Bobby Dunbar - Q+A

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 авг 2018
  • Why use dynamite?
    MERCH: We've got it! SHOP NOW: bzfd.it/2MDBk2d
    Watch on Amazon Instant Video: amzn.to/2nxA2q6
    Watch on Hulu: hulu.tv/2FHqdMT
    Check out our BuzzFeed Original Series channel on Roku: bit.ly/2DUnOlE
    Credits: www.buzzfeed.com/bfmp/videos/...
    Welcome to the BuzzFeed Unsolved Network! This channel is your one-stop destination for all things mystery, conspiracy, supernatural, true crime, and everything in between. Subscribe here: bit.ly/2zuaR06.
    MUSIC
    Licensed via Audio Network
    SFX Provided By AudioBlocks
    (www.audioblocks.com)
    STILLS
    Generic Soup Can
    befehr/Getty Images
    corn
    song_mi/Getty Images
    eyes collection
    perrineweets/Getty Images
    italian pasta in plate with fork
    LoopAll/Getty Images
    American Bunting
    RUSSELLTATEdotCOM/Getty Images
    Peach
    larryrains/Getty Images
    eyes
    kowalska-art/Getty Images
    vector men head character
    kowalska-art/Getty Images
    Retro Silver Robot Set
    Tomacco/Getty Images
    Six hens
    colematt/Getty Images
    Military Armed Forces Dog Tags
    stevezmina1/Getty Images
    French fries, chicken leg and popcorn
    seamartini/Getty Images
    Kawaii funny muzzle with pink cheeks and winking eyes
    Ekaterina_P/Getty Images
    Realistic human eyeballs brown iris pupil
    Geerati/Getty Images
    Teenage feet in morgue with copy space
    Peter Dazeley/Getty Images
    Vector fashion glasses isolated on white background
    adekvat/Getty Images
    Male and female eyes eyebrows vector elements
    MicrovOne/Getty Images
    Cartoon faces expressions vector set
    andegro4ka/Getty Images
    Hats Set Fashion for Men. Vector
    Bigmouse108/Getty Images
    White textile advertising banners with folds template set.
    lightkitegirl/Getty Images
    Chili con carne in pan - mexican traditional food. Vector engraving
    DenPotisev/Getty Images
    Happy smiling catholic priest mascot character dressed in white gold clothes
    PrettyVectors/Getty Images
    Aviation transport and worker colorful poster on white
    Godruma/Getty Images
    Funny cartoon comic faces on white background
    lilu330/Getty Images
    dog tags military isolated. death medallion. Soldiers badge isolated. Iron War medal on white background
    MaryValery/Getty Images
    volume sound button
    anigoweb/Getty Images
    Flat cartoon sci-fi gun blaster with acid liquid
    Yuzach/Getty Images
    Vector low poly construction machinery
    tarras79/Getty Images
    Scene with two lampposts on pavement
    colematt/Getty Images
    Flat icon - Telescope
    puruan/Getty Images
    Banner
    sanchesnet1/Getty Images
    Set of vector lamposts with advertising flags.
    Topuria Design/Getty Images
    Round sport podium - champion pedestal, winner awarding
    GoMixer/Getty Images
    Crane truck and happy worker in uniform
    bagira22/Getty Images
    Human Skull | Antique Medical Scientific Illustrations and Charts
    nicoolay/Getty Images
    Studio portrait of a bearded man with tattooed arms
    Loop Images RF/Getty Images
    Two horses in a field, Iceland
    SollaMatt/Getty Images
    Cute baby on the white bed
    Дарья Амосеева/Getty Images
    Horse Running On Shore At Beach
    Natalie Alexeeva (anakonda) / EyeEm/Getty Images

Комментарии • 2,5 тыс.

  • @BuzzFeedUnsolvedNetwork
    @BuzzFeedUnsolvedNetwork  5 лет назад +625

    Unsolved has merch! Check it out here: goo.gl/druyya
    Watch on Amazon Instant Video: amzn.to/2nxA2q6
    Watch on Hulu: hulu.tv/2FHqdMT
    Check out our BuzzFeed Original Series channel on Roku: bit.ly/2DUnOlE

    • @myronperreiraa
      @myronperreiraa 5 лет назад +8

      A case on the mysterious disappearance of Subash Chandra Bose please unsolved

    • @EmmaViljakainen
      @EmmaViljakainen 5 лет назад +3

      BuzzFeed Unsolved Network Do you guys deliver to finland? I didn't find it on the website

    • @EzioTheProphet
      @EzioTheProphet 5 лет назад +3

      Been waiting months only to just now find out they have their own channel, wow

    • @joshuafix5062
      @joshuafix5062 5 лет назад

      Hello

    • @monstrosity6738
      @monstrosity6738 5 лет назад +1

      The next episode might be about the Dark Web

  • @kaci5678
    @kaci5678 5 лет назад +5071

    In response to the mother not being able to identify her child:
    My brother died when I was thirteen and the hardest thing I went through was how quickly I forgot his appearance. Back then, they wouldn’t have pics on their iPhone to remember. You’d be amazed at how quickly the brain forgets. I often wonder if I were to walk past my brother on the street, would I recognize him? With all the grief and stress Mother Dunbar was going through, her memory could be affected

    • @MeaLyse
      @MeaLyse 5 лет назад +203

      May he rest in peace, my friend ♡

    • @marvandthe4topz
      @marvandthe4topz 5 лет назад +178

      Kaci Balfany such a great point. And I’m sorry for your loss.

    • @KaylieBeth822
      @KaylieBeth822 5 лет назад +77

      @@victorialarson6415 ...are you okay?

    • @destinymclaughlin1059
      @destinymclaughlin1059 5 лет назад +136

      @@victorialarson6415 you really have issues EVERYONE can forgot their child. It is how the brain works. I can understand a couple months but with no pictures after a couple years you forget. Search up how the brain remembers. After a couple years your memories are fake...

    • @ashmetzger2393
      @ashmetzger2393 5 лет назад +102

      victoria larson it was 1912 there were usually no photos that these mothers would have. Plus Bobby wasn't out with people they didn't know he was with a family friend. Also I'm not surprised Julie Anderson didn't go to the police as she had given permission to the uncle to take him for a few days so he would just say he gave her permission to have the child cause in 1912 if a woman says one thing and man another the man is going to be believed over an unwed woman. Look at how the media treated her

  • @bobbydunbar9767
    @bobbydunbar9767 5 лет назад +6464

    Hey it's me Bobby. I'm good, very old. Chime off bro.

    • @cutepie7582
      @cutepie7582 5 лет назад +143

      Wow

    • @anemxia9393
      @anemxia9393 4 года назад +131

      What the-

    • @PoochieCollins
      @PoochieCollins 4 года назад +162

      @Bobby Dunbar : what do you think of DNA testing concluding that you're not actually Bobby Dunbar?

    • @SalsaPie
      @SalsaPie 4 года назад +136

      Beat me to it by a year. Damn

    • @zackdornan6074
      @zackdornan6074 4 года назад +35

      tired doodle are you being sarcastic or sincere? it’s actually hard to tell

  •  5 лет назад +2255

    hi on the notion of tatted babies: in croatia during the war children were getting separated from their parents by the italians and nazis and so parents literally tattooed their small children with very intriciate and specific patterns so that if they ever were separated because of the war, they would be able to find each other when they were older. If you look up traditional croatian tattoos you can see the style of pattern they used :)

    • @JennaWallgren
      @JennaWallgren 5 лет назад +46

      NIKÅ Very cool, thanks for sharing!

    • @shariwelch8760
      @shariwelch8760 5 лет назад +146

      That is heartbreaking but so interesting, will look it up.

    • @prettylittleravenna
      @prettylittleravenna 5 лет назад +167

      I actually met an old woman who was tattooed that way, it was cool but also sad. Also some people in really old times (ottoman empire) tattooed girls so the turks wouldn't take them as slaves (apparently it was taboo to be tattooed in Islam)

    • @namesurname9200
      @namesurname9200 5 лет назад +57

      Being from Croatia and seeing someone know this *gasps thank u*

    • @thickdaddy._.3593
      @thickdaddy._.3593 5 лет назад +16

      This ws very sad but pretty cool too thx for sharing it. 😁😄

  • @icemagiciangh3268
    @icemagiciangh3268 5 лет назад +944

    I feel like Bruce was probably being abused at home- an uncle beating him, a mother not looking for him for forever, etc. He saw an escape from his hard life, and chose to be Bobby Dunbar.

    • @gingey1423
      @gingey1423 4 года назад +11

      That's a good analysis ✌️

    • @pranavpanicker1120
      @pranavpanicker1120 4 года назад +25

      Gallifreyan_ Hunter but he was too small to think of such big lies. And evn if he pulled it off, he surely would’ve blurted it out to someone quickly once everything had cooled down

    • @tayloranderson7547
      @tayloranderson7547 4 года назад +3

      I feel like Bruce was probably being abused at home an UCL binging him , for foaver, ect, he saw

    • @andresperez2264
      @andresperez2264 4 года назад +34

      Pranav Panicker Bruce clearly isn’t just thinking this up and being like “Hold on damn, this life is kind of gucci” after going through all the emotional trauma that this kind of event would bring, his own identity would just latch onto this idea of Bobby Dunbar. Think of FFVII and what Cloud does with Zack’s identity and him latching onto that, I know it’s a much more unrealistic example but it’s kind of what maybe going on here Psychologically. I personally like the theory that both Bobby and Bruce were “kidnapped” and Bobby died, Bruce was traumatized and the question if his true identity affected him even more, so he subconsciously in an effort to escape the tragedy’s he’s lived through, became Bobby Dunbar.

    • @emilylittle1187
      @emilylittle1187 4 года назад +15

      He was also quite a small child, I feel like he was probably very confused

  • @leturna9866
    @leturna9866 5 лет назад +4396

    if the next season of ruining history doesn't talk about the french people dancing, i am going to RIOT

    • @nicoleb7106
      @nicoleb7106 5 лет назад +89

      How would you do it? Please say by dancing

    • @Rexmoona
      @Rexmoona 5 лет назад +13

      I thought it was actually Italy that the people dancing 😂 they told me the story in my Italian classes in year 2 and I never forgot about it. I thought it had something to do with a spider bite but I was always confused because wouldn’t dancing pass the venom through the body quicker haha

    • @Rexmoona
      @Rexmoona 5 лет назад +22

      Okay wait just googled it, apparently it’s to do with wolf bites in southern Italy. It’s called Tarantism. It’s a hysteria

    • @VeronicaCasillasOuO
      @VeronicaCasillasOuO 5 лет назад +3

      Literally it's all I want in life

    • @yaxofossiad
      @yaxofossiad 5 лет назад +1

      Seriously.

  • @ashleygarrity3475
    @ashleygarrity3475 5 лет назад +1731

    Every time I hear about the people in France who danced until they died I think where’s the episode

    • @cherrycola10986
      @cherrycola10986 5 лет назад +7

      Ashley Garrity exactly!

    • @ronnie3235
      @ronnie3235 5 лет назад +11

      Ashley Garrity mass hysteria is weird but not interesting enough for a full episode in my opinion

    • @emilykwilson3611
      @emilykwilson3611 5 лет назад +84

      It’d be a good Ruining History

    • @chandirairina8884
      @chandirairina8884 5 лет назад

      I think I read on some comments that ryan and shane have mentioned this a few times, can anyone tell me which episodes were those?

    • @Elena-ec7ei
      @Elena-ec7ei 5 лет назад

      Chandira Irina they haven't made an ep about it

  • @oliversolar3504
    @oliversolar3504 5 лет назад +1103

    okay but why haven't they made a video about the french dancing thing?

    • @megancarvalho457
      @megancarvalho457 5 лет назад +40

      Because it's not unsolved

    • @gwenmogs5913
      @gwenmogs5913 5 лет назад +6

      because it was ergot poisoning

    • @Blau-grana
      @Blau-grana 5 лет назад +3

      NEIN NEIN NEIN!

    • @mothsprojects
      @mothsprojects 5 лет назад +42

      @@megancarvalho457 it is unsolved, they don't actually know why those people danced till they died

    • @-callmecrazy-5859
      @-callmecrazy-5859 5 лет назад +11

      It was just a disease that caused everyone to move continuously until their bodies tired out and they died. It was some kind of poisoning I think

  • @TheNeonCupcake
    @TheNeonCupcake 5 лет назад +567

    Personally I believe that the woman was so beside herself with grief that when she was presented with a child that looks similar she latched onto the idea that this IS her child. Similar to how women who have a still birth become obsessed with caring for those like like baby dolls. They know it's not their baby but they will swear down that it is because the alternative is too much for them to handle.

    • @amshazow
      @amshazow 4 года назад +4

      TheNeonCupcake like in the boy
      but that film was fucked up

  • @Live_wire_1
    @Live_wire_1 5 лет назад +5231

    Theory: Shane can actually see ghosts and has just been messing with Ryan this whole time

  • @SaltyPug
    @SaltyPug 5 лет назад +942

    Still waiting for #BoogaraGuitara

    • @Chimerical_
      @Chimerical_ 5 лет назад +18

      KRISTEN NEWMAN *BOOGARA GUITARA BOOGARA GUITARA*

    • @Nagarath16
      @Nagarath16 5 лет назад +14

      What if Shane promises to stop hotdaga if instead there will be #BoogaraGuitara..? Because we probably have to ask them make that kind of deal to get Ryan to play.

  • @ceciliagomez6582
    @ceciliagomez6582 5 лет назад +239

    As a mother I think with out photos to remind you of what they looked like and the fact that a 4 year old changes so much in a matter of months I think I would have a hard time knowing with out a doubt if a child was mine. Also children forget people even faster then an adults so I’m not surprised that the child wouldn’t recognize its mother.

    • @ethanweeter2732
      @ethanweeter2732 2 года назад

      The eyes getting smaller would be odd, unless Bobby’s eyelids maybe grew over just 8 months.

    • @swimminginhoney
      @swimminginhoney 2 года назад +2

      @@ethanweeter2732 I think I remember hearing that eyes are the only part of the body that stay the same size while the rest of the body grows. That's why kids seem to have big eyes but then they look 'smaller' as they get older. But either way, it wasn't Bobby anyway ahaha

  • @hcneydew4226
    @hcneydew4226 5 лет назад +55

    5:58 to be fair, my 98 year old great grandmother watches unsolved

  • @Thesweetestpegasus
    @Thesweetestpegasus 5 лет назад +1024

    “Pony or bike?”
    “Neither”
    *5 seconds later*
    “God I want a horse”

  • @dianapullen1705
    @dianapullen1705 5 лет назад +28

    Funny story. My mom lost me in a department store and when she came to the security asking for me, they asked her “what does she look like” and my mom was like she has a giant scar on her forehead and blonde hair and the guy was like “I’m going to need more of a description than that” and my mom literally yelled “HOW MANY BLONDE KIDS WITH GIANT SCARS ON THEIR FOREHEADS DO YOU HAVE BACK THERE.” Let’s just say he delivered me back to my mother within seconds lol

  • @EKP0133F
    @EKP0133F 4 года назад +96

    Ryan: Welcome back to post mortem.
    Shane: *Suprised Pikachu face*

  • @jayfaisa6016
    @jayfaisa6016 5 лет назад +149

    *stressed* “God, i’d love a horse.”
    “... okay, moving on”

  • @waffles05
    @waffles05 5 лет назад +1784

    Who else loves when Shane realizes that the show just started? 0:06

    • @panbiznesmen2950
      @panbiznesmen2950 5 лет назад +34

      This is even better than Hot Daga :D

    • @imgrim391
      @imgrim391 5 лет назад +7

      My Geeky Life lmaooo

    • @conormoriarty4444
      @conormoriarty4444 5 лет назад +4

      Like 100 💯

    • @jordansievert2154
      @jordansievert2154 5 лет назад +34

      My favorite part of every episode

    • @boybutch
      @boybutch 5 лет назад +90

      He’s been doing that *thing* in the beginning of each episode this season, I think it’s a bit lol

  • @lerinorthcott
    @lerinorthcott 5 лет назад +791

    they look so bright and crisp wow

  • @haileymcewan4208
    @haileymcewan4208 4 года назад +63

    00:00
    Shane:
    ‘What- we’re starting?’’ ‘Oh ok.’’ ‘What’s Ryan babbling about’’ ‘How did I get here’’

  • @delanapaige
    @delanapaige 5 лет назад +120

    I love watching Shane lose all interest as the questions are ending so that he can pull up the Hotdoga. 😂

  • @liamrollinson4435
    @liamrollinson4435 5 лет назад +592

    Please do the thing about the people in France dancing😂

    • @Huniebun_
      @Huniebun_ 5 лет назад +2

      That-guy-liam 1 YES

  • @mereisnotonfire
    @mereisnotonfire 5 лет назад +266

    Ryan looking BUFF

  • @tommyp467
    @tommyp467 5 лет назад +91

    10:03 why does shane’s lying face look like max from max and ruby

    • @mkz2250
      @mkz2250 4 года назад +4

      this is simultaneously the best and the worst comment

  • @oliviacarr6986
    @oliviacarr6986 4 года назад +48

    I know this was a year ago but I felt I should add my two cents! I can personally attest to the brain being very bizarre and complex! I went through a really rough time in my life when my best friend took her own life. The odd thing was the moment I got the news it was like most of my memory of her and I together just disappeared. My body grieved and felt sick but my mind still felt extremely disconnected. It’s six years later and I’m FINALLY dealing with it now and starting to get my memories back. Her voice I couldn’t remember until last month. Though I could recognize her face even then it really really wouldn’t have surprised me if (especially in those times) the mother, struck in grief and cycling thoughts met the child and ended up questioning her own recognition abilities with so many details lining up. It’s an odd situation for sure but the mental strain from grief is unpredictable and hard. She might have had a gut feeling that this wasn’t her child but often when we are desperate we become really good at lying to ourselves.
    Edit: ALSO side note there’s actually a condition that’s not often diagnosed because it doesn’t tend to be a massive issue is the inability to recognize/remember faces. And back then education on mental conditions was severely limited so who knows its possible she had a severe case of it and didn’t realize how important it was until her child was actually lost.

    • @Nimish204
      @Nimish204 3 года назад +2

      I am so sorry for your friend. I hope she found peace

  • @annieromero145
    @annieromero145 5 лет назад +143

    my mom complained about me not having a birth mark or scar that stands out just to identify me, so I got a tattoo. now she's pissed at me.

    • @ellauglov8891
      @ellauglov8891 5 лет назад

      Annie Romero 💀

    • @moderatemoon3306
      @moderatemoon3306 5 лет назад +3

      Well she wanted you to have a birth mark now you have one technically

  • @FlapJacques
    @FlapJacques 5 лет назад +440

    When are we getting the BuzzFeed Unsolved True Crime: The Dancing French People episode?? That thing has been a running joke ever since the beginning of Shane's appearance

    • @floating_rock172
      @floating_rock172 4 года назад +22

      They covered it on the new show, Puppet History on Watcher

  • @emileefisher4314
    @emileefisher4314 5 лет назад +33

    Also why was it never mentioned that some journalists had in fact theorized that Lessie & Percy had something to do with his disappearance but played it off using Bruce to cover the deeds.

  • @pk6010
    @pk6010 5 лет назад +52

    buzzed unsolved should do solved sundays

  • @sarahdowd7046
    @sarahdowd7046 5 лет назад +441

    Post-mortem is just like
    People send questions to people who don’t know the answer to your questions

    • @Tri_monster
      @Tri_monster 5 лет назад +28

      That's the show on a nutshell

    • @Loveya226
      @Loveya226 5 лет назад

      Lmaooo

    • @dragonmaid1360
      @dragonmaid1360 5 лет назад +1

      don't think they care lol

    • @Bluey306
      @Bluey306 5 лет назад +7

      sometimes we get "questions" that are more interrogative remarks on one theory/suspect or the other, illuminating certain factors in a way the ghoul boys didn't in the episode, and i think that's pretty cool.

    • @dillonmoran1861
      @dillonmoran1861 5 лет назад

      And it’s fantastic

  • @crisis4415
    @crisis4415 5 лет назад +172

    Pam’s attack on the dark master was the equivalent of Loki’s attack on Thanos.

    • @brugmoment3289
      @brugmoment3289 5 лет назад +16

      The moonlight tiger why would you say something so controversial yet brave

    • @jothequeermeleon4495
      @jothequeermeleon4495 5 лет назад +6

      Pam started regretting she was a villain = Loki becoming a hero in Ragnarok and iw
      Theory: does Pam is Loki?!

    • @brugmoment3289
      @brugmoment3289 5 лет назад +3

      Ioana Nicolae my new favorite headcanon

  • @jeffreybinninger8948
    @jeffreybinninger8948 5 лет назад +64

    PSA: Ryan said this on Twitter regarding there being no video this past Friday, August 31'st.
    "Hey folks... just letting you know that the season finale will air NEXT Friday. Needed a little more time to work on this one. You guys deserve the best episode we can put out, and this week will allow that. Sorry everybody and hope you have a good weekend!"
    TLDR; They weren't satisfied with the quality of the video yet, so instead of publishing a somewhat incomplete episode, they're releasing this week's video next Friday.

    • @kimbooley90
      @kimbooley90 5 лет назад +2

      Thanks! Came here just to see if anyone else was wondering why there was no new episode. I just assumed it was the end of the season.

    • @satori4183
      @satori4183 5 лет назад

      Thanks! I was hitting Reload with an increasing sense of annoyance (didn't think about checking twitter) so now I can stop doing that 😀

    • @yoakumchristopher
      @yoakumchristopher 5 лет назад

      It better be a banger

  • @ChandelierPG
    @ChandelierPG 3 года назад +19

    Also hadn’t it been like 8 months from the time he went missing to the time he was found? Kids grow and change so much at such a young age, I could see how the mother, knowing that, would have trouble being completely certain that was her baby. And like Ryan said, it’s a traumatic event, so I would also take that into consideration

  • @MaureenLongoriaTheOneAndOnly
    @MaureenLongoriaTheOneAndOnly 5 лет назад +182

    As someone who works with horses, I can confirm - I have found myself occasionally clicking at humans instead of horses

    • @teresahowick5197
      @teresahowick5197 5 лет назад +5

      Maureen Longoria same. I do it to my kids all the time. Haven’t ridden a horse in years, sadly.

    • @garbagemanwithgarbagehands7370
      @garbagemanwithgarbagehands7370 5 лет назад +16

      My family got a dog when I was young and I often accompanied my mom when she was training him. Specifically when she made him respond to whistling, as a result I ALSO started respond to her whistle. The dog died years ago but she still whistles to find me in crowds and I perk up every time lol.

    • @frauleinbird
      @frauleinbird 5 лет назад

      @@garbagemanwithgarbagehands7370 My family and I always respond to whistling. It's very useful when we lose one another. But for some reason, my boyfriend's always a bit offended when I'm trying to make him respond as well :D

  • @rebeccahyde9909
    @rebeccahyde9909 5 лет назад +524

    When are we gonna get an episode about the people that danced ‘til they died tho?

    • @sydney8715
      @sydney8715 5 лет назад +18

      Rebecca Hyde it's not techincally unsolved though which is the point of this series. some sort of mass hysteria caused it. it's definitely interesting but it shouldn't have an episode

    • @rebeccahyde9909
      @rebeccahyde9909 5 лет назад +46

      sydney mancini I can understand where you are coming from but BUN has been putting up shorter episodes not related to Unsolved but still with weird cases, and I’d be satisfied with a video like that. It would just be nice with how often it is referenced. Could do a whole, “Bizarre cases of mass hysteria,” short video and include that in it honestly.

    • @aliexiety
      @aliexiety 5 лет назад +25

      Hopefully in Ruining History 😔🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @rebeccahyde9909
      @rebeccahyde9909 5 лет назад +4

      Alie Flores yeah that would be super cool if they could find a way to work it in

    • @iprobablywontseeyourreply.7193
      @iprobablywontseeyourreply.7193 5 лет назад

      sydney mancini mass hysteria was all they could come up with. It’s basically just a theory lol

  • @madelineo4128
    @madelineo4128 5 лет назад +21

    ok whoever animated the space pope outdid themselves hat's off my dude

  • @GlitterGal95x
    @GlitterGal95x 5 лет назад +25

    When I listened to this story I thought hmm this family (the Dunbars) seem pretty wealthy if they could afford to get their “son” a pony and a bicycle willy nilly. And the fact that they had a holiday home, the town raised such a large amount of money and threw a parade for his return makes me think that they were pretty well known/influential in the community which makes me think they could’ve influenced the way the press wrote the story. I’m thinking the mum was so beside herself and so desperate for it to be bobby that she just said it was and her family/friends will have understood and gone along with it for her sake. It’s still suspicious how bobby disappeared though.. I’d love to know what happened to him

  • @Myplaylistsofmusic
    @Myplaylistsofmusic 5 лет назад +142

    The thing that I always look forward to in every postmortem episode is when Shane does the 😦 face at the beginning of the episode. Also in the supernatural series when he shakes his head in the main episode as Ryan asks “are ghosts real?” Lol

  • @hallinguyen2169
    @hallinguyen2169 5 лет назад +361

    I didn't realize how invested I was in the Hotdaga until Gene got shot and I wanted to cry.

    • @maria-rl4ec
      @maria-rl4ec 5 лет назад +13

      h. nguyen nguyen wow. Spoiler

    • @PoochieCollins
      @PoochieCollins 4 года назад +7

      @@maria-rl4ec : Vader is Luke's father. Bruce Willis was a ghost.

    • @elliottwatt5297
      @elliottwatt5297 4 года назад +12

      maria as a general rule, don’t read the comments till you’ve watched the video, I know it’s tempting but you’ll save yourself a lotta pain in the end.

    • @ArcanineEspeon
      @ArcanineEspeon 3 года назад

      @@elliottwatt5297 Bruh I'm pretty sure she was joking. I was about to make the same joke.

    • @DarthVader-jv9rv
      @DarthVader-jv9rv 3 года назад +2

      @@PoochieCollins I'm glad everybody knows I'm his father.

  • @oliwood13
    @oliwood13 5 лет назад +70

    Can you do an ep on the disappearance of Madeline Mccan?

  • @orieking
    @orieking 4 года назад +12

    14:52 "that actually hurt my heart"
    - ryan @ *shane's creative genius*

  • @bobbydunbar4525
    @bobbydunbar4525 5 лет назад +565

    Hey it's me Bobby, I'm good. Very old. Very alive. Chime off bro

  • @emmawalker7796
    @emmawalker7796 5 лет назад +283

    When is ruining history coming back

    • @davidgilchrist3270
      @davidgilchrist3270 5 лет назад +1

      Been throwing pennies in a well for this for weeks.
      Very expensive wish.

  • @Danielpeter2344
    @Danielpeter2344 4 года назад +11

    Shane at the beginning of the video "Oh hey, didn't see you there. Wait, where the hell am I?"

  • @percy5950
    @percy5950 5 лет назад +139

    I’m a bit late but I have a theory that the guy who kidnaped “bobby” could have burned his foot in hopes of getting the reward money idk

    • @brelonwy
      @brelonwy 3 года назад +2

      I doubt it because there was a good chance of penalty of kidnapping being death

  • @tgyhjdfgh
    @tgyhjdfgh 5 лет назад +486

    Shane at the beginning always makes my day :)

  • @moonydoll7109
    @moonydoll7109 5 лет назад +1361

    Not to be morbid or crude but back in those days people didn't really acknowledge pedophilia as we do today. Most people didn't consider it at all (unless someone was an outed homosexual, not saying homosexuals are pedophiles, just that homophobes choose to think that ). The fact that a non-relative was spending so much time with these children already puts me at unease, and the fact the he had an "affectionate" nickname for Bobby is even creepier. And for the other children that were with him, children are so susceptible they can pretty much be convinced of anything if you say it right or say it to them enough. The weird friend is the reason Bobby went missing IMO

    • @coffe4meplz
      @coffe4meplz 5 лет назад +63

      Yeah thats what I was thinking....

    • @TosyaChan
      @TosyaChan 5 лет назад +14

      Usually children can't hide secrets

    • @moonydoll7109
      @moonydoll7109 5 лет назад +331

      @@TosyaChan That's literally not true. Children are easily convinced that they should hide things to protect either the abuser, themselves or something of the like. They can be manipulated by being told it's the right thing do to, by being threatened or by being indoctrinated. They can be manipulated easily because they have such little framwork to base their morals, tactics and world views on.

    • @QuarterLifeCrises
      @QuarterLifeCrises 5 лет назад +129

      I guess it depends on family dynamics though. And social circles in those days were a lot different than they are today. That guy taking all the children out didn't seem creepy to me. It might have been if he was focused on only one child, but that didn't seem to be the case, he just had a favorite. Idk, maybe because I grew up being sometimes taken care of by non-relatives or distant relatives, including going on short vacations with them sometimes, clouds my judgement.

    • @fluorescentadolescent2640
      @fluorescentadolescent2640 5 лет назад +28

      Around at what point in time people started knowing about pedophilia? Just really interesting how culture changes

  • @TrueBlueICONiacz
    @TrueBlueICONiacz 5 лет назад +16

    6:39 the way Ryan pronounced ‘Clarke’ stresses me out

  • @emilymackey1863
    @emilymackey1863 5 лет назад +2

    I’ve been commenting about the people in France for weeks!😁Thank goodness they finally mentioned it again!🤗

  • @reaganjaegan
    @reaganjaegan 5 лет назад +459

    Shane, blink twice if you're being held hostage

    • @tayloranderson7547
      @tayloranderson7547 4 года назад +1

      Blink twice you begin hold hostinge

    • @izumiii544
      @izumiii544 4 года назад +3

      @@tayloranderson7547 wtf 🤨🤨

  • @anabonilla7063
    @anabonilla7063 5 лет назад +308

    I’d love an episode on the French people dancing!!

    • @danieldowse8068
      @danieldowse8068 5 лет назад +3

      Would be good for paranormal. Nice choice.

    • @25mjs03
      @25mjs03 5 лет назад +1

      @@danieldowse8068
      Except it's not really a paranormal thing, lol.

    • @ivyburns1329
      @ivyburns1329 5 лет назад +1

      Why does everyone want this all of a sudden?

    • @TheDundeeBiscuitLuvU
      @TheDundeeBiscuitLuvU 5 лет назад +12

      People have wanted it for years, look at the comments of any episode where it's mentioned. I think it would be a better candidate for ruining history, Shane's series, than unsolved tho, it's pretty much solved, it's supposed to have been caused by some sort of fungus.

    • @chiknboi4939
      @chiknboi4939 5 лет назад

      It should be a ruining history

  • @emmy9484
    @emmy9484 5 лет назад +24

    huh I’ve seen at least 12 different Bobby Dunbar’s in this comment section

    • @ArcanineEspeon
      @ArcanineEspeon 3 года назад +1

      Yo Ditzy over here is the real sleuth. This comment needs more likes.

  • @reemia
    @reemia 5 лет назад +1

    the bobby dunbar case honestly made the most interesting unsolved video in a while i liked it a lot

  • @nikolasa.6163
    @nikolasa.6163 5 лет назад +440

    I think I am in the minority which prefers True Crime over Supernatural

  • @daisydolan6623
    @daisydolan6623 5 лет назад +62

    About the fact that she couldn’t immediately recognise her son you have to take into consideration that Bobby would have aged. This was around the ages of 4 and 5, a time where children are developing pretty rapidly. The main thing that caused doubt in the mothers mind was that his eyes looked smaller, this would have happened due to head growth. Regardless of whether the boy was actually bobby or not it is something to take into consideration.

    • @missemeriin
      @missemeriin 5 лет назад +8

      Daisy Dolan also mothers aren't the infallible beings people think they are? Like was said in the episode, Lessie the more middle class (she brought her son a bike and a pony so I assume...) mother was forgiven but the single mom was vilified for not recognising.

  • @hellectra1
    @hellectra1 5 лет назад

    Can't wait for the next episode!!!

  • @ItzMeAudrey
    @ItzMeAudrey 5 лет назад +2

    I’ve been watching you guys for a while but I just want you to know your intro made me subscribe. I felt shamed. I didn’t realize I wasn’t! 😂😂😂 Glad to be here though, love these videos!

  • @loquatmuncher
    @loquatmuncher 5 лет назад +380

    I can't wait for Buzzfeed Unsolved Supernatural. Skinwalker Ranch, the Falcon Lake UFO incident, and the Hoia Baciu forest are all on my investigations wishlist. Hoia Baciu and Skinwalker would be awesome onsites.

    • @camillevoyage9727
      @camillevoyage9727 5 лет назад +5

      a moon oh dude Hoia Baciu would be LIT

    • @loquatmuncher
      @loquatmuncher 5 лет назад +3

      Right?? I'm imagining the boys in their element -- Wandering through the forest Blair Witch style. Ryan wheezing into the camera, Shane telling ghosts to kiss his apple taters. It'd be great.

  • @leonyoungs463
    @leonyoungs463 5 лет назад +193

    You could do a video on the strange disappearance of Richey Edwards, who disappeared from Wales in 1995. His body was never found, although his car was found near the Severn Bridge. What adds mystery to the case is that 2 weeks prior he took lots of money from his account each day?? Could be an interesting video.

    • @herebyhereby2874
      @herebyhereby2874 5 лет назад +3

      Faked suicide

    • @joysfulljourney
      @joysfulljourney 5 лет назад +2

      YES! Manics fans unite

    • @Lucien-si5yx
      @Lucien-si5yx 5 лет назад

      "What adds mystery to the case," "2 weeks prior" sounds like buzzfeed unsolved already lol

    • @rqgefqultz750
      @rqgefqultz750 5 лет назад

      Hahaha you sound like buzzfeed

    • @coffe4meplz
      @coffe4meplz 5 лет назад

      I just read this in Ryan's voice idk why

  • @ImaZaphod
    @ImaZaphod 5 лет назад

    Yes, I LOVE when y'all go on location!

  • @KennyMcCormick99
    @KennyMcCormick99 5 лет назад +2

    MAN! If like I wasn't already looking forward to Friday's episode... AND ESPECIALLY NOW AFTER WHAT THEY SAID ABOUT IT!!!

  • @carolinetripp8052
    @carolinetripp8052 5 лет назад +81

    ryans face while shane is reading the hot daga is so funny...he looks so done. #boogara

  • @Stephanie-rg5ln
    @Stephanie-rg5ln 5 лет назад +335

    alright normally I’m here for the crime and ghouls but I must say... Shane and Ryan are looking extremely handsome in this video 👀🌹

    • @BiancaLouise91
      @BiancaLouise91 5 лет назад +1

      Yes! They look particularly handsome here. I thought the same thing. Damn. 🔥🔥🔥

    • @jojojojojojo3979
      @jojojojojojo3979 5 лет назад

      Ikr

  • @Reviewermythoughts
    @Reviewermythoughts 5 лет назад

    I saw u guys on amazon prime , so proud 🙃

  • @pelo4040
    @pelo4040 5 лет назад

    Hey guys. I love your work and appreciate the time you spend on these episodes. One question though: are we getting any more episodes of Ruining History this year?

  • @juliannavelazquez4400
    @juliannavelazquez4400 5 лет назад +1402

    Parades *are* very boring. Thanks for someone finally saying that. 👏

    • @Johnwicklover1994
      @Johnwicklover1994 5 лет назад +10

      They’re only boring if you don’t watch the marching bands lmao

    • @bobbydunbar9767
      @bobbydunbar9767 5 лет назад +7

      I enjoyed it.

    • @TheRantMaster53
      @TheRantMaster53 5 лет назад +38

      Only parade worth seeing is Pride tbh

    • @yikes4946
      @yikes4946 5 лет назад +4

      *YOU TAKE THAT BACK NOW YOU SCOUNDREL!!!*

    • @yuh5470
      @yuh5470 5 лет назад +15

      The black parade seems great, and the pride parade

  • @virtualjayna
    @virtualjayna 5 лет назад +385

    People who are a mix of Shaniacs and Bergaras should be called either "Booniacs" or "Shoogaras" #postmortem

  • @esme66669
    @esme66669 5 лет назад +1

    You guys have referenced the French dancing fiasco so many times 😭 please do a video on it!

  • @michaellaverinto3687
    @michaellaverinto3687 5 лет назад

    I swear this buzzfeed channel is the most underated channel EVER.

  • @andreagwlo
    @andreagwlo 5 лет назад +356

    Pam really is a complex villain... Shane, we need a more complex backstory!

  • @theedac
    @theedac 5 лет назад +314

    Please do a video about kendrick Johnson. Poor guy and his family need justice and I'd love for y'all to dig deep into this mysterious case.

    • @candicem8931
      @candicem8931 5 лет назад +7

      Yes!!! Please do this one, it's so bizarre

    • @N..P..
      @N..P.. 5 лет назад +12

      It isn't really all that mysterious. What throws most people off is they don't know that the family used his post autopsy photo and everyone acts like that's how he looked when found. Other than that it's just heresy for the most part. The coroners all say one thing then go back on it then change their minds.
      Spoiler: Faces never look right after being peeled back to look at the muscles underneath.

    •  5 лет назад +6

      Nathan Pace hearsay? Heresy is a crime against a religion lmao

    • @N..P..
      @N..P.. 5 лет назад +8

      @
      Heresy - opinion profoundly at odds with what is generally accepted.
      Or
      belief or opinion contrary to orthodox religious (especially Christian) doctrine.
      "Lmao".

    • @bryntendo
      @bryntendo 5 лет назад +4

      Nathan Pace Did you just mean 'hearsay/hear-say' and are now trying to cover it up? =P Most people never use 'heresy' in anything but a religious contex, and even with some obscure unused other definition the term doesn't particularly fit what you were saying, hahaha

  • @matildeaglaee
    @matildeaglaee 5 лет назад

    Ok I “moved my finger that much” and subscribed lmao I love you guys 😭😭😂

  • @waitforurluv
    @waitforurluv 5 лет назад

    You should do a video on the Chiong Sisters, it’s confusing and chilling at the same time and I’m sure I’m not the only one who’s asking for this. love you boyos! x

  • @lillyhall7062
    @lillyhall7062 5 лет назад +62

    Ryan's arms🔥

  • @chamibrown7083
    @chamibrown7083 5 лет назад +428

    When Ryan said "stimulus" then corrected it to "stimuli" I was inexplicably turned on

    • @MagisterialVoyager
      @MagisterialVoyager 5 лет назад +14

      I feel ya, girl. 😂

    • @SuperLeonieXD
      @SuperLeonieXD 5 лет назад +25

      I don't know why but I also instantly developed a crush on 8:19

    • @SuperLeonieXD
      @SuperLeonieXD 5 лет назад +5

      Yup not even going to argue that

    • @chamibrown7083
      @chamibrown7083 5 лет назад +7

      @Di Vepets As soon as he said it wrong it I knew ppl would come for him in the comments because he's kinda known for mispronunciation and grammatical errors. I just love seeing growth in a man 😭🤣🤣👌🏾

    • @maturelydisapointingmember2699
      @maturelydisapointingmember2699 5 лет назад

      What time did he say it lol I forgot

  • @user00306
    @user00306 5 лет назад +1

    Please make a playlist for all the Hotdaga episodes! Also it will be loves and forever cherished in my heart.

  • @carterrichardson5492
    @carterrichardson5492 5 лет назад +4

    It’s almost 12:30 on a Saturday and I’m still up waiting for a Friday Unsolved episode

  • @bobbydunbar9707
    @bobbydunbar9707 5 лет назад +898

    Greetings, it is I, Bobby Dunbar (the real one). I am very old, and confined to a wheel chair. But anyway, as my father would say, “chime off bro”. P.S. sorry I was late on this video.

  • @emilybenoit4923
    @emilybenoit4923 5 лет назад +278

    Omg great idea drunk unsolved video you know one step closer to solving one shot that will be so funny 😂 I want to see Shane drunk

    • @lickthatsweater2841
      @lickthatsweater2841 5 лет назад +4

      He's been drunk on his insta story before, or at least buzzed, and it's exactly how you'd imagine, lol

    • @kittles201
      @kittles201 5 лет назад +2

      ruclips.net/video/ei5pHaPxG6w/видео.html He got drunk in an episode of the Test Friends! Ryan too. 😂

    • @emilybenoit4923
      @emilybenoit4923 5 лет назад +1

      I know I just think there reactions to the mysteries will be funny drunk especially when they do the part when they talk but it shows up on the screen in writing 😊

    • @SheBe-eb1oh
      @SheBe-eb1oh 5 лет назад +5

      I think if they did do a drunk unsolved it might come off as offensive. They are talking about someone's family member's murder or disappearance and being drunk would make them seem like buttholes. They already tread on the line.

    • @emco7400
      @emco7400 5 лет назад +1

      Emily Benoit what if they did that for a Supernatural episode

  • @bekkichance9052
    @bekkichance9052 5 лет назад

    love the editing on this vid

  • @saracarr3382
    @saracarr3382 5 лет назад +5

    I think people underestimate how hard it is to keep track of children,especially if you're in the woods. It would be so easy for Paul to get caught up with the other kids, and not notice Bobby is missing for a few minutes. I don't suspect Paul at all.

  • @taaptee
    @taaptee 5 лет назад +80

    It's 03:44 am on a school night, I've just finished watching To All The Boys I've Loved Before, and now I'm here

  • @paigemurphy109
    @paigemurphy109 5 лет назад +166

    Have the bois..... never touched horses before tho?

    • @looseleafteabutworse
      @looseleafteabutworse 5 лет назад +20

      Next episode they should go see horses

    • @emilyryan4026
      @emilyryan4026 5 лет назад +3

      They live in LA lol

    • @shariwelch8760
      @shariwelch8760 5 лет назад

      Hey, I live in LA and I've touched horses! We're not prisoners here haha

  • @lisahaynes8259
    @lisahaynes8259 5 лет назад +1

    I love you guys...poor Bobby...I would hope if something happened to my son I would know him ...1 day 1 year 20 years or more later...keep up the amazing job guys.

  • @madissenleigh330
    @madissenleigh330 5 лет назад

    the lighting is so good!

  • @Moondragon1821
    @Moondragon1821 5 лет назад +179

    I've truly grown to hate the Hotdoga, but I still watch just to watch Ryan silently fume about it. #boogara #downwiththehotdoga

    • @kingsly2275
      @kingsly2275 5 лет назад +21

      Same but I don’t complete despise it quite yet I’m more like a mom who’s tired after coming home from work but still wants to be supportive of their child

    • @amnajaved6894
      @amnajaved6894 5 лет назад +6

      Haha I think it should get it's own series on the channel

    • @hannahyokoyama149
      @hannahyokoyama149 5 лет назад +5

      I've never watched it, but I also support it since it bugs Ryan so much lol

    • @foeof
      @foeof 5 лет назад +5

      I think it's horrible and ruins the quality of their series but I do watch to share the feelings Ryan is having.

    • @KayleeFarnes
      @KayleeFarnes 5 лет назад +2

      I got lost so now I have no idea what's going on, so I dislike it. It should end soon.

  • @RealElongatedMuskrat
    @RealElongatedMuskrat 5 лет назад +40

    With regard to Paul Mizzi staying for 3 days afterwards, I wonder if that could be comparable to the perpetrators of modern crimes who hang around the area to act as concerned interviewees and remove suspicion. Hypothetically speaking, if he were responsible for an accident or murder, maybe he was playing the part?

  • @jhicks9902
    @jhicks9902 5 лет назад +9

    Shane: Weekly Q&A concluded...
    Ryan: *gun show*

  • @ariellaabrahams
    @ariellaabrahams Год назад +9

    Don't forget, when Bruce was taken and given to the Dunbars he went from being whipped to being showered with gifts. Not such a huge injustice

  • @k_a_y_l_e_e
    @k_a_y_l_e_e 5 лет назад +83

    Shane's brilliant idea: hey, BRAND YOUR CHILDREN.

  • @GothicCitrus
    @GothicCitrus 5 лет назад +74

    4:20 I feel like if you're the type of mother who is so afraid of losing their child that you faint simply by being informed that they've been missing for about an hour, which eventually turns into eight months, it's not such a stretch to imagine being so hysterical and distraught that accepting any little boy who looks mostly like how you remember your child to be as your son.

  • @cyraconforth9989
    @cyraconforth9989 5 лет назад

    Nooooo not the finale!! I love the show I don’t want a hiatus!!

  • @oliviafrancis1926
    @oliviafrancis1926 5 лет назад +8

    The hot daga has stepped its game up wow I am genuinely enjoying this thanks Shane ❤️

  • @davidasher22
    @davidasher22 5 лет назад +25

    I think the water acts as a buffer from actually mutilating the corpse. Similar to blast fishing, where underwater dynamite stuns or kills via shockwave.

  • @lily5462
    @lily5462 5 лет назад +39

    I saw Ryan at the mall twice but I was too scared to say anything😢

    • @Tri_monster
      @Tri_monster 5 лет назад +8

      You should've said something! At least just say hi and ask for a selfie.

  • @ASMRish
    @ASMRish 3 года назад +2

    Rewatching all the series, and in retrospect, the Hotdaga was the only part of the Q&As that mattered.
    Pouring one out for the original masterpiece.

  • @ThePositive0ne1
    @ThePositive0ne1 4 года назад

    Parades are not a waste of time. Just imagine in December being with family and friends that you love snuggled up with a blanket drinking hot cocoa just watching amazing floats go by. I am in marching band and it is so fun to see people's faces with joy. Or in July watching a dope marching band go by playing some tunes for times we didn't live in. It truly feels amazing imagining being in that time period. You Ghoul Boys should enjoy a parade sometime.

  • @kendrajade6722
    @kendrajade6722 5 лет назад +31

    "sEaSoN finale" ok well screw you then

  • @madisynalbanes1211
    @madisynalbanes1211 5 лет назад +230

    I hate seeing the time for the video and being excited for all the questions and the banter and then Ryan says “that’s it for the questions” and I’m so upset remembering about the hot doga. Not that the hot doga is bad, just want more questions.

  • @mindfreakmovies9586
    @mindfreakmovies9586 3 года назад +1

    Guys please come back. Lot's of love from India.