It’s not very noticeable on this album because it matches his vocal range better, if he tries to perform anything from saturate it can get kinda bad bc he’s just not as young as he used to be. It’s still good tho. This band is my first musical memory
+CommanderCodyHD Ben’s disease shouldn’t affect his voice one bit. Unless it’s destroyed the part of his brain that can sense pitch, it shouldn’t matter.
For the people that say it's hard to play this song live. I feel like every song has its challenges, but this has to be because of the quality of the recording. It sounds just as good live than recorded. I just saw them in tampa and man when they opened with red cold river it was just way too good!
In all the breaking Benjamin concerts I've been to and seen online,I've never seen Ben without his guitar. And definately never heard him not do his signature growl and have a filler do it. Lol
It’s a shame this song is impossible to replicate live. So many blended vocals with no breaths. I’m sure Ben knew that while writing/recording it. Love the song but I’ll stick with the album version. It’s not very metal but using a backing track for the chorus live would help
Get Ben a guitar. It doesn't have to be up. He doesn't even have to play. But that man doesn't need to be redefining his stage presence this many albums deep lol
Unfortunately I'm very disappointed in the drumming.... I know they do not play to a click track live but as a drummer it is your job to keep time.... So this dude could have at least attempted to keep the right timing of the song throughout it. 😢
His timing is pretty good, it's just that he's feet are a little off/sloppy on some double kick parts. Otherwise, Shaun is a great drummer! It's impossible for a drummer to hold the exact same tempo throughout a song live without a click. Even legends like Stewart Copeland rushes and drags when playing live
brandough crox aka ogb..well let's see...its very pitchy..out if tune, mixed horrible .and the wizard of ozz set is laughable. I like alot if this bands music..just think this particular song is a bit rough .please.don't beat me up. Just an opinion.
Jeffrey The Dotard in all fairness, I can see where you’re coming from. Ben has a medical condition affecting his voice, so he really uses his screams in recordings. Honestly though, it’s better than lip-syncing.
![Breaking Benjamin [VIP Platinum on-stage] - Red Cold River Live - Broomfield, CO 4/5/2019](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CUvgvXMjz9M/mqdefault.jpg)
Ben's voice crack actually sounds good cause it's genuine since he's putting in effort
It’s not very noticeable on this album because it matches his vocal range better, if he tries to perform anything from saturate it can get kinda bad bc he’s just not as young as he used to be. It’s still good tho. This band is my first musical memory
Legit got chills from Aaron's screams omg
Ben is so awkward on stage without his guitar LOL
Gruddy 12 has his own Style,Love it 😂😂
I've never seen a front man yet that could handle not having an instrument... lol
Adam Gontier seemed to do alright back when One-X dropped, but that may be nostalgia goggles.
I thought he was pretty good. Better with his guitar but he didn't look awkward. He loves trying to get the crowd into it more than he used to.
Cory Price Anthony Davis, Corey Taylor?
Loved the way ben said war and the way it echoed at 1:47
He is actually saying run.
That scream dude
Matthew Pugh Ok that's isn't Ben thats scream, but still amazing 😂
It's Aaron Bruch who does the scream because Ben can't scream live because of his sickness
+CommanderCodyHD Ben’s disease shouldn’t affect his voice one bit. Unless it’s destroyed the part of his brain that can sense pitch, it shouldn’t matter.
This song sounds really hard to do live especially the vocals in the bridge
Man I see people too calm while they’re playing this song. I would go totally nuts!
Mobile phones are the worst thing to happen to gigs...
I was there! Such a great time!
For the people that say it's hard to play this song live. I feel like every song has its challenges, but this has to be because of the quality of the recording. It sounds just as good live than recorded. I just saw them in tampa and man when they opened with red cold river it was just way too good!
Finally a video where Keith isnt drowning out ben
Best song on stage. Wow.
Say them live last week. It was fire
Corey Tevis thats how we do it
Hell yeah I love them in concert they rock can't wait tile they come to st Louis
I love it !!!!!! 😍
it's awesome
Put your goddamn phones away and enjoy the show....except for the guy recording LOL
This song is not easy to perform live
Kushal Bhattacharjee u r wrong, id too easy just ben dont practic
Imagin how horse he would be
It really is for sure.
Too many vocal harmonics going on
Ernesto Mendoza okay, then go play it live in front of a huge crowd. Oh wait, you can't??? huh, i thought it was easy
I was there!!
I met them all live last year soooooo fucking good
In all the breaking Benjamin concerts I've been to and seen online,I've never seen Ben without his guitar. And definately never heard him not do his signature growl and have a filler do it. Lol
Great video man! Thanks for this!
I was there for all three days
Wish I woulda gone the first day now ugggggggggggh
Wow hes lost weight
Had the same thought, almost skinny at this point :/
I was right in the front and got crushed multiple times by crowd surfers that got thrown the wrong way... Good times
Gotta love concerts ay
They sound weird live still enjoy them tho
Blueschy it’s the sound quality from the recording, it would be better if you were actually there.
Is the crappy cell phone Mic not being able handle the volume.
The double eye bass drums are Hilarious
I'm surprised the crowd isn't going nuts lmfao the fuck
I love this band, but can somebody please teach Ben how to hold a microphone?
Jesus_the_frog42 otherwise he might drop the mic and re-christen the name of the band lol
Hes new at being guitarless lol
Awesome performance but does Ben not perform screaming vocals live anymore?
It’s a shame this song is impossible to replicate live. So many blended vocals with no breaths. I’m sure Ben knew that while writing/recording it. Love the song but I’ll stick with the album version. It’s not very metal but using a backing track for the chorus live would help
Ben's voice for better!
I always thought Ben did the harsh vocals too. Slightly disappointed
He does only on recordings. He sometimes screams on stage too, though.
It makes him sick
Screaming hurts your voice, hence why he doesnt do it live.. Cause it would literally tear his voice down completely
Rov Ippi it only hurts if you are using the wrong technique
ErikRichardson Not screaming.. You must be thinking of growling, two different things
Get Ben a guitar. It doesn't have to be up. He doesn't even have to play. But that man doesn't need to be redefining his stage presence this many albums deep lol
Oooh Ben's sounding a bit rough hope it was just a summer cold or something
Unfortunately I'm very disappointed in the drumming.... I know they do not play to a click track live but as a drummer it is your job to keep time.... So this dude could have at least attempted to keep the right timing of the song throughout it. 😢
His timing is pretty good, it's just that he's feet are a little off/sloppy on some double kick parts. Otherwise, Shaun is a great drummer! It's impossible for a drummer to hold the exact same tempo throughout a song live without a click. Even legends like Stewart Copeland rushes and drags when playing live
I really couldn't enjoy it because of all the crowd surfers. There were too damn many of them at Breaking Benjamin's set. Still good show.
Brian Heath it’s a metal show, kinda expected in those man😂
Well rock on the range is to small to do anything else on the field. Got to rock out somehow
Did you just call BB metal? You obviously have no idea what metal is.
Andrew Elam I’m pretty sure B.B. is somewhere in the metal scene, especially the new album
Benjito Burrito, you're right.. Breaking Benjamin is classed as an alt metal band. Same as rammstein, Papa Roach, SOAD and many more
0:40
World war 3 TRUMPS office
What state is this ?
Jason grant ohio
Nick Warts thanks just making sure the band didn't pass my state, that would suck.
His voice is not the same as it used to be in live performance
He's sick, no doctor has actually been able to say what it is but many people believe that its a side effect from his drinking problem.
Yeah.......... I have heard that he had some throat problem which took a heavy toll in his voice.
Best BB drummer yet question mark?
Tyler Spinella naw. Their old one was the best we were gonna lol
As much as I love Chad I do think Shaun is better
I definitely think Chad is better(He's amazing) but Shaun is awesome as well!
Not the best but damn sure good!!!
Cantó terrible Benjamin Burnley...pero la canción no deja de ser hermosa, no sé si es que estaría enfermo de la garganta o algo...
Tiene 38 años de edad más la enfermedad que tiene impide que tenga el rango vocal que tenía antes.
Ian Pezo Torres que enfermedad es la.que tiene? No sabia ese dato.... Pues mi sospechas eran ciertas
I love bb , but in this video i didnt like it , sorry ben
Thats cause its recorded with a phone
why is this drummer so bad at this double kick part? lol
I don't like the new band
This drummer is using triggers? For what reason? Any mediocre drummer can swing this groove.
Horrible.....sorry.
Please tell me where I can find your band
How the fuck is this terrible
brandough crox aka ogb..well let's see...its very pitchy..out if tune, mixed horrible .and the wizard of ozz set is laughable. I like alot if this bands music..just think this particular song is a bit rough .please.don't beat me up. Just an opinion.
Zach Sargent can't you respect opinions?
Jeffrey The Dotard in all fairness, I can see where you’re coming from. Ben has a medical condition affecting his voice, so he really uses his screams in recordings. Honestly though, it’s better than lip-syncing.
Totattly fake