Here are my picks for the best of the best when it comes to each season (that matters) of Thomas & Friends! Thank you for watching and please share your picks down below!
I think Daisy is clearly the MVP of S20 cause of her best use of returnee screen-time and how she's used. I do hope Toad gets the MVP of S18 for that same reason.
I love how the fandom pretty much completely agree on seasons 1-4 MVPs here's my input 1-5: same as yours for same reasons 6: hear me out Salty considering in just a few episodes he changed the status quo with the docks and we see his fun side, emotional side, non chalant side and never letting the little demons, cranky, and gordon get to him. Heck right after his debut bill and ben permanently respect him 7: Gordon in a season where barely anyone got extended focus we saw all sides with him tho this season was a toss up between him, emily and arthur for me 8: James for your reasons 9: Percy same as unlucky tug reasons 10: James for same reasons as unlucky tug 11: Gordon for being a big brother role 12: Hector literally no one else optimal 17: Hiro for having great leads 18: Duncan for completing his character arc and actually maturing 19: Thomas same reasons as yours 20: Daisy for your reasons plus I am sure we all are gonna predict this when tug gets to here 21: Cranky for completing his character arc that being said diesel was extremely close
There are characters at their development point during each season even with the bad ones which you don't discuss here on the channel and it's fine but respected for me.
@@karenfan010 there’s still elements of it at play in future seasons however in Trusty Rusty, Duncan Gets Spooked, Dunkin Duncan etc. and since no other reason is given than the one seen in S4 of Duncan not liking Rusty for being a diesel, it can be assumed it is for that reason thus the arc has reset itself
@@PeePeeSam but duncan wasn’t biased against rusty in either of those episodes, duncan gets spooked was about him not believing ghosts and dunkin duncan was about him rushing his work, rusty just happened to be the voice of reason in those episodes.
I’m glad we agree with most of these but that we also give some other contenders in packed seasons the award if someone else already had a win or it was just your personal opinion
@@LazyOldFusspot_3428 Gordon - I feel he’s the most consistently written across the entirety of the show and always managed to have the best episodes in spite of how poor the quality of writing may have been 👍🏻
I think Daisy is clearly the MVP of S20 cause of her best use of returnee screen-time and how she's used. I do hope Toad gets the MVP of S18 for that same reason.
I think it's INCREDIBLY obvious that when Tug does her sodors finest it's an EASY CGI win and I think season 20 she'll be MVP
I love how the fandom pretty much completely agree on seasons 1-4 MVPs here's my input
1-5: same as yours for same reasons
6: hear me out Salty considering in just a few episodes he changed the status quo with the docks and we see his fun side, emotional side, non chalant side and never letting the little demons, cranky, and gordon get to him. Heck right after his debut bill and ben permanently respect him
7: Gordon in a season where barely anyone got extended focus we saw all sides with him tho this season was a toss up between him, emily and arthur for me
8: James for your reasons
9: Percy same as unlucky tug reasons
10: James for same reasons as unlucky tug
11: Gordon for being a big brother role
12: Hector literally no one else optimal
17: Hiro for having great leads
18: Duncan for completing his character arc and actually maturing
19: Thomas same reasons as yours
20: Daisy for your reasons plus I am sure we all are gonna predict this when tug gets to here
21: Cranky for completing his character arc that being said diesel was extremely close
Another banger video my friend. Some strong choices and loved your passion when promoting Peter Sam as the season 4 character 😜
Very well done ☺️🚂🚃
@@TheGingerEngine thank you very much my friend! The support is always appreciated!
Great picks! I'm not sure who I'd say is my favourite for each season, I'll need to make a list some point as I'm curious now
@@amitysluzara2022 thank you for the support!
There are characters at their development point during each season even with the bad ones which you don't discuss here on the channel and it's fine but respected for me.
3:06 that was only one episode it never happened again afterwards.
@@karenfan010 there’s still elements of it at play in future seasons however in Trusty Rusty, Duncan Gets Spooked, Dunkin Duncan etc. and since no other reason is given than the one seen in S4 of Duncan not liking Rusty for being a diesel, it can be assumed it is for that reason thus the arc has reset itself
@@PeePeeSam but duncan wasn’t biased against rusty in either of those episodes, duncan gets spooked was about him not believing ghosts and dunkin duncan was about him rushing his work, rusty just happened to be the voice of reason in those episodes.
I’m glad we agree with most of these but that we also give some other contenders in packed seasons the award if someone else already had a win or it was just your personal opinion
i agree with a lot of these picks, also the season 4 pick was so shocking
@@Cooperfriends1856 I bet it was 😂
You just skipped the nitrogen era
@@meciomontoya8440 yep! Didn’t want to talk about them, I never really do with these videos 👍🏻
@@PeePeeSamnone of them are good so why bother
Because there’s nothing working talking about
However I would give season 13 Hiro and Season 16 Luke or Victor if I have to throw them a bone
Who is the best written character between the big engines and why?
@@LazyOldFusspot_3428 Gordon - I feel he’s the most consistently written across the entirety of the show and always managed to have the best episodes in spite of how poor the quality of writing may have been 👍🏻
Magnificent
@@naveentaylor6197 thank you!
Rex
What’s your favorite hit season
@@eileenmurphy8150 Season 9 👍🏻
Agreed magic lamp the best hit episode
Was that the class acts opening by brandon Rogers
@@rileywebster2008 indeed 👍🏻
You skipped the Nitrogen Era and BWBA Era
@@duckno.8woodenrailway I always do with videos like these, as I do not want to talk about them 👍🏻
I understand. Those seasons are trash
Yesterday I made Peter Sam speak like in The Show
Awesome
@@BlueyTheNarrowGaugeEngine thank you!