@@chesiresays they have been dancing from so long, okay? Their breaths are out of control and it's hard to take care of your vocal cords on tour lol. Understand this
@@nishthagupta1357 and stop being a toxic blind supporter just digest the fact it is actually happening no one they are bad it's just they dint do well enough no one's perfect including bp also lol
naur not jennie struggling to sing while standing still 😭 they need vocal coaching fr. theyve been relying on making their voice sound a particular way for their branding and it's not doing them good live.
I personally think that Rosé is the only artist who really care about music and vocals, even when she raps she does it perfectly.... Rest all are just for looks or dance
Y’all are sounding like you know what is an artist or an idol lmaoo, they aren’t robotics as your 100001 tones of kpop clones, they’re better like that and I prefer Blackpink than the other kpop groupes even if their choreos needs 191910010101 energy and useless moves, their song are mid, blackpink still are the queens and only have hit songs, agreed or not I really really dgaf, have a good day jobeless people
@@neemootheoneDude learn to make proper sentences, when you’re speaking about one topic stick to that 💀 If you “really really dgaf” you should’ve scrolled down instead of wasting your time here defending for people who don’t even know you exist. You’ve prolly never been to a bp concert and wasted your money there, but for those who spent over 500 dollars it’s a major loss. Fans are giving money to see them perform and if they can’t even give the literal bare minimum they should just disband at this point. Groups like red velvet and twice have been in the industry for longer than bp, go on many tours, have cheaper tickets yet you don’t see them giving no efforts, they’re always energetic and make the fan’s money worth to spend. Please keep your nonsense to yourself instead of hating on other groups when your favs are basically old grannies on stage.
we need to stop babying them, they seriously need to practice. this is their job. EDIT: this is not a hate comment, it is simple criticism. This is a social platform, I am allowed to have an opinion. I loveee their music but think they could use more practice for their live performances. This will do well for their futures and will provide a better experience for blinks at concerts. please do not hate on these girls.
this is really bad... no hate but 7 yo group with many and long lasted hiatuses among Kpop groups, this really hurts... sorry for saying that... they don't have a hard choreo and didn't sing whole discografy so it's really not acceptable for the best GG in the world to perform like that... I really love them but it's not fair for those artists/groups who leave a soul on stage at every concert/award/or any other shows and don't heve even 1% of their fame.... sad for us... Edit: correct some grammar mistakes
they’ve been on a nonestop tour the past 5 months straight. i went to their show in dallas n they did amazing vocally and u could hear them clearly on their mics. it was their second show so they had done better vocally. this is obvious vocal strain and overuse of singing.
@@esseoi now this is the sad part. blinks thinking they’ve made their money’s worth. you’re so accustomed to mediocre quality that you think even the bare minimum is worth it. and girl, a five month tour isn’t gonna botch up your vocals. if anything, it should improve because now you’ve had more experience. and lol you know DAMN well this isn’t “vocal strain due to overuse of singing” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@esseoi What about other groups that also tour for a year and sing live, have more difficult choreography and still perform better than the group whose choreography is mostly easy and they don't sing half of the songs? Not to mention that other groups don't get two year breaks like Blackpink
Only rosé can perfectly execute it. And that too while dancing.. she is so stable. But blinks ignore her. This is so sad to see. Rosé definitely deserves a better fandom. Jisoo is the lead vocalist not the main.
fr rosie doesnt much of the hype and i feel sorry for her. when i went to the concert everyone screamed for jisoo and lisa while jennie and rosie got barely anything :(
@@kalina7965 no if you go to the concert you can see the actual hype is for rosé but in social media world it's just lisa and jisoo. Whoever goes to the concert becomes a rosé fan.
@@rits6510 i went to Atlanta concert day 1. I was there when each bp member showed up on the stage one by one and it was annoying how ppl didn’t scream for Rosie and Jennie like i felt like I was the only one screaming for them
@@kalina7965they probably awed by her, like she is being real for performing live without backtrack while they have inner fight with their egos cuz their fav couldnt
Honestly it depends and varies. Peoples bias on which member gets favoritism is never equal or the same all of the time. It's never personal or like that deep ever.
if it was deadass any other group they would get dragged to absolute hell and back and probably wouldn't have a career but blonks will blonk so ofc they will defend this but drag another idol if so much as a a hair is out of place on their head.
Liesss. Pls what a lie. When its Blackpink their dragged everywhere across the internet like this video, and this channel has posted dar too many videos hating on Blackpink for the smallest things like Jennie falling down . Idols get hate for not singing live but when idols like Blackpink actually sing live they get even more hate, no other group gets this amount of hate not BTS, not twice or rookie groups that don't even sing live. So let's be real here, I'm not even a blink and I know that.
But that doesn't mean that has to be the same for them. Y'all be the first ones to call them out but be the first ones to also say y'all so-called fans. Y'all don't know how hard they work to get where they are at now. They have fought for their spot in the entire industry. Yet y'all still found ways to bring them down. Even though it may not seem like it there still talented unlike you sitting on your couch watching people sing whilst still hating on them because they could sing.
Bro I watched this performance and it was honestly phenomenal I enjoyed it very much Jisoo did amazing actually she only slipped up for 2 seconds which is normal in a performance stop expecting them to be perfect in every way this performance was very good and there going through a lot right now so just stop being like “Jisoo messed up she’s so unprofessional” you really aren’t being a blink right now.
yeah and then there's rosé, the most talented among the blackpink but the most ignored member and most hated member these days. What's even worst is most of the people who hate her are the people from her own fandom and most of the 3 sub fandoms (Lisa, Jennie, Jisoo solo stans)
@@kyylee_ lol most talented pls...she is a vocalist and that's her only talent... Dance is crazy it's same like a vocalist not in control so chaotic.. But in vocals too (rosé strongest point) she is not the best maybe she is best in bp but not overall she can't relate many of small vocalist out their, so in that way she is lucky... Bp from day 1 was not known for it's vocals (it itself says main vocalists Incompetency) it was because of many other factors & rosé lacks that the most in bp, so pls... And about other members this live the one who carried the best was jennie... Lisa had her best vibrato in this live, rosé was fine but not as per a MAIN vocalist should...
@@kateginger lol he meant least popular, in their ideology least popular means people hate her, but it's like people like other members better than her and each person has own reason to chose a member as fav
Frrr blinks are always like 'jennie has an ankle injury that's why she can't dance' it's been YEARS since blinks have been using that excuse 💀 they were on a hiatus for 2 years, they had alot of time to practice but all bp did was model on insta lmao
This is the reason why the blinks are overprotective. At this moment they have done nothing wrong but you guys hate them so much that you litterly go search a peformance f years ago so that you guys have something to hate on.
Bruh jokes aside only Rosé is the one actual singer among all of em now and they are letting her potential get wasted.....She can sing while dancing unlike others
@@mun_army I agree with You but all k-pop groups disband one day that is inevitable and they go and grow in their solo career.. This is was one of the hardest truth i had to learn when i got into k-pop 😩
yea ikr and her still being one of the lesser biased than other members just proves how the toxic blinks solo stans dont care about their vocals but just about visuals,clothing and popularity
@blessed Muslimah Fun fact, Jisoo is working on an album while on a world tour with no rest + she has a youtube channel. For yall ignorant people to hate on her
Rose is the only one who can call herself a singer. I love her live vocals so much! But as much as I also love the other girls, their live vocals are usually a big dissapointment :(
As long as jisoo had lines in shut down which she does I personally don’t give a care if her vocal isn’t on point. It’s the fact that she sang makes me love it.
@@pickachu2789 yea the first two vids are clearly edited like pls even a 5 year old would know but y’all wanna drag bp so bad cause they’re the standard
I am not a blink, not even that into kpop as well but I watched the whole performance and Jisoo's vocals were soo great during the performance except that 3 seconds, specially in the beginning parts she killed it. So please watch all of it before you judge. She also corrects her voice immediately after that. I watched her performing liar both dancing and singing, she was really stunning.
@@asjaj8037 Idk why people are so filled with hatured, I personally don't know about BP's debut times maybe they performance slightly decreased right now. But I watch their some live performances and their absolutely good, of course mistakes can happen but I think in stage performances what's important is that how fast and confident you can make it up.
Now bp is all about beauty , fashion and money. They are idols but they can't give a performance singing and dancing well where fans pay so much to watch. Ironic..
@@jkislove6255 A armyblink speaking lmao 💀 y'all are the most delulu breed to ever exist in Kpop community. Shut up, it's not edited. YG have been only showing u the edited content to the point y'all can't see what's fake and what's real. If y'all saw them perfrome live y'all would still be saying iT'S eDiTeD. There's a reason why Chinese BLINKs called BlackPink racists, ungrateful and lazy after attaining their concert, there's a reason why K-Blinks said they were embarrassed to think BP were "the best/biggest K-girl group". Many OG blinks who've been spending money on BP for literally just existing are unstaning BP coz they realised what BlackPink really is, y'all would come out of ur lil delulu bubble soon too. (I'm saying it from personal experience, I've been stanning them ever since they debuted. But after their born pink release I've realised a lot of things about pinks... I just waisted 6-7 yrs of my life on ungrateful insta models)
Woooow, you're really first person who says it and it's true, and I agree, also when Jennie sang with this deep voice in forever young, that was beautiful ❤
ppl who have no idea what singing live is or even what going off key is think they can pick her apart. it's laughable. Sometime you can't even hear your own voice when singing live with all the music. It was only the verse that sounded strange. The second part was fine.
I don't understand why whenever people call Jennie out everyone agrees but when they tell the TRUTH about jisoo's terrible vocals everyone starts defending her and throwing the other members under the bus too??? and give stupid excuses like "well she wanted to be an actress not an idol" cool. but she's been an idol for over 6years so wtfff are y'all on? even jennie and lisa (THE RAPPERS of the group weren't struggling like jisoo) so bffr. give her the same energy y'all give jennie.
@@janemaxhopper2846 Even Lisa is better vocalist than Jimin Jimin is F tier vocalist like Lisa nd Jisoo ( F tier means no support range) + Lisa is more relaxed than him
i fail to understand why she couldn’t have just sat down and sung the song without the guitar in the first place like my lord that’s so embarrassing 😭😭
As much as I love BLACKPINK, this just goes to show what a couple of years hiatus really does. Maybe if they hadn’t had such a long hiatus, they would’ve had room for more vocal improvement!
They didn't do vocal practice enough, even during their break they could easily have done that but they didn't, now their flaws are showing, it's so embarrassing to watch
if they use that fucking long hiatus to go to vocal classes every week and train well to build their stamina for concert/tour type of performance then i hv no problem whatsoever. but we know what happen. jennie only does yoga to make her body looks good for her sleazy CK underwear campaign, instead of doin that to help her become energetic in concert performance. other members also busy doing photoshoots for mag and brand campaigns.
Rose saves live performances, i could see she is the one who has been grown up like her voice getting fierce and strong than in their early era. Let this girl has a freedom doing her type of music. i could see she would nail it on her own
@@babarukh6502Blackpink are dance groups or singers ? You can see that Rosè always does better in vocals. It's not about the dance, concerts are not meant for dancing 24×7 when they are singers
cant defend my girls anymore. what has been going on recently is crazy... how did they get so bad at singing and why are they making absolutely no effort?i feel like they lost passion for music and now theyre nothing but models and brand ambassadors. it hurts to see them like this but you know when you're really famous u can just do whatever and people will still defend u just cause of your fame... it is what it is
I feel like they got overwhelmed with all the success. And they lost intrested in progressing since everything was made for them .from music to their clothing . And of course since no matter the they do they think they still will be on the top.
I got a feeling you never even defended "your girls" before. Like, y'all be replaying the same small clip over and over again and start making a huge deal over a simple mistake that every other idol does
Ok... First of all they need to breathe as jisoo was dancing she needed to breath.... Jennie was struggling but now she is improving as her new song mantra and she even sing it live and it was perfect
You do realize construct criticism and hate are two different things? If you only want to hear the good stuffs how are you supposed to know you're bad at something. All of them were bad on stage and needs serious re-training, that is a fact not a hate.
No one is literally hating on her, people are just pinpointing the fact how she was struggling (along with how other members aren’t stable). Nobody said she was struggling alone. Jeez bro learn to distinguish criticism apart from hate comments.
There is no "hate" in this video. These are all valid criticisms. Besides, these are professionals on their 7th year as musicians. Their seniors, Bigbang went on world tours from 2014-2017 and they always deliver the best concert experience for any kpop fan. I'm not trying to compare, I'm saying if these girls are dead serious about their careers then they should never slack off and stay passionate about getting better each time they set on stage
@@yakin9940 mention a stadium that can contain *millions*. The only kpop group who has sold out the most seats is BTS . Both rose bowl and Wembley stadium.
i hate the fact that ppl wont accept that blackpink is struggling alot and say that they need a 'break' girl wtf they didn't had a comeback in like 3years wtf
still not understanding how ppl keep using the “singing live” excuse like there's a difference between that and barely speaking like you’re outta breath.
Tf u guys hating on jisoo ....these clips are edited i went to the concert jisoo didn't stutter a bit u guys just need a reason to hate on black pink 🙂
@@bestestkpopfan the Jisoo clip wasn't edited true but she did fine for most of the performance. Compare the weak moments to her best moments then make a judgement if u actually care to make a more objective opinion. If not, have the guts to just say u don't like em, that's more respectable.
@buffdaddy yall always do this when it comes to blackpink and their mistakes and their consistency. I basically do not like them because of what they do to their fans. but maybe if you tell them to do better, then that'd did be very useful.
When Einstein said - PPL won't remember what great deeds you've done but will definitely point out when you make one mistake and hate, he wasn't wrong at all
@@jos-josradvanji6203 I forget to eat and have one to two meals a day 💀 i don't know how i'm not so skinny yet, but i'd rather be happy that i'm not. Gotta eat.
for the people who says that jisoo can be the main vocal. I really don't agree with that because rose is the main vocal and lead dancer and she always proved that . Jisoo is really not that good performer and i think acting profession suits her more
They struggle a lot especially Jennie. Only Rose's vocals and Lisa's charisma and dance are always on point. They save everything. I'm a music expert so don't start your bias hate.
sorry all idols at one point have messed up at a certain time. they make mistakes, im terribly sorry that u feel the need to knick pick someone for a mistake they made once. hope u do soemthing better for once!
sorry all idols at one point have messed up at a certain time. they make mistakes, im terribly sorry that u feel the need to knick pick someone for a mistake they made once. hope u do soemthing better for once!
@@user-to4vy3mc8t I never said idols never make mistakes. And even when idols make mistakes they get bare bashed and hated for. But if blackpink make mistakes there's always ab excuse for it. And the fact they went on two years hiatus they should've of been practicing. There are rookies who work day and night trying to achieve their goals. Blackpink have it easier cus they know their fans will back them up. And I get being an idol can be hard but it's their JOB.
Bro guys it was a mistake, everyone makes mistakes they can’t be perfectionists y’all. And to all the ppl who are saying “it’s their job” try to put yourself in their shoes. I don’t think Jisoo needs a vocal coach after SOME mistakes. And what are you guys doing? Commenting all day long about how they should work harder? Be real. Jisoo is a K-pop idol, model, and a actress. Isn’t that enough? She surely is putting more effort than you guys over there. Yes, I am defending her cuz y’all are just tiring “StOp DEfeNdinG HEr bE fR” “LaZY” “WoRK hARDer” it’s not like you’re the boss? Stop criticizing Jisoo y’all it’s rlly annoying.
Rosé deserves way more. She is so talented she can do everything like dance, singing even she has improved a lot in rap during born pink concert. I am really very proud of hér but some blinks don't notice her. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH ROSÉ❤️🫶🏻
@@28mahek all the members are talented and has contributed in various aspects. When you look at vocals and songwriting you have Rosé. Rapping and songwriting you have Jennie. Vocals,songwriting and acting you Jisoo. Lastly dancing and mentoring you have Lisa. Each member is very important. Saying "YG slept on Rosé's talent" when Rosé released her own solo project is the biggest lie Akgaes stans can make. Rosé has had a lot of opportunities such as solo,fashion week,song writing and there will be more coming soon.
Yass now let's make her goddess than goddess than goddess goddessx1000000000000 goddess's in vocals not hating rose but FR if one member makes mistake rose is better if rose make mistake in dance Lisa is better if Jennie mistake in rap Lisa is better I god damn want to leave this fandom but I can't leave my queens so I'm staying literally you guyz are so rustic
These girls are professionals. When this kind of thing happens, it’s usually more of an issue with the Sound system, like their earpieces or speaker monitors. If you can’t hear your vocals well over the sound of the audience, and the background music, you’re going to have a hard time staying in key, even if you are very well trained , talented and professional. I can say this from experience as a stage singer.
Stop using the "As the a Blink" card when all Sultry film does is target Blackpink and make most of her vids based on Blackpink. They will struggle because they performed back to back so wouldn't they be out of breath? What's so hard to understand?.
@@jquinoa5282 I love Rose and she's my bias but I gotta agree. I often see people saying she's the best vocalist in this era or no one can song like her, and a lot of different praises. I agree that she's good but people are exaggerating it. Still love her though
@@ericelestineyorfrylle1525these days,i think people have become more matuted to understand that she isnt the best and past years true i used to see that but now i havent seen people saying it at all...people says she has one of the best voice not vocals which is true tho
I’m no blink, but y’all should see the whole performance. It’s easy to pick and choose bad parts, but Jisoo was just fine except for this one part. Tbh, I love every mistake, every voice crack, every little thing because it’s *real*. They cannot be perfect 100% of the time. Your faves have made mistakes when going live too. Don’t get it twisted. This was a great performance *overall*, and they’ve really gotten into their groove so to speak since the semi-disastrous beginnings of their world tour. I never say this, but y’all are just looking for a reason to hate atp. Rosè put in almost no effort in the beginning of the tour, but now she’s being called “queen” and all that so people can’t shit on Jisoo. Make up your minds.
Bro stop protecting them.. this is their job . They should focus on their vocals .NOW YOU ALL SAYING "NO ONE CAN SING WHILE DANCING" BRO THEY ARE 3RD GEN IDOLS AND IF THEY CANT STILL DO THIS WHY EVEN CALLING THIS LIVE PERFORMANCE!! HAVE YOU SEEN BTS ?! THEY LITERALLY WORK SO HARD AND SING LIVE WHILE DOING HARDEST CHOREOGRAPHYS!!! BLACKPINK LACKS LOTS OF PRACTICE!
Oh please about the vocal talk. Bro have you even seen there performances? They are not like this everytime are they? I know them for quite a bit now, i have seen there vocals. Rather than focusing on their 20% try to focus on the 80%. They are not the biggest girl group in the world for nothing right?
@@anupamaray6319 Wow what an excuse…ideally they should also refund that 20% to the ppl who attended with high hopes and received bathroom singing performances..
@@Sam-xr9lf Nah man i ain't getting money for making excuses on their behalf im just stating facts and about the 20% thing its a human nature that if the 80% part is great then the 20% is just vanished, thats what i said focus on the better part and if you think that they are not up to the mark then don't go to their concerts, go stan someone who you think will be perfect without any flaws.
Guys they have hard time dancing good and singing it’s hard I even tested out with myself and it’s really tiring so just understand the situation. Thank you 😊
Not you'll watching one mistake 😭 there are not a single artist who didn't do any mistake and pls see positive side also like did they struggle this much before & give bad live performance?? No instead they were known for their live performance
My friend was saying rosé was the only member who danced, rap others part sometimes, did stable vocal, gave great and proper visual , and at her part her voice was more clear than other He even said that he changed his bais from lisa to rosé
They promote them too much in the fashion industry that they forgot their an idol 👀 tbh if they spent time practicing their vocals and can see their improvement we can still defend them as a blink , we can't really protect them anymore because it's quite embarrassing that the people we put high up there can't put an effort to perform better 😩
@@Nwildindon’t judge someone till you walk a mile in their shoe, it is their job, but it’s not an easy job they’ve been doing this practically their hole life, do you think the most popular singers liked Taylor swift next had a bad performance, on stage or not everyone has slip ups
@@NwildinI laughed at your comment, “you salty bitch.” 😭 But fr you are right. I hate the argument, “why don’t you try to sing and dance.” Like I’m sorry but I didn’t train for MULTIPLE YEARS, I didn’t have vocal coaches, dance coaches, and I’m not an idol. This is literally Jennie’s job, she’s been doing it for I think 7 years now. Tbh there are rookie groups who are better then this.
Idk why but something in me doesn’t wanna believe that’s actually them singing 😂 Besides Rose is more of the vocal queen and I’ve heard the members sing vocally good before. Idk where the “not always good at vocals” came from?
@@jkislove6255 istg these are all the fans who can't even afford to buy a mfing merch who are saying they went to the concert and giving these reviews 💀✋
Not to be this person and I'm definitely not hating on them I actually like them, but they're not the only idols in the industry lmao in fact Blackpink isn't even that worked like they just got out of a 2-year hiatus. Rookie groups can perform while singing live like it's literally their job and what they trained to do, singing/rapping while dancing isn't a good enough excuse to sound like that, they're not rookies, at this point they're seniors and if we compare them to other senior groups like BTS or Twice then Blackpink are seriously lacking and ya'll need to hold them accountable.
jisoo actually slayed that concert her voice just cracked for seconds , also it's very difficult to sing and dance at same time we should appreciate their effort🍃
I’m a blink, a huge one, but this is out of hand. Us blinks have tried to protect them as much as possible but this, there is no way to defend them now. Kinda hope they disband this year. BUT! Rosé is an amazing singer and she should debut as a kpop soloist, Jennie as a model, Jisoo as an actress, and Lisa as a western dancer, because she tends to be a bit more sexy and that’s more western style, and she would get less hate. That’s just my opinion and don’t come at me. Pin pls?
I understand what you are saying but your first paragraph is a shitty attitude. I've seen them live and it was great. And do you not like any of their studio produced music? They love you dude. Don't abandon them. Think of Jisoo. Rosés tears in the netflix doco. Jennie's "I don't wanna cry I don't wanna cry." Lisa - "Yadom" Think. And reflect. Don't leave Dalgom out in the cold. Please. Ok, time to stop drinking. ❤❤❤❤❤
To be honest, there's no justification to their unstable live. They debuted years back and been around the world and it's disrespectful for the stage and fans that they still have this problem. That's why years of practice and continued practice is preached to have a spectacular stage. Btw, I'm a fan of EXO and at most, from their concerts, they cracked at times but recovered immediately. It's a funny mistake cause it rarely happens, but to these girls, damn I don't want to imagine how many times it's been.
Did u watch the shut down performance? Cos they did absolutely fine? Jisoo's mistakes weren't even that bad. And she carried on fine even after the mistakes. U could literally make a compilation out of any groups having vocal mistakes but perhaps no other group has such a magnifying glass put on em, waiting for any tiny mistake to blast and gaslight the masses.
This isn’t just a “bad day” tho😭😭😭 there are literally many videos of them messing up (singing and choreography) in every concert. Like not 3-4 mistakes but more than 10. Many Blinks were literally complaining about how bp doesn’t give their best anymore and they feel like the amount of money for the ticket wasn’t worth it😅 aren’t they supposed to be idols that trained for years? Why is Lisa the only one with energy?
U choose to hear what u wanna hear. They were plenty of ppl who went to the shows who found the clips and ppl like u dramatic and exaggerating. For every clip u choose to pick apart there are many good ones j choose to ignore. Be real. Have se balls and just admit u don't like em. Don't be so weak and fake.
I'll never shut up about this; ygneeds to stop undertraining their female idols. I hope they at least train baemon properly cause the pinks are genuinely hurting themselves like this
okay but at this point, is it really just yg's fault? bp are all very rich and powerful women with lots of connections. if they really wanted to train, they have access to the best coaches in the industry. like what's stopping them?
@@sunghoon-officialaccount well honestly jisoo didn't even struggle, her voice just cracked for 2 secs and these k tubers reuse these 2 secs over and over to criticize her. It's so low for people to do that honestly
Oh come on, how hard it is to realize that dancing and singing together is really hard. Dear haters , try to sing and dance at the same time and try to do it in front of thousands of people , you will never be good as them ,so don't spread hate.
@@thesanestan but l don't think they were all successful as blackpink, l hope nobody would get me wrong l love each group from what you mentioned , l,m a fan of each group but why do you compare groups to each other. Also if blackpink weren't stable as you say , why would they became top 1 kpop girl group , l am sure each group from what you mentioned made mistakes but the real fans still love them, but some people would spread hate for whatever they do or compare them to other teams, those people are called haters for a reason because they want to spread hate due to their jealousy .
Jisoo is stable everywhere since debut in all her concert. She just cracked for 2 sec only in one concert and get hated for it(a lot of kpop singer's voice get cracked too at some point like jimin when his health was not good and jisoo is not an exception). During the whole blackpink performance, jisoo and rose are live singer. Jisoo really slayed her part and become more confident like her stage presence improved a lot. Rosie posie always slayed the vocals not even a single mistake. Lisa slayed dancing but i expected that she will rap her part live cause she has really great solo songs and yeah jennie is best performer except in some parts. Accept the fact whoever bp member attract more people's eyes get more rating. Perfect example is lisa. Jennie is all rounder and a great performer but lisa caught more audience due to her dance or some hype parts. Same happening with jisoo and rose. BTW Love OT4❤❤❤❤
Brro go and see more mr removed of blackpink she is just posting the worst parts Jisoo's voice just cracked for 2 or 3 secs and then it got normal again
@@bbeuchin741 actually I do not only am I good at studies and sports I am a dancer too so shut the fuck up ik for a fact that my on finger has more strength than someone's ankle 😍😍👆👆
Here comes the obsessed blinks oddly talented in making up excuses! Imagine other idols singing like this once and blinks are "omg she's talentless", "she shouldn't be an idol", "oof, need more training" and put hate on them like hell. Meanwhile when bp performs terribly loads of times, it's "they're humans too", "they don't deserve the hate, "she had an injury", "people have bad days", "you can't live a day without being obsessed putting hate to our girls" Like wtf & bffr😭
@@BANGTANSTV_ remember when Momo from twice got dragged through hell for her bad live vocals? Yeah I ain't seen none defend her or day that shes just a human and even Twice fans admitted that shes not the most vocally gifted of the group and that's fine. Blinks on the other hand cant seem to admit the fact that their faves really arent all that when it comes to singing and have the audacity to get mad when people call them out for their awful vocals. Blinks are the 1st to hate on all the female idols who lip synch or have bad live vocals yet their faves are both combined.
Here comes that person who always say something about the blinks who defend blackpink like someone hadn't said in the comments like a hundred times. Btw not defending bp
Jisoo was always mid tier, fans just hype her up because they feel bad no one talks about her, every kpop group has that lacking member. You could see it in her solo performances like clarity, she was shrieking and straining so bad but fans kept praising her. That’s why she hasn’t gotten a solo yet. I’m saying this as a fan
That actually hurt to watch. Didnt know it was this serious.
No dancing & singing together gets bad all the time lol
@@nishthagupta1357 she’s barely dancing, I’ve seen rookies with better vocals while actually dancing
@@chesiresays they have been dancing from so long, okay? Their breaths are out of control and it's hard to take care of your vocal cords on tour lol. Understand this
@@nishthagupta1357 and stop being a toxic blind supporter just digest the fact it is actually happening no one they are bad it's just they dint do well enough no one's perfect including bp also lol
it isnt that serious half of these clips are edited
Blackpink is not a vocal group whatsoever. They are a visual, rap and dance group at best. I love them, but I'm not blind or deaf.
Not even dance tbh .. they’re not good at performing at all! and i dont think i can call them rappers when they dont be writing their bars themselves
a group of insta models
@@whenyousmileismiletoo5419 yeah
@@whenyousmileismiletoo5419 fr
@@whenyousmileismiletoo5419 sadly true
naur not jennie struggling to sing while standing still 😭 they need vocal coaching fr. theyve been relying on making their voice sound a particular way for their branding and it's not doing them good live.
Someone spoke facts 💋
Shut up
They really do
Frr
Yeah cuz they be singing over and over for their tour
I personally think that Rosé is the only artist who really care about music and vocals, even when she raps she does it perfectly....
Rest all are just for looks or dance
erm lisa is carrying the group atp😭 along with rosé ig?
In my opinion there all just nervous with a orchestra
Y’all are sounding like you know what is an artist or an idol lmaoo, they aren’t robotics as your 100001 tones of kpop clones, they’re better like that and I prefer Blackpink than the other kpop groupes even if their choreos needs 191910010101 energy and useless moves, their song are mid, blackpink still are the queens and only have hit songs, agreed or not I really really dgaf, have a good day jobeless people
@@neemootheoneDude learn to make proper sentences, when you’re speaking about one topic stick to that 💀 If you “really really dgaf” you should’ve scrolled down instead of wasting your time here defending for people who don’t even know you exist. You’ve prolly never been to a bp concert and wasted your money there, but for those who spent over 500 dollars it’s a major loss. Fans are giving money to see them perform and if they can’t even give the literal bare minimum they should just disband at this point. Groups like red velvet and twice have been in the industry for longer than bp, go on many tours, have cheaper tickets yet you don’t see them giving no efforts, they’re always energetic and make the fan’s money worth to spend. Please keep your nonsense to yourself instead of hating on other groups when your favs are basically old grannies on stage.
If she's you're bias,don't try to cover her up for hating💀
I miss the time when jisoo was called most stable vocalist
She’s stable ??? Let me see u dance and sing
Now the crown leads to our senior Taeyeon
And when did that happen? Never heard of it, seriously.
No one one in BP was stable before , idk why they called jisoo so
She is still
... that's not struggling a bit. That's struggling a lot 😳
Its live and their dancing cam y'all not give them a break is it everyday. Like.
True, so so true
🤣
Agree
Its k to struggle sometimes
we need to stop babying them, they seriously need to practice. this is their job.
EDIT: this is not a hate comment, it is simple criticism. This is a social platform, I am allowed to have an opinion. I loveee their music but think they could use more practice for their live performances. This will do well for their futures and will provide a better experience for blinks at concerts. please do not hate on these girls.
Or maybe listen to the actual performances
@@jdraws8318 you? Yeah you pretty much did by proving that you didn't even saw the original performances and jumping to "they need practice 🥺"
Maybe you do their schedules?
What a bad performance 😁😂😅
@@s-9817so these aren’t?? Damn such propaganda!!!
"WHen wE PUlL uP YoU KnOw ItS a SHUtdoWn "
Just because ur a Jennie fan don't make fun of other members
@@vsdevaki6890it’s a joke ❤
@@AAARRTTTTmaking fun of others or insulting them is srsly joke for y'all?!
@@Pavnda she wasn’t actually making fun of jisoo BCS it’s a joke
@@AAARRTTTTit’s not an ok thing to say even if it’s a joke
this is really bad... no hate but 7 yo group with many and long lasted hiatuses among Kpop groups, this really hurts... sorry for saying that... they don't have a hard choreo and didn't sing whole discografy so it's really not acceptable for the best GG in the world to perform like that... I really love them but it's not fair for those artists/groups who leave a soul on stage at every concert/award/or any other shows and don't heve even 1% of their fame.... sad for us...
Edit: correct some grammar mistakes
they’ve been on a nonestop tour the past 5 months straight. i went to their show in dallas n they did amazing vocally and u could hear them clearly on their mics. it was their second show so they had done better vocally. this is obvious vocal strain and overuse of singing.
@@esseoi now this is the sad part. blinks thinking they’ve made their money’s worth. you’re so accustomed to mediocre quality that you think even the bare minimum is worth it. and girl, a five month tour isn’t gonna botch up your vocals. if anything, it should improve because now you’ve had more experience.
and lol you know DAMN well this isn’t “vocal strain due to overuse of singing” 🤣🤣🤣🤣
G DRAGON KING ...
I like their songs. Their beats are good but sadly they can't sing. Cause singing needs born talent.
@@esseoi What about other groups that also tour for a year and sing live, have more difficult choreography and still perform better than the group whose choreography is mostly easy and they don't sing half of the songs? Not to mention that other groups don't get two year breaks like Blackpink
Only rosé can perfectly execute it. And that too while dancing.. she is so stable. But blinks ignore her. This is so sad to see. Rosé definitely deserves a better fandom. Jisoo is the lead vocalist not the main.
fr rosie doesnt much of the hype and i feel sorry for her. when i went to the concert everyone screamed for jisoo and lisa while jennie and rosie got barely anything :(
@@kalina7965 no if you go to the concert you can see the actual hype is for rosé but in social media world it's just lisa and jisoo. Whoever goes to the concert becomes a rosé fan.
@@rits6510 i went to Atlanta concert day 1. I was there when each bp member showed up on the stage one by one and it was annoying how ppl didn’t scream for Rosie and Jennie like i felt like I was the only one screaming for them
@@kalina7965they probably awed by her, like she is being real for performing live without backtrack while they have inner fight with their egos cuz their fav couldnt
Honestly it depends and varies. Peoples bias on which member gets favoritism is never equal or the same all of the time. It's never personal or like that deep ever.
if it was deadass any other group they would get dragged to absolute hell and back and probably wouldn't have a career but blonks will blonk so ofc they will defend this but drag another idol if so much as a a hair is out of place on their head.
Bro imagine if this was IVE 💀 they would get dragged to hell
Liesss. Pls what a lie. When its Blackpink their dragged everywhere across the internet like this video, and this channel has posted dar too many videos hating on Blackpink for the smallest things like Jennie falling down . Idols get hate for not singing live but when idols like Blackpink actually sing live they get even more hate, no other group gets this amount of hate not BTS, not twice or rookie groups that don't even sing live. So let's be real here, I'm not even a blink and I know that.
The most truth full comment I ever came across 💀
Exactly so annoying
But that doesn't mean that has to be the same for them.
Y'all be the first ones to call them out but be the first ones to also say y'all so-called fans.
Y'all don't know how hard they work to get where they are at now.
They have fought for their spot in the entire industry.
Yet y'all still found ways to bring them down.
Even though it may not seem like it there still talented unlike you sitting on your couch watching people sing whilst still hating on them because they could sing.
Bro I watched this performance and it was honestly phenomenal I enjoyed it very much Jisoo did amazing actually she only slipped up for 2 seconds which is normal in a performance stop expecting them to be perfect in every way this performance was very good and there going through a lot right now so just stop being like “Jisoo messed up she’s so unprofessional” you really aren’t being a blink right now.
Fr
FR
you are right
Wait where did you watch it? Were you actually there? Or did you find it on RUclips? I’m asking cuz I wanna see it too
@@Jisungsnoona668 it’s on RUclips
none of them sing like professional singers other than rosé and fans are too damn obsessed with them to see that
a lot of professional singers (also non kpop) have bad days where they don't really sound good..
yeah and then there's rosé, the most talented among the blackpink but the most ignored member and most hated member these days. What's even worst is most of the people who hate her are the people from her own fandom and most of the 3 sub fandoms (Lisa, Jennie, Jisoo solo stans)
@@kyylee_ I never noticed people hating Rose? Why do they hate her? I never noticed it.
@@kyylee_ lol most talented pls...she is a vocalist and that's her only talent... Dance is crazy it's same like a vocalist not in control so chaotic.. But in vocals too (rosé strongest point) she is not the best maybe she is best in bp but not overall she can't relate many of small vocalist out their, so in that way she is lucky... Bp from day 1 was not known for it's vocals (it itself says main vocalists Incompetency) it was because of many other factors & rosé lacks that the most in bp, so pls... And about other members this live the one who carried the best was jennie... Lisa had her best vibrato in this live, rosé was fine but not as per a MAIN vocalist should...
@@kateginger lol he meant least popular, in their ideology least popular means people hate her, but it's like people like other members better than her and each person has own reason to chose a member as fav
Stop with the "she's human 🥺" bullshit, this is their job, if they can't do it correctly, then it isn't their's.
👏🏽👏🏽
Tbh they should just become models now ngl-
My bro woke up and chose violence 🗿
Truee, they'll always use the "not feeling well", "they were tired", "the video is edited", "ankle injury" stuff like that
Frrr blinks are always like 'jennie has an ankle injury that's why she can't dance' it's been YEARS since blinks have been using that excuse 💀 they were on a hiatus for 2 years, they had alot of time to practice but all bp did was model on insta lmao
atp they’re just treating their ACTUAL jobs as side jobs😭
They are focusing on their brand endorsements more now
This is the reason why the blinks are overprotective. At this moment they have done nothing wrong but you guys hate them so much that you litterly go search a peformance f years ago so that you guys have something to hate on.
What is atp? adenosine triphosphate?☠️
@@GARIMASINGH-ue2by at this point
@@meditationforlife4427 ok
Rosé is the most stable in the group
rosé sounded amazing tho
@@christenevans848 she sounded great wdym
She’s so bad
@@dylanhicks4771 you should really get your ears checked, I’m concerned for u 😔
yeah she is good but it's not about her
@@dylanhicks4771 mf what 💀💀
Bruh jokes aside only Rosé is the one actual singer among all of em now and they are letting her potential get wasted.....She can sing while dancing unlike others
I agree! She should just go solo at this point
true
@@Deeptivijayalakshmi ye she should but I think she likes the members as well so she probably wouldn't want to leave them I guess
@@mun_army I agree with You but all k-pop groups disband one day that is inevitable and they go and grow in their solo career.. This is was one of the hardest truth i had to learn when i got into k-pop 😩
@@Deeptivijayalakshmi ye when they disband they probably will move on with solo careers. But we will definitely still support them each separately ♥️
Rose is the real vocalist
Why hate ??
@dreamymoonsxz its not hate bruh
facts. And to THINK there are sooya’s sayign jisoo is better at singing than rosé. Had a fight with a delulu sooya who couldn’t accept the facts
Lisa, rosé & jisoo are
Rosé also had time stress vocal too
Jisoo acctually proved her haters they are not lip syncing
Yes
@@Asunaro11037yes. She proved two things at a time. Genius 💀
But still can't sing properly
WTF YA'LL BLINKS TRYING TO JUSTIFY LMAO😂
@@Angel-ed4bngo watch the whole performance it was great,
Rose probably struggles the least atm because her craft is singing she is definitely the most in love with music and art out of the group
yea ikr and her still being one of the lesser biased than other members just proves how the toxic blinks solo stans dont care about their vocals but just about visuals,clothing and popularity
@@Tannieami_ rose is the least popular? i've always thought it was lisa > jennie > rose > jisoo
Fr
@@KirigayaKazutoBeater jisoo is really popular in korea
yeah. she’s so underrated she’s been my fav from the beginning i truly think that if given the opportunity she could be an amazing solo artist.
okay but why do they actually sound like me at 3am in my bedroom pretending to sing in my own kpop concert 💀💀💀💀💀
@blessed Muslimah Fun fact, Jisoo is working on an album while on a world tour with no rest + she has a youtube channel. For yall ignorant people to hate on her
Maybe because the person who made this video only choose the worst clips ?!?!?!?!
@@adri9418 i dont think jyp groups are having rest but theyre still slaying.
@@adri9418 gurl stop babying them they lost the whole point of their job. as a dancer i have to dance 14 hours a day but i give my best on stage
@@duolingo766 exactly
Rose is the only one who can call herself a singer. I love her live vocals so much! But as much as I also love the other girls, their live vocals are usually a big dissapointment :(
As long as jisoo had lines in shut down which she does I personally don’t give a care if her vocal isn’t on point. It’s the fact that she sang makes me love it.
remember when blinks used to bully a lot of groups and say that blackpink performed better? well... how the table turns!
frrrrr they are dying now defending their own group lmao
LOOOL RIGHT
fr tho
Npc moment with the “!” at the end 😭
@@gurnoorkaur6160 yes
Rosé was the only one whose vocal was stable and she slayed
Jennie did good too.
@@ghostyrach girlie watch this video again PLEASE U NEED IT
@@pickachu2789 yea the first two vids are clearly edited like pls even a 5 year old would know but y’all wanna drag bp so bad cause they’re the standard
@@ghostyrach yeah bro sure everyone is a liar for the sake of proving your bias perfect when she's absolutely not
Yep, she's stable and focus is good at it
I am not a blink, not even that into kpop as well but I watched the whole performance and Jisoo's vocals were soo great during the performance except that 3 seconds, specially in the beginning parts she killed it. So please watch all of it before you judge. She also corrects her voice immediately after that. I watched her performing liar both dancing and singing, she was really stunning.
Ikr these ppl are just trying to find anything to hate on bp
@@asjaj8037 Idk why people are so filled with hatured, I personally don't know about BP's debut times maybe they performance slightly decreased right now. But I watch their some live performances and their absolutely good, of course mistakes can happen but I think in stage performances what's important is that how fast and confident you can make it up.
Louder gurl everyone needs to read this and thank u so much for understanding BLACKPINK ❣️
Well she is a seven year old idol and I've seen one year old rookies perform better than her lmao you all are deaf and blind open your ears and eyes
You are better than a good half of the blinks, THANK YOU
Ok i never knew it was this bad. I used to be a blink until it just faded out, now im just constantly getting clips of their failed performances
Bro the first clip of Jennie singing forever young💀
Ikr she sounded soo good! You should shut up:)
@@V1OL3T_GDwhy should they?
It was bad but like they don’t need to say that
@@V1OL3T_GD bro you got blind by what jennie sorry excuse?😂
My ears are bleeding😂
Now bp is all about beauty , fashion and money. They are idols but they can't give a performance singing and dancing well where fans pay so much to watch. Ironic..
Ikr Disappointing tbh.....
Visual, fame, popularity, money... ig models suit them ig. I lost the ticket of their concert but I was maybe lucky saving money...?
you just dont have money honey, dont be bitter pls?
@@jkislove6255 Its not edits they are struggling in every concept u can watch other clips also
@@jkislove6255 A armyblink speaking lmao 💀 y'all are the most delulu breed to ever exist in Kpop community. Shut up, it's not edited. YG have been only showing u the edited content to the point y'all can't see what's fake and what's real. If y'all saw them perfrome live y'all would still be saying iT'S eDiTeD. There's a reason why Chinese BLINKs called BlackPink racists, ungrateful and lazy after attaining their concert, there's a reason why K-Blinks said they were embarrassed to think BP were "the best/biggest K-girl group". Many OG blinks who've been spending money on BP for literally just existing are unstaning BP coz they realised what BlackPink really is, y'all would come out of ur lil delulu bubble soon too. (I'm saying it from personal experience, I've been stanning them ever since they debuted. But after their born pink release I've realised a lot of things about pinks... I just waisted 6-7 yrs of my life on ungrateful insta models)
Omg that jennie one was embarrassing 😳
IKR
just let her party guys chill. Her feet and throat only hurts in the stage
@@Cherry_squ1d so much hate huuhh.. be kind.
And she was standing still, not even dancing 💀
@@Cherry_squ1d how come yall always have an excuse , it's impressive really
As a former blink, I am glad I am a "former" blink.
Bro jisoo voice cracked for 2sec and the whole performance was amazing
Woooow, you're really first person who says it and it's true, and I agree, also when Jennie sang with this deep voice in forever young, that was beautiful ❤
@@Finnicks_trident_ yeah. i saw the actual video and it wasn't that bad- like ???? am I missing out on smthing
@@AnimeS1mp like what?
@@AnimeS1mp haha, understand now
ppl who have no idea what singing live is or even what going off key is think they can pick her apart. it's laughable. Sometime you can't even hear your own voice when singing live with all the music. It was only the verse that sounded strange. The second part was fine.
I don't understand why whenever people call Jennie out everyone agrees but when they tell the TRUTH about jisoo's terrible vocals everyone starts defending her and throwing the other members under the bus too??? and give stupid excuses like "well she wanted to be an actress not an idol" cool. but she's been an idol for over 6years so wtfff are y'all on?
even jennie and lisa (THE RAPPERS of the group weren't struggling like jisoo) so bffr.
give her the same energy y'all give jennie.
theyre all horrible singers
That's true, jennie shouldn't be even singing most of the time, she should be rapping because clearly, that's where she is comfortable.
Yeahh frr
Come on bro. No need to put Jisoo down to please your favs. Please like them all equally. OT4!
Fr
the audacity of blinks to defend these events .
The audacity of “jimin” display name complaining on this kind of video 💀
@@nindyakirana9923 Oh pls
He is a lot stable now and can sing way better than JiSOo
@@nindyakirana9923 Jimin can hit notes higher than your faves talent and passion for their work 💀
@@nindyakirana9923 Jimin outsings the whole Blackpink let’s be real
@@janemaxhopper2846 Even Lisa is better vocalist than Jimin
Jimin is F tier vocalist like Lisa nd Jisoo ( F tier means no support range) + Lisa is more relaxed than him
Her voice cracked for 5 seconds. This is les pieces des jaunes, it's only for 15 to 20 euros, yeah that cheap. And French blinks were the happiest.
Y'ALL JENNIE LITERALLY TRIED TO LIPSYNC A FREAKING GUITAR...AND FAILED- 😭💀
edit: y'all blonks in the replies stay mad 😘
No way 😂😂
@@laviniamenezes6571 ikr 😭 search "kpop idols who faked their performance" by the youtuber Sultry Film
@tiddies.🗿🍷 IT WAS WILD 😭💀
She couldn't even lip sync the guitar properly 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
i fail to understand why she couldn’t have just sat down and sung the song without the guitar in the first place like my lord that’s so embarrassing 😭😭
plus with the ticket fee and the long hour wait just to hear this must be devastating
did you pay for them
shut up u didn't pay for them🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
@@hm6096 did u?
@@hm6096 the people who went to the concert did
@@hm6096 the one who recorded did
my bias rosé stays slaying
YES
She actually wants to be an idol just like Lisa,she claims she’s not good at singing but she should listen to her live vocals
Lisa is always stable
@@uniqua2621 yeah
Idm to make anyone upset or mad but rose was struggled just as much as the rest
i think it's very difficult to sing while dancing. so please everyone don't make fun of them because it hurts😢
if they can’t do it properly then dont be a kpop idol
@@FionaAlexandraaWho are you to say that
@@FionaAlexandraa then why are you watching them
As much as I love BLACKPINK, this just goes to show what a couple of years hiatus really does. Maybe if they hadn’t had such a long hiatus, they would’ve had room for more vocal improvement!
Yeah true but they could’ve also practiced they don’t need to have a cb to be good singers
they could've still practiced during the hiatus or just before they released pink venom and ready for love.
Many groups train when in hiatus. Even in companies where they dont give an ass about their groups, they train in their own
They didn't do vocal practice enough, even during their break they could easily have done that but they didn't, now their flaws are showing, it's so embarrassing to watch
if they use that fucking long hiatus to go to vocal classes every week and train well to build their stamina for concert/tour type of performance then i hv no problem whatsoever. but we know what happen. jennie only does yoga to make her body looks good for her sleazy CK underwear campaign, instead of doin that to help her become energetic in concert performance. other members also busy doing photoshoots for mag and brand campaigns.
Rose saves live performances, i could see she is the one who has been grown up like her voice getting fierce and strong than in their early era. Let this girl has a freedom doing her type of music. i could see she would nail it on her own
Yes she's real queen ❤
she did save the performance with her live vocals but sorry to say i was disappointed by how she was not dancing well
@@babarukh6502Blackpink are dance groups or singers ? You can see that Rosè always does better in vocals. It's not about the dance, concerts are not meant for dancing 24×7 when they are singers
@@babarukh6502she got praised alot since How you like that era and until now Shut down for her powerful move, she is consistent and always grow
cant defend my girls anymore. what has been going on recently is crazy... how did they get so bad at singing and why are they making absolutely no effort?i feel like they lost passion for music and now theyre nothing but models and brand ambassadors. it hurts to see them like this but you know when you're really famous u can just do whatever and people will still defend u just cause of your fame... it is what it is
I feel like they got overwhelmed with all the success. And they lost intrested in progressing since everything was made for them .from music to their clothing . And of course since no matter the they do they think they still will be on the top.
I got a feeling you never even defended "your girls" before. Like, y'all be replaying the same small clip over and over again and start making a huge deal over a simple mistake that every other idol does
same, can't fight with others anymore
Yea same
Ok...
First of all they need to breathe as jisoo was dancing she needed to breath....
Jennie was struggling but now she is improving as her new song mantra and she even sing it live and it was perfect
She is not only one struggling. Rose voice also crack Jennie voice also and Lisa was also struggling
SHE WAS NOT ONLY ONE STRUGGLING
that's why they all need vocal classes or some
You do realize construct criticism and hate are two different things? If you only want to hear the good stuffs how are you supposed to know you're bad at something. All of them were bad on stage and needs serious re-training, that is a fact not a hate.
No one is literally hating on her, people are just pinpointing the fact how she was struggling (along with how other members aren’t stable). Nobody said she was struggling alone. Jeez bro learn to distinguish criticism apart from hate comments.
There is no "hate" in this video. These are all valid criticisms. Besides, these are professionals on their 7th year as musicians. Their seniors, Bigbang went on world tours from 2014-2017 and they always deliver the best concert experience for any kpop fan. I'm not trying to compare, I'm saying if these girls are dead serious about their careers then they should never slack off and stay passionate about getting better each time they set on stage
Rosé never cracked lol, pick a struggle.
man I'd be so embarrassed and guilty if I performed like that in front of thousands
millions lol
@@yakin9940 mention a stadium that can contain *millions*. The only kpop group who has sold out the most seats is BTS . Both rose bowl and Wembley stadium.
@@badalnath3511 BP Japan concert 2018 or 2019 sold all the seats
@@badalnath3511 you didn't understand her? She meant videos being posted to fans watching the performance online 💀
@@uniqua2621 ow. I thought she was talking about offline lol.
Jennie’s vocals…I almost choked
then how about your voice ? probably sound like a cow.
at least she can sing , but how about you ?
@@bbeuchin741 If you call that singing
Almost whole of the comment section is a band of singers
@@bbeuchin741 if that’s how she sings then I sing just like her or even better
@@marianovelo2005 God ! can you please watch the long video clip of her singing ? don’t judge her based on shot clip video
i hate the fact that ppl wont accept that blackpink is struggling alot and say that they need a 'break' girl wtf they didn't had a comeback in like 3years wtf
still not understanding how ppl keep using the “singing live” excuse like there's a difference between that and barely speaking like you’re outta breath.
They are out of breathe? Singing is difficult, so let's treat them like humans
Tf u guys hating on jisoo ....these clips are edited i went to the concert jisoo didn't stutter a bit u guys just need a reason to hate on black pink 🙂
@JK IS LOVE ! those clips werent edited. stop making up excuses for your disbanding favorites.
@@bestestkpopfan the Jisoo clip wasn't edited true but she did fine for most of the performance. Compare the weak moments to her best moments then make a judgement if u actually care to make a more objective opinion. If not, have the guts to just say u don't like em, that's more respectable.
@buffdaddy yall always do this when it comes to blackpink and their mistakes and their consistency. I basically do not like them because of what they do to their fans. but maybe if you tell them to do better, then that'd did be very useful.
When Einstein said - PPL won't remember what great deeds you've done but will definitely point out when you make one mistake and hate, he wasn't wrong at all
Your name says it all
@@rahma8067 bruh 🙇♀️ that's savage
True!!
@@rahma8067 can we not notice the name and actually focus what he or she is saying? Lol
@@itzsarah89stop being so sensitive lol
This is what happens when particular music industry only wants visuals
thank you!
completely agree
What visual? More like media play 😬
Agreed
Literally
Blinks will say "they are human too is good to make a mistake" 💀
Like u😂😂😂😂 your from the SEWER where all the rats go
Bro at this point if they could be idols I could be the next biggest thing in kpop
Seriously, I zumba way harder than them. 💀
lmao 😭
I thought my vocals are shit and i can barely do a higher note but holy crap i agree with you.
ok go ahead and attempt to survive their diet and workout schedule and then come back xD I am not a fan of theirs but you’re overdoing it.
@@jos-josradvanji6203 I forget to eat and have one to two meals a day 💀 i don't know how i'm not so skinny yet, but i'd rather be happy that i'm not. Gotta eat.
for the people who says that jisoo can be the main vocal. I really don't agree with that because rose is the main vocal and lead dancer and she always proved that . Jisoo is really not that good performer and i think acting profession suits her more
Facts
Fax..
None of them deserve to perform at such big stage, i have seen people more talented in college fest for god sake.
They struggle a lot especially Jennie. Only Rose's vocals and Lisa's charisma and dance are always on point. They save everything. I'm a music expert so don't start your bias hate.
Jennie? Did u see Jisoo? Jennie is way better and just jumping around isnt charisma and lisa also is really bad at vocals
@monowarabegum5786 I spoke about Rose's vocals not Lisa's my little bias friend. 💚
@@Gin_koc i also wrote about lisa's so called "charisma" my friend
@monowarabegum5786 Charisma includes a lot of things. Enjoy the rest of your day 😀😀😀😀
@@Gin_koc what jumping and running around is an charisma now?
When Instagram models try to sing-
FR😭
Frrrrr
living up to your username
Lmao true
yepppp
She sounds like when I’m singing in the shower
she sound like me when i strain my voice to sound like rose in d4
That's kinda humiliation 💀💀
Gurl then you sound really bad 😭 (not meant to be rude, it's just a joke)
HELPPP
💀💀💀💀
Their fame and popularity overshadows things like this...I'm glad people actually are acknowledging they need to have more practice
sorry all idols at one point have messed up at a certain time. they make mistakes, im terribly sorry that u feel the need to knick pick someone for a mistake they made once. hope u do soemthing better for once!
sorry all idols at one point have messed up at a certain time. they make mistakes, im terribly sorry that u feel the need to knick pick someone for a mistake they made once. hope u do soemthing better for once!
@@user-to4vy3mc8t I never said idols never make mistakes. And even when idols make mistakes they get bare bashed and hated for. But if blackpink make mistakes there's always ab excuse for it. And the fact they went on two years hiatus they should've of been practicing. There are rookies who work day and night trying to achieve their goals. Blackpink have it easier cus they know their fans will back them up. And I get being an idol can be hard but it's their JOB.
@@maisha668 Yeah this was a 2-second slip up, she was stable throughout the rest
@@maisha668 But everytime this happens to bp everyone is hating on them but when its another group everyone is like its okay it doesnt matter etc.
Bro guys it was a mistake, everyone makes mistakes they can’t be perfectionists y’all. And to all the ppl who are saying “it’s their job” try to put yourself in their shoes. I don’t think Jisoo needs a vocal coach after SOME mistakes. And what are you guys doing? Commenting all day long about how they should work harder? Be real. Jisoo is a K-pop idol, model, and a actress. Isn’t that enough? She surely is putting more effort than you guys over there. Yes, I am defending her cuz y’all are just tiring “StOp DEfeNdinG HEr bE fR” “LaZY” “WoRK hARDer” it’s not like you’re the boss? Stop criticizing Jisoo y’all it’s rlly annoying.
Essas pessoas são doidas concordo com vc❤
Blind fans 😂
@@onlytruth846 how?
@@onlytruth846 blind? It was just a voice crack
@@SECUNDARY3 blinks*
I love you Rosé, the best!💚
Rosé deserves way more. She is so talented she can do everything like dance, singing even she has improved a lot in rap during born pink concert. I am really very proud of hér but some blinks don't notice her. I LOVE YOU SO MUCH ROSÉ❤️🫶🏻
Blinks do notice here girl
Yg sleeping on rose talent. She is most talented among all but don't get much opportunities 😕
@@28mahek all the members are talented and has contributed in various aspects. When you look at vocals and songwriting you have Rosé. Rapping and songwriting you have Jennie. Vocals,songwriting and acting you Jisoo. Lastly dancing and mentoring you have Lisa. Each member is very important. Saying "YG slept on Rosé's talent" when Rosé released her own solo project is the biggest lie Akgaes stans can make. Rosé has had a lot of opportunities such as solo,fashion week,song writing and there will be more coming soon.
Yass now let's make her goddess than goddess than goddess goddessx1000000000000 goddess's in vocals not hating rose but FR if one member makes mistake rose is better if rose make mistake in dance Lisa is better if Jennie mistake in rap Lisa is better I god damn want to leave this fandom but I can't leave my queens so I'm staying literally you guyz are so rustic
@@BP_BAEMON_ no some blinks don't notice her at all and do u know that she is the least loved member
That's why they are overrated.
Facts☝☝
True
Fact
Fr bro
Facts
These girls are professionals. When this kind of thing happens, it’s usually more of an issue with the Sound system, like their earpieces or speaker monitors. If you can’t hear your vocals well over the sound of the audience, and the background music, you’re going to have a hard time staying in key, even if you are very well trained , talented and professional. I can say this from experience as a stage singer.
Rose sounded so good in that performance ngl
Rosé is the only member who can nail the vocals while dancing, as a blink this just hurts to watch that they are struggling
Which is the song jennie singing after forever young..
@@__M.G__ hope not
@@maanya1405 thanks
Stop using the "As the a Blink" card when all Sultry film does is target Blackpink and make most of her vids based on Blackpink. They will struggle because they performed back to back so wouldn't they be out of breath? What's so hard to understand?.
Now, people should actually acknowledge and praise rosé
She barely gets noticed and praised
in any other group she wouldn't be main vocal
@@jquinoa5282 I love Rose and she's my bias but I gotta agree. I often see people saying she's the best vocalist in this era or no one can song like her, and a lot of different praises. I agree that she's good but people are exaggerating it. Still love her though
@@jquinoa5282 idc, she has been improving everyday, her technique has been improving,she always performs live and is loud so she deserve some praise
@@ericelestineyorfrylle1525these days,i think people have become more matuted to understand that she isnt the best and past years true i used to see that but now i havent seen people saying it at all...people says she has one of the best voice not vocals which is true tho
It's in a shorts because the great vocals during black pink performance would need a movie length .
Set them free they’re better off as models, dancers or actors..
Tbh Rosé is the only good vocalist in the group she would be better of a soloist
I’m no blink, but y’all should see the whole performance. It’s easy to pick and choose bad parts, but Jisoo was just fine except for this one part. Tbh, I love every mistake, every voice crack, every little thing because it’s *real*. They cannot be perfect 100% of the time. Your faves have made mistakes when going live too. Don’t get it twisted. This was a great performance *overall*, and they’ve really gotten into their groove so to speak since the semi-disastrous beginnings of their world tour. I never say this, but y’all are just looking for a reason to hate atp. Rosè put in almost no effort in the beginning of the tour, but now she’s being called “queen” and all that so people can’t shit on Jisoo. Make up your minds.
Thank you
Don't know where this haters come from
Thank you God let then breathe
Thanks❤❤❤
She is pro vocalist. She MUST BE better then you in a bathroom
@@annb2387she isn't a pro. And she has had training she is SUPPOSED to be better than us
Bro stop protecting them.. this is their job . They should focus on their vocals .NOW YOU ALL SAYING "NO ONE CAN SING WHILE DANCING" BRO THEY ARE 3RD GEN IDOLS AND IF THEY CANT STILL DO THIS WHY EVEN CALLING THIS LIVE PERFORMANCE!! HAVE YOU SEEN BTS ?! THEY LITERALLY WORK SO HARD AND SING LIVE WHILE DOING HARDEST CHOREOGRAPHYS!!! BLACKPINK LACKS LOTS OF PRACTICE!
BTS! 💯💜
Bruh, the entire K-pop girl groups I know sing while dancing to serious hard core choreographies..
Oh please about the vocal talk. Bro have you even seen there performances? They are not like this everytime are they? I know them for quite a bit now, i have seen there vocals. Rather than focusing on their 20% try to focus on the 80%. They are not the biggest girl group in the world for nothing right?
@@anupamaray6319 Wow what an excuse…ideally they should also refund that 20% to the ppl who attended with high hopes and received bathroom singing performances..
@@Sam-xr9lf Nah man i ain't getting money for making excuses on their behalf im just stating facts and about the 20% thing its a human nature that if the 80% part is great then the 20% is just vanished, thats what i said focus on the better part and if you think that they are not up to the mark then don't go to their concerts, go stan someone who you think will be perfect without any flaws.
Guys they have hard time dancing good and singing it’s hard I even tested out with myself and it’s really tiring so just understand the situation. Thank you 😊
I hope you said the same for Lesserafim 😊
@@chisonacoins this vid isn’t abt le sserafim no hate to le sserafim I love them but this vid has nothing to do with them….
HELP IT SOUNDS LIKE THAT ONE MEME OF JUNGKOOK IN STAY GOLD BUT JUNGKOOK WAS WITH A SOUND FILTER-
BUT THIS ISNT AND IT SOUNDS WORSE 💀💀😭😭
Lmao true 😂
😭😭😭😭iam dead
Not you'll watching one mistake 😭 there are not a single artist who didn't do any mistake and pls see positive side also like did they struggle this much before & give bad live performance?? No instead they were known for their live performance
LMOA IKR
Help 😂😂😆 you are right
Actually that vocal king jk shouldn't even deserve to be mention here
He is the best
I think Rose is the only one who can actually sing in their group
She is though, and even she is average at best in vocal tiers
She must be good at singing to save that part lisa saving the dancing, jennei the rap
I agree.I love her voice and singing.But her dancing is average and she is just visual
@@ereh11she is Mid W-A...
@@munggo_lloyd she's D- right?
You literally nitpicked the small mistake and made it the whole show, bruh😂
FRRRR
Like did u see every single second of the concert ? Yh no 😭💀
Yep exactly
It still suck and soul less
They shouldn’t be making those mistakes
My friend was saying rosé was the only member who danced, rap others part sometimes, did stable vocal, gave great and proper visual , and at her part her voice was more clear than other
He even said that he changed his bais from lisa to rosé
They promote them too much in the fashion industry that they forgot their an idol 👀 tbh if they spent time practicing their vocals and can see their improvement we can still defend them as a blink , we can't really protect them anymore because it's quite embarrassing that the people we put high up there can't put an effort to perform better 😩
that was the only line she messed up plz the entire performance was good
Exactly people are only focusing on the bad things
@@manarelmahi2227 fr they say that black pink can’t sing just bc they messed up a couple times
@@alixxee exactly!!
exactly!!!
@@manarelmahi2227 Yeah, they are literally human and this channel who is trying to humiliate them is just overrated and over opinionated.
😭 I can't defend them anymore. They sound like they are dehydrated or something 😭😭😭
Why don’t you try to sing while dancing? 💀
@@_ilvrekiit's not our job you salty blink 💀
@@Nwildindon’t judge someone till you walk a mile in their shoe, it is their job, but it’s not an easy job they’ve been doing this practically their hole life, do you think the most popular singers liked Taylor swift next had a bad performance, on stage or not everyone has slip ups
@@NwildinI laughed at your comment, “you salty bitch.” 😭 But fr you are right. I hate the argument, “why don’t you try to sing and dance.” Like I’m sorry but I didn’t train for MULTIPLE YEARS, I didn’t have vocal coaches, dance coaches, and I’m not an idol. This is literally Jennie’s job, she’s been doing it for I think 7 years now. Tbh there are rookie groups who are better then this.
@@HunniHaloit's their FREAKING JOB. It's for their OWN RICHES
She proved haters they are not lip syncing...❤
Idk why but something in me doesn’t wanna believe that’s actually them singing 😂 Besides Rose is more of the vocal queen and I’ve heard the members sing vocally good before. Idk where the “not always good at vocals” came from?
@@jkislove6255that was not their tour clip 😭😭
@@jkislove6255 istg these are all the fans who can't even afford to buy a mfing merch who are saying they went to the concert and giving these reviews 💀✋
@@jkislove6255 it's not edited. Don't lie
@@jkislove6255 That was a special event, how tf did you went there??
Not to be this person and I'm definitely not hating on them I actually like them, but they're not the only idols in the industry lmao in fact Blackpink isn't even that worked like they just got out of a 2-year hiatus. Rookie groups can perform while singing live like it's literally their job and what they trained to do, singing/rapping while dancing isn't a good enough excuse to sound like that, they're not rookies, at this point they're seniors and if we compare them to other senior groups like BTS or Twice then Blackpink are seriously lacking and ya'll need to hold them accountable.
yea exactly
jisoo actually slayed that concert her voice just cracked for seconds , also it's very difficult to sing and dance at same time we should appreciate their effort🍃
yes. we should all appreciate their effort in even going. i think the rest of their performance was fabulous
But all kpop groups do it not only blackpink
There are groups that can sing and dance. And Jennie is standing still and singing lol. If they're this bad then they shouldn't be so popular.
Beyonce sings while dancing lol even when she was younger she killed it.
@@angelamagatti6231 not you pulling up irrelevant topics to bring the most successful group down 😂
I’m a blink, a huge one, but this is out of hand. Us blinks have tried to protect them as much as possible but this, there is no way to defend them now. Kinda hope they disband this year.
BUT! Rosé is an amazing singer and she should debut as a kpop soloist, Jennie as a model, Jisoo as an actress, and Lisa as a western dancer, because she tends to be a bit more sexy and that’s more western style, and she would get less hate.
That’s just my opinion and don’t come at me.
Pin pls?
I understand what you are saying but your first paragraph is a shitty attitude. I've seen them live and it was great. And do you not like any of their studio produced music?
They love you dude.
Don't abandon them.
Think of Jisoo.
Rosés tears in the netflix doco.
Jennie's "I don't wanna cry I don't wanna cry."
Lisa - "Yadom"
Think.
And reflect.
Don't leave Dalgom out in the cold.
Please.
Ok, time to stop drinking.
❤❤❤❤❤
sOoo True bro
The only blink with a brain lmao
To be honest, there's no justification to their unstable live. They debuted years back and been around the world and it's disrespectful for the stage and fans that they still have this problem. That's why years of practice and continued practice is preached to have a spectacular stage. Btw, I'm a fan of EXO and at most, from their concerts, they cracked at times but recovered immediately. It's a funny mistake cause it rarely happens, but to these girls, damn I don't want to imagine how many times it's been.
Did u watch the shut down performance? Cos they did absolutely fine? Jisoo's mistakes weren't even that bad. And she carried on fine even after the mistakes. U could literally make a compilation out of any groups having vocal mistakes but perhaps no other group has such a magnifying glass put on em, waiting for any tiny mistake to blast and gaslight the masses.
This isn’t just a “bad day” tho😭😭😭 there are literally many videos of them messing up (singing and choreography) in every concert. Like not 3-4 mistakes but more than 10. Many Blinks were literally complaining about how bp doesn’t give their best anymore and they feel like the amount of money for the ticket wasn’t worth it😅 aren’t they supposed to be idols that trained for years? Why is Lisa the only one with energy?
U choose to hear what u wanna hear. They were plenty of ppl who went to the shows who found the clips and ppl like u dramatic and exaggerating. For every clip u choose to pick apart there are many good ones j choose to ignore. Be real. Have se balls and just admit u don't like em. Don't be so weak and fake.
where are these mistakes? blinks who have been to a concert say that it was amazing, only people like you complain seeing only their mistakes
Rosé too actually
For me of course
Rose did quite well
The time I went to a concert for me it was less about the music and more about seeing the artist
I'll never shut up about this; ygneeds to stop undertraining their female idols. I hope they at least train baemon properly cause the pinks are genuinely hurting themselves like this
okay but at this point, is it really just yg's fault? bp are all very rich and powerful women with lots of connections. if they really wanted to train, they have access to the best coaches in the industry. like what's stopping them?
@@KirigayaKazutoBeater People always blame YG when it comes to vocals that they are struggling
Honestly rosé is only who loved being a k-pop idol I think rosé should be a solo singer she will shine more her, vocals are so good ✨👑
Yes
Yup ❤
Her: jisoo was struggling throughout the concert
Also her: *shows 2 sec video*
True man they call this facts where the biggest fact is this channel is made to criticiz every kpop group 😅
Sadly a lot of ktubers do this and it's so annoying. Like this video proves that people just need a reason to hate them.
Bro it's a 1 min vid you want her to you the whole performance
@@sunghoon-officialaccount well honestly jisoo didn't even struggle, her voice just cracked for 2 secs and these k tubers reuse these 2 secs over and over to criticize her. It's so low for people to do that honestly
@@NeverlandXidleso true.
Oh come on, how hard it is to realize that dancing and singing together is really hard.
Dear haters , try to sing and dance at the same time and try to do it in front of thousands of people , you will never be good as them ,so don't spread hate.
eh sure but there are groups that are still stable while dancing like dreamcatcher, skz, itzy, mamamoo, and more
@@thesanestan but l don't think they were all successful as blackpink, l hope nobody would get me wrong l love each group from what you mentioned , l,m a fan of each group but why do you compare groups to each other.
Also if blackpink weren't stable as you say , why would they became top 1 kpop girl group , l am sure each group from what you mentioned made mistakes but the real fans still love them, but some people would spread hate for whatever they do or compare them to other teams, those people are called haters for a reason because they want to spread hate due to their jealousy .
Jisoo is stable everywhere since debut in all her concert. She just cracked for 2 sec only in one concert and get hated for it(a lot of kpop singer's voice get cracked too at some point like jimin when his health was not good and jisoo is not an exception). During the whole blackpink performance, jisoo and rose are live singer. Jisoo really slayed her part and become more confident like her stage presence improved a lot. Rosie posie always slayed the vocals not even a single mistake. Lisa slayed dancing but i expected that she will rap her part live cause she has really great solo songs and yeah jennie is best performer except in some parts.
Accept the fact whoever bp member attract more people's eyes get more rating. Perfect example is lisa. Jennie is all rounder and a great performer but lisa caught more audience due to her dance or some hype parts. Same happening with jisoo and rose. BTW Love OT4❤❤❤❤
lol exactly. compare the comments here to the recent jimin video one, baffling.
She isn't stable. Her voice also crack
She has thin voice, she is always crack
@lindo_..3024 for 2 sec, she is always stable in the other concerts.
Her voice was like that for the entire concert
ok but rose was genuinely good
Queensé carried the performance vocally as always 💅
Pls tell me that was sarcasm-
@@giventaken- She's was good idk what yall talking. SHE carries the world tour with her vocals
@@giventaken- nah she carried shut down and pink venom for real
Hell No..she is the main vocalist but is the worst
@@giventaken- nah i feel like she's the only one who knows how to perform live and she legit carried all their songs
Blinks saying it's hard to sing while dancing as if they are giving their 100% in dancing 💀
Brro go and see more mr removed of blackpink she is just posting the worst parts Jisoo's voice just cracked for 2 or 3 secs and then it got normal again
they are average in every talent lmao not just vocal
Yes
So true. 德不配位
and how about you ? probably don’t have any talent .
@@bbeuchin741 actually I do not only am I good at studies and sports I am a dancer too
so shut the fuck up ik for a fact that my on finger has more strength than someone's ankle 😍😍👆👆
But not on luck
Here comes the obsessed blinks oddly talented in making up excuses! Imagine other idols singing like this once and blinks are "omg she's talentless", "she shouldn't be an idol", "oof, need more training" and put hate on them like hell.
Meanwhile when bp performs terribly loads of times, it's "they're humans too", "they don't deserve the hate, "she had an injury", "people have bad days", "you can't live a day without being obsessed putting hate to our girls"
Like wtf & bffr😭
Agree! Sadly i like their songs.
SO TRUE!💯
@@BANGTANSTV_ remember when Momo from twice got dragged through hell for her bad live vocals? Yeah I ain't seen none defend her or day that shes just a human and even Twice fans admitted that shes not the most vocally gifted of the group and that's fine. Blinks on the other hand cant seem to admit the fact that their faves really arent all that when it comes to singing and have the audacity to get mad when people call them out for their awful vocals. Blinks are the 1st to hate on all the female idols who lip synch or have bad live vocals yet their faves are both combined.
@@beyivy691 im okay. But i don't knw abt these things much. Cause im not a blink and don't knw much abt other groups but i listen to their songs.
Here comes that person who always say something about the blinks who defend blackpink like someone hadn't said in the comments like a hundred times. Btw not defending bp
it looks that jennie and jisoo are holding a burp tbh 💀
@مليكة🤍 yes, I did
@مليكة🤍 bro I didn't understand the "chock in my water"
@مليكة🤍 Now I understand, I made you laugh with my comment, right?
BRO 😭
I think personally they need more training they were really struggling and it hurt to watch it I didn’t think they’d be that bad.
Jisoo was always mid tier, fans just hype her up because they feel bad no one talks about her, every kpop group has that lacking member. You could see it in her solo performances like clarity, she was shrieking and straining so bad but fans kept praising her. That’s why she hasn’t gotten a solo yet. I’m saying this as a fan
I agree