Ohio House passes bill to ban transgender girls from female sports | USA TODAY
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 2 окт 2024
- In a late night session, the Ohio House passed a bill prohibiting transgender girls from participating in female sports in high school and college.
RELATED: Trans athletes are speaking out against bills to ban them from sports bit.ly/3GQv7Ij
House Republicans passed a bill late Wednesday that would prohibit transgender girls from joining female sports teams in high school and college, shoving the proposal into an unrelated bill before taking off for summer break.
Wednesday's vote, which came on the first day of Pride Month, marked the second time Republicans sought a back-door path for the controversial measure. The House initially added it to a bill to allow college students to profit off their name, image and likeness, a move criticized by Gov. Mike DeWine when it passed last year.
» Subscribe to USA TODAY: bit.ly/1xa3XAh
» Watch more on this and other topics from USA TODAY: bit.ly/3q3ON4B
» USA TODAY delivers current local and national news, sports, entertainment, finance, technology, and more through award-winning journalism, photos, videos and VR.
#Ohio #TransgenderAthletes #LGBTQ
hallelujah! finally some sane actions have been taken.
A big win for the girls 🏅
Absolutely unacceptable. If you want to support women there are other ways to do it. Trans women are women so you are still erasing the true women
@@jayceprice8952 trans women's are biological men. A real women is a born women.
@@richmind5867 except that this is false. No debate. You are mentally sick if you think so. A women and a natal female are different things
Girls that, if accused of being trans, will be required to undergo an internal and external exam of their genitalia and have a blood test to determine testosterone levels and genetic makeup.
Doesn't sound like a win at all. Maybe you should read the bill.
@@_NoHandle_ exactly!
Amen! Go Iowa!
I believe it is appropriate to administer a physical to every potential school athlete. This was a requirement during my school years. (Proof of age , physical exam by a certified physician approving athletic participation.)
Thank you! Finally a little bit of normalcy coming back
This won't last
This bill has a provision that if a student athlete’s gender is called into question, that athlete would have to undergo an internal and external exam of their genitalia and have a blood test to determine testosterone levels and genetic makeup.
You call this a "bit of normalcy"? Normal is NOT having kids submit to exams of their genitals because they're Accused of being trans.
There is NOTHING normal about this
@@jayceprice8952 how about you stop being confused about who you truly are?
i only request that from you because you seem to only care about how you feel, have you ever thought about how woman feel about competing with males? i doubt it cause you are full narcissistic behavior.
Now if everyone else will follow suit....let them all have a fair chance of winning...wtg Ohio
Fair chance... because trans girls are giving soccer teams an unfair advantage - and baseball teams and basketball, volleyball - you know, TEAM sports. Oh, and those trans girls in dance troops... totally unfair that they can dance.
Cis girls are winning against EVERY trans girl out there. And that's unfair.
Well, I'm not so sure about Rachel McKinnon. I think letting her compete was a mistake. But that's 1 person out of THOUSANDS.
Your idea of fair is twisted and evil.
Fairness requires compromise. Keep trans women out of top-tier sports but let the majority play who stand 0 chance of breaking so much as a high school record.
They wont
@@jayceprice8952 Trans girls will never be given a fair opportunity if these people have their way.
Now how about doing the same for there locker rooms 🤔
Shout to Ohio! Good Work upholding morals and biology. Even though these ideologies shouldn't even be so apparent like the man said only 11 in 6 years! How could a majority cater everything to such a small minority makes no sense
.
This is what happens when you get your morals and biology from politicians.
Fascism is taking over.
You support pedophiles
This law also says female athletes who's biological sex is in dispute have to have their genital examine before they can participate. You're okay with that?
Yes. Do not let the delusional determine what rules they selfishly believe what’s right. They are DELUSIONAL!
Awesome
Take away 1 group's freedoms to protect another group's feelings.
Fairness requires compromise. If I get all I want and you get nothing, that's not fair. And yet republicans are taking away the rights from ALL trans girls and giving nothing in return. And they call it fair.
When will people start listening to doctors, biologists, psychiatrists, nurses, pediatricians and stop listening to politicians?
Years ago there was a huge boy on my small son's foot ball team. He was a sweet heart & they all got along, but the smaller boys like my son got hurt by him too often, some with concussions. They moved him up with the older kids. but those kids were much more coordinated & matured, so they wound up sending him back. He wound up hurting more kids & felt terrible about it. & the atmosphere became even more stressed. I know parents feel the need to fight for their kids, but they often don't even know what their kids want. While on a job in an old age community I noticed alot of beautiful pencil bust drawings on the walls. I asked the old timer who did them & she said she did. She said she started 5 years ago when she was about 80. It turned out that she'd been told by her parents that she wasn't the artistic one, tho she wanted to be. Her family & then her husband insisted she couldn't draw a straight line all her life & pushed her elsewhere. It wasn't untill a few years after her husband died, when there was no one left to control her that she gave it a go. You can't make the world adapt to your kids, but you can help your kids by listening to them, what they want & how to adapt. Their social well fare is more important to their health & happiness than what ever it is you want them to do or be. Lastly, kids fantasize about everything. It doesn't mean that every fantasy defined them anymore than every compulsion defines anyone. We seem to be living in an era of relentless urgency in a race for security. We're so worried about being some where that we don't even know where we are.
Ok...
Dave Chappelle Did a show in Buffalo and gave every dime of the proceeds to the family's of the victims of the shooting. But no one wants to talk about that.
i checked and you're right, i haven't heard anything abt that
NOT SURE WHAT THAT HAS TO DO WITH THIS STORY?........
Finally some sane news from the US
Common sense prevails!!!!!
Common sense requires a basic working knowledge: context. You lack the necessary education to deduce anything of value.
You have Common Nonsense.
Sure RUclips. AN UNKNOWN ERROR HAS OCCURRED. Lol.
You GNIKCUF SEISSUP. One has to resort to typing words backwards or your algorithm will delete messages that hurt your feelings. Lol.
@@ashayacatl RUclips has word filters. Use the wrong word and your comment is blocked. Channel owners can add to that list.
If you cannot figure out how to reword your statements without gnipyt drawkcab then perhaps you need a thesaurus. There are plenty online.
I get around the filters by editing my post a minute or so later, adding a "." then saving. If I get the "Unknown Error" message, I copy the post and paste it into a new post, then reword it.
@@r-platt , you can’t use a thesaurus when I’m cussing at you.
@@r-platt Awe, poor thing.....you're broken. They got you!
You got GOT! You think Women Penises are a thing....oh, LOL!!!
Don't worry though.
Based on your demographic type, and I'm deducing here based on empirical evidence, namely your post & profile pic.....you're jabbed up plenty good as to clog up your circulatory system & cause you to be affected by that craze that is sweeping through elite, world-class athletes who are dropping like flies on the football pitch, tennis & basketball courts, even after a half marathon in Brooklyn a couple of weeks ago - - - - Point is, even though you're broken, you won't have to suffer it too long. My condolences, sincerely ♥
"Brought to you by....Pfizer!"
Thank god. Thank god there’s still common sense
Why is Khazarian Tube hiding so many Replies?
As a biological man who has competed against women in sports, in soccer and martial arts, I urge, desperately urge, any sound-minded people, to support any legislation banning the participation of biological males in women’s sports!!
Don't they know that boys make the best female athletes? Haven't they seen how much faster and stronger boys with long hair are? Don't they want to win?
Trans girls are not boys.
They do not perform anywhere near boys' levels. They DO perform at typical levels for girls.
Thus no trans girl wins more than 30% of races.
And where are all the soccer, volleyball, basketball or even baseball teams going to state finals because of a trans teammate?
@@r-platt Men still make the best women. No other woman has come anywhere close to Caitlyn Jenner's 1976 Olympic score. And I'll bet that scrawny little chick Fallon Fox dominated still has headaches from her easily cracked skull.
Good finally! Give them a inch and they take a mile
That is the fly in the ointment. Imagine Mike Tyson re-identifies as Transgender and he then becomes World Champion as a woman boxer, he'd waltz that one, whatever that means. ;-)
Not 1 man has EVER claimed to be a girl/woman just to win a competition. It will never happen.
That makes your what-if meaningless.
The bill requires any girl accused of being trans to have their genitals internally checked. This covers elementary to college level.
I thought conservatives were against penetrating young girls against their will, not for it.
Good save woman sports from transformers 😂😭🤣😂 let's go Brandon....MAGA...TERF....
I approve this message 🖐️
I stand with Ohio
👍🏽👍🏽✅✅✅
Males have their sports teams ..as well as female.
Transgenders can form trans sports without impinging unfairly against females.
👍
Great job folks!
Yeap, finally some sense into light.
Not at all.a ten year old can be freaking stripped searched, hormone levels drawn and internally examined just to play a sport. What. The. Actual. Hell. They think it's child abuse to have a 1st grader wear a mask but stripping a child isn't?
And WE'RE the problem?!
Transgenders should still compete again those Soccer Feminists to shut them up about equal pay nonsense.
Hell yeah!!!
It's about time!!!
Wow
YES!!! 🎉🎉🎉
KUDOS!!!!!!
Yes Ohio
Thank god.
Destroy trans girls' lives to save cis girls from feeling bad for sometimes losing.
This is very sad.
Why are all the examples of trans women winning in single-player sports like track or swimming?
Why no trans girls taking their soccer team to the nationals?
Think about it.
a ten year old can be freaking stripped searched, hormone levels drawn and internally examined just to play a sport. What. The. Actual. Hell. They think it's child abuse to have a 1st grader wear a mask but stripping a child isn't?
And WE'RE the problem?!
👏👏👏👏👏
the word "biological" or the words "born biologically as" should be used in front of the word male or female on federal and state and city forms. If LA can pass legislation banning particular trans-gender sports competition...then it seems reasonable to be able for states to pass laws pertaining to check marking what gender a person was biologically born as... on legal documents/forms....beginning with birth certificate to death certificates and anything in-between.
You birth certificate already says what sex you are born with
Nice
HURRAY !!!.... "Trans" guys who were competing with biological women was getting way out of control.... If trans athletes want to compete, then they should compete against each other.....
Do you really give a crap about women's sports as a conservative person, or are you just pretending to give a crap because you're afraid of the normalization of trans women?
Did you know the vast majority of trans girls never beat so much as a school record? They've been playing on girls' teams since 2014 and yet only in 2020 did it suddenly become a problem - and ONLY by politicians. They stirred up people with lies (surprise!) and are doing a great job of promoting solutions to problems that do not exist.
There must be 6 trans girls breaking records. I think they are up to 0.01% of the total records to beat. Another 1000 years and they will dominate everything!
Oh, but there are not enough trans athletes to form teams. Besides, segregation did not work so well the last time we tried it.
a ten year old can be freaking stripped searched, hormone levels drawn and internally examined just to play a sport. What. The. Actual. Hell. They think it's child abuse to have a 1st grader wear a mask but stripping a child isn't?
And WE'RE the problem?! I'm a trans male and no one ever knew when I was playing sports , because the sex on my birth certificate was changed
Jawana Man
And the fight back is on, about time.
Name 1 team sport where a trans girl is responsible for an unfair advantage. So far we see trans girls in single-player sports like track and swimming. What about soccer, basketball, volleyball or baseball? Why don't "biological advantages" show up there?
You don't even hear about trans girls in relay races. WHY?
Could it be using 2 or 3 people to condemn thousands is a bad idea?
America is now the #1 worst country of ALL TIME for trans people. Attacks are at record levels - worse than Iran! Law makers are taking away our freedoms based on junk science.
There's no fight. It's just a pointless and petty argument.
@@peeweemaroske8619 Open your eyes, it's a fight back.
@@davidswain8772 What fight? Normally there's a fight when there's a problem. As it was stated there's no problem. So it's pointless.
@@peeweemaroske8619 People are standing up and starting to do something about men identifying as women so they can enter and win at sports, something they couldn't do as men.........it's called a fight back.
Lets goo
Nooooooo
I took a Gender Studies course at Texas Christian University (it's a real course, and it's not as useless as Conservatives think), and I read in our textbook at 1 point that roughly 7% of the U.S. population (or 1 in 15 people) is openly in the LGBT+ community, but only a fraction of them are actually in the T category, so even for Republican politicians, FOX News hosts, and Conservative RUclipsrs, their blatant anti-transgender propaganda makes no logical sense (on top of being morally wrong) because they're attacking the minority group of a minority group.
Well said. I have yet to see 1 of these bills / laws use REAL science and medicine.
They are taking away trans girls' freedoms to "protect" cis girls' feelings.
They talk about "fairness". Well, when there is contention, fairness requires compromise. If I get everything I want and you get nothing, that is not fair. And yet republicans are taking all sports from all trans girls and giving nothing in return.
It’s because Republicans in Ohio don’t want to help all the struggling people who make the minimum wage of $9.30, who don’t have healthcare, who can’t afford rent, who can’t afford child care……so they mob on children who did nothing wrong but the “crime” of existing in a way that republicans don’t like. Republican voters are motivated by hate and they don’t ever vote for improving their own circumstances, they vote to keep others down because they incorrectly see life as a hierarchy of demographics and think if you get yours, they don’t get theirs.
@@LocoGeorge123 genius
Also, there is no such thing as a female penis🤣🤣🤣
Women are the 50% of the population, and still that 1% of the population managed to erode women's boundaries and access to fair sports and single sex facilities.
So, trans is pretty much a minority, a strong one if state congress had to set in to protect the rights of 50% of the population.
Oh and the other thing if you think xx and XY mean anything I know a guy that has the XX when he was born and he was a male when he was born and I have a friend in Asia that is born with the why xy that is pleasantly for the boys but she is a female and she was born with that genetic deficiency so don't try to say it's genetic bullshit because XY and xx don't mean shit anymore because we proved it with actual science and God gave us science to to allow us to unlock his full environment and his absolute full dream for us not for you to ruin and God will get you
Since both XX and XY can produce a male body, they do a very poor job of marking sex.
Genitals are the real measure.
If you have an outtie, you're male. If you have an innie, you're female. If you have neither, you're neuter.
BUT being a man or woman requires far more than just being male or female.
For one thing there are dozens of sex-segregated behaviors that need to be learned.
Subjective identity traits are the most important in any society. Traits like language, name, profession, likes, loves, morals, values, etc.
I keep asking: what are these laws protecting?
My answer: cis girls' feelings and a trophy. Is there anything else?
What are these laws costing?
The mental health of ALL trans children.
"With the first link, the chain is forged. The first speech censured, the first thought forbidden, the first freedom denied, chains us all irrevocably." - Aaron Satie (STNG)
Always found it interesting how America can simultaneously be the champion of progressive causes like civil rights and environmentalism while at the same time, producing backward bigoted garbage like this that serves to take humanity back in progress.
Championing women's rights is progressive. Belief doesn't change biology.
@@clc2432 you're not championing women's rights, you're excluding women.
@@RareRameus bruh your beats are ass
I think almost every country is like that sometimes.
@@overdrive7349 true, but with America it’s like it operates in extremes.
"signed verification from a doctor"
does a birth certificate count, in that regard? if so, where's the problem? You want to take part in a female competition? provide evidence that you meet the required qualifications.
and there's nothing wrong with solving a problem, before it hurts someone. Because we have seen that this problem has hurt others elsewhere. Why wait til someone is hurt?
The South Park video was very disturbing on this. It does seem fundamentally unfair.
Fair... fair requires compromise. You want to keep trans girls/women out of top-tier sports, fine. Where are republicans compromising and letting trans girls play who stand 0% chance of beating so much as a high school record? This is not about fairness. It is about protecting FEELINGS at the expense of other's freedoms.
Trans girls have been in school sports since 2014. They've been allowed in the Olympics since 2003.
16 years and not 1 trans woman qualified for the Olympics. NOT 1.
5 years and not 1 complaint about trans girls playing sports. NOT 1.
Then 2 trans girls win a track race in 2019 BUT conservative media did not start reporting it until well into 2020 - not because of COVID, but because nobody cared.
The episode was jokes lol. Let's these silly people see their hypocrisy.
keep it in the circus, we need Barnum and Bailey's circus back.
A good Act.
I completely agree with this.
a ten year old can be freaking stripped searched, hormone levels drawn and internally examined just to play a sport. What. The. Actual. Hell. They think it's child abuse to have a 1st grader wear a mask but stripping a child isn't?
And WE'RE the problem?!
I will move to this State. This is the State of the Lord Jesus Christ. I wish they could expel these people from the State
Take away 1 group's freedoms to protect another group's feelings. I am sure your god would approve.
Tell ALL girls that they are weaker and slower than ALL men, that they cannot compete against men. There is no way that could bleed over into other areas of life, right?
Fairness requires compromise. If I get all I want and you get nothing, that's not fair. And yet republicans are taking away the rights from ALL trans girls and giving nothing in return. And they call it fair.
When will people start listening to doctors, biologists, psychiatrists, nurses, pediatricians and stop listening to politicians?
If Jesus came back - YOU would throw dirt in his face for wearing a dress and having long hair.
a ten year old can be freaking stripped searched, hormone levels drawn and internally examined just to play a sport. What. The. Actual. Hell. They think it's child abuse to have a 1st grader wear a mask but stripping a child isn't?
And WE'RE the problem?!
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
"An issue searching for a problem that doesn't exist" is exactly correct. Ruining bond building and friendships for the few trans girls that want to play sports. This fake science transphobes spout is ridiculous.
There is so much incentive for young children to become trans before they even know how to count that it is seriously becoming an issue. Trans used to be extremely rare when it was genuine. Now children are so confused by gender ideology forced onto them in schools that they don't know what pronouns to use...
no such thing as trans and girls sports is for real females NOT Biological males
So now you have to tell everyone what is in your underwear. Go small government! FFS. SMDH
THANK YOU! Ohio is transphobic af! And they passed this during Pride month, so sad 😞
Take away trans girls' freedoms to protect cis girls' feelings.
Fairness requires compromise. If I get all I want and you get nothing, that's not fair. And yet republicans are taking away the rights from ALL trans girls and giving nothing in return. And they call it fair.
When will people start listening to doctors, biologists, psychiatrists, nurses, pediatricians and stop listening to politicians?
@@r-platt I wish I had the answer...
@@victoriawilliams2786 Thank you.
The answer is the unilateral nature of these laws will be their undoing. The fact that they go against medical advice, the fact that they use junk science... it will eventually surface and people will be (privately) embarrassed. The laws will be struck down and forgotten.
@@r-platt I believe you're right.
Wow, this is so gross, and blatant discrimination I can’t believe this is happening and during Pride Month of all times! Ohio is a transphobic state, I feel for the ignored little girls there, trans girls are little girls too
Maybe little trans girls should have there own league.
Conservatives are disgusting. I hate them so much. I was like starting PG inn HS, only 90lbs but I as better then most men at my school. Seems like the solution on the left is to completely integrate sports. Problem is - conservative men are afraid to find out that men aren't always the best athletes.
@@user-ol2mk6tg6p maybe we should just integrate sports and move on. I was better at most sports then especially the conservative men at my school, lol.
B BLACK: As you can tell by the comments, quite a few of us don't give one damn about pride month.... Just because a guy decides to change to a "woman" , they STILL are a BIOLOGICAL male... They cannot change their CHROMOSOMES !!!... The exact same thing applies to a BIOLOGICAL woman who decides that she is a he.... It's called gender dysphoria.... You can't argue with scientific FACTS ... Get over yourself....
Trans identified male are men, and when young, they are boys.
Women have a right to fair sports, giving away girl's right to fairness in order to coddle a handful of boys is wrong and cruel.