Daria Navalnaya: What It's Like To Be a Teenager in Putin's Russia | NYT Opinion
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 июн 2019
- Teenagers who have grown up in Russia have known only one leader in their lifetimes: Vladimir Putin. In the video Op-Ed above, Daria Navalnaya, host of an influential RUclips channel and daughter of the opposition leader Aleksei A. Navalny, interviews a cross-section of young Russians about how they feel about Mr. Putin, politics and their country’s future. Her interviews reveal a generation frustrated with the status quo, pessimistic about the possibility of change, and torn between their dreams for the future and their deep sense of patriotism.
Subscribe: bit.ly/U8Ys7n
More from The New York Times Video: nytimes.com/video
----------
Whether it's reporting on conflicts abroad and political divisions at home, or covering the latest style trends and scientific developments, New York Times video journalists provide a revealing and unforgettable view of the world. It's all the news that's fit to watch.
What Russia is like for teens? Ask top Russian oppositions daughter...
for real, lol
Hahaha, I hope she does not get Novyshock to her face... or her dad...but yet, the NYT is shameless.
M. Talk who?
@M. Talk prove it 😂😂😂😆😂😆😂😆
that's not what they did, they asked everyone else...
18 year olds in Russia are like 35 years old
пиздиш
That's depressing.
Hard life forces you to grow up fast.
Seán O'Brien
As smart as 30 year old American you mean? It’s indeed the truth, Russian education is one of the best in a world. When Russian people immigrate their kids advanced by few years in a school and they go 1 or 2 years ahead.
Yeah, in the US right now people think that if a man puts on a dress he becomes a woman and should be able to compete in competitive female sports.
If you couldn't get some other teenager then daughter of leader of opposition to represent "typical" teenager of 130 million state, then this opposition is really weak.
Bruh they literally interviewed all sorts of teenagers with different views... what's your point.
Exactly.
150 million
Navalny is a Criminal not a leader of the opposition. H is a traitor of his motherland. He is paid by the rotten USA. Countess Ursula Widawska
Another ckemlebot
You do not have to love your government to love your country and that goes for any country. You can't follow someone aimlessly without thinking of yourself and others first as it will only end in more pain and suffering.
Lies again? Disgrace America
@@NazriB You're so lost it's sad. Stop with the America garbage for it's outdated and people are tired of hearing the complaints and blame of America or anyone else allied with them. GET OVER YOURSELF AND GROW UP ALREADY!!!!
I agree with you. But Russian propaganda thinks differently and older people are charged with the idea that critiquing your own country is non-patriotic and even traitorous, which is very infuriating.
Especially a politician. Politicians are scum.
You know your country is in trouble when the president has a youth group.
Putin doesn't personally own any youth groups...There are many youth groups around the country some are nationalist some are communist some are military oriented some are more political and leadership oriented...
Like US boy/girl scouts?
@@username6135 Yep there are many variations and not one is named after Putin...
boy scout run by the president?
@@professorm4171 nope there are Youth Groups that belong to Political Parties but they are not funded by the goverment...There is no youth group in Russia currently that spacificly involved the president...There are a few Politicly minded pro putin youth groups and they enjoy some support but they are at most just funded by Putin's political party...
a 17 yr old oppositions leader's daughter asks a polling company to find out... Where did the money come from?
CIA anti Russia agents
It is obvious, of course from her father( the leader of our opposition)
how much will it cost to pick random teenager and hire session of interview shooting = about avarage american daily income
Lol now your supreme leader putin is exposed. Navalny for PM.
Why doesn't New York Times do the same about Trump? Are there no more problems in America for Americans to mind Russian business?
16 JJ It’s the same thing. It would be the continent if they added north before America. You rarely see people using America as NA not USA.
comrade M Be side Because New York Times also covers foreign new and has covered the opioid epidemic and other trump things.
These people look healthier and happier and look like they have better lives than their US counterparts..
Who go to University then leave having to pay off their Uni debts for life and end up working three jobs in the gig economy or become prostitutes, drug pushers and hooked on Oxycodone...
NYTimes look in your own back yard before critiquing the Russians and Putin.
@@ashton6478 silly trump fan alert
The host sounds really like a paid actor
Her father is the biggest Anti-Putinist in Russia and is well known there.
Exactly 💯
@@TimTDM and now putin is scared of her father.
@@carl4243 putin is scared of nobody what are you on about.
How very objective of the New York Times. The interviewer is literally the daughter of the opposition leader
It does say that in the description and in the beginning of the video
Based on the drama from the Russia Collusion saga, using that logic, this would imply NYT and by extension, the US was meddling in Russian politics.
She interviewed people with a RANGE of views!
HAHAHAHA wait really? The racist one that is now the liberal friend of American media?
I'm surprised that they even put people on who straight-up admitted they want to stay in Russia though. I would say a lot of teenagers in Russia see the problems with their country but they also deeply love it and most do not want to leave. I would've preferred a more neutral interviewer without such emotional reactions though who gave less personal input. I'd rather the media I consume not try to appeal to my pathos. Let the interviewees speak for themselves. But it is true that Russia does have a lot of issues with poverty and corruption. If you deny this fact you're delusional. Most capital in the country is controlled by a minority (the oligarchs) and most funding goes to Moscow and St. Petersburg while the rest of country is left to live in dirt.
*What It's Like To Be a Teenager in Putin's Russia.... virtually no mass school shootings*
So,we actually have,1 was in 2018 50 injured 20 murdered
but our special forces nice working,and thats rarely happen
idk...What would u like - school shootings, or 20% of population below poverty line+thief and murderer for president? I mean, it is somehow hard to answer that.
@Gleb B. / Глеб Б. , @Эдвард Одинцов: You're indeed right. It was already late when I wrote this - i must have misread his answer, and therefore misinterpreted it. You're indeed right, what I wrote was stupid. So I deleted it. And I apologzie for having written that crap. Indeed, the choice between school shootings, and 20%&thief&murderer is comparable in misery-level. Nobody should have to live under either circumstance. Yes, the USA is not perfect. But that doesn't make Russia any better either. I'm just sorry for anybody who has to live in either of such country. And glad I don't live in any of them - althought Switzerland is not perfect either ;) I just wish that one day, Russia will find its way to the table of nations with a civilized government - preferably together with the USA.
@@webformssuck that is my hope for the future of our countries as well 🥰
You don't even have the right to boycott a foreign nation (Israel) and you are here talk about Russia????
Come on.... Why don't you look at your own backyard????
This was so short seems like you cut out a lot of things which didn't fit your narrative
yeah add those who speak against Putin
@@aliatiq6273 Later they will be kidnapped
I remember this vedio i saw this 3 months ago i thought this of a regular opposition vedio but your dad is a super man clearly one brave Bear his service to his country are deserveing of highest honor
you guys are blessed to have him.
ap
Also, the Russians and us (the U.S.) have a lot in common. We’re disappointed with our government, see massive problems but at the end of the day we still love our country (at least I do).
If we love the US, than maybe it's already time to fight for a better US. Change won't come without us acting.
Why does she speak English so well? Is she living in America and not in Russia?
she studies in standford
She lives in Coomifornia. Better stay there.
@@pajeetsingh California is a crap hole
Teens who raised in Germany are knowing one one leader since 14 years mama Angela Merkel
But... Democratic elections have kept her in....people have. A choice,they chose her since 2005.
@@GlaringDiamon now they don't anymore.
@@GlaringDiamon Democratic elections kept Putin in as well. Even the morons at the NYT admit this in the video above.
These people look healthier and happier and look like they have better lives than their US counterparts..
Who go to University then leave having to pay off their Uni debts for life and end up working three jobs in the gig economy or become prostitutes, drug pushers and hooked on Oxycodone...
NYTimes look in your own back yard before critiquing the Russians and Putin.
@@maximkostenko9933 Incorrect.
This video was too short, empty and left me waiting for more, not the content I was expecting...
ña na right?!??? Like just play the whole interviews
@@ipodtouchfreak100 why would they do that? it's so much easier to sway context of the conversation if you just cut pieces out as you find fit. It's propaganda...
Care
On her RUclips channel, all videos available in full length. Each video about 15 minutes length.
@@amnest1ac Full videos on her (Dasha's) RUclips channel.
An opposition's daughter? Like really?🤦♂️
as an outsider just watch russia from the news and youtube, i would say the lives of ppl there are definitely improved economic wise at least. i am living in Bali in tourism industry. in the 00's we have lots of russian tourist but mostly comes from rich community,we can see it from the hotel they stay at and their spending habit...but now in the 10's we have a lot more russian tourists that looks like comes from various social and economic class, from ppl who doesnt even care about the money they spent to the ppl who count in detail how much they spent and think a $4 double homemade cheese burger is very expensive. i don't think they can afford to travel abroad in old russian economy. now at least they can afford traveling to a far away country. for me that definitely shows that their economy is improving alot. their ppl now have more money that they can burn for a vacation abroad. and the fact that these kids can talk like this on a public internet to an american news media and still alive is definitely an improvement ...just saying
i wish i could visit Bali ... now when all borders are closed... i am very sad because of pandamia. How is your weather now? how the tourist season begins in the new year 2021?
@@user-um1tj5nm1g tourism here has not change in the holidays, its very crowded but the weather has been nice. i dont recommend going here currently as Indonesia has a high case.
Уровень жизни населения в России рос только в период с 1999 по 2008 год. Происходило это благодаря дефолту, который российское правительство объявило в 1998 году. Российская экономика сильно пострадала от оттока инвестиций, но зато были обнулены долги. В период с 1991 по 1998 экономика России также только падала - советская экономика обвалилась из-за политики низких цен, типичной при социализме, производство товара стоило дороже доходов от его продажи, и в СССР это пытались компенсировать доходами от нефти и газа, но в 1981 году нефть обвалилась, а вместе с ней и экономика. Большинство советских элит противились рыночным реформам до последнего - когда в 1988 году начался уже катастрофический обвал. В 1991 году произошла революция, устроенная прогрессивными рыночными реформаторами под руководством Ельцина, но и реформаторы вскоре раскололись на 2 лагеря - депутатов совета России и сторонников Ельцина, поскольку Ельцин прекратил существование СССР Беловежскими соглашениями. В 1993 году пришлось пострелять из танка по депутатом совета России, поскольку они хотели устроить войну для объединения СССР, войну как в Югославии.
А рыночные реформы в России были проведены неправильно - центральный банк пытался спасти неконкурентоспособные и нерентабельные советские заводы, печатая для них деньги, что вызвало гиперинфляцию, а приватизация была проведена очень криво и в спешке, чтобы политически подавить коммунистов. В 1998 году был дефолт, и с 1999 начался бурный экономический рост. В 2008 произошёл Мировой финансовый кризис. К 2011 году Россия от него оправилась, но к тому моменту экономический рост сошёл на нет - в 2012 году начался застой экономики. В 2013 застой экономики превратился в страшное падение в результате топливного кризиса. А в 2014 Россия захватила Крым и начала вторжение в Украину, чем навлекла на себя ограничения. Но потом Россия сделала себе хуже, введя свои санкции в ответ на западные, запретив импортную продукцию на своей территории, что убило конкуренцию как количественную, так и качественную, ибо российский крупный бизнес представляет из себя несколько частных монополий, которые сотрудничают с коррумпированным государством. С тех пор в России экономика только падает, но что хуже, растёт социальное расслоение, и фактически с 2013 года средний россиянин стал беднее на 10%, а если брать не среднего россиянина, ведь всё таки социальное расслоение огромное, а медианного - там падение будет во все 20% доходов. В 2012 году номинальный ВВП России составлял 2.1 триллиона долларов, по ппс в американских ценах - 3.4 триллиона. В 2021 году номинальный ВВП России - 1.4 триллиона долларов, по ппс в ценах США - 3.6 триллиона. Т.е. в ценах США производство не упало за 9 лет, но фактически из-за роста социального расслоения основная масса россиян стала жить беднее. А на международной арене российская экономика потеряла позиции, и импортная продукция либо исчезла, либо подорожала, а Россия экономически уходит в изоляцию от Запада. Изоляция ни к чему хорошему страны Азии в 18-19 веках не привела.
Во время пандемии коронавируса правительство России совершенно не помогло частному бизнесу в своей стране, в результате чего в России сейчас инфляция и рост цен выше, чем в любой стране Мира. В США сейчас инфляция 6%, и там это считается апокалипсисом, а у нас в России инфляция 9%, при этом продуктовая - 20%. Цены на продукты по курсу валют уже выше, чем в Европе и США.
Что касаемо устройства российской экономики, то фактом является то, что в России коррумпированные полицейские прокуроры облагают частный бизнес незаконными поборами за "крышу", а за неуплату предприятие закрывают. Это лишает частный бизнес части доходов, притом что налоги для бизнеса в России высокие, учитывая развитость российской экономики. Да и закрытие предприятия не есть хорошо. Благодаря открытым границам ситуация ухудшается, потому что предприниматели просто уезжают из России. Закрытие предприятий и незаконные взятки и поборы приводят к падению конкуренции между производителями и излишней монополизации экономики, и как следствие ухудшению качества товаров. К тому же эта ситуация ещё и отпугивает инвесторов от российского рынка, потому что права бизнеса не защищены. Следующей проблемой российской экономики является действительно коррупция, которая унаследовалась от СССР вместе с правящими элитами. Несменяемость власти и отсутствие политической конкуренции привели к деградации советского правительства. А современную российскую политическую систему построили люди, которые были важными шишками ещё при СССР - Ельцин, Чубайс, Гайдар и Геращенко. И современная российская система это тоже однопартийная диктатура без конкуренции. Следующим фактором, который отпугивает инвесторов от российского рынка, является зависимость валюты от нефти и газа, что обусловлено скорее коррупцией в государстве и неэффективном использовании нефтедоходов. Как итог, с 2012 года, не без помощи внешних Мировых экономических тенденций, российская экономика в застое. А застой экономики только всё усугубляет инфляцией, в результате чего центральный банк России в последние годы ведёт политику вывода денег с рынка, что достигается высокими кредитными и ипотечными ставками - в России они составляют 15-20% годовых. Это опять же усугубляет ситуацию с инвестициями. А поскольку российская экономика это несколько частных монополий, которые сотрудничают с государством, либо вовсе государственные монополии, то они просто легко поднимают цены.
@@arty5876 отправляемся в изоляцию
I couldn't keep up....Everyone was rushin
Ha!
Rash B side
Ha
A-ha! Gottchu
Sounds like alot of kids in American..... not alot of hope for change.
It does sound a lot like America, but idk I feel like we are a little more hopeful from the sounds of it.. this video is also biased so idk
Alisha M You’re supporting an illegal revolution?
Give us a longer version. 5 minutes of content can't be representative of anything, one way or another. A longer version or nothing at all, this can do nothing but distort speech and arguments.
Biased content
All content like this has a bias.
Second generation traitor?
How is she an “average” Russia? Just listen to her accent. 🤣
The real Russians aren’t Muscovites or Saint Petersburg citizens...
SHRAVAN KUMAR ur just proving there point
It's jarring how different people from Moskow and a few other big cities live comparing to everyone else in Russia XD
@SHRAVAN KUMAR разговаривать с русским на английском языке? Гениально. Про "нет путина = нет россии", типичной аргумент путинистов. Точно так же можно сказать про абсолютно любую страну, якобы "нет этого "супер крутого" диктатора, нет страны, потому что мне так сказали".
@SHRAVAN KUMAR wait you're not even russian yet you're saying putin is a great president? w h y.
And also not incredibly rich as her LMAO
As a American I enjoy seeing how other countries are like, the media makes other countries seem so bad and America is so good
Guess the American media was right about Putin.....
@@yunged I mean its not American media.. its all medias that discuss how bad putin is lol.. literally all NATO countries that have decent media will report on how putin murders and jails opposition members.
exact same thing to how everycountry wants the nuclear weapon.
That country is steadily gaining in power and respect acrosss the board and this girl is talking about changing her home countries trajectory?? Something just seems off here.
Yes we must bring back the USSR
NYTimes pays daughter of Navalny...
....hmmmm🤔🤔🤔🤔
She is also attending Stanford university... Brainwashed and corrupted girl
@@879mely Any dissent is a brainwashed person in Kremlin bot's eye
or the other way round
There was a network movie about Germany in WWII where the lead character, played by Michael Moriarty, talks of joining the party for career opportunities but otherwise being apolitical. The longer I live the more I feel that nothing is really new.
Its a pretty low bar when all you can say is ''We eat. Its ok''
Yes, but for most of human history this was the ideal, the best the masses of people could hope for.
@@Yowzoe Yes I know, thats my point. This would be a laudable achievement in 1700, but expectations are higher in 2019.
@@JamesBu11 I hear ya.
@@JamesBu11 people now see their privileges as rights, whatever that means
If a political figure has their own “youth group” that’s a bit scary...
no its not, they have something similar in the United States, its to encourage and promote education and often they will offer scholarships and grants and education assistance and more if youths attend.
The sheer number of Russian bots in this comment section is hilarious.
Same as the us bots 🐻🇷🇺❤👍 Maiby because it 's about our country and President.Hm?
if nationalism and homophobia are the main problems in Russia, this is a great country. As far as I can see, US citizens, whether democrats or republicans are ultra-nationalists. So are british, italians, ukrainians to a pathological degree, etc... Then when a youngster is pushed to claim he wants less power for the president and that he would organize more democracy, will he actually achieve it with less power? Russians have a hard life, and complaints about corruption,healthcare, pensions, everyday difficulties come actually far before foreign policy, which unfortunately is a driving motivation of V. Putin. Some of his justified reforms (pensions) have led to a substantial drop of his popularity... the interviews miss many issues. There are far less screams in favour of wars in Russia than in NATO countries.
I dont think you know what nationalism is if you think all US citizens and especially Democrats are ultra nationalists.
Democrats are among the worst warmongers (initiated Vietrnam, Somalia,Libya,Serbia bombing,troops in Eastern Syria), and invented 'russian meddling while they meddled everywhere. Not that republicans are blameless ( Afghanistan,Irak). So, if they are not driven by nationalism,
Why did democrats do that?
Imagine soviet Pravda taking teen hippies opinion on how US should be governed
BTW, the NYT has pushed much more propagandistic lies than Pravda, and those lies were much more grave (including on Iraq, Lybia, Syria and, in the past, about Vietnam, etc)
Stranger Happened Was this account created a few days ago?
@@glebsokolov9959 Yours?
Right
60 thousand people in 80 cities protesting.... that are only 750 people per city. That is actually laughable.
This comment is for Daria/the person who posted this video!! I rarely, if ever comment on RUclips videos but this one was actually super informative! Especially with what's going on with Russia and Ukraine right now! And i love that you also speak english!! For obvious reasons...this video would have been alot harder to understand. And/or I feel like things easily get lost in translation all of the time! Awesome video/topic....you should definitely keep posting more videos! Thank you!
These guys don’t look like average Russians. They look a bit more well off.
They asked the daughter of Nawalny. Wow very objective..
"Putin is too long in government Its my dad's turn"
He was attacked by regime and he's democratic opposite to regime. Think what are you talking, brat. It's not normal fight, one fight for freedom and the other control whole country.
@@eevve9894 you still belive in that american told propaganda? time for you to learn facts. but hey you dont like facts. so you listen to america.
Nice Propaganda america
Good job
Oh, sorry, mustn't offend Putin or his minions.
The New York Times is a joke, and a bad one at that, and that’s coming from an American
New York Times is owned by Mexicans not the USA.
@Hi Qwerty look it up dude. Do you not know how?
"Propaganda" he says, as hundreds of pro Putin minions vote everything critical about Putin down.
I don’t blame you of course you have everything but just can’t appreciate it and find a way to make your country and yourself better in your own little way. If you want change step out of your comfort zone ( Russia) then you will understand change is not an easy thing these days. Putin is not your problem your problem is you are still too young to understand that your country is blessed. Unlike most countries destroyed with poverty, lack of light and crisis etc
Isaac Okechukwu thank you 🙏
As if russia isn't in poverty or crisis
Russia is the representation of poverty and misery - what has it been blessed with?
@Nenad Tomic Yes, as defined by the World Bank. Guess the state has made it so that its citizens can actually earn more than 1-2 euros hourly (which is overall good), but far from making the life of Russians materially alright. Across all regions the minimum wage's 140 (a raise they instituted last year) or thereabouts and in Moscow it's approximately 200, which is an absolute joke considering living prices - fortunately a big chunk of Russians earn above that, but still not hoghly. This in the same country with one of the highest number of billionaires mind you. Shows the economic inequality. From one Eastern European country to the other.
@Nenad Tomic Putin's reign has lasted 20 years and in the first decade there's an obvious explanation to his popularity - yes, indeed the economy was looking up, wages were rising fast and inflation became a thing of the past. Corruption has always been something that our Eastern European systems have grappled with and Putin didn't set a better example for himself or his administration. The economy has gone from stagnant to falling after the invasion of Crimea and the ruble has inflated to 1 dollar for 80 ruble, savings, jobs are lost etc. There's also not really a choice for the Russian people, society has turned sharply against Putin in the following years and started looking at him as the politician he is, not a deity or saint to save Russia. Unlike Serbia and Bulgaria (where I'm from, *not much better than Russia, but I didn't state so) there isn't mass emigration, but that's cause visa policies are strict for Russian citizens. Though I myself am not Russian, I had friends of Russian/Moldovan background move to Russia for strictly personal reasons (not economic, if you're Serbian/Bulgarian there's not a real economic incentive to move to Russia) and they've been having difficulties the last few years and job cuts cause the oil industry's been failing them.
Given that the NYT has its articles vetted and approved by the security services before publication it should exercise a little caution before throwing stones.
you should do one about sri lanka. where freedoms for teens are limited at most.
Who are they protesting against ? A man who assembled a broken nation ? A man who prevented further disintegrations in Russia ?
Many people of all countries even in most of the developed and richest countries are not satisfied with the govt of their nation...they think that foreign nations are good but actually this is not the case.....everyone has their own problems which we can't understand
There is many places better then russia for sure you uave no clue
@@danielstokker there are many places worse then russia as well. what are you even trying to say lol.
@@metalvideos1961 is Russia going to compare itself with poor Asian and Africa countries now?
Before I start I must say that I'm Chinese and currently live in Italy, all I can say is I saw there is huge economic growth during Putin's years of charge, and thanks to him that your country can enjoy more social and international political stability.
No countries are perfect, and there are always corruptions, it requires time to fix it. That doesn't mean we shall burry Putin with criticism :)
I recognize Russia's relative prosperity as well. These kids seem to want their Russia to be less oppressive socially and politically, but other than that, their complaints (in this brief, superficial video were few). I'm no Putin apologist, but he has taken the country from collapsed state to a stable one.
中国的逻辑一直好差🥴
PG nice prosperity, 20 million of Russian under poverty line. Yeah, prosperity’s
Maybe Russia's economy rose because of rising oil and gas prices, not because of Putin himself. How you don't understand, in the 90s, criminal gangs were in the street and and now those criminal gangs are in Kremlin, governing the whole country. Putin is not some strong leader, he is a mafia boss.
@@majesticfrag7697 if you compare it to before you would be shocked.
Once Putin is gone, these trolls would be jobless. So keep trolling!
I guess they want Russia to be just like it was before Putin
@@Cytoplasm4508 it is just that Russia is way better with Putin than what it was before he came to power. Before Vladimir Putin came to power Russia used to be controlled by America after the fall of the Soviet Union. And these kids they want to live the same life as American kids or as European kids. They talked about democracy but US America s European countries they go around the world taking advantage of other countries and they talk about these countries as if they were perfect. At the end they have all the right to express themselves. They are too young and all for them is about money showing off. If they want a different Russia they have to prepare themselves so one day they can do all those changes they want to benefit all Russians not only them like the actual government might be doing right now
@@Cytoplasm4508 the girl is typical sjw-opposition-"liberal" thing, which is mistakingly(or on purpose?)&sadly called "left wing" in western media. She and the likes of hers is an absolute nightmare for the real leftists.
@@Cytoplasm4508 Putin is a centrist same as the Democrats
The fact that she's daughter of most-known anti-establishment politician dont make her opinion proconcieved and distorted. She had been living in this system. She actually faced with the healthcare system, education system and another bureaucracy and she definetely know what it is. In addition, she represented very different positions for the same questions of teens she asked. Moreover people in comments misunderstand the difference between "being anti-putin politician" and "being anti-corruption politician". The second way is more correct because it shows that its not just a stupid war for authority and power , its a war for common sense and transparency in government exactly.
If you've ever been to Eastern Europe you know these kids are rich af
For sure. 99% of these kkds have salary less than 500$ monthly. And have to pay 30 years for 40square meter apartments. What a nice life and bright perspectives
Teenager : talking about politics
Putin : wanna drink tea ???
Only russian can understand this joke
loveyou I think it’s about when a news reporter who was about to die in the hospital said that he drank Putin’s tea and that’s why he is dying( so basically Putin poisoned him)
@loveyou dont bother its propaganda. literally a stupid propaganda joke that is neither funny not scenical.
17 years old?!You look way older than me despite the 1 year age gap
Januzai Ramli same with me
Riviere Marc LMAO what a pos comment.
@Riviere Marc sensitive little man
@Riviere Marc I'm 9ft tall and 300 pounds muscle. I've wrestled blue whales and elephants and I'm also a world class fighter
that's what being Russian is like
I am 24 years old. and I think, not all teenagers under 20 years old can be trusted. Age when still looking for identity. We haven't seen the world at large
Loool Moscow kids who’s never been hungry despise people who are content when there is a food on a table. Folks, a bit of insight in Russian culture. There’s saying in Russia that Moscow is its own country.
Excellent presentation. Thank you.
I was really interested to hear this, but it yielded very little content
Despite involving the daughter of the Russian opposition leader, this video is actually quite representative of what teens in Russia think about their government
I live in Russia and none of my classmates will ever say that they fully support Putin because of the rapid decline in the standards of living after his election in 2018 (it’s hard to ignore)
PLUS everyone realises how corrupt the system is, even if they claim to be ‘patriots’, especially the justice system where everything is decided by those who have money, so that nobody is surprised when rich people get away with murder
This just goes to show that kids know nothing about the world or politics and shouldn't be involved
There was Coronavirus in 2019...
I hope all these kids are gonna be ok- they all still live in Russia and they’re making anti government statements for viewers in the United States/ English speaking world.....
Christina Chavez sorry, but I will "take off my rose-colored glasses." Navalny is by no means an honest person who loves Russia, but a liar and a traitor to his homeland. He is happy to sell all of Russia to the West and the United States. If Putin has returned the former glory and power of Russia, then Navalny will destroy everything that Boris Yeltsin and Bill Clinton destroyed in the 90s. I sincerely wish you all good luck in life and I advise you to treat “Putin's Russia” well, because “Putin's Russia” can become a good ally or a formidable enemy
Yeah I didn’t say anything about her dad, I don’t know anything about him. I just hope these kids are ok.
Christina Chavez unfortunately, the daughter continues the work of his father. Russian oppositionists dream of selling Russia to the West, as Boris Yeltsin once did. But Vladimir Putin does not allow them to do this, for which they hate him and dream of a revolution in Russia and its overthrow. And Daria Navalny and Alexei Navalny only aggravate the situation in order to turn Russians and foreigners against Putin. And here's another fact about Daria. Her father often scolded Russian officials for sending their children to study abroad, and then he sent his daughter to Stanford. By the way, Alexei Navalny is unemployed, so it is not clear where he takes money from to learn from Daria
@Eliza Grogan yeah you so not brainwashed. Btw, what do you people expect by releasing these kind of video, as if it will affect putin.
@Eliza Grogan Yes, and every morning Putin drinks the fresh blood of babies)))
Those Russian Teenager are really more mature than most of teenager in my country
Can someone get in trouble for stating their opinion of the Government, assuming it is not favorable?
Well this is very true for many democracies around the world. I can relate it with my country. I feel DEMOCRACY CAN ONLY EXIST IN THEORY, AND IS OUTDATED..... It’s a failed experiment & can function well only if the majority of citizens are politically matured....... 👤
Incorrect translations that supports NYT's narrative? Also, I have seen similar incorrect translations in their other videos. Coincidence?
Don't think so...
*"She's the perfect person to ask!"*
~ No-one
Not gonna lie Putin shook his head when he saw this video
i grew up in USA, i am studying in USA,i spent my entire life in USA.,but i proudly represent Russia,,,hows that!!!!
I don't think a person that young with ignorance about foreign governing powers has enough insight to make such strong conclusions as this.
Lies, lies everywhere:
Don't worry, brother. You know they're lying, I know they're lying. There are seven and a half billion people like you and me on the planet, and there are only a handful of "highly responsible" journalists and politicians who preach hatred. They won't do anything to us. The main thing is not to become like them yourself.
This girl is simply interpreting what these guys are saying in her own way.
America Propaganda...
If you want to get on then you have to comply. Just like the EU and any other organisation.
How can she be neutral when her dad is/was leader of a opposition party?
or the video?
@bokeh18 Shame on Russia - Shame on Putin
Top 5 reasons for SHAME (links blow)
1. FSB involvement in the Moscow Apartment Bombings
2. The forced doping of the Great Russian Olympic Athletes
3. Panama Papers reveal Putin controls shell companies worth 200 billion dollars.
4. Putin ordered the bombing of civilian cities in Syria expressly to force migrants to fee into Europe.
5. Murder of opposition leaders, journalists, defectors, honest judges and police officers.
links to more information:
1. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russian_apartment_bombings#Explosives_in_Ryazan_controversy
2. Russian Olympic Doping en.wikipedia.org/wiki/McLaren_Report
3. Revealed: the $2bn offshore trail - Putin www.theguardian.com/news/2016/apr/03/panama-papers-money-hidden-offshore
4. Russia's Bombing of Aleppo www.opensocietyfoundations.org/voices/russia-s-bombing-aleppo-must-end
5. www.washingtonpost.com/news/worldviews/wp/2017/03/23/here-are-ten-critics-of-vladimir-putin-who-died-violently-or-in-suspicious-ways
Artemas Ward
Let me correct you
1. BS
2. BS
3. Not sure, either way don't care
4. BS
5. BS
For gullible westerners : wikipedia and washimgton post are bad sources to look for truth
Anastasia Hey Is RT a better source.
I'm watching this after the poison attack on Navalny and his subsequent arrest.
Well now you know the truth about Putin being a Satan.
@@glitchinggaming7581 and Navalny being an anti muslim? being a fascist? not even respecting his country's WW2 veterans? being a bigger nationalist than Putin?
@@glitchinggaming7581 its never been proven that russia is behind it. but ofc you believe the western lying american propaganda. so ofc you think russia is behind it. people like you are believing anything but facts.
@@sleepyguy6201 dont bother people like him dont like facts. all they hear is american propaganda and see it as facts.
Definitely the best person to answer. Not a propaganda piece or anything.
Some idiots seem to have a problem understanding that a young woman can be intelligent and express her own opinions.
Thank you for watching. This program was sponsored by the corrupt media moguls. Only the "edited out" segments were hurt during the making ...of whatever this is. 👍
For more than 70 years Russia suffred badly under the brutal totalitarian bolshevik regime.The average russian concept of democracy is an abstraction.The country was more or less destroyed save the military .Young russians should be proud of their rich vast country, work for it and make whatever they want of it.
According to official figures, 200,000 people leave Russia annually. I do not believe the official data, I know that every second person in Russia wants to move to Europe, the USA, Japan, even to China, anywhere ... we don’t want to live under a dictatorship, we are tired of the leftist views that have turned our country in the wasteland. If the revolution did not happen a hundred years ago, then who knows, maybe the United States would not be standing on top?
I loved the anwser from the first girl. When she first says the official Kremilin line but then almost bursts into laugh
How you study in Standfort?
Sorry im just thinking about how old Russian teens look like
1- why is she speaking to a foreign news channel about the domestic problems of her home country?
2- Why is NYT interested in this particular geography right now?
3- all world countries have corruption, including the U.S which has day light treason from most politicians by following foreign lobby groups policies.
4- let each country determine its own fate however they see fit. It's no one's problems.
5- this piece is similar to the war ravaged countries that were publicized before with "they have WMD's", "they need democracy", "he is a dictator"....
Most unclean!
@Feuertaufe corruption's tentacles exists in every country in the world. I am not naive. This is a domestic problem. Between the country and its populous. Yes I know what will happen to dissidents; History is filled with such. When enough people revolt for the reasons they see fit, change happens. Yes blood will run in the streets.
Yes, NYT reports a variety of eclectic topics. Though when foreign politics is among them, especially a country's dissidents and given the track history of American journalism with regards to spreading "democracy ", this smells of foul. The regime change industry.
@Feuertaufe good luck.
Lots of Russian troll bots in these comments
I don't think freedom and democracy were mentioned, there you go.
everyone in this interview was terrified i don't blame them
Of what?
@@dirkfolscher3001 Of a lynching "liberal" mob in case of them stepping out of line and saying something positive about Russia.
I wonder what she thinks now after the whole "Novichok Fiasco"
Another falling angel from heaven 😍
More NY Times propaganda eh ?
People are rooting for your futures. We look forward to seeing you as soon as possible. Don't give up! You guys can do it!
She is no longer live in Russia,so she can root it in America
lol the daughter of the opposition leader: biased; propoganda :D
She interviewed people who agreed with Putin! Are you deaf?
@@Musicienne-DAB1995 the video is titled: what's it like to be a teenager in putin's russia. And it's the daughter of the opposition leader asking questions. How can it not be biased?
@@bknite01 So what? She still gave the other viewpoint. Does Putin include the views of his critics during his interviews? No. He poisons them instead.
@@Musicienne-DAB1995 putin's badass. Hes the only person that can deal with the biggest bully this earth has seen which is USA
@@bknite01 Badass? He is an incompetent gangster who has impoverished a great country by stealing billions worth of national assets. I have my criticisms of America, but that country is in a far better position economically than Russia.
I propose to all admirers of mr. President who left comments here, to move permanently to live in province Russia. Not for teaching English (to easy and unfair money) but actually for doing the same type of work you do in your home countries. Then in a couple of years, please reread you comment here.
the kid at 2:30 reminded me of young Octavian responding to Ceaser in HBO's rome. haha
Let's ask Navalny's daughter for an unbiased report on life in Putin's Russia!
Oh, I'm sure they would if they were having a cheap dig at Putin.
A great thinker once said..." happiness is pretty hard to find within oneself.... but it cant be found sonewhere else."
People dont like their govt because their bored or achieve their wishful thinking. Lol thats normal for kids to be dissatisfied... so few kids are not dissatisfied of their own family... they wznt to go outside and to have fun and funded by your parents, right? But you will get mad because they wint give money to have a good time.
Dear Kids, same is true when your dissastisfied with govt hut what your asking for to be happy will have great price to pay since you dont know the monster you want to create, suggested by people (who may have an agenda or may not... just as ignorant you. But its has to common similarity to those who have and agenda, crying for the same thing) to to you that govt that the govt can do better. But sadly, but creating a govt working the right way? Takes centuries to accomplish with people who will do right thing! Do you have those people around? Are you sure you want to gamble tranquility for chaos just to have have fun and may your dreams come true!?
Sorry dear, what you wish for isnt fun.... you really think people go are having fun? The reason they come home because life is for more boring there than where they are. You just feel envious people look so happy in the pictures. Why you think they seem happy? It isnt because they been ask to smile for camera or people just simply pretend deliriously happy on camera?
Not going hungry or working like a slave? Is the best place you want be.... just be patient and try new things like having group gardening for herbs and spices and a place to hangout every weekend and doing group research on how to be good at it and perhaps build something for livestock.
Great things comes from very simple things, only fools rush in for their big dreams with bigger monster waiting for you to show up!...
Anywsy, posting pictures of you and your buddies having a picnic in your herb garden is far more inspiring than those whi are traveling around the world learning nothing. Its an emoty and depressing world where everyone hardly know anybody. You will be stuck in a room and nowhere to go or go out with friends. Is that the life you want dear hmm?
The only reason why people people are bored? Because most everyone are as dumb as clueless as you. Travelling around world and none has found any happiness... just bewilderment for being in a new place and gets ver old very fast.
*PuTin's YoUth GRoUp*
Never thought l'd hear those words lol
A few years ago, I was in a Russian gaming alliance. One particularly outspoken young lady vanished for close to a year. She wouldn't talk about where she was. 🍓
The mood of the conversation was that she had been arrested. She was a very outspoken critic of Putin.
The Russians want a national uprising and do not want Western democracy
Only people who has never lived abroad not as a tourist thinks there is a better life.
Речь идёт на о каком-то удивительном райском мире, а о чуть большей заботе государства, чуть большей ( ВВП по ппс ) зарплате, чуть меньшему количеству коррупции, чуть более развитым регионам, чуть меньшей религиозности, чуть большей свободе слова.
В конечном итоге все это комом собирается и получается немалый стимул свалить)
Буддийский монах (Кхеминда бхиккху) I live abroad, it is better to live in western countries :)
This isn't specific to Russia. Young people everywhere always want to "change" things and feel like they can't. And older people are always more conservative. Also young people don't always understand things are the way they are for a reason. The thing that is specific to Russia is some people in Russia for some reason feel like democracy is some cure all for all there problems. Let me tell you, it isn't.
Glen has the right idea... America could use more people like him.
Media is ridiculous......using opposition 😂😂😂😂
The young man with the jeans and black jacket with the camouflage arm is the most educated and realistic. He doesn't give up on Russia, he just wants to improve it and bring it into the realm of success of European countries. Russia can become a good country if enough people like himself exist in the newer generations.
No Russia has been worthless since its inception
Hopefully it is soon wiped of map
why would anyone take a teenager's opinon on anything. plus NYT is behind that, smells like an intricate propaganda.
@Curtis Martin no not really.
It is fascinating to listen to russians when you are playing call of duty. Whedazshwhhekheghvvwu ❤❤❤😂
Aaahhh yes..17 years old teenagers. Surely they know better how to run a country then the government.
If Russia don’t want him,somewhere here in the west will take him😊😊