Jimmy Robinson ruin is a very strong word, she still has a gorgeous voice so i wouldn’t say ruined, and considering she’s 50 years old her voice in very good shape.
I stopped using my hands so much cause I feel it can be distracting for people to watch/listen. But she makes me realize it shouldn’t matter and it kinda adds to a performance.
I love this tone down version of Hero. Mariah is singing amazingly lately. Her voice is really there and she proves she still has it. Bravo Mariah 😃👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Her voice hasn't really deteriorated at all. It's just changed with age. Check her vids of her singing some snippets of her emancipation of Mimi album and you'll know. She still has great support, flawless transitions and great tone.
yesss she hasss to react to them twitter or instagram or tik tok whatver it was vocals those were like amazing she was letting her voice loose which is something that she's normally very afraid to do so on the shows with fear of failing in front of ppl
Mariah paints music with her hands. You give her colors and you'll see the color of the Eb5, C5 and so on... and if you are a real lamb admit it, you can't help doing it either.
Loved the reaction💕Mariah is a legend. Her career/achievements are unmatchable. This woman has been in the music industry for years. And still sounds better than most singers today. It just seems like every time she does well they try to bring up assumptions and negative comments. And people wonder why she suffers with so much anxiety when performing at award shows. For example at the BBMA’s last year, she was so anxious. And at the end of the performance you could tell how disappointed she was with her performance. Because people are so critical of her vocals and have such high expectations. Where’s with this performance she was comfortable and her voice was well rested. She sounded amazing but people can’t take the fact that she’s still able to performance so well. Which shouldn’t even be questioned in first place. She truly inspired a whole generation of singers.
It's so ridiculous to me that people literally complain that at the age of 50 she doesn't sound like she did at 20. Like uhhhhhhhhhhh HELLO ITS BEEN THIRTY YEARS. Your little Ariana won't even exist in the music industry in 30 years.
Mariah never lost vocal ability, her voice just changed. That's all. This performance is evident of that. You could check out her little home videos where she was singing some of her older songs, hitting flawless and effortless Eb5's and sounding almost exactly like the studio version for more proof that Mariah is still Mariah.
I love her hand movements personally. As she herself and others have said, it’s how she conducts herself/the notes while singing. Iconic in every way. ❤️
I love Mariah during these times. Unlike other celebrities showing their mansions and flaunting their high status, Mariah gives comfort and real love to the ones affected. Egoistic maniacs like Jlow and some others better buck up.
I wanna see JLos house....👀 Just curios her design style. If you dont wanna see her house theres a simple solution for that....don’t watch...lol Shes not watching you.....
Thank you for your honest commentary!! I’m a lamb for life, but yes...she’s been in the public eye 30 yrs singing...singing is an athletic sport..whose voice wouldn’t change after that much use. She’s still Mariah and she uses what she has to the best of her abilities NOW. That being said, she truly has more confidence and assurance when she’s RESTED. She should never do any performance these days without the proper sleep and rest
Mariah sounds and looks amazing! I love when all the focus is on her talent and natural beauty like in this video. This was only done once straight through though. She sings this just as good or better in every concert. Anyway we all will have our opinions thanks for reacting and sharing this beautiful and inspirational performance
Whats so beautiful about this song is that ,she not only sang this perfectly but she wrote it too. Like being a steller singer i can understand ,but then she wrote it too😭😭😭😭.
She’s singing & using hand movements to articulate the vocal emotions melodically with rhythmic registers, riffs & long notes. She mentioned that in one of her interview back in 2007.
Definitely her voice has changed through the years but she definitely can still sing. Her voice is still one of the best up to this day. This is one of the reasons why I adore her.
Mariah's speech before she sang nade me teary-eyed. And while she sang the chills gee of her voice wow and the lyrics so emotional Amazing live. I salute all the frontliners pls be safe everyone God Bless.
Mariah is a Goddess! Her vocal ability. I mean trained by her mother. A professional opera singer. Can’t get any better than that. Love her hand movements with her vocals. I do the same as a vocal conductor.
as a real fan, I've been from the very beginning, it's like one gets to know each and every gesture of hers... I could tell you each and every video bit that doesn't correspond with the moment she sang it. other than that, lots of people focus on her being the most incredible voice ever ... I would never deny that from listening to circles or outside acapella, just one of many many expamples, despite realizing when there were cuts... but anyway, you go and do it. other people focus on just hating on her.... but apart from having being a vocal gymnast, what always has amazed me the most is her musicality. she is Einstein music/voice wise. no one touches her there, not even close.
I enjoyed the vocal performance here. And agree with a lot of comments regarding vocals/people changing with time. Also I’d like to add that I read somewhere eon twitter that Mariah’s vocals have gotten bald stronger over the last few years. All she might need currently is to strengthen her singing technique? If she does that she’ll gain even more confidence...
Nice video. I love your reactions. I think you should react to all pf her singing videos acapella on instagram of songs like fly like her bird, we belong together, your girl, stay the night. She hits crazy high belts and whistles please react
Celine Dion and Mariah Carey are the remaining true divas...... Whitney...r.i.p. Im crying while thingking that these three singers has a great historical and legendary voice...co thet are so amazing
This is my first time listening critics from a coach. I simply think you're kind and do justice to the judging if not coaching of Mariah's voice. I truly enjoyed it...greetings from Singapore....being semi lock down here
Missed seeing the "syncing up" about which you're talking. I figured Mariah was listening to a melody of Hero in her phones then recorded a number of times like you're saying. Then the piano an strings added post. Anyways, good stuff. Peace of Lord Jesus upon you and yours
I'm smiling throughout the video. Aside from honestly reacting on her singing, it really shows that you genuinely love her. 💓😍 Thanks for always making quality reaction videos! One of a kind 😘
Thank you for your channel ! Being in choir in college right now inspires me to sing everyday. Your interpretation and etc is amazing ! Thank you again ! I’m learning so much just by watching your channel
You got skills too. I'm sure you can tear up the stage with your voice. Would love to see you sing covers someday of stuff like this. Glad you approved of her performance. I'm not a pro vocal coach but I helped vocal arrange for a few singing groups around my hood in Harlem in my teens and 20s (I'm in my 30s now). There were a few things I noticed about her too: 1. She tends to rush through some of her runs and end them quick when she could have extended the note a little. 2. Her lines tend to end with a downward note and it's the same downward note every time. To a finnicky listener, it can be very noticeable and annoying. 3. She even though she has started to finally bring the key of her songs down in recent days, she tends to show she's scared to go for the higher notes in whatever scale she's singing in. Even if it's a one time performance and not a 2 hr concert. That's all. But good voice and good assessment. I can tell you're also a big fan of hers. I love all her albums from 1990-2001 immensely. Plus she grew up in New York too for the most part.
She uses the hand movements as a way of self direction. She’s mentioned this on occasion.
Dylan Roberts it actually helps with singing , I do it 😁
Noo kidding
Yea, it really helps singing. It's like you're controling your voice.
I do the same thing
Personally, It helps visualize resonance for me, if I want to throw my headvoice over my head, I need to lift my hand hhaha or do some intricate runs
Regarding the hand movements, it's as though she conducts herself through her songs. I love it 🥰
who loves mariah???
You are beautiful 😍
You're SO right about MARIAH'S hand movements! Totally making sure she hits every single note just right! You made my day Mr, thanks for the comment!
OMFG. Giorgina’s run in 4:22 is totally clear and supported. Damn
Sr. Cátalo I stan ur profile picture 💕
I was about to comment this!!! Such a good run!!!
LITERALLLLY. I WAS LIKE OMG
she’s still got it after 30 years!!! btw i’m such a big fan of you and mariah i love your reactions!
Congrats on being the first comment, I'm the 2nd! ☺
Yes she can still sing however all the high notes over the years ruined her voice unfortunately and you can hear it. Its a shame.
crazy how the vid was posted an hour ago but your comment was 20 hours ago..
@@jimmyrobinson1136 How is her voice ruined? Her highest note here (Eb5) is almost her highest consistent supported note when she first started out.
Jimmy Robinson ruin is a very strong word, she still has a gorgeous voice so i wouldn’t say ruined, and considering she’s 50 years old her voice in very good shape.
I stopped using my hands so much cause I feel it can be distracting for people to watch/listen. But she makes me realize it shouldn’t matter and it kinda adds to a performance.
I understand what you say about hand movements, but I think it just shows how into the song and music she is.
Rayne Michael same
I feel it helps
Use it if its natural for you, Whitney and the greats did it. You'll stand out and be you.
Rayne Michael I think for a performer like her that doesn’t dance .., the hands movements somehow brings you on the journey
OMG GEORGINA THAT RUN YOU DID AT 4:22!! THAT WAS MARIAH LEVEL PERFECTION!! So clean!
YAAAAAAS, she nailed it!
I was so shocked it was amazing 😳😳
I love it!!!
That was amazing!!!
Yasssss. That's why I never doubted her credibility. She's got the chops dahling.
Can we just point out how EFFORTLESS Georgina's example of the high belt AND the breathy tone too? Ya'll. Those riffs were CRISP 💕💞🙏
Nobody:
Literally nobody:
Mariah: 👋🏼✋🏼👌🏼👐🏼👋🏼🖐🏼👋🏼
She's the queen!!
Mack Carey exactly! She invented it!
GIRRRLLLLLLL!!!!!!!
When she does this 👌🏿, I know I’m about to get some fire soft breathy vocals.
I love this tone down version of Hero. Mariah is singing amazingly lately. Her voice is really there and she proves she still has it. Bravo Mariah 😃👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Her voice hasn't really deteriorated at all. It's just changed with age. Check her vids of her singing some snippets of her emancipation of Mimi album and you'll know.
She still has great support, flawless transitions and great tone.
yesss she hasss to react to them twitter or instagram or tik tok whatver it was vocals those were like amazing she was letting her voice loose which is something that she's normally very afraid to do so on the shows with fear of failing in front of ppl
It has deteriorated, don't be delusional. It doesnt mean she Lost her voice or talent
She was slaying those Eb5s yesss
Shaun Music plus those were morning clips. At night she sounds better.
Don’t be delusional Mariah isn’t.
Everyone: home quarantined
Mariah: 👌👌👌👌👌
Mariah paints music with her hands. You give her colors and you'll see the color of the Eb5, C5 and so on... and if you are a real lamb admit it, you can't help doing it either.
her voice is amazing when it getting it's rest 🥰
Loved the reaction💕Mariah is a legend. Her career/achievements are unmatchable. This woman has been in the music industry for years. And still sounds better than most singers today. It just seems like every time she does well they try to bring up assumptions and negative comments. And people wonder why she suffers with so much anxiety when performing at award shows. For example at the BBMA’s last year, she was so anxious. And at the end of the performance you could tell how disappointed she was with her performance. Because people are so critical of her vocals and have such high expectations. Where’s with this performance she was comfortable and her voice was well rested. She sounded amazing but people can’t take the fact that she’s still able to performance so well. Which shouldn’t even be questioned in first place. She truly inspired a whole generation of singers.
pk_ xo she set the bar so high that the only thing they can compare her recent vocals is from her prime
It's so ridiculous to me that people literally complain that at the age of 50 she doesn't sound like she did at 20. Like uhhhhhhhhhhh HELLO ITS BEEN THIRTY YEARS. Your little Ariana won't even exist in the music industry in 30 years.
your riff at at 4:22 was absolutely perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!
Her voices is simply beautiful. Doesn't matter what anybody says. Her voice is amazing.
Why do i get emotional every time i hear this song? This song is very special to me. God bless you queen Mariah for giving us this song🙏😭
I definitely get emotional when I listen to a lot of her songs... the Songstress Mariah :) ... I love her
I listened to this like 5 time’s today. She’s too good 🥺
Nice comment. And beautiful profile picture at the moment
Ben James You should try Jessie J’s I Have Nothing 🥳🥳🥳
Mariah never lost vocal ability, her voice just changed. That's all. This performance is evident of that. You could check out her little home videos where she was singing some of her older songs, hitting flawless and effortless Eb5's and sounding almost exactly like the studio version for more proof that Mariah is still Mariah.
this time to RELAX is really helpiing her voice...like A LOT.
Heartfelt and sincere. Full of emotions and it comes from her heart of hearts. ❤
Really great performance! She still has it after all these years!
I love her hand movements personally. As she herself and others have said, it’s how she conducts herself/the notes while singing. Iconic in every way. ❤️
Her voice just sounds so resonant and clear here. The tone is gorgeous.
I love Mariah during these times. Unlike other celebrities showing their mansions and flaunting their high status, Mariah gives comfort and real love to the ones affected. Egoistic maniacs like Jlow and some others better buck up.
Oh wow....
Jlow be lippin and using auto tune during a live charity event.
I wanna see JLos house....👀
Just curios her design style.
If you dont wanna see her house theres a simple solution for that....don’t watch...lol
Shes not watching you.....
@@tysonb3568 which one though? She changes them every 3 years.
Her hand movements will always be LEGENDARY ❤SHE IS A LEGEND😍
THE SONGBIRD SUPREME! ❤💯
Thank you for your honest commentary!! I’m a lamb for life, but yes...she’s been in the public eye 30 yrs singing...singing is an athletic sport..whose voice wouldn’t change after that much use. She’s still Mariah and she uses what she has to the best of her abilities NOW. That being said, she truly has more confidence and assurance when she’s RESTED. She should never do any performance these days without the proper sleep and rest
I have been waiting for this video!! I haven’t watched any of reactions, I have been waiting for yours. You are the truest vocal coach on RUclips!!! 💛
What a beautiful song!! Especially during these uncertain times we're living in❤i love this channel. Thank you for sharing
4:22 AMAZING 👏🏼👏🏼
This performance was totally live and I really love the changes. She is really sounding perfect!! I like your videos Georgina ❤
Mariah sounds and looks amazing! I love when all the focus is on her talent and natural beauty like in this video. This was only done once straight through though. She sings this just as good or better in every concert. Anyway we all will have our opinions thanks for reacting and sharing this beautiful and inspirational performance
Whats so beautiful about this song is that ,she not only sang this perfectly but she wrote it too. Like being a steller singer i can understand ,but then she wrote it too😭😭😭😭.
Only Mariah would use a wind machine in a home video. Iconic.
Hahahahaha.... yessss... I loved it
She’s singing & using hand movements to articulate the vocal emotions melodically with rhythmic registers, riffs & long notes. She mentioned that in one of her interview back in 2007.
Honestly when I saw this performance I cried, her voice is so ethereal and incredibly gorgeous...Mariah is my heart she really is 🥺💖💖💖
Definitely her voice has changed through the years but she definitely can still sing. Her voice is still one of the best up to this day. This is one of the reasons why I adore her.
I’m so glad you got your channel back!!!!
I loved this video from mariah. Just what we needed right now.
Mariah's speech before she sang nade me teary-eyed. And while she sang the chills gee of her voice wow and the lyrics so emotional Amazing live. I salute all the frontliners pls be safe everyone God Bless.
As soon she started her speech your eyes got all teary and bright 😢😭
Mariah is a Goddess! Her vocal ability. I mean trained by her mother. A professional opera singer. Can’t get any better than that. Love her hand movements with her vocals. I do the same as a vocal conductor.
Thank you once again for reacting to one of her performances and giving your honest opinion. Love ya Georgina! 💗
Love your reactions to the worlds greatest singer 🙏🏾❤️
WE LOVE YOU GEORGINA 💗
as a real fan, I've been from the very beginning, it's like one gets to know each and every gesture of hers...
I could tell you each and every video bit that doesn't correspond with the moment she sang it.
other than that, lots of people focus on her being the most incredible voice ever ... I would never deny that from listening to circles or outside acapella, just one of many many expamples, despite realizing when there were cuts... but anyway, you go and do it. other people focus on just hating on her.... but apart from having being a vocal gymnast, what always has amazed me the most is her musicality. she is Einstein music/voice wise. no one touches her there, not even close.
NO the voice of Mariah CARREY has changed, getting older, it is just different now, but it is sill a lovely voice...
At 5.21 the row of notes she sings are truly astounding. AMAZING !!!
okay but you did so good with singing both those parts 😍 wow great stuff!
I enjoyed the vocal performance here. And agree with a lot of comments regarding vocals/people changing with time.
Also I’d like to add that I read somewhere eon twitter that Mariah’s vocals have gotten bald stronger over the last few years. All she might need currently is to strengthen her singing technique? If she does that she’ll gain even more confidence...
Nice video. I love your reactions. I think you should react to all pf her singing videos acapella on instagram of songs like fly like her bird, we belong together, your girl, stay the night. She hits crazy high belts and whistles please react
Ryan's Channel yes please!
You're my favorite vocal coach! I always love your comments and emotional reactions about all singers, especially Mariah.
you can tell she’s had to adjust to some new vocal techniques, and I think that’s what makes her still one of the BEST singers to walk this earth
Celine Dion and Mariah Carey are the remaining true divas......
Whitney...r.i.p.
Im crying while thingking that these three singers has a great historical and legendary voice...co thet are so amazing
She sounded great. Mariah is still the Queen. She altered parts of the song just right to suit her voice of today, which is great.
I ❤️ that she cracked, shows her humanity, because her vocal ability is SUPER-HUMAN.
Your reactions is the best! We love Mariah and we love u so much for your supporting her! Kisses from Brazil 🇧🇷 💙👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Nice profile picture at the moment :)
This is such a lovely performance. Touching speech at the beginning.
Proves that she always had it ❤️ Love your reactions. Thank you for all you do!
Agreed. Vocal rest is truly a blessing and I'm glad that she is getting it.
Beautiful!! Song with soft power and maturity and still had the elements of nostalgia!!😍😍❤❤
The legend. The icon. Vocalist. Songwriter supreme. 19 number one hits. NINETEEN!!!
#BlackGirlMagic
Its the coach for me doing the ‘find love’ in breathy voice!!! What a tone and agility!!😱
Thank you for the honest feedback. I LOVE Mariah and she keep inspiring me to sing.
One & only this performance brought tears to my eyes still the best & still perfect ❤️
This is my first time listening critics from a coach. I simply think you're kind and do justice to the judging if not coaching of Mariah's voice. I truly enjoyed it...greetings from Singapore....being semi lock down here
The incomparable songbird supreme. 🌈🦋🇵🇭❣️
I'm so happy you're so updated 💜
Mariah needs her confidence from her emancipation of mimi era
Missed seeing the "syncing up" about which you're talking.
I figured Mariah was listening to a melody of Hero in her phones then recorded a number of times like you're saying. Then the piano an strings added post.
Anyways, good stuff. Peace of Lord Jesus upon you and yours
Always love when you review Mariah 😊❤️ Such a sweet and gorgeous video from her.
Stunning and heart-warming rendition! Thank you for reviewing our Mariah!
We love the reaction dahhhling, and those runs!! ❤️
It's cool, I get the feeling Mariah self directs when singing with her hands.
That's exactly what she's doing.
She proved she never lost her voice!Amazing BirdRiah!
I'm smiling throughout the video. Aside from honestly reacting on her singing, it really shows that you genuinely love her. 💓😍 Thanks for always making quality reaction videos! One of a kind 😘
When you sang "you can find girl." I shouted SING GIRL!!
But... It was "you can find love" not "girl"
She sounds clean and controlled
Georgina, love your happiness for Mariah Carey. ❤❤❤
Beautiful, love Mariah ...............love the Honest Vocal Coach too !!!
She did so well!
Thank you for your channel ! Being in choir in college right now inspires me to sing everyday. Your interpretation and etc is amazing ! Thank you again ! I’m learning so much just by watching your channel
Her hands depict what is going on in her mind visually with respect to the music she is singing. Its really neat to watch
This is the one I've been waiting for♥️👆🇵🇭
she's fabulous
Love her, tone, notes attempt, control, and her confident
her gestures reminds me of Whitney and how she used to shudder her lower jaw, I've only seen a few other artists do that
Great I seen it too one of my favorites too hugs. Do Christina Aguilera genie in a bottle or what a girl wants they are compared.
Natural and impeccable
What a lovely voice ever!
We love you Ms Carey. Thank you.
You got skills too. I'm sure you can tear up the stage with your voice. Would love to see you sing covers someday of stuff like this. Glad you approved of her performance. I'm not a pro vocal coach but I helped vocal arrange for a few singing groups around my hood in Harlem in my teens and 20s (I'm in my 30s now). There were a few things I noticed about her too:
1. She tends to rush through some of her runs and end them quick when she could have extended the note a little.
2. Her lines tend to end with a downward note and it's the same downward note every time. To a finnicky listener, it can be very noticeable and annoying.
3. She even though she has started to finally bring the key of her songs down in recent days, she tends to show she's scared to go for the higher notes in whatever scale she's singing in. Even if it's a one time performance and not a 2 hr concert.
That's all. But good voice and good assessment. I can tell you're also a big fan of hers. I love all her albums from 1990-2001 immensely. Plus she grew up in New York too for the most part.
I’m so proud of my baby 🥺10 years a fan
I’ve been waiiiiting for this reaction!!
I love it 100% this is MC at here best!
Beautiful she is always
I'm curious, do you know why she has to break down long notes now?
"And you cast your fears asi-I-I-ide" instead of "asiiidee"
is it a voice issue?
Good question.. would be good if we get a reply on this one 😊😊
Yes shes changing certain keys up because of vocal damage spot on.
They're called runs...
It's just a stylistic choice.
Hayden Rowse her choice, she wanted to do the runs =)) she always sing different versions.
Thank you for the video. Been waiting for it for almost three days now and glad you made it. Mariah 🦋 is amazing not matter what.
Love this performance. Also, this is the first video of yours that I’ve come across. YOU’RE SO LOVELY!!!! X
Georgina that run was so good!!!!! 4:22