Это видео недоступно.
Сожалеем об этом.
Marc Lamont Hill, Educator William Reusch Debate Critical Race Theory
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 6 фев 2022
- Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers vetoed a bill proposing to ban the teaching of critical race theory concepts in schools.
Assembly Bill 411 would have forced the schools to change how educators discuss race, discrimination, and other classroom injustices.
Evers said the proposal that passed the state Senate 20-13 was a form of censorship, restricting schools from teaching quote, “Honest, complete facts about important historical topics like the Civil War and civil rights.”
High school social studies teacher William Reusch joins Marc Lamont Hill on “Black News Tonight” to share his take on critical race theory.
All this and more on “Black News Tonight.”
To watch BNC programming, visit bnc.tv/how-to-...
Follow BNC on social media:
Facebook: / bncnews
Twitter: / bncnews
Instagram: www.instagram....
#CriticalRaceTheory #Wisconsin #MarcLamontHill
Marc is the best at debating CRT, I really enjoyed this conversation and hearing a calm, reasonable explanation from the teacher with a conservative bent. I hope he learned something new!
perhaps conservative on THIS issue, but very heterodox in general. Thank you, I would love to dive deeper
@@WillReusch What makes you think he's not conservative "in general"?
You're blacker than 3 AM, aren't you?
Chris rufo schooled him.
@@marohan this guy did too..
Marc is doing great work on this subject...
He is- and is using his platform in a great way
Gee, I wonder if you two are black...lmfao
@@PipByMac
Don't laugh, I am "black", but they may or may not be, but I also know Marc, and anyone who think like Marc is a baffoon, "black" or "white"!!!
Btw, your reply is r@cist, showing truly, just what you are, and is a testament to the ignorance across the board...
Good day Robby.
@@WillReusch
No, that would be the opposite "sir", wake up!
Marc is a paid puppet sent to deceive the simple...
#ThatWouldBeYouAndDarius
@@MrWhiskeycricket
exactly, just f'n weird
Diversity in blackness politically absolutely I agree needs to be discussed because we are not a monolithic.
Willam didn’t come off as a rude man, but he very much seemed like a non-black man who is afraid to discuss race out of fear of feeling uncomfortable.
Perfect way to shut the opposition even if they make valid points. Just because someone is white their points on crt are not valid. Woke marxist insanity
I didn't get that from him at all. He seems to be in favor of more balance.
@@sigmanocopyrightmusic8737 I thought you guys were against the victim hood mentality. 🤔
@@awardtour93 He is a teacher, so if he wants balance in the curriculum, he has all the right in the world to introduce it. Plus, I feel he is being a tad bit disingenuous. Most black figures prior to the 1960s were mostly Republicans, and the last I checked, Booker T. Washington seemed pretty conservative. If guys like Larry Elder and Thomas Sowell want to be mentioned in history, then maybe the should stop trying to appeal to the F🦊X News crowd, and maybe truly advocate for what black Americans say they want.
@@MrMetro-mt5qv you seem to misunderstand what he's getting at.
Anytime Lil Billy or Tyronne/ lil Beth or Keisha can distinguish a difference between where the people who don't look exactly like them largely lives, the environment differences & conditions there-in & poses the question: Why?...it should not be answered based on the comfortability of an apprehensive teacher or any uninformed adult. They deserve a comprehensive reply (rooted in both truth & history) by an educator willing to break-down the 'why' appropriate to both a classroom audience & an individual's capacity to learn. The main tool in use for this is...*drumroll*....Teacher/Educator Professional Development.
well.... not in Florida. better not make them feel bad. otherwise you're in violation of the law
Facts.
A good teacher won't make them feel bad
This!!!!
The frustrating and irritating part about all this rhetoric, is that Black people have to live with these realities directly and our experiences, history and real things that happened to our ancestors are swept under the rug, minimized, ignored or told by using safe and untrue language
Does this CRT ban hoopla mean we will no longer be able to recite the Star Spangled Banner in schools because it talks about fighting enslaved people in the third verse and the writer wrote that blacks were inferior in other works??? This is definitely separating us. Be careful what you wish for.
🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️
Not much of a debate here.. Mark clearly articulated his point.. Ummm what happened to the opposition viewpoint for a debate???
He seemed super unprepared to actually make a statement. He just took sips of water and rambled. Marc tried so hard to get him to get to his point, any point.
@@nigeldavis9704 I was not told this would be labeled a "debate". I don't want to "Win"... I want to expose nuance and find a good solution. That takes time and details. Highlighting myopic ideological boogiemen is not my thing, I'm sorry. I did make very valid points, they just weren't "dunks"
Nah, you didn't
Will always offers a very balanced (and often unpopular) view to conversations, and I’m so glad he was invited here!
Thank you so much! Truly.
Hold up. If we can point to the data of outcome and see major discrimination in educatiom finance healthcare & socialism. Then what is the argument about educationing kids on there group and how it benefits them or doesnt the idea is to make change or we just continue? Based om the data... what?!!? 🤔
I would respect it if they were honest
To be honest, I feel like I'm more confused after listening. I know it's a difficult topic but you guys are both educators and very articulate and still struggle with what should or can be accepted by most.
I enjoyed it though.
It is too nuanced for a short segment like this
This guy says that it’s a trend that kids are being taught to look at them selves as I’m groups as if this hasn’t always been the case! The things people say that America isn’t is bullshit it is exactly what America is‼️
This teacher should just sit up and not readjust himself every time he speaks
Bizarro world
It's funny how ppl call these setups news shows yet they are just debates.
I heavily respect both of these men
I disagree with Marc. Education should absolutely be neutral, that's the issue. And no it doesn't mean denying history or blackness. Things should be taught sensitively and wisely not in some simplistic trendy narrative.
Education CAN'T be neutral, that's impossible. It's impossible because America is a racist country. White supremacy and extremism is on the rise and students need to be taught that so they can navigate race and its effects in this country. Students of ALL colors need to be taught that America is not yet equal and we need to continue to fight to make it equal.
@@MPR2 I see what you're saying, thanks for the input. I just don't see both things are mutually exclusive.
What I think is really going on is that the rise of these white extremists and sentiments or generally conservatives coincides with the rise of the "progressive" left. Both sides basically feed on each other. Hateful racists will always be there, but the majority of them will possibly die out eventually. It just can't happen overnight. And when the you talk about racism that much and see it everywhere it becomes your reality, even though things are probably not as bad as they seem to be. (I'm sure in regular life you meet enough people that are good, whatever color)
So the left by being so forceful and lot of times stupid and extreme IMO makes the conservatives even more defensive. And therefore the public discourse has become too hyped up and hysterical and you've become stuck. The US needs to find a common ground and common sense in all this, otherwise you won't move forward. Both sides need to get more reasonable and own their mistakes.
@@ITold-YouSo I'm disappointed to see you "Both Sides" this, the left is not extreme nor hateful nor overtly racist like the right, there's NO comparison between the two. The right wants to take away our freedoms and rights, the left wants to give us healthcare and higher wages. Please don't try to be neutral, that would be immoral. Open your eyes, WAKE up to reality, admit the truth.
Morales, values, these people clearly don’t understand this language. Sad. Inhumane
bingo, Marc is a baffoon!!!
wow
Lamont is such an intellectually dishonest person..basically a bad faith actor that hopes his audience isn't looking too carefully.
This is false
Wow, no wonder USA is not at the top for education. He is a teacher? Holy crap, we are in trouble. He cannot even articulate his point.
Let’s have a public conversation… email me
Critical Race Theory👻 (in 1975 Europe I was taught it's basics, age 13, partly literally & partly by connecting the obvious lecture/topical dots in my mind, but in most west-Europe junior/-high schools it is merely a minor factoid in 'post-16th century world history' - it's 1 reason why many Europeans are currently looking at horror at the 'sudden' shift to identity-supremacism in the US). Q: Why are a slight-majority of US whites so afraid of factual contextual US history coupled race discussions?
Answer (in descending order of behavioral-sublimation magnitude): (a) the US culture-wide suppressed collective-and-personal-unconscious taboo-avoiding class-struggle/classism (a.k.a. fear of an empowered working-class, or even worse: fear of an overseer-class, a.k.a. middle/lower-management-class, co-siding/co-struggling with an empowered working-class against the elite-ruling-class, and then on to the more 'conscious' American-wide culture...
(b): starting with descriptive titles and the American-wide denial or suppression of contexts, paradox, and complexity in almost any degree: 'critical thinking' (a.k.a. 'scientific' or 'logical' or 'analytical' or 'holistic' thinking) is considered by a slight-majority of US whites as the biased-ignorant wet dreams of elite ivory-tower white-socialist/foreign-socialist (even Jew-socialist or Papal-socialist, for white supremacists) and radical law-skirting ghetto-escaped black activists susceptible to 'un-American influences' (i.e. foreign and/or not-of-European-descent influences), so any 'theory' coupled with the word 'critical' is considered an attack on 'American values' (code for 'white-American' values) (even the word 'theory' in many US white's minds is akin to 'lie' cos in their minds 'theory' is not 'fact' therefore = 'lie', note: half of Republicans think dinosaurs and humans existed side-by-side, they also think the US higher-education system in rightwing-run school-districts is the best in the world by far and would be better if kids were taught less about life and indoctrinated more about how great of-European-descent-American-culture-&-economic-system is), so...
(c): Actual 'critical race theory' is a no-brainer to many white people (critical thinkers) outside the US (I was taught the general summarized-paragraph concept as a 13 year old in 1975 Europe without realizing it!) and is largely about how the white financial/power elite are puppeteers for the majority white non-elite as well as non-whites and blacks in particular, and how white elites use white-'servants' to keep non-whites and non-elites alike in their subordinate place, and how historically that happened and how it permeates the society today and always into the future unless enlightenment (critical race theory) becomes the norm:
RUclips-search: Critical race theorist Derrick Bell on racism (29 min, from 2017)
Founder of contemporary critical race theory. Note: all the main points of 'critical race theory' are nothing new, and haven't been 'new' for over a century!
+
RUclips-search: Critical Race Lecture Series presents Jodi A. Byrd (1:50 hrs)
Law School Lecture (2017):
start video at 4:20 minutes.
Don't worry God going toand punish
CRT will never be taught in America. Understand that!!
Marc here are some objectively divisive pedgogies that are characteristic of CRT and are being taught in schools 1) Associating all inequality in the west today with a race or a concept of race like "whiteness" Inequality exists and will always exist in every culture despite the communist utopia envisioned by Marx or racial justice envisioned by CRT identity communisits 2) Claiming and teaching there is something structurally racist simply because of outcomes without any evidence or little evidence of discrimination. The 15 year average age difference alone can explain most of the inequality between blacks and whites we see today 3) Looking at the color of a persons skin then inferring negative predispositions onto the individual An example is that person is inherently superior because of their white privledge. 4) Treating people as groups often based on one superficial characteristic like race with one designated as superior and one inferior or oppressor oppressed 5) Claiming that the past inequality caused by clear racism is evidence that the present system is racist even though the present explicitly through laws and social norms makes discrimination illegal and immoral. CRT has become a conspiracy theory to explain inequality of outcome.
Black underachievement today can not be traced back to slavery 150 years ago.
Fatherless homes is a bigger factor, for one. Massive drug use is another.
Drug use is not a big issue, the fatherless homes are just as prevalent in the white population. It absolutely can be traced back to slavery as slavery led to Jim crow which led to policies and practices that became ingrained in every institution in this country that disadvantage blacks and minorities.
Everything that deals with the plight of Black People in America can be directly traced back to slavery...😑 TF are you talking about?!?!? The first fathers to leave their children in the dust were white slave owners... Please study and actually learn the true Amerikkkan His-story.
@@machsimillian14 that’s not true. The single motherhood rate was from 20-30% in the 1960’s. It’s a lie that slavery caused that situation, because logically if a slave was freed he would probably want to reunite with his family.
@@machsimillian14
Drug use is a huge issue.
Have you met the kids from "problematic" families?!
People are saying that "12yo are just kids & cannot consent."....
Dude I've seen those kids who by age 12 behave like 30-40yo inmates.
Not a joke.
They all drink & do drugs & sex & ....
They will manipulate & extort you, and sexualy abuse you at a gun point.
That's why I admire Erin Pizzey.
She opened the 1st Women's Shelter.
And she said that Women are as violent as Men.
And it's all intergenerational.
*
An example everyone knows is Mike Tyson.
By age 13 he was beatting up semi-professional adults.
They had to lie that he is 18-21.
Even he is short (5'10").
I had a guy in my team who was 6'2" wrestler when we were 13-14yo.
He would knock out adults by hitting them on top of the head.
@@bestdjaf7499 your anecdotal issues aren't representative of the whole. Drug use is not a huge problem within the African American community. There are the small pockets of people who use drugs, just like there is the small pocket of people who commit crimes. Looking at the .01% of the population to categorize the entire group is ridiculous.