GUYS (of all genders, obviously): THANK YOU! This vid got zero traction when I first posted it, but in the past month it has picked up roughly 6K views. That isn't much for most channels, but for mine, it's huge. So thank you, thank you, thank you! 🤘
Regarding where this band is from. There's a definite accent from the singer before they covered "Like A Prayer". They started a tour in South America, a lot of bands start touring in their home countries and possibly continents. In the song "Feel The Zeal" Lilith punishes herself by kneeling on rice and in "My First Peak" she kneels on corn. Both as punishment. While these are old, outdated punishments, I could only find mention of them among South American Catholics. I could be wrong but it's been hella fun trying to guess and speculate the origins of Dogma!
Great to hear it! Thanks for joining the conversation (and check out my review of their Lima show, if you're interested: ruclips.net/video/rApNMhpMPlE/видео.htmlsi=iJfnHRFQb5WaXcQy ) 🤘
I was at Dogma's first headliner show ever in Mexico City. They are a great live band! They never lose character and their show is pure rock'n'roll. They introduced a couple of new songs and they sound pretty good.
I saw Dogma on November 17, 2024 in San Antonio. They are great!! I got to meet them at a Meet&Greet after the show. They didn't say much, but they each handed me a trinket. They each said in a soft and beautiful voice as they handed me the trinket, "This is for you". I was thrilled to say the least. I got some pictures as well. My new favorite band.
I'm glad that there's more people getting obsessed with this magnificent band. The last time this happened to me was with Ghost, for obvious reasons. I love the threaticallity, the mystery, the concept behind it, but most of all, the music. I'm so hyped about attending their debut live show, right here in Mexico City. :")
@@Georgie_idol ¡Eso es realmente algo bueno! Los primeros dos o tres shows de cualquier gira, de cualquier artista, inevitablemente contienen cosas que no funcionan bien, pero para su concierto en la Ciudad de México (el tercero de la gira), ya deberían haber resuelto la mayoría de los problemas. ¡Es emocionante que vayas! ¡Por favor, infórmanos y cuéntanos si disfrutaste el espectáculo! 🤘
Dogma at Present is composed of entirely new members. An article, in the authors own analysis, stated that 11 females altogether have used the respective pseudonyms at least two times, with the recent members still unrevealed. That said, the former members were: Lilith I - Isa Roddy Lamia I - Bruna Terroni Nexi I - Lina dela Parra Abrahel I - Nanu Villalba Abrahel II - I forgot her name... :(, but all talented musicians on their own.
There have indeed been several! If you'll check out the WeAreDogma group at a website that RUclips erases any mentions of--but it rhymes with "Fled It"--you can find some very well researched material about the band's members and history. Thanks for watching! 🤘
Are you sure that their drummer was Nanu? I thought that especially after Nanu moves and "stopped playing drums" I thought that somehow it was her actually playing in the band. Anyway Im pretty sure that their actual bass player is from Argentina.... Dont know if she recorded the album or is only playing live....
Original singer Isa Roddy is a solo artist now Original guitarist Bruna torreni is a solo artist original bassist lina De la parra is in a band named Highway original drummer Nanu Villalba was in nervosa but left in early 2023 and now session and for hire.they all have Instagram accounts hopefully they will reform under a new name because the original 4 are very talented musicians just listen to the videos they're sound is much tighter than these new players 😊
@@roberthoeg1964 I disagree that the original four sound tighter than the current lineup. However, I completely agree with the sentiment that those original four should form a band of their own! Thanks very much for watching and joining the conversation! 🤟
I think that one of them (only in one of their videos) is a Colombian Bassist I will go to the first show in Mexico City on July 4th and Im realy impatient to see Dogma´s show, they have an amazing concept Thanks for this interesting video, greetings from Mexico 🤘
Thanks so much for watching and commenting! Let us all know how the Mexico City show goes. I'm going to Peru to see them July 10, so I'll report back from there. I'm very curious to hear whether the Lilith at the Meet & Greet session is the same voice as she who recorded the answers to my interview questions. It's a testament, I think, to the songwriting and the vision that even though we all know this band has already been a revolving door of members, I am still ridiculously psyched to see & hear them live. 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 I have the M&G ticket too, Sure¡ after the concert Im going to let you know how was it. you dont know who are the actual members and neither do I Hahaha In spite of that I´m really excited
The band - at least, the band that performs in videos and presumably the forthcoming tour, absolutely did not come together "organically". Every single member has been replaced, some more than once. They're sessionists put together by a manager.
@@LIZMGD YT deletes comments mentioning it but if you visit a popular site that rhymes with Geddit there is a post called "who's really behind dogma" with all the proof you could want. And another post "The history of Dogma" with all the lineup changes (no current performers are outed).
Who cares as long as they put on a good show and they sound like they do on the record I mean whoop the crap do you think ghost was an organically put together unit or any other thing like that Of course not All of that stuff is metered and you weigh options and then you decide to take a chance to do certain things none of it just falls together
Thanks for bringing this to us, Prof. I liked their sound so much that I bought their album from iTunes. Yes they are pushing the boundaries in their lyrics and visually in their MVs but the music is great, powerful and very catchy. I’m a big fan of all female bands, I saw Rolling Quartz in January and recently saw Lovebites twice in London so I can’t wait for Dogma to tour Europe.😊
Thanks for watching, and you're very welcome! I'm glad I could turn you on to this band. I, too, am loving the all-female Metal and Hard Rock bands. Somehow I didn't discover this scene until less than a year ago. It has been a game-changer: I'm enjoying music now more than I have in ages. ALSO, I'll be making a least one video (hopefully more) when I go to the Lima meet & greet and show next week, so be on the lookout for that! You might take a look at the site that I can't name because RUclips apparently deletes any references to it, but it rhymes with "Fled It." The WeAreDogma group already has a batch of links, vids, pics to the band's first show from last night (July 2). 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 thanks for your reply I will check out the site you recommended. I also watched your excellent and very detailed reaction to Dogma’s album. Like you my life has been greatly enhanced since I discovered some of the Japanese power metal bands, like Lovebites, Aldious etc. I have seen many iconic bands in my time, Deep Purple, Led Zep, AC/DC, Motörhead, Heart, Fleetwood Mac, Pink Floyd, RHCP, but Lovebites are now my favourite. Cheers from the 🇬🇧
Man the voice of Lillth in the answers of the interview is an AI generated voice. I think Dogma is a project, not a band in the conventional way. Even if you hear with attention an even in the videos you can see that Lilith is not the same person that sings and performs the video Father I have Sinned or Forbidden Zone than the woman that signs Made Her Mine. I know she is wearing a mask in that video, but a pair of her atributes are not as plethoric as the ones the girl of the first videos have, not to say her voice and vocal resources. So, I think that Dogma is a project created to transcend the persons that are implied in the band, being able to change the persons behind the characters as needed. The live concert that we are all anxiously waiting will give us some ansers, we´ll see.
First, man, thanks so much for watching and commenting! I too hope the tour will clear up some questions. I'm going o the Meet & Greet in Lima, and I'm curious whether the voice coming from Lilith will be the same as that in interview. (I've asked for an interview in person, but no response yet.) I'm not sure, though, that the voice is AI. It has some pauses and inflections that AI hasn't nailed yet. The rather monotonic delivery I think is simply because she's reading from a script (which is surprisingly difficult to do well). IN ANY CASE, yeah, looking forward to the tour! In my listenings to all the songs, it sounds to me as though there are three Lilith voices (although others have said only two), and I'm not certain the woman in the first few videos is the person doing the actual singing. We'll see! 🤘
Oh, and that doesn't sound like an AI voice to me. The respondent clearly is reading from a script, yes, but neither the cadence nor the inflection of many phrases sounds artificial. AI voices always pause for the same amount of time after each comma and period/question mark/exclamation point. Also, AI (as far as I've heard, anyway) doesn't slow down to emphasize any individual words. As noted in my previous response, I'll be curious whether Lilith in person sounds like the voice in the responses. Thanks for watching and reading, and I'll pump out as many vids as quickly as I can re: the show itself! 🤘
Oops, sorry, I should have posted this a few weeks ago: now having met and spoken with Lilith, I can confirm that the voice is indeed hers. And although she's obviously reading from a script, I have it on fairly good authority that she wrote it.
@@LazarusRood Good question! This is the second, current Lilith. The original cut of "Father I Have Sinned" had a different vocalist's contribution, but it was re-recorded with current Lilith. Caveat: After seeing the band live, I thought that the album Lilith had been replaced again, but I'm not so sure of that anymore, after listening more carefully to various passages. This all begs the question: was yet a *different* Lilith used in the vids for everything up to "Carnal Liberation"? Or was a specific area of our current Lilith, um, "enhanced" for the vids? And another question: WTF was up with the mask for the "Carnal Liberation" and "Made Her Mine" vids? I wish I could tell you, but I simply don't know. Thanks very much for watching and chiming in! 🤘
Finally! I was waiting for it Speaking of which it's always great to listen to Lillith's answers, they can tell a lot without sharing too much information. Besides that I knew they were not colombian, I insist, I am colombian and music over here doesn't sound like that. But well, should you go to the shows? I think it would be interesting if you were able considering those will be their very first shows, it's an unique opportunity
@@skepticalbadger Exactly! I've been saying this, because I've immediately recognised Montevideo's Cathedral in one video (Father I have sinned) and Cerrito's Church in another. Nobody believed me, but it's obvious! I've commented this with people from here (metal musicians from here, and no one had realised the videos were filmed in Montevideo).
I love how mysterious they are, and I literally just heard of Dogma last night. Definitely go to one of their shows if you ever get a chance, just to tell us what the live church service is like.
Oh, man, I am in love with their album. I'm going to Peru in July (my first time abroad!), to both the concert and Dogma's pre-show meet & greet, and I'll report back with as much detail as I can (minus, of course, anything the band would not like to be made public). Thanks for watching and commenting! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 If you really want to solve a mystery, see if you can figure out who the guys are in the Dogma music video for the song Cancer. Either they found the best sex change surgeons of all time, or they are involved behind the scenes somehow.
@@Anubis424242 I will give it my best shot! I'm a poor bastard, myself, but I have splurged to give myself a present for getting through a very difficult personal period.
@@MetalProfessor65 Congratulations on getting through whatever was going on. I don't know if you made a video about that or not since I just found your channel, but I'm going through a difficult period of my own. Dogma provided a decent distraction.
Wind Rose seems an odd pairing to me, as the image/styles between the two bands don't really match. I would think Ghost, Theatres Des Vampires, Deathless Legacy, ect. would match more in terms of theme and style. But regardless, I'm glad to see Dogma advancing and continuing their success.
@@russellhamilton8903 I'm in Lima, Peru, right now with up-front tix to both the show and the meet & greet on Wednesday. I'll definitely be making at least one vid (hopefully more) about the experience. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤟
I'm going to be at on of the M&G in Mexico. It could be a very interesting thing to discuss impressions after a closer encounter with them. By the way, I just watched a couple of pictures from the M&G in their very first show in Guadalajara and I can say they aren't really tall, which supports the theory of a Latin American / South American origin.
Nice! Thanks for watching! I'll be at the meet & greet and show in Lima next week. You might take a look at the site that I can't name because RUclips apparently deletes any references to it, but it rhymes with "Fled It." The WeAreDogma group already has a batch of links, vids, pics to the band's first show from last night (July 2). Let us all know how things go at the meet & greet and show that you attend. 🤘
Tobias Forge is definitely involved with this. The whole thing screams Ghost, the sound is very similar and you can hear a male background vocal on most their tracks although there is no male in the band. Forbidden Zone sounds exactly like a Ghost song, listen to the chorus.Tobias?
@@michaelbell75 Thanks for watching! Both Dogma and Ghost wear their 80s influences on their sleeve, to be sure. Dogma are the brainchild of Ian Di Leo and one or both of the Rabaquino brothers, but I've no doubt they're keenly aware of the Ghost comparisons. 🤟
Grazie mille! Tra pochi giorni andrò allo spettacolo a Lima, in Perù, quindi sono piuttosto carico! Farò uscire quanti più video possibile dall'esperienza. Grazie per la visione! 🤘
Yes, they added second guitarist Rusalka before the tour. I assumed they would need to add either another guitarist or a synth player, and I'm glad they chose a guitarist. Not only is Rusalka a *really good* player, but I don't care whether synth is on tracks. I'd rather hear live guitar than live synth. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤘
i think Live the guitar couled be louder. The kick drum is the doominating sound in the mix. That could go down a tiny pinch & guitar upa tiny pinch & less piano-y tunes. but yeh Im liking them
I aint' got nothing to say bad about Jesus himself, his followers however, we all could right a book! Dogma has some catchy tunes, totally dig what they are doing musically
Just started listening to this band recently . They are very interesting to say the least. I am curious tho. Sometimes there are 4 members and i believe this was mentioned in you video. But live they are 5 members. Who the extra member?
They added a second guitarist before the tour: Rusalka is her stage name. I figured they would add either a second guitarist (which they did) or a synth player. I'm glad they went with a guitarist. I have no problem with synth being on tracks, but I want guitars live. And this lineup has performed so well on the tour that I sincerely hope they keep all five for the next album. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
@@eddiebuerger9145 I just went to their website and clicked on the "Contact" link. I don't recall specifically what the email address was, but I have no reason to think it's not still there. Thanks for watching and chiming in!🤟
I have a theory. Judging by watching their performances and paying attention to small details. It appears that their outfits have arm bands, leg bands and Lilith has the slits of the front of her dress with what looks to be Hebrew lettering. I am wondering if they are from Israel. It could be just a cosmetic detail but it could be more. She spoke very proper English which to me the lack of more slangish terms especially considering their type of music implies it may not be her first language and it was school taught. Let me know what you think.
@@MercilessWaysDesigns Interesting ideas! And while I, myself, do not speak or read Hebrew, I am told by some that the lettering is indeed that. To me, Lilith 's speaking voice sounds very naturally American. It seems perhaps a bit stilted only because she is reading from a script (which she wrote, I am given to understand). But as for there being from Israel, well, they assert that they do not want to discuss where they are from, but having spoken (albeit quite briefly) with each member of the band, I would go with "not Israel." 😊 If you haven't checked out the--well, RUclips sometimes seems to delete references to the website, so let's just say it rhymes with "Thread it"-- anyway, check out the WeAreDogma sub-thread-it, and you'll find all kinds of great stuff, people talking about these kinds of things. Thanks for watching the video and for chiming in! 🤟
I did a review of them myself, and during my extensive research, I am pretty sure they are from Mexico. Anways, it doesn't matter. What matters is the music. I love their sound and their image. It's refreshing. And they can play. I know good musicians when I see and hear them, and these people can really play their intruments - I mean REALLY play their instruments.Well done Professor on scoring a unique review. I have been clamboring for more information on them myself. Their debut album is spectacular, and I hope they will one day tour Australia.
Thanks so much for watching & commenting! I as hoping to get a real-time review instead of recorded answers, but hey, I'll take what I can get. I'm going to their concert and meet & greet in Peru this July, so hopefully I'll have a chance to ask and record some questions. Re: where the band is from. I can't say the name of the website because YT seems to automatically delete all mentions of it, BUT the site's name rhymes with "Get It." There's a Dogma group there, and they've done some fascinating research into the the band's history and changing lineup. I highly recommend it.
Oh damn! Well that "interview" destroyed my outlook on this band. The ridiculous comical "answers" radiated an immaturity and naievity on a level far in excess of what I have heard before. Impossible to take them seriously at all. Musically they are a talent, but lyrically I could give the benefit of the doubt, but now I'll give them a wide berth. Maybe if they are still around in 10 or so years, have matured a little and dropped the whole contrived comic book "shock" persona that renders nothing but laughter, I might give them another chance? Thanks for this, it opened my eyes.
Wow, damn, sorry it opened your eyes in that direction. This band is a theatrical project, and its managers are hands-on with everything, I suspect even including the scripting. Those clearly were not heartfelt words, but part of the theater. If you take the words seriously, then your conclusion is entirely appropriate. If, on the other hand, one recognizes the theatrics, it--for me, anyway--doesn't bother my fondness for this band very much. And I will tell you that the voice in the answers is, in fact, Lilith's speaking voice, and these musicians (five now, a second guitarist having been added) are already a pretty cohesive unit and can deliver even in the tiny venue in which I saw them (Kantaro Theater in Lima, Peru). But to each his or her own. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 I realize it's theater, but it's very cringe. I actually like the music they make, just not so much the packaging. It's old, been done before so many times. They don't need it tbh. The music alone is good enough.
@@chris101gray3 You must be new to Dogma?! When I first heard about them almost a year ago the first thing I did was check their website and they had this exact type of philosophical paganry in it! It surely suits their image and does not either break it make it the deal for me. I find it bizarre that this interview destroyed ur outlook on the band! What exactly was ur outlook before then?! We are talking about hot nuns singing about sins in explicit videos after all... And u say this has been done before many times - when exactly was the last time u heard anti-christian nuns in corpsepaint playing catchy heavy metal?! And sadly nowadays doing good music is often NOT enough! U need to stand out somehow from the thousands of bands. They chose this image and it fits their music and seems to work. When u got good music AND u stand out = that's the winning formula!
... Yes cool Mrs Le Professeur, I dont know what genre of music Dogma is (I'lii go to your album review) ... I love the look, for me old french guy, they could be a good Black Metal band or better a Batcave (Goth) band like Siouxie Sioux (I was a fan once with the Cure). But I think they are not, it must be something like metal or hard-rock (because you're The Metal Professor, it's why I think it's like that ^^). And from all the person you presented as "I am Dogma", I only saw one that I knew about him, Al Di Meola (an old, 2 years older than me, guitar hero, oh shit ^^, so it cannot be Black Metal or Goth music). And yes, I wish you' go to see one of their show, Bogota perhaps (I saw some shows there on youtube from some bands and I felt some good vibes, but Bogota is not the safest city in the world, so yes ...). Ok I'll go to the album review ... Merci and au revoir !!! And never forget, Dany is The Greatest (The Warning !!!!!!).
Merci beaucoup d'avoir regardé et rejoint la conversation! I had wanted to go to the Bogota show, actually, but I couldn't get straight answers from the club about some things, so I'm planning to go to the Peru concert and pre-show Dogma meet & greet. It would be my first time abroad, so I'm pretty excited and a little nervous. But my son is going with me, and he's a big fella (he'll be 32--I wouldn't take along an actual child), so I'm not too worried about our safety. Obviously we'll take all the common-sense precautions.
You're _sort of_ correct! There have been at least sixteen bands named Dogma, all of them but this one had male singers, and I believe one was indeed from the Netherlands. _This_ Dogma, though, has an international lineup and has been all-woman since the beginning (just a few years ago). Thanks for watching and joining the conversation!
They do--"Dogma", released late 2023--and it's a killer. Seriously, I'm more impressed by this than by an other debut album I've heard in years. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤘
@@kevjul100 Yes! It's pretty well hidden, even searching on Amazon (I think they'd sell a lot more albums if it were easier to find). I hope this link works for you : www.amazon.com/dp/B0CLFJWPG5/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2VCJ0NMQF5GIQ&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.YvFBggZnIc1S0MJXDHaoqslGHPeUlR2gh7Cq_mrUyZ92RZAQSpNS7eJuhpy0aPqIV-n1X2WOCXaJ7N5Ub4hxVGnbDg4_n4YwpsQBYeB3IXwqFs3kJlkaq8t2NQ6CnHQq5uUXRq4N5XyL2LwoNCycObnzpaiSA44urFw48cmn9m-8uZlLLQUjcPjGqTQksgfaiie3kg6GmW1rCEiUG9cvQVwg_Kyds1sV0l5NeEXp330.zcfvJqQ3--hScLq8sOk4nt_Obh-vCLMimq2kC5FXBHE&dib_tag=se&keywords=dogma&qid=1717867077&s=dmusic&sprefix=dogma%2Cdigital-music%2C96&sr=1-4 🤘
They're not, at least not this band called Dogma. They are at least the sixteenth band with that name, so maybe a previous Dogma came was Dutch...? In any case, thanks for watching and chiming in!
LA vos de la entrevista no es normal " de una persona " es algo armado y tampoco es leido , es muy raro como la vos del telefono de una contestadora automatica
¡Gracias por unirte a la conversación! Sin embargo, después de haber hablado con Lilith cara a cara, estoy seguro de que es su voz y que está leyendo un guión. (Y alguien mucho más informado que yo me dijo que ella misma escribió el guión, en lugar de que lo escribieran los managers de la banda). ¡Gracias por mirar! 🤘
Glad I'm not the only Missouri boy digging the "metal sex nuns!" I'm happy that the almighty Algorithm finally introduced me to a band fairly quickly after their debut, as opposed to the usual "here's an 11-year-old video you might like."🖤
Let me throw this out there. Ghost become more successful when Tobias was outed. This interview sounds like a 15 year old boy trying to be edgy. This band has real chops. So be professional musicians and don’t try and live the gimmick outside of its context. It doesn’t lessen the art one but.
Maybe the timing has something to do with it as well. Ghost had gained a respectable following & garnered quite a bit of interest before the whole legal thing with Tobias came about. Several years and three albums at least. So maybe playing up the mystique and anonymity for a while will a be advantageous for Dogma as well.
"Want to keep things secret because they don't want to distract from the message" People spending more time trying to figure out who they are and where they're from, and hardly anyone talking about the "message" itself. Considering how many members they've gone through in less than a year makes me wonder how many of them actually cared about or believe in their "message". Makes it all come across as disingenuous. It's still a great album but this sort of thing really puts a damper on the band and kinda spoils the vibe. I'd have more respect for them if they just admitted it was a corportate entity and stopped pretending to be a group of like-minded people/friends that formed a band.
I get where you're coming from. We could argue that a message of self-determination runs throughout their music. We also have to admit that, yeah, this band was put together with a specific approach and collective persona already in mind. But if it makes you feel any better, I'm told that the five women in the band now have put an active, collective hand on the rudder and display few if any qualms about disagreeing with management. So we might just have an actual band now, after all, marketing mysticism notwithstanding. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
I hear you. It would be crazy-difficult, though, to program the interplay of the general or vague statements with those that that very specific and differently nuanced, tonally. It would be easier just to write the response one's self. Which, I'm told, is what she did. 😊 Thanks for joining the conversation! 🤘
@@Oxymoron666 Thanks for watching and chiming in! It's not AI. Having met and spoken with Lilith, I can say with a good deal of confidence that the voice is hers. She is, however, obviously reading from a script, and to do so and make it sound spontaneous is more difficult than one might think.
That was what I thought, too, when the videos for "Carnal LIberation" and "Made Her Mine" appeared. However, I'm pretty certain that "masked Lilith" was a stand-in: she lacks the freckle on her upper right arm that distinguishes current Lilith. Current Lilith's is the voice on the record (the vocals for "Father I Have Sinned" were re-recorded for the record), she was on the tour, and she appears in the "Like a Prayer" vid. *And I'll attest that, live, she too is fire!* Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Not a fan of the answers. Kinda cringe. A question i would ask: is this an actual band or session musicians? a Are the members the same that tours than the ones in the videos and recordings? Is there a permanent member that is the "leader"?
@@salva0922 Oh yeah, they almost never break character even when answering questions. There have been several lineup changes. Current Lilith is on the album, but I don't know about the other members.
No, all five are women (there were only four when Lilith recorded those answers, but they added another guitar player right before the tour). Thanks for asking! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 Thank you for your reply. 🙏 I learned a lot from reading other comments on this video. ✍ In the end, it doesn't matter if the members are male or female except for the vocalist! (Although it would be better if they were all female...) But they're a band with a bright future! If you like 80's rock, you'll love them! 👍👍👍👍👍 Unfortunately, they won't be coming to Japan...
@@takuyakimura7621 You're quite welcome! And I wouldn't count out their coming to Japan. Their first tour seems to have gone very well, so I'm hopeful they'll be touring more soon! 🤘
the band has a good style and good proposal, but fails in the same point as Ghost: the style is incompatible with the musicianship. The band's sound is expected to be heavier to be generally accepted within the world of Black Metal, like bands like Dimmu Borgir and Behemot or Batuska.
That's an interesting observation! I think style is quite subjective, and lately there are many bands whose both visual and musical stylings are in combinations that I would never have expected. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Well, the answers were obviously pre-written. And I suppose can't say with 100% certainty that its Lilith's voice, because I wasn't present when the responses were recorded. But I *can* say that I met Lilith after the Lima, Peru, gig, and her speaking voice sounded like the recording to me.
@@MetalProfessor65I have been a metal head since the 80s and have not changed it I go to all the festivals and cruises and I have never seen a band like dogma im a big fan I like all of the female bands I can only stand looking at 4 or 5 guys for so long now a days
Oh yeah, management is pushing the "mysterious" angle hard. But see them live and for the duration of the set you'll forget about everything but the music and the beauty. Thanks for watching! 🤘
GUYS (of all genders, obviously): THANK YOU! This vid got zero traction when I first posted it, but in the past month it has picked up roughly 6K views. That isn't much for most channels, but for mine, it's huge. So thank you, thank you, thank you! 🤘
Regarding where this band is from. There's a definite accent from the singer before they covered "Like A Prayer". They started a tour in South America, a lot of bands start touring in their home countries and possibly continents.
In the song "Feel The Zeal" Lilith punishes herself by kneeling on rice and in "My First Peak" she kneels on corn. Both as punishment. While these are old, outdated punishments, I could only find mention of them among South American Catholics.
I could be wrong but it's been hella fun trying to guess and speculate the origins of Dogma!
Discovered the band about a week ago and got to see them live in Sao Paulo last night and it was FUCKING FANTASTIC. Best surprise of the year
Great to hear it! Thanks for joining the conversation (and check out my review of their Lima show, if you're interested: ruclips.net/video/rApNMhpMPlE/видео.htmlsi=iJfnHRFQb5WaXcQy ) 🤘
Great interview, thanks for posting!!
I'm not sure it was great, but thanks much for watching and joining the conversation! 🤟
I was at Dogma's first headliner show ever in Mexico City. They are a great live band! They never lose character and their show is pure rock'n'roll. They introduced a couple of new songs and they sound pretty good.
I saw Dogma on November 17, 2024 in San Antonio. They are great!! I got to meet them at a Meet&Greet after the show. They didn't say much, but they each handed me a trinket. They each said in a soft and beautiful voice as they handed me the trinket, "This is for you". I was thrilled to say the least. I got some pictures as well. My new favorite band.
@@victorr-kn4so Right on! 🤟
Dogma needs to come to AMERICA they need to be heard here
Damn straight!
América is from Alaska and Canadá to the south of Argentina and Chile.
Ummm...such American bravado 🤣
Let's get this straight...YOU need them more than THEY need you!!! 🤪
I'm glad that there's more people getting obsessed with this magnificent band. The last time this happened to me was with Ghost, for obvious reasons. I love the threaticallity, the mystery, the concept behind it, but most of all, the music. I'm so hyped about attending their debut live show, right here in Mexico City. :")
Right on! I'm hitting the Lima concert a few days after that. Let's meet back here and compare notes! 🤘
Ya no nos tocará ver su show debut porque estarán en Guadalajara y Monterrey antes :( pero igual presenciaremos su primer tour
@@Georgie_idol ¡Eso es realmente algo bueno! Los primeros dos o tres shows de cualquier gira, de cualquier artista, inevitablemente contienen cosas que no funcionan bien, pero para su concierto en la Ciudad de México (el tercero de la gira), ya deberían haber resuelto la mayoría de los problemas. ¡Es emocionante que vayas! ¡Por favor, infórmanos y cuéntanos si disfrutaste el espectáculo! 🤘
Going to see Dogma and Wind Rose live tonight! I'm excited!
@@0xDiegoR Have a great time! Let us know how it goes! 🤟
Dogma at Present is composed of entirely new members. An article, in the authors own analysis, stated that 11 females altogether have used the respective pseudonyms at least two times, with the recent members still unrevealed. That said, the former members were:
Lilith I - Isa Roddy
Lamia I - Bruna Terroni
Nexi I - Lina dela Parra
Abrahel I - Nanu Villalba
Abrahel II - I forgot her name... :(, but all talented musicians on their own.
There have indeed been several! If you'll check out the WeAreDogma group at a website that RUclips erases any mentions of--but it rhymes with "Fled It"--you can find some very well researched material about the band's members and history. Thanks for watching! 🤘
Are you sure that their drummer was Nanu? I thought that especially after Nanu moves and "stopped playing drums" I thought that somehow it was her actually playing in the band. Anyway Im pretty sure that their actual bass player is from Argentina.... Dont know if she recorded the album or is only playing live....
New abahel is Elisa Fortunato from Italy now living in New York she has many RUclips videos.
Original singer Isa Roddy is a solo artist now Original guitarist Bruna torreni is a solo artist original bassist lina De la parra is in a band named Highway original drummer Nanu Villalba was in nervosa but left in early 2023 and now session and for hire.they all have Instagram accounts hopefully they will reform under a new name because the original 4 are very talented musicians just listen to the videos they're sound is much tighter than these new players 😊
@@roberthoeg1964 I disagree that the original four sound tighter than the current lineup. However, I completely agree with the sentiment that those original four should form a band of their own! Thanks very much for watching and joining the conversation! 🤟
I think that one of them (only in one of their videos) is a Colombian Bassist
I will go to the first show in Mexico City on July 4th and Im realy impatient to see Dogma´s show, they have an amazing concept
Thanks for this interesting video, greetings from Mexico 🤘
Thanks so much for watching and commenting! Let us all know how the Mexico City show goes. I'm going to Peru to see them July 10, so I'll report back from there. I'm very curious to hear whether the Lilith at the Meet & Greet session is the same voice as she who recorded the answers to my interview questions. It's a testament, I think, to the songwriting and the vision that even though we all know this band has already been a revolving door of members, I am still ridiculously psyched to see & hear them live. 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 I have the M&G ticket too, Sure¡ after the concert Im going to let you know how was it. you dont know who are the actual members and neither do I Hahaha In spite of that I´m really excited
The band - at least, the band that performs in videos and presumably the forthcoming tour, absolutely did not come together "organically". Every single member has been replaced, some more than once. They're sessionists put together by a manager.
well, prove it
@@LIZMGD YT deletes comments mentioning it but if you visit a popular site that rhymes with Geddit there is a post called "who's really behind dogma" with all the proof you could want. And another post "The history of Dogma" with all the lineup changes (no current performers are outed).
@@LIZMGD You already read the proof on the fan sub and chose not to believe it. That's fine - my comment is directed at the channel host.
Who cares as long as they put on a good show and they sound like they do on the record I mean whoop the crap do you think ghost was an organically put together unit or any other thing like that Of course not All of that stuff is metered and you weigh options and then you decide to take a chance to do certain things none of it just falls together
@@skepticalbadgeryou have to learn to differenciate proof from speculation
Thanks for bringing this to us, Prof. I liked their sound so much that I bought their album from iTunes. Yes they are pushing the boundaries in their lyrics and visually in their MVs but the music is great, powerful and very catchy. I’m a big fan of all female bands, I saw Rolling Quartz in January and recently saw Lovebites twice in London so I can’t wait for Dogma to tour Europe.😊
Thanks for watching, and you're very welcome! I'm glad I could turn you on to this band. I, too, am loving the all-female Metal and Hard Rock bands. Somehow I didn't discover this scene until less than a year ago. It has been a game-changer: I'm enjoying music now more than I have in ages. ALSO, I'll be making a least one video (hopefully more) when I go to the Lima meet & greet and show next week, so be on the lookout for that!
You might take a look at the site that I can't name because RUclips apparently deletes any references to it, but it rhymes with "Fled It." The WeAreDogma group already has a batch of links, vids, pics to the band's first show from last night (July 2). 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 thanks for your reply I will check out the site you recommended. I also watched your excellent and very detailed reaction to Dogma’s album. Like you my life has been greatly enhanced since I discovered some of the Japanese power metal bands, like Lovebites, Aldious etc. I have seen many iconic bands in my time, Deep Purple, Led Zep, AC/DC, Motörhead, Heart, Fleetwood Mac, Pink Floyd, RHCP, but Lovebites are now my favourite. Cheers from the 🇬🇧
i really like this band. i hope they go far, like their style and their riffs and lyrics are definitely well thought out!
You can't just not appreciate four hot nuns forming a band and writing a song about, some things.
Man the voice of Lillth in the answers of the interview is an AI generated voice. I think Dogma is a project, not a band in the conventional way. Even if you hear with attention an even in the videos you can see that Lilith is not the same person that sings and performs the video Father I have Sinned or Forbidden Zone than the woman that signs Made Her Mine. I know she is wearing a mask in that video, but a pair of her atributes are not as plethoric as the ones the girl of the first videos have, not to say her voice and vocal resources. So, I think that Dogma is a project created to transcend the persons that are implied in the band, being able to change the persons behind the characters as needed. The live concert that we are all anxiously waiting will give us some ansers, we´ll see.
First, man, thanks so much for watching and commenting! I too hope the tour will clear up some questions. I'm going o the Meet & Greet in Lima, and I'm curious whether the voice coming from Lilith will be the same as that in interview. (I've asked for an interview in person, but no response yet.) I'm not sure, though, that the voice is AI. It has some pauses and inflections that AI hasn't nailed yet. The rather monotonic delivery I think is simply because she's reading from a script (which is surprisingly difficult to do well). IN ANY CASE, yeah, looking forward to the tour!
In my listenings to all the songs, it sounds to me as though there are three Lilith voices (although others have said only two), and I'm not certain the woman in the first few videos is the person doing the actual singing. We'll see!
🤘
Oh, and that doesn't sound like an AI voice to me. The respondent clearly is reading from a script, yes, but neither the cadence nor the inflection of many phrases sounds artificial. AI voices always pause for the same amount of time after each comma and period/question mark/exclamation point. Also, AI (as far as I've heard, anyway) doesn't slow down to emphasize any individual words. As noted in my previous response, I'll be curious whether Lilith in person sounds like the voice in the responses. Thanks for watching and reading, and I'll pump out as many vids as quickly as I can re: the show itself! 🤘
Oops, sorry, I should have posted this a few weeks ago: now having met and spoken with Lilith, I can confirm that the voice is indeed hers. And although she's obviously reading from a script, I have it on fairly good authority that she wrote it.
@@MetalProfessor65 which one of them? there' s various Lilits.
@@LazarusRood Good question! This is the second, current Lilith. The original cut of "Father I Have Sinned" had a different vocalist's contribution, but it was re-recorded with current Lilith. Caveat: After seeing the band live, I thought that the album Lilith had been replaced again, but I'm not so sure of that anymore, after listening more carefully to various passages. This all begs the question: was yet a *different* Lilith used in the vids for everything up to "Carnal Liberation"? Or was a specific area of our current Lilith, um, "enhanced" for the vids? And another question: WTF was up with the mask for the "Carnal Liberation" and "Made Her Mine" vids? I wish I could tell you, but I simply don't know. Thanks very much for watching and chiming in! 🤘
十日前我還未知道這女子樂隊，十日後我已是這樂隊的忠實支持者✌️✌️，她們有很好的歌唱聲音，有點性感、沈穩。整張專輯的所有歌曲都非常耐聽，樂器演奏散發著硬朗情感。。。總之，Dogma是我心目中十大的其中之一⋯⋯我很貪心，祈望她們快點帶來第二張專輯。。。🙏🙏☺️☺️。。
Finally! I was waiting for it
Speaking of which it's always great to listen to Lillith's answers, they can tell a lot without sharing too much information. Besides that I knew they were not colombian, I insist, I am colombian and music over here doesn't sound like that.
But well, should you go to the shows? I think it would be interesting if you were able considering those will be their very first shows, it's an unique opportunity
Yeah, took a while. Heavy stuff on the homefront put the channel on hiatus for a while. But hopefully that's done, and I hope you enjoyed the vid! 🤘
They are from Uruguay. The lineup is a revolving door but primarily from Central & South America.
@@skepticalbadger Exactly! I've been saying this, because I've immediately recognised Montevideo's Cathedral in one video (Father I have sinned) and Cerrito's Church in another. Nobody believed me, but it's obvious! I've commented this with people from here (metal musicians from here, and no one had realised the videos were filmed in Montevideo).
I love how mysterious they are, and I literally just heard of Dogma last night. Definitely go to one of their shows if you ever get a chance, just to tell us what the live church service is like.
Oh, man, I am in love with their album. I'm going to Peru in July (my first time abroad!), to both the concert and Dogma's pre-show meet & greet, and I'll report back with as much detail as I can (minus, of course, anything the band would not like to be made public). Thanks for watching and commenting! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 When you go there, enjoy it for the both of us. I'm a poor bastard, so I can only enjoy what's released afterwards.
@@MetalProfessor65 If you really want to solve a mystery, see if you can figure out who the guys are in the Dogma music video for the song Cancer. Either they found the best sex change surgeons of all time, or they are involved behind the scenes somehow.
@@Anubis424242 I will give it my best shot! I'm a poor bastard, myself, but I have splurged to give myself a present for getting through a very difficult personal period.
@@MetalProfessor65 Congratulations on getting through whatever was going on. I don't know if you made a video about that or not since I just found your channel, but I'm going through a difficult period of my own. Dogma provided a decent distraction.
Wind Rose seems an odd pairing to me, as the image/styles between the two bands don't really match. I would think Ghost, Theatres Des Vampires, Deathless Legacy, ect. would match more in terms of theme and style. But regardless, I'm glad to see Dogma advancing and continuing their success.
Deathless Legacy is new to me. Thank you for that mention.
I hope that you have been to one of their shows or are going. Hopefully you will report back.
@@russellhamilton8903 I'm in Lima, Peru, right now with up-front tix to both the show and the meet & greet on Wednesday. I'll definitely be making at least one vid (hopefully more) about the experience. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤟
I'm going to be at on of the M&G in Mexico. It could be a very interesting thing to discuss impressions after a closer encounter with them. By the way, I just watched a couple of pictures from the M&G in their very first show in Guadalajara and I can say they aren't really tall, which supports the theory of a Latin American / South American origin.
Nice! Thanks for watching! I'll be at the meet & greet and show in Lima next week. You might take a look at the site that I can't name because RUclips apparently deletes any references to it, but it rhymes with "Fled It." The WeAreDogma group already has a batch of links, vids, pics to the band's first show from last night (July 2).
Let us all know how things go at the meet & greet and show that you attend.
🤘
I just discovered them, I think they are great! Looking forward to an American you!!❤
Tobias Forge is definitely involved with this. The whole thing screams Ghost, the sound is very similar and you can hear a male background vocal on most their tracks although there is no male in the band. Forbidden Zone sounds exactly like a Ghost song, listen to the chorus.Tobias?
@@michaelbell75 Thanks for watching! Both Dogma and Ghost wear their 80s influences on their sleeve, to be sure. Dogma are the brainchild of Ian Di Leo and one or both of the Rabaquino brothers, but I've no doubt they're keenly aware of the Ghost comparisons. 🤟
Dogma and In This Moment US tour for the win!
Ciao, un bellissimo servizio sui DOGMA, ebbene, si spero che tu vada, ne sarei felicissimo!!! ....Grazie
Grazie mille! Tra pochi giorni andrò allo spettacolo a Lima, in Perù, quindi sono piuttosto carico! Farò uscire quanti più video possibile dall'esperienza. Grazie per la visione! 🤘
Dogma & King Diamond just might do real well at Manchester Music Hall in Lexington KY. I saw a 5th Dogma member called Rasulka.
Oh yeah, Rusalka just kills on guitar, absolutely kills (and she knows it, which is cool)!
Thank you ,what about ROSE in DOOM interview please 😊
@@jamieheffy177 Thanks for the tip! I will check them out 🤟
i noticed that dogma have 5 members now
Yes, they added second guitarist Rusalka before the tour. I assumed they would need to add either another guitarist or a synth player, and I'm glad they chose a guitarist. Not only is Rusalka a *really good* player, but I don't care whether synth is on tracks. I'd rather hear live guitar than live synth. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤘
I’m going to the Orlando show and I bought the green and meet I hope I get a picture with the band im going to dress as a satanic priest
@@MetalJoe101 If that doesn't impress, I don't know what would. :) You go, man!
i think Live the guitar couled be louder. The kick drum is the doominating sound in the mix. That could go down a tiny pinch & guitar upa tiny pinch & less piano-y tunes. but yeh Im liking them
I hear what you're saying. Remember, though, that the mix we hear in the recordings doesn't faithfully replicate how the mix sounds live.
Someone was listening to my kraken squns (elite priestess society)but also my Black metal ballerina(where sense movements are)
Actually, had I known, I would have travelled to Brazil to see them live.
Apparently "cleavage rock" is a thing now. Yes... I made that term up.
Lol! "Cleavage RUclips" is a thing, too, and it correlates directly with how many subscribers one gains.
I aint' got nothing to say bad about Jesus himself, his followers however, we all could right a book! Dogma has some catchy tunes, totally dig what they are doing musically
Just started listening to this band recently . They are very interesting to say the least. I am curious tho. Sometimes there are 4 members and i believe this was mentioned in you video. But live they are 5 members. Who the extra member?
They added a second guitarist before the tour: Rusalka is her stage name. I figured they would add either a second guitarist (which they did) or a synth player. I'm glad they went with a guitarist. I have no problem with synth being on tracks, but I want guitars live. And this lineup has performed so well on the tour that I sincerely hope they keep all five for the next album. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Wow eye mind opening thank you 😊
@@jamieheffy177 you are very welcome! Thanks for watching! 🤟
PLEASE! tell me the email you used to write to them! I love their music and the stage persona's they present!
@@eddiebuerger9145 I just went to their website and clicked on the "Contact" link. I don't recall specifically what the email address was, but I have no reason to think it's not still there. Thanks for watching and chiming in!🤟
I have a theory. Judging by watching their performances and paying attention to small details. It appears that their outfits have arm bands, leg bands and Lilith has the slits of the front of her dress with what looks to be Hebrew lettering. I am wondering if they are from Israel. It could be just a cosmetic detail but it could be more. She spoke very proper English which to me the lack of more slangish terms especially considering their type of music implies it may not be her first language and it was school taught. Let me know what you think.
@@MercilessWaysDesigns Interesting ideas! And while I, myself, do not speak or read Hebrew, I am told by some that the lettering is indeed that. To me, Lilith 's speaking voice sounds very naturally American. It seems perhaps a bit stilted only because she is reading from a script (which she wrote, I am given to understand). But as for there being from Israel, well, they assert that they do not want to discuss where they are from, but having spoken (albeit quite briefly) with each member of the band, I would go with "not Israel." 😊 If you haven't checked out the--well, RUclips sometimes seems to delete references to the website, so let's just say it rhymes with "Thread it"-- anyway, check out the WeAreDogma sub-thread-it, and you'll find all kinds of great stuff, people talking about these kinds of things. Thanks for watching the video and for chiming in! 🤟
I did a review of them myself, and during my extensive research, I am pretty sure they are from Mexico. Anways, it doesn't matter. What matters is the music. I love their sound and their image. It's refreshing. And they can play. I know good musicians when I see and hear them, and these people can really play their intruments - I mean REALLY play their instruments.Well done Professor on scoring a unique review. I have been clamboring for more information on them myself. Their debut album is spectacular, and I hope they will one day tour Australia.
Thanks so much for watching & commenting! I as hoping to get a real-time review instead of recorded answers, but hey, I'll take what I can get. I'm going to their concert and meet & greet in Peru this July, so hopefully I'll have a chance to ask and record some questions.
Re: where the band is from. I can't say the name of the website because YT seems to automatically delete all mentions of it, BUT the site's name rhymes with "Get It." There's a Dogma group there, and they've done some fascinating research into the the band's history and changing lineup. I highly recommend it.
I saw they were from NY, that is what Amazon music has in their “about the band” section.
Oh damn! Well that "interview" destroyed my outlook on this band. The ridiculous comical "answers" radiated an immaturity and naievity on a level far in excess of what I have heard before. Impossible to take them seriously at all. Musically they are a talent, but lyrically I could give the benefit of the doubt, but now I'll give them a wide berth. Maybe if they are still around in 10 or so years, have matured a little and dropped the whole contrived comic book "shock" persona that renders nothing but laughter, I might give them another chance? Thanks for this, it opened my eyes.
Wow, damn, sorry it opened your eyes in that direction. This band is a theatrical project, and its managers are hands-on with everything, I suspect even including the scripting. Those clearly were not heartfelt words, but part of the theater. If you take the words seriously, then your conclusion is entirely appropriate. If, on the other hand, one recognizes the theatrics, it--for me, anyway--doesn't bother my fondness for this band very much. And I will tell you that the voice in the answers is, in fact, Lilith's speaking voice, and these musicians (five now, a second guitarist having been added) are already a pretty cohesive unit and can deliver even in the tiny venue in which I saw them (Kantaro Theater in Lima, Peru). But to each his or her own. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 I realize it's theater, but it's very cringe. I actually like the music they make, just not so much the packaging. It's old, been done before so many times. They don't need it tbh. The music alone is good enough.
@@chris101gray3 You must be new to Dogma?! When I first heard about them almost a year ago the first thing I did was check their website and they had this exact type of philosophical paganry in it! It surely suits their image and does not either break it make it the deal for me. I find it bizarre that this interview destroyed ur outlook on the band! What exactly was ur outlook before then?! We are talking about hot nuns singing about sins in explicit videos after all...
And u say this has been done before many times - when exactly was the last time u heard anti-christian nuns in corpsepaint playing catchy heavy metal?! And sadly nowadays doing good music is often NOT enough! U need to stand out somehow from the thousands of bands. They chose this image and it fits their music and seems to work. When u got good music AND u stand out = that's the winning formula!
... Yes cool Mrs Le Professeur, I dont know what genre of music Dogma is (I'lii go to your album review) ...
I love the look, for me old french guy, they could be a good Black Metal band or better a Batcave (Goth) band like Siouxie Sioux (I was a fan once with the Cure).
But I think they are not, it must be something like metal or hard-rock (because you're The Metal Professor, it's why I think it's like that ^^).
And from all the person you presented as "I am Dogma", I only saw one that I knew about him, Al Di Meola (an old, 2 years older than me, guitar hero, oh shit ^^, so it cannot be Black Metal or Goth music).
And yes, I wish you' go to see one of their show, Bogota perhaps (I saw some shows there on youtube from some bands and I felt some good vibes, but Bogota is not the safest city in the world, so yes ...).
Ok I'll go to the album review ... Merci and au revoir !!!
And never forget, Dany is The Greatest (The Warning !!!!!!).
Merci beaucoup d'avoir regardé et rejoint la conversation! I had wanted to go to the Bogota show, actually, but I couldn't get straight answers from the club about some things, so I'm planning to go to the Peru concert and pre-show Dogma meet & greet. It would be my first time abroad, so I'm pretty excited and a little nervous. But my son is going with me, and he's a big fella (he'll be 32--I wouldn't take along an actual child), so I'm not too worried about our safety. Obviously we'll take all the common-sense precautions.
Dogma has been around for a while. They had a male singer in the beginning.
You're _sort of_ correct! There have been at least sixteen bands named Dogma, all of them but this one had male singers, and I believe one was indeed from the Netherlands. _This_ Dogma, though, has an international lineup and has been all-woman since the beginning (just a few years ago). Thanks for watching and joining the conversation!
Do they have an album?
They do--"Dogma", released late 2023--and it's a killer. Seriously, I'm more impressed by this than by an other debut album I've heard in years. Thanks for watching and chiming in! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65 thanks mate!! You know by chance where I can find it?
@@kevjul100 Yes! It's pretty well hidden, even searching on Amazon (I think they'd sell a lot more albums if it were easier to find). I hope this link works for you : www.amazon.com/dp/B0CLFJWPG5/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2VCJ0NMQF5GIQ&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.YvFBggZnIc1S0MJXDHaoqslGHPeUlR2gh7Cq_mrUyZ92RZAQSpNS7eJuhpy0aPqIV-n1X2WOCXaJ7N5Ub4hxVGnbDg4_n4YwpsQBYeB3IXwqFs3kJlkaq8t2NQ6CnHQq5uUXRq4N5XyL2LwoNCycObnzpaiSA44urFw48cmn9m-8uZlLLQUjcPjGqTQksgfaiie3kg6GmW1rCEiUG9cvQVwg_Kyds1sV0l5NeEXp330.zcfvJqQ3--hScLq8sOk4nt_Obh-vCLMimq2kC5FXBHE&dib_tag=se&keywords=dogma&qid=1717867077&s=dmusic&sprefix=dogma%2Cdigital-music%2C96&sr=1-4 🤘
Dogma is from Netherlands.
They're not, at least not this band called Dogma. They are at least the sixteenth band with that name, so maybe a previous Dogma came was Dutch...? In any case, thanks for watching and chiming in!
@@MetalProfessor65 last time i checked they moved from Armenia to the Netherlands. But everyone thinks they're mexican.
I think they should tour with Ghost. Then no one would know who anyone, except Tobias Forge, performing is. 😄
LA vos de la entrevista no es normal " de una persona " es algo armado y tampoco es leido , es muy raro como la vos del telefono de una contestadora automatica
¡Gracias por unirte a la conversación! Sin embargo, después de haber hablado con Lilith cara a cara, estoy seguro de que es su voz y que está leyendo un guión. (Y alguien mucho más informado que yo me dijo que ella misma escribió el guión, en lugar de que lo escribieran los managers de la banda). ¡Gracias por mirar! 🤘
Glad I'm not the only Missouri boy digging the "metal sex nuns!"
I'm happy that the almighty Algorithm finally introduced me to a band fairly quickly after their debut, as opposed to the usual "here's an 11-year-old video you might like."🖤
You are definitely not! Maybe we can lobby for a KC gig sometime soon. 😉 Thanks much for watching and chiming in! 🤘
yes you should go
Thanks! I'm now planning on it!
Yes
Let me throw this out there. Ghost become more successful when Tobias was outed. This interview sounds like a 15 year old boy trying to be edgy. This band has real chops. So be professional musicians and don’t try and live the gimmick outside of its context. It doesn’t lessen the art one but.
All of black metal is filed with overly serus homeless edge lords, and it works for and worked for them
Maybe the timing has something to do with it as well. Ghost had gained a respectable following & garnered quite a bit of interest before the whole legal thing with Tobias came about. Several years and three albums at least. So maybe playing up the mystique and anonymity for a while will a be advantageous for Dogma as well.
Let's hope so! I can tell you that there *is* a plan, so we'll see what happens. Thanks for watching and chiming in!
Yes please Prof get yourself down there
Got my ticket to the Lima, Peru show and the Dogma meet & greet. I'll let you know how it goes! Thanks for watching! 🤘
Yes I would like for you to go to Latin America and do a review on it you got to review my new stuff though too bro
I love you Lilith
Awesome Italian metal band!
Yeahhh
I LOVE NUNS. I have a t shirt and patch that sez so
"Want to keep things secret because they don't want to distract from the message"
People spending more time trying to figure out who they are and where they're from, and hardly anyone talking about the "message" itself.
Considering how many members they've gone through in less than a year makes me wonder how many of them actually cared about or believe in their "message". Makes it all come across as disingenuous. It's still a great album but this sort of thing really puts a damper on the band and kinda spoils the vibe. I'd have more respect for them if they just admitted it was a corportate entity and stopped pretending to be a group of like-minded people/friends that formed a band.
I get where you're coming from. We could argue that a message of self-determination runs throughout their music. We also have to admit that, yeah, this band was put together with a specific approach and collective persona already in mind. But if it makes you feel any better, I'm told that the five women in the band now have put an active, collective hand on the rudder and display few if any qualms about disagreeing with management. So we might just have an actual band now, after all, marketing mysticism notwithstanding. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Their responses sound like they were written by A.I.
I hear you. It would be crazy-difficult, though, to program the interplay of the general or vague statements with those that that very specific and differently nuanced, tonally. It would be easier just to write the response one's self. Which, I'm told, is what she did. 😊 Thanks for joining the conversation! 🤘
i don’t think that’s lilith’s voice.
It feels like an AI is responding to your questions, not a real person.
@@Oxymoron666 Thanks for watching and chiming in! It's not AI. Having met and spoken with Lilith, I can say with a good deal of confidence that the voice is hers. She is, however, obviously reading from a script, and to do so and make it sound spontaneous is more difficult than one might think.
@@MetalProfessor65 that explains the feel I get. Thank you very much for your answer!
Isa was best Lilith, she was fire in FIHS
That was what I thought, too, when the videos for "Carnal LIberation" and "Made Her Mine" appeared. However, I'm pretty certain that "masked Lilith" was a stand-in: she lacks the freckle on her upper right arm that distinguishes current Lilith. Current Lilith's is the voice on the record (the vocals for "Father I Have Sinned" were re-recorded for the record), she was on the tour, and she appears in the "Like a Prayer" vid. *And I'll attest that, live, she too is fire!* Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Come in italy
Not a fan of the answers. Kinda cringe. A question i would ask: is this an actual band or session musicians? a
Are the members the same that tours than the ones in the videos and recordings? Is there a permanent member that is the "leader"?
@@salva0922 Oh yeah, they almost never break character even when answering questions. There have been several lineup changes. Current Lilith is on the album, but I don't know about the other members.
Anne Herbert
@@LSPalm Pardon?
And this is an ai voice.. this is an unnatural speech pattern and inflection
Would like to take my view back
Sorry, dude, no AI. I've spoken with Lilith face to face, and this is her. She's clearly reading from a script, but it's her.
Lilith is female, the others are male.
Right?
No, all five are women (there were only four when Lilith recorded those answers, but they added another guitar player right before the tour). Thanks for asking! 🤘
@@MetalProfessor65
Thank you for your reply. 🙏
I learned a lot from reading other comments on this video. ✍
In the end, it doesn't matter if the members are male or female except for the vocalist!
(Although it would be better if they were all female...)
But they're a band with a bright future!
If you like 80's rock, you'll love them! 👍👍👍👍👍
Unfortunately, they won't be coming to Japan...
@@takuyakimura7621 You're quite welcome! And I wouldn't count out their coming to Japan. Their first tour seems to have gone very well, so I'm hopeful they'll be touring more soon! 🤘
the band has a good style and good proposal, but fails in the same point as Ghost: the style is incompatible with the musicianship.
The band's sound is expected to be heavier to be generally accepted within the world of Black Metal, like bands like Dimmu Borgir and Behemot or Batuska.
That's an interesting observation! I think style is quite subjective, and lately there are many bands whose both visual and musical stylings are in combinations that I would never have expected. Thanks for watching and joining the conversation! 🤘
Fanaticism is Forbidden. Enjoy, Admire, but don't para socially sweat over them. Or any artist, athlete, musician etc. No Swiftie nuns
df kind of interview was this...
They need to tore with ghost, they look like a ghost rip of
Hey these girls can rock, not a fan of all the satanic shit...but some of the guitar work i can diggit
A gimmick.
A fine example of how much false BS can be spread in 20min. That was not Lilith !!!!!!!
Well, the answers were obviously pre-written. And I suppose can't say with 100% certainty that its Lilith's voice, because I wasn't present when the responses were recorded. But I *can* say that I met Lilith after the Lima, Peru, gig, and her speaking voice sounded like the recording to me.
I got ask why there are no live videos
They simply didn't want to provide any. I suggested it and would have preferred it, but no go. Thanks for watching, and thanks for asking! 🤟
@@MetalProfessor65I have been a metal head since the 80s and have not changed it I go to all the festivals and cruises and I have never seen a band like dogma im a big fan I like all of the female bands I can only stand looking at 4 or 5 guys for so long now a days
You the man
I don't feel like the man, but I appreciate it! :)
dogma is a good band, this video however was pure stupid
Great band, excess pseudoscience and pseudo intellectual nonsense
Oh yeah, management is pushing the "mysterious" angle hard. But see them live and for the duration of the set you'll forget about everything but the music and the beauty. Thanks for watching! 🤘