CITY OF ASHES BY CASSANDRA CLARE

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 фев 2025

Комментарии • 323

  • @mtsktowa
    @mtsktowa 9 лет назад +337

    I really love the part when Alec is about to confess to his parents. It's hilarious!

    • @emmacarstairs4622
      @emmacarstairs4622 9 лет назад +18

      That was the best part in the book!😂😂

    • @mysteriousmusician4334
      @mysteriousmusician4334 9 лет назад +4

      Oh yeah!!!

    • @lo4950
      @lo4950 9 лет назад +19

      same 😂😂 or when Magnus and Alec where in the car and Alec was like, " take my hands, and my strength too. whatever of it you can use to-to keep yourself going."

    • @mtsktowa
      @mtsktowa 9 лет назад +6

      MALEC scenes 💕

    • @elig.velasco3594
      @elig.velasco3594 8 лет назад +21

      I was like "Oh dang, it's about to go down!" Then Magnus sort of knocked him out I was like 😐....😂😂😂

  • @EllaIngram
    @EllaIngram 8 лет назад +63

    Also, I think Simon and Clary got together because Clary was trying to stop herself loving Jace as she believed they were brother and sister. So she got together with Simon, hoping that she would develop feelings for him and forget her feelings for Jace. Which didn't work out, obviously, as she still loved Jace and only liked Simon as a friend.

  • @EllaIngram
    @EllaIngram 8 лет назад +50

    I don't think the faeries are perverted, necessarily. The Seelie Queen is just cruel and likes to taunt them. Also, when she said they were blood related, she didn't mean they were brother and sister. She meant they were blood related because they were both descended from the Angel Raziel and they both have angel blood in their veins.

  • @vincentvanstop
    @vincentvanstop 10 лет назад +147

    Clary is such a frustrating character. I just want to be her friend so I can tell her how frustrating she is.

  • @krazeovau
    @krazeovau 10 лет назад +96

    Throughout the whole book, Clary and Jace were literally looking at each other and it felt like eyef*king. They are supposed to be siblings but uh.....

  • @mb-sb5ever
    @mb-sb5ever 5 лет назад +17

    "What happened to you"
    "I took a walk"
    "Did you run into some vamps"
    "No I fell"
    "On your neck?"
    Anyone else like this part

  • @paulineliu8286
    @paulineliu8286 10 лет назад +104

    When she went to tell Jace that she loved him and he was like: "I'll be your brother from now on" I was like NO NO NO NO YOU STUPID WHY DOES THIS ALWAYS HAPPEN JUST GET TOGETHER JESUS WHO CARES ABOUT THE RIGHT THING and then the book ended and I was miserable until I got City of Glass (which was like 3 days later, but still)

    • @mothshroooms
      @mothshroooms 7 лет назад +2

      Pauline Liu
      Who cares if their siblings and it's incest and literally disgusting, right?
      (I've read the whole series, so I know what happens.)

    • @beberoro1
      @beberoro1 7 лет назад +1

      LMAO SAME

    • @booklover7931
      @booklover7931 5 лет назад +5

      Omg me too . Like who cares if you’re sibling I bet deep down they know at least a little there is a potential there not siblings . They should have done a dna test

    • @mb-sb5ever
      @mb-sb5ever 5 лет назад +1

      @@booklover7931 thank you so far you are the only one I've seen who has mentioned that they should have done a DNA test so thank-you

    • @samanthajester3312
      @samanthajester3312 4 года назад +3

      Ikr all I wanted was for them to be together. I was like," who cares you're siblings, run away and live happily ever after"

  • @keelykirkpatrick3620
    @keelykirkpatrick3620 9 лет назад +74

    am I the only one who likes Clary? Think about all that she has gone through. She is an extremely strong character. I didnt mind Tessa, she wasn't my favirote because she never acted, she always waited for someone else to do something. She did have moments but Clary was so confident and awesome. Her relationship with Jace is amazing because in big ways their relationship is strange but you really feel for the characters.
    I love the mortal instruments and it is just my opinion

    • @annabelle_620
      @annabelle_620 7 лет назад +1

      Keely Kirkpatrick No I love her character and her development throughout the series

    • @tina0724
      @tina0724 7 лет назад +1

      Keely Kirkpatrick same

    • @janetratliff7578
      @janetratliff7578 7 лет назад +1

      I love her too

    • @anindobagchi3408
      @anindobagchi3408 5 лет назад

      MK Vlogs finally someone really gets me

  • @joysreedey
    @joysreedey 8 лет назад +198

    The Clary and the Simon relationship made me cringe. 😣

    • @janetratliff7578
      @janetratliff7578 7 лет назад +1

      Brin_ 184 same

    • @glory1015
      @glory1015 6 лет назад +5

      Yes it was very forced like she finds out that her and jace are related and then her and Simon are together...

    • @emysayer4796
      @emysayer4796 5 лет назад

      Ooh. I kinda disagree, I liked it but I prefer Magnus and Calgary

    • @johnlewis9844
      @johnlewis9844 4 года назад +2

      Tbf, relationships at that age are so cringe

  • @candymoneer1680
    @candymoneer1680 4 года назад +6

    I'm so proud of Simon for just saying 'no, I want to be appreciated and loved the way I appreciate and love you and clearly that's something you can't do so we're just gonna have to be friends.' SO PROUD OF OUR LIL CINNAMON ROLL! Because we never see the 'other guy' find the courage to leave (in books with the love triangle trope) because he really does deserve better. #welovesimon

  • @kathrynmar7692
    @kathrynmar7692 10 лет назад +42

    Yay another TMI fan!!
    Shadowhunters unite!!

  • @miraculus4204
    @miraculus4204 8 лет назад +25

    imogen was like a second umbridge through almost the whole book

    • @summerfontana_fan2570
      @summerfontana_fan2570 4 года назад

      OH MY GOSH THIS IS SO TRUE HAHA

    • @meghnagoel6766
      @meghnagoel6766 3 года назад +1

      No way, she was more like Snape in my opinion at least.
      Umbridge was so much worse.

  • @mysteriousmusician4334
    @mysteriousmusician4334 9 лет назад +24

    I knew that this stuff is epic and so I bought all 6 at once!

  • @ShivalikaKeni
    @ShivalikaKeni 9 лет назад +65

    To be honest, even though the Jace-Clary situation was super ew, I'm glad Cassandra Clare kept it in the book because it added so much more realism; like yeah, they're siblings stop fantasizing about each other but I guess feelings, especially when you're in love with someone, are hard to get rid of. But what frustrated me was that while Clary was in love with Jace, she was making out with Simon, like as a distraction, and I was like you don't play with someone's feelings like that! -_-

    • @andrealewis2501
      @andrealewis2501 6 лет назад +6

      Just because it was wrong doesn't mean people don't do it, she did it because she WANTED to feel for Simon the way she felt with Jace.

  • @elvanmelikesutlu2611
    @elvanmelikesutlu2611 5 лет назад +2

    That the inquisitor died made me really sad, althought she was a horrible person, but her past affect her bad acting and at the end her open heart get showed❤️😢

  • @ebonycostantini4514
    @ebonycostantini4514 9 лет назад +12

    I think she went for Simon because she knew Jace was her brother and she can't go there so she move her feeling onto Simon thinking she would forget about jace, but overall it was amazing book !

  • @gemmawatkins2984
    @gemmawatkins2984 10 лет назад +14

    You need to read The Infernal Devices before City of Heavenly Fire! I know, three more books and a different series, but you'll appreciate COHF so much more if you do and it'll make more sense and be more clever :)

    • @gemmawatkins2984
      @gemmawatkins2984 10 лет назад +4

      Also, in reference to City of Ashes, Simon's relationship with Clary also annoyed me so much. It felt so forced and the Seelie Court scene... creepy, and I knew the same thing as you! But still, uber uncomfortable.
      I loved that Simon turned though! I was in shock after reading that! He was a really clingy, whiny and annoying character to start with. He's one of my favourites now. He goes through one hell of a journey and grows a lot.

  • @JulEnglefaris
    @JulEnglefaris 10 лет назад +2

    City of Ashes was one of my favorites. So much happens action wise and relationships wise, across the board.

  • @BrunetteBibliophile
    @BrunetteBibliophile 10 лет назад +5

    Maryse is, believe it or not, my favorite character! She is such a strong character and is just a boss. I noticed a lot of points you brought up and I kept thinking 'wait until you read the 3rd & 4th book'

  • @lilyortiz6993
    @lilyortiz6993 10 лет назад +2

    YAY! You finally read it! This is one of MY FAVORITE Series! Please keep reading on and doing Book Reviews!

  • @moondancer295
    @moondancer295 10 лет назад +1

    I think that I read somewhere within the books, maybe it was Luke, that Mayrse's name is pronounced May-Ris or may-erse. :)

  • @suyareads
    @suyareads 10 лет назад

    i'm so happy that you are reading tmi! i feel like most people take this series for granted and don't teally appreciate how good it is.

  • @maggielastname3039
    @maggielastname3039 10 лет назад +3

    So excited that you're reading TMI! Can't wait until you move into the infernal devices :D

  • @violetcupcakes
    @violetcupcakes 10 лет назад

    FREAKING LOVE YOU AND THE MORTAL INSTRUMENTS JESSE

  • @SnigdhaKucharlapati
    @SnigdhaKucharlapati 9 лет назад +31

    I wanted to see who Jace was casted as in the TV series and searched Google for Jace Wayland halfway through the first book and it showed "Jace Herondale" and I practically threw my phone on the floor

  • @enzodapan5016
    @enzodapan5016 6 лет назад +1

    What about some appearances of Magnus?

  • @EmmaBagnall07
    @EmmaBagnall07 10 лет назад +8

    You described the awkwardness between Clary and Simon perfectly. I hated their relationship.

  • @ilsenleon2378
    @ilsenleon2378 7 лет назад +3

    This video is so old but I'm just starting to get into the Mortal Instruments. I know I'm late to the party. City of Ashes wasn't my favorite because they were making me ship incest (I also got spoiled). I didn't like Simon and Clary together. I also thought there was very little Isabelle in this book. But I did love all the action in this book but the freaking Inquisitor annoyed me. I am now on City of Glass and really enjoying it

  • @KATProductionsBooks
    @KATProductionsBooks 10 лет назад

    IM SO HAPPY YOURE READING THIS SERIES!!!! It makes my day :)

  • @TheLovelyBooks
    @TheLovelyBooks 10 лет назад

    The books get sooo good as you keep reading the series. I read this exactly a year ago and I loved seeing you review it because I agree with you on a lot of things. And yeah lack of Isabelle in CoA.
    I think you'll like the infernal devices, by the way!

  • @smhtxffmsp3478
    @smhtxffmsp3478 8 лет назад +15

    Haha instead of buying the book when its released i waited until all the books were released and i bought them all at once so when i was done one book i could get to the other book ^-^

  • @nanyprincesa
    @nanyprincesa 10 лет назад +23

    I really hated Clary and Simon's relationship in this book, and with Jace is the same...
    A quick question, have you read TID? I need to know what you think of those books!

  • @andreasaldana4720
    @andreasaldana4720 9 лет назад +10

    I've noticed he always wears a black shirt when he does a TMI book talk😂😂

  • @angel_lina02
    @angel_lina02 8 лет назад +2

    Jesse I don't know if this is on your copy of the book but on mine it goes from page 242 to page 275 it skipped liked 30 pages? Is this on your copy of the book?

  • @user-fl3zq1fd9b
    @user-fl3zq1fd9b 10 лет назад

    Can't wait for the next review! What Shadowhunter Chronicles book are you on now?

  • @amyherondale1052
    @amyherondale1052 10 лет назад

    I love this book! This series gets better and better with each book!

  • @heatherp.6906
    @heatherp.6906 10 лет назад

    Yeah!!!! I can't wait for you to finish this series Jesse!

  • @leannb2513
    @leannb2513 10 лет назад

    great discussion! i'm watching a bunch of booktalks about TMI because I forgot a ton of stuff and I don't have time to reread the series before starting CoHF.

  • @Cara.Plummer
    @Cara.Plummer 10 лет назад

    You're bringing back my early tmi feels!

  • @saiyuriinuzuka6400
    @saiyuriinuzuka6400 6 лет назад

    I have been obsessed with this series since I discovered it. I LOVE this book, and I knew in my heart they should be together. This book had me yelling, cursing, banging on my knee/table, etc. So great! And I'm on the 4Th book starting today. :)

  • @RaRyBeAr183
    @RaRyBeAr183 10 лет назад

    I haven't read the infernal devices yet but I've read city of heavenly fire. It didn't bother me, still such a good book and I can't wait for you to read it!!

  • @andrealewis2501
    @andrealewis2501 6 лет назад +2

    Am I the only one who empathized with Clary and Jace and Clary's situation? They couldn't help how they felt so I was never mad at them, they tried not to feel that way, and even if messing with Simon was wrong, she was trying to force a square into a circle trying to be close to Simon the way she felt about Jace, I've never done what she did, but I do not judge her because I totally understand how difficult her situation was to cope with, and even if she did do the wrong thing, and/or maybe that's the whole point to realize that no one is perfect, maybe it's normal to be frustrated with certain characters the way we get frustrated with people in real life.

  • @leannb2513
    @leannb2513 10 лет назад

    I like the display of the TMI books on your shelf. I have yet to read CoHF. also, 1:14 is the best!

  • @jochusbooks2886
    @jochusbooks2886 6 лет назад +1

    I hated clary’s and Simon relationship, it was so awkward and weird, I don’t know it just didn’t felt right and, when they broke up I was really happy.
    But then jace broke clary’s and my heart with that ending 💔

  • @emilycarisch7387
    @emilycarisch7387 7 лет назад +1

    I read this book pretty much in one sitting (it took me 8 hours) even though my family was dragging me around town ALL day (all I want to do is read, is that so much to ask for) and I have to wait an entire DAY to go to the library tomorrow to pick up City of Glass (no offense to the people who had to wait like six months for the next book to come out; I appreciate and admire your stamina)

  • @kirstenh2371
    @kirstenh2371 10 лет назад

    Yay you finally have read this book! I just finished this book too, and I agree with all of the things that you said about this book. THE SIMON AND CLARY RELATIONSHIP WAS WEIRD. Question - have you read the rest of the series yet?

  • @elvanmelikesutlu2611
    @elvanmelikesutlu2611 5 лет назад +1

    Wait, what about malec!? In my opinion (even if there wasn‘t many malec scenes in this book) malec ist the best relationship, OMG THEY ARE MY LIFE. LITERALLY MY LIFE!!!

  • @saiatada1630
    @saiatada1630 4 года назад

    I just started the book series.. And we have the same reaction about jace and clary (3:54). Haha i hate it too. But i think there will be a twist in the next book. I just finished the city of ashes though.
    I agree also about Simon and clary (6:03)

  • @catalinasanchez9956
    @catalinasanchez9956 9 лет назад

    i saw your books on the second shelf and nearly cried because you have alex's books and they are my favorites

  • @alainagaston4125
    @alainagaston4125 8 лет назад +1

    Malec!!

  • @alyssaajk
    @alyssaajk 10 лет назад

    I really hope you do continue doing these book talks! I'm currently on book 4 and will most likely finish the series by the end of June!

    • @jessethereader
      @jessethereader  10 лет назад +1

      I'm gonna try to stick to making them for this series! I'm having too much fun reading and talking about them. :) Are you / Have you read TID?

    • @alyssaajk
      @alyssaajk 10 лет назад

      I haven't read them yet but I definitely plan on reading them as soon as I'm done with The Mortal Instruments series!

    • @heyyouyou1000
      @heyyouyou1000 10 лет назад

      Alyssa Klein no no no dont, please read first tid before the last book of tmi, because there are some major spoilers and the precuel is so amazing you should read it without knowing things...

    • @alyssaajk
      @alyssaajk 10 лет назад

      ariadna cisneros Thank you for the advice! I'll definitely pick up the series soon!

    • @heyyouyou1000
      @heyyouyou1000 10 лет назад

      Yeah pick it up youll love tid, tell me what you think :)

  • @vcdc6742
    @vcdc6742 10 лет назад

    For me, the best scene in the book was when Jace is with Valentine on the ship and he starts to see all the demons above e below him, all the different kinds of creatures! That's just amazing! I absolutely WORSHIP Cassie's criativity and writing, and she is my inspiration to become a fantasy writer!
    BTW, great video, Jesse! I really like you :D

  • @missOhdrey
    @missOhdrey 10 лет назад

    Have you read The Infernal Devices before? If not, you should read them after City of Glass, or at least befor city of Lost Souls because otherwise you'll miss a lot of important details.

  • @madisynowens3974
    @madisynowens3974 10 лет назад

    You are going to love City of Glass. It gets so much better. That is by far my favorite TMI book.

  • @ginanicole0211
    @ginanicole0211 10 лет назад

    I was so excited to see this review! Thanks for the video :D

  • @brandenjobrien
    @brandenjobrien 10 лет назад

    I have only read the first book in this series: City Of Bones. And I had no motovation to read the second book. But after watching your nonspoiler part of your review, I want to pick it up. Thanks! jessethereader

  • @kotaskollection4043
    @kotaskollection4043 9 лет назад

    One I loved the book and two I am a huge fan for your book shelf

  • @_reveux
    @_reveux 10 лет назад

    You HAVE to read The Infernal Devices too!! Those books play a very impprtant role in TMI too!!

  • @tiyabear
    @tiyabear 9 лет назад +4

    I found it interesting that we learn that Valentine abused Jace. Come on anytime marks given to you by a person are reminders of that person, they've abused you. It helped me get Jace a little better.

  • @KarineBeaulieu1
    @KarineBeaulieu1 8 лет назад

    Finished this book today! Some parts I just sped through cause it's so good and others I just wanted to cry about how slow pace it was.. Loved the ending! Simon and Clary relationship was super awkward I hated him up to the point where he changed from then on I grew to love him! I'm giving my head a rest for the night but i'm starting City of Glass tomorrow

  • @arrrose
    @arrrose 10 лет назад +2

    I knew the truth about Clary and Jace from the beginning. Like when they "show" Valentine for the first time. I was like "Oh here, Clary's father". It was weird to see Clary and Jace as "siblings" even if it was for a short period of time.

  • @Jenexplainsitallx
    @Jenexplainsitallx 10 лет назад

    I loved this book! I agree, such a step up from the first one. I like learning about the downworlders more in this book, especially the fairies and vampires. Can't wait for the rest of your TMI discussion videos :). I hope you do these when you read TID too because there are so many feels in that series!

  • @paigeeelycia1422
    @paigeeelycia1422 10 лет назад

    this is so true. i LOVE reading it buuuut like the characters annoy me so much sometimes!! with the actions they do. i loved this review !!

  • @sandyreadsalot
    @sandyreadsalot 10 лет назад

    I'm glad that you're enjoying the TMI series. I can't wait to hear your thoughts/review on the rest of the books. :)

  • @athousandlives7231
    @athousandlives7231 10 лет назад +1

    City of Ashes is not my favourite book in the series, but the Fearless rune incident is certainly one of my favourite moments. ^^

  • @emlylunar
    @emlylunar 10 лет назад

    I remember reading the ending and then just falling apart and crying because clary was about to tell jace how she felt about him, and then jace interrupts her and tells her that he'll start to act like her brother.

  • @UnquenchableReads
    @UnquenchableReads 10 лет назад

    Cool review! I love The Mortal Instruments.

  • @marbellyme
    @marbellyme 10 лет назад

    Ugh I love your videos!

  • @smma25
    @smma25 10 лет назад +6

    I love all the books ps you are hilarious 😆

  • @xoloveyg9900
    @xoloveyg9900 4 года назад

    @jessethereader I really wanna know when was the first one you picked cassandra's book and specifically mortal instrument ? And how much it took you to read the whole?

  • @jesuschristerica
    @jesuschristerica 10 лет назад

    I finished City of Ashes a little while ago as well! I really WANT to like Simon's character but I feel like at times Cassandra Clare writes him to be annoying so that we ship Jace/Clary more or just dislike him until something terrible happens to him and then we feel bad. I think he's actually a funny, selfless guy (especially in the later books) and I don't think we got to see enough of that side of him in CoA! I'm 100ish pages into City of Glass and loving it so I can't wait to see your review of that one soon!

  • @SamM-fo7wo
    @SamM-fo7wo 10 лет назад +4

    STOP TRYING TO SINK MY SHIP YOURE HURTING MY CLACE FEELS 😭

  • @idkbutilikeskittle9286
    @idkbutilikeskittle9286 8 лет назад +2

    I was spoiled! The wholes series!!! My friend spoiled the whole series to me!!!

    • @fffhehe
      @fffhehe 6 лет назад

      Idk But i like skittle hahahahah I spoil all the books I read to my friends

  • @MatthewsAdventuresSFGAM
    @MatthewsAdventuresSFGAM 9 лет назад +6

    Sped read this just to watch this review

  • @crownofthorns1651
    @crownofthorns1651 7 лет назад +1

    I actually really do ship Jace and Clary. I know they're related and I usually am not on board with incest ships BUT this is the exception and if someone else doesn't ship it I get it...but I ship it and I'm going to continue to ship it.

  • @aliciamcguire7163
    @aliciamcguire7163 4 года назад +1

    Clary as a character really pisses me off sometimes but she’s also relatable. I feel like in the fighting scenes she’s pretty useless and I keep wanting to yell “DO SOMETHING” to her. When he grabbed the sword toward Valentine I finally sighed with relief because wow she can do something other than watch?!?!

  • @Sheryl301
    @Sheryl301 10 лет назад

    This whole series is so good that I'd like to reread it again!! Have u read City of Glass? That's my fav by far! Jace and Clary relationship was just weird

  • @ladymacbook4255
    @ladymacbook4255 10 лет назад

    All the awkward malec interractions or mentions of malec were my favourite parts. That scene with the fearless rune? Priceless.

  • @SuperAliens101
    @SuperAliens101 10 лет назад +3

    My favorite part is when Simon turned into a vampire in the Jewish cemetery.

  • @nicoleflo
    @nicoleflo 10 лет назад

    I have kind of mixed feelings about this series, but what I absolutely love is all the secondary characters and how well you get to know all of them. That's really what kept me reading through all of them.

  • @jeacay5983
    @jeacay5983 9 лет назад

    Was Jordan introduced in City of Glass? If not, what book did he come up in? It's been a while since I read the books.

    • @spicyramen0008
      @spicyramen0008 9 лет назад +1

      I think he was introduced in city of fallen angels.

  • @gabriellelanglinais6179
    @gabriellelanglinais6179 10 лет назад

    I am reading the book right now

  • @ryanthefanboy
    @ryanthefanboy 10 лет назад

    I just read it as well, and I LOVED it so much! Really excited to go on with the series. Also, I really liked and agreed with your review/booktalk. You're awesome :D

    • @jessethereader
      @jessethereader  10 лет назад +1

      Thank you! I'm glad you're enjoying the series. :)

  • @heckyeah2540
    @heckyeah2540 6 лет назад

    Honestly the Fairy’s reminds me of some of my friends in away

  • @abigail6394
    @abigail6394 10 лет назад

    City of Ashes is my favorite in the series.

  • @shanaynayokeil6553
    @shanaynayokeil6553 5 лет назад +2

    I am 25. Is it weird that I am enjoying the Mortal Instruments? My friends keep saying the books are for kids and teenagers. I feel embarrassed.

    • @Mel-pv6lq
      @Mel-pv6lq 5 лет назад

      Please don't feel embarrassed

  • @jackiewhite5890
    @jackiewhite5890 10 лет назад

    I love your books!!!

  • @jaysailsthesea
    @jaysailsthesea 6 лет назад

    So... are the faeries weird, or is it Cassandra Clare? Honestly, I’m leaning towards the latter.

  • @justfourfangirls
    @justfourfangirls 10 лет назад

    How can you read cohf without reading tid?? I mean, isnt it majorly spoiled!

  • @lilialorenzo2579
    @lilialorenzo2579 10 лет назад

    Finally someone comments on the Inquisitor and how she was about to tell him something right before she died! I literally just finished this book today and haven't been spoiled, but my guess is that he might be her grandson that she thought died *shrugs* I don't know I guess I'll have to read on.

  • @catcarstairs8179
    @catcarstairs8179 6 лет назад +4

    May-rizz? I'VE BEEN PRONOUNCING IT MAURICE 😂😂😂

    • @mb-sb5ever
      @mb-sb5ever 5 лет назад +1

      Well in the show it started with may-rizz then it went to Ma-riss-a so it's fine I don't think it really changes anything

  • @esh4941
    @esh4941 8 лет назад

    +jessethereader Please please please give me a link of the movie I love that book i saw the first movie and I'm crying right now 'cause I can't find the movie.

  • @bealockhart7448
    @bealockhart7448 7 лет назад

    Is it just me or is this review SO RELATABLE 😆😱❤️❤️❤️

  • @ColeMovies
    @ColeMovies 10 лет назад

    Can't wait for CoG BOOKTALK

  • @imnotsospecial1996
    @imnotsospecial1996 5 лет назад

    I was so happy when I realised that there were more then three books in the series. I cried though 😭 :D

  • @gandapinta1
    @gandapinta1 10 лет назад

    I used to love fairies!

  • @TheMalinator1
    @TheMalinator1 10 лет назад

    Your going to love City of Glass because it gets even better than City of Ashes. I really enjoyed hearing what your thoughts were on this book. Can't wait to see what your thoughts are going to be on City of Glass. I really liked this book when I read it, but it is not my favorite of the series.

  • @selfmadeoranges
    @selfmadeoranges 10 лет назад +2

    THE ENTIRE FAIRY SCENE I WAS SPAZZING OUT AND LIKE NO NO NO NO #AWKWARD #INCEST #NAAAAAAH

  • @Alanbricks
    @Alanbricks 10 лет назад

    Have you read the whole series?

  • @LorienKittyBooks
    @LorienKittyBooks 10 лет назад

    I'm so glad that all my issues with this book you covered. In fact, what you said about the characters and the situations between them bugged me so much I stopped reading after the third book. I was just tired of it and didn't see a reason to continue. And I tried, but book 4 didn't interest me at all.