Probably because she isn't between top 3 vocalist of the group, she also isn't very stable during live performances and her voice sound shaky at times and out of her comfort zone.
@@artemisrayne so is Yuri and sooyoung it doesn't justify them not having at least 10 seconds... An idols first job is to sing and if they can't even get 10seconds it makes them seem untalented which they're not
+priscila ramos oh I know I'm just saying like in general (kinda hard to explain what I'm saying through text lol) but what I mean if it was put in a category like the main vocalist would be (tiff, tae,Jess, Sunny, and Seo) and the rap line would be (Hyo,Yoona, Yuri, and Sooyoung ) that's kinda what I meant
I remember when everyone used to hate on Tiffany... the only reason she has so many lines here is that she got a lot of adlibs, and it's not like people like Yoona and Hyoyeon can sing her parts. Also, I'll never understand why people are so fixated on the "roles" of members, they don't matter, if a person's voice fits a part, they'll get it, regardless of rather they are a main, lead, or sub vocalist.
Good Enough! But I Would Divide TIFFANY’s “Super Sonic, Hyper Tonic” Like This: 1st One: TIFFANY 2nd One: Duet Of HyoYurSooYoon 3rd One: JESSICA With Some Harmony Of TaeSunSeo You Know, Just To Make It Fair!
TTS is a sub unit but Tiffany is not part of the main vocal line she's part of the lead vocal line... JTS are the main vocals but there's clearly some fany bias been going on for the past few years and it's like seohyun was just kicked out of the main vocals and pushed to the side. It became increasingly more and more Taeyeon and Tiffany and eventually even Jessica was left out of the main vocals
Why everyone hate Tiffany? She's really a hardworker and her voice is really good. Ok, I know if she ever say if Taeyeon's voice is like a goat and Yoona isn't pretty, but now she has changed. Something wrong with all of you?
Idk why but when i was not aware of line distribution (note that ive been listening to them since gee first came out) thingy i thought taeyon jessica and tiffany is like the main vocal so i dont understand the whole “why tiffany” thingy when jessica left until i watch their old songs’ line distribution and it hit me hard to the fact that she used to rank lower than sunny(who i thought was the least skilled vocal line), i can only conclude that tiffany really improved over time
Minion Gi totally agree!!Even tho I can be not always objective,because she is my bias,but have you seen her notes ,with all her mistakes in all the songs she ever sang?Or some moments in the studio recording?She is a freaking crazy perfectionist,she is working so hard..it makes me sad,that people don't appreciate that..
What's the freaking problem with Tiffany singing the most in this song?!?! Is she not allowed just because she's a lead and not a main singer? Geez, get over it..
they weren't ad libs, but the one where her bar was moving was she did the "goodbye" part with taeyeon though i also don't think it dragged for that long either
It counted exactly how long she sang, she finishes at the same time that Taeyeon finishes her high note, look up MR removed. And she actually has 1 more adlib at the very end of the song that wasnt counted here, she sings the "ohyeah oh oh oh" part or whatever she says so she should actually have a few seconds more. Dont be bitter
Nate Sparda i didn't say she wouldn't thats why i was replying to the comment that it probably didn't last long but its not a huge difference in terms of her lines
SNSD = Tiffany and her background dancers. I'm sure that their songs will be credited as Girls' Generation & Tiffany in the near future. Seriously, SM could be less conspicuous with the Fany bias they have going on....
She literally sings this much in this ONE SONG because they give her the English lines usually and there’s so much of it here.. (“supersonic.. and hypertonic”)
I thought Sooyoung was in a japanese group pre-debut. So I thought she is good in japanese. I always wondered why she got so less lines in SNSD's japanese songs, then.
No, Tiff is lead vocalist, always. So everyone always talk about why Tiff has more lines than main vocal is Sica. If Tiff is a main vocal, noone would complain that
She already was even with Jessica on it. She always got the most lines, and i'm pretty sure SM were shading SNSD's vocal ranking in Dancing Queen AND My Oh My. My Oh My: Jessica sings the first "my oh my", then Tiffany, then Taeyeon. We could consider that as: 3. Jessica, 2. Tiffany, 1. Taeyeon. Dancing Queen - Seohyun sings the first high note, then it's Jessica, Tiffany suddenly appers with her high note, and Taeyeon the last. So, 4. Seohyun ; 3. Jessica ; 2. Tiffany ; 1. Taeyeon ______ Now, people said that Dancing Queen is originally from 2008, and they decided to post it in 2013. I think it were supposed to be only a top 3, wich just includes Seo, Sica and Tae. But as time were passing, Tiffany improved a lot in her vocals so SM thought she would take Sica's position. Now TaeNy are the main vocals, and it feels like SM made an upgrade in Dancing Queen, putting a high note to Tiffany after Jessica. Meaning that Tiffany >>> Jessica. We can notice too that Jessica were getting less high notes as time was passing. In Paparazzi, only TaeNy gets the high notes, but what about Jessica? Wasn't she supposed to be the 2nd main vocalist? In Mr.Mr, Tiffany gets a higher note than Jessica. In Catch Me If You Can, Tiffany gets more high notes than Jessica. But, in her times she were still in SNSD, she got a pretty huge attention for her talent. We can see that 2011 were her time to shine. Sometimes i even think SM were treating her as the 1st main vocal. In the whole The Boys album, Jessica got the most attention. Have you seen her high note in Oscar? And i think in Oscar, there was also a shading, wich is: Tiffany is the first to sing, Tae after, then Jessica. May we consider that as 3. Fany, 2. Tae and 1. Jessica? And in The Boys, she sang the higher note. Plus the fact that she was in the visual line, that made her be at the center for a very long time in The Boys. And remember that she was going to be the 2nd main dancer with Hyo? Well, this is only a theory, believe if you want to.
***** Lol Tiffany had the most lines in literally ALL of their last songs. I do like Tiffany actually, she's my 4th bias, but you know, we all have to face the truth
***** Lol calm down dude, no need to be offending someone, i didn't offend you. And in my comment i never said it was "unfair" or saying that it's not good because Tiffany is getting much more lines, i was just stating a theory together with a FACT. Just accept the truth, Tiffany is getting too much lines in their songs. And people hate it mostly because of her voice, wich even Tiffany's fans may admit they don't like too. And as everyone knows, TAEYEON AND JESSICA WERE MAIN VOCALISTS, so it's freaking fair for them to get the most lines, not the way SM distribuited the lines to the whole group tbh. But it's fcking unfair to a main vocal get less lines than a lead. And it all happened when the freaking TTS came out. Everything were messed up now. The lead vocalists get more lines than a main. If Jessica wasn't a main vocalist now then just freaking change their freaking positions, make Tiffany a main now. And if it was just Tiffany, ok, but it's 2 LEAD vocalists, wtf Jessica needs some recognition as a main vocalist, they should praise her skills not hide under TTS. Lastly, i never said SM's new lines are unfair.
Everybody is saying why tiffany has a lot of lines. But if you think about it tiffanys voice suits this song better than the other members voice. It could be a reason that the person who made the song have her the most lines
wow i like the "ranking" thing at the bottom
yeah same
Why my baby Hyoyeon is always last ! She is so talented :( ❤️ Sm please give her some love
She has a dance break in 2:00
but I want Hyoyeon can get more lines too!
agree,let her explore her voice more!
Yes I love her dancing but the reason I fall for her is her voice so unique, so I want her to sing more :/
I love her voice especially her low pitch (The song 'Goodbye' suits her very well but she has only few seconds :'(
(and sorry for my bad english
Wing Ki Yeung yeah
woww tiffany and taeyeon .......
thank you ^_^
Love the ranking bar at the bottom, hope you keep it! :)
Great job Tiffany. 👏 👏💕.I seriously don't understand why people hate on you when you ranked on top 😞
Me neither, I can't understand. Tiffany's voice is beautiful and she's so charming! ♥
Probably because she isn't between top 3 vocalist of the group, she also isn't very stable during live performances and her voice sound shaky at times and out of her comfort zone.
Because she's an attention seeker.
SicaRun so she is still a talented singer may sometimes not have the best condition in her voicd but she has the best in her capacity
Falschem Namen she's a entertainer that's her job. she's not going to sing to an empty audience.
Tiffany is the Quenn !💕
Tiffany and TaeYeon - Mr Taxi ft. Other talented girls
. love tiffany always
I love Girls Generation with 9 members
ys, yuri got the most in the dance line
For me she is the best singer in the dance line 💗
+Ariadne Lydia Me too ❤
lol she always do
+Jahred Birthday Girl No,Sooyoung too^^
Yeah Yuri often gets the most lines in the dance line, I'd say about 60 % of the time. 30% Sooyoung, 15% Yoona, 5% Hyo.
Tiffany queen 😍😍😍
Hyoyeon and yoona didn't even get 10 seconds..
but they're the dance line so...
@@artemisrayne so is Yuri and sooyoung it doesn't justify them not having at least 10 seconds... An idols first job is to sing and if they can't even get 10seconds it makes them seem untalented which they're not
@@angela-dm7vo Sooyoung and Yuri are better vocalists in dance line so they get more, but I agree that YoonHyo should get more than 5 seconds 😂
I love this new theme that you're using! I especially like the ranking bar at the bottom :)
tiffany should give some to Hyoyeon and Yoona. She has too much
Well tiff is one of the main vocalist so I would assume she would get some of the most lines lol..yoona and Hyo are more of the rap line
+MrsMarie Orton The main vocalists was Taeyeon and Jessica :3 Tifanny is a lead.
+priscila ramos oh I know I'm just saying like in general (kinda hard to explain what I'm saying through text lol) but what I mean if it was put in a category like the main vocalist would be (tiff, tae,Jess, Sunny, and Seo) and the rap line would be (Hyo,Yoona, Yuri, and Sooyoung ) that's kinda what I meant
Oh! I'm sorry, I understand you now ^^
+priscila ramos no it's okay most ppl do t understand what I mean sometimes lol
I love TaeNy songs, their voices get on very well
please love TaengSic...
+권희승 I like TaengSic as well but what's the point of that comment lol
+Starlight because i like taengsic
Sic Taeng lol
TaeNy is the real thing 😀
I PICK TIFFANY SHES MY FAVOURITE
Thats my TaeNy!!!
Im sure lots of locksmiths happy about this
I'm not gonna play like it's not fair, but Tiffany's voice reaaaaaally suits this song. Hyoyeon definitely deserved more though.
OMG!!!! I LIKE THIS NEW DESIGN!!!
Tiffany my love ❤
hyoyeon, queen of 3.8 seconds
I remember when everyone used to hate on Tiffany... the only reason she has so many lines here is that she got a lot of adlibs, and it's not like people like Yoona and Hyoyeon can sing her parts. Also, I'll never understand why people are so fixated on the "roles" of members, they don't matter, if a person's voice fits a part, they'll get it, regardless of rather they are a main, lead, or sub vocalist.
if hyo couldn't sing she definitely wouldn't be releasing her soloes now
@@littleperiwinkle8742this is a stupid comment
Good Enough!
But I Would Divide TIFFANY’s “Super Sonic, Hyper Tonic” Like This:
1st One: TIFFANY
2nd One: Duet Of HyoYurSooYoon
3rd One: JESSICA With Some Harmony Of TaeSunSeo
You Know, Just To Make It Fair!
Funny some of y'all complain about a song that was released 5 years ago like honey move on, it was so long ago smh
Fany!!
1-Tiffany
2-taeyeon
3-seohyun
4-jessica
5-sunny
6-yuri
7-sooyoung
8-yoona
9-hyoyeon
TTS IS LIFE SNSD MY QUEENS
The lead singer are Taeyeon Seohyun Tiffany.so they have the small group of TTS
Fanny Swee Taeng and Jess are main vocals
You got the wrong info tho
haha, before TTS ,they had JTT( sica ,sehyun,tiff)
TTS is a sub unit but Tiffany is not part of the main vocal line she's part of the lead vocal line... JTS are the main vocals but there's clearly some fany bias been going on for the past few years and it's like seohyun was just kicked out of the main vocals and pushed to the side. It became increasingly more and more Taeyeon and Tiffany and eventually even Jessica was left out of the main vocals
@Dahyun The Queen of Extra what I meant by main vocal is that she dominated more of the vocal part I didn't mean she IS a main vocalist
why does everyone hate on tiffany?!?!
Emily Arreola this is the question i always ask tbh like damn i am not Tiffany stan but seriously
because tiffany is a horrible singer
sunny,yoona,yuri need more atention ;-;
Because it's queen 👸
Because some can’t still accept the fact that Tiffany is a great singer.
We hate SM not Tiffany
Wow,I never thought Tiffany was first,my bias slaysss
If you’re mad your fav doesn’t have the most lines, then say they should have more lines. Don’t bring down the other girls. Not their faults.
Why everyone hate Tiffany? She's really a hardworker and her voice is really good. Ok, I know if she ever say if Taeyeon's voice is like a goat and Yoona isn't pretty, but now she has changed. Something wrong with all of you?
Didn’t know that Tiffany sang the most yay
Justice for yoona and hyoyeon please....
Tiffany deserved many lines, shut up "sones".
I don't know why but taeyeon always got the best part of the song. i love taengoo
i Like tiff has many lines
Wow this is pretty cool! Thanks for making it!!!
TTJ:Taeyeon,Tiffany and Jessica💜💙💖
Tiffany is my love 😍
Sunny and Sooyoung is my favourite love you from india
.°.I LOVE YOU! •°. Jessica jung* (@.@)
LOVE this new layout and ranking system.
Good job it's totally correct, I also like that ranking thing
SM favorite ranking
1.Taeyeon
2.Tiffany
3.Jessica
4.Seohyun
5.Sunny
6.Yuri
7.Yoona
8.Hyoyeon
9.Sooyoung
like the new design ! and the ranking at the bottom ! nice!
Ok wait around 2:28 there was a big increase due to barely heard ad-libs. Why is everyone complaining a majority of tiffany's lines were ad-libs.
Mv of tiffany name mr taxi (feat.taeyeon and seohyun)
I knew there was a reason I didn't love this song as much as I do some others!
hyoyeon voice verry good and unique, in snsd member voice different are jessica and hyoyeon, other member same voice.
no offence to FANy's(see what I did there😉) but the rest has a good voice too they should be distributed "equally"
At 1:25 , what I hear is "I'm so short" not "I'm so sure" XD
I love this song
Tiffany❤👑
OK I am new to gg who's Jessica. I saw an episode in weekly idol with gg and I didn't saw Jessica
Jessica leaved the group in 2014
Jessica didn't leave, she was kicked out...
she was planning to leave after lion heart anyway
***** i thought the official statement mentioned her plans to leave after the next Album (cmiyc was a single), but maybe you're right.
Damn Tiffany got a lot of lines
Jessica love you ♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️🌹
Idk why but when i was not aware of line distribution (note that ive been listening to them since gee first came out) thingy i thought taeyon jessica and tiffany is like the main vocal so i dont understand the whole “why tiffany” thingy when jessica left until i watch their old songs’ line distribution and it hit me hard to the fact that she used to rank lower than sunny(who i thought was the least skilled vocal line), i can only conclude that tiffany really improved over time
TaeNy
Why are you hating Tiffany... She's working so fucking hard and you didn't appreciate it
Minion Gi totally agree!!Even tho I can be not always objective,because she is my bias,but have you seen her notes ,with all her mistakes in all the songs she ever sang?Or some moments in the studio recording?She is a freaking crazy perfectionist,she is working so hard..it makes me sad,that people don't appreciate that..
Minion Gi Most people are trying to say that she isnt even a lead vocalist but she got the most lines
Clarisse Anne Cyla Lagera Cerilla Well,she is
anna ci I mean that time. She is not a lead vocalist back then but she got most lines than Jessica
complete.bliss Im so sorry I mean MAIN vocalist.
Hyoyeon just breaths
What's the freaking problem with Tiffany singing the most in this song?!?! Is she not allowed just because she's a lead and not a main singer? Geez, get over it..
then where are the songs where seo and sunny both lead got moreparts than the main
Hyoyeon is d best... Luv u... 😘😘😘
poor yoona and hyoyeon
Damn! Tiff's line.
What? I'm pretty sure Tiffany is not really doing some of these adlibs she was counted for.
they weren't ad libs, but the one where her bar was moving was she did the "goodbye" part with taeyeon
though i also don't think it dragged for that long either
+igot7-lu it would not make a big difference anyway lol she would still be first
It counted exactly how long she sang, she finishes at the same time that Taeyeon finishes her high note, look up MR removed. And she actually has 1 more adlib at the very end of the song that wasnt counted here, she sings the "ohyeah oh oh oh" part or whatever she says so she should actually have a few seconds more. Dont be bitter
Nate Sparda i didn't say she wouldn't
thats why i was replying to the comment that it probably didn't last long but its not a huge difference in terms of her lines
her goodbe was dragged for a long period. U can hear in background.
TTS slayed here
Just wondering how long does it usually take you to make these it seems complicated and what not
Fyi tiffany has adlib on last part too
SNSD = Tiffany and her background dancers. I'm sure that their songs will be credited as Girls' Generation & Tiffany in the near future. Seriously, SM could be less conspicuous with the Fany bias they have going on....
laracroftvideos really, based on 1 song? -_-"
laracroftvideos go check Lion Heart line distribution
She literally sings this much in this ONE SONG because they give her the English lines usually and there’s so much of it here.. (“supersonic.. and hypertonic”)
Yoona Aji
LINE DISTRIBUTION (Without Yoona and Yuri)
1. Tiffany 41.6 *22.7%*
2. Taeyeon 36.0 *19.7%*
3. Seohyun 33.1 (+7.6) *18.1*
4. Sooyoung 27.8 (+ 15.8) *15.2%*
5. Jessica 19.9 *10.9%*
6. Sunny 19.0 *10.4%*
7. Hyoyeon 5.8 *3.2%*
Yoona , jessica❤
Yaaa ... you forget taeyeon high note & supestar hypertonic
Instead Of TaeFany Sharing That High Note, TaeSica Could Have Done It!
Fair Yet, Or What!?
Please Give Yoona More Lines.......
Tiffany and Jessica are supoer names my favourite girls of this group is a Tiffany Jessica Taeyeon Sooyoung and YoonA
Mr. Taxi by Tiffany and Taeyeon ft. SNSD.
can u make sunny girls taxi line distribution ?
too bad all of Jessica's lines except one went to Taeyeon
Queen FFANY ~☆☆☆☆☆
What is the name of the program
I thought Sooyoung was in a japanese group pre-debut. So I thought she is good in japanese. I always wondered why she got so less lines in SNSD's japanese songs, then.
i realy love girls generation
Sica😍
Hyoyeon :(
believe me, if Jessica didn't out the group, Tiffany would never become a main vocalist.
She's always one of the main vocalist, what the hell is wrong with you?
No, Tiff is lead vocalist, always. So everyone always talk about why Tiff has more lines than main vocal is Sica. If Tiff is a main vocal, noone would complain that
She already was even with Jessica on it. She always got the most lines, and i'm pretty sure SM were shading SNSD's vocal ranking in Dancing Queen AND My Oh My. My Oh My: Jessica sings the first "my oh my", then Tiffany, then Taeyeon. We could consider that as: 3. Jessica, 2. Tiffany, 1. Taeyeon. Dancing Queen - Seohyun sings the first high note, then it's Jessica, Tiffany suddenly appers with her high note, and Taeyeon the last. So, 4. Seohyun ; 3. Jessica ; 2. Tiffany ; 1. Taeyeon ______ Now, people said that Dancing Queen is originally from 2008, and they decided to post it in 2013. I think it were supposed to be only a top 3, wich just includes Seo, Sica and Tae. But as time were passing, Tiffany improved a lot in her vocals so SM thought she would take Sica's position. Now TaeNy are the main vocals, and it feels like SM made an upgrade in Dancing Queen, putting a high note to Tiffany after Jessica. Meaning that Tiffany >>> Jessica. We can notice too that Jessica were getting less high notes as time was passing. In Paparazzi, only TaeNy gets the high notes, but what about Jessica? Wasn't she supposed to be the 2nd main vocalist? In Mr.Mr, Tiffany gets a higher note than Jessica. In Catch Me If You Can, Tiffany gets more high notes than Jessica. But, in her times she were still in SNSD, she got a pretty huge attention for her talent. We can see that 2011 were her time to shine. Sometimes i even think SM were treating her as the 1st main vocal. In the whole The Boys album, Jessica got the most attention. Have you seen her high note in Oscar? And i think in Oscar, there was also a shading, wich is: Tiffany is the first to sing, Tae after, then Jessica. May we consider that as 3. Fany, 2. Tae and 1. Jessica? And in The Boys, she sang the higher note. Plus the fact that she was in the visual line, that made her be at the center for a very long time in The Boys. And remember that she was going to be the 2nd main dancer with Hyo? Well, this is only a theory, believe if you want to.
***** Lol Tiffany had the most lines in literally ALL of their last songs. I do like Tiffany actually, she's my 4th bias, but you know, we all have to face the truth
***** Lol calm down dude, no need to be offending someone, i didn't offend you. And in my comment i never said it was "unfair" or saying that it's not good because Tiffany is getting much more lines, i was just stating a theory together with a FACT. Just accept the truth, Tiffany is getting too much lines in their songs. And people hate it mostly because of her voice, wich even Tiffany's fans may admit they don't like too. And as everyone knows, TAEYEON AND JESSICA WERE MAIN VOCALISTS, so it's freaking fair for them to get the most lines, not the way SM distribuited the lines to the whole group tbh. But it's fcking unfair to a main vocal get less lines than a lead. And it all happened when the freaking TTS came out. Everything were messed up now. The lead vocalists get more lines than a main. If Jessica wasn't a main vocalist now then just freaking change their freaking positions, make Tiffany a main now. And if it was just Tiffany, ok, but it's 2 LEAD vocalists, wtf Jessica needs some recognition as a main vocalist, they should praise her skills not hide under TTS. Lastly, i never said SM's new lines are unfair.
Everybody is saying why tiffany has a lot of lines. But if you think about it tiffanys voice suits this song better than the other members voice. It could be a reason that the person who made the song have her the most lines
Im glad Yuri has more than 17 seconds. Sm has always been unfair with the dance line.
how can you make this with two part separate up and down? sorry for my bad english
i mean the video
One of the most unfair line distributions that f(x) is more fair than in any group for my opinion!
Sorry for my bad English and grammar!
Fany queen✌
girls generation Beaty ranking 2016 Part1/2 color coded
dont hate tiffany becuase she deserve that line because she was getting worst line in their before comeback
You forgot some Taeyeon's adlibs
Hyoyeon and Yoona are singers too 😐
I wonder why Jessica isn't second in having the mosi lines considering sings like this would fit her voice🤔
taeyeon at part
2:49
2:53
Why no one talking about Hyoyeon?
SM should have made a sub unit with Jessica & TTS, everyone would have loved that !