Before you make a comment about the Jake part, please read this : I meant that he has the same positive vibe as Jake. It was not meant to compare their skills in any way. Enhypen is one of my ult groups and I love Jake. I never meant anything negative.
rush hour (for me-) was absolutely immaculate. they really were PREPARED. They had the vocals, the rap, the dance, the stage presence, and the facial expressions. not only that, but it felt like a very american pop music spin on the song that was almost refreshing i’d say? considering all of these factors, jay and kamden really did put on an amazing performance and DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!!!
Very true they r the best especially Jay singing his heart out best rapper and best singer ever… clear concise voice ever… he is a pro entertainer ever🍀🙏🥰✌️🏆🌟🌟🌟
Rush Hour was the best lol, they were the only ones who had everything perfect. The vocals, the rao, the dance and the expressions, they literally had everything on point
Only Jay and Kamden offered an immaculate performance. No flaws, perfect live singing, charisma, they had fun while performing... Rush hoye was the best.
the g group performance of kick it was my fav, the chemistry in the team was superior. Brian left us shocked by his facial expressions and stage presence AND HIS VOCALSSS, Ollie was hyped up and left us speechless with his rap like our Ricky, who also danced like the wonderful trainee he is, he didn't lie when he said he was young and rich, tall and handsome
Oh my, Hui was there? xD is he a judge or something? I don't keep up with Boys Planet. Edit: oh I just learned he's a contestant! Wow, he's gonna win over everyone haha
rush hour was def my favourite performance, i think k groups kick it was good but i dont think they all deserved all star, esp if theyre not giving smone like kamden or hanbin all star, i think at most two of them shouldve gotten it but all? it wasnt outstanding enough tbh 😗
Mong chờ gì công bằng ở Mnet hả bạn. Chương trình chọn sẵn người thắng cuộc hết rồi chỉ có thực tập sinh từ công ty lớn điển hình trong đây là cty Yue Hua còn các tts khác chưa được train như Công vào chỉ để làm nền thôi. Nếu bạn ấy cố gắng bứt phá thì may ra ,chứ là không được đâu. Cứ tập trung vote là được chứ chả mong đợi gì.
My Ranking 🙈 1. Rush Hour 2. All I Wanna Do 3. Tiger Inside 4. Beautiful 5. Kick It G 6. Kick It K 7. G.B.T.B 8. Glitch Mode 9. Crown 10. View 11. Mmmh 12. Call Me Baby 13. My House (Bak Doha) 14. Shine 15. Ko Ko Bop 16. Damdadi 17. My House (Mingyu) 18. Criminal K (Wooseok) 19. Criminal K (Donggun) 20. God Menu 21. Hot
On a technical level, kick it K group was better. However kick it G group was my all time favorite performance of the episode because the boys were so talented, charismatic, and memorable. Ollie was a great person to give the first line and slayed the ending.
For me I thought that K group’s dance was amazing but the vocals were kinda bad except for the high note and gyuvin’s part, while G group did a pretty decent job in general, the vocals weren’t perfect either but I LOVED the rap, the dance was good too.
we were just discussing with my friend how vocals have taken a backseat in Kpop lately ...like dance and aesthetics seems to be the dominating factor which is actually pretty disappointing.
Then maybe kpop is not for you. Anyways, dont be dvmb and lazy. Kpop is more than just the modt popular idol groups. You can find what you are looking for, if you search for it instead of complaining
@@ryerye6587 is it reading comprehension that you lack or are you purposely this dense? what does being a popular idol have anything to do with vocal talent? Secondly, opinions and criticisms are actual things so I suggest you look up their definitions, considering you seem a bit slow.
My Ranking 1. Kick it ( G group) 2. beautiful beautiful 3. All I Wanna Do 4. Rush Hour 5. G.B.T.B 6. Kick it ( K group) 7. tiger inside 8. Glith mode 9. View 10. crown 11. call me baby 12. mmmh 13. damadi 14. kokobop 15. shine 16. My house ( both) 17. Criminal K (Wooseok) 18. Criminal K (Donggun) 19. God's menu 20. hot
I feel like Mnet had the trainees be 'bad' in order to show their 'huge improvement'. And in order to pick out the most popular ones by giving them lots of praises with editing to secure them for the elimination.
park gunwook was so good he should have gotten all stars and also people thinks he's bad at singing but if you see him on the show wild idol he is VERYVERY good and talented at singing
1.My first choice would be rush hour cuz they were flawless 2.beautiful cuz I love hanbin charms in it. 3. Ggrp kick it THE PERFORMANCE was a chef kiss. 4. The real, the guys are enjoying performance and I was enjoying watching them. 5. Shut down no comment, it's hui I know it's gonna be lit. 6. K grp kick it damnn the dance break I love it. 7. Tiger inside, my respect for Kuan jui~🫂 8. zero conduct the whole osaka's were so good I love their energy. 9. G.B.T.B hands off to the power they hold love them. 10. Glitch mode love the haruto rap and they did pretty good.. That's all my top 10 choice ♥︎
fr the boys from Tokyo actually pulled off grt facial expressions and their dance was sooo good as well, if it wasn't for Itsuki I shouldn't have got interested, but ig this is what we get TT. tbh I'd liked itsuki's vocals (cant rlly say tht tho it wasn't stable) esp Ouju who lacked a lot. still i'm looking forward for it, who knows who will improve :D
i was so annoyed how kick it g group didnt all get 4 stars??? some of the other people they gave 4 stars should have gotten 3 instead but not them like omg
A little fact about Yuehua's G Group is that for 3 months they practiced NCT Dream's Beatbox up until a WEEK before evaluations because Mnet changed their performance to Kick It instead. Another snake move by Mnet. Ollie exposed this on a live.
You are so based man, G group Kick It is the one I always go back to. I get that K group had the cool dance elements that reminded them of one of the judges but they gave two of them half a line to sing each and didn’t ask them to show more in vocals at all to get the 4 stars. Why did they do that to them only to stress the kids out during signal song training and make them drop from 4 stars and feel bad, just because they wanted K group to win first? I shouldn’t expect mnet to be fair or rational I guess. It was also such a plus for me that there was an actual rap section in G group because that’s what I’m expecting in 127 songs as a NCT fan lmao everyone have pretty solid amount of lines that showcased them each pretty well too! They were so well balanced !!
I actually love Mingyu (red house). He is not great but seeing him get more and more comfortable on stage and growing is fun to watch. He is also just precious.
I agree with you,, tbh of course comparing him to trainees that obviously have been training to be come idols and for longer than him, he wasnt that good, but its obvious he's been working hard for the missions and lowkey mnet's comedic edit on him makes me feel a bit :((
~my ranking /// *Presentable ;;; ok w/ this for near-debut level* 1. Rush Hour. Kinda nice + did kamden write his rap?? 2. Kick It ~ K Yuehua 3/4. Beautiful. personally, find choreo tougher. also, def has the idol presence / vibe cuz duh- 4/3. All I Wanna Do *Presentable near-debut / may tweak a bit tho w/ a few lines or parts' vocal tone delivery, etc; good tho* 5. Tiger Inside (it's a bit hiyahhh energy for some line delivery for me, but they're very stable despite the choreo) 6. GBTB 7. Kick It ~ G Yuehua. I watch this the 1st/2nd most tho. Just the rap needs a bit of tone adjustment for Ollie, tho this inflections & flow are ok + maybe Ricky can say the shhh better, tho I think Ricky prefers singing>rapping, tho he's not that off-beat. 8. Glitch Mode 9. View ~also in fine level ______________________________________________________________________ *Fine-ish. needs more to stand out a bit more /// or a bit more training time w/ the song* 9. View (nearly there tho) 10. Criminal ~ Wooseok. for the trainee levels here, esp for Taemin songs, I'm surprised his voice didn't give out as much for the 1 min 12/11. Call Me Baby. They had more stage presence tho I'd prefer they'd train better w/ this; some projected vocals tho faltered 12/11. Mmmh. I think more charisma is needed for solo tho skills are fine, but singing is a bit safely fine. idk if rap was needed tho he can do a kpop rap def ______________________________________________________________________ *Ok-ish tho also needs more time training or a better take* Tbh, unsure w/ these 3; kinda interchangeable ranks for me 13. damdadi. not as hard to sing+dance simultaneously, tho they suit it for maknae stage & voices are projected enough + dance is ok 14/15. Kokobop. My issue is Winne kinda is the most stable for 14th/15th spot people but their vocal skills clashed imo. dance is fine + presence is 50/50 tho their energy is fine. Winne just stood out for stability to me for 13-15th place. 14/15. Crown. I actually like crown the best of these 3, but the vocals don't seem that trained, tho if not trained, this is decent + kinda stable. stage presence & energy suit the song. I enjoy watching the 2 the best. ______________________________________________________________________ *def more time training w/ the song & some skills* 16. Criminal ~ Donggun. ~I'm on the fence w/ this cuz he tried to project but skipped way too many lines + was on vocal struggle. His visuals do help w/ presence, esp for the song concept. dance is ok tho he was def struggling vocally + just flowed into the high note tho ended up shouting it; he is doing this solo tho, so tbh would he be much better just in a group tbh cuz I think he kinda knows what the key is but just isn't trained enough to sing solo like this. Also, his voice kinda gave out tho he didn't get the worst voice cracks I've seen in ep 1 17. Shine ~ Osaka? ~need more time training def. tried to project vocally, esp osuke, tho they lack in vocal training. they had presence tho + kinda suited the concept, but it was def on vocal struggle for them all; voice cracks or voice just getting hoarse often on simpler parts in the chorus. dance is ok + they were entertaining performers tho cuz presence wasn't that bad tbh + they were quite audible/projected-ish tho couldn't sing high enough. ________________________________________________________________________ *nah- def need more training-* 18/19. My House ~ Mingyu. ~he's not exactly off-key tho like drunk karaoke amateur singing. was likely meant to be a "fun stage" planned by mnet tho. vocals are struggling for the song requirements, esp w/ the choreo level. he also can't sing high enough. Has some natural charisma/presence w/ proportions / vibes tho. 18/19. My House ~ Bak Doha. ~I prefer this to Mingyu's tho he's more off-key, tho he did get to do the post-chorus choreo. his voice is more naturally projected than mingyu's tho. I'm unsure between the 2 cuz I think Mingyu is more on-key. This is also a "fun stage" tho 20. God's Menu ~did not need to be that shout-y, esp on jisung's verse. the prechorus vocals faltered a bit. the loudness was kinda jumpscare-ish. Also, not projected enough; mostly just shouted. It's just a bit too much. Think they should've trained differently w/ the energy output. dance is ok tho. idk if I should put this before the my house's tho this was seen as a more "serious effort" than my house- The guy w/ brown hair was the most tolerable tho cuz he was a bit more on pitch + I was more ok w/ the vocals @ the last post-chorus 21. Hot ~seems underprepared. They're not synced well. Vocals seem sloppy & uncertain + vocal struggle to project the singing-ish parts. Also, dk why they chose to sing the chorus breathy. Also, a bit out of breath. idk if they're like vocal positions at all??
View - Cong, Dang Hong Hai Kick It K group - Han Yujin, Kim Gyuvin,Yoo Seungeon, Ji Yunseo Rush Hour - Na Kamden, Jay G.B.T.B. - Park Hyunbeen, Park Gunwook, Han Yuseop, Jang Yeojun All I Wanna Do - Seok Matthew Beautiful - Sung Hanbin Kick It G Group - Ollie, Zhang Hao, Ricky, Brian
I’m just confused on how everyone in k group kick it got all star. Only 2 did extra performances. The other 2 just danced and sung along. They’ve should’ve given kamden all star if that was the case. G group was doomed from the start
everyone saying rush hour was the best and i need yall to be serious for a sec because jay didn’t do the dance justice like kamden did and that’s the only think that lacks making it not the best but probably 3rd or 4th
Thinking about how the production team has a say on their song choice...such a turn off. It's kinda waste of time also for you to rank. Contestants could've picked a safe song where the dance isn't that hardcore but they can still sing properly (stable). But produce said no, "pick more recent songs/pick songs from popular groups". *If you're not that good why would you pick EXO, SEVENTEEN & Golden Child's songs* . Their choreo are intense.
Rush hour team remains me to Dumdi Dumdi team in Girls Planet, just one trainee get screen time. At the time mashiro and hiyajo showing the great performance. But mashiro got the spotlight bcz she's from JYP ex Trainee almost debut with itzy, and hiyajo, no one talk about her, it's sad, if she got more spotlight, she coukd one of best main dancer in gp99. And the history repeated at bp, jay is great. But, Kamden is great rapers. Fortunatelly kamden save from last elimination. I really love all of them, jay, kamden and mashiro, hiyajo. I just didn't like how mnet overshadowing one person for make another trainee get more spotlight. Ps. English not my first language
Мне кажется люди стали забывать каково это: петь и танцевать одновременно. Из-за того что у некоторых выдающихся людей получаетсч это делать, не значит у молодых парней НЕ дебютировших получится также
I agree with All I wanna do, but not better than Jay Park, please, let's not compare to the original artist. It is better to say they it was another cute version
you put a performance where you said 3/4 of the trainees werent good at number 4 but you put rush hour that was amazing all around at 6.. what sense does that make
Before you make a comment about the Jake part, please read this :
I meant that he has the same positive vibe as Jake. It was not meant to compare their skills in any way. Enhypen is one of my ult groups and I love Jake. I never meant anything negative.
ok😂😂
rush hour (for me-) was absolutely immaculate. they really were PREPARED. They had the vocals, the rap, the dance, the stage presence, and the facial expressions. not only that, but it felt like a very american pop music spin on the song that was almost refreshing i’d say? considering all of these factors, jay and kamden really did put on an amazing performance and DID NOT DISAPPOINT!!!!
Very true they r the best especially Jay singing his heart out best rapper and best singer ever… clear concise voice ever… he is a pro entertainer ever🍀🙏🥰✌️🏆🌟🌟🌟
totally agree, it was such a refreshing stage jay and kamden were so good
Totally agree with you. It makes me so mad that they cut off so much of Kamden’s parts 🥹
Rush Hour was the best lol, they were the only ones who had everything perfect. The vocals, the rao, the dance and the expressions, they literally had everything on point
Only Jay and Kamden offered an immaculate performance. No flaws, perfect live singing, charisma, they had fun while performing... Rush hoye was the best.
the g group performance of kick it was my fav, the chemistry in the team was superior. Brian left us shocked by his facial expressions and stage presence AND HIS VOCALSSS, Ollie was hyped up and left us speechless with his rap like our Ricky, who also danced like the wonderful trainee he is, he didn't lie when he said he was young and rich, tall and handsome
frr!! it was my fav as well
I feel sad for the Seventeen fans who watched this cover of Hot. And I feel sad for Hui because he had to watch that cover(?) of Shine.
Oh my, Hui was there? xD is he a judge or something? I don't keep up with Boys Planet.
Edit: oh I just learned he's a contestant! Wow, he's gonna win over everyone haha
He was touched that they covered the song
He literally cried because he was happy. I don’t think he cared about the performance being bad
rush hour was def my favourite performance, i think k groups kick it was good but i dont think they all deserved all star, esp if theyre not giving smone like kamden or hanbin all star, i think at most two of them shouldve gotten it but all? it wasnt outstanding enough tbh 😗
Brooo exactly, only 2 of them did extra performances the other 2 should’ve gotten 2 or 3 atleast.
for me rush hour here was another level compare to other performances like srsly vocal, dance, expressions everything was on point
justice for my viet boys 😭
Mong chờ gì công bằng ở Mnet hả bạn. Chương trình chọn sẵn người thắng cuộc hết rồi chỉ có thực tập sinh từ công ty lớn điển hình trong đây là cty Yue Hua còn các tts khác chưa được train như Công vào chỉ để làm nền thôi. Nếu bạn ấy cố gắng bứt phá thì may ra ,chứ là không được đâu. Cứ tập trung vote là được chứ chả mong đợi gì.
@@hanyukul8077 they haven’t selected it, just pushed some contestants a lot.
My Ranking 🙈
1. Rush Hour
2. All I Wanna Do
3. Tiger Inside
4. Beautiful
5. Kick It G
6. Kick It K
7. G.B.T.B
8. Glitch Mode
9. Crown
10. View
11. Mmmh
12. Call Me Baby
13. My House (Bak Doha)
14. Shine
15. Ko Ko Bop
16. Damdadi
17. My House (Mingyu)
18. Criminal K (Wooseok)
19. Criminal K (Donggun)
20. God Menu
21. Hot
I agree with most of it
For me would definitely be Rush Hour for #1 they had the best vocal, dance, rap, facial expressions, and stage presence
On a technical level, kick it K group was better. However kick it G group was my all time favorite performance of the episode because the boys were so talented, charismatic, and memorable. Ollie was a great person to give the first line and slayed the ending.
same but k group was quite boring while g group has the stage presence and can improve
For me I thought that K group’s dance was amazing but the vocals were kinda bad except for the high note and gyuvin’s part, while G group did a pretty decent job in general, the vocals weren’t perfect either but I LOVED the rap, the dance was good too.
It has always been that way since Produce 48.
But this season particularly have a lot of on-par-with-K-group global contestants. Zhang Hao, Jay, etc.
we were just discussing with my friend how vocals have taken a backseat in Kpop lately ...like dance and aesthetics seems to be the dominating factor which is actually pretty disappointing.
Exactly like I’m not gonna be looking at their faces when I’m trying to listen to some good music
Then maybe kpop is not for you. Anyways, dont be dvmb and lazy. Kpop is more than just the modt popular idol groups. You can find what you are looking for, if you search for it instead of complaining
@@ryerye6587 is it reading comprehension that you lack or are you purposely this dense? what does being a popular idol have anything to do with vocal talent? Secondly, opinions and criticisms are actual things so I suggest you look up their definitions, considering you seem a bit slow.
2:59 and they got 1-2 star 😢😢😢
the fact that the judges gave viet line 1-2 stars for that performance was crimes against humanity.
Yes then had the audacity to give all of kick it k group all stars🤦🏾♀️
Rush hour is the best, both of them rocks ❤️
My Ranking
1. Kick it ( G group)
2. beautiful beautiful
3. All I Wanna Do
4. Rush Hour
5. G.B.T.B
6. Kick it ( K group)
7. tiger inside
8. Glith mode
9. View
10. crown
11. call me baby
12. mmmh
13. damadi
14. kokobop
15. shine
16. My house ( both)
17. Criminal K (Wooseok)
18. Criminal K (Donggun)
19. God's menu
20. hot
my top 10:
1. rush hour
2. kick it g
3. glicht mode
4. kick it k
5. all i wanna do
6. tiger inside
7. beautiful
8. g.b.t.b
9. mmmh
10. view
I feel like Mnet had the trainees be 'bad' in order to show their 'huge improvement'. And in order to pick out the most popular ones by giving them lots of praises with editing to secure them for the elimination.
park gunwook was so good he should have gotten all stars and also people thinks he's bad at singing but if you see him on the show wild idol he is VERYVERY good and talented at singing
Justice for my viet boys bc whyd they get so little stars when their performance was one of the better ones 😭😭
My most fav was G group's Kick It too huhu
1.My first choice would be rush hour cuz they were flawless
2.beautiful cuz I love hanbin charms in it.
3. Ggrp kick it THE PERFORMANCE was a chef kiss.
4. The real, the guys are enjoying performance and I was enjoying watching them.
5. Shut down no comment, it's hui I know it's gonna be lit.
6. K grp kick it damnn the dance break I love it.
7. Tiger inside, my respect for Kuan jui~🫂
8. zero conduct the whole osaka's were so good I love their energy.
9. G.B.T.B hands off to the power they hold love them.
10. Glitch mode love the haruto rap and they did pretty good..
That's all my top 10 choice ♥︎
rush hour was definitely number 1 for me
Jay Chang the best dancer and excellent clear awesome singer ever .. he is a pro ever
Agreed！all the boys in Kick it G are soooo good！😊
fr the boys from Tokyo actually pulled off grt facial expressions and their dance was sooo good as well, if it wasn't for Itsuki I shouldn't have got interested, but ig this is what we get TT. tbh I'd liked itsuki's vocals (cant rlly say tht tho it wasn't stable) esp Ouju who lacked a lot. still i'm looking forward for it, who knows who will improve :D
Rush hour is easily first for me , the only ones that truly had no flaws
bro jAy improved SO MUCH looking at enhypen dance practices now
I don't understand why yuehua or maybe Mnet put the k-group and g-group perform with same song...
Rush hour was the best
1st gp 999 Kick it
1st bp 999 Kick it
rush hour and all i wanna do were amazing imo
i was so annoyed how kick it g group didnt all get 4 stars??? some of the other people they gave 4 stars should have gotten 3 instead but not them like omg
A little fact about Yuehua's G Group is that for 3 months they practiced NCT Dream's Beatbox up until a WEEK before evaluations because Mnet changed their performance to Kick It instead.
Another snake move by Mnet. Ollie exposed this on a live.
You are so based man, G group Kick It is the one I always go back to. I get that K group had the cool dance elements that reminded them of one of the judges but they gave two of them half a line to sing each and didn’t ask them to show more in vocals at all to get the 4 stars. Why did they do that to them only to stress the kids out during signal song training and make them drop from 4 stars and feel bad, just because they wanted K group to win first? I shouldn’t expect mnet to be fair or rational I guess.
It was also such a plus for me that there was an actual rap section in G group because that’s what I’m expecting in 127 songs as a NCT fan lmao everyone have pretty solid amount of lines that showcased them each pretty well too! They were so well balanced !!
I honestly don’t think everyone in k group deserved all star. Maybe only 2 of them
I actually love Mingyu (red house). He is not great but seeing him get more and more comfortable on stage and growing is fun to watch. He is also just precious.
I agree with you,, tbh of course comparing him to trainees that obviously have been training to be come idols and for longer than him, he wasnt that good, but its obvious he's been working hard for the missions and lowkey mnet's comedic edit on him makes me feel a bit :((
Where's Zihao's performance of veil? And Mirotic?
just wanted to say. the worst groups performances were the most entertaining and made me smile the most hahhahaa
Yeah cause it’s funny how bad they are. Makes me wonder how they even got on the show
Chen Kuan Jui deserves more!
respect to u for putting tiger inside in the top 5
chen kuan lui is so talented
Vote for Kuanjui✨✨✨✨ He deserves it❤❤
Ichika carried the shine performance llike woah he needs to be recognized more
~my ranking ///
*Presentable ;;; ok w/ this for near-debut level*
1. Rush Hour. Kinda nice + did kamden write his rap??
2. Kick It ~ K Yuehua
3/4. Beautiful. personally, find choreo tougher. also, def has the idol presence / vibe cuz duh-
4/3. All I Wanna Do
*Presentable near-debut / may tweak a bit tho w/ a few lines or parts' vocal tone delivery, etc; good tho*
5. Tiger Inside (it's a bit hiyahhh energy for some line delivery for me, but they're very stable despite the choreo)
6. GBTB
7. Kick It ~ G Yuehua. I watch this the 1st/2nd most tho. Just the rap needs a bit of tone adjustment for Ollie, tho this inflections & flow are ok + maybe Ricky can say the shhh better, tho I think Ricky prefers singing>rapping, tho he's not that off-beat.
8. Glitch Mode
9. View ~also in fine level
______________________________________________________________________
*Fine-ish. needs more to stand out a bit more /// or a bit more training time w/ the song*
9. View (nearly there tho)
10. Criminal ~ Wooseok. for the trainee levels here, esp for Taemin songs, I'm surprised his voice didn't give out as much for the 1 min
12/11. Call Me Baby. They had more stage presence tho I'd prefer they'd train better w/ this; some projected vocals tho faltered
12/11. Mmmh. I think more charisma is needed for solo tho skills are fine, but singing is a bit safely fine. idk if rap was needed tho he can do a kpop rap def
______________________________________________________________________
*Ok-ish tho also needs more time training or a better take*
Tbh, unsure w/ these 3; kinda interchangeable ranks for me
13. damdadi. not as hard to sing+dance simultaneously, tho they suit it for maknae stage & voices are projected enough + dance is ok
14/15. Kokobop. My issue is Winne kinda is the most stable for 14th/15th spot people but their vocal skills clashed imo. dance is fine + presence is 50/50 tho their energy is fine. Winne just stood out for stability to me for 13-15th place.
14/15. Crown. I actually like crown the best of these 3, but the vocals don't seem that trained, tho if not trained, this is decent + kinda stable. stage presence & energy suit the song. I enjoy watching the 2 the best.
______________________________________________________________________
*def more time training w/ the song & some skills*
16. Criminal ~ Donggun.
~I'm on the fence w/ this cuz he tried to project but skipped way too many lines + was on vocal struggle. His visuals do help w/ presence, esp for the song concept. dance is ok tho he was def struggling vocally + just flowed into the high note tho ended up shouting it; he is doing this solo tho, so tbh would he be much better just in a group tbh cuz I think he kinda knows what the key is but just isn't trained enough to sing solo like this. Also, his voice kinda gave out tho he didn't get the worst voice cracks I've seen in ep 1
17. Shine ~ Osaka?
~need more time training def. tried to project vocally, esp osuke, tho they lack in vocal training. they had presence tho + kinda suited the concept, but it was def on vocal struggle for them all; voice cracks or voice just getting hoarse often on simpler parts in the chorus. dance is ok + they were entertaining performers tho cuz presence wasn't that bad tbh + they were quite audible/projected-ish tho couldn't sing high enough.
________________________________________________________________________
*nah- def need more training-*
18/19. My House ~ Mingyu.
~he's not exactly off-key tho like drunk karaoke amateur singing. was likely meant to be a "fun stage" planned by mnet tho. vocals are struggling for the song requirements, esp w/ the choreo level. he also can't sing high enough. Has some natural charisma/presence w/ proportions / vibes tho.
18/19. My House ~ Bak Doha.
~I prefer this to Mingyu's tho he's more off-key, tho he did get to do the post-chorus choreo. his voice is more naturally projected than mingyu's tho. I'm unsure between the 2 cuz I think Mingyu is more on-key. This is also a "fun stage" tho
20. God's Menu
~did not need to be that shout-y, esp on jisung's verse. the prechorus vocals faltered a bit. the loudness was kinda jumpscare-ish. Also, not projected enough; mostly just shouted. It's just a bit too much. Think they should've trained differently w/ the energy output. dance is ok tho. idk if I should put this before the my house's tho this was seen as a more "serious effort" than my house- The guy w/ brown hair was the most tolerable tho cuz he was a bit more on pitch + I was more ok w/ the vocals @ the last post-chorus
21. Hot
~seems underprepared. They're not synced well. Vocals seem sloppy & uncertain + vocal struggle to project the singing-ish parts. Also, dk why they chose to sing the chorus breathy. Also, a bit out of breath. idk if they're like vocal positions at all??
Yes kamden wrote his own rap
the second place song is beautiful beautiful by onf. they're super talented, yall should give them a listen if you haven't already
i feel bad for shine group their formation was changed was 6 member to 3 member last minute 😭
seok woohyun oppa 🫶🏻🫶🏻
For me The all I want to do is best for me, I don’t think he did it better than jay Park but he did it insanely good
100% AGREE
Rush hour should be 1 and kick it I like korean one cuz zhang hao good at high note but seung eon voice is everything 🤕
Can somene tell me who was in :
9 view
7 K group
6 RUSH HOUR
5 G.B.T.B
3 all I wanna do
2 beautiful
1 G group
View - Cong, Dang Hong Hai
Kick It K group - Han Yujin, Kim Gyuvin,Yoo Seungeon, Ji Yunseo
Rush Hour - Na Kamden, Jay
G.B.T.B. - Park Hyunbeen, Park Gunwook, Han Yuseop, Jang Yeojun
All I Wanna Do - Seok Matthew
Beautiful - Sung Hanbin
Kick It G Group - Ollie, Zhang Hao, Ricky, Brian
yall better vote for matthew :)
Fighting 💪
❤️
I’m just confused on how everyone in k group kick it got all star. Only 2 did extra performances. The other 2 just danced and sung along. They’ve should’ve given kamden all star if that was the case. G group was doomed from the start
My top 5:
1. Beautiful
2. Rush hour
3. Kick it k-groupe
4. All I wanna do
5. kick it g-groupe
The vocals are really
Lolllll you must be a Jay Park hater to say that Matthew performed All I Wanna Do better than the og singer
Kick It K group should've been higher imo top 3 other than that pretty spot on
I'm sorry matthew is incredible thats is for sure and he'll debut but saying thats he perfomed better than j-park is just a little bit too much XD
AGREED. WITH ALL THE RANKINGS ISTG
Totally agree
everyone saying rush hour was the best and i need yall to be serious for a sec because jay didn’t do the dance justice like kamden did and that’s the only think that lacks making it not the best but probably 3rd or 4th
Thinking about how the production team has a say on their song choice...such a turn off. It's kinda waste of time also for you to rank.
Contestants could've picked a safe song where the dance isn't that hardcore but they can still sing properly (stable).
But produce said no, "pick more recent songs/pick songs from popular groups".
*If you're not that good why would you pick EXO, SEVENTEEN & Golden Child's songs* . Their choreo are intense.
OMG I LOVED WOOSEOK"S CRIMINAL PERFORMANCE IT WAS SO GOOD (granted I REALLY like Taemin so that plays a factor ig)
my fav is K group kick it, although g group did. well too
i wont rank it high either but i actually like hot perfomance alot
Wait.....
Mnets the one giving them songs?
Is all survival show like this?
I'm really sad that minseo left 😔
rush hour and all I want to do is top 2 for me.
Personally for me Kick it was the best like I really enjoyed their stage it was awesome
I thought I was hearing a parody , and then I opened youtube and these are actual performances OMGGG huhuhu
Rush hour team remains me to Dumdi Dumdi team in Girls Planet, just one trainee get screen time. At the time mashiro and hiyajo showing the great performance. But mashiro got the spotlight bcz she's from JYP ex Trainee almost debut with itzy, and hiyajo, no one talk about her, it's sad, if she got more spotlight, she coukd one of best main dancer in gp99. And the history repeated at bp, jay is great. But, Kamden is great rapers. Fortunatelly kamden save from last elimination. I really love all of them, jay, kamden and mashiro, hiyajo. I just didn't like how mnet overshadowing one person for make another trainee get more spotlight.
Ps. English not my first language
rush hour top 1 imo
BFFR you did not put Kamden and Jay below Matthew, Han Bin and Ricky's group the fuck?
kick it k group is too low though imo, it’s the best one. vocal and dancing on point!
in my opinion, kick it k group made it more
3. I swear
lol did you just dissed Jay Park in favour of matthew?!
like this was good, but....... no babes just NO
Vote for your favourite Boys Planet contestants on my fanmade survival show : docs.google.com/forms/d/1WcsVItlh0K2jOMzXX093J0qojI9AR1Kx8kM2EXFaka4
Мне кажется люди стали забывать каково это: петь и танцевать одновременно. Из-за того что у некоторых выдающихся людей получаетсч это делать, не значит у молодых парней НЕ дебютировших получится также
I agree with All I wanna do, but not better than Jay Park, please, let's not compare to the original artist. It is better to say they it was another cute version
ichika carried shine, the other two boys tho ......
can you make one for fantasy boys?
so were all these shown in the show??? I'm so sure that it didnt but did i just skip an episode???
Why is SHUT DOWN not here?
Its in the second video
Why does Mnet give them the song to perform on star test level? Based on what???
They give list of songs. You prepare it by ur own.
@@partibaankrishnasamy3717 thank yo
Not u comparing Mingyu to jake
Que paso con la actualización de Hui
DON'T DO JAKE LIKE THAT
They meant it in a good way ..
I cannot agree @4:34 where you stated that Matthew performed Jay Parks song better than Jay Park
you put a performance where you said 3/4 of the trainees werent good at number 4 but you put rush hour that was amazing all around at 6.. what sense does that make