Hello Everyone I'm torn about this! I choose Wendy overall, but I can't deny YuJu is amazing, too! Wendy when she sings her solo stuff has that timbre that resonates that she doesn't always have when singing in a group. I am going to get people pissed at me for saying this, but I'm waiting for YuJu to go solo because I feel the music Gfriend releases isn't good enough for her vocal range. Their music lacks something that other groups like Red Velvet, Black Pink, Girls Day, F(x), Twice, and Girls Generation have. I heard YuJu sing a Beyonce song a few months ago and lost my damn mind and then when I tried to get into Gfriend I was so disappointed. I'm not saying they are bad, but I just prefer songs with a little more oomph to them. A little more sass and soul to them with that dirty pop, as Nsync used to say! HaHa! I do love some poppy stuff that is a bit cheesy! HaHa! I've yet to hear a Gfriend song where YuJu can blow like she does hear. In contrast Wendy's group has a better quality sound to them and she's able to show off her vocals more. Taeyeon, Wendy and Seulgi, Minah, are just some of the best Kpop idol singers and I feel YuJu is on their level, but the music Gfriend releases sounds like bubblegum pop in comparison. YuJu should have joined JYP or SM or YG. She's that good to me!
Her voice are simply crafted by god, not many idols can sing so perfectly and every words is so clear like her when you see the current generation of kpop talents 98% of them all sound the same. This is why singer like Hwang Chi Yeul, Wheesung and many other senior musical legends had spoke so highly of her...
The acapella parts were just as smooth as a droplet falling down from a melting snowflake. That being said i wouldn't mind her singing the whole song without music; its so beautiful and deep, and the rush of soulful emotions will surely breakthrough that barrier that hold your tears..
'Common voice' is probably cause she's textbook singing. It's not a bad thing, it means she learned how to sing correctly (she needs to practice low registers more tho). But the problem is, people tend to praise singers with certain style, saying how great and unique they sound, despite using incorrect technique. Those that sing like Yuju, especially idols / pop singers, are less appreciated. Sad really.
Foreigners would cry for her voice, but for Koreans, we all remember and cry for the original singer of that song, Hae Cheol Shin, the genius, the god, the greatest mento of our life, and the man who have died so soon despite of his talent and his insight to this complex world of uncertainty.
Yuju never fails to impress me everytime i see her, I've said this many times but gonna say this again because she definitely slay whenever she's doing something. She's a true definition of talent, uri golden member Yuju, you did incredibly great! Making us buddies proud of you countless time, thank you and i love you ❤💙
As expected of Yuju, but she is even more full of emotions!! And she even hit low register notes at the start especially at 0:34-0:39 (what note was that) aside from slaying the fifth ocatave in later part of the song. But the most important thing is that she brought the audience to tears with her performance!!!! I am so proud of our main vocal!!!!
Everytime i hear her voice i end up feeling so proud of her, she sings with Emotion and her voice reaches all of my feelings. I will never get tired of her
유주의 창법이 목에 부담이 될 수도 있는 창법임에도 특유의 안정감은 그대로 유지하는 저 실력은 정말......... 성량 역시 대박이군요....... 이 날 1승도 못했다는 것이 이해가 안 될 정도의 퀄리티의 라이브인 것 같습니다....... 적어도 400표는 넘는 무대인데........ 뮤지컬 했으면 좋겠다는 분들 많은데 그 의견들에 저도 찬성입니다^^ 저 감성과 안정감은 정말.......
Can I say how proud I am that I stan this wonderful girl? Because of her and the rest of GFRIEND, I decided to stay on kpop and support them. They're the only gg I stan and some bg and GFRIEND is my ultimate group. So proud to stan them ㅠㅠ Gonna be Buddy foreverㅠㅠ
![사랑해 그리고 기억해🌸 여자친구 불후의 명곡 경연곡 모아보기 | #소장각 | 불후의 명곡 [KBS 방송]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/z2XLwX0S05g/mqdefault.jpg)
![사랑해 그리고 기억해🌸 여자친구 불후의 명곡 경연곡 모아보기 | #소장각 | 불후의 명곡 [KBS 방송]](/img/tr.png)
![GFRIEND’s Yuju - When Our Lives End | 유주 - 우리 앞에 생이 끝나갈 때 [Immortal Songs 2 / 2017.11.11]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EfhdIqfDvCE/mqdefault.jpg)
i'm not saying Choi Yuna is the most talented vocalist in girl group but thats what i'm saying
Exactly she's unique
haikal liverpool agree she good in everything and she can do everything.
Wendy says hi
HalfBloodOtter no one asked.
Hello Everyone I'm torn about this!
I choose Wendy overall, but I can't deny YuJu is amazing, too! Wendy when she sings her solo stuff has that timbre that resonates that she doesn't always have when singing in a group.
I am going to get people pissed at me for saying this, but I'm waiting for YuJu to go solo because I feel the music Gfriend releases isn't good enough for her vocal range. Their music lacks something that other groups like Red Velvet, Black Pink, Girls Day, F(x), Twice, and Girls Generation have.
I heard YuJu sing a Beyonce song a few months ago and lost my damn mind and then when I tried to get into Gfriend I was so disappointed. I'm not saying they are bad, but I just prefer songs with a little more oomph to them. A little more sass and soul to them with that dirty pop, as Nsync used to say! HaHa! I do love some poppy stuff that is a bit cheesy! HaHa!
I've yet to hear a Gfriend song where YuJu can blow like she does hear.
In contrast Wendy's group has a better quality sound to them and she's able to show off her vocals more.
Taeyeon, Wendy and Seulgi, Minah, are just some of the best Kpop idol singers and I feel YuJu is on their level, but the music Gfriend releases sounds like bubblegum pop in comparison.
YuJu should have joined JYP or SM or YG. She's that good to me!
Her voice are simply crafted by god, not many idols can sing so perfectly and every words is so clear like her when you see the current generation of kpop talents 98% of them all sound the same. This is why singer like Hwang Chi Yeul, Wheesung and many other senior musical legends had spoke so highly of her...
When did Chi Yeul talk about her?
Samee
번역: 그녀의 목소리는 단순히 하나님에 의해 만들어진, 많은 우상이 너무 완벽하게 노래 할 수 없습니다 그리고 모든 단어는 kpop 재능의 현재 세대를 볼 때 그녀처럼 너무 분명하다 98% 그들 모두는 같은 소리. 황치열, 휘성 등 가수가 그녀를 높게 말한 이유다.
Yess
I saw Yuju, I clicked right away and I liked even before watching bc I knew she was gonna slay.
Yuju you're just sooo good😢💕
Same here
I clicked again to watch it again after watching it live on kbs yesterday
Please ShareThis. ppl need to know Yuju's amazing voice.
She performed well. Better luck next time, Yuju. I believe that Immortal Songs will invite you more in the future.
Aji H.P Yes, and she got good comments from Hwang Chi Yeul and Shin Yong Jae (4Men).
The acapella parts were just as smooth as a droplet falling down from a melting snowflake. That being said i wouldn't mind her singing the whole song without music; its so beautiful and deep, and the rush of soulful emotions will surely breakthrough that barrier that hold your tears..
One of the best vocalist of this generation 😃💕
Gfriend is in 3rd generation, right?
Arya Gading Prabowo yes
@@yujuswifebecauseshesveryfr9414 ah, ok
Even without understanding the lyrics, just listening to her voice alone put me on the verge of tears...
that's true
Ahjussi Don't hold it. :P
Yeah, this song is horribly sad actually
SuperPianogirl123 What is it about?
Same😭
Yuju has an unique voice full of emotion, i Love her
Doing solo for 6 minutes in immortal song, daebak uri yuju-yaaa 💗💗💗
Best vocal k pop👍
that's a stretch.
Айдана Жалгас Ailee says Hi
no one asked for Ailee so sftu
One of the best for sure
Айдана Жалгас ailee hyorin taeyeon luna wendy and lee haeri says hi
Her voice seriously gave me goosebumps. So beautiful and smooth !
It's not just her voice, it's how she uses it. This was a great performance
When 'common voice' slay the audience. RISE CHOI YUNA RISE!
Harunara That shade.
'Common voice' is probably cause she's textbook singing. It's not a bad thing, it means she learned how to sing correctly (she needs to practice low registers more tho). But the problem is, people tend to praise singers with certain style, saying how great and unique they sound, despite using incorrect technique. Those that sing like Yuju, especially idols / pop singers, are less appreciated. Sad really.
Harunara coz jyp suckks
qI ò__ó Ip She is always training her low voice ;-;
I remember what JYP said to Yuju. Hihi
4.45 - 4.58: The climax. You can feel her "angry" and emotion.
so proud as a Buddy
Imanuella Gerlani YESSS 😭😭 IT'S SO TOUCHED 😭
Hate to do this but *anger*
@@ID-qn1ph Haha sorry I laughed😆
YUJUUU 😍😭😭😭 YOUR VOICE SO LIT 🔥😭😭 I LOVE YOUR VOICE BCZ SO UNIQUE 😭
Yesss😍😍👌🇰🇷👑
이 노래 커버로 유주와 손승연이 거론되던데 솔직히 취향차이에요 손승연은 국밥처럼 깊고 감정이 확 터지지만 유주는 설렁탕처럼 바르고 맑고 잔잔하죠. 둘다 해철이형님의 삶의 반성, 죽음에 대한 고뇌를 잘 나타냈어요.
ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
동감 합니다~~
원곡의 음을 아예 통째로 편곡할 필요는 있었을까 싶네요. 아예 다른 감성의 다른 곡이 되어버려서 가창력을 떠나서 저는 이 곡은 커버곡으로는 완벽한 실패곡이라 느껴집니다..
국밥이고 설렁탕이고 해철형님 그리워요
웃고갑니다 전 손승연 1표
baby yuju! fighting. the best main vocal.
im not crying *grab tissue boxes
Yuju slay it again 😭
GFRIEND fighting 💪💪💪
QUEEN 👑✨
you doing great sweety. i love you, i love gfriend ❤
Legend the best main vocal of Kpop
아직 학생안데도 이노래만 들으면 나이들어서 지나간 인생 돌아보는 기분 듦..
유주는 뮤지컬하면 대박칠 수 있는 재능을 가진거같음. 창법도 벨팅이고, 연기와 감정표현도 훌륭하다.
그런데 최근에 목 상태가 많이 나빠지고 그게 계속 잘 나아지지 않는 것 같아서 많이 속상하네요 ㅠㅠㅠ
최근에 목상태가 많이 나빠지고 그게 잘 나아지지 않는 것 같아서 많이 속상하네요...ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Who's cutting onions ?? Tell me tell me 😭😭😭.
Yuna it's okay if you didn't win ,you did your best and did great . This performance is so amazing 😭😭
Namjoon does hahahah😂
Foreigners would cry for her voice, but for Koreans, we all remember and cry for the original singer of that song, Hae Cheol Shin, the genius, the god, the greatest mento of our life, and the man who have died so soon despite of his talent and his insight to this complex world of uncertainty.
Yuju 💕
Yuju's voice is just-- 😆😆😆
Ahh, I really think she has the best vocal in this generation. Everything about her voice is just sooo perfect 😘😘😘😘
여자친구 유나(유주)언니 자체가...그냥 노래만 부르는게아니라 진짜 사연이있는것처럼 연기하면서 부르니까..노래에 더 몰입하면서 보게돼는것같다...요즘에는 목상태안좋은데 메보역할한다고 더 상하고있는것같은데...고음은 큰은비언니가하긴하지만 어려운부분은 유나언니가 맡다보니까...나아질 겨를이없으니까...진짜 목관리해서 유나언니 고음 듣고싶다...
YUJU
I liked the video even before watching Yuju performance bcoz I knew it will be daebak! Amazing job Yuju!👍🏻😍
나 왜 눈물날거같지 ㅜㅜ 유주가 부르는 건 내 맘을 톡톡 건드린단말이지
그런 호소력이 있어
유주 노래 짱이다
Yuju never fails to impress me everytime i see her, I've said this many times but gonna say this again because she definitely slay whenever she's doing something. She's a true definition of talent, uri golden member Yuju, you did incredibly great! Making us buddies proud of you countless time, thank you and i love you ❤💙
We all are proud as buddies we all love her . GO BIAS YUJU/YUNA CHOI
I'm a simple buddy... I see Yuju and I click. Good job girl!!
담백하게 잘 불렀네요.. 가사 생각하다 보면 울컥 할수 있을텐데. 감정 조절을 잘한듯.
내 가수 최유나 사랑해 노래해줘서 고마워 최고야
If Yuju sings this song again in BHL concert for tribute, im gonna cry 😢
Uwaa,Hwaiting
유나야 많이 아낀다 정말
As expected of Yuju, but she is even more full of emotions!! And she even hit low register notes at the start especially at 0:34-0:39 (what note was that) aside from slaying the fifth ocatave in later part of the song. But the most important thing is that she brought the audience to tears with her performance!!!! I am so proud of our main vocal!!!!
proud my girl😢😢😍😍👏👏👏👏👏👏
저 이거 매일 듣고 있어요ㅠㅠ 넘 잘불러ㅠㅠ
Everytime i hear her voice i end up feeling so proud of her, she sings with Emotion and her voice reaches all of my feelings. I will never get tired of her
누가 부르던, 신해철, 마왕의 노래를 기억하고 불러준다는 것 자체가 의미있다는 것이다.
Yuju love you 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍 😍
이노래가 하늘에 계신 마왕께도 닿길...ㅠㅠ
유주 넘나 멋있구...♥
Choi Yuna, the voice that always hits the feels. Powerful, angelic, emotional, beautiful, soulful, mesmerizing..😪❤ Thank you for singing👼🙏
Y Buddy id choi yuna is another name of yuju?
iPong singa her real name is Choi Yuna, Yuju is her stage name
유나야~~~~ 리메이크 앨범 하나 발매하자 꼭
눈물이 핑 돌 정도로 애절한 목소리 .. 영상이 6분인 게 아쉽다
정말 대단하죠, 나이 스물에(1997년생) 이 길고 어려운 곡을 혼자서 해 내다니. 천재입니다.
결과 어떻게 됐어요? 유주 나오는 편 못 봐서...
@@viviz8594 저도 당시 방송으로는 못 보고 유튜브로만 보았습니다.
유주의 창법이 목에 부담이 될 수도 있는 창법임에도 특유의 안정감은 그대로 유지하는 저 실력은 정말.........
성량 역시 대박이군요.......
이 날 1승도 못했다는 것이 이해가 안 될 정도의 퀄리티의 라이브인 것 같습니다.......
적어도 400표는 넘는 무대인데........
뮤지컬 했으면 좋겠다는 분들 많은데 그 의견들에 저도 찬성입니다^^
저 감성과 안정감은 정말.......
노래해줘서 고마워 유나야
진짜 사랑해 유나야...
I cry 😥😥😥😭😭😭😭😭😭 Choi Yuna SarangHae 😍😍😘😘😘😘😘
The voice that drawn me to Gfriend more, I'm so proud of her
I love YUJU because she's Yuju!
Thanks for singing choi yuju!
Perfectly perfect complete package!
Queen indeed.. 😭😭😭😍😍😍
It's already 2024 but this song yuju ver suddenly became my fav song these days❤️
무대 이쁘네 목소리도 이쁘넷 최유나언니 짱인듯ㅠㅠ❤
팬심 빼고 정말 최유나 노래 잘한다 저 노래에 감정을 마치 담아 전달하는 느낌임
yuju might cover this again at the bighit labels concert at the end of the year
갓유주
외쳐 갓유주 아세 갓 유세 유주
유주도 노래 은근 잘부른단 말이지 .. 보컬이 단단해 ..
은근이 아니라 잘 부르는거 아닐까요? 잘 부르는거 유명하던데요
@@user-fq6xk2cs4p 맞아여...자랑스럽쓰
은근이 아님 우리에겐 최강
보석이죠 진짜...🤍💙💜
고운 목소리에 감정표현까지 정말 감동이네요
Yuju 😍😍
생각나서 다시 찾아본 영상 너무 좋네요 마왕의 노래에 유주의 목소리까지 마음이 먹먹해집니다
YUJU UNNIE SARANGHAEYO
Can I say how proud I am that I stan this wonderful girl? Because of her and the rest of GFRIEND, I decided to stay on kpop and support them. They're the only gg I stan and some bg and GFRIEND is my ultimate group. So proud to stan them ㅠㅠ
Gonna be Buddy foreverㅠㅠ
Me too only stan gfriend and i know kpop just because them
Malaysia buddy here
Firdauz adam same
Firdauz adam same here
me too
you cant deny thats the best vocal performance in kpop
Yuju's the best female vocal of this generation... Yuju's just too good... slays it every time!!!
유주 화이팅!!
🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷🇰🇷
Yess🇰🇷👑😍
I saw her tear on stage , she had just given me emotion from her angelic voice . She's an angel
유주 노래야 두말하면 입아푸고...
마왕은 겁나 보고싶고...
눈물나고...ㅜ.ㅜ
TH BEST MAIN VOCAL CHOI YUNA
최고라서 최유나 유나언니 노래해줘서 고마워요 사랑해
스물한살이 이런 감성을 해석했다는게 놀라움..
Omg!!! The way she moved the audience. Seeing them crying. Ahhhh. She is just sooo goood!!! She deserves all of this. 🌹🌹💐
최고의 가수 최고의 목소리
그리고 우리들의 마음속 깊은 곳에 영원히 기억될 마왕 가수 신해철
ㅇㅈ......................
@@andy2440 님 늦은 시간에 답변해 주셔서 감사합니다 코로나 유행하는데 안 걸리게 마스크 꼭 쓰고 다니세요 항상 행복한 일들만 가득하길 바랄게요 화이팅!~♥
@@user-vm2fs7uh1t ㅎㅎ 감사합니당! 현민님두 코로나 조심하세요~!
@@andy2440 님 답변 감사합니다~♥
얼굴도 예쁘고 노래도 잘해... 😥💞
suddenly missing yuju on immortal song 🥹
oh my gosh... her beauty voice... goosebumps 😳
손승현버전보다 전 이게 좋네요,
질러대는데 이제는 피곤힌ㅂ니다
유나야 오래오래 가자 영원히
here voice in coming from here heart it so touching❤
Yuju!!! Wonderful 💖💖💖💖
The best only the best main vocal in my heart ㅠㅠ
유주야 노래해줘서 고맙다 사랑한다
Notice kpop because fall in love with gfriend, and fall in love with gfriend because of this voice 💕
Dea Amelia same as me! ✌ 😄
Yeah GFriend ultra quality brings me to kpop
Still they are the best kpop group untill now
Are we going to see yuju performing this song again with another artists on year end concert!?
YESSS!! I CAN’T WAITT😭✊🏻
와 이걸 이제야 보다니
저도 이제야 봤어요ㅜㅠ
Best vocalist
너무 잘한다 여자친구 화이팅!♡^^~ 유주언니 넘예뽀
유주는 아이돌을 넘어서 진짜 가수다....
YUJU💕💕
Omg yuju voice is so beautiful😙😙😙😙
유주님은 지금도 너무 좋지만 미래가 더욱 기대되네요.. 20살 초반에 저정도인데..
Yuju's voice is simply incredible....I'm so proud to be a Buddy😍😍😍
Words cant describe how proud i am of this girl. Shes really special..💕
진심이 담긴 무대 잘들었습니다
슬픈데도 마지막에 노래 망치지않으려고 감정조절하는거 멋지다
she sang beautifully ❤️
Go check out Yuju for Alice OST!!! Her technique isnt joke, chest register, modulation, low note, belting, high note etc.
Ahhhhh it's really touching😭❤
Our main vocal Choi Yuna😭
실력을 떠나서 이 명곡을 커버해줘서 고맙다.