356m Tall Skyscraper Shaking Again, Monitoring Data released, analysis of the causes of shaking
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- On May 20th, Shenzhen's third tallest skyscraper, the 356 meters tall SEG Plaza, shook once again for the third time after similar shaking on the 18th and 19th.
On the same day, a number of SEG Plaza merchants said that around 12:30pm, the 35th, 55th, 60th and many other floors felt shaking, and security guards have informed merchants on higher floors to evacuate.
There is also a video uploaded by netizens showing a number of large trucks carrying building materials into SEG Plaza. Various construction materials are also piled up on the ground floor of the building.
The group said that according to the test data, everything is normal and do not exceed the corresponding limitations.
Some netizens called into question the causes of shaking given by the experts. So why didn’t it shake before?
The construction quality of SEG Plaza has since become a hot topic of discussion.
SEG Plaza was given all kinds of praise by Chinese officials at the time. However, a 20-year-old master's thesis from Huazhong University of Science and Technology, titled "Shenzhen SEG Plaza Construction Project Review" was dug up in the past two days and became viral on the Internet, referred to as "divine prophecy" by Chinese netizens.
The author of the paper pointed out some shortcomings in the construction process. For example, modifying the design while construction was underway, designing after construction, and starting construction before the design drawings were done.
The recent developments of SEG Plaza’s shaking incident have caused people to think about China's other super high-rise buildings.
According to statistics, China has 40% of the world's high-rise buildings, including 2395 buildings above 150 meters, 823 buildings above 200 meters, and 95 buildings above 300 meters, all three numbers rank first in the world.
Some industry insiders analyze that SEG Plaza is a typical example of China's large-scale construction projects, and quality problems are certain. Large-scale construction projects in China have 5 characteristics.
#China#ShakingBuilding#SEGPlaza#Shenzhen#356mSkyscraper#ToufuBuilding
All rights reserved!
![Tee Grizzley - Blow for Blow (feat. J. Cole) [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wNLN5xsx5dc/mqdefault.jpg)
"the building shook again as if it's not willing to cooperate with the experts' explanations" LOL
😂
Where
Timestamp please
@@bomdila 0:30
@@newerest1 thanks 😂👍
It must be Monday lol
I think the narrator meant to say “corroborate” :p
It has a new award, 'shakiest building in the world'.
Ok
They should put it on Tiktok.
Its shaking when theres no earthquake, imagine if theres an actual earthquake
Won't have much impact...
That's the only time it actually stands still.
There's a list of buildings that have fallen in the USA on Wikipedia. I would question why this skyscraper is in question after 20 years. Everyone agrees there is HAARP technology.. No such thing as tectonics?
Don't get your panties in a bunch US sympathizers.
@@15seconds3 slow 👏
@@15seconds3 I am pretty sure they will say the same thing if it were US, like "THE COMPANY MUST BE SUED!" "SUCH UNACEPTABLE! !!".
edit: they will probably blame the democrats or republicans tho .
They are monitoring it closely until it collapses.
They will have data on the longevity of the building so that they construct buildings that last precisely for 5 years maximum.
A through and complete study
"Seems that the building has suffered a catastrophic failure" says the monitoring team
That building contractor better of left the country or he is going to jail
🙈
Reminds me of the old saying- Do you want it right, or do you want it right now? because you can't have both.
I can give you the right answer to 1 + 1 right now for our standard decimal numerical system. It is 2.
Checkmate, old saying.
I did the vibration research before (on industrial centrifuges), although not on the building, the basic concept is the same. Before the building foundation is solid, now you have trains running under the building, so the foundation is not as solid as before, this will change the natural frequency of the building, ...., my suggestion is to put grand pianos in each room of each level, adjust the mass of the building, this way the natural frequency of the building will also be changed, hence, the shaking should be eliminated.
🤣😂🤣
We ain't got the time to do it right! But we got the time to do it twice !
Awww man, I'm storing this one in my noggin, the Missus will be hearing this line very soon 😂 👌 🍻
Anyone with an ounce of sense will get out and not go back.
@ Lars Cain - you are one hundred percent, right ! Roland Singh, Canada 🇨🇦
If you are suffering from motion sickness, working in tall buildings not suitable for you.
@@rolandsingh its common sense that the building being 79 storey tall does not mean it is 100% free from defects. Swaying is an inherent characteristic and to dampen it is in the equation.
@@acheable According to the Video, the building wasn't "swaying". It was SHAKING !! 😒
@@rolandsingh Swaying and vibration as reported partly due to the vortex induced resonance of the two long vertical mast or antennas at the top of the tower. Experts initially suspected the vertical mast based on similar vibrations it caused for similar installations in tall towers elsewhere.
They give themselves awards! Just like they do their own investigation!🤣⚰️
Everybody gets a trophy! It's the modern way!
Copying Boeing and FAA. Same builder and regulator gangster.
@@josephgaviota Reminds me if a certain political viewpoint in the US.
Kind of like police brutality internal investigation in the US!
Just like holly weird.
We will never learn that rushing engineers and construction workers on a critical infrastructure project is not a good idea, right?
Seven months before the deadline, omg
Their sex also have deadline,Max 5 mins
reminds me of Australia. We have a couple of buildings like that the industry is plagued with corruption
@@pixelmasque it is the exception rather than the rule.
@@normanschlongdongovic4124 They maxamized pull out speed though. They’re pros at not procreating. (No hate, just facts)
Same country that hid how serious COVID-19 was. Didn’t want the help required to prevent a pandemic.
It was leaked in the WuhanLab where hundreds of coronavirus were being tested....
Make the building a government headquarters and then see if they start showing some interest in proper investigations and accountability.
🇺🇲🦅🪂👍🏼
Cubic yards (meters) of concrete...at least know what you’re talking about.
BoCom sez it already is. 👀. Ask Andrew the Bunnie what was in and around that building
Obviously some tie points have fractured, and it may only be a matter of time before a Chinese gravity anomaly occurs.
👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
She’s coming down - just a mater of time, shaking is the enemy to strong concrete.
Shaken building syndrome.
Not concrete but steel supporting column structure infill with concrete as per report
The building isn't coming down due to resonance oscillation, as such vibrations are common in supertall buildings, and can be managed (for occupant comfort) with solutions like a tuned mass dampening system (we have buildings in NYC, such as the 436m 111w 57th street and the 425m 432 Park Avenue, that due to their supertall status combined with extremely narrow footprint, require tuned mass dampeners for occupant comfort; you can watch 432 Park's dampener in action on the 99th floor at ruclips.net/video/QJXThNHexJc/видео.html ).
Every integrative structure (especially those that are Khan style tube-structure skyscrapers) has a primary natural frequency that, under the right circumstances, will resonate (vibrate) which can then setup secondary oscillations through other parts of the structure. During design and construction, these types of issues are factored in and addressed through structural tweaks, mass dampening, stiffeners, and other solutions, so that the finished building doesn't exhibit significant unsettling vibrations (keep in mind, these building are designed to move and flex in significant fashion - and modern all-concrete supertall structures, such as 432 park, are no exception).
The reason this building is in potentially serious trouble is that the sudden appearance of these oscillations, after 20 years, is indicative of a significant structural state change. IMHO, this is a warning sign that energy management and load dispersal mechanics of the building have very abruptly shifted, and my guess would be that the foundation is the culprit. The building materials, going in, look like they are setting up framing to do reinforcing concrete pours for the substructure, which would further indicate that the foundation is suffering from some sort of structural deficiency. Just based on this video, a lot of irregularities seem to exist in how this building was built, so the engineers are going to have to account for a lot of variables that could prove difficult to verifiably quantify.
The biggest problem is that, if these are foundational issues, they are particularly tricky to remediate, primarily because the failure mode can be easily misdiagnosed. Factor in that this building was a vanity project for the CCP, the potential pressure to just implement some fix that addresses the symptom (the oscillations) and not the core issue (that something has changed to allowing excitation of noticeable oscillations) and you have a real potential for a future disaster.
@@smakfu1375 Vortex shedding
I don't know. They said that about the three gorges dam for a very long time and it's still there. However, smakfu's comment seemed to make a lot of sense.
due to wind + subway
tokyo buildings: am i a joke to you?
Yes....😤😤😤
Bay Area Buildings : am i a joke to you?
@@herbertant4096 Those are the toughest buildings I know, other than the ones in Dubai
Japan has great technology
Just the wind and wrong shape of the building, the building looks like a plain pipe and this is bad shape for tall building.
The good solution to that is visible in 6:42, that twist is changing interaction with wind and twisting shape you can often see welded on surface of tall steel pipes to prevent this type of interaction with wind.
If the building will not cooperate, arrest it!
It’ll get charged with resisting arrest, but they still need to figure out how to get it into custody.
They are always arresting anyone they donot like including buildings.hahahah
And after a show trial they can shoot it in the elevator shaft.
I think they will Demo it before it collapses
That's not going to happen, but it might disappear in the middle of the night
The shaking is part of the original building design plan. It is designed to prevent people from falling asleep during the work hours. The study showed that the shaking is within the design limits. Nothing to worry.
FunnyAF
Sound logical !
People are having wild sex inside the building that caused the building to shake
Good one’s
Sarcasm alert! Sarcasm alert! Sarcasm alert! 🤣
Are they freaking kidding? I had lived in a way taller building for more than 7 years, and it never shook whatsoever even with very strong wind. Even when there was a typhoon in my city, it never shook at all. In Korea
There’s gonna be a duct-tape shortage very shortly.
Too expensive. The government ain’t gonna be using that to save people. Scotch tape at most.
wheres red green signal at lmfao
time to buy duct tape stocks and hold
😀😁🤣🤣😃
lol
it'll be fine, as soon as we shore things up with this truckload of bamboo we tried sneaking in
Lol! I saw that. Didn't look like it would help much. Hopefully they can figure something out. Nobody wins if that thing collapses.
😂😂
I heard the shaking is caused by a woodpecker.
@@marylandgirl9246 lll9
@@marylandgirl9246 you're wrong there. The bamboo cartel wins.
Especially with the Florida condo tragedy lately, this story terrifies me.
Bigger buildings fall regularly in China. They don't care. Blackout the media and clear the rubble the real estate market must expand at all costs
@@Fallen7Pie Rebuilding then makes more money for the corrupt officials.
There is a reason I don't and won't ever live in a Skyscraper:
Gravity.
And height.......How high do the rescue ladders reach?
If you are offered free stay 2D1N in a skyscraper luxurious hotel your fear will disappear instantly.
@@acheable Nope, fuck skyscrapers. I like my feet firmly on the ground.
And money
@@acheable don't care I'm not going into those buildings. What if there's a fire and the elevator is fucked stairs too
“How much rebar is in that building?”
China; “what’s rebar?”
China: We have 4 bars on Huawei.
No rebar. Just tofu.
bamboo is cheaper.
😂😂😂👊
There's plenty of rebar in that building. Unfortunately it's all made of chinesium pot metal. 😂
I've heard that it's more difficult to insert the rebar after the building has been constructed.
I recall reading about an apartment block in the Soviet Union. Shortly after completion the building started to sag so the built what was basically a steel support system on the outside with beams running through the building. Of course, being the USSR they didnt bother about just where they ran the beams through the building so some residents had to climb over, or under, beams that ran through the middle of their living spaces. maybe they could try something similar here...
If they cannot stop the shaking it will be dangerous because the constant shaking will fatgue the structure and it will eventually break and give way.
right
People will refuse to go into the stupid, piece of crap building.
Sounds like it's ready to collapse much like a mountain rumbles before a landslide
Bingo!☝️
This is giving me Sampoong Dept. Store vibes.
Same
Damn. Yes.
And now Florida surfside vibes
I lived in China for 20 years, my condo was across the street from one of these multi building projects. The last two pits dug for foundations was below the waterline in that are because it was within 30 meters of a river. The pit flooded and after months of pumping there was no drop in the water level so the contractor filled the pit with sand till the level of the water was reached. then he poured a lightly reinforced slab about 1 meter thick (NO pilings) and built the 32 floor building on top of the slab. there was no compaction of the fill.
Sounds about right.
Man that's crazy... Without piles in that slab it will eventually crack and the whole building will shift if the water levels push up again.
Do you believe what this joker said? Bullsh t. If true the building would have collapsed long ago. How on earth a building can rest on such flimsy foundation.
@@cfyong1105
Well, they did do this in Shanghai, and while digging a hole for an underground carpark the foundations of a residential tower next to the hole sagged and the building fell over. This was next to the Pudong River, yet the foundations consisted of tiny concrete piles and a thin concrete baseplate about two stories underground.
@@cfyong1105 I believe him. It took decades for the Leaning Tower of Pisa to start leaning.
Speshul Experts: "Structurally sound, shaking not related to physics but paranormal ghost activity."
you never kno
Starcraft 2 reference
Haunted building
Optical illusion.
Outside interference
When people say everything is fine…Run
Mostly the communist china!!
In my humble opinion, the bamboo piles that they installed underneath the foundation has reached its life span and starts to decay.
Interesting.
Plot twist
NOT
😂😂
Well you're either a trump cheerleader or someone with a sense of humour, can't be both I'm afraid
Rapid, unplanned disassembly is lurking on the horizon.
Is this spacex reference?
Gonna go wtc real soon
Wen drop?
Gravity sucks . .. buildings to the ground
Given the fact that this is in China, I wouldn't believe any reassurance that they may give regarding the building's safety.
What?! Are you saying that relaxed construction, business and relaxed government oversight regulations are not good?
Italy: Leaning Tower
China: Watch this
🤣🤣🤣🤣
Best comment yet. But it should be China: hold my beer.....
Good one
Darn funny, thank you
I can't believe people actually went back inside the building after the first day of shaking. And then again after the second day. I wouldn't get within two blocks of the thing.
Guess where they would end up if they refused?
So you think you have the right to choose in China?
Chinese concrete...what could go wrong?
@@LRRPFco52 they use dead workers to keep it tight and steady 😂.
It's over 300m tall I would leave the city tbh lol
In light of the recent collapse of the condo in Florida I wonder what tenants in the building are thinking now!!
They might not even know what happened in Florida thanks to the firewall
This video will be in everyone recommend after that building collapse. Maybe in few years
Yes lol
I need that shit to go down now I hate China
I think a few years maybe a bit too optimistic...
That’s what happens when you build a sky scraper in 2 weeks….
And use the cheapest things you can so you can keep more money for yourself. Saw a video of concrete being only surfaces level deep, under it was papir and sawdust.... frightening.
@@-JustHuman- tofu buildings.
wait till they make Mars spaceship for human in 2 weeks.
@OPEN DEFECATION .......... you're Chinese.... aren't you....?
@@gbot9000 Well he is lieing and trying to blame others for his own countries failiurs, so yes he checks all the bokses for being a CCP person. I wouldn't call him Chinese as he properly isn't from the real China aka Taiwain.
Getting it done in record time by trimming a few corners here and there, what could go wrong.
Also, down below.... "Rebar, what's that?".... priceless!
Modular design of tall buildings reduces human errors or shortfalls in components installation. Components such as Steel bars/cages, steel frames are prefabricated and even concrete batching are done computer aided in the plant/ factory and later assemble on site. Comments of shoddy wormanships, trimming corners etc are irrelevant nowadays. Hope you are enlightened to the rapid advance in building technology.
They literally cut corners, now the building is in the process of collapse.
@@gorillaump5869 dont worry high rise towers like this one found with all "corners" intact. Experts already discovered the cause. Similarly 1 million high rise buildings in Miami have to undergo structural checks after the condo beach collapsed.
OMG their multi award winning building is like this... Imagine the standard of non-award winning buildings.
Those who didn't buy the reward are confident on their build.
High rise building in the greater bay area is 2nd to none. I take it you have never left the west
It's a last century building. Sour grape!
@@aliceweide6539 completely different topic, but. I like sour grapes doe.
All chinese buildings are award winning. Just everyone covering each other's backs to hide the corruption.
Not Enough Chop Sticks in The Concrete
Wow, the Chinese officials being shady with the truth. Nah you must be mistaken 🤣
"Combined effects of wind, subway and temperature differences" of that day. The building then shakes twice more. It is a cover up of shoddy construction.
Both
Tofu building.
@@patriciadunmore9767 There are no tofu buildings in Ba Sing se.
@@patriciadunmore9767 tofu scrapes*
I believe that because it's the only building in the world that gets wind blown on it, and changing temperatures. Also, subways have caused thousands of high rise buildings to fall over. Oh wait....
No one:
China: The wind is why the water is jumping out of the pool.
It's not shaking, it's bouncing.
No shit Sherlock
Those who bought appartment there, got scammed for sure.
Everywhere in China is a running scam. It's all a house of cards. There is a saying in Mandarin, "if you can cheat and get away with it, cheat".
@@FirstLastOne even the actual chinese people know that they call most modern CCP construction "tofu scrap construction"
Wow, that was some serious shaking going on. Good thing to know that ”everything is normal” and they have the first prize in excellence in engineering!
This building is going to collapse in spectacular fashion.
the 3 Gorges dam was also built by "glorious people's gooberment" of China. THAT'S gonna be a show when it fails.
@@diogeneskoolaid8437 The 3 Gorges dam has collapse every year for the past decades if you listen to the china bashers. If you care to search here in youtube, there were perhaps hundreds of videos last year saying the dam moved and became crooked and was soon to collapse. The latest video saying it failed just came out 14 hours ago saying it was turned off due to cracks, lol.
CCP Lie People Die
We managed to control the virus and we'll control everything! Sorry to disappoint you😎
@@aliceweide6539 Control a virus? When? 2020? Nothing was controlled arrogant one! Oh well you'll learn as you age, you control NOTHING!
Relax people. This is just Shenzhen trying to build iconic structure like "Leaning tower of Pisa". From now on, this will be called "Shaking skyscraper of Shenzen" and it will bring in millions of tourists every year.
thank goodness they are going in there with those wooden sticks. everything should be fine now
Bamboo sticks, so strong it’s used for scaffolding
@@tsunamis82 Not good for stabilizing a sky scraper though especially since they're flexible.
@@tihspidtherekciltilc5469 perhaps they are using them as internal scaffolding and will stabilise with something else. I think they should pull it down and start again.
😆
It ticks the environmental green box too, well done China for keeping true to your climate change agenda and population control.
I'm happy here in The Netherlands we build things to last. Not to set speed or height records.
Same thing in India. We believe in quality than quantity.
It's like that in most 1st world counties. This is just a China thing.
Sorry to break it to you @Francis. these days newly built is prefab and crap. It's too expensive to keep building the way we used to. We've been cutting so many corners, theres hardly any similarities to older built houses.
Groetjes aannemer in Nederland.
@@anujpriyambaruah5975 hahaha really
Lol so Dubai is bad? Ok gotchu
Reminds me of when of the US skyscrapers was built they forgot to take into account wind gust at certain angles so they installed a counterweight on the top floor to absorb that. But I doubt China would admit to any fault in construction, so good luck trying to fix a problem when they can’t figure out what they did wrong.
US engineers wont forget. The design criteras incl wind impact for skyscrappers. Old ones may not have robust TMDs. Certainly not the fault of skyscrappers constructors.
@@acheable RoC77 refers to the Citicorp Center in particular, which was at risk of toppling from quartering wind loads until the chevron braces were reinforced
@@mikegaskin5542 An old skyscraper built in 1977 when the design criteria for wind impact not fully assumed. Wherelse this 2K tower no excuse wind dynamic impact not factored in.
Good video. Next time someone lectures me about "Shenzhen speed", I'll send him/her the link to this video.
Like I said before it's only a matter of time before What will be known as The Great Earthquake in China
Yep that will likely be the CCP's claims when it falls to the ground
“Magnitude 7.3 earthquake
Affected countries: India, Myanmar (Burma), and China
113 miles from Haixi Mongol and Tibetan Autonomous Prefecture, Qinghai, China ·
May 21, 12:04 PM”
We’re Getting There...
Karma is long overdue.
@@glyph241 can't wait to see that headline on my phone screen
China certainly has the capable engineers, but will they be able or allowed to arrange for a secure collapse (of the NYC Twin Towers kind, but evacuated)?
That's just 3000 nervous Chinese people who are scared of the government.
really wouldnt suprise me if the building collapses and the ccp decide to punish the people who lived in it
7:04 imagine living next to a Chinese made nuclear power plant?
The Japanese invented the word 'tsunami' but built their recently exploded nuclear plant within yards of the ocean.
@@barrybarnes96 they need the water to cool it off but they built it on a fault line.
The foundation is crumbling under the weight. They still can't make concrete right.
That architect was so famous that in 10 years of construction I never heard of her.
in china, there's no architects, there's only scammers and cheats.
If a skyscraper falls in China, but no one is allowed to talk about it, did it really fall?
And then there’s Europe: skyscrapers, what’s that? We still live in well made houses from 300 years ago
That’s pretty coo. I wish we had 300 year old sky scrapers in US 🤣
living in a house made 300 years ago, is a priviledge, you make it sound like a negative....
and thank god we dont have them ugly huge skyscrapers that are just a eye sore, and the people living in normal houses dont get any sunlight anymore, and are just in the shade of such a big building, not to mention they cant see the sky anymore walking in the city serrounded by these big ugly buildings,
and lets not forget these are chinese made sky scrapers... when was the last time you bought anything made in china that lasted more than a few months?? , answer = never...
@@SDeww he's being sarcastic, saying that the 300-year-old houses work and have none of these problems
Europeans have more class for sure.
In 2008 we stayed in an Airbnb in Austria that was built in the 1200s.
Someone forgets cement needs water, fastest skyscraper to be built, fastest to come down?
Now we have something to watch until the Plum season rains hits the 3 gorges again.
IF three gorges is still there. Something is going on and they have blocked Google earth with a false image (or it straightened itself over night)
i personal think it has to do with the underground, the soil is saturated with water after all this rain, and this is a reason they banned building higher then 300meter, because this buildings are very heavy, some little mistake in the Base, and this is very difficult to solve especially afterwards, they used bad Quality steel, it rusts inside the cement, theoretically it should be isolated, btw, even at the Airport it was raining through the roof, everything leaking!! i'm sure they will have difficulties to fix it, the only way is to bring down the Weight
@@shadowcat3163 the livecam are blocked, and most of the time a Dam doesn't collapse within a few months, but it has already started, some big cracks on the side wall. Reinsurance companies could not visit all part's, "because of maintenance" working, i mean maintenance sounds not so good, but our "investigator" can't speak openly, i hope you understand that! should the Dam fail, they will only pay when they was able to monitoring all the prescribed parameters, otherwise they will pay only a certain % to the insurance companies! i can tell you, big cracks were spotted! watch closely in this video in min 7.12, they seems not big, but i can tell you they are immense, don't forget, the Dam is 180meters high , ca. 590feet
@@Ezekiel903 do you have a link to the video of the dam and cracks that you are talking about here?
@@barrybarnes96 yes, only this, it's from a former service technician, he lives in Cambodia, watch carefully min 7.11, this cracks are huge, the building is 180meter high!! ruclips.net/video/1oid3hp-7qA/видео.html
Tofu building.
Marshmallow.
That would be horrifying living in such a place 😯
You mean China, right? They regularly have buildings and bridges collapse but not usually of this size or renown.
That is the future of belt and road.
Cheap can think only negative
@@engrmunim hello Munim, do you know North Korea was a respectable country till they aligned with China. Do you know what is happening to uighur muslims ?
@Varun Chaudhary jealousy of species that shat by the roadside . Need vaccines 😂😂😂,?
@@romanodom6223 should of done it the Indian way if a project never ends it can’t collapse
Ahaha... so true
Who was on the top floor taking the video ofthe pool??😁😁😁
Don't know who, but I bet they needed to change their underwear.
every body chill.. china is known world wide for the quality of the products it produces
Lol 😂👍
Lol
Cut corners in planning to finish fast . Alter blueprints ongoing while building that are unapproved. Recipe for disaster. Maybe that's why the man made islands are sinking in the China sea.
And those manmade island aren’t theirs to claim 😂
Simultaneous design, revision, and construction: sounds like an Agile approach on a skyscraper build 😁
I wonder what the daily stand ups, sprint planning sessions, ans backlog refinement sessions were like... lol
🤣
If you look at virtually every major structural collapse, they all follow that very recipe. It’s a very common thread found on disaster shows.
Looks like another "Sparrow round up Revolution" to me..
lol
When rushing mistakes are make, corners are cut, shortcuts are used etc etc. In other words, its coming down
Built in record time.
Razed in record time.
That's called Chinese standard.
Think of all the Chinese projects built around the world. All counting down.
MICKEY MOUSE CONSTRUCTION
The US infrastructure does not even rate a C when investigated by engineers
Probably way under budget as well.😂
Jean Xzy, The entire country’s infrastructure, like every single road, bridge, pipe, dam, levy, etc is C- and worse?
Or is it an agregate of all the roads, bridges, pipes, dams, levys, etc score? I am very curious to know. Is that even bad when compared to global standards? Ive been around, seems to me roads are shit everywhere unless they’re freshly paved
@@dizimz Aggregate score. Lots of old dilapidated shit. I mean have you seen their subway. Holy shit! Should be a health hazard, especially NY subway. 🤢🤢
I still remember seeng a german report on how they built a hospital in only 3 days. Their speed is incredible, yes, but there is the cost for it.
Was this report during the beginning of the Corona virus?
If so, the "hospital" you mentioned was simply a glorified tent. It had fabric walls and ceilings with many rooms built in, powered by multiple generators.
The “hospital” was a quarantine shanty town to jail the sick. Sanitation conditions on the floor of a public toilet in Germany’s red light district in 1990 would be like a 4 seasons compared to those “hospitals”
@@AG-en5y 😂
@@pauliewalnuts240 yes and the first time it rained, it leaked like a sieve. :)
It was a containerhospital
“I was writing that for a college thesis, so never mind my work”.
China, still to this day, has no regard for anything a woman declares, even though many intelligent and talented women work in architecture/engineering.
@@passinthru4788 let's hope she doesn't disappear
"everything is normal"
- ok, so seg plaza is gonna fall down soon.
Was thinking same
I’d be moving out , FAST !
This is another example of ‘Tofu construction’ and will likely collapse.
Don't just move out.....run away fast!
It’s easier Said then Done…. For some, it’s their only home.
When???
Would rather sleep 💤 on the street, would be safer.
@@jacquelinestewart3820 Wait . . . wait ✋
Wait for it . . . Wa-a-a-a-i-i-t
Wa-a-a-a-i-i-t . . . is the world getting higher or is the building getting shorter? 😏
"Everything is normal, everything is fine".... Famous Last Words
I would not want to be in a neighboring building within a ten block radius of that building.
Better make than 100 blocks, glass really flies far in a building collapse.
*I would NEVER want to enter any building or cross any bridge that was built by the CCP. **#TofuBuilding*
You better not want to go to China actually...
Unless you wanna be abused, monitored and disappear...
Did you see that guy stuck halfway across a glass paneled bridge where the panels were falling out around him because of a little wind? Terrifying heights.
@@diegotr1903 typical trumper
officials reported that the building shook simply because it overheard music playing in the elevator and the building has such good rhythm that it felt compelled to shake and wiggle.
Salty sea sand used in the concrete foundation construction.
Or foundation soil displacement due to water level or poor quality of material
My 1st. home built in 1929 had used beach sand. I had to replace some of it, it was crumbling.
Just 40 years ago Shenzhen was a fishing village
Look on the tag if it says made in China than this is normal, I always have problems with China products
engineer: why is the bulding shaking?!
man: its made in china.
engineer: ah that explains it.
go read today news miami condo collapse. made in usa.
@@spaideman7850 yeah, but it's like the same scenario i think, the news say that the building in Miami was being checked and they said that there was not any problem
@@salvadorhenriquez4091 in 2018 they found and reported the miami condo problem to the owner but nothing was done. corrupt.
Nah, shake like that once and I’m outta there.
Also: ah yes, Chinese buildings
I wonder if they used saltwater at any point when mixing the concrete? Most places won’t use saltwater as the sodium causes the concrete to absorb too much moisture and it becomes weak and crumbly. But if pressed for time?
Very interesting take. That was a major problem at the Fortress of Louisbourg in Canada, if anyone wants an old-timey case study.
Sir, It sounds like this is the case here due to time frame in building this structure.
Salty sand is more likely than salt water.
@@danblumel yes, there was a case in my area where a construction company run by someone my dad knew rinsed their sand with salt water pumped straight from the sea instead of fresh water to save money. Said sand was then used in concrete by another company that purchased the sand without knowing it had salt in it. Even though fresh water was used in the concrete, the salt in the sand weakened the concrete and led to the collapse of a warehouse. for anyone curious, it was in mindelo portugal
If they want public confident, ask the whole government authority said it's safe to move into the building. 😂
" the WIND...the SUBWAY...and DAY & NIGHT TEMPERATURE DIFFERENCES ".......they must have learned to fashion their SPIN after the us media's style of reporting.............
Well it wouldn't be the first time that the wind has caused a collapse. Dealing with wind is a very real issue for tall buildings.
So the wind there has only blown for these 3 days?????????
Of course not China Fox....part of the spin.
oh god shut up. that country is controlled by the government completely top to bottom. they are spin. their existence relies upon the people accepting them as legitimate so everything is made sure to convey the proper message. they had to take politics into consideration on construction of this building ffs.
Yes blake...the SAME spin as the former usa uses when anything happens or a particular narrative is needed,
Made in China!
I know the name of the engineer who designed this building his name is"SUM-THUG-WONG" LMAO
I heard his name was sumcunt?
That reminds me of the news clip i saw on youtube about 4 pilots and the names they had used.
Ohhhh....the sight of WOODEN POLES is definitely REASSURING..................................
Hahaha yeah 🤣
pretty sure it's gonna decrease the swaying movement +/- 4 degrees horizontally from the 35th-floor upwards. ✌😁
probably for making scaffolding.
I’m guessing the piles have been compromised and they will end up drilling thru bottom mat and end up pumping tons of concrete into the ground.
Piles? What piles?
@@andrewtaylor940 figured the building was sitting on dirt not bed rock. Pictures of its foundation already had mat laid down. So figured in order to stabilize the building they needed lots of piles into the dirt possibly down to bed rock.
@@watomb I’m not saying the building didn’t need piles. I’m just questioning whether it actually has them? And if it has them, whether they actually contain rebar? The building is swaying, with no wind and no measurable seismic activity. It’s floating on it’s foundation. And if that’s the case, I can’t imagine how they would go about fixing it?
@@andrewtaylor940 ya was thinking if the mat is thick enough they could bolt it to bed rock(thousands). But if it’s floating or has piles (I assumed) then pumping concrete under the foundation might help. If you calculate.001 inch movement is over a foot at top. Someone screwed up
@@watomb how much movement would you need to get the water in the top floor swimming pool cresting 1-2 meters above the pools sides?
Interesting that this issue shows up only after 20 years. You'd expect such issues to crop up much earlier. Why is it shaking just now?
Because China can’t build shit.
because china builds fast but dosent give a crap about quality like every communist goverment in history unless its rulers palace like in romania then its built ROCK SOLID
Same question came to my mind. Also, why does it stop shaking, what changes?
Sounds like the building was designed bass ackwards constantly retro-fitting earlier mistakes.
The only thing holding up that building now is rebar. Unless you have a death wish, stay the hell away from that jenga tower.
Gonna be tricky considering that the government built all these Jenna buildings
And there is fake rebar in those concrete columns aswell
@@Tharsis879 Excellent point! We have seen this with the Chinese-made structural steel that was used in the Oakland/San Francisco bay bridge that is corroding and cracking with Hydrogen embrittlement.
@@videomaniac108 just wait until the 3 Gorges Dam fails.
and bamboo, apparently
0:12 That's a 5 star wave pool. Jealous!
Faulty Tower😉
BASIL!!!
The unspoken building life in modern China usually about 25 to 30 years. With this in mind, the best practices and higher costs are avoided in building projects Since projects can be replaced in the future.
I find your life span overly optimistic.
Speed is never always good... not when we're talking about Infrastructures...this tall 😩
i 100% garantee they didnt do proper ground survey work to determine if the foundation was suitable, and if they did some corrupt official probably pushed it through. If i was an investigator id be asking where the people involved are right now, cause if they fled the country it's obvious what's up
True! I think if i were an investigator, I'd throwin the towel. Nothing to investigate... we all know what and why
Most people know what Shenzhen is built on top off and it is really not a good place to build high skyscrapers
In other words everything was properly done, inspected and approved in according to Chinese requirements which are all written in pencil.
That building is going to collapse. The foundation is failing. Someone should get a theodolite set up and look for signs of lean.
An iconic CCP building?
Huge face involved?
Party response: “Nothing to see here.”
That’s terrifying. Best wishes for anyone near that.
It's a Chinese JENGA game
A terrorist plane from "Taiwan" is going to crash there, and China will invade Taiwan looking for weapons or mass destruction.
So is the wave pool on the top floor a feature 🤣.
It is now.
It's too top heavy first thing is take out that pool. It's waves cause it to sway back and forth! To much weight on top will cause it to sway back and forth like that!
Well done, CCP. Should be C+P ... Copy + Paste.
It wasn’t built to last. My refrigerator or that building. lol