This was an interesting documentary. I had never heard of this woman. My grandmother lived the life of "My Antonia". She was raised in a dugout near a lake in Iowa. She married and raised 9 children. One was my Father. I was raised next door to my grandmother in the 1950-60's. She then lived in a regular house and tho she had no running water her house was spotless. She had a garden, canned vegs and made bread. She was a quiet pleasant woman. Never complained.Just did her work as if it was just the way it is and you do what you had to do. I wish I had asked her more questions about growing up in that dugout. But I imagie she would have had a different outlook on it than I did. When I think I have it rough I think about my granny and my gr grandmother who rased my granny and her 7 siblings in that dugout. And wondeer what I'm complaining about..
PK , very well said ... and well-written . You have a bit of a writer in you and if you don't already write , you might want to think about doing so because you have a way with words that people will appreciate ... and maybe even benefit from .
Yes, thank you for sharing your story. I can’t imagine I live in the dugout and raise kids and wash clothes no running water in boiling water to wash clothes that was a one full day of laundering. I would like to recommend the book: “Bird by Bird” which teaches you how to write in a simple way by Anne Lanotte. You may also want to read the book by Elinore Pruitt Stewart: “Letters of a Woman Homesteader,” Elinor is so down to earth humorous and endearing. It’s one of my favorite books I read each spring. She will also inspire you to write. 🌷 Wishing you all the best, ~ Nell
@@gardensofthegods thank you . I've always wanted to write but have been a huge procrastinator. My High School English teacher always said I had talent too Maybe it's not too late. :-) I have a lot of events in my life I could put into short stories. My own life would be quite the novel.... Some nitty gritty and triumph combined....Thank you for the encouragement.
I wrote my Masters thesis (1987) on Willa Cather's southwest novels, Death Comes for the Archbishop, mainly and the two parts about the Southwest in The Professor's House and Song of the Lark. My thesis was that she treated landscape as a character in all of her novels, using all of these as examples. I read all of her novels and a great deal of the research on her. I had a fabulous Professor who taught a seminar class on her work, who was also a famous author, William Dickey, which sparked a love of her work; I had lived in both Nebraska and New Mexico (my favorite state) , as a military brat, as well as in Europe.
Finally after 40+ years of sitting on my shelf, I am opening a Library of America volume Willa Cather Later Novels. Watching this beautiful documentary is very emotional 😢 truly a great American, an amazing mind, a truly free woman
I wrote my undergraduate senior thesis on Willa Cather. I read most of her books. I really love her work. She had a unique voice for women. My Antonia was the focus but I just loved all of her female characters.
I must say I really enjoyed this biography of Willa Cather. I had never heard of her but now I'm going to go and pick up one of her books. Thank you for introducing her to us
This is one of the best programs of its kind that I have had the pleasure of viewing. Thank you, to all involved with creating this and getting it to us.
What strikes me about this very introspective and highly gifted writer is her humbleness and true grit to follow her path for writing. I am touched by her love for women who grant her wish of destroying their letters so their love and true selves are strictly private. A fascinating woman indeed. I thoroughly enjoyed the bio pic of Willa. Marvellous! Thank you.
I've been a fan of Cathers' work for almost 30 years. This film has made me fall in love all over again. Thanks for this gift for lovers of enduring literature.
Found her at the library to read all her stuff decades ago. Unusually enjoyable even set in a place that normally would not draw my interest.....that well written. Cutting her hair off, dressing in male clothes, later she came out as gay living in N.Y.C.
I enjoyed this documentary . I was made aware of this lady author. Her life must have been very lonely. 82 and have endured many years per self and it’s no life.
A wonderful documentary. She was hugely brave multiple times to leave a pleasant "sure thing" and jump into the unknown again and again. And she succeeded in something many artists aspire to, she managed to erase her personal life and leave us only with her written work.
It's because of Willa Cather that I took up writing. I love (and still own) the ancient copy of My Antonia from which I studied Cather's writing, word for word. She was able to make you feel the heat of the train car rumbling across the prairie, and feel the cloud of dust as your hand hit the hot, fading red velvet covered car seats. The Shimerdas - the life of the immigrants, the Swedes - she made it all come to life. I was always sad to read the ending of when Antonia was a mother with missing teeth due to her harsh life, so would always go back and read when she was a bright and sunny girl again, with chestnut cheeks. I must have read that book once a year for at least 3 decades - just to keep my own writing fresh. She, and F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby," and Robert Nathan's "Portrait of Jenny," are the go-to books to study for any aspiring writer. As Anton Chekhov - another must-read writer, wrote, "Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass."
Loved *My Antonia*, btw... The Shimerdas were Bohemian, not Swedish. Also, haunted by *Portrait of Jenny*.. the movie was good, too. Robert Nathan was a rare find; a fellow librarian introduced him to me. I thought it was a true story (because of the intro?) Short but sweet. If you have a powerful theme, it doesn't matter how long or short your novel is. Hudson's *Green Mansions* is another haunting book like this. Not too crazy about F. Scott Fitzgerald, though. Still need to read Chekhov.
@@LS-ei7xk If you were my neighbor, we'd be fast friends! It is next to never that I have heard of anyone has read Portrait of Jenny - let alone knew it was a book before they made the movie! Or who was as enamored with My Antonia as I. The Great Gatsby is in this group of great novels, I think, because his descriptions are succinct yet visually powerful, and one can learn a lot just through that alone. And he was only 27 when he wrote it! But, I do confess it took me decades to get into it. I had tried to read it but always shut the book after the first two paragraphs of the first chapter - until one day I forced myself to read it through, and I was hooked. Another great book is, believe it or not, A Christmas Carol by Dickens. But topping that book is his masterpiece, Great Expectations. The characters are so alive, you can feel sympathy for them, or hate them just as easily, but it also has that great twist in the end. He had characterization, form and plot down to perfection. My fortune is that I did not even know what the book was about until my friend nagged at me to read it - blew my mind. Add to that repertoire is, of course, Gone with the Wind. It is so thick, that one of my friends who begged me to read it after I balked at the size of the novel, promised me that I would not be able to put it down. I took up her challenge - and true to her word, read that whole, entire, voluminous book in one weekend, unable to sleep until I finished it. Regarding the Shimerdas being Bohemian and not Swedish - I guess I should have written that sentence more clearly - Yes, the Shimerdas were Bohemian, but Cather also wrote about the life of the immigrants as well as the Swedish immigrant population - the girls in town who took in laundry and worked for others. That is what I meant. A lot of love for the Nebraskan immigrants whether they were Bohemians or Swedes, went into Cather's writing. I'm thankful for the likes of her as well as Dickens, Nathan and other fine novelists, because the art of the novel seems to be dying in this texting and often vulgar age. We need to bring back the beauty of language.
You can smell, feel, taste, the world she paints artfully, each sentence crafted keenly, with beautifully chosen words. Her personal life was superfluous to her work and she knew it, God love her, and saw to it, it remain so. Smart lady.
PBS, of course! Awoke at 3am, ciuldnt slerp, found this delight and now a new fan! What a fantastic bio. Looking forward to reading her works. Loved the excerpts.
this showed up in my youtube recommendations! i am so happy! this was an incredible documentary! I look forward to watching more, especially women writer's.
This was a brilliantly conceived and executed documentary. The selection of the people who commented or criticized was faultless, as was the editing of their thoughts with the passages from Cather’s books. I would go so far as to say that this is one of the finest and most revealing biographical docs I have ever seen. Even the musical interludes were sympathetic to the content. Never before have I felt so inclined to find without delay and read the works of any author. bravo to the entire team who constructed this flawless portrait.
Agreed. It really is flawless. Even the discussion of her personal life and sexuality was done so well, no hyperbole or agenda. We don't KNOW, because we don't know. And it has nothing to do with the WORK, which is all that really matters. And Alison, the woman reading Cather's words is Marcia Gay Harden. Great actress. Miller's Crossing, Pollock, Mystic River.
How wonderful to find this author in 2024 with all that is going on today she would be amazed iam 76 and happy to find out life and people do not change we are born who we are and who we will be*
Extraordinary - thank you. “My Antonia” has been one of my favorite books for decades, read and reread it many times, but never knew anything at all about the author, now I know more….
I love her work and, as much, her fierce privacy and share her feelings. Many Americans, today, feel they are entitled to know public figures intimately and I don't blame their fury upon intrusion. She was truly gifted and under appreciated in today's pseudo intellectual literary landscape.
I wish people would stop so hoping for people to be homosexual to the point they would be disappointed if they aren't when they don't know enough about their sex lives. No wonder she wanted her things burnt, she knew her privacy would be destroyed. Some of us don't need to be all up in everyone's private life, to know what another woman or man chooses to do in their private bed. It's becoming where we are at risk of being defined by our sexuality. We are so much more than this. We are spiritual beings.
Tracie Becker Very well said. Close the bedroom door and come to the table, read and enjoy the fruits of the good book. Let's go on a trip of another's life. What will we learn? What secrets will we uncover? Only read then you can find out.
My spirit connected to the first book I read by Miss Cather. Our journeys all start with that first step,we explore,we experience,we gain knowledge and understanding. Whether we ever gain success...we were here and then we move to our next life enriched. Willa conveyed that very well. Thank you.
Same here, I'm 66 now, I camped for several months this summer in Neb., Wyo, Colo. and NM. Drove many miles across Nebraska twice once not far from Red Cloud and thought of Willa for the first time in many years. Paddled the Niobrara out of Valentine, Neb the day that Tim Walz was picked to be the running mate of VP Harris. Turns out he grew up in Valentine! I think it's time to read another of her stories after sleeping many nights in the sandhills of Neb.
My high school literature teacher introduced her work to me in the 70’s. I grew up on the prairie of ND. Never knew much about her life until now. Fascinating. Thank you for this gem.
Thank you so much for uploading this documentary on Willa Cather. Her stories 'The Song of the Lark' and 'My Antonia' have lingered with me for decades.
I am perhaps one of the few Brits who knows the works of Willa Cather. Inevitably perhaps the first I read was Death Comes for the Archbishop. I think America produced some marvelous writers in the early part of the 20th century. Willa Cather I certainly rank in the top drawer, along with Theodore Dreiser (how relevant is The Trilogy of Desire today), Carson McCullers and so on.
I'm far from a Cather scholar, but I've read a good bit of her stuff. The two, it seems to me, that most people talk about are Death Comes For The Archbishop and, of course, My Antonia. Both great books, but I would highly recommend The Song Of The Lark. That's the one that really got me. Anyone who is pursuing a life in the arts, or any life that is not the normal laid-out path - you would love that book. Her shorts, also, are great. "Neighbor Rossicky" had as much of an influence on my own writing as anything has. Style-wise, pacing-wise, I pretty much just imitated it for years. "The Enchanted Bluff," "The Sculptor's Funeral," "Coming, Aphrodite!" Etc, etc. Her shorts are really something.
A truly great writer. Those two central novels "The Professor's House" and "Death Comes For the Archbishop" are as good as anything in American fiction. They deal masterfully with universal themes, so that they speak even to me, a reader sitting in south west London. There can be no greater accolade, and hopefully, with many of her titles now appearing in Penguin Modern Classics, she will regain the wide readership she deserves.
Death Comes For The Archbishop was a truly magical reading experience for me. It was like being part of something sacred. Her writing style just grew on me. It's hard to describe. And this is coming from someone who can rarely sit still to focus on anything!
I listened to this with my heart...like Willa writes. I felt connection to her and wept, feeling her deep love of her women friends.... I'm a man and we aren't allowed sensitivity like that because it's considered effeminate.... I'm not unmanly, but I have melted a heart of stone.
Of course, I've known about her "forever," but just realized I have never actually read her books. This fine documentary has spurred me to do just that.
I've loved the writing of willa Cather since I was a teenager. The profound emotional impact of My Antonia and Oh Pioneers has haunted the many decades of my life. I recently reread My Antonia and was just as in awe as the first time I read it. Next, Oh Pioneers.
IMO....Willa Cathers' concrete imagery is amazing. And I love her view of things she thought was fascinating. I feel like she is a part of my own spirit.
My Antonia was the first Willa Cather book that I read in 6th grade. I'm from Nebraska and now live in Virginia. I completely understand how she became passionate about those open spaces. I long for them even now as I get older. I became passionate about the ocean. I will stay here in Virginia because I love it, but I will long for Nebraska till the day I die. I love her books. They take me back to those open expanses.
That is ironic. My family was from Virginia but I was raised in Nebraska. So it's the other way around for me. I knew of Willa Cather and her work from an early age. So her and Laura Ingles Wilder(I was born near her home in South Dakota) were THE authors of my childhood. Stuart Virginia, where my family is from is in the southwestern side of the state. So not very near back creek.
I haven't known any daughters who wanted to live a life like their mothers. This includes my friends, my grandmother, mother, my aunts, myself and my granddaughters That isn't some rare profound discovery of who a woman wants to be. She wants to be herself, off course.
@@avaperry9167 ah but I am born and bred.. I also don't want my daughter and granddaughters to be like me. I believe we are all meant to be unique. Of course there are similarities in biological traits and hopefully we teach each other to be caring and kind but I think our differences is what makes us, us ❤
Only 10 minutes in and being reminded of Will and Abby Deal that also moved to Nebraska after the Civil War. They are written about by Bess Streeter Aldrich in her book called, "A Lantern in Her Hand (1928)". I always wondered if Will and Abby Deal were her grandparents but have never really researched. Bess was born in Iowa in 1881 and died in Lincoln, Ne. in 1954. Her pen name was Margaret Dean Stephens but I never knew that until grabbing facts for this post. In any case I read that book at least 5 or 6 times as a pre-teen and teen. And a few others written by Bess. Just learning about Willa Cather and thinking that I'll be looking for some of her books. GREAT documentary thus far. Back to Willa Cather!
What an extraordinarily done documentary! What a remarkable life story and work of an amazing writer and woman. I loved listening to the female voice reading Willa Cather's writings... such a hypnotic voice... Thank you so much for this gem!
Thank you for this wonderful documentary. Such personalities outlive their natural lifespan, and I am reminded of the artist Georgia O’Keefe, who also thrived in New Mexico, who also found inspiration in the untamed environment. I shall certainly endeavour to find her books.
As Always PBS, has the Best programming & this Documentery was very well done🤗👍👏, Now I need to vsit my local Library & ck out what books they may have on Willa Cather, thank you👏😊
I'll never understand why Willa Cather has fallen out of fashion. I've read almost everything she ever wrote, including the young adult novel of the French Canadians. IMHO she and Mark Twain are the two greatest American novelists. Her masterpieces are the stories and novels of the westward settling of the the Great Plains. They chronicle an American past that never really was, but that we all believe is true. These works are quintessentially American folklore but must be read with a critical eye. The truth is there, but not readily apparent in the same way the Little House sagas of the same period seem so idyllic but are full of hardship and misery romanticized out of existence.
Young peope today don't care about the history of settling America. What past are you speaking if that really wasn't? My grandmother grew up in a dugout. I've been doing genealogy (fascinating and like reading a novel of pioneer days) and people in the mid 1800's traveled all over resettling. It really wasn't romantic. It was a very hard life. They had to always be preparing for the next day or week or they wouldn't have survived. My great grandfather helped settle the little town I grew up in.
An America that never really was? I think the lives described on My Antonia were the America that really was. Dugouts, suicide were only folklore? The corruption and decline of A lost Lady are folklore? Little House on the Prairie can't compare to Willa Cather's novels.
The experiences during that time (and indeed ALL times) were lived and experienced individually and in different ways by every single person. There can never be one account of what happened, not one true reality. Novels are like people: one voice, working to describe and share an experience or a vision of their world. The fact that it might be fiction, biographical, autobiographical or based on actual history, does not matter one whit - it is a life lived. The way that life is described and presented is what makes it a success. We cannot say that any novel distorts a human life, because somewhere amongst all of human society there will be elements of those experiences, even the idealised or romanticised aspects. If we can understand this, we can read and enjoy well written fiction as a version of human life.
Little House, book series written by Lauren Ingalls Wilder is meant for children, Willa Cather is a writer for adults, which is darker and more complicated than life on the "wholesome Nebraska Plaines".
Alison: Brilliant comment. Beautifully written. Thought provoking. Sound philosophy. Thank you from an 81 year old granny and frustrated writer in southwest Montana
Great documentary--thanks for sharing this. I love that Cather closed the blinds on her private life, even though I wish like crazy that her letters had survived. My introduction to Cather was 'The Bohemian Girl', which is still one of my favourites.
My heartfelt thanks to Dr. Angela Elliott, of Centenary College, for sharing this documentary years ago. I'm watching again, many years later without her, as she left us in 2015. Thanks Angela, for the immense wealth you gave me in life and now, in death.
Delighted to hear Marcia Gay Harden's reading! Never delighted when they say "he (a bishop, a king etc.) build..." when we sometimes know, sometimes not know how horrible the conditions for the workers were who BUILD. The people living there surely did not need a bishop and a cathedral!
Oh I read a few of her books and yes the energy you feel is so intense, and she flows like no other author I have read! I fell in love, and read Death for the Arch bishop and Oh Pioneer and My Antonia, I think of my Grandma coming to America through Ellis Island, going to North Dakota, in the 1800's. Just amazing How much you feel a part of it, want it crave it, Thank you for the wonderful documentary. She grew up here in Winchester not to far from where I live. I can't imagine how it was back then, Virginia's rolling hills, and valleys..
Beautifully done documentary. Ive always been an avid reader yet somehow lve missed reading any of Willa’s work! I’ll now purpose to find some of her books and enjoy them. There was such beauty in the parts of her writing which were shared in this documentary! So much of what was said of Willa’s reticence to her changing world rings true to me and my own writings of over 50 yrs will probably forever remain in storage as l haven’t the courage Willa possessed! Bravo for Willa!
I was on the mesa in the 1960's with my "Swinger" Camera . I can tell you I got a great picture of my fingertip and a half-a-snap of the cliff-dwelling. Good times were had by all!
I happened upon "O Pioneers" in a library years ago. I remember it being one of those stories in which I lost myself. I was inspired with the hope the main character was able to find in love and in the prairie, but I absolutely bawled at the senseless deaths of the people she loved. The depth of thought and feeling Cather brought out in me is hard to describe. I'd need Cather's talent to do that!
Excellent, in-depth documentary of a writer that, as mentioned, fell by the wayside after the wars. Upon seeing the Southwest for the first time, like Cather, I felt the enormity of space that is isolating yet comfortably accepting of the misfit or creative. That edition of "Death Comes for the Archbishop" shown in the doc is the same one I have here in New Mexico. Cather, so strong, independent, and creative, should be more widely known than she is now as it is obvious she was a trailblazer in journalism and creative writing.
I once did a spoken word where I was being filmed and I asked them to stop filming. I wanted people to remember me as I was and my words, my work. I totally understand what she meant. I got chills as the orator began reading a few lines of her words. Ty.
For whatever reasons,..people cannot just enjoy something for the wonderful story. There’s always the JUDGEMENT. Who cares what she did or did not do in her personal life? She was about living her life to give others stories to enjoy….. Wonderful documentary! I think I will read My Antonia tonight…..Thank You Willa Cather……❤
*Thank you for this wonderful documentary! I learned to love Willa Cather's writing in my 20's, and "My Ántonia" was the first book of "serious literature" that I tried to teach when I started working as a college lecturer in Japan. This first course was not an overwhelming success, but I hope to be able to repeat it at least once more--now that I've learned "a thing or two" about conducting literature courses for students whose language and culture is so remote from that of the USA--especially in the 19th and early 20th centuries.*
Beautifully scripted, narrated, and orchestrated documentary on an exceptionally gifted writer.
Really a fine example of public television and public radio. I think this is a great documentary .
This was an interesting documentary. I had never heard of this woman. My grandmother lived the life of "My Antonia". She was raised in a dugout near a lake in Iowa. She married and raised 9 children. One was my Father. I was raised next door to my grandmother in the 1950-60's. She then lived in a regular house and tho she had no running water her house was spotless. She had a garden, canned vegs and made bread. She was a quiet pleasant woman. Never complained.Just did her work as if it was just the way it is and you do what you had to do. I wish I had asked her more questions about growing up in that dugout. But I imagie she would have had a different outlook on it than I did. When I think I have it rough I think about my granny and my gr grandmother who rased my granny and her 7 siblings in that dugout. And wondeer what I'm complaining about..
Thanks so much for sharing, wow!
yes, those women had hard lives and few choices. it's heartbreaking to think of what they went through.
PK , very well said ... and well-written . You have a bit of a writer in you and if you don't already write , you might want to think about doing so because you have a way with words that people will appreciate ... and maybe even benefit from .
Yes, thank you for sharing your story. I can’t imagine I live in the dugout and raise kids and wash clothes no running water in boiling water to wash clothes that was a one full day of laundering.
I would like to recommend the book: “Bird by Bird” which teaches you how to write in a simple way by Anne Lanotte.
You may also want to read the book by Elinore Pruitt Stewart: “Letters of a Woman Homesteader,”
Elinor is so down to earth humorous and endearing.
It’s one of my favorite books I read each spring.
She will also inspire you to write.
🌷 Wishing you all the best,
~ Nell
@@gardensofthegods thank you . I've always wanted to write but have been a huge procrastinator. My High School English teacher always said I had talent too Maybe it's not too late. :-) I have a lot of events in my life I could put into short stories. My own life would be quite the novel.... Some nitty gritty and triumph combined....Thank you for the encouragement.
Thank you for the beautiful documentary, a piece of art in itself. I enjoyed every moment of it
...a beautiful documentary. I read My Antonia years ago when I was in my 20's. I'm 74 now and would like to revisit it.
What a wonderful documentary about the author, Willa Cather. I have all her novels.
I wrote my Masters thesis (1987) on Willa Cather's southwest novels, Death Comes for the Archbishop, mainly and the two parts about the Southwest in The Professor's House and Song of the Lark. My thesis was that she treated landscape as a character in all of her novels, using all of these as examples. I read all of her novels and a great deal of the research on her. I had a fabulous Professor who taught a seminar class on her work, who was also a famous author, William Dickey, which sparked a love of her work; I had lived in both Nebraska and New Mexico (my favorite state) , as a military brat, as well as in Europe.
I am struck by this careful, respectful look at the art and life of Willa Cather. Thank you.
Finally after 40+ years of sitting on my shelf, I am opening a Library of America volume Willa Cather Later Novels. Watching this beautiful documentary is very emotional 😢 truly a great American, an amazing mind, a truly free woman
Willa Cather is one of my favorite North American authors. I love her short stories, as well as her novels. Truly brilliant.
I wrote my undergraduate senior thesis on Willa Cather. I read most of her books. I really love her work. She had a unique voice for women. My Antonia was the focus but I just loved all of her female characters.
I must say I really enjoyed this biography of Willa Cather. I had never heard of her but now I'm going to go and pick up one of her books. Thank you for introducing her to us
Willa Cather lived just 35 miles from where my grandfather grew up. So her stories are a magic carpet ride to my grandpa's childhood. ♥️
This is one of the best programs of its kind that I have had the pleasure of viewing. Thank you, to all involved with creating this and getting it to us.
The best story of an American writer I have ever read. Bravo
Brilliant, elucidating, moving, documentary. I felt her so deeply and found it changed me. Thank you.
What strikes me about this very introspective and highly gifted writer is her humbleness and true grit to follow her path for writing. I am touched by her love for women who grant her wish of destroying their letters so their love and true selves are strictly private. A fascinating woman indeed. I thoroughly enjoyed the bio pic of Willa. Marvellous! Thank you.
Loved this ❤
I've been a fan of Cathers' work for almost 30 years. This film has made me fall in love all over again. Thanks for this gift for lovers of enduring literature.
Found her at the library to read all her stuff decades ago. Unusually enjoyable even set in a place that normally would not draw my interest.....that well written. Cutting her hair off, dressing in male clothes, later she came out as gay living in N.Y.C.
Loved this documentary, what an amazing woman and writer!! Thank you.
An amazing writer who led an equally amazing life. Thank you for a truly wonderful documentary!
Of course!
So many things to learn from Willa Cather!
Öl å was
I loved this. Rest in peace Ms.Cather, you are not forgotten.
So beautifully written and illustrated. Thank you for posting this!
I enjoyed this documentary . I was made aware of this lady author. Her life must have been very lonely. 82 and have endured many years per self and it’s no life.
A wonderful documentary. She was hugely brave multiple times to leave a pleasant "sure thing" and jump into the unknown again and again. And she succeeded in something many artists aspire to, she managed to erase her personal life and leave us only with her written work.
It's because of Willa Cather that I took up writing. I love (and still own) the ancient copy of My Antonia from which I studied Cather's writing, word for word. She was able to make you feel the heat of the train car rumbling across the prairie, and feel the cloud of dust as your hand hit the hot, fading red velvet covered car seats. The Shimerdas - the life of the immigrants, the Swedes - she made it all come to life. I was always sad to read the ending of when Antonia was a mother with missing teeth due to her harsh life, so would always go back and read when she was a bright and sunny girl again, with chestnut cheeks. I must have read that book once a year for at least 3 decades - just to keep my own writing fresh. She, and F. Scott Fitzgerald's "The Great Gatsby," and Robert Nathan's "Portrait of Jenny," are the go-to books to study for any aspiring writer. As Anton Chekhov - another must-read writer, wrote, "Don’t tell me the moon is shining; show me the glint of light on broken glass."
Loved *My Antonia*, btw... The Shimerdas were Bohemian, not Swedish. Also, haunted by *Portrait of Jenny*.. the movie was good, too. Robert Nathan was a rare find; a fellow librarian introduced him to me. I thought it was a true story (because of the intro?) Short but sweet. If you have a powerful theme, it doesn't matter how long or short your novel is. Hudson's *Green Mansions* is another haunting book like this. Not too crazy about F. Scott Fitzgerald, though.
Still need to read Chekhov.
@@LS-ei7xk If you were my neighbor, we'd be fast friends! It is next to never that I have heard of anyone has read Portrait of Jenny - let alone knew it was a book before they made the movie! Or who was as enamored with My Antonia as I. The Great Gatsby is in this group of great novels, I think, because his descriptions are succinct yet visually powerful, and one can learn a lot just through that alone. And he was only 27 when he wrote it! But, I do confess it took me decades to get into it. I had tried to read it but always shut the book after the first two paragraphs of the first chapter - until one day I forced myself to read it through, and I was hooked. Another great book is, believe it or not, A Christmas Carol by Dickens. But topping that book is his masterpiece, Great Expectations. The characters are so alive, you can feel sympathy for them, or hate them just as easily, but it also has that great twist in the end. He had characterization, form and plot down to perfection. My fortune is that I did not even know what the book was about until my friend nagged at me to read it - blew my mind. Add to that repertoire is, of course, Gone with the Wind. It is so thick, that one of my friends who begged me to read it after I balked at the size of the novel, promised me that I would not be able to put it down. I took up her challenge - and true to her word, read that whole, entire, voluminous book in one weekend, unable to sleep until I finished it.
Regarding the Shimerdas being Bohemian and not Swedish - I guess I should have written that sentence more clearly - Yes, the Shimerdas were Bohemian, but Cather also wrote about the life of the immigrants as well as the Swedish immigrant population - the girls in town who took in laundry and worked for others. That is what I meant. A lot of love for the Nebraskan immigrants whether they were Bohemians or Swedes, went into Cather's writing. I'm thankful for the likes of her as well as Dickens, Nathan and other fine novelists, because the art of the novel seems to be dying in this texting and often vulgar age. We need to bring back the beauty of language.
I read “My Antonia” in college, and I love that book ever since.
You can smell, feel, taste, the world she paints artfully, each sentence crafted keenly, with beautifully chosen words. Her personal life was superfluous to her work and she knew it, God love her, and saw to it, it remain so. Smart lady.
her writing is truly like no one else's.
I love David McCullough and his thoroughly knowledgeable historical perspective.
Beautiful documentary. Truly moving picture of her life.
“My Antonia” is available for free in PDF form. Just google the title and put pdf. Happy reading. 🥀
Thank you
Thanks and hope to read it, after watching this fantastic documentary film.
@@dimitrialiberty2779 it’s such a pleasure to pass this on. 📚
@@yeowkl7541 I think the book might be even better than this amazing documentary. Enjoy! 📖
I watched this from Ireland and applaud you for a most beautifully crafted documentary
This was a superb documentary in all its aspect from the writing, the narration, the photography, even the accompanying music
PBS, of course! Awoke at 3am, ciuldnt slerp, found this delight and now a new fan! What a fantastic bio. Looking forward to reading her works. Loved the excerpts.
This is wonderful. Thank you. I'm English and had never heard of this lady until now.
What a brilliant and gifted lady . Ahead of her time. By the way , to whoever who made this documentary , you did an excellent job . Support PBS .
🕊️🕯️🕯️🕯️🕊️VERY WELL SAID.....
yes! the clip of her at 14 getting her hair buzzcut blew me away. i have too many thoughts to write them all now!
She was not "ahead of her time." She was exactly OF her time. It's where she lived and where she worked. IN her time.
First time hearing about her, interesting I like Walt Whitman. And John Keats.
I have a Shakespeare book
this showed up in my youtube recommendations! i am so happy! this was an incredible documentary! I look forward to watching more, especially women writer's.
Same here. It is a wonderful depiction of her life. She seemed as if she never really knew herself and was continually searching all her life.
This was a brilliantly conceived and executed documentary. The selection of the people who commented or criticized was faultless, as was the editing of their thoughts with the passages from Cather’s books. I would go so far as to say that this is one of the finest and most revealing biographical docs I have ever seen. Even the musical interludes were sympathetic to the content. Never before have I felt so inclined to find without delay and read the works of any author. bravo to the entire team who constructed this flawless portrait.
😊😊😊
I agree. The narrator of her work gives an exquisite performance. Every word savoured.
Agreed. It really is flawless. Even the discussion of her personal life and sexuality was done so well, no hyperbole or agenda. We don't KNOW, because we don't know. And it has nothing to do with the WORK, which is all that really matters.
And Alison, the woman reading Cather's words is Marcia Gay Harden. Great actress. Miller's Crossing, Pollock, Mystic River.
You are a gifted writer yourself.
So true! Love this doc too, was thinking it on the level with Ken Burns (in quality & emotions) & even better!
Reading her books took me back to a time and place that lived again through her writing...so moving.
A thoroughly enjoyable documentary. I really enjoyed learning about Willa Cather. A true artist!
How wonderful to find this author in 2024 with all that is going on today she would be amazed iam 76 and happy to find out life and people do not change we are born who we are and who we will be*
I read five of her books in a row. This was so interesting. The prairie is beautiful. I saw it while on a train to LA.
One of my all time favorites : READ HER!
All I can say is Wow.. She is one of my favorite authors.
What a beautiful presentation -the music, the presenters, and of course the subject. I knew nothing of the lady. Thank you.
This was a documentary that I never knew I needed. I am so glad I clicked to check it out though. Wonderful!
Very thorough biography; I am truly impressed
Extraordinary - thank you. “My Antonia” has been one of my favorite books for decades, read and reread it many times, but never knew anything at all about the author, now I know more….
What a splendid documentary. Thank you for introducing me to this fascinating person.
Beautifully done documentary. Absolutely worth watching.
I love her work and, as much, her fierce privacy and share her feelings. Many Americans, today, feel they are entitled to know public figures intimately and I don't blame their fury upon intrusion. She was truly gifted and under appreciated in today's pseudo intellectual literary landscape.
Fascinating!!! thank you
When I visit Mabel Dodge Lujan House in Taos, I always stay in Willa Cather's room to soak up the vibes.
Love that!
I wish people would stop so hoping for people to be homosexual to the point they would be disappointed if they aren't when they don't know enough about their sex lives.
No wonder she wanted her things burnt, she knew her privacy would be destroyed. Some of us don't need to be all up in everyone's private life, to know what another woman or man chooses to do in their private bed.
It's becoming where we are at risk of being defined by our sexuality.
We are so much more than this. We are spiritual beings.
Not any more, we're not. Now we're vulgar peeping Toms. (Not you and me, of course; "we" as a society.)
Tracie Becker
Very well said.
Close the bedroom door and come to the table, read and enjoy the fruits of the good book. Let's go on a trip of another's life. What will we learn? What secrets will we uncover? Only read then you can find out.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
@@hijodelaisla275 Hubris seems to be your forte.
@@carolperczak9938 And making baseless slurs seems to be yours.
My spirit connected to the first book I read by Miss Cather. Our journeys all start with that first step,we explore,we experience,we gain knowledge and understanding. Whether we ever gain success...we were here and then we move to our next life enriched. Willa conveyed that very well. Thank you.
This is such a thoughtful comment, so now I'm curious: what was the first book of Cather's that you read?
O Pioneers
@@karenwright8556 Thank you! I'm adding it to my reading list.
@@tothelighthouse9843 Thank you,enjoy the good read!
Excellent documentary! Thank you
Magnificent documentary. Just exquisite. The story of a beautiful lady and of her life and her gift. Presented in such a perfect way.
Thank you for this! Willa Cather is my favorite American novelist!
That's awesome! I love her short stories myself
I read Death comes to the Archbishop 45 years ago and it remains strongly fixed in my memory. A truly great novel.
Same here, I'm 66 now, I camped for several months this summer in Neb., Wyo, Colo. and NM. Drove many miles across Nebraska twice once not far from Red Cloud and thought of Willa for the first time in many years. Paddled the Niobrara out of Valentine, Neb the day that Tim Walz was picked to be the running mate of VP Harris. Turns out he grew up in Valentine! I think it's time to read another of her stories after sleeping many nights in the sandhills of Neb.
My high school literature teacher introduced her work to me in the 70’s. I grew up on the prairie of ND. Never knew much about her life until now. Fascinating. Thank you for this gem.
Thank you so much for uploading this documentary on Willa Cather. Her stories 'The Song of the Lark' and 'My Antonia' have lingered with me for decades.
Thank you for this! One of my favourite Writers, Willa Ella Cather! 🙏🍀💕
Wow! I read My Antonia many yrs ago and have never forgotten it. This is wonderful. I am motivated to read others! Thank you!
What an incredible early American writer! Why has her Virgina birth house outside Winchester, been abandoned?
I am perhaps one of the few Brits who knows the works of Willa Cather. Inevitably perhaps the first I read was Death Comes for the Archbishop. I think America produced some marvelous writers in the early part of the 20th century. Willa Cather I certainly rank in the top drawer, along with Theodore Dreiser (how relevant is The Trilogy of Desire today), Carson McCullers and so on.
I'm from the UK and was fortunate enough to be introduced to Willa Cather at university 40 years ago. She is still my favourite writer!
How am I 59 years old and never heard of this author and her books? And I was a reader all my life. Going to have to catch up...
Because your school system sucked
Well I am 57 and also just discoveted het on YT. I have some excuses tough.
Me too, which book should I start with?
My Antonia is a masterpiece
@@BoninBrighton I loved all of her works that I've read, but Song of the Lark was my favorite.
I'm far from a Cather scholar, but I've read a good bit of her stuff. The two, it seems to me, that most people talk about are Death Comes For The Archbishop and, of course, My Antonia.
Both great books, but I would highly recommend The Song Of The Lark. That's the one that really got me. Anyone who is pursuing a life in the arts, or any life that is not the normal laid-out path - you would love that book.
Her shorts, also, are great. "Neighbor Rossicky" had as much of an influence on my own writing as anything has. Style-wise, pacing-wise, I pretty much just imitated it for years.
"The Enchanted Bluff," "The Sculptor's Funeral," "Coming, Aphrodite!" Etc, etc. Her shorts are really something.
Thank you for this, I have appreciated hearing about this amazing writer who lived through challenging times.
A truly great writer. Those two central novels "The Professor's House" and "Death Comes For the Archbishop" are as good as anything in American fiction. They deal masterfully with universal themes, so that they speak even to me, a reader sitting in south west London. There can be no greater accolade, and hopefully, with many of her titles now appearing in Penguin Modern Classics, she will regain the wide readership she deserves.
Was this remark posted by Tony Bennett, professor of cultural studies?
Death Comes For The Archbishop was a truly magical reading experience for me. It was like being part of something sacred. Her writing style just grew on me. It's hard to describe. And this is coming from someone who can rarely sit still to focus on anything!
Death Comes for Archbishop is my favorite of hers.
I listened to this with my heart...like Willa writes. I felt connection to her and wept, feeling her deep love of her women friends.... I'm a man and we aren't allowed sensitivity like that because it's considered effeminate.... I'm not unmanly, but I have melted a heart of stone.
Of course, I've known about her "forever," but just realized I have never actually read her books. This fine documentary has spurred me to do just that.
7
I've loved the writing of willa Cather since I was a teenager. The profound emotional impact of My Antonia and Oh Pioneers has haunted the many decades of my life. I recently reread My Antonia and was just as in awe as the first time I read it. Next, Oh Pioneers.
"Hell, even I thought I was dead once...'til I found out that I was just in Nebraska."
( Little Bill Dagget, _Unforgiven_ ).
IMO....Willa Cathers' concrete imagery is amazing. And I love her view of things she thought was fascinating. I feel like she is a part of my own spirit.
Very much enjoyed this documentary. Thank you.
Amazing documentary thank you! I'm so inspired and will be buying her novels
My Antonia was the first Willa Cather book that I read in 6th grade. I'm from Nebraska and now live in Virginia. I completely understand how she became passionate about those open spaces. I long for them even now as I get older. I became passionate about the ocean. I will stay here in Virginia because I love it, but I will long for Nebraska till the day I die. I love her books. They take me back to those open expanses.
That is ironic. My family was from Virginia but I was raised in Nebraska. So it's the other way around for me. I knew of Willa Cather and her work from an early age. So her and Laura Ingles Wilder(I was born near her home in South Dakota) were THE authors of my childhood. Stuart Virginia, where my family is from is in the southwestern side of the state. So not very near back creek.
I haven't known any daughters who wanted to live a life like their mothers.
This includes my friends, my grandmother, mother, my aunts, myself and my granddaughters That isn't some rare profound discovery of who a woman wants to be. She wants to be herself, off course.
You definitely aren’t Southern!
@@avaperry9167 ah but I am born and bred..
I also don't want my daughter and granddaughters to be like me. I believe we are all meant to be unique.
Of course there are similarities in biological traits and hopefully we teach each other to be caring and kind but I think our differences is what makes us, us ❤
Love this. Thank you for the upload. New Mexico is a very Spiritual place
Only 10 minutes in and being reminded of Will and Abby Deal that also moved to Nebraska after the Civil War. They are written about by Bess Streeter Aldrich in her book called, "A Lantern in Her Hand (1928)". I always wondered if Will and Abby Deal were her grandparents but have never really researched. Bess was born in Iowa in 1881 and died in Lincoln, Ne. in 1954. Her pen name was Margaret Dean Stephens but I never knew that until grabbing facts for this post.
In any case I read that book at least 5 or 6 times as a pre-teen and teen. And a few others written by Bess. Just learning about Willa Cather and thinking that I'll be looking for some of her books.
GREAT documentary thus far. Back to Willa Cather!
How wonderful these documentaries are! Thank you.
Glad you enjoy them!
What an extraordinarily done documentary! What a remarkable life story and work of an amazing writer and woman. I loved listening to the female voice reading Willa Cather's writings... such a hypnotic voice... Thank you so much for this gem!
The actress is Marcia Gay Harden.
@@zharapatterson Thank you so very much! I really loved her voice and interpretation... It was so touching...
Thank you for this wonderful documentary.
Such personalities outlive their natural lifespan, and I am reminded of the artist
Georgia O’Keefe, who also thrived in New Mexico, who also found inspiration in the untamed environment.
I shall certainly endeavour to find her books.
As Always PBS, has the Best programming & this Documentery was very well done🤗👍👏, Now I need to vsit my local Library & ck out what books they may have on Willa Cather, thank you👏😊
My mother had me read My Antonia when I was in grade school. Thank you, Mom. Great call. I am 64 and I still remember being enthralled.
Brilliant. I loved every minute. I will read Willa Cather.
Wow!! I have just witnessed a great writer I knew nothing about. Thank you!
Like many people, I had not heard of this woman; another great PBS job, dramatic but without hysteria, a well held line.
I'll never understand why Willa Cather has fallen out of fashion. I've read almost everything she ever wrote, including the young adult novel of the French Canadians. IMHO she and Mark Twain are the two greatest American novelists. Her masterpieces are the stories and novels of the westward settling of the the Great Plains. They chronicle an American past that never really was, but that we all believe is true. These works are quintessentially American folklore but must be read with a critical eye. The truth is there, but not readily apparent in the same way the Little House sagas of the same period seem so idyllic but are full of hardship and misery romanticized out of existence.
Young peope today don't care about the history of settling America. What past are you speaking if that really wasn't? My grandmother grew up in a dugout. I've been doing genealogy (fascinating and like reading a novel of pioneer days) and people in the mid 1800's traveled all over resettling. It really wasn't romantic. It was a very hard life. They had to always be preparing for the next day or week or they wouldn't have survived. My great grandfather helped settle the little town I grew up in.
An America that never really was? I think the lives described on My Antonia were the America that really was. Dugouts, suicide were only folklore? The corruption and decline of A lost Lady are folklore? Little House on the Prairie can't compare to Willa Cather's novels.
The experiences during that time (and indeed ALL times) were lived and experienced individually and in different ways by every single person. There can never be one account of what happened, not one true reality.
Novels are like people: one voice, working to describe and share an experience or a vision of their world. The fact that it might be fiction, biographical, autobiographical or based on actual history, does not matter one whit - it is a life lived. The way that life is described and presented is what makes it a success. We cannot say that any novel distorts a human life, because somewhere amongst all of human society there will be elements of those experiences, even the idealised or romanticised aspects. If we can understand this, we can read and enjoy well written fiction as a version of human life.
Little House, book series written by Lauren Ingalls Wilder is meant for children, Willa Cather is a writer for adults, which is darker and more complicated than life on the "wholesome Nebraska Plaines".
Alison: Brilliant comment. Beautifully written. Thought provoking. Sound philosophy. Thank you from an 81 year old granny and frustrated writer in southwest Montana
Great documentary--thanks for sharing this.
I love that Cather closed the blinds on her private life, even though I wish like crazy that her letters had survived.
My introduction to Cather was 'The Bohemian Girl', which is still one of my favourites.
What a treasure. Thank you for creating the videos!
My heartfelt thanks to Dr. Angela Elliott, of Centenary College, for sharing this documentary years ago. I'm watching again, many years later without her, as she left us in 2015. Thanks Angela, for the immense wealth you gave me in life and now, in death.
Delighted to hear Marcia Gay Harden's reading! Never delighted when they say "he (a bishop, a king etc.) build..." when we sometimes know, sometimes not know how horrible the conditions for the workers were who BUILD. The people living there surely did not need a bishop and a cathedral!
Oh I read a few of her books and yes the energy you feel is so intense, and she flows like no other author I have read! I fell in love, and read Death for the Arch bishop and Oh Pioneer and My Antonia, I think of my Grandma coming to America through Ellis Island, going to North Dakota, in the 1800's. Just amazing How much you feel a part of it, want it crave it, Thank you for the wonderful documentary. She grew up here in Winchester not to far from where I live. I can't imagine how it was back then, Virginia's rolling hills, and valleys..
Thoroughly enjoyed this, thanks for posting. Had never heard of her before and eager to start reading her work. Thanks from Ireland x
Wonderful brilliant
Thank you so much for your dedication to this subject documentary!
Beautifully done documentary. Ive always been an avid reader yet somehow lve missed reading any of Willa’s work! I’ll now purpose to find some of her books and enjoy them. There was such beauty in the parts of her writing which were shared in this documentary! So much of what was said of Willa’s reticence to her changing world rings true to me and my own writings of over 50 yrs will probably forever remain in storage as l haven’t the courage Willa possessed! Bravo for Willa!
I absolutely love her writing.
Willa Cather surpasses others.
I was on the mesa in the 1960's with my "Swinger" Camera . I can tell you I got a great picture of my fingertip and a half-a-snap of the cliff-dwelling. Good times were had by all!
I had a Swinger! I remember taking pictures of everything.
I happened upon "O Pioneers" in a library years ago. I remember it being one of those stories in which I lost myself. I was inspired with the hope the main character was able to find in love and in the prairie, but I absolutely bawled at the senseless deaths of the people she loved. The depth of thought and feeling Cather brought out in me is hard to describe. I'd need Cather's talent to do that!
great artists just show others what is in them.
Excellent, in-depth documentary of a writer that, as mentioned, fell by the wayside after the wars. Upon seeing the Southwest for the first time, like Cather, I felt the enormity of space that is isolating yet comfortably accepting of the misfit or creative. That edition of "Death Comes for the Archbishop" shown in the doc is the same one I have here in New Mexico. Cather, so strong, independent, and creative, should be more widely known than she is now as it is obvious she was a trailblazer in journalism and creative writing.
Nels: Beautifully written comment. It's refreshing to read your well crafted words. I'm a frustrated writer. 81 yr old granny, in Montana, USA.
I once did a spoken word where I was being filmed and I asked them to stop filming. I wanted people to remember me as I was and my words, my work. I totally understand what she meant. I got chills as the orator began reading a few lines of her words. Ty.
For whatever reasons,..people cannot just enjoy something for the wonderful story. There’s always the JUDGEMENT. Who cares what she did or did not do in her personal life? She was about living her life to give others stories to enjoy…..
Wonderful documentary! I think I will read My Antonia tonight…..Thank You Willa Cather……❤
*Thank you for this wonderful documentary! I learned to love Willa Cather's writing in my 20's, and "My Ántonia" was the first book of "serious literature" that I tried to teach when I started working as a college lecturer in Japan. This first course was not an overwhelming success, but I hope to be able to repeat it at least once more--now that I've learned "a thing or two" about conducting literature courses for students whose language and culture is so remote from that of the USA--especially in the 19th and early 20th centuries.*