My ideal TOP 10 : Judith, Aron, Negan, Daryll, Carol, Eugene, Gracie, Gabriel, Ezequil, Lydia. It would've been the most memorable episode in TV history. Of course the question would be: How to continue when so many main characters are dead. But hey for the last 2 seasons they could ve done something completly different. Maggie and Connie as the new dream duo and a timejump with Ricks son as the new Carl.
My ideal lineup: 1. Ozzy (Leader of the Highwayman) 2. DJ (Alexandria) 3. Scott (Alexandria) 4. Frankie (Alexandria) 5. Syndie (Leader of Oceanside) 6. Luke (Magna's Group) 7. Tammy Rose (Hiltop) 8. Rodney (Hiltop) 9. Addy (Hiltop) 10. Enid (Hiltop) 11. Tara (Leader of Hiltop) 12. Ezekiel (Leader of the Kingdom)
well they killed tara off bc she wanted to leave the show to pursue other acting opportunities. it really hurt me when i saw her head on a pike though. i really liked her character and was excited to see her in a leader role so it was a shame to see it end so quickly and so quickly after jesus died like what the hell…
Man Ozzy & the Highway Man were the biggest examples of wasted potential on the show (behind Jesus, Elijah, Cole, Toby, etc). They should’ve had them introduced a few episodes earlier & have the confrontation be a little more intense with a brief shootout on the highway at night with the Kingdom militia led by Ezekiel & Carol (who’s in her badass No Sanctuary mode) & the mannequins are all around & it’s dark as hell so they just see the silhouettes & don’t know how many hostiles there are. That would be so awesome but then say Carol grabs Alfred & holds him hostage and makes them all come out & they negotiate and finally come to an agreement that the Highway Men can join the joint communities if they work at patrols on the roads. Then establish ALEC more, have him be one of the pike deaths which infuriates the rest of his group. Then have the finale of that season instead of being that boring ass winter episode, it’d be Alfred & Margo beating up Lydia (like Morton attacking Rick in issue 150 like the show) and have Lydia bite one of them to make it a lot more like the comic scene. She gets seriously injured & the council exile the Highway Men & play it like they’re a new threat, but then later in the episode they cross the border with new guns & weapons (breaking the “truce”) and have them attack the Whisperer camp, only to get slaughtered one by one (also we saw a few Whisperers with automatic weapons so it would be really sweet if they had silencers and a few of them actually fire back within the horde) & then that would be the catalyst that starts the Whisperer War. How awesome would that have been!? Damn I wish I could’ve been brought on as a writer in season 10. I would be more qualified that the ones who did right that shitty season.
Lol killing Daryl? The god of TWD universe. AMC’s cash cow. You’re playing a dangerous man and I respect you for not being afraid of the Daryl stans.😂😂
I mostly agree actually, but I would make some changes: 1. Alec (HWM) 2. DJ (Alex/Sav) 3. Frankie (Alex/Sav) 4. Tammy Rose (Hilltop) 5. Addy (Hilltop) 6. Luke/Kelly (Hilltop/Magna) 7. Nabila (Kingdom) 8. Enid (Hilltop) 9. Sydney (OS) 10. Ezekiel (Kingdom) I love Tara and while she was always like a "no plot character" I really love her, maybe we could have seen a plot about her having to be a leader while she doesn't like it because its just not for her. Also she has connections to Sydney, so that would be interesting. Kal...is nothing honestly, I liked him in the Hilltop Arc S6-S8 but he just dissapeared and I don't think he would really matter. I know Alec is a nothing character too, but he is a HWM and we could have something cool with the group with Ozzy being angry or something, idk the HWM appeared and disappeared. I think either killing Kelly or Luke could work, both are from Magna's group and work as a death. Luke is a charismatic character and would hurt for the audience and also he does nothing for the rest of the show (mainly cuz the actor but anyway). Kelly had some story with Connie's fake death and she being deaf, but idk, I don't think Kelly is a bad character but just boring, this death could work cuz it affects Connie and thanks to that, it also hurts Daryl a bit. Enid just works, she a likable character and an old character since S5, and she went a little lost since Carl's death. It also helps developt Alden, so I think it works. I wished we had some arcs like Rodney and Gage bullying Lydia cuz thanks to her, Addy died, so Henry has to protect her. Magna's group rebelling for Luke/Kelly's death. HWM DOING SOMETHING.
Me personally: 1. Ozzy. 2. Abby. 3. Rodney. 4. Tammy. 5. Mikey. 6. Nabila. 7. Luke. 8. Laura. 9. Tara. 10. Ezekiel. Ezekial, Tara and Luke are iust the right choices for the list, creating shocking deaths which aldo move the plot forward. They are all also victims in wother the comics or TV series. Laura does nothing going forward, and I think that Alden and Negan should be the main Saviours left over, she was akso part of the Alexandrian council so thats another Alexandrian leader gone. I never thought of adding Nabila until now, so thanks for the idea. Ozzy, Abby, Rodney and Tammy are all perfect victims for the pykes. Mikey because 1. I didnt have enough Alexandrian deaths, and 2 because I hate hiw he died in season 8 because he didnt even really die, he was just lumped in as dying thoutlessly, so Im nringing him back to see what he's been doing then kill him off. Another thing I'd do is put Jerry in Siddiq's place, his wife and best friend have died so now he has to grapple with that turmoil and be part of the Dante plotline. Another thing is to make Alden and Enid the new guardians for Adam (whisperer baby) going forward so Enid gets to live. With Ozzy gone from the Highwaymen, I think a plotline of them being taken over by Carol as a way to start the Whisperer war eould be interesting. A bunch of angry, leaderless people being led by Carol against the Whisperers could be pretty fun. It would also make things more snappy. This is all just my opinion.
Actually, I think Kelly would have worked as a pike death Connie's group is introduced same season as the pike deaths, I think it'll be interesting if one of their group dies there, Magna, Yumiko and Connie are a big no no because of their relevance, Luke is just a good guy everyone can like, leaves it with Kelly, she does not much relevant things post season 9 and will shock Yumiko more than she already got, may open to character development to the group, specially Connie
Disagree it's not the strongest storyline and I think they could have upped the stakes and made it more interesting for sure but killing of Henry was pointless storywise when you achieved the same thing but better by killing of Ezekiel. if you hate Henry that much there's two choices Either just don't adapt the Carl storyline from the comics full stop and don't do anything with Henry's character, keep him as a background character. Or you flesh out the Henry and Lydia stuff and make it more interesting.... I prefer this one
You put Daryl on the pike in your thumbnail and wonder why no one’s clicking
You’ve attacked the mob
okay Jackson
Lol well you clicked so seems to be working
Jerry losing Zeke and his wife same day would be insane
@@TheBagman99 hell yeah but might make him more than just a comic relief
Henry’s death is the only one that really bothered me he had so much potential for the whisperer war
My ideal TOP 10 : Judith, Aron, Negan, Daryll, Carol, Eugene, Gracie, Gabriel, Ezequil, Lydia.
It would've been the most memorable episode in TV history. Of course the question would be: How to continue when so many main characters are dead. But hey for the last 2 seasons they could ve done something completly different. Maggie and Connie as the new dream duo and a timejump with Ricks son as the new Carl.
bro you would kill literally every good character that was in the show 😭
I mostly agree, would only put rosita in nabila place
My ideal lineup:
1. Ozzy (Leader of the Highwayman)
2. DJ (Alexandria)
3. Scott (Alexandria)
4. Frankie (Alexandria)
5. Syndie (Leader of Oceanside)
6. Luke (Magna's Group)
7. Tammy Rose (Hiltop)
8. Rodney (Hiltop)
9. Addy (Hiltop)
10. Enid (Hiltop)
11. Tara (Leader of Hiltop)
12. Ezekiel (Leader of the Kingdom)
well they killed tara off bc she wanted to leave the show to pursue other acting opportunities. it really hurt me when i saw her head on a pike though. i really liked her character and was excited to see her in a leader role so it was a shame to see it end so quickly and so quickly after jesus died like what the hell…
Man Ozzy & the Highway Man were the biggest examples of wasted potential on the show (behind Jesus, Elijah, Cole, Toby, etc). They should’ve had them introduced a few episodes earlier & have the confrontation be a little more intense with a brief shootout on the highway at night with the Kingdom militia led by Ezekiel & Carol (who’s in her badass No Sanctuary mode) & the mannequins are all around & it’s dark as hell so they just see the silhouettes & don’t know how many hostiles there are. That would be so awesome but then say Carol grabs Alfred & holds him hostage and makes them all come out & they negotiate and finally come to an agreement that the Highway Men can join the joint communities if they work at patrols on the roads. Then establish ALEC more, have him be one of the pike deaths which infuriates the rest of his group. Then have the finale of that season instead of being that boring ass winter episode, it’d be Alfred & Margo beating up Lydia (like Morton attacking Rick in issue 150 like the show) and have Lydia bite one of them to make it a lot more like the comic scene. She gets seriously injured & the council exile the Highway Men & play it like they’re a new threat, but then later in the episode they cross the border with new guns & weapons (breaking the “truce”) and have them attack the Whisperer camp, only to get slaughtered one by one (also we saw a few Whisperers with automatic weapons so it would be really sweet if they had silencers and a few of them actually fire back within the horde) & then that would be the catalyst that starts the Whisperer War. How awesome would that have been!? Damn I wish I could’ve been brought on as a writer in season 10. I would be more qualified that the ones who did right that shitty season.
Lol killing Daryl? The god of TWD universe. AMC’s cash cow. You’re playing a dangerous man and I respect you for not being afraid of the Daryl stans.😂😂
I’m not afraid of any of the stans, including those Negan fanboys
@@MagnusRobert Yeah them too. Honestly I think Negan should of died in TWDU. I mean what’s left for him? His fan base just loves nostalgia.😆
I mostly agree actually, but I would make some changes:
1. Alec (HWM)
2. DJ (Alex/Sav)
3. Frankie (Alex/Sav)
4. Tammy Rose (Hilltop)
5. Addy (Hilltop)
6. Luke/Kelly (Hilltop/Magna)
7. Nabila (Kingdom)
8. Enid (Hilltop)
9. Sydney (OS)
10. Ezekiel (Kingdom)
I love Tara and while she was always like a "no plot character" I really love her, maybe we could have seen a plot about her having to be a leader while she doesn't like it because its just not for her. Also she has connections to Sydney, so that would be interesting.
Kal...is nothing honestly, I liked him in the Hilltop Arc S6-S8 but he just dissapeared and I don't think he would really matter.
I know Alec is a nothing character too, but he is a HWM and we could have something cool with the group with Ozzy being angry or something, idk the HWM appeared and disappeared.
I think either killing Kelly or Luke could work, both are from Magna's group and work as a death.
Luke is a charismatic character and would hurt for the audience and also he does nothing for the rest of the show (mainly cuz the actor but anyway).
Kelly had some story with Connie's fake death and she being deaf, but idk, I don't think Kelly is a bad character but just boring, this death could work cuz it affects Connie and thanks to that, it also hurts Daryl a bit.
Enid just works, she a likable character and an old character since S5, and she went a little lost since Carl's death. It also helps developt Alden, so I think it works.
I wished we had some arcs like Rodney and Gage bullying Lydia cuz thanks to her, Addy died, so Henry has to protect her. Magna's group rebelling for Luke/Kelly's death. HWM DOING SOMETHING.
Me personally:
1. Ozzy.
2. Abby.
3. Rodney.
4. Tammy.
5. Mikey.
6. Nabila.
7. Luke.
8. Laura.
9. Tara.
10. Ezekiel.
Ezekial, Tara and Luke are iust the right choices for the list, creating shocking deaths which aldo move the plot forward. They are all also victims in wother the comics or TV series.
Laura does nothing going forward, and I think that Alden and Negan should be the main Saviours left over, she was akso part of the Alexandrian council so thats another Alexandrian leader gone.
I never thought of adding Nabila until now, so thanks for the idea.
Ozzy, Abby, Rodney and Tammy are all perfect victims for the pykes.
Mikey because 1. I didnt have enough Alexandrian deaths, and 2 because I hate hiw he died in season 8 because he didnt even really die, he was just lumped in as dying thoutlessly, so Im nringing him back to see what he's been doing then kill him off.
Another thing I'd do is put Jerry in Siddiq's place, his wife and best friend have died so now he has to grapple with that turmoil and be part of the Dante plotline.
Another thing is to make Alden and Enid the new guardians for Adam (whisperer baby) going forward so Enid gets to live.
With Ozzy gone from the Highwaymen, I think a plotline of them being taken over by Carol as a way to start the Whisperer war eould be interesting. A bunch of angry, leaderless people being led by Carol against the Whisperers could be pretty fun. It would also make things more snappy.
This is all just my opinion.
i don't understand how people call this a bad ranking there is a few tings i would change but overall its good
interesting
Interesting
Actually, I think Kelly would have worked as a pike death
Connie's group is introduced same season as the pike deaths, I think it'll be interesting if one of their group dies there, Magna, Yumiko and Connie are a big no no because of their relevance, Luke is just a good guy everyone can like, leaves it with Kelly, she does not much relevant things post season 9 and will shock Yumiko more than she already got, may open to character development to the group, specially Connie
Yeah i think Kelly could work
My ldeal pikes
Ozzy
Dj
Kal
Frankie
Dianne
Tammy Rose
Rodney
Kelly
Luke
Enid
Tara
Ezequiel
My opinion
They baiscally removed the itemlimit and added massive shitload of land so play tapped out agaim
@@overlord6993 Nah probably won’t sorry
I'm glad they killed off Henry, he was my least favorite character in TWD universe and Henry + Lydia storyline was so boring.
Disagree it's not the strongest storyline and I think they could have upped the stakes and made it more interesting for sure but killing of Henry was pointless storywise when you achieved the same thing but better by killing of Ezekiel.
if you hate Henry that much there's two choices
Either just don't adapt the Carl storyline from the comics full stop and don't do anything with Henry's character, keep him as a background character.
Or you flesh out the Henry and Lydia stuff and make it more interesting.... I prefer this one
Aaron and Gage should have been chosen to be on the pikes,these two were so annoying characters
Mine:
Gabriel
Ezekiel
Tammy
Henry
Lydia
Kelly
Rodney
Beatrice
Magaret
Oscar
terrible
Yeah I think there's too many big deaths there
Interesting
LOL what a deranged ranking lol
@@nosireyessir how so ?
Interesting
interesting
Interesting