arab world have been acting this out since the beginning of islam.

  • @JonathanRossRogers
    @JonathanRossRogers День назад

    I'm used to seeing extreme anti-Zionist comments on RUclips videos. Apparently, the opposite exists as well.

  • @Beretta249
    @Beretta249 День назад +3

    Yeah the heidegger and gibson tangent was really unnecessary. Even for an "upmarket" audience. Plus the actual anti-semitic apologia. Maybe don't do that. When it comes to inciting g3nocide the art doesn't make up for the artist. "I love your analogies " means _"I can't f*cking believe you actually said that to my face."_
    I like this interviewer (Jonothan Kay) normally, but this time Quilette needed a quality check. Digging that hole began with f*cking _heidegger,_ and then _mel gibson,_ and maybe should have stopped there?

  • @phillipmargrave
    @phillipmargrave 7 минут назад

    Intifada means world wide socialist revolution.

  • @sshender3773
    @sshender3773 День назад +1

    I find it somewhat amusing that both men here are seriously discussing certain things without even understanding their meaning first. "Globalize the Intifadah" doesn't mean let's do Jewish pogroms, suicide bombings and murder Jews around the world. For those chanting it, the Intifadah is not synonymous with that campaign of terrorism and carnage that we have grown to associate that word with during the second intifada. For them, Intifada (literally translated from Arabic as shaking off) means the unshackling of the "downtrodden" from their colonial masters. It's hardly news that these people view Israel as a settler collonial state imposed by the white imperialists unto the indigenous Arab population, and the Intifada as the righteous and inevitable pushback against that "colonial" project. They see the resistance embodied in the intifada as the ultimate goal to be globalized and repeated across the world. In their feverish minds, colonialism has morphed into corporate, rather than state, colonialism so there are always things to rebel against and shakles to shake off.
    Strawmanning this doesn't help anyone.

    • @dogbert52
      @dogbert52 16 часов назад

      Cool. So you inveneted a straw man and then went against straw manning..... thats the new trick?

    • @sshender3773
      @sshender3773 15 часов назад

      @@dogbert52 What straw man did I invent, oh wise one?

  • @ruthhorowitz7625
    @ruthhorowitz7625 День назад

    I guess I'm a bad Zionist 😂

  • @Behave_New_1984
    @Behave_New_1984 День назад

    This show sounds like a pseudo-intellectual antisemitism apologetics roadshow...

  • @Behave_New_1984
    @Behave_New_1984 День назад

    Wagner and good music? Lol... Just check what his contemporaries had to say / write (and even compose) about Wagner 😂

    • @Hesnotoneofus
      @Hesnotoneofus День назад

      lol wtf do you live as contrarian because you too scared to hold real opinions? Wagner is obviously incredible music despite his antisemitism and racism... I would think that Stephen Fry Has better taste that you...