Learn to Code or Game Design? Which is better? (and why?)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 ноя 2019
  • Check out the Course: bit.ly/3jd0tfM
    I see people ask the question all the time, should I learn to code or learn game design?
    Today I'll answer that question the best I can, and explain why I went into code & how I became a unity game programmer even though I'd always wanted to be an unreal game designer.
    I'll talk about the differences between the two positions, how to get jobs in code or design, and what it's like day to day working as a game programmer or a game designer.
    If you've been wondering what you should learn, which job is right for you? Design or Code? This video will lead you down the right path :) (don't worry, it's not ALWAYS code :)
    More Info: unity3d.college
    Join the Group: unity3d.group
    Patreon: / unity3dcollege

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @nameplaceholder
    @nameplaceholder 4 года назад +2617

    When I was at the university, we all wanted to become game designers and there were only few people that could program. I pulled the short straw in my group and ended up programming all the designs we came up throughout all our projects. The programming kinda grew on me, since I liked designing and optimizing systems and making them fun. Nowadays, I'm kind of the guy that sits with the designers and 'translates' to the programmers in a language they can understand and to also tell them what's just impossible to do within certain time budgets. I feel that the programmers and designers are a lot better than me, but having a diverse skill set can work out, too, I guess. Just do both! lol

    • @zenahrb8316
      @zenahrb8316 4 года назад +51

      Does your position have a name? Like... Technical Art translator or something.

    • @nameplaceholder
      @nameplaceholder 4 года назад +136

      @@zenahrb8316 I wish it had a cool name like Technical Designer or something, but I'm basically a Lead Programmer, since I was the only programmer back then and when people joined I just slipped into that role. It's funny how I'm the one that actually programs the least. lol

    • @kserra9112
      @kserra9112 4 года назад +1

      @JuJu I hear there's this guy name "
      Jason Weimann", that has some content covering this topic of coding.

    • @MrCorrectify
      @MrCorrectify 4 года назад +31

      "Game Designers" are idea guys. Everyone is one and everyone thinks they're the best. They usually wax philosophically about the state of gaming and how the world is unjust and won't give them a chance.
      Coders, artists, and project managers tend to be doers, and have the real world experience to know what ideas will work and why, as well as how to delegate tasks and distribute resources. Those are your future game designers and where you should spend your time if you actually want a shot at what is essentially a rockstar job (small handful of well paid positions in the world).
      I guess there's also rich people who can just throw money at a project and call themselves whatever they want.

    • @khevan5277
      @khevan5277 4 года назад +12

      That’s exactly the kind of thing I love doing too. Having knowledge in both fields so I can help in communication and also be able to do both tasks to a somewhat decent degree

  • @MadSki11s
    @MadSki11s 4 года назад +907

    "So my first game design interview,
    Went great!
    But I did not get the job."

    • @Unity3dCollege
      @Unity3dCollege  4 года назад +125

      Too funny and true... I should see if the guys who interviewed me even remember it or if they do and remember it completely differently :) may be getting together with one of them soon, now I've got something to talk about :)

    • @LumbridgeTeleport
      @LumbridgeTeleport 3 года назад +10

      Warcraft 3 orb of fire human merchant shop.

    • @larryboles5064
      @larryboles5064 3 года назад +20

      I bombed my first design interview too. But don't give up if that's what you really want to do. I kept trying and got in eventually.
      Been working as a designer for over 14 years now.
      Now I'm trying to pick up my coding skills so I can expand my options, try to release some of my own things.

    • @marcellbalog
      @marcellbalog 3 года назад +1

      @@larryboles5064 Are you perhaps a designer at Blizzard?

    • @larryboles5064
      @larryboles5064 3 года назад +1

      @@marcellbalog Yes sir

  • @Zeriel00
    @Zeriel00 4 года назад +4051

    Learn to code so when you can't get a job in game design you don't starve to death

    • @Bananenbauer123
      @Bananenbauer123 4 года назад +395

      This people. Wise words.

    • @artemisDev
      @artemisDev 4 года назад +56

      @COVID-19 PANDEMIC Or resist being a pandemic virus

    • @freelanceart1019
      @freelanceart1019 4 года назад +9

      @COVID-19 PANDEMIC the weaboos called you a hoax now in Japan, the Hikikomoris dead bodies are piling up.

    • @thedemonnoof4383
      @thedemonnoof4383 4 года назад +30

      @@freelanceart1019 You would figure the hikikomoris would be the last to get it and die because they never leave their flats. They always self quarantine themselves from the world.

    • @PanchomanPlusUltra
      @PanchomanPlusUltra 4 года назад +54

      I work in something really basic, gas delivery, part time, and in my spare time work on my game, everything self taught. My friend, who is studing informatic engineering always tells me "your code will always be bad cause you are not in college like ME, im a good coder cause Im at university and you're not blablabla" but I think hes just jealous cause I can code self taught and design and draw and compose music and design puzzles, etc. Basically what im trying to say is you dont need to study something "the propper way" (its better to have a degree but if you dont like to study, like me, you can do it by yourself), and you can make some money somewhere else while learning and developing your game!
      Sorry for my english, im not a native speaker and im stupid i cant help it.

  • @sandorhahn9441
    @sandorhahn9441 3 года назад +1227

    Learn both, they both help each other. And stay physically/socially healthy while you're doing it

    • @sandorhahn9441
      @sandorhahn9441 3 года назад +38

      there's an argument to be made in the favor of learning both, plus freedom as an artist/programmer is what we want right?

    • @yuxanne.
      @yuxanne. 3 года назад +23

      @@sandorhahn9441 there's always a learning curve anyways, you just gotta go through it to get set and comfortable with what you do
      I don't know code but as a music producer, and illustrator those are my thoughts. Game design I kind of have an advantage already being someone who draws and makes music, I do a little writing too lol, so coding is just another skill I want

    • @gedludek8245
      @gedludek8245 2 года назад +38

      “Stay physically/socially healthy”… menacing words.

    • @gedludek8245
      @gedludek8245 2 года назад +3

      I mean, you wrote like it’s an unusual thing to do both.

    • @AcridDragoon
      @AcridDragoon 2 года назад +21

      mental health, physical health, programming, game design- pick 2 or less

  • @kevinmiles5857
    @kevinmiles5857 3 года назад +243

    "Anybody can do Game Design, most people can't do it well". Amen.
    Even at a professional level this is true.

    • @fdevstudio5692
      @fdevstudio5692 2 года назад +1

      You are muslim?

    • @Sammysapphira
      @Sammysapphira 2 года назад +16

      Explains why so many game devs are out of touch with players.

    • @hplovecraftmacncheese
      @hplovecraftmacncheese 2 года назад +19

      @@fdevstudio5692 "Amen" is a Christian prayer word.

    • @JacobKinsley
      @JacobKinsley 2 года назад +1

      Animal crossing new horizons designers take note

    • @Speculaas
      @Speculaas 2 года назад +1

      Same goes for drawing.

  • @axolniz6597
    @axolniz6597 2 года назад +124

    I'm studying computer science, but always wanted to be a designer, after a while I found out that if you know how to code properly, getting into game design and really understanding what's possible or not is much easier for you. Coding is such a valuable skill, you can't lose anything if you learn it. After my bachelor in computer Sc I'm gonna apply for a short term game design program. I don't love coding, I know it's not for me but I wanna push through all these mathematics and problems to understand what it really takes to make a game.

    • @justsomeguywithasandwich5906
      @justsomeguywithasandwich5906 Год назад +18

      This is basically what I plan on doing in the future as well, study CS and get a bachelor degree. Get a job, and spend my free time learning about Game design and 2/3D Animation. I don’t like math, but I like the idea of being able to create a game. Maybe I’ll come back here to this comment in a few years for updates. I wish you the best of luck! Stay motivated!

    • @jmlopezponce
      @jmlopezponce Год назад +14

      WoW, I feel exactly the same way. I study CS too and I also wanted to be a designer. I'm plannig take a course of 3D odeling/Animation when I get a bachelor on CS. It's really nice to know people who feel the same way I do. however I do love coding, and I have been learning Computers Graphics which is an amazing field that combines Math, Design and Programming and helps you to understand all the magic behind the game engines. Have a nice day. Sorry by my english :)

    • @phunguyenminh2225
      @phunguyenminh2225 Год назад +1

      damn, i felt the same way.

  • @victorliebenberg2803
    @victorliebenberg2803 4 года назад +564

    Love to write: Check
    Love to design: Check
    Addicted to video games: ABsooLutelY
    GAME DESIGN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    • @pussinboots9983
      @pussinboots9983 3 года назад +126

      Game Design is the creative side of a game developer.
      Programming is the logical side of a game developer.

    • @cortesschemes7053
      @cortesschemes7053 3 года назад +1

      @@pussinboots9983 what do you mean.

    • @ThisisCitrus
      @ThisisCitrus 3 года назад +133

      @@cortesschemes7053 What he said is pretty self explanatory.

    • @prinniesforeveryone321
      @prinniesforeveryone321 3 года назад +54

      ​@@pussinboots9983 That's not the case at all. Programming takes a huge amount of creativity. You also need a toolset to back it up. At university I went to school with programmers and game design students. It was very very evident that the design students weren't going to be getting jobs when they graduated. Generally everyone can think of design. Not having any skills to apply it with means guess what? You're useless and nobody will hire you and I don't want you as a team member. In fact, yesterday someone messaged me saying my teammate and me seemed like we "get the job done" and when I asked what actual applicable skills he had he said "mostly design and writing" which to someone who can actually work in engine and actually IMPLEMENT IDEAS translates to "i wan maek gaem idea and have oders make it for me".

    • @egemenozan5641
      @egemenozan5641 3 года назад +16

      @@prinniesforeveryone321 great observation. A designer cant push their game to great lengths without knowing the limits of programming.

  • @nosirrahx
    @nosirrahx 4 года назад +188

    In the broader software industry you see a disconnect between the "idea guys" and the developers. A critically overlooked position is a liaison between the developers and "idea guys". This liaison understands both the idea phase and actual coding enough that they can effectively mediate the misunderstandings between the two teams.
    The takeaway from this is that if you learn design and coding you automatically unlock an additional potential job as liaison.

    • @orionmedivh5859
      @orionmedivh5859 2 года назад +7

      I think in software industry the ‘liaison guy’ are usually called software architect/director, etc?

    • @nosirrahx
      @nosirrahx 2 года назад +3

      @@orionmedivh5859 Maybe director but the architects are still designing stuff. This was just my observation watching people that were amazing at creating solutions and people that were amazing at coding solutions not having an easy time communicating with each other.

    • @orionmedivh5859
      @orionmedivh5859 2 года назад +2

      @@nosirrahx yeah, communication gap always exists and there's no easy solution for that.

    • @vornamenachname594
      @vornamenachname594 Год назад

      @@orionmedivh5859 it's generally part of the role of the designer who interfaces with the dev lead who translates it into tasks

  • @RealCoachMustafa
    @RealCoachMustafa 4 года назад +593

    I've been trying to be a game designer for so long and now I'm learning to program so I can be a programmer instead. The killer thing about being a designer is that your skills are not useful anywhere else. If you can't get a job as a game designer, you're boned. At least programmers can take their skills elsewhere and be software developers, plus software devs make more money.

    • @007MrYang
      @007MrYang 4 года назад +37

      you get some soft skills and some industry knowledge, but yeah, programming might be the better bet.

    • @ahalan13
      @ahalan13 3 года назад +11

      You can just make the safe way tho, apply for progamming while you train your writing, so one day you can use your reputation to switch jobs.

    • @juanalvarado7794
      @juanalvarado7794 3 года назад +17

      Whats a good way to learn programing and what language should I stick with? Im currently taking a course in Udemy for C# for unity engine. Is this a good way? Where should i go next?😀

    • @samljer
      @samljer 3 года назад +33

      @@juanalvarado7794 C# UnityDev is a decent way, AAA studios do make some stuff with it.
      but C++ with Unreal looks a lot better on paper. and is hugely more popular for most studios.
      Unity is easier to fiddle with if you want to solo make some games though, a lot easier.
      If you learned blender, with unity and C#, you could literally solo create a game as many have. it wont take nearly as long as it would with Unreal.

    • @vijaykvk1426
      @vijaykvk1426 3 года назад

      @@samljer hello

  • @stefke1993carina
    @stefke1993carina 4 года назад +269

    As a young game designer who's struggling with coding my own game, this video really helped! Thank you :)

    • @stefke1993carina
      @stefke1993carina 2 года назад +2

      @Yeet Yeet Not really. However, I did manage to make a prototype that got me into a program where I had a team, so I had programmers there to work with :D

    • @hipxel8918
      @hipxel8918 2 года назад

      Mee too!

    • @coar119
      @coar119 Год назад +1

      im 12 years old

    • @YourKyckling
      @YourKyckling Год назад +1

      @@coar119 Cool bro, it's good to start young

  • @nathanhung9057
    @nathanhung9057 4 года назад +190

    Took comp sci and game dev in high school. Loved it so much that I was able to use these skills in college combining the medical field and education. Now doing rehab research with game dev as well!

    • @thomasmadden3080
      @thomasmadden3080 3 года назад +5

      Can you elaborate on that more?

    • @dhirendersingh3687
      @dhirendersingh3687 3 года назад +4

      Yeah man what do you do for living ??

    • @vijayach3523
      @vijayach3523 3 года назад +1

      That was great bro

    • @GuitarListen
      @GuitarListen 2 года назад +4

      @@alexeliz75 CS is pretty prevalent in HS. Game dev though, never heard that lol

    • @lou9605
      @lou9605 2 года назад +1

      Woah we dont have comp sci here till college :/

  • @pattech3960
    @pattech3960 4 года назад +308

    Tip:
    It's not about which is better,
    it's about what you like to do :)
    For example, I love to do programming.
    So I would choose the Coding

    • @kserra9112
      @kserra9112 4 года назад +20

      Anyone likes what they do when they get good at it. I didn't like coding, but I pushed through enough and now I'm better at coding than I am at art, which is what I went to school for.
      So its really about being the type of person who looks at learning new things as the best use of their time.

    • @suplextrain
      @suplextrain 4 года назад +63

      "Anyone likes what they do when they get good at it."
      False. I was really good at my prior profession and it was a well paying job, but I didn't like doing it at all. I also had to study a lot of high level math back in school but I didn't enjoy doing it one bit, even though I got good grades.
      You CAN start enjoying something once you get more into it, but that's not a guarantee.

    • @fdevstudio5692
      @fdevstudio5692 2 года назад

      I learned both

    • @sonicraft9996
      @sonicraft9996 2 года назад +1

      Cringe

    • @orionmedivh5859
      @orionmedivh5859 2 года назад

      It is the very few who can truly turn their passion to their career. Sometimes, it’s the career chose you :(

  • @GreedAndSelfishness
    @GreedAndSelfishness 4 года назад +56

    Its real tough making a game on your own. Programming, modeling, animating, designing, writing, texturing...Without Unity/Unreal and Internet this shit would be almost impossible. And of course, passion is a must if you want to create a game. You must be 100% in. Time and love.

    • @kdmaarof8387
      @kdmaarof8387 4 года назад +1

      unity have a feature call team of work > and with this feature you will contact with a lot of folks who are in this programming unity , they will help you to complete your project , also you don't have invite strangers people , you just can invite you friends who , also work in the same fields .
      with unreal program I don't have much info about this program unfortunately, because literally I work with only program who is ( unity ) . And is also who makes a choice to start firstly with unity , i just told him he's / she's with the right choice .
      Sincerely

    • @GreedAndSelfishness
      @GreedAndSelfishness 4 года назад +1

      @@kdmaarof8387 Thats interesting.

    • @EnRaye
      @EnRaye 2 года назад

      ...

    • @newsmansuper2925
      @newsmansuper2925 8 месяцев назад

      Daisuke Amaya , hold my pixel.

  • @HVACTechMechanic
    @HVACTechMechanic 3 года назад +4

    I'm glad this video was recommended to me. You are great at explaining things!
    I have a full time job and only want to program/design for fun but this was very informative.

  • @Digitalgaming
    @Digitalgaming 3 года назад +8

    Wow dude you just oppened my mind to how different these two discipline are, thank you! Maybe going with programing first and then diving into the design aspect of things might be a better idea. Thanks Jason!

  • @brianpangburn5573
    @brianpangburn5573 4 года назад +23

    definitely interested in learning how to find work game programming
    , especially when you don't live anywhere near any game companies

  • @Salmontres
    @Salmontres 4 года назад +22

    Yes, please try to get some game designers for a quick interview. I would love to see that!

  • @frawsten
    @frawsten 4 года назад +19

    Thanks so much for this video! I’ve been trying to get a grasp of what I want to specifically study in college and this vid explained a lot to me and showed me that I’d lean more towards programming

  • @MidKnight_Sicario187
    @MidKnight_Sicario187 2 года назад

    Hey I’m starting school for video game coding this august. I just wanted to say I appreciate how upfront you are about the day to day of the job. I was really on the fence about design and programming. So thank you for making this video.

  • @jammahan
    @jammahan 11 месяцев назад +1

    Thank you sooo much for saying this! I love how you just talked about the daily tasks and skill sets of each role, along with what kind of person/interests align with the role. Everywhere I see, people attribute this a race war between game art, game programming, and game design when they're all supposed to work together. Even in college, by teachers, everyone had to validate why there tribe was the best and for the longest time I never had a concrete understanding about what they (especially game designers do. I would love to see more videos on game design and all the other stuff that go into the process (pre-planning, producing, quality assurance, etc.). Love your insights.

  • @carabidus
    @carabidus 3 года назад +16

    Thank you for this honest disclosure! I would imagine that digital artists who generate the assets have an even tougher time getting full time work. There are a LOT out there with the skills and I'm sure even super talented folks fall through the cracks.

  • @nivalius
    @nivalius 3 года назад +58

    legend says once upon a time there was no difference between game designers and programmers

  • @retex73
    @retex73 3 года назад +1

    Awesome course ! The pace was excellent - I didn't feel like I was racing to keep up hitting pause every few seconds. Great concepts and I really feel like I can go away and create a (basic) 2D game. Thank you for all your hard work

  • @skylergibson3161
    @skylergibson3161 3 года назад

    I'm about to go back to school this fall and I've been debating between literally these two positions and this video definitely had some important insight. I've always leaned towards design as I'm more creative than I am practical and logical, but I'm thinking of pushing towards programming for the stability and the ability to more efficiently turn the creative ideas I do have into something tangible. Thanks for making this video!

  • @ProfFibi
    @ProfFibi 3 года назад +31

    That bit about game devs being able to make a prototype of a game idea on their own really solidified programming for me. Thanks so much for explaining everything so clearly.

  • @sockMonster241
    @sockMonster241 4 года назад +4

    New sub, very interested in game design. Expanding on that would be super helpful, especially since you're actually in the industry. A lot of channels out there talk about game design but don't really have experience doing it or dealing with designers. It's a big topic and finding good information is tough. Thanks a lot, and great video 👍

  • @shawn4664
    @shawn4664 3 года назад

    You do a great job of communicating your thoughts. Great video, glad to have found your channel.

  • @GotCamel
    @GotCamel 2 года назад

    WOW!!! I have been fighting myself on whether I want to go to school for game design or programming and you cleared that right up for me! Game programming it is! Thank you so much for all of this info!!

  • @Remi10pm
    @Remi10pm 3 года назад +7

    This sounds sooo FUN. I'm an Artist (Graphic Design, Animation) & I was considering software development... but its like do I have a passion for it? But your description sounds like Game Programming is something I would love to do on a day to day. I could also design and* create my own projects!! ^__^

  • @diysly6950
    @diysly6950 3 года назад +6

    You are SO right! I come from web developpement, 20 years of fullstack experience. I started to work on game stuff (physics and VR) as a enthousiast and this is seriously a challenge. Web APIs are so easy to master and even to create... I just finished a API for my client to let them sell online through resellers, it took 2 big weeks and its done! But my VR module? I have been putting in a 20 hours a week for 1 and a half years and still no release. Jeez...

  • @zodiaq7186
    @zodiaq7186 2 года назад

    This video really opened my eyes. Thanks Jason!

  •  Год назад

    Love the insight! Very good talk

  • @dreamingacacia
    @dreamingacacia 4 года назад +61

    I'm a solo indie game developer, A lot going through my brain here. I'm glad that the wall is quite high so not just anybody could stay in this path for long. Well I don't have any published game yet, but I fall enough to know that I would never give up.

    • @dreamingacacia
      @dreamingacacia 4 года назад +6

      @@ericalbers3923 though it's true, but my ego say something else. I would rather die with it than just give up on my path.

    • @ZoidbergForPresident
      @ZoidbergForPresident 4 года назад +2

      @@dreamingacacia Good luck to you, may trends not get in your way. ;)

    • @Ne0mega
      @Ne0mega 4 года назад +4

      With you Acacia. Two years Solo dev now, lots of pain, not even close to giving up. Technology is rapidly progressing, constantly making easier and easier to use programs. I'll get there in the end. And like you, I am glad the wall is high.

    • @dreamingacacia
      @dreamingacacia 4 года назад

      @@Ne0mega I think the rapidly growth on technology is still irrelevant right now especially solo dev. If you use mainstream engine you'll never got outdated, folks with their personal custom engine would be quite hard there unless they know what they're doing.

    • @yulihere
      @yulihere 3 года назад

      Hey! How's your game going so far? hope you're still working!!!

  • @mykilpee
    @mykilpee 4 года назад +17

    Same reason why I've always wanted to get into games...

  • @dorfriedman9115
    @dorfriedman9115 4 года назад

    Always good to here from you :)

  • @borisnaftaliev2911
    @borisnaftaliev2911 Год назад

    Deep thoughts, Jason. Thank you. 👍

  • @nickyoutube3757
    @nickyoutube3757 4 года назад +136

    Programming may be reasonably easy to learn, but physics and math is hard.

    • @JaguarPanda
      @JaguarPanda 4 года назад +41

      you can program a lot of different game types that won't rely on crazy physics, as for math, you'll probably mainly use vector maths... pretty easy stuff really.

    • @thedesertfox7502
      @thedesertfox7502 4 года назад +48

      Programming has basic maths. It's pure logic

    • @paglaith5561
      @paglaith5561 2 года назад +6

      There are libraries for everything. You don't even need to know the maths to use them.

    • @anirudhkumar9139
      @anirudhkumar9139 2 года назад +11

      @@thedesertfox7502 Well depends. Most programs do require simple arithmetic only, but for more advanced and research based things, the maths gets much more complex. Also I think Nick is talking about the courses in college rather than the ones you face in day to day work tbh.

    • @slash148
      @slash148 2 года назад +10

      Funny thing is... Maths and Physics are not much harder than programming itself. It is just that the way physics and maths is teached in schools is not the best, and that made us hate them. If you were thaught programming in school, you'd probably think it is hard too.
      Wanna try? Look for free math and physics courses here in youtube. Search for one that teaches in a way you find easy to follow, and you will be amazed of your own progress.

  • @darshan9188
    @darshan9188 3 года назад +13

    I would love a video about the work conditions, work hours and income for game design and game programming

    • @setayeshfatehi3760
      @setayeshfatehi3760 3 года назад

      Work hours 👌I like my eyes, but I'd like to be a programmer too, somehow the thing that scares me is, if I become a programmer, do I have to were glasses after some years? 😶

  • @Irishpierre1
    @Irishpierre1 3 года назад

    You're very informative, I appreciate the knowledge and experience you bestow onto your viewers! Your videos are nice and clean and you explain things as though you care, instead of "preaching" to a crowd!

  • @kevinsamarasekara3829
    @kevinsamarasekara3829 3 года назад

    Thank you so much. I didn't know which path to choose and I was stressing out and you've helped me alot. Thanks ✌️

  • @michaelros7817
    @michaelros7817 4 года назад +8

    Hey there, since you were mentioning tools design so prominently, could this be something that you could perhaps sometime do a (couple of) video(s) about? Like more imroving the UnityEditor kind of stuff, making tools that designers could potentially use?

  • @justinwhite2725
    @justinwhite2725 4 года назад +71

    Thanks for this. I'm a programmer that's been trying to start my own game studio - what you said about 'if you know how to code it's easy to get non game work'
    A friend of a friend of mine needed a unity programmer to do someAR work with vuforia (basically animating painted window murals). I had never done anything with AR/VR but I've got the all working and we've been doing events all over Calgary for 3 years. I have no degree in programing completely self taught but I picked up just enough to make money programming in unity even if it's not on games.

    • @acetown2263
      @acetown2263 4 года назад

      Hell yeah man, you're living my dream =) I'm jealous but in a good way. Someday this coding will click with me I hope!

    • @blackknightjack3850
      @blackknightjack3850 4 года назад +1

      There was a programming firm that hosted a game developer meetup every month and I remember asking exactly what kind of work a firm like this would be taking part in that would require a professional programmer and the answer I got made it sound like they primarily made applications akin to forms you can make in Access. It sounded like they developed things you can learn to program yourself with about a year of simple college programming classes.

    • @juanalvarado7794
      @juanalvarado7794 3 года назад

      Whats a good way to learn programing and what language should I stick with? Im currently taking a course in Udemy for C# for unity engine. Is this a good way? Where should i go next?😀

    • @justinwhite2725
      @justinwhite2725 3 года назад

      @@juanalvarado7794 C# and unity are what I use, so it's well enough. At any rate the biggest thing to take away is the thought patterns behind programming and not the language itself. Once you understand the flow of code it doesn't matter what language you use really. Different languages have some special features that are handy, though. C# and the. Net suite are heavily object oriented based.

  • @MQNGameDev
    @MQNGameDev 4 года назад +1

    Thanks for the great info. Id love to hear more about how to get a job in programming. I've been coding for years but I have never had a job in it. I created an Upwork profile but wasn't sure how much to charge. So hearing more on the subject would really help myself and others like me. Thanks, Jason for all your awesome info.

  • @breadenthusiast
    @breadenthusiast 3 года назад

    Subscribed. Fantastic, content! FYI, I really dig your workspace!

  • @Akrymir
    @Akrymir 4 года назад +3

    Great video. Tools and engine coders are very under appreciated outside of the industry.
    As a programmer who went to school for game development but got into enterprise software, I'd recommend going to a good school for a CS degree instead of a game focused one. This gives you more options and more stability. You can get a non game dev job right out of school while working on the game development skills on the side. This way you can look for a job you want in game development instead of getting stuck with a job you need to pay the bills. Many of the programmers I know in the games industry do not work on the kinds of games they want to. That's not the say they are unhappy with their job, just that the job isn't as rewarding as it could be which is important when you consider sacrifices that come with game development.
    Also, most of the game specific schools do a terrible job teaching you the skills you need to know. If you are going to go to a game dev school then I'd highly recommend Digipen in Redmond, WA.

  • @salehamini2036
    @salehamini2036 4 года назад +7

    Please talk more about how you get paid and also if possible brings a designer to have some talk.
    Love you

  • @animesh6535
    @animesh6535 2 года назад +1

    Thanks for making this video
    It just made all the thing so clear in my mind

  • @julianb4432
    @julianb4432 4 года назад

    Im interested in that expounded pay side video.
    I study Interactive Media in Sydney Australia. Originally I entered into the bachelors to become a game designer, but more and more I discover everyday that it seems MUCH more rewarding to be a programmer with a flair for design, rather than a designer with a flair for programming? Still making up my mind on how I want to try and enter the industry. Finishing up my third year of study after 1.5 more semesters.
    Your channel is a godsend.

  • @BudLeiser
    @BudLeiser 4 года назад +62

    100% THIS!
    Great video. Wish this was out 10 years ago for myself and for others. You should have mentioned that theres NOTHING wrong with a game designer taking courses in programming. In fact it will really help them land those interviews AND if they ever want to make their own games they can. LISTEN TO 37 year old me, if you wanna make/design games go learn programming!

    • @jordangales6633
      @jordangales6633 2 года назад

      Any tips for a novice to find a good mentor or someone to point me in the right direction. I have a lot of questions and goals.

    • @axolniz6597
      @axolniz6597 2 года назад +3

      You made this comment 2 years ago and I listened to it. I'm studying computer science, but always wanted to be a designer, after a while I found out that if you know how to code properly, getting into game design and really understanding what's possible or not is much easier for you. Coding is such a valuable skill, you can't lose anything if you learn it. After my bachelor in computer Sc I'm gonna apply for a short term game design program. I don't love coding, I know it's not for me but I wanna push through all these mathematics and problems to understand what it really takes to make a game.

    • @BudLeiser
      @BudLeiser 2 года назад +2

      @@axolniz6597 That's awesome brother good for you!

    • @EnRaye
      @EnRaye 2 года назад

      ...

  • @guilhermeissa3600
    @guilhermeissa3600 4 года назад +23

    I imagine game designers for fighting games might as well be cuffed to the art team knowing how much animation, frames and visibility are essential for the design of any fighting game character

  • @pure-kuro8573
    @pure-kuro8573 3 года назад

    thank you very much, I kept getting confused with game design and game programming. You're awesome.

  • @thecharliewhiskey
    @thecharliewhiskey Год назад

    Starting my journey as a game dev right now and this was phenomenal information! Thanks for sharing!

  • @Bahcorp
    @Bahcorp 4 года назад +131

    Do both and feel happy like me.

    • @joecorr288
      @joecorr288 4 года назад +7

      Exactly!

    • @Programm4r
      @Programm4r 4 года назад +15

      game design is a very broad subject (level design, content design, lore, mechanics, etc.)
      I stick to programming and gameplay mechanics. But i've done it all.

    • @RangeFlam3r
      @RangeFlam3r 4 года назад +2

      @@Programm4r Do you have any school experience? If so, what do you recommend for someone who has zero experience but just a want, to get into the industry

    • @Programm4r
      @Programm4r 4 года назад +4

      XRP PHOENIX yes, I’ve got school experience in games and web. It’s hard to say what to recommend, I don’t know anything about you.
      Are you looking for good paying jobs? I’d recommend into programming. In addition there’s a lot of employers (not just for games) looking for programmers. Computer science would be the best route to take.
      Have you ever worked in campaign editors or map editors? If that’s your thing, level design would be up your alley. You can also use your mods or maps as portfolio pieces.
      Whatever you decide, be sure you learn or take a couple courses in “agile scrum.” That’s how software developers work in large teams to manage projects. You’ll need it.

    • @GreedAndSelfishness
      @GreedAndSelfishness 3 года назад +7

      You dont seem very happy in your profile pic.

  • @johnburien4391
    @johnburien4391 4 года назад +5

    I'd like to see the salary video maybe cover all fields

  • @bahtiyorusmanov7211
    @bahtiyorusmanov7211 3 года назад

    Thank you! You have shed light on many things.

  • @softskin1669
    @softskin1669 4 года назад

    Thank you SO MUCH for making this!!!!

  • @t-dabbingt-dabber2298
    @t-dabbingt-dabber2298 3 года назад +6

    Every person looking to develop games should watch this video.

  • @dukemagus
    @dukemagus 4 года назад +5

    Jason, could you do a video about general "types" of programming jobs you can get in a big game company? Like grahics/shader programmer, database, network, AI, simulation, etc. What's better to focus on each, what's the "difficulty level" of each, recommended tools and languages to learn, etc.

  • @OnPoint760
    @OnPoint760 Год назад

    Thank you for this. your video helped me see the differences in specialties when creating a game.

  • @FaebuOG
    @FaebuOG 3 года назад +1

    Man 6 minutes into the video and you made such an inpact on my life I swear!

  • @seagullfire2764
    @seagullfire2764 Год назад +8

    As an new indie game developer who is having to do everything, what I learned from this video is I really REALLY wish I could afford to hire a game coder to help free me to be just a designer.
    I'm having to learn to code enough to finish my first game. Hopefully at least, if I can grow my company for future games my coding knowledge will just make it easier to work with programmers and be a better designer for them to work for.

  • @PorthoGamesBR
    @PorthoGamesBR 2 года назад +3

    A good game designer need to know just enough about every area in the making of a game, so i think the best aproach is to learn game design and choose a specialization (An area that you will learn more about than the others). IF you want to make games as a hobby or just want to work in the area because its lucrative, i recomend programming or other specialized area (Art, music, special effects, etc).

  • @Revulga
    @Revulga 3 года назад +1

    This was a very helpful and informative video. Thank you for the information.

  • @Matty.B
    @Matty.B 2 года назад

    Thanks for sharing! Great video.

  • @alancurson8009
    @alancurson8009 2 года назад +4

    I curently am in university and 4 months away from my Bacholers degree in Game Design. I want to say thank you, this has helped me see the difference between the two because though I have learned alot about game design I learned what is probably considered basics of coding and I am not very good at it but I was really hoping I would be better at coding comeing in to my degree, I was under the impression that coding was synonamous with game design and I did not really understand why I did not have more classes going over C#/C++ or any other coding language for that matter. I am not saying this because I feel that the university has done wrong, I love where I am going to school. I think it was more that I didnt understand and I my classes are very fast paced. It was not obviuos that they are quit different jobs. So again thank you for this video.

  • @noanyobiseniss7462
    @noanyobiseniss7462 3 года назад +15

    You want to know how you know a interview went well?
    When the guy says "when can you start".

  • @NeonCyberSamurai
    @NeonCyberSamurai 2 года назад

    Thanks for the insight , hope this info changes my life for the better ✌🏿

  •  4 года назад

    You are a great influence, Jason. Thank you for your videos.

    • @RachelWilliams-um1en
      @RachelWilliams-um1en 8 месяцев назад

      Hello, how are you doing today 😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊😊

  • @benoitrousseau4137
    @benoitrousseau4137 4 года назад +32

    With the atrocious crunch and overwork culture of the game industry, having the option to branch out and get an 8 to 5 job with Fridays off is definitely a massive advantage that comes with being a programmer, especially once you have kids and want to see them grow. I wouldn't say that non-game programmer jobs are easy though. (You definitely don't want bad a mediocre programmer to work in embedded systems, hardware drivers or safety critical stuff.) It's mostly web and mobile development that is mindbogglingly easy (and boring...) and that seem to be 80% of the job offers I see.

    • @orionmedivh5859
      @orionmedivh5859 2 года назад

      Had same thoughts about the ‘non-game programmer jobs are easier ‘ part. There are easy ones, of course, but there are also challenging ones as well, e.g. in the AI/ML field.

  • @MTrax
    @MTrax 4 года назад +16

    I‘ve been working as a non game Android dev since 2011. I kinda feel the same about the auto pilot mode. Most of the time we do the same stuff under different names with different with different architecture.
    Even in a mobile development environment, which is the fastest changing besides game dev that I can think of, it’s really nothing new.
    I never made the change to a game dev though. Mostly because of money. I feel that you do not get paid as good as a regular developer. I don’t say that I do not like what I am doing. The team is most of the times awesome. Since there are less constrains, you can actually influence the products you build. But something inside of me always drags me back to the idea to becoming a game developer.

  • @CodeLife_12
    @CodeLife_12 4 года назад +1

    Hey, I'd love to see the video about game dev's salary you talked about! Great videos btw!

  • @endodroidgames5363
    @endodroidgames5363 4 года назад

    This gave me a lot of confidence, thankyou!

  • @JustGabe
    @JustGabe 3 года назад +23

    When you mentioned the benefits of a Game Designer, recognition was the very first thing that came into mind, and no why they get almost all the credits: they're the masterminds of a game and the directors that make everything fit well together. While the programmers' job is undoubtedly important, they don't get even half the recognition because you can find several great programmers, but very few great designers.

  • @santoscolon530
    @santoscolon530 4 года назад +24

    god why can’t I find the exact answer to my questions like this everytime

  • @RubberDuckyGuy
    @RubberDuckyGuy 2 года назад

    Thanks man explaining this stuff helps a lot off people

  • @anthonywallace5081
    @anthonywallace5081 3 года назад

    Great vids man, just graduated Games Design and Games Programming 🎮 trying to feel out what to do next these are a great resource thank you

  • @masterctrlx1567
    @masterctrlx1567 3 года назад +71

    The globe in the bottom right is moving. There now you're distracted.

  • @NorthstriderGaming
    @NorthstriderGaming 4 года назад +4

    Meh, this makes the decision even harder because I love programming but also creating concepts. I mean most of my programming experience comes from programming emulators which involves alot of understanding the background mechanics of a game and I think this alone gave me quite some ideas how to approach a game properly in terms of programming.

  • @jonobacon
    @jonobacon 2 года назад

    Great work, Coach Beard.

  • @shanta32220
    @shanta32220 3 года назад

    Thank you Jason. I learnt a lot. You're awesome!

  • @warpzone8421
    @warpzone8421 3 года назад +232

    Why not learn neither and just take peoples' money for ten years for a game that takes two weeks to make, like Yandere Dev?

    • @ronkeylinarizini8049
      @ronkeylinarizini8049 3 года назад +5

      Lol

    • @deadmeme1296
      @deadmeme1296 3 года назад +10

      I WASNT EXPECTING THAT 💀💀💀

    • @augustjay6436
      @augustjay6436 3 года назад +3

      @@i-p1363 or.....OR.... you have no idea what he's talking about and are just a random rude person on the internet.

    • @strrawberrytekken3698
      @strrawberrytekken3698 3 года назад +4

      @@augustjay6436 must of been that cause i-p13 be gone LMAO

    • @augustjay6436
      @augustjay6436 3 года назад +2

      @@strrawberrytekken3698 lmao I don't know what I was right about but I'm happy about it

  • @CodemasterJamal
    @CodemasterJamal 4 года назад +4

    I think when I finally start searching for a job, I'm going to go into Programming. I can get into Programming a lot more. Game Design is interesting but, I prefer to design systems and tools that people can use.

    • @NukeCloudstalker
      @NukeCloudstalker 4 года назад +1

      designing tools for game designers feel an awful lot like a game in and of itself to me!
      It's so f*cking satisfying to make a tool that is flexible and unbreakable, that the designers suddenly use in ways neither they nor yourself saw coming!
      It's a lot of fun!
      However, when they suddenly make 10.000 nested objects with a tool that wasn't made with that purpose in mind, that can spell trouble, lol.
      But really, making the tools for people to make good games, feels very much like playing some sim-/engineering-game like Factorio or the like. I can only recommend it - although I haven't done it in any strictly professional setting yet, only in an internship semester at uni.

  • @JossinJax
    @JossinJax 3 года назад

    Your instructional video on getting starting with game production really inspired me. Wanting to break into the industry. There's so much to learn! I'm in my senior year in CS and still feel like a noob :/

  • @kykilli3126
    @kykilli3126 2 года назад

    I appreciate you doing these videos on industry experiences. I designed a game and I am always dropping off at the part of the interview from people who reached out to me, where they realize I have never worked on a team at a studio before. I have been wondering what exactly am I missing from that experience to have the interview drop off at that point every time by people who reached out to me to interview. This is helping me under stand the workflow better I guess. I created cannabis farmer strain master its on steam. My first project I learned C# on and Unity.

  • @pastuh
    @pastuh 3 года назад +11

    Created a lot of maps for TF2 , Counter-Strike , Starcraft and so on..
    Created some tools with Javascript..
    So it's time to create game :X

    • @JoJoKaiser1504
      @JoJoKaiser1504 3 года назад

      Are any tf2 maps you made in the official map roster?

    • @pastuh
      @pastuh 3 года назад

      @@JoJoKaiser1504 in official map no, but in random servers sometimes appears :)
      "pastuh gamebanana"

    • @JoJoKaiser1504
      @JoJoKaiser1504 3 года назад

      @@pastuh Shame that none of them are in the official maps, but i'm glad to hear that you left a mark on the game :)

  • @johnburien4391
    @johnburien4391 4 года назад +3

    I feel like I'm towering over you when I watch your videos lol.

  • @scottisitt
    @scottisitt 4 года назад

    Very helpful insight. Thank you!

  • @Greatdictator
    @Greatdictator 4 года назад +1

    Hey i just came across this video today and i want to say THANK you for helping clear up on the diffrence cause i hear a lot when it comes to being a game designer needing to code / programming. Obviously it helps but im glad its not a nessecity (im more a creative myself haha )

  • @mightyfineincredible2252
    @mightyfineincredible2252 3 года назад +11

    I'm concerned and interested in game design. I've heard from many people that a degree in game design is completely useless, but I'm entirely aware that no one is going to hire me because of my 'game design' degree, but because of my portfolio. Just as it is with all other design and art related degrees - portfolio is what matters, degree does not.
    So, I've been wondering if I should get a degree in game design or not. I'm not really interested in programming or computer science since they get too technical for me, but I am willing to learn some programming while studying for a game design degree - I just don't want to make it my major. The subjects I AM interested in are writing, art, animation, music and design.
    I also wonder if cheap colleges are worth it. In Europe, there are many cheap colleges in the Netherlands, for example. I don't know if it's better to get a degree from a cheap European college or an expensive American/Asian one.

    • @xXItzLazerzXx
      @xXItzLazerzXx 3 года назад +1

      MightyFineIncredible Just to give some input on the topic of American colleges, as someone who is currently enrolled in one, I think that it’s worth noting that just because our schools are expensive doesn’t mean that they provide a higher quality of education. From my own experience, much of the curriculum is standardised (especially within the first two years), meaning that what you get at a community college here for $4,000 a semester can be identical to what a private school for $20,000 a semester can offer. The high cost is largely a product of private institutions exploiting the demand for post-high-school education in the workplace, in addition to the constant creep of attempting to “out do” other schools by making larger, more lavish campuses. Unless your concern is how the name of a specific school looks on your résumé (even then, the really prestigious colleges here tend to have ridiculously high application expectations and tuition costs) it may be a better idea to seek European schools (this said, I know much less about education in Europe in comparison to what we have here in the U.S.). While I’d genuinely suggest looking into the subject yourself, as only you can know what’s best for you, I hope that this was helpful.

    • @TheHed94
      @TheHed94 3 года назад +1

      As a European, I can tell you that our colleges are on the same or even higher level than the one in US. The difference in price is because in Europe we see the education as an invest in the future, so they are accesible to anyone. Thats why its paid by tax payers and not the students.
      With that said, I completely agree with you about the necesity of degree in gaming or IT industry. You dont really need it, the skills you have are more important.
      BUT having a degree certainly helps, it never hurts. If there are two candidates with the same skills, guess who wins. Also college helps you grow as a person. You dont really know who you are until you attend one 😅

    • @TheHed94
      @TheHed94 3 года назад +1

      @@xXItzLazerzXx Yea some schools are monetizing its name so hard. Its like Samsung or Apple, you pay the higher price just for the name.
      As I have written in the other comment here, EU schools are as good as the US ones. The price is just matter of different view about the education. We take education as an invest into future, thus making it cheap or free so anyone has opportunity to get proper education he deserves. Tax payers pay the difference. 😅

  • @Panosky
    @Panosky 3 года назад +3

    I see a lot of people either saying that game design by itself is tricky to find a job in the field, so you need to learn game design and programming. Well, I am a game designer and have a background in growth marketing and business analysis (and am a History with Archaeology graduate) and they go together great.
    Programming is not the only profession to mix with game design, branch out to what you like/think it provides value - besides programming or game design, you need an extra edge over everyone else who stays in the box.

    • @irocklalot
      @irocklalot 3 года назад

      Hey, I'm a 3d level designer with a degree in marketing, would like to ask you how?

    • @Panosky
      @Panosky 3 года назад

      @@irocklalot how I mix the two?

    • @irocklalot
      @irocklalot 3 года назад

      @@Panosky yeah, how much money you can get, how it could be for international worker, etc.

    • @Panosky
      @Panosky 3 года назад

      @@irocklalot if you want, I have the whole recipe for success; details everything, how much money, in how much time, where, when, why etc.

    • @irocklalot
      @irocklalot 3 года назад

      @@Panosky yeah sure, I appreciate some advice, got Facebook or Instagram?

  • @Gords1229
    @Gords1229 4 года назад +2

    hi Jason,
    Yes I would more content on game design (guests will be amazing also) and
    Yes i would like more content on jobs/pay for programmers/game deveoplers (junior to senior roles)
    i have seen some of your stuff before as I was looking for tutorials on some programing stuff i needed to do as part of a Game dev degree. As I am almost completed that degree this topic is something that is on the forfront of my mind as I move into the industry.
    subbed and hope to see more great stuff on the channel

  • @andreasmoyseos5980
    @andreasmoyseos5980 3 года назад

    Thank you very much for your content, it's very valuable. Keep up the great work!

  • @pudgystump
    @pudgystump 4 года назад +4

    Would love to hear more about the pay for game programming!

  • @vikingghost117
    @vikingghost117 2 года назад +4

    I would love to know what a good place to start is for getting into programming tools and what not for games. My background is basically college drop out because I suck at school but I love programming. I instead have been taking Udemy and Skill share courses for Full stack Dev and QA. I've even gone to a full stack bootcamp and made it through the first 2 stacks.
    Currently I'm trying to just get my foot in the door anywhere and because of my experience in programming QA seemed like the easiest way into the computer science/tech field, I'm getting interviews and all that so I feel it's only a matter of time before I get a job in the QA field and automation, but I KNOW I don't want to stay there. I just love making things too much to stay in a position where I'm just testing other things that other people are making. Don't get me wrong it's an important part of the process, and definitely beneficial for me in seeing the big picture.... I guess my question is, how do I move forward from here?
    My basic plan is once I'm settled at a new job that pays the bills, I'm going to devote all my free time to learning Unity, and Blender so I can just start building things... get confident enough to do some game jams and hopefully get some recognition and potentially employed that way, or at least have it on a resume. I like many people here have plllllenty of ideas for what would make a cool game story and fun game play, but I just want to see those ideas come to fruition sooner rather than never, you know what I mean? Not like I"m asking for shortcuts, but just the fastest track possible. I don't care if I have to take a pay cut even just to get in, as long as there's a way upward and forward.
    THANKS FOR THIS CHANNEL AND ALL YOU DO! Super useful and I come away edified every time.

    • @AwesomelyVideos
      @AwesomelyVideos 2 года назад +1

      good luck with your endeavors

    • @vikingghost117
      @vikingghost117 2 года назад

      @@AwesomelyVideos thank you :D. you as well

    • @diqueze
      @diqueze 2 года назад +1

      Good luck hope your dreams come true I want to learn to code and program but I am thinking about using buildingblock first just to start off to see what it’s like to make a game without coding then transition to unity later on

  • @ajhenning4246
    @ajhenning4246 Год назад +1

    I'd definitely be very interested in a video about pay differences between designers and programmers/coders. How the entry level and top pay varies from designer and developer. I'm starting school soon and want to make sure I'm going to take the correct courses for what interests me more. If you could also go in depth on what skills or personality types are better for both too that would help give me great insight.
    Please make the video!! Lol, thank you

  • @caiobastos9085
    @caiobastos9085 4 года назад

    Highly informative and super fun video! Thanks!!!

  • @mytube1411
    @mytube1411 4 года назад +4

    I’m wanting to find a good paying job so I’d be interested in salaries of each

  • @hurshwardhannashine6128
    @hurshwardhannashine6128 4 года назад +4

    Please talk about the jobs and their pays

    • @kexyp
      @kexyp 3 года назад

      You could literally search up this info, $70k - $100k
      Edit: it all depends on the success of the game itself

  • @nadsplo5379
    @nadsplo5379 3 года назад

    This is really interesting and gave me great info . Please do a video about game designer jobs and also starting it as a indie game developer

  • @YouCanMove
    @YouCanMove 4 года назад

    I’d love to see a video on game design as a job and more on game programming jobs!!