Sonic the Hedgehog CD (ソニック・ザ・ヘッジホッグ ＣＤ Sonikku za Hejjihoggu Shīdī?), more commonly known as Sonic CD (ソニック ＣＤ Sonikku Shīdī?), is a 2D platformer game in the Sonic the Hedgehog series, developed by Sonic Team and published by Sega. It marked the first official appearance of both Metal Sonic and Amy Rose. It was released for the Sega Mega-CD in Japan on 23 September 1993, in Europe in October 1993 and for the Sega CD in North America on 23 November 1993.
@@TheMentok well guess what GOOGLE IS ALWAYS WRONG WELCOME TO THE INTERNET THE WORLD THAT WAS ONCE A PEACEFUL PLACE UNTIL YOU DAMN MAVERICKS CAME OUT OF NOWHERE AND RUINED IT FOR US
The Japanese version where Sonic "proposes" to Amy has that part muted, and it's actually revisited in season three when Amy takes Sonic to a fortune-teller. It's revealed that Sonic said, "I really missed you a whole lot".
I really appreciate how respectful you were when talking about Amy's character, A lot of people can be immature and write her off as an obsessive, annoying, Sonic fan girl when really that's not the case at all, she's truly a strong and considerate character.
But that was what she was supposed to be. A fanatic with occult obsession to meet her celebrity. Sonic supposed to be cool and very popular like a popstar. This is why he rejects her: she's too much and a shallow fangirl! Adventure era decides to grow her into sometjing but it's not really clear what that is. So you can see why there's a devide and complex towards her
It's been confirmed by Sega already that sonic like Amy but just isn't showy with it. The way I always seen it was he liked her but just can't get in a relationship. Goes against his rebellious, free spirited nature, not to mention he's a hero busy saving worlds pretty often
I just watched the second movie and considering the hint on the after credits I can see Amy being introduced differently for the next movie and a future movie to have the plot of CD which could make it better since Sonic would have more reasons to save Amy from Metal than just being a random girl that happened to be there and getting captured. They could still make her a big fan similar to how they did it for Tails in the movie, but ended up mistaken Shadow from Sonic which happens in the game too and just go from there maybe following Shadow first until she actually finds the “faker” Sonic
Actually, I think it's hinted that Amy is already ON Earth, more in the New-York area. She's likely living with someone though, probably hearing rumors of Sonic, Etc. (Assuming the Easter-Egg of a stock-image of a girl with Amy Rose as the username when looking for apartments in the 1st Movie isn't just a fun little easter egg)
In the french version of Sonic X, Sonic says "Of course I love you Amy, since forever" It was so romantic! I was a child but at that time I was so happy. Amy is my favorite character (after Sonic of course) So yeah, I will like to see them together, but no if it's "Amy the fangirl" but as "Amy the fighter" who really help Sonic and the team. Thank you for this video! I really enjoy it. If you are curious about the french version here : ruclips.net/video/e10_44Vsz-4/видео.html&ab_channel=SonamyBP
The house of Amy rose edit was done by TMS the company that animated Sonic X, this was meant for any dubbing companies to add text over but for whatever reason 4kids choose not to do it.
Yeah, people born under the sign of Cancer are sometimes called "cancerians". It sounds like a weird alien species, but at least people don't think you're being called a tumor in a mean spirited way XP
If the Sonic movie team introduce her. I HOPE it'll be through her tarrot cards. She's got even more abilities than Sonic. Being super strong, psychic and at some point having the power to erase her presence and making herself invisible. Doesnt make sense but it's still fun!
Classic Amy was originally the same age as tails but modern Amy is only 2 years younger then sonic. Also fun trivia fact real life hedgehogs go into heat By extended close contact with potential mates. Meaning that her stocker like tendencies could just be a byproduct of the time manipulation from the incident on little planet combined with her fanaticism of him, also explains why all the other male hedgehogs are also loners not ready to be baby daddy's.(also more than likely means that somebody on staff had pet hedgehogs at some point.)
@@emmazone2403 OK either way my point still stands someone needs to give Amy the talk before she randomly inappropriately touches A less gentlemanly male hedgehog Lmao.
Those 2d animations that look similar to the Sonic CD ones, but clearly way more modern. Who does those? They look fantastic. I wanna check out their work.
Those were released by SEGA themselves :) Go check out Sonic Mania Adventures on RUclips. They'll be up on the main Sonic the Hedgehog channel. You're in for a treat
TMS the studio that made Sonic X provided a versions of the show to localizers where signage that had Japanese text on it was removed. Presumably so the localizers can easily put their own text in the proper language. 4kids as lazy as they were just didn't bother to put English text as replacement and in other cases removed even more text. Fun Fact: In episode 16 of Sonic X Sonic and his friends are given official documentation for travel and such. The show Amy's Social Security card and her number shows that Station Square is located in Ohio. This info was wiped in the 4kids bub of course.
This makes a lot more sense to me now. I know a little Google search probably would have explained it but I figure I could get away by throwing that question out to the comments 😂
Station Square... in Ohio? Now that just makes NO damn sense. Station Square was right on the coast. Ohio is a state with no coastline. And something tells me we aren't going to find Mystic Ruins in Columbus.
10:54 since you asked for an explanation I’d like to point out 4kids also censored out the part in Sonic X where Amy gets a job as a waitress, moves out of Chris’ house and rents an apartment of her own, in episode 20 there’s even a touching moment as she’s leaving the apartment and looking back on it all empty saying her farewells.
The only reason for that sign edit I can possibly think of is someone at 4kids saw the sign after that scene and thought “this is definitely implying sex, we have to censor it.” You might think that’s fucking stupid and no one would ever think that, but I’d like to remind you 4kids made this dub. I wouldn’t put it past them. Also, what a god damn thumbnail lmao. I know we talked about you using that in the stream but I didn’t think you’d actually do it lmao
These videos are great man. I've loved the sonic ones and would love to see mario/nintendo characters origins like this as well. Daisy and Yoshi would be cool examples.
Love this comment! As I sit here procrastinating on the next video, reading these types of comments always makes the end result worth it. I'll be moving away from Sonic after I feature a few more characters! I know my main subs are Sonic fans so it will be a risk but I'm willing to push through it to broaden my audience a bit :)
@@TheMentok Sonic's my favorite character, but there are so many good game characters to branch out to. Mario, Rayman, Mega Man, Samus, etc. I hope to see more.
Those IDW comics are legit awesome. Highly recommend if you liked the Adventure games, or hell even if you just like comics lol. They're extremely well written, in fact my only complaint with them is, so far, the story has been so good I'm disappointed we'll probably never get games with these stories. I mean the "Metal Virus" arc (I dunno if it's called that) even added an interesting mechanic to Sonic that would be cool to have explored with a game, I would explain it but I don't want to spoil it for anyone who wants to read it.
Sonic the hedgehog saved my life, I never married my girlfriend and she threw a hammer at me... which is totally not acceptable just because she's a chick, so she went to juvie.
I didn't get confused over the Princess Sally thing, but I also first saw Amy in issue 25 of the Archie comic where she was referred to as Amy Rose and met Princess Sally. I got a Sega CD after this and then read the instruction manual, but the comic warned me about the typo ahead of time.
When I was a kid in the 1990s, I remember reading a video game magazine that announced a new character named "Emmy" would be introduced and asked "Is Sonic getting a girlfriend?"(This was around the time "Sonic" SatAM was on the air.) I assume the writer misheard or mistranslated "Amy?"
If I had to guess I’d say they edit Amy name out of the sign because the fact sonic decided to land in front of her house might suggest sonic and Amy despite not dating are living together and 4kids probably didn’t like that so they edited it out.
11:01 maybe because is stated since adventure Amy live in a City, and in Sonic Battle they clarify she live in a apartament complex(her room is a one of the scenaries). That house look more like Vanilla and Cream's house(Sonic advance 2 or 3 show their house in the good end). Most likely the cartel said it was a error in the first place.
@@HenshinFanatic but only in the English versión, they added the "Amy's House" it's not in the original version. Besides the house look more like Vainilla's House of the videogames.
As someone who’s only vaguely familiar with the Sonic lore I’ve really appreciated these videos. If you are gonna do other games you could always go over Mario and Zelda characters
11:10 4Kids refused to allow ANY text in their shows. Like even the book store in Sonic X was changed to just have the tiny book logo by itself. They were ridiculous about that.
I like to think that Amy's journey through the years is her growing up in maturity and learning her own value, while still not entirely dropping her love for Sonic. It's still there but it's no longer her driving force, she started to learn how to fight and be a hero to impress him but now does it for its own sake. And in the future the fact that she does do it for its own sake might actually be the thing to draw Sonic in - I've always thought their relationship to be one that could happen in the future only after years of building a solid foundation. But regardless - Amy kicks ass.
I guess 4kids didn’t want the show to insinuate that sonic and Amy would be staying the night at her home after all the romance built up to that moment. A preventative measure
4Kids had a habit of editing out text in their adaptations, even if it was in english. Part of the reason was so it was easier to subliscence to other languages.
"Who else would you want to have in this series?" Honestly, my first thought was Shantae. None of the extended cast has enough origins to warrant more than a full group video, but Shantae herself has enough stuff you could easily pull together.
Little bit of Archie comic trivia: while Amy was always amy, they did introduce Rosie the Rascal as Amy's evil anti-verse version who was this unhinged yandere with a spikey hammer
My biggest gripe with that waste of space is that they used her old nickname and design. Amy was already treated like shit in Archie but this is throwing an entire truck of salt to the wound.
Great video man, I like the title of this video series too! 4kid's one piece was so ridiculous that I didn't become a fan of the anime until I watched it uncut on dvd years later at home lol
For that sign thing, I think I read somewhere that 4 kids had been given footage with no lettering with the expectation that they would add it back in in english, but it being 4 kids they were too lazy to do so
@@ultimatewolfgaming4171 I was referring to a community post TheMentok made before posting this video where he hinted at the character he was going to cover, and provided a picture of Rouge's body, ultimately bamboozling everyone who thought as such.
About the 4Kids edit at 11:05, removing the sign text: From what I remember, 4Kids removed as much text from the show as they could, under the (very questionable) logic that *"the kids watching can't read."* It pervaded the entire show, at times causing direct conflict with the script: One major example being that the characters used initials embroidered on a handkerchief as a clue in an episode. It was vital to the plot, yet 4Kids removed the embroidery in the animation anyway. 4Kids was in full swing at the time, as was the justified hate for them; so it was quite a big stink on the internet back then.
@@tribot_leader from what I understood after reading online, Sega is ultimately its own company, with the parent company being called Sega Sammy holdings. Sega as we know it is a subsidiary of the Sega group corporation, which is a part of Sega Sammy holdings.
11:10 I don't know if this is official or not, but I heard the Japanese animation team cleared all the text off of things before sending the videos over, in case the English localization team wanted to change/add something. But apparently the English team was just too lazy to fill it back in, so we have these weird moments.
Ring of Acorns? I remember it being the Sword of Acorns, after the King is returned from the Zone of Silence and the Sword's power is drained by her instead of helping the King.
11:01 Take it with a pinch of salt but I have read the reasoning was so the studio could sublicense the anime broadcast version out more easily to various regions without those foreign nations having to edit out the text themselves for local audiences.
4 kids didn’t ruin yugioh, they drastically improved it by creating invisible guns, dark energy disks and the shadow realm which is still used in yugioh media such as duel links XD
*I would also add that British Fleetway comics’ Amy Rose also adds in the development in her character rather than the love-stricken stereotype with a hammer*
4kids were the kings of pointless edits. Like an Pepsi ad in an anime would just be a blue sign with nothing on it or calling a rice ball a jelly doughnut. They had no reason for half their edits. Overall it was just ridiculous. Even the thing with the guns in Yu-gi-oh was stupid because in the movie they keep them but in the series they were edited to finger guns. While I understand the reasoning "Guns= violence= bad influence on children" it still looks hilariously bad because when Kaiba jumps out the window all I can think is "What are you two gonna do? Point at me?" Like he has no reason to jump until you find out they were originally pointing guns at him.
Actually , there is one thing 4Kids did better than the original. 4Kids had a series finale was actually final , unlike the Japanese cliffhanger version.
I can see where they were coming from with initially referring to Amy as Princess Sally, since in the first batch of Archie Comics and the first episode of SatAM, Sally was the same shade of pink as Amy and the translators for Sonic CD probably thought "A pink character is in the game? Must be princess Sally then!" As for the sign being blank in the dub, I remember reading somewhere that every sign in Sonic X was scrubbed clean to allow for other countries to fill in the blanks with whatever text they wanted in their respective languages, but none of them ever got the memo on that intention and just left the signs blank.
I don't believe someone is that dumb to confuse Amy with Sally in that instance. Sally was not pink, like, at all, her pilot appearance was but not her final design, they had time to think that through considering Sonic CD launched in 1993.
Amy was supposed to be Sally in CD? I always thought Sally sent Sonic to LBP, and he ran into Amy. It was because of that I thought Sally existed in the Sonic games but never made a physical appearance
Like to think that amy was raised normally and was born on little planets/mrecale planets and one day she was doing a fountain card reading and then she realized that she was destinyed to meet a blue hedgehog and then after cd she went on a long adventure and landed on the tornado and the rest is long history
The reason the HOUSE OF AMY ROSE text was removed is the same reason text is removed from other anime series when dubbed. Since they're dubbing it they no longer need translated text, so they just take out ALL text without checking if it's necessary or not, already translated or not, or necessary or not. It's a stupid and lazy thing to do.
Sonic and Amy are a very awesome duo because there ware both made by Naoto Ohosima By the way a blue hedgehog and a pink hedgehog that sound a good idea!
So I believe a reason that text was taken out of a lot of scenes in the Sonic X dub (even English) is because of other countries. A lot of countries tend to dub over an English dub rather than the original Japanese (maybe finding English interpreters is easier? I don’t know) It may be out of a sense of responsibility to release a version for non-English western countries, but just as likely about money. 4Kids won’t get any money out of non-English dubs because it’s over Japanese footage and all English voice acting is taken out. However, by making edits to the visuals and replacing music with their own, then they get a cut along with the original Japanese producers since now they “helped” on the work
What I'm implying by this is that I actually enjoy looking at the comments of videos, seeing what people quote, their reactions to certain parts of the video, stuff like that. It's just odd seeing such a small comments section.
I like Amy she is a good character the only problem i have is how she is obsessed with Sonic she really should move on from him That Anime had a extra season or a sequel where the boy went to Sonics world
Wrong fucking wrong sonic cd was released in 1991 ORIGINALLY AS A SEQUEL DUMBASS
Until it was replaced with sonic 2 in 1992
Sonic the Hedgehog CD (ソニック・ザ・ヘッジホッグ ＣＤ Sonikku za Hejjihoggu Shīdī?), more commonly known as Sonic CD (ソニック ＣＤ Sonikku Shīdī?), is a 2D platformer game in the Sonic the Hedgehog series, developed by Sonic Team and published by Sega. It marked the first official appearance of both Metal Sonic and Amy Rose. It was released for the Sega Mega-CD in Japan on 23 September 1993, in Europe in October 1993 and for the Sega CD in North America on 23 November 1993.
@@TheMentok well guess what GOOGLE IS ALWAYS WRONG WELCOME TO THE INTERNET THE WORLD THAT WAS ONCE A PEACEFUL PLACE UNTIL YOU DAMN MAVERICKS CAME OUT OF NOWHERE AND RUINED IT FOR US
@@usaproductions3178 I like you xD Happy New Year, bruv
@@TheMentok oh so think I'm joking hmm alright wise guy piece every single lore in less then a minute
5:30 "But I really don't think SEGA cares about these ages anymore."
Neither does the fandom
We're all still late to the party: Ken Penders _never_ cared about ages
@@PhycoKrusk no. Just no
Loads up e621.
Welcome to the internet, where everones horny.
@@hellishwerewolf7798 loads up shotgun
The Japanese version where Sonic "proposes" to Amy has that part muted, and it's actually revisited in season three when Amy takes Sonic to a fortune-teller. It's revealed that Sonic said, "I really missed you a whole lot".
Thats so bittersweet thats the nicest way to let her down tbh
@@jellosquidyea, but shes still getting friendzoned. in a nicer way
I really appreciate how respectful you were when talking about Amy's character, A lot of people can be immature and write her off as an obsessive, annoying, Sonic fan girl when really that's not the case at all, she's truly a strong and considerate character.
But that was what she was supposed to be. A fanatic with occult obsession to meet her celebrity. Sonic supposed to be cool and very popular like a popstar. This is why he rejects her: she's too much and a shallow fangirl! Adventure era decides to grow her into sometjing but it's not really clear what that is. So you can see why there's a devide and complex towards her
@@turbulonTV Then the 4kids era turned her back into a shallow, narrow-sighted, possibly abusive, stalker.
@@yoder6162 And the Meta Era made her EVEN MORE of one that Sonic (character) haters would defend!
We have all been an Amy rose to someone at some point
@@naturalistmind speak for yourself
It's been confirmed by Sega already that sonic like Amy but just isn't showy with it. The way I always seen it was he liked her but just can't get in a relationship. Goes against his rebellious, free spirited nature, not to mention he's a hero busy saving worlds pretty often
Sally: “Amy you are 8, you are too young to join!”
Also Sally: “Despite you being 6, we will let you join Cream.”
That pissed me off so much ngl, (Ik Sally was watching out for Amy but she wasn’t even weak during those times)
@@laurragarden Yeah exactly. Like it’s not fair.
Or tails also being 8 and being allowed to join
@@lucapeyrefitte6899 That too, like what?!?!?
She knew Amy liked sonic
Maybe the origin of Amy with the little planet could be hinting to how sonic movie 3 could be how Amy will be introduced if it does happen
Would love a Little Planet adaptation in a future Sonic movie, complete with an epic race with Metal Sonic!
I just watched the second movie and considering the hint on the after credits I can see Amy being introduced differently for the next movie and a future movie to have the plot of CD which could make it better since Sonic would have more reasons to save Amy from Metal than just being a random girl that happened to be there and getting captured. They could still make her a big fan similar to how they did it for Tails in the movie, but ended up mistaken Shadow from Sonic which happens in the game too and just go from there maybe following Shadow first until she actually finds the “faker” Sonic
Actually, I think it's hinted that Amy is already ON Earth, more in the New-York area. She's likely living with someone though, probably hearing rumors of Sonic, Etc. (Assuming the Easter-Egg of a stock-image of a girl with Amy Rose as the username when looking for apartments in the 1st Movie isn't just a fun little easter egg)
@@HarukaxYuuki they could make it so they replace the finale of the game referenced with Metal Sonic and go Godzilla vs Kong sort of take on it.
My buddy hates Amy with a passion, but I find her endearing. And adorable.
Well at least you think good of her! 😊😎💖
WWWWWW
@@georgeshaw4017 I have a question 😭 Did Amy rose come into the comics before Sally?
@@Nobodyishereeelyea think so. in jp though
Amy > Sally
In the french version of Sonic X, Sonic says "Of course I love you Amy, since forever" It was so romantic! I was a child but at that time I was so happy. Amy is my favorite character (after Sonic of course) So yeah, I will like to see them together, but no if it's "Amy the fangirl" but as "Amy the fighter" who really help Sonic and the team.
Thank you for this video! I really enjoy it.
If you are curious about the french version here : ruclips.net/video/e10_44Vsz-4/видео.html&ab_channel=SonamyBP
Amy SHOULD have been in the DIC cartoons, especially Sonic Underground since Sonic is the CROWN PRINCE of planet Mobius in that.
I always wondered if Sonia was meant to be Amy Rose but there was a case of miscommunication between DiC and Sega that resulted in Sonia’s creation.
@@rayvenkman2087 Maybe.
In my SU reboot she is Sonic's love interest. Wanna see?
@@Angie2343 I do
I personally wish people would talk about Amy and sonic underground characters more! Always loved Amy and Sonia.
The house of Amy rose edit was done by TMS the company that animated Sonic X, this was meant for any dubbing companies to add text over but for whatever reason 4kids choose not to do it.
3:19 Just saying when he says Amy is a fan of Cancers, Sonic's Zodiac sign because of his birthday, June 23rd, makes him a Cancer.
Yeah, people born under the sign of Cancer are sometimes called "cancerians". It sounds like a weird alien species, but at least people don't think you're being called a tumor in a mean spirited way XP
@@DeepEye1994 humans are the tumors of our planet
If the Sonic movie team introduce her. I HOPE it'll be through her tarrot cards. She's got even more abilities than Sonic. Being super strong, psychic and at some point having the power to erase her presence and making herself invisible. Doesnt make sense but it's still fun!
Fingers crossed 🤞🏽
None of that is cannon though. Thats all just badly written fluff from the archie comics.
@@Brucifer2 her being able to read Tarrot cards is indeed game canon. Her turning invisible was in 06.
@@Brucifer2 she is super strong if she can lift and move a hammer thats bigger and heavier than her
Classic Amy was originally the same age as tails but modern Amy is only 2 years younger then sonic. Also fun trivia fact real life hedgehogs go into heat By extended close contact with potential mates.
Meaning that her stocker like tendencies could just be a byproduct of the time manipulation from the incident on little planet combined with her fanaticism of him, also explains why all the other male hedgehogs are also loners not ready to be baby daddy's.(also more than likely means that somebody on staff had pet hedgehogs at some point.)
Actually 3 years younger than sonic because shes 12 and sonic is 15
@@emmazone2403 OK either way my point still stands someone needs to give Amy the talk before she randomly inappropriately touches
A less gentlemanly male hedgehog Lmao.
@@Doctor_Odin ok lol i just dont want anyone spreading misinformation lol xD
@@Doctor_Odin Dude stop being disgusting.
Amy on SA1 was the pinacle of her character. She was great on SA2, Shame she wasn't playable on the story.
Those 2d animations that look similar to the Sonic CD ones, but clearly way more modern. Who does those? They look fantastic. I wanna check out their work.
Those were released by SEGA themselves :) Go check out Sonic Mania Adventures on RUclips. They'll be up on the main Sonic the Hedgehog channel. You're in for a treat
The animators name is Tyson Hesse. He’s a very talented artist!
TMS the studio that made Sonic X provided a versions of the show to localizers where signage that had Japanese text on it was removed. Presumably so the localizers can easily put their own text in the proper language. 4kids as lazy as they were just didn't bother to put English text as replacement and in other cases removed even more text. Fun Fact: In episode 16 of Sonic X Sonic and his friends are given official documentation for travel and such. The show Amy's Social Security card and her number shows that Station Square is located in Ohio. This info was wiped in the 4kids bub of course.
This makes a lot more sense to me now. I know a little Google search probably would have explained it but I figure I could get away by throwing that question out to the comments 😂
Station Square... in Ohio?
Now that just makes NO damn sense. Station Square was right on the coast. Ohio is a state with no coastline. And something tells me we aren't going to find Mystic Ruins in Columbus.
@@feshpince7181 doesnt ohio is in the great lake area maybe emerald coast is an great lake coast
@@amadeuszmajewski3551 Nah, Orcas don't live in the Great Lakes. Emerald Coast sees you run from an Orca. It's gotta be the ocean.
@@feshpince7181 well does emerald coast from sonic x have orcas?
10:54 since you asked for an explanation I’d like to point out 4kids also censored out the part in Sonic X where Amy gets a job as a waitress, moves out of Chris’ house and rents an apartment of her own, in episode 20 there’s even a touching moment as she’s leaving the apartment and looking back on it all empty saying her farewells.
The only reason for that sign edit I can possibly think of is someone at 4kids saw the sign after that scene and thought “this is definitely implying sex, we have to censor it.” You might think that’s fucking stupid and no one would ever think that, but I’d like to remind you 4kids made this dub. I wouldn’t put it past them.
Also, what a god damn thumbnail lmao. I know we talked about you using that in the stream but I didn’t think you’d actually do it lmao
These videos are great man. I've loved the sonic ones and would love to see mario/nintendo characters origins like this as well. Daisy and Yoshi would be cool examples.
Love this comment! As I sit here procrastinating on the next video, reading these types of comments always makes the end result worth it. I'll be moving away from Sonic after I feature a few more characters! I know my main subs are Sonic fans so it will be a risk but I'm willing to push through it to broaden my audience a bit :)
@@TheMentok Sonic's my favorite character, but there are so many good game characters to branch out to. Mario, Rayman, Mega Man, Samus, etc. I hope to see more.
Not a sonamy shipper but I cannot lie some of these moments were cute
Those IDW comics are legit awesome. Highly recommend if you liked the Adventure games, or hell even if you just like comics lol. They're extremely well written, in fact my only complaint with them is, so far, the story has been so good I'm disappointed we'll probably never get games with these stories. I mean the "Metal Virus" arc (I dunno if it's called that) even added an interesting mechanic to Sonic that would be cool to have explored with a game, I would explain it but I don't want to spoil it for anyone who wants to read it.
I guess I need to give better hints in my community posts. ;) Let me know what you think of the new segment name: Origin Oracle!
Sounds cool!
I'm not a weeb
Sonic the hedgehog saved my life, I never married my girlfriend and she threw a hammer at me... which is totally not acceptable just because she's a chick, so she went to juvie.
I'm sorry SHE DID WHAT!?!
I always thought of amy and sonic's relationship as similar to gravity falls where dipper is 12 and wendy is 15. Sonic being in wendy's shoes.
I didn't get confused over the Princess Sally thing, but I also first saw Amy in issue 25 of the Archie comic where she was referred to as Amy Rose and met Princess Sally. I got a Sega CD after this and then read the instruction manual, but the comic warned me about the typo ahead of time.
When I was a kid in the 1990s, I remember reading a video game magazine that announced a new character named "Emmy" would be introduced and asked "Is Sonic getting a girlfriend?"(This was around the time "Sonic" SatAM was on the air.) I assume the writer misheard or mistranslated "Amy?"
That's how the japanese say Amy.
If I had to guess I’d say they edit Amy name out of the sign because the fact sonic decided to land in front of her house might suggest sonic and Amy despite not dating are living together and 4kids probably didn’t like that so they edited it out.
Where are we supposed to think that they are? Some random house?
0:56 Dude that was a perfect cut
11:01 maybe because is stated since adventure Amy live in a City, and in Sonic Battle they clarify she live in a apartament complex(her room is a one of the scenaries). That house look more like Vanilla and Cream's house(Sonic advance 2 or 3 show their house in the good end). Most likely the cartel said it was a error in the first place.
Except in Sonic X, that house was in a different reality than the prior Earth-based seasons.
@@HenshinFanatic but only in the English versión, they added the "Amy's House" it's not in the original version. Besides the house look more like Vainilla's House of the videogames.
As someone who’s only vaguely familiar with the Sonic lore I’ve really appreciated these videos. If you are gonna do other games you could always go over Mario and Zelda characters
11:10 4Kids refused to allow ANY text in their shows. Like even the book store in Sonic X was changed to just have the tiny book logo by itself. They were ridiculous about that.
I like to think that Amy's journey through the years is her growing up in maturity and learning her own value, while still not entirely dropping her love for Sonic. It's still there but it's no longer her driving force, she started to learn how to fight and be a hero to impress him but now does it for its own sake. And in the future the fact that she does do it for its own sake might actually be the thing to draw Sonic in - I've always thought their relationship to be one that could happen in the future only after years of building a solid foundation.
But regardless - Amy kicks ass.
I guess 4kids didn’t want the show to insinuate that sonic and Amy would be staying the night at her home after all the romance built up to that moment. A preventative measure
Oh god, that's good. Opening up the video with that good Amy theme song, YAGA!
The best Amy theme!
@@TheMentok On God. Possibly one of the best bops in the series. (Character theme-wise)
4Kids had a habit of editing out text in their adaptations, even if it was in english. Part of the reason was so it was easier to subliscence to other languages.
"Who else would you want to have in this series?" Honestly, my first thought was Shantae. None of the extended cast has enough origins to warrant more than a full group video, but Shantae herself has enough stuff you could easily pull together.
Little bit of Archie comic trivia: while Amy was always amy, they did introduce Rosie the Rascal as Amy's evil anti-verse version who was this unhinged yandere with a spikey hammer
Rosie was hella amsuing to watch in action lol
My biggest gripe with that waste of space is that they used her old nickname and design. Amy was already treated like shit in Archie but this is throwing an entire truck of salt to the wound.
Great video man, I like the title of this video series too! 4kid's one piece was so ridiculous that I didn't become a fan of the anime until I watched it uncut on dvd years later at home lol
Yeah 4Kids destroyed One Piece in the west. Thankfully I think it’s picking back up traction. Glad it’s getting the respect it deserves now!
Ain't it the truth
“ Looking for a Minnie to Sonic’s Mickey for that extra *MONNEY.* Money. “
oh wow, now this was a good video.
4kids had this really weird rule that they had to get rid of every trace of anything written in signs or billboards even if they were in English
Love your work! Great job! 💖
Ayooo amy is into the occult??? This is spiking my fanart obligation
For that sign thing, I think I read somewhere that 4 kids had been given footage with no lettering with the expectation that they would add it back in in english, but it being 4 kids they were too lazy to do so
9:01 Amy's room starts playing, 9:03 TheMentok gets a new sub
Sonic Battle holds a special place in my heart
SEGA: "Sonic and Amy is supposed to be a one-sided love interest"
Bioware: "I'm gonna pretend I didn't hear that"
you're so fucking funny dude !!! definitely subbing now LMAO i loved this !!! cant wait to see more videos like these of other sonic characters
The 21 sound clip made me sub, hilarious and informative keep it up
cheers for the chad warden feature
I needed that
Hey wait a minute this isn't Rouge 💀
I thought everyone would have gotten this
Can you not see the head? Or are you too attracted to the... other parts of the body.
@@ultimatewolfgaming4171 I was referring to a community post TheMentok made before posting this video where he hinted at the character he was going to cover, and provided a picture of Rouge's body, ultimately bamboozling everyone who thought as such.
The whole IDW Metal Virus Saga is really entertaining, emotional, and hard hitting. And yes, Sonic is a fuckboi, which Amy probably realizes later on.
Some amazing art in the Metal Virus Saga.
About the 4Kids edit at 11:05, removing the sign text: From what I remember, 4Kids removed as much text from the show as they could, under the (very questionable) logic that *"the kids watching can't read."* It pervaded the entire show, at times causing direct conflict with the script: One major example being that the characters used initials embroidered on a handkerchief as a clue in an episode. It was vital to the plot, yet 4Kids removed the embroidery in the animation anyway.
4Kids was in full swing at the time, as was the justified hate for them; so it was quite a big stink on the internet back then.
But the English dub as the 4Kids VAs which are the best sonic VAs
Did you know?: Rouge was part of a Nintendo™ of Japan's staff member's nsfw folder and the company thought it was a character design.
Rouge is a sega character though
@@naturelove8605 Nintendo bought sega
@@tribot_leader I looked it up and it says they didn't. They collaborated on game before but Nintendo didn't buy Sega.
@@naturelove8605 then who owns Sega. Does Sony own sega
@@tribot_leader from what I understood after reading online, Sega is ultimately its own company, with the parent company being called Sega Sammy holdings. Sega as we know it is a subsidiary of the Sega group corporation, which is a part of Sega Sammy holdings.
Video about Rouge when? Also, Sonic X is my favorite Anime.
If the Order of the Games are Sonic 1 than Sonic CD than Sonic 2 that means he knew Amy and Metal before Tails and Knuckles
the chad warden references lmao. love ur vids man
11:10 I don't know if this is official or not, but I heard the Japanese animation team cleared all the text off of things before sending the videos over, in case the English localization team wanted to change/add something. But apparently the English team was just too lazy to fill it back in, so we have these weird moments.
Whatever I want to refer to her as?
Mrs. Sonic the Hedgehog will do.
Sonic wants a chilli dog and amy rose wants sonic the hedgehog's chilli dog
Would have been worth bringing up her evil version from Scourges dimension.
Ring of Acorns?
I remember it being the Sword of Acorns, after the King is returned from the Zone of Silence and the Sword's power is drained by her instead of helping the King.
Amy being 8 in CD implies that sonic was 10 in the Genesis games
Thats contradicted though, seeing as Knuckles is 15 at the time according to the manual. Making Sonic 14
Awesome video and happy new year
+new subscriber earned
Welcome Fliqpy! A glorious new year to you. Much appreciate the sub and comment :)
She should be her own individual and have a character arc.
11:01 Take it with a pinch of salt but I have read the reasoning was so the studio could sublicense the anime broadcast version out more easily to various regions without those foreign nations having to edit out the text themselves for local audiences.
4 kids didn’t ruin yugioh, they drastically improved it by creating invisible guns, dark energy disks and the shadow realm which is still used in yugioh media such as duel links XD
*I would also add that British Fleetway comics’ Amy Rose also adds in the development in her character rather than the love-stricken stereotype with a hammer*
4kids were the kings of pointless edits. Like an Pepsi ad in an anime would just be a blue sign with nothing on it or calling a rice ball a jelly doughnut. They had no reason for half their edits. Overall it was just ridiculous. Even the thing with the guns in Yu-gi-oh was stupid because in the movie they keep them but in the series they were edited to finger guns. While I understand the reasoning "Guns= violence= bad influence on children" it still looks hilariously bad because when Kaiba jumps out the window all I can think is "What are you two gonna do? Point at me?" Like he has no reason to jump until you find out they were originally pointing guns at him.
2:40
apparently they made a waifu.
Cream the rabbit is my favorite especially when she is with her chao friend Cheese. They are both very cute.
Actually , there is one thing 4Kids did better than the original.
4Kids had a series finale was actually final , unlike the Japanese cliffhanger version.
Haha I had to pause the video real quick to look up about that sonic manga where Amy first appeared before sonic cd
I learned something too making this video 😂
Hm, how very interesting, i wonder what is next For Amy?
Hm, i wonder how a Amy Rose Game would be like?
Sega does not like the idea of amy having real estate.
I can see where they were coming from with initially referring to Amy as Princess Sally, since in the first batch of Archie Comics and the first episode of SatAM, Sally was the same shade of pink as Amy and the translators for Sonic CD probably thought "A pink character is in the game? Must be princess Sally then!"
As for the sign being blank in the dub, I remember reading somewhere that every sign in Sonic X was scrubbed clean to allow for other countries to fill in the blanks with whatever text they wanted in their respective languages, but none of them ever got the memo on that intention and just left the signs blank.
I don't believe someone is that dumb to confuse Amy with Sally in that instance. Sally was not pink, like, at all, her pilot appearance was but not her final design, they had time to think that through considering Sonic CD launched in 1993.
@@dragondelsur5156in the very first issues of Archie comics sally is pink
@@lala-jd6em "Her pilot appearence was but not her final design". Archie came out after SatAM, I'm still not buying that excuse.
Amy was supposed to be Sally in CD? I always thought Sally sent Sonic to LBP, and he ran into Amy. It was because of that I thought Sally existed in the Sonic games but never made a physical appearance
I was always confused on why they got rid of princess sally
Pleaaaaase do a deep dive into the origin of Mithos Yggdrasil from the Tales of Symphonia series. The cast too but Mithos is my maaaans!!!!!
Like to think that amy was raised normally and was born on little planets/mrecale planets and one day she was doing a fountain card reading and then she realized that she was destinyed to meet a blue hedgehog and then after cd she went on a long adventure and landed on the tornado and the rest is long history
0:00 I remember that Song! Aaaahhh!!!
Mentok? The MINDTAKER?
Sonic the hedgehog came out in 1991 back when I was 3 years old. Amy never appeared in the original TV series until years later.
Okay but seriously Amy's theme is straight 🔥 🔥 🔥
The reason the HOUSE OF AMY ROSE text was removed is the same reason text is removed from other anime series when dubbed. Since they're dubbing it they no longer need translated text, so they just take out ALL text without checking if it's necessary or not, already translated or not, or necessary or not. It's a stupid and lazy thing to do.
Sonic and Amy are a very awesome duo because there ware both made by Naoto Ohosima
By the way a blue hedgehog and a pink hedgehog that sound a good idea!
It's really just like the Naruto Universe but this pink haired girl IS ACTUALLY USEFULL.
I now enjoy Amy rose's new nickname now known as the monster
They probably edited the sign because Amy falling into Sonic's lap at her own house is sus for kids.
Hey, TheMentok. How about an origin story of Ratchet from the Ratchet & Clank franchise?
So I believe a reason that text was taken out of a lot of scenes in the Sonic X dub (even English) is because of other countries.
A lot of countries tend to dub over an English dub rather than the original Japanese (maybe finding English interpreters is easier? I don’t know)
It may be out of a sense of responsibility to release a version for non-English western countries, but just as likely about money. 4Kids won’t get any money out of non-English dubs because it’s over Japanese footage and all English voice acting is taken out. However, by making edits to the visuals and replacing music with their own, then they get a cut along with the original Japanese producers since now they “helped” on the work
The thumbnail is cursed
You: *talking*
Amy: *OOOOOOOOOO*
I... just realized the amount of comments this video has on it. I feel empty.
What I'm implying by this is that I actually enjoy looking at the comments of videos, seeing what people quote, their reactions to certain parts of the video, stuff like that. It's just odd seeing such a small comments section.
I like Amy she is a good character the only problem i have is how she is obsessed with Sonic she really should move on from him
That Anime had a extra season or a sequel where the boy went to Sonics world
Sonic x Amy is like chi chi
Basically
4 kids usually Removes on-screen Text from any of their Dubs
I hate how they screwed up this confusing this story this is what happens when you have multiple writers each with their own unique spin