IGN Top 100 Games of All Time was a disaster...
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 15 сен 2024
- Coney looks at IGN's Top 100 Games of All Time, and is immensely disappointed with the list. His favorites are either non-existent or very low on the list while all the games he despises are rated too high. Is Coney out of touch with the current game sphere?
➤ WATCH ME LIVE: / coney
➤ Follow me on Twitter: / coney
➤ Subscribe to my RUclips: / coneyzz
➤ Watch my VODs: / @coneyvods
Edited by Quinn: / quinnandwin
#coney #ign #breathofthewild #thelegendofzelda #legendofzelda
Coney went through four out of the five stages of grief when he saw BOTW at number 1. I don’t think he reached acceptance.
Because it shouldn't be there lol
It’s such a good game. Coney is just dumb
@@silvesta5027 Is objectively it good? Yes, yes it is. But is it anywhere close to as good as people think it is? No absolutely not, it’s pretty to look at but ultimately the game is extremely boring. I’m pretty sure whoever decided it was #1 of all time, BOTW was the first Zelda game they ever played lol
@@silvesta5027 I respect that, I’m not calling it bad in any regard, I just think putting it as the #1 game of all time is just going off the reviews and fan opinions. No list is going to be perfect but you could be a little more objective. I would put it somewhere in top 15 or so but there are definitely more defining Zelda games to choose for the higher placings.
Maybe it’s the fact that BOTW is the top spot and games like FFVII and Ocarina of Time are much lower. Heck Persona 5 didn’t even make the list.
The thoughts going through my head when I read this list:
1. Is this ordered?
2. Are they joking?
3. Are you sure this is ordered?
4. They’re definitely mutants or giga-hipsters
I doubt they’re ranked. I think it’s just 100 good games
@@Blockoumi Yeah but botw got its own art highlight
I'm surprised egg scramble from fall guys isn't in this list
@@7k_VNix true. But honestly, ranking 100 things is insanely hard
Do you know how hard it is to exterminate giga-hipsters?
I mentioned this in the chat a couple times; right above the title of the article there is a list of the top 5 games, so him guessing wrong with those visible was really funny.
Hey, at least he wasn't capping you know? He was genuinely clueless.
its more interesting that way lol, its just entertainment
so ur that type of person, eh
I love coney’s confidence in the beginning only for him to fall apart when he gets to the 20’s
I appreciate the "Assassin's Creed: The Pirate One" art for the short moment it was up
honestly if any AC game was gonna make it onto this list it would be Black Flag
@@simmy0019 easily the best AC. Real AC fans know this, followed by 2.
They’re really putting retro-good games and current trends over games that literally helped define their genre, huh?
Good ole IGN.
At the beginning of the article it says it's based on quality and doesn't consider impact at all like they used to do it. I agree with that tbh.
@@Matthew.Morcos and yet LoL made the list
@@Matthew.Morcos and yet the original mario was put in over celeste…
@@gamer-hl4cp SMB1 unironically plays like balls by today's standards
IGN does have some good names working for them though, like Max Scoville or Michael Swaim. they do have some really intelligent, passionate people on their team, who i root for as individuals- but yeah overall they just seem like shills. I think Gametrailers was the best.
CONEY: "I love Yoshi's Island."
Also CONEY: "I HATE YOSHI, AND IF YOU LIKE YOSHI YOUR A CHILD!"
Theres a differencw between yoshi island and yoshi in smash bros
they made the smash character for people who haven't learned how to read the "fun to play with, not to eat" label on Play Doh
If there is anything I have learned from alpharad it’s that I can’t possibly be any older than 6 since I play yoshi
T R U E
The duality of Coney.
Neither of the Super Mario Galaxy games broke my damn heart
other games were just better what can i tell ya
Fr
nah man original donkey Kong does NOT beat galaxy, legacy can only get a game so far
im sorry but i love the two and they don’t beat out any of the ones above them
Coney is the best streamer because he can go from absolute based takes to the fucking dregs of RUclips comments-tier takes in the blink of an eye
He sounds like the most human streamer.
FF7 98 “too old”
3 of the top five are from the snes
Not saying I agree with this list but I'm not surprised snes games would be rated so high. Snes tend to age way better visually and gameplay wise than ps1 or n64 era games.
@@slitchey oh yeah for sure snes game aged way better visually but you can’t say a game is old so it’s low then put 30 year old games above it
@@Idranim I'd say it's especially strange to say that FFVII's gameplay has aged poorly and then put Earthbound ~50 slots higher when Earthbound (for as much as I adore it) also has not aged the most gracefully in the gameplay department.
@@TheWrathAboveeb’s just better than ffvii
I’m convinced these lists only exist to stir controversy and aren’t meant to be taken seriously. The content of the list is fine but the ordering is so strange
Barely 6 minutes in and they put MK11 over ANY of the other ones in the franchise.
Oh absolutely it is controversy over others.
@@VVheeli mkx supremacy
@@trevorlorah4992 legit the people I knew that actually played MK9 loved its jank “everyone’s broken”. MKX was uniquely explosive and fast for NRS. The old ones like MK1-MK3 helped push the genre to western audiences.
I don’t know a single pro player that thinks NRS did a good job handling MK11. The fact that it’s the only MK rep is bonkers.
@@VVheeli Guess it's more casual popular and thats why its listed
tbh I think hollow knight is in the top 3 games of all time, but seeing it at 54 was reasonable. then they put Ms. Pac Man directly after and I can't even really describe the feelings I felt.
I mean Ms. Pac-man's a good arcade game, would probably fit right in around the 80 mark. But better then Hollow Knight and at the mid 50s? Idk man that just ain't right.
LMFAO. This is why y'all don't make lists. Stay in the comments.
@@guitarhero38633 if you think ms pac man is better than hollow knight you are deluded
@@joshuaselley2262 I am not talking about Ms pac man being better than hollow knight
I am taking about hollow knight not belonging in top 15. Let alone top 3
Hard agree
I find it amusing that they pretty much completely ignore their own standards listed before getting into the top 100. Predictable, but still amusing.
I just think its funny that they bashed Final Fantasy 7 for being "old" then listed 6 like 15 slots higher
@@furyofyuriy Yeah that's wild, I get that people have their preferences on which is better, but they're not that disparate in quality.
@@furyofyuriy I think 7 shows it's age more. The artstyle doesn't hold up as well and they went so hard on showcasing the visuals that it sometimes killed the pacing of the combat
@@Technoblast649 Graphically you're certainly right, though in general I'd be argue that 6 and 7 are roughly equal in quality.
IMO I love BOTW, at first it was meh running in a random direction collecting korok seeds and magnetizing chests out of rivers but when I realized I could just ignore that and do stuff I wanted like climb that giant frost mountain, break into Hyrule underleveled, and sail to that stranded island, the game suddenly felt incredible. Playing any open world game like a completionist is just miserable. All that said it should be top 50 not number one lmao.
Its good but far from perfect
True. I think it's amazing but NOT perfect, and there have been and were games better than it.
@@Commander-peepers Its perfect
@@Jacob_G9 its perfect
@@emmamiller. play a different game.
I think we need a Coney top 100 games Tier List.
His list would be high key trash and i wanna see it so badly.
Don't get why people get so offended by top lists lol you are not gonna agree with them and thats why I watch them
@@DumbIdeaPresentedStupidly especially a list of 100. There's no way you're ever going to find out all list of 100 games that you agree with even half of.
Oh I want this so badly
He shouldnt because hes going to offend a bunch of people just like how he did in this video saying breath of the wild is trash. Its my favorite video game of all time...it means so much to meee 😭
@@emmamiller. your tears sustain him
I said this on the video itself, but ever since the dislike button got basically removed they been making a lot more top 10 lists
👀👀
Unfortunately for them, there's an extension that lets people see them again
It’s literally impossible to create a list of the top 100 games. If doesn’t matter what you say, people will 100% disagree with you. Also who has even played 100 games? Let alone 100 of the best ones. I feel the only person on the planet qualified to make a list like that would be Jirard the Completionist
I've played 355 games in my life but only 21 on that top 100 list
Huh? 100 is not a lot if you're a life long "gamer". How many films do you think people have seen? Also, it's not necessary to beat the games that start to feel like a waste of your time.
@@lastburning Not everyone is a ‘lifelong gamer.’ If you’ve beaten 100+ games you’re in the vast minority
@@lastburning Just because hardcore gamers are a vocal minority does not mean there are very many who have actually played enough games to make a top 100. You're participating in a community that plays a lot of games and acts as an echo chamber to make it seem like there are in fact a lot of people who have played that many.
@@DineAuZor And?
Coney's thoughts on Breath of the Wild conflicting with just about everyone in chat made me realize that IGN's list is just as valid as anyone else's top 100 games, because you can't make the list without it almost entirely being based on personal bias, and that's okay. It just helps to understand the voice of the crtiic, if anything.
Honestly, I'm surprised Banjo-Kazooie didn't make the list. Pretty much everyone that has played the game loves it. Personally I love Tooie more, but I think Kazooie should take the spot, because as far as I've seen public opinion online, people generally like that one better.
Fellow Tooie lover, that game is my childhood right there
Tooie is better, realistically both should have made it in here.
@@trueblueryu5713 I feel which is better is pretty much purely subjective and they're just about equal in quality with both excelling at different things.
while i'm not going to say there wasn't a lot of competition this list is very clearly heavy in "What's relevant to the average reader of our website that doesn't actually engage with video games very often" or at least something like that
Collectathons are a pretty subjective genre as not a lot of people like them. But I believe that most 3d mario games are better in general. Although, the quirkiness of banjo kazooie/tooie is unrivaled and should at least be somewhere in the list.
Breaking news, local boomer upset time is moving forward.
He isn't completely wrong. It's been more than a year and that list still feels like a shitpost.
I don’t know why Coney brings up sales or most played so much while also dissing Animal Crossing New Horizons, which sold more than almost every game on the list lol. Or basically any game that sold well but he doesn’t like.
Copium.
A game should have sold well AND be well liked by most people, and I don't think New Horizons is considered that which is what Coney was probably going for in terms of "best game of all time". 99% of Animal Crossing fans will tell you that New Leaf is a billion times better than New Horizons and it had a much longer cultural impact.
@@KongQuest95 After the latest update, New Horizons is probably better than New Leaf in most ways. On top of that, it’s more culturally impactful and significant as well. Even if a fair amount of people prefer some older game, most people still seem to like or love New Horizons, so that doesn’t fit. It was overall received well, this ain’t amiibo festival my dude.
The dude also praises freaking Fortnite lmao That game is hated a lot more than New Horizons from my perspective.
Not only that, but that isn’t what Coney said at all.
@@Random1567 most people have no idea what the new update is because they quit playing like a year ago
@Random1567 from what I've seen, most people still prefer New Leaf while New Horizons is still contorversial. New Horizons had a big splash just like Kirby: Star Allies and Mario Kart 8 Deluxe, all are fine games but it had more to do with right place right time and died out within a couple of months. New Leaf had a dedicated community for its entire life and then some.
Fortnite created an entirely new, insanely popular game genre that has taken over at least 2 entire generations of people. And, just like Minecraft at the time, of course there are gonna be haters.
I didn't say Coney said that, I'm just inferring that based on what he's saying should and shouldn't be in the top 100.
The biggest travesty is the fact that pokemon yellow is on there that games both aged and not very good
Honestly, if they were going to pick a Pokémon game, they should've went with Emerald, Platinum or Heart Gold/Soul Silver, because those have aged far greater and as far as I can tell most people love those games the best of the series.
Honestly yeah but I feel like they're barred by being on older systems
Obviously emulation exists although not everyone has that but for the most part I agree, hgss emerald and platinum are all pretty good and definitely better and just more polished than yellow
@@Selsius96 I would also add, although would put Black and White above those even. Or hell, B2/W2 for gameplay perspective alone. No more artificial limitation with TMs. To where if you want to do post game stuff, like Battle Frontier or whatever it's equivalent might be, you have to purposely gimp your entire team from having any good moves they can't learn outside of the TMs. Because you usually had one shot on them learning the moves, and had to be really careful and absolutely sure the Pokemon you've raised is something you want learning the TMs. Plus them making it less of a pain to traversal the region, especially for main story, where HMs are more optional, than mandatory. So less places blocked off by the HM obstacles.
People have been coming around to loving those games as well, as of recent, after coming with the realization of what those did. Compared to what recent Pokemon games are doing.
Fun fact: In IGN’S top 10 roguelike list, they put Hades as number 2, and Isaac as number 1.
Yet Hades is on the list and Isaac is not.
What!?
Bc ign isn’t just one guy it’s a corporation of people with different opinions 👍
They became back their money I guess
"Do you know how many games did (open world sandbox) before (BOTW)?"
it's just an unwritten rule of the games industry: Something is revolutionary twice. Once when it's introduced, and then a second time when Nintendo does it.
When has something like this ever happened previously though? Not talking about the concept of open world games to be clear, I'm referring to your claim about the game industry claiming something is revolutionary when Nintendo does something that has already been done before because this is the only instance I can think of where something like this has happened.
There is no doubt in my mind that ign knows they're a meme and is now purposefully getting it so wrong that know one agrees but just close enough that people dont know they're trolling
@Multi well "too much water" is something they got right
Has anyone ever come across a top list on the internet and said "yeah this is so right" no you argue with the list and thats what makes them fun
Only thing I knew about the list was BOTW getting top spot so Coney's slow realization to it was good cinema
Bro really posted his BOTW rant on RUclips , a fatal mistake
My guesses before I see this list:
Somewhere in top 25 in no particular order:
1. OOT
2. Super Mario World 3
3. Bioshock
4. Portal
5. MGS 5 (because IGN)
6. KOTOR II
7. Metroid
8. Mass Effect
9. WoW?
10. Halo 2
11. TF2 (because IGN)
12. Half Life 2
13. Backyard Baseball
14. Freddy Fish
15. Sneak King
16. Smash Bros Brawl
17. Star Wars Galaxies
18. Words With Friends
19. Farmville
20. Sonic on Sega Genesis
21. Mario Kart 64
22. Harry Potter 2
23. Fallout Mobile Game
24. Freddy Fish II
25. Monkey Island
*also, free content --- you could re-arrange their top 100 in a **correct** order. And then the internet will hate on you anyway
My mans pulled out the Sneak King ROFL
Portal and not portal 2? I liked portal 2 better personally
@@darkyz8538 bro read the rest of the list lol
No shot u thought brawl was gonna be the best of the smash games
Okay, if we ignore the competitive scene, Brawl actually is the best Smash game I feel like.
I played Super Metroid for the first time about a year ago on my switch. Enjoyed it a lot
he's to harsh on the metroidvanias except hallowknight for some reason. personally i found the metroid games more enjoyable than hallow knight but i guess everyone does have different taste
@@Da_Puff personally Hollow Knight is still my favorite Metroidvania, but Super Metroid is currently in 3rd place for me, right after Metroid Dread because I thought the story was super fucking sick
My 100 would also have included (in no particular order)...
Super Castlevania IV
Timesplitters 2
Donkey Kong Country 2
Super Mario Galaxy
Super Mario Galaxy 2
Super Mario Oddessy
Civilization V
Resident Evil 4
Football Manager
Secret of Mana
Seiken Densetsu 3
I think the thing that separates BOTW from other open world games is it gives you chance to think out of the box. If you can see it, you can probably go to it. If you choose to, you can even go straight to Hyrule castle without the need for "leveling up".
Gotta say. I played Super Metroid for the first time in December of last year and it’s one of my favorite games.
22:21
Unironically, I played it for the first time a year or two years ago, and even though I struggled a bit, I had a lot of fun.
It actually got me into the Metroid series. I’ve played Dread, Am2r, and Fusion since then, and I’m also working on Zero Mission.
Yeah honestly Coney's Metroid takes are clown food lol
Same, I played all the mainline Metroid games for the first time 2 years ago and even though AM2R and Prime 3 ended up being my favorites, Super Metroid is definitely THE best Metroid game and definitely one of the best metroidvanias of all time.
For the exact reasons you described, Metroid is one of the best sagas in gaming. You play one and then there are like 3 others you can pick up almost immediately. Which is exactly what happened during Dread's sales. Everyone downloaded Samus returns. If they end up remastering the first one again the circle will be complete. You will never need to buy another Nintendo console.
I played botw a lot so kinda biased but I think it deserved it.
I also think it deserved it
God thanks I’m not the only one. The guy is stupid
Yeah it’s a great game, kind of wished Majoras mask was on the list tho. But I think this guy just was bad at botw lol
I think the platform is what truly elevates BOTW. Just playing a game like that handheld is something truly unique to me. You can't put Horizon Zero Dawn on the Switch and it isn't.
Hi @CONEY , resident woman here
I can firmly say that Squall is absurdly hot, way above the necessary level, therefore making FF8 unquestionably better than its predecessors
See now this is an argument for FF8 being good that actually has some weight behind it.
Thank you now we understand lol
And I could not disagree more, Sabin from FF6 is the hottest FF character.
As a Dota 2 player, it does feel weird we're on top LoL. I think we were fucked by Riot ever since they released that KPOP/Champions band hybrid.
And as a gamer, this list sucks.
I don’t think we’ll look back on BOTW as the greatest game of all time.
I think we’ll look back on BOTW 2 as the greatest game of all time.
yesss
BASED
Yesssssss
@@jacobdumas7643 darn it you ruined the chain >:(
Who in their right mind consider BoTW even in top 30?
22:10 I booted this game up on my switch without ever playing it before and it became one of my favorite games of all time. So……..
Am I the only one surprised that Mario odyssey wasn’t on the list
Mega man 3 is not from 1933 but from 1990
It actually pains me how neither Mario Galaxy game got in this list
Were there any 3d marios
im sorry but galaxy and odyssey should definitely be top 100
Certainly odyssey
Definitely man. Both of those games go dummy
Ok, as someone who had never really played a video games until 2018, and didn’t really get into gaming 2020ish, odyssey is amazing. First video game I ever played (that wasn’t like a party game) and it made me fall in the love with the medium. People dog on mario games for being easy but who cares when they’re so goddamn fun.
@@anyazxr one of the things that's so good about odyssey is that you can make it easy or difficult on yourself if you want. You can play normally and never even have to learn how to cap bounce or you can learn the movement tech and do some speed strats
9:05
Earthbound does have flaws, being an SNES game, but I would put it higher personally. It’s combat is pretty great in my opinion, one of the first games to not use random encounters, and it’s pretty good overall.
I agree strongly
Y'all aren't ready to hear this, but while EarthBound is better in battle gameplay, Mother 1 is better in story and characters. After you play Mother 1 you realize EarthBound is a soft-remake with a less focused story and nothing characters.
Openly attacking BotW in 2022? Can’t wait to see how that’s gonna turn out 😅😅
I actually agree with him. I think it's a good game but there's a lot of things I personally don't like about it.
From my experience I was bored. I liked Twilight Princess cause I felt threatened XD
@@shatteredsentient5321 My problem with the game is just how slow it is and repetitive the srines are. I would climb the tower, locate shrines, then solve them. I hate the stamina system because it makes climbing and swimming a hassle which to me is kind of counter intuitive to having an open world type of game. I want to explore everywhere but it's just too big. I personally don't like the durability system, I'm fine if they kept it but rewards from the shrines but you typically get bad weapons so it doesn't encourage the player to use them or allow tthe weapons to repair them. To me there's just a lot of problems that keep it from being amazing. It's a good game though
Botw is only fun for me using speedrun mechanics like btbs and wind bombs playing it normally I got bored after 2 divine beasts back when it came out
@@shatteredsentient5321 "I liked Twilight Princess cause I felt threatened"
Good joke of the year so far. If it was anything like a Link to the Past, then I would believe you were serious.
Not to be that guy but Maximillian Dood just played Super Metroid for the first time and it was in his top 5 games of the year list.
I played it as a young adult for the first time and it's in my top 5. Coney has -10 patience and extreme streamer brain, (and that's what I like about him as a streamer lol) but atmospheric exploration games like Metroid and Outer Wilds (or BOTW for that matter) are just not for him.
if IGN wanted a "do whatever you want how you want" game then they should've gone with like outer wilds as number 1. but breath of the wild is a really solid, popular, and uncontroversial game to put into number 1 and i feel like IGN's been about that so it's ok. weirdly enough, i think coney is the only person i've heard who does not like breath of the wild
This list has me dying. I was astonished by borderlands 2 being at 100
How can you put the biggest crossover in gaming history that's a banger competitively and casually at 76?
I am a fan of Ultimate but if you have no friends to actively play it with then your options are basically Online, Classic mode, or Spirits (which was really fun the first go round at the cost of not very replayable)
75-76 ish seems fair because I can see someone put it at 90 or 50 and understand why
some of these changes are crazy: in IGN's 2018 list botw was 26 and oot was 2 lol
17:29
I didn't know Coney was the voice actor of the vulture.
You really don't understand the significance of the half life games do you? they weren't just tech demos. They pretty much set the standard for first person shooters. It also has a very solid story. Why do you think there were so many expansions to the games? The first game with three different expansions that focused on different points of view in the black mesa incident. And Half life 2 in continuing the story after the main game in an episode format. The reason why an episode three never came is because they drove themselves into a corner with the story at the end of episode 2. Half Life Alyx fixed that mistake and there are more possible stories to work with now assuming valve gets off their asses, hires more people, and actually decide to make progress on a third entry.. The story can be vague but environmental storytelling can tell you a lot about what happened and not a lot of games do that well
This is now my favorite coney video since his reactions to almost all the games is Hilarious
6:46
eFSmash, the one in the chat, I am coming for you
And I’m going after VeryBigSeagull at 3:10
No Mario Galaxy?
Best 3D mario game
Best Mario game in general
Ok but 30 hours in BOTW is basically nothing 🤣
Breath of the wild did really deserve to be in top 3 but 1st place don’t know but the game is legendary it’s so good
Whats so good about it? It's plainly boring. You just run from shrine to shrine, do your save the city quest four times and beat the bad... thingy at the end? I only started to enjoy it with waikuterus randomizer which gave the game at least some challange.
@@exschweizer The good thing about it is that you dont have to do any of the things you stated, instead you can go straight to ganon, or only defeat one divine beast, and what do you mean bad thingy at the end? like 75% of games like this have a big villain boss battle at the end. You dont have to do shrines! like im starting to think that you just didnt play the game and are just a fan of this guy, if this is how you think the game is, and yes it does have a shit story i agree, but sometimes you gotta sacrifise the story, for the gameplay. You also have multiple ways to solve puzzles, not every game has that.
@@Isaac-mo2op I played BotW multiple times to a varying degree of completence (All shrines, minimalistic etc.) The bad thingy at the end was ganon;-). I agree that the mechanic to finish the game at any point is good and kind of well done and also that its pretty neat how creatively you can solve the puzzles.
But the game as a whole is for one far to big (900 Korok-Seeds, inventive dishes are pretty much useless, far spaces of just empty hyrule which wouldn't matter if taken away), has atrociously few enemy-types (bokoblins, moblins, lizalfos, hinox, lynels and 3 Guardian-types) you encounter on a regular basis (unlike small guardians, stone talus) and are a threat (who cares about chuchus or keesees?). The Enemies do not get more interesting with their color, they are still the same boring procedere, it just takes more hits to kill them.
The Puzzles are rather simple. It is cool that you can solve them multiple ways, but then again, your ways only include like 5 interactionpossibilities (Arrows, bombs, paragliding, stopping time/movement, freezing pillows and occasional apparatusses), therefore it's more of a rather short try and error.
And finally whats your job? You have like 5 "main quests" which do make a difference during gameplay, being shrines, divine beasts, beating ganon, finding koroks and getting the mastersword. Thats it. You've finished the game.
Now have fun trying all the glitches and goofing around in singleplayer, because there is no more meaningful gameplay.
@@exschweizer here's the thing though, one of the main reasons it's so fun is the physics in the game which were intentionally made to be messed with, it's fun to see what you can accomplish from experimenting, no game is able to be fresh forever but breath of the wild does its job by having there be a big world with a good amount if interesting landmarks to find and simple yet fun puzzles to solve, if you watch other youtubers play it many of them have a blast with the game and that's because it's just fun to chill and do whatever and just mess around, I'll admit it's far from perfect but the things you can do in the game are what make it interesting plus the little details in the game don't hurt either, in short it's not perfect but saying it doesn't deserve the praise it gets at least to me is wrong cause if it's getting a lot of praise even to this day then there's an obvious reason and no it's not because everyone is easily impressed or because they have simple minds, the game is just fun to play and it's nice when the puzzles you need to solve are in the form of riddles and things like that.
@@exschweizer you have to feel this game and see it as relaxation sometimes
i agree that Botw shouldnt be No. 1 but its also my favorite game of all time so im just gonna sit here and laugh at Coney's pain
The glitches in BOTW makes it goated. Makes it wayyyy more fun and they are still finding new ones to this day :)
Its so much fun!!
Am i wrong or Isn't there a single Kirby game in the fucking IGN list. C'mon at least return to dreamland or Planet robobot should've been in there
I expected Super Star Ultra personally considering their hard on for SNES games and the fact that Kirby Super Star is *the* popular Kirby game
@@TheWrathAbove it's like they hate kirby
Claiming botw as the greatest video game of all time is the most IGN thing I have ever heard in my life
“How did they brainwash so many people”. I legitimately don’t know and that’s the real question.
I have played Super Metroid for the first time in 2019, and I loved it, so no you don't need to know everything about the game to like it.
the worst part is that people dared to compare that garbage with Horizon Zero Dawn, the only reason Breath of the shit won goty was because it's titled Zelda, remove that title and nobody would have cared. Horizon was far more engaging with better graphics.
Is it though? I mean what about the graphics are better? If you answer that they're more realistic then that isn't a good answer cause that's a design choice and like it or not, Breath of the Wild's design choice isn't even bad, it's just different than what you like. Also...you wonder why people compare botw to hzd when the latter came after botw, does many things that are in botw and the second title of that game adds a paraglider which gives people more reason to compare the two. For me personally I like both but HZD has some janky gameplay compared to botw, riding striders in that game is hard for the wrong reasons, climbing mountains or almost anything in that game doesn't feel very natural since when you jump to a ledge that's in front of a aloy but it isn't the first ledge you're supposed to grab onto, she plops down like a rock to catch the lowest one, the combat in that game isn't any better or anymore creative that BOTW and travelling in that game for me personally sometimes becomes annoying because again travelling with a strider is janky and there are enemies everywhere that sometimes you can't even avoid when you really don't want to deal with them. Anyways in short, HZD isn't any better than BOTW and has many flaws, knowing you'd like to actually explain why you think BOTW is "trash" then go ahead.
P.S, there are people who have never heard of or played a Zelda game yet still loved breath of the wild so yeah, it ain't only cause it's titled zelda
True af
I like Breath of the Wild but it's truly a tech demo. Nobody will admit it especially Nintendofans and game journalists that want to be on good terms with Nintendo but it's a tech demo. I have insanely high expectations for the sequel because of it. They'll of had over 5 years with day zero literally being BOTW's physics, combat, world and models. They better have a legitimate game next time for all the unearned and overdone accolades they got last time. I truly think it was just a massive group-coping session on the part of Nintendofans that were desperate for a W after half a decade of Wii U shame and embarrassment.
I think you mean proof of concept not tech demo, botw doesn't really do anything unique with the wii u hardware and it wouldn't make sense for it to be a tech demo either considering it's the last wii u game
@@bobboberson8297 Yeah that's more accurate.
I’m just pissed that they had Pokémon yellow on the list. Pokémon generation 1 is objectively the worst generation. The games barely functioned and had almost nothing to do outside of the main quest. I would have been fine if they had put literally any other Pokémon game on this list.
Based
What you are not understanding is this is the top 100 biggest payouts IGN made from gaming, either from fudging the higher score or getting clicks for views when the game was mentioned.
Is it just me or does anyone else get a little upset when someone dogs on a game just because it's old? Just a little bit of criticism, but when he mentioned how goldeneye deserves the place it was at because it's old and janky, but is shocked that ocarina didn't rank top 5? That seems a little unwarranted as ocarina of time, in today's terms, is also old and has janky controls. Ocarina is a great game and I wish gaming companies who make these lists would judge them by how good they are rather than how old and how popular they are.
That one pic of coney wiyh the grin kills me
If uninfluenced by what I'm "supposed" to put in a top 10, mine are
-DKC2: Diddy's Kong Quest (SNES)
-U.N. Squadron (SNES)
-OoT
-Smash Ultimate
-Animal Crossing New Horizons
-KH2.5 Remix
-Wrath of the Lich King
-Cuphead
-007 Nightfire (Multiplayer)
-Lion King (SNES)
Haven't even heard of Horizon Zero Dawn and I just looked it up. Looks awesome! I'll definitely get it. Thanks, Coney!
If this isn't bait or any other inside joke a filthy RUclips only wouldn't know, then I'll say, it's a pretty good game. Even my dad is replaying it now since we got it fully upgraded on the CORONI deals.
@@hamzahkhan4067 no joke! I've been MIA in gaming for a bit. Last console i had was Xbox360. Got a switch last year and just got a gaming PC a week ago!I've missed A LOT of games so I'm trying to make a list of games i should play and have missed out on.
i love hzd and im glad youre getting into it too
It's a fun game but idk if I'd compare it to BOTW in the ways coney did gameplay wise it's a lot clunkier and a lot more of a traditional open world RPG. It's still super solid though, just wouldn't put it up with BOTW.
But I also wouldn't put BOTW as #1 game let alone #1 Zelda game lol
@@KingR098 i agree with the last part. most zelda fans would put oot or majoras mask as their #1 LoZ game.
I think a lot of games like persona 5 royal, Mario Galaxy, Mario Sunshine, Mario Odyssey, Halo 3, Final Fantasy 7 Remake, and many more should be high up on the list
I want to see Coney's Top 100 now
The difference between horizon zero dawn and botw is that botw is actually fun
You hate it cause it’s a bit u love or hate it type game but botw is genuinely a top of all time for fun sand box exploration
Sorry you didn’t like it and I agree it’s not the best Zelda but it deserves top 10 at least imo
Who said Horizon isn’t fun?
I love BOTW! Yeah, the story was bare and some of the mechanics like the rain and weapon durability can be really annoying, but I really love the open world sandbox gameplay and the detail they put into every inch of this game. But! I would not say it’s top 10 material, I haven’t played many of the games on this list, but I don’t think it belongs any where above top 25.
P.s. Ocarina of Time 3D is better than the original.💯
Pretty much all of its mechanics are annoying. Most either have a limiter or involve some kind of requirement to not drain your health every few seconds. Only mechanics they did right were physics, which I barely used.
@@rpgfanatic9719 Really? You never drop a metal box on a Moblin? Blown a Bokoblin off of a cliff with a Korok Leaf? Snowboarded down a mountain with a shield? Made yourself fly by hitting a rock you froze in time?
@@jackmrsich3178 I didn't say never, I said barely
@@rpgfanatic9719 ah, yeah. But they’re still fun to do!
I feel like I'm the only person who likes weapons breaking. sure they could put in more work but I really like the mechanic and makes me use my hollow head
The biggest joke of the list is not having Mario galaxy, Mario galaxy 2 or Mario odyssey in the top 100 but instead they had Mario 64 in the top 10. Nothing against Mario 64 but it is certainly not better than Mario galaxy 2 or Mario odyssey
I guess they wanted to avoid 10 of the 100 slots being mario, but like, Mario games are stupidly high quality. You can't help that.
Ok Breath of the Wild is a very good game don’t get me wrong, but is it the best game of all time??? I don’t think so. As someone who has over 500 hours into the game I’ve see all the goods and bads of the game and sure it’s fun but there’s points where it is quite uninteresting. I love it but IGN is crazy for ranking it #1
Just exploring is great, but the main quest is boring IMHO
They probably just did everyones favorite game of all time and not the best game of all time. I think Ocarina of time should be top because it made such a huge freaking impact on gaming.
a sick, twisted part of me wants to make a top 100 games of all time list of my own after seeing this.
Going through and marking down games that aren't just good video games or considered to be classics, but also games that are cultural juggernauts that still remain relevant to this day.
Then I realize i wouldn't get clicks from angry gamers for having BOTW at #1 and now I suddenly think that's a very, VERY bad idea.
If Garden warfare 2 isn't on this we riot
Also I predict at least one shantae game and hollow knight and the binding of isaac.
Oh yeah and undertale. Of course. Undertale is like top 15 for sure. Ignore the fact that I chose only indie games and one nieche shooter
Edit: I got hollow knight (and smash in my head), never even played that game I just felt it on here
Isaac is a great game (one of my top 5 favourite in fact), but I'd argue it's far too obtuse and off-putting to ever make it in what is essentially a popularity contest
Wait does coney actually think horizon is better than BOTW please tell me that’s a bit
I played botw for 70 hrs, beat it twice (once when i felt like it, second time to get the "true" ending)
and coney is 100% right.
You utter buffoon, you don't have to start over to get the "true ending", you just need all the memories, clear all the Divine Beasts, and get the Master Sword. The game literally puts you right before the final boss after you beat it, you did almost twice the work for nothing
Nah
You did not just say Horizon is better than BOTW
No Donkey Kong Country is sinful
DKC2 should have been there
I feel like IGN released this list & everybody immediately skipped to the top 10, because man ... some of those early picks are bonkers & I'm shocked I didn't see any memes about them.
Unmatched writing, Borderlands.
Buttstallion isn't the pinnacle of writing? Or shooty mcshootface?
The series known for all of 1 really well written character in it's 5 games.
I’m gonna be real, it is a CRIME that a Hat in Time wasn’t on this list. Banger music, great characters, great movement, post-game content, great DLC, it’s got it all and it WASNT HERE?
Your rantsona is needed here more than anything
Oot at 34 and lttp at 4 is insane
No Mario galaxy games made the list??? Wow
The fact that IGN made a list AT ALL shows that they don't understand gaming. What makes a video game good is subjective to the player. For example, my heart cracked when you said Metroid Prime was boring, but that's because Metroid Prime isn't a game for everyone. It's not possible to create a video game that pleases everyone, and a lot of games are designed around a target audience. You cannot have a single "Greatest Game of All Time" when every person has a different idea as to what that should be.
Coney, some of these takes are straight up dog water, but I really enjoyed this video. Keep the content coming please 🤲.
When you look up un-based in the dictionary, it should just give you a link to this top 100 list.
The first Pokemon games should not be top 100 because about it's a game held together with DuckTape and dreams.
Those games are buggy messes
Im not expecting to see a shin megami tensei
Edit :Ofc Persona 5 Royal is there, not surprised
P5 def deserves it, but it do kinda hurt to see no SMT3.
@@TheWrathAbove right
Where Mario Galaxy 😢
Gotta love how BOTW is listed as the number one game of all time and its already been fully replaced by it's sequel
APEX OVER FORTNITE? EXCUSE ME
It has to be randomized. No way any human whos played through Ocarina would put it that low smh
BOTW is one of my favourite games ever.
How in the heck is it number 1?
same.
As much as I adore BotW, there's no way it's the best game of *all* time. Maybe top 10 but not number one, I would say if a Zelda game was 1st place it would have to be Ocarina of Time.
"Theres nothing to do in it" Dude I have 500+ hours and ive never gotten bored of it. But I guess thats your opinion.