If you have any *questions* about *vocal technique* please leave them in the comments below or visit my homepage to get in touch for private lessons www.gideonclark.com
Thank you for reacting to it. Please do not use lyric video as they are not authorised and most are inaccurate. Please use original version uploaded by BigHit or Bangtan TV. Jungkook's as main vocalist , his backup vocal and adlibs always are best part of the song, whatsmore, this song is written by him.
BTS don't do lip sync. During one of their world tour, V had a problem with his throat. Fans sing during his parts and there was no recorded voice. He was so frustrated by that and even cried on stage. They are just too good, that's why you have doubts. But never lip sync with them, just backing tracks for ad libs
Well, they've improved their lip syncing for the Dynamite MV. 😂 Some of their lip syncing for MVs don't even involve moving their mouths and are funny as heck. 😂
Jimin has the brightest voice and V has the darkest voice tone in vocal line. Jin and Jungkook’s voices are more breathy. They all have very interesting and unique tone but blended so well in their songs. I personally prefer Jimin’s voice. But I really love Jungkook’s English cover song too. Looking forward you to next BTS’s songs.
The song is for the fans, JK produced the song inspired by one of RM's speech to the fans.In the beginning instead telling the fans that yes you can do it all be great why don't we share our story and Suga's verse hits home like you said its about developing one self its not about instant success or tuning away from difficulties
@@sariel8406 He is a producer already. Your Eyes Tell is produced by him. Magic Shop and Still With You is his. He co-produced one of their earlier song too. Fyi Jimin is already stepped into production too. He is the producer fro Friend. Yup, bangtan is learning new things all the time.
For me, this song is about acknowledging our difficulties in life including moments of not being able to love yourself, despair, like you're at the end of the rope and that they also experience this. Sharing stories are an important part of life and helps connect us. Show me, tell me your problems, and they'll do the same, let's empathise with each other and BTS will be there to support you if you need them to, find them within yourself when you need (door inside your heart - a way to self-soothe imagine beautiful sunsets, relax drink some tea and look at the stars). I liked the part where they choose not to invalidate your emotions by telling you to just be strong (have strength) as people are generally not taught the importance of validating others' emotions - people often don't want solutions but for someone to listen and acknowledge their feelings.
"Magic shop" is an actual psychological technique for coping with anxiety or depression. Jungkook (one of the members) wrote and produced this song for their fans. Great reaction! It was really interesting to watch. I recommend to check out BTS - "On. Kinetic Manifesto Film: Come Prima". And for comparison between live and studio versions you can react to "Your eyes tell". Also if you want to know more about them you can watch "This is BTS. Introduction to BTS (part 1)". It is very informative and updated video.
@@beany1944 You are really everywhere to say he didn't produce it when my dear check the freaking credits better because in there in "PRODUCERS: Jungkook, Hiss Noise, ADORA" anyone more in there HE IS THE ONLY MEMBER THERE in the production part of this song!!!! in WRITERS: Jungkook, Hiss Noise, RM, DJ Swivel, Candace Nicole Sosa, ADORA, J-Hope, Suga! JK is the FIRST ONE in the list because he contributed THE MOST and Yoongi and Hobi are there because it's well known they often write their raps in the songs. Check better the song credits and shut up before trying to despise one of the member works
@@beany1944 perhaps you're getting confused with Your Eyes Tell? In that one he's credited as writer and not as producer (that title goes to Gustav Mared and UTA)
BTS don't lip sync..they sing live with some backing track since they do hard choreography while singing but basically they sing live and their stamina and voice control is absolutely amazing.
Jimin sometimes lip synced during Lie or Serendipity due to choreo, he even had to ask the others if he sang live because he couldn't remember if he did that day or not in a commentary on, if I remember correctly, the Love Yourself Tour? But sometimes he sang the whole thing live, you can tell when he does. I don't think they have any problem with lip syncing when their choreo is hardcore. They're human, so, doesn't really bother me personally when they do.
Swusi Jimin only lip synced in those songs bc how tf is he supposed to sing and be stable while he is jumping and then grinding on the floor. That’s gonna be hard
One of the things i love about them is they don't even try to lipsync that parts.. jimin leaves that parts in serendipity and lie and we can see that he is not singing..
@@user-zp4bq4cl9k they do not lip sync, they not sing in their solos, check J-Hope "Just Dance", Jungkook "Euphoria". Lip sync is when you hold your mic and PRETEND you are singing, not sing and to have back track vocals is absolutely another thing and it is normal when there is hard choreo OR when in the original song there are adlibs made at the same time when the main line goes. You can't sing two things at once in reality...
Their live performance is amazing. Especially, Jimin's voice is so catchy and attractive to me. I like their vocal combination. Thank you for the reaction.
@@amandaking1463 i was thinking that but then so many ppl said JK had i got confused. And BTS themselves said Jin had a high range they had to change the keys to a song. ty
@@marinal. yw, but just so you know they said jin AND jimin's high range were why they had to raise Fake Love's key, and namjoon has mentioned a lot that they've had to raise the keys for lots of songs bc Jimin's voice is so high. jin can hit incredibly high notes and slay them, jimin just has a naturally higher voice than everyone else!
V’s natural voice is very unique his vocal coach used to say it sounded like there was something in his mouth. It seems as if different people tried to train him out of it, but it’s really just how he’s built. The other guys know what an asset his timbre brings to the emotional songs and make a point to place him well.
V has naturally that darker sound and jimin the brighter one. You can hear that even when they talk. They have several times the bridgepart together because it they sound so differently
JK usually does all of the harmonies except when Jimin provides the harmony for JK. Their voices blend so well that sometimes it's difficult to differentiate them.
frankly i love the way you compare they way they sang..not every vocal coach does that,thank you for your thorough explanation (details in the videos also)we appreciate your honest opinion💜
@@GCVocalCoaching I watch lot of reactors, even professionals like you, and rare do that comparison. I love it ! It was awesome ! You have different style of doing things than many others, in little subtle ways and I really-really like it. Your first BTS reaction made me subsribe and that is rare. I hope you react lots of their music and widely to K-pop (there is opinions that BTS is not K-pop anymore, but they have grown over and beyond that..). Anyway many of their stylistic choices (also in singing) are based on how things are done in K-pop, so I hope you would understand them better, understanding "the musical culture" where they come from.. :)
Thank you Pika! I'm glad you like it. Not sure when I'm gonna do another bts reaction. I want to keep it balanced and varied. But I'll probably do another one. I hope you'll also check out my other content in the meantime 😉
Studio or Live version....? Ofcourse live version, this song is for army.....when im feeling down and listen to this make me feel better... this song really inspired me.... its like telling me dont give up..and as a bts army i need to show something to myself...
I cried when I heard the song live at the concert in London. I always listen to this song when I'm having a panic attack. There's something about it that calms me down - I think maybe the pulsing of the track and then the almost sing along part at the end gives me something else to focus on and feel. So when I heard it live it felt very very emotional. I will never forget it.
V - KIM TAEHUNG voice is so unique beautiful, deep and strong!! the bridge en magic shop is the best part of the song to me! and YES! I always think that their songs are much better in live than in studio recorder. They are amazing!!
BTS really shines when they perform live. As great as the studio versions are, their lives are almost always better. Their energy and joy while performing just really brings something extra to their performances. :)
U should react to JIMIN's song LIE, or SERENDIPITY. JUNGKOOK's song EUPHORIA. V's song SINGULARITY. And JIN's song EPIPHANY. U will definitely be able to tell the difference of their vocals from each one of these songs. So please check them out
I always prefer the live version, even if they make some mistakes, you can feel the emotion they put in the song, for me it's worth it because usually that improves the performance a lot. My opinion, I'm not an expert lol💜
This song is based on the psychological principles of the “Magic shop”. It is based up on the book called “Into the Magic Shop” by James R.Doty. I suggest you read that to understand the meaning on a deeper level. BTS songs are deep and contains many psychological references. There is a whole series that covers the philosophies of the psychologist Carl Jung.
Appreciate all the extra effort and detail you put into this. Even the cute part at the end, the way you edited in comments you hadn't said out piud at the time for us to read and notice. Looking forward to more videos from you, thank you!
Well, magic shop is a really healing song for me. It's about finding a place where you can feel alright and heal your inner conflicts within yourself. And i love the love version too🥺💜
I love their studio music, but I almost always prefer their live versions. I think sometimes the studio versions have too much "polish" or special effects, and sometimes take away from their voices. They all sound so wonderful and sometimes I don't understand why they don't highlight it more. Like with their newest song Dynamite, the studio version is a bop and gets me dancing every time I listen to it, but when I watched them perform it live at the VMAs, they blew me out of the water with how good they sounded, and you could actually hear the vocals of the members Jin and V better in the live version. So while ARMY love the studio versions, in my experience, a LOT of us prefer the live versions.
this song was written by the youngest member, jungkook, and it was about ARMY, their fans. the magic shop it's supposed to be the place where you can exchange something that brings you sadness to something that will bring you joy so when they sing that we're gonna open a door in our hearts and they'll be there is because we as fans allowed them to live in our hearts and they're prepared to help us to get over bad stuff in our lives. also when they sing "you gave me the best of me so you'll give you the best of you" it's something like "you were able to help us become who we are now, you helped to find the best of us so you're able to do that to yourself as well". it's a really deep song about the bond between BTS and ARMY 💜 btw thank you SO MUCH for this reaction!!! I'll make sure to check more of your videos!
i think this is the first time i see a vocal coach (or anyone really) who does a lil research on them, listens to the studio version and then the live version, and only then gives an honest opinion on it, really cool thanks 👍🏻 no one expects people to know their names or recognise their voices when you've never heard a bts song before, of course, so i think it's cool that you took the time to look them up 👍🏻
There are 4 vocalists (Jungkook, Jimin,V & Jin) 3 rappers (RM, Suga & J-Hope). IMO they sing/rap better live than studio. For the vocal line ck out- house of cards, the truth untold, dimple. For a rap, ck out- outro: tear, cypher 3, cypher 4, ddaeng Oh and they have solos and mixtapes too.
magic shop is based in the book ‘into the magic shop’ is a book written by a neurosurgeon that focus on a little boy that has a lot of family problems and he finds a lady on the magic shop that teaches him how to deal with his feelings, how to relax, meditate and more, making the magic shop feel like a place of comfort for him (BTS also talks about it in the song) a really good book, no wonder BTS got inspired by it.
When he replayed *J-Hope's* part I cried cause finally someone recognised how amazing *J-Hope's* voice is 😌😭 and *V* doing the bridge is so emotional, I love it and it never fails to make me tear up 😭😭. The live versions are always better than the studio versions 💯💜
Interesting style of video reaction here. One thing I want to say that keep in mind, that these guys are dancing very difficult choreos sooo much on their concerts. So their voice can be unstable. But this song in particular very calm. Still even though they are dancing and singing at the same time they are doing it really great compare it to many other western artists. They've gone through so much tough training to be able to do that. Bc in Korea industry they dance so much while performing. Almost 6 years ago when I found out about them for the first time I was really impressed and even now I'm still impressed every time. I can see their improvements. They are really great singers, rappers and performers. 🙏🏻🖤
I really enjoy vocal coach reactions to BT and I enjoyed yours. I'm looking forward to more. I liked how you wrote comments in post and revisited parts of the song relistening and also comparing between live and studio versions. I think you had a good mix of technical comments on the different vocal types also. High five :)
Thank you for your reaction! I am very glad that you are a serious young man, it is nice to see your room without children's toys and other nonsense. You were commenting essentially without raising your voice. I really liked it!!!
I love ot7 but Jin Jimin Jungkook Hi's voice my goodness i love the mix voice and vocal His have amazing voice good job in every song's i love this voice's ❤❤
BTS is unique in that they have a number of songs written specifically for their fans. Basically love songs from BTS to ARMY, their fan group. BTS plays to audiences in sold out stadiums that hold 60,000 to 90,000 people and with the stadium being dark and the fans waiving their light sticks, the fans look a lot like stars in the night sky. Because of that, there are a lot of references to stars, lights, and galaxies in BTS' songs for ARMY. BTS struggled a lot in their careers, especially in the beginning, and they credit ARMY for giving them the strength to overcome everything that they went through. BTS will literally push themselves to collapsing, performing on stage for ARMY and ARMY has been known to do some pretty awesome stuff in the name of BTS, too.This song is about that relationship, between BTS and ARMY. The "Magic Shop" is an actual psychological technique where you trade negative things for positive and that's what BTS is saying they'll help ARMY do. Turn the negative into positive. The thing is, they actually do just that for their fans.
Oh wow! I am so happy that you chose "Magic Shop". Usually new reactors stick to Bangtan's title tracks to react to. I personally love this song and was thrilled that someone decided to give it a listen. 💜
I love BTS live preformances there are always so many adlibs they just throw in and they will feed off the fans and lets join in with the refrains, fan chants etc etc.
Thank you for the review. Magic shop is my favorite song from bts. But the live version from their concert is more beautiful. They are not doing the lip sync.
I like how you pause and compare to the studio version ^^, I love this so song much it means a lot to me. It has helped me through personal hardships. When I doubt myself I find myself listening to this song. It comforts me and also gives me strength to pull myself out of whatever situation I find myself in. I love them so much my heart could shatter into millions of pieces.
Also could you react to Ken(Vixx)- Its only my world @duet song festival? No vocal coach reacts to this one but in my opinion it’s worth to watch because Ken and Sangyeop are doing an incredible job. If you don’t it’s okay but I like your reaction and your attention to detail.
believe me, it's not just me but you asked which one we prefer, being there yourself is the best, of course not everyone gets to even if they want to, but when you are surrounded by so many people, it just makes you emotional and it's just so magical, i didn't expect it but when they started singing and when it came to fanchant parts i fricking cried so hard, i can't describe it any other way then magical, truly.
I’m A.R.M.Y. but being retired (I’m 66), and from a very small town, I’ve never had the chance to see them live (yet!), but I’ve heard them talk about how much strength and energy they get from being able to look into the eyes of their fans and see the love there, and how much that means to them because they genuinely love us, too. That’s why the live versions are better. The direct contact between us empowers them strongly.
At this concert, they sang Magic Shop right after IDOL which is super intense with really difficult choreography, so at the beginning of this song they were still a little out of breath from the previous performance...and they still did a phenomenal job!
Bts are best live trust me I have been to their concert they are the best performers on this planet they have a huge discography keep reacting Fyi they write and produce there own music with beautiful lyrics this one is done by jk sometime they do use us writer just to covert the language otherwise they are always involved in their songs I highly recommend THIS IS BTS by xceleste before any other reaction you might get knows a lot about their music and how it came to be MUST WATCH
Besides having God given talent...of course they have to practice even if takes a hundred times. The best about BTS is how they persistently & consistently work hard in their craft. So they can give great performances for us.
Magic Shop is a song by BTS dedicated to their fans, the ARMYs, and serves to tell us they will forever be with us.💜Magic shop is a place where your fears are exchanged for happiness💜A song made for fans by the youngest member of BTS, Jungkook. He expressed that they would feel very happy if fans can find comfort through this song when they’re struggling, tired & in pain.💜
honestly I can't end the song without crying, they mean so much to me even though they don't know me.. they make me feel better about myself when I'm down and they're really the best people I've ever listened to..
If you want to hear more of their individual voices, they all have solo songs in the Wings album, the Love Yourself trilogy and the Map Of The Soul albums. 3 songs for each member in total
There were probably around 60,000-75,000 people at that concert. I've seen them sing this live at a different concert and it was so incredibly beautiful and touching. Thanks for the great analysis :)
Omg I really enjoyed watching your reaction video !! I mean, you know lots of people make reaction content about BTS, then write a title with, "Vocal Coach React BTS bah blah blah," but in reality the content of the content is not much different from the usual reaction content. But you are different, you really explained the singing technique that BTS uses in the 'Magic Shop' 🥺 Thank you for your hard work😭😭
Great reaction, it's the first time i watch a reactor really compare the studio and the live version, and of course we prefer live than studio one because this boys are better live, try "Your Eyes Tell", it's also wrote and produced by the same member, our JK.. plis continue to listen to our boys, we purple you.....
"Magic Shop is a song by BTS dedicated to their fans, the ARMYs, and serves to tell us they will forever be with us." These mega talented young men even sing live during their fast and complex choreography. They train for breath control by singing while running on a treadmill.
This was cool to compare the live to the recording. They are so similar 🤩Our guys are super professional. That is why they are #1 right now. They love what they do. 🤗🥰💜
the lyrics to magic shop hits me the most because whenever i feel down or in a bad mood this is a song i would play and while thinking about it again i try my beat to do the things i can
If you have any *questions* about *vocal technique* please leave them in the comments below or visit my homepage to get in touch for private lessons www.gideonclark.com
Plz react to Bts born singer live
Bts your eyes tells (wrote and produced by jungkook) live
BTS Airplane plane pt 2 live
I love your reactions, for all. Have a nice day! 💜
React to BTS- your eyes tells
Pls React to BTS - the Truth untold
Thank you for reacting to it. Please do not use lyric video as they are not authorised and most are inaccurate. Please use original version uploaded by BigHit or Bangtan TV. Jungkook's as main vocalist , his backup vocal and adlibs always are best part of the song, whatsmore, this song is written by him.
Live version is much more emotional than studio version.
I agree
Bcs they're singing with army and the purple ocean can't hold my tear 😭
@@fikayuliana6777 that's what I said, too! I was like "it's cuz we're all close to crying in one venue together 😭😭"
V's bridge in magic shop is so beautiful it never fails to make me cry. V's voice is full of emotions!
My eyes gets watery when I hear the bridge especially their live versions 💜
bcs the lyrics “would u believe me if I said I was afraid of everything too? all the sincerity, the remaining times” he sang it fully hearted 🥺
I feel the same way.
Even the video he chose to react the live one is visually beautiful too
LoveMutz same it’s so beautiful
BTS don't do lip sync. During one of their world tour, V had a problem with his throat. Fans sing during his parts and there was no recorded voice. He was so frustrated by that and even cried on stage. They are just too good, that's why you have doubts. But never lip sync with them, just backing tracks for ad libs
Well, they've improved their lip syncing for the Dynamite MV. 😂 Some of their lip syncing for MVs don't even involve moving their mouths and are funny as heck. 😂
Неважно (Neva) lmao me & my friend noticed it too🤣 that’s why we say BTS can’t do lip-syncing. the only thing they’re suck of!😂😂
That was Jimin, not V.
@@sariel8406 Both of them cried bc of their voice. But I was talking about V. If you have seen the movie 'Bring The Soul' you can see that.
@@sariel8406 It was in Paris, there are plenty of fancams on youtube of fans singing V's part in The Truth Untold.
Jimin has the brightest voice and V has the darkest voice tone in vocal line. Jin and Jungkook’s voices are more breathy. They all have very interesting and unique tone but blended so well in their songs. I personally prefer Jimin’s voice. But I really love Jungkook’s English cover song too. Looking forward you to next BTS’s songs.
I also really like Jimin's voice, his voice is angelic only a few boys have that voice
Yeah me too his voice just really hits differently
Jimin's voice touches the heart 💜
he is high notes King💜💜💜💜
The song is for the fans, JK produced the song inspired by one of RM's speech to the fans.In the beginning instead telling the fans that yes you can do it all be great why don't we share our story and Suga's verse hits home like you said its about developing one self its not about instant success or tuning away from difficulties
Jk co-wrote, not produced. One of the songwriters for this also co-wrote We Are Bulletproof: The Eternal :). Jk has not done music production as yet.
Sariel pls check the credits for magic shop en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Love_Yourself:_Tear
@@sariel8406 He wrote and produced his song Still With You. He's also credited as a main producer for Magic Shop and Love Is Not over.
@@sariel8406 He is a producer already. Your Eyes Tell is produced by him. Magic Shop and Still With You is his. He co-produced one of their earlier song too. Fyi Jimin is already stepped into production too. He is the producer fro Friend. Yup, bangtan is learning new things all the time.
For me, this song is about acknowledging our difficulties in life including moments of not being able to love yourself, despair, like you're at the end of the rope and that they also experience this. Sharing stories are an important part of life and helps connect us. Show me, tell me your problems, and they'll do the same, let's empathise with each other and BTS will be there to support you if you need them to, find them within yourself when you need (door inside your heart - a way to self-soothe imagine beautiful sunsets, relax drink some tea and look at the stars). I liked the part where they choose not to invalidate your emotions by telling you to just be strong (have strength) as people are generally not taught the importance of validating others' emotions - people often don't want solutions but for someone to listen and acknowledge their feelings.
"Magic shop" is an actual psychological technique for coping with anxiety or depression. Jungkook (one of the members) wrote and produced this song for their fans.
Great reaction! It was really interesting to watch.
I recommend to check out BTS - "On. Kinetic Manifesto Film: Come Prima".
And for comparison between live and studio versions you can react to "Your eyes tell".
Also if you want to know more about them you can watch "This is BTS. Introduction to BTS (part 1)". It is very informative and updated video.
"Your Eyes Tell" is much more about singing than "ON" which is more for performance and hype/energy boost.
Jk co wrote the song, he did not produce it.
@@beany1944 You are really everywhere to say he didn't produce it when my dear check the freaking credits better because in there in "PRODUCERS: Jungkook, Hiss Noise, ADORA" anyone more in there HE IS THE ONLY MEMBER THERE in the production part of this song!!!! in WRITERS: Jungkook, Hiss Noise, RM, DJ Swivel, Candace Nicole Sosa, ADORA, J-Hope, Suga! JK is the FIRST ONE in the list because he contributed THE MOST and Yoongi and Hobi are there because it's well known they often write their raps in the songs. Check better the song credits and shut up before trying to despise one of the member works
@@beany1944 Jungkook is credited as the main producer of "Magic Shop". He produced this song with Hiss Noise and ADORA.
@@beany1944 perhaps you're getting confused with Your Eyes Tell? In that one he's credited as writer and not as producer (that title goes to Gustav Mared and UTA)
BTS don't lip sync..they sing live with some backing track since they do hard choreography while singing but basically they sing live and their stamina and voice control is absolutely amazing.
Jimin sometimes lip synced during Lie or Serendipity due to choreo, he even had to ask the others if he sang live because he couldn't remember if he did that day or not in a commentary on, if I remember correctly, the Love Yourself Tour? But sometimes he sang the whole thing live, you can tell when he does. I don't think they have any problem with lip syncing when their choreo is hardcore. They're human, so, doesn't really bother me personally when they do.
Swusi Jimin only lip synced in those songs bc how tf is he supposed to sing and be stable while he is jumping and then grinding on the floor. That’s gonna be hard
@@user-zp4bq4cl9k grinding on the floor👀💜
One of the things i love about them is they don't even try to lipsync that parts.. jimin leaves that parts in serendipity and lie and we can see that he is not singing..
@@user-zp4bq4cl9k they do not lip sync, they not sing in their solos, check J-Hope "Just Dance", Jungkook "Euphoria". Lip sync is when you hold your mic and PRETEND you are singing, not sing and to have back track vocals is absolutely another thing and it is normal when there is hard choreo OR when in the original song there are adlibs made at the same time when the main line goes. You can't sing two things at once in reality...
I really love Jimin's high note in magic shop,his voice is amazing
I love jimin vocal so much. He has the power that attracts people's hearts and catching ears.
Jimin's breathing and high note sound is mesmerizing😊
Their live performance is amazing. Especially, Jimin's voice is so catchy and attractive to me. I like their vocal combination. Thank you for the reaction.
jimin voice is highest one
others might say its Jk or Jin. V can go high too. All their voices are similar but different. They are beautiful nonetheless.
@@marinal. Jimin has the highest voice tone in the group...
@@amandaking1463 i was thinking that but then so many ppl said JK had i got confused. And BTS themselves said Jin had a high range they had to change the keys to a song. ty
Yas, jimin no.1 and jin no.2 most high note in BTS
@@marinal. yw, but just so you know they said jin AND jimin's high range were why they had to raise Fake Love's key, and namjoon has mentioned a lot that they've had to raise the keys for lots of songs bc Jimin's voice is so high. jin can hit incredibly high notes and slay them, jimin just has a naturally higher voice than everyone else!
I love Jimin. Amazing.
me too
Marina L. Me three :)
Same here
The very high voice is Jimin - always
React to “Your Eyes Tell” studio and live please
Produced , composed and written by Jungkookie
🍪
Yes please
YESSS UPP
With the right training you can get there too. 😁
💖Jimin's voica is mesmerizing and beautiful high note fatal blow💖🤩😍👍👏
I love jimin voice the best kk that's it, that's the comment💜💜💜💜
King of High notes & falsettos
💜💜
V’s natural voice is very unique his vocal coach used to say it sounded like there was something in his mouth. It seems as if different people tried to train him out of it, but it’s really just how he’s built. The other guys know what an asset his timbre brings to the emotional songs and make a point to place him well.
Interesting info. Thx for the insight. ✌️
I love how supportive and encouraging the guys are of each other, they are truly like brothers or best friends.
V has naturally that darker sound and jimin the brighter one. You can hear that even when they talk. They have several times the bridgepart together because it they sound so differently
There's actually 70,000 or more people in there. It is actually performed at japan.
Thx for the information 👍
Jimin always blew me away.
JK usually does all of the harmonies except when Jimin provides the harmony for JK. Their voices blend so well that sometimes it's difficult to differentiate them.
That's jimin who hit the high notes
this is the best reaction ever, calm and detailed
Glad you like it! 🙂
Every vocal coach react to bts will smile when he hear jimin voice haha
frankly i love the way you compare they way they sang..not every vocal coach does that,thank you for your thorough explanation (details in the videos also)we appreciate your honest opinion💜
Thank you, Farrah! I'm glad you like it! Thx for watching. 🙂
@@GCVocalCoaching I watch lot of reactors, even professionals like you, and rare do that comparison. I love it ! It was awesome !
You have different style of doing things than many others, in little subtle ways and I really-really like it. Your first BTS reaction made me subsribe and that is rare.
I hope you react lots of their music and widely to K-pop (there is opinions that BTS is not K-pop anymore, but they have grown over and beyond that..). Anyway many of their stylistic choices (also in singing) are based on how things are done in K-pop, so I hope you would understand them better, understanding "the musical culture" where they come from.. :)
Thank you Pika! I'm glad you like it. Not sure when I'm gonna do another bts reaction. I want to keep it balanced and varied. But I'll probably do another one. I hope you'll also check out my other content in the meantime 😉
V has a very amazing voice,surprising voice range,every song is different,he is unpredictable,he can sing anything...
Studio or Live version....?
Ofcourse live version, this song is for army.....when im feeling down and listen to this make me feel better... this song really inspired me.... its like telling me dont give up..and as a bts army i need to show something to myself...
I cried when I heard the song live at the concert in London. I always listen to this song when I'm having a panic attack. There's something about it that calms me down - I think maybe the pulsing of the track and then the almost sing along part at the end gives me something else to focus on and feel. So when I heard it live it felt very very emotional. I will never forget it.
Pls next reaction Jimin best live hight notes and raspy vocals
He does raspy vocals? 😳
@@GCVocalCoaching only occasionally 😊
@@GCVocalCoaching Here's the link of jimin's live high notes and raspy vocals compilation ruclips.net/video/1LtSXxUN9fw/видео.html
V - KIM TAEHUNG voice is so unique beautiful, deep and strong!! the bridge en magic shop is the best part of the song to me!
and YES! I always think that their songs are much better in live than in studio recorder. They are amazing!!
BTS really shines when they perform live. As great as the studio versions are, their lives are almost always better. Their energy and joy while performing just really brings something extra to their performances. :)
V's voice is so deep and soulful i just love it
he can also get high notes
@@rengina484 of course, that's part of why he's my bias XD his voice is just so beautiful
U should react to JIMIN's song LIE, or SERENDIPITY. JUNGKOOK's song EUPHORIA. V's song SINGULARITY. And JIN's song EPIPHANY.
U will definitely be able to tell the difference of their vocals from each one of these songs. So please check them out
jimin lie is legend
@@rengina484 Agreed!
I always prefer the live version, even if they make some mistakes, you can feel the emotion they put in the song, for me it's worth it because usually that improves the performance a lot. My opinion, I'm not an expert lol💜
Yes 💜
I wholeheartedly agree!
3:07 i don't know if someone said this already, but the one who harmonises (with the lower voice) is j-hope. he's one of the rappers of the group :)
Thanks for the info! :)
I always prefer live version of bts. Rap and vocal line sounds much better live, the emotions are diferent than the studio version
yep, agree
This song is based on the psychological principles of the “Magic shop”. It is based up on the book called “Into the Magic Shop” by James R.Doty. I suggest you read that to understand the meaning on a deeper level. BTS songs are deep and contains many psychological references. There is a whole series that covers the philosophies of the psychologist Carl Jung.
JUNGKOOK IS SO TALENTED this song is one of the best song ever exist on..
Appreciate all the extra effort and detail you put into this. Even the cute part at the end, the way you edited in comments you hadn't said out piud at the time for us to read and notice. Looking forward to more videos from you, thank you!
Thank you for the appreciation! 🙂
Personally i prefer live versions because they're singing live so there's no autotune and they're killing it!
Well, magic shop is a really healing song for me. It's about finding a place where you can feel alright and heal your inner conflicts within yourself. And i love the love version too🥺💜
jungkook’s vocals never fail to deliver 🤧
I love their studio music, but I almost always prefer their live versions. I think sometimes the studio versions have too much "polish" or special effects, and sometimes take away from their voices. They all sound so wonderful and sometimes I don't understand why they don't highlight it more. Like with their newest song Dynamite, the studio version is a bop and gets me dancing every time I listen to it, but when I watched them perform it live at the VMAs, they blew me out of the water with how good they sounded, and you could actually hear the vocals of the members Jin and V better in the live version. So while ARMY love the studio versions, in my experience, a LOT of us prefer the live versions.
this song was written by the youngest member, jungkook, and it was about ARMY, their fans. the magic shop it's supposed to be the place where you can exchange something that brings you sadness to something that will bring you joy so when they sing that we're gonna open a door in our hearts and they'll be there is because we as fans allowed them to live in our hearts and they're prepared to help us to get over bad stuff in our lives. also when they sing "you gave me the best of me so you'll give you the best of you" it's something like "you were able to help us become who we are now, you helped to find the best of us so you're able to do that to yourself as well". it's a really deep song about the bond between BTS and ARMY 💜 btw thank you SO MUCH for this reaction!!! I'll make sure to check more of your videos!
He co wrote, he did not wrote it
@@beany1944 Get a life my dear
@@Marta-rz7iq i think you must get one you are really misinformed and rude to the core.
i think this is the first time i see a vocal coach (or anyone really) who does a lil research on them, listens to the studio version and then the live version, and only then gives an honest opinion on it, really cool thanks 👍🏻 no one expects people to know their names or recognise their voices when you've never heard a bts song before, of course, so i think it's cool that you took the time to look them up 👍🏻
Thank you for the nice comment, Andra. I'm glad you appreciate it. Make sure to check out my vocal tips in case you sing too. ✌️
There are 4 vocalists (Jungkook, Jimin,V & Jin) 3 rappers (RM, Suga & J-Hope). IMO they sing/rap better live than studio.
For the vocal line ck out- house of cards, the truth untold, dimple.
For a rap, ck out- outro: tear, cypher 3, cypher 4, ddaeng
Oh and they have solos and mixtapes too.
magic shop is based in the book ‘into the magic shop’ is a book written by a neurosurgeon that focus on a little boy that has a lot of family problems and he finds a lady on the magic shop that teaches him how to deal with his feelings, how to relax, meditate and more, making the magic shop feel like a place of comfort for him (BTS also talks about it in the song) a really good book, no wonder BTS got inspired by it.
When he replayed *J-Hope's* part I cried cause finally someone recognised how amazing *J-Hope's* voice is 😌😭 and *V* doing the bridge is so emotional, I love it and it never fails to make me tear up 😭😭. The live versions are always better than the studio versions 💯💜
I listen to their lives more than their studio versions. They're brilliant. Created to perform. GOAT.
Interesting style of video reaction here.
One thing I want to say that keep in mind, that these guys are dancing very difficult choreos sooo much on their concerts. So their voice can be unstable. But this song in particular very calm. Still even though they are dancing and singing at the same time they are doing it really great compare it to many other western artists. They've gone through so much tough training to be able to do that. Bc in Korea industry they dance so much while performing. Almost 6 years ago when I found out about them for the first time I was really impressed and even now I'm still impressed every time. I can see their improvements. They are really great singers, rappers and performers. 🙏🏻🖤
Please react to 'BTS Jimin best live high note and raspy vocal compilation' by Jem
I really enjoy vocal coach reactions to BT and I enjoyed yours. I'm looking forward to more. I liked how you wrote comments in post and revisited parts of the song relistening and also comparing between live and studio versions. I think you had a good mix of technical comments on the different vocal types also. High five :)
Thank you so much, "Meh" 😀🙌
Thank you for your reaction! I am very glad that you are a serious young man, it is nice to see your room without children's toys and other nonsense. You were commenting essentially without raising your voice. I really liked it!!!
React to jimin high notes
I like all their MVs but seeing them doing live..its real pleasure..and watch their concert with armys ,goosebump all over my body..
I love ot7 but Jin Jimin Jungkook Hi's voice my goodness i love the mix voice and vocal His have amazing voice good job in every song's i love this voice's ❤❤
BTS is unique in that they have a number of songs written specifically for their fans. Basically love songs from BTS to ARMY, their fan group. BTS plays to audiences in sold out stadiums that hold 60,000 to 90,000 people and with the stadium being dark and the fans waiving their light sticks, the fans look a lot like stars in the night sky. Because of that, there are a lot of references to stars, lights, and galaxies in BTS' songs for ARMY. BTS struggled a lot in their careers, especially in the beginning, and they credit ARMY for giving them the strength to overcome everything that they went through. BTS will literally push themselves to collapsing, performing on stage for ARMY and ARMY has been known to do some pretty awesome stuff in the name of BTS, too.This song is about that relationship, between BTS and ARMY. The "Magic Shop" is an actual psychological technique where you trade negative things for positive and that's what BTS is saying they'll help ARMY do. Turn the negative into positive. The thing is, they actually do just that for their fans.
Oh wow! I am so happy that you chose "Magic Shop". Usually new reactors stick to Bangtan's title tracks to react to. I personally love this song and was thrilled that someone decided to give it a listen. 💜
I love BTS live preformances there are always so many adlibs they just throw in and they will feed off the fans and lets join in with the refrains, fan chants etc etc.
They are a whole new level live. They give you so much energy. And we haven't even talked about the message of their songs yet.
Thank you for the review. Magic shop is my favorite song from bts. But the live version from their concert is more beautiful. They are not doing the lip sync.
I like how you pause and compare to the studio version ^^,
I love this so song much it means a lot to me. It has helped me through personal hardships. When I doubt myself I find myself listening to this song. It comforts me and also gives me strength to pull myself out of whatever situation I find myself in. I love them so much my heart could shatter into millions of pieces.
Also could you react to Ken(Vixx)- Its only my world @duet song festival? No vocal coach reacts to this one but in my opinion it’s worth to watch because Ken and Sangyeop are doing an incredible job. If you don’t it’s okay but I like your reaction and your attention to detail.
believe me, it's not just me but you asked which one we prefer, being there yourself is the best, of course not everyone gets to even if they want to, but when you are surrounded by so many people, it just makes you emotional and it's just so magical, i didn't expect it but when they started singing and when it came to fanchant parts i fricking cried so hard, i can't describe it any other way then magical, truly.
The singing guru Gideon. He’s the best vocal coach out there. I’m on my second 10 lesson’s soon with this guy,and what a great journey it’s been.
Honored to help you out! 🤘
I’m A.R.M.Y. but being retired (I’m 66), and from a very small town, I’ve never had the chance to see them live (yet!), but I’ve heard them talk about how much strength and energy they get from being able to look into the eyes of their fans and see the love there, and how much that means to them because they genuinely love us, too. That’s why the live versions are better. The direct contact between us empowers them strongly.
The live versions always bring tears to my eyes
V's Live Vocal it's more amazing than studio version in every songs actually...
Thank you for that reaction
Thank you for watching! 😊
At this concert, they sang Magic Shop right after IDOL which is super intense with really difficult choreography, so at the beginning of this song they were still a little out of breath from the previous performance...and they still did a phenomenal job!
Jungkook sing exactly like the studio version..he is incredibly stable and he eat cd everyday...thanks for the reaction...
best jimin's voice
This is about Jungkook.... but not disagreeing
Bts are best live trust me I have been to their concert they are the best performers on this planet they have a huge discography keep reacting Fyi they write and produce there own music with beautiful lyrics this one is done by jk sometime they do use us writer just to covert the language otherwise they are always involved in their songs I highly recommend THIS IS BTS by xceleste before any other reaction you might get knows a lot about their music and how it came to be MUST WATCH
Please reaction to jimin high note...
Besides having God given talent...of course they have to practice even if takes a hundred times. The best about BTS is how they persistently & consistently work hard in their craft. So they can give great performances for us.
Oh~ That's a very interesting reaction~ If you like Magic Shop then you'll also like The truth untold by the vocal line (Jin, Jimin, V and Jungkook)
They always rise to the occasion and excede themselves when they sing live.
Magic Shop is a song by BTS dedicated to their fans, the ARMYs, and serves to tell us they will forever be with us.💜Magic shop is a place where your fears are exchanged for happiness💜A song made for fans by the youngest member of BTS, Jungkook. He expressed that they would feel very happy if fans can find comfort through this song when they’re struggling, tired & in pain.💜
honestly I can't end the song without crying, they mean so much to me even though they don't know me.. they make me feel better about myself when I'm down and they're really the best people I've ever listened to..
The lyrics of this song are always so emotional no matter how many times I hear it. 💜
If you want to hear more of their individual voices, they all have solo songs in the Wings album, the Love Yourself trilogy and the Map Of The Soul albums. 3 songs for each member in total
Thank you so much for react to our boys! And was a really interesting video, i hope we can see it more bts in your channel!
There were probably around 60,000-75,000 people at that concert. I've seen them sing this live at a different concert and it was so incredibly beautiful and touching. Thanks for the great analysis :)
Yes live version! Not sure if somebody already said, this was in one of their concerts in japan..
This song always bring me back to their concert and idk why but my eyes always get watery
yeah they're doing so good in their live performance and they're not lipsyncing and also they're perform many songs and still sounds great.
Omg I really enjoyed watching your reaction video !! I mean, you know lots of people make reaction content about BTS, then write a title with, "Vocal Coach React BTS bah blah blah," but in reality the content of the content is not much different from the usual reaction content. But you are different, you really explained the singing technique that BTS uses in the 'Magic Shop' 🥺 Thank you for your hard work😭😭
Great reaction, it's the first time i watch a reactor really compare the studio and the live version, and of course we prefer live than studio one because this boys are better live, try "Your Eyes Tell", it's also wrote and produced by the same member, our JK.. plis continue to listen to our boys, we purple you.....
Glad you liked it! 🙂
Jk did not produce YET. Gustav Mared was the producer.
@@sariel8406 he was a composer for the song
I am infatuated with the parts of Jimin every time. Anyway, all seven are one, I love
"Magic Shop is a song by BTS dedicated to their fans, the ARMYs, and serves to tell us they will forever be with us."
These mega talented young men even sing live during their fast and complex choreography. They train for breath control by singing while running on a treadmill.
This was cool to compare the live to the recording. They are so similar 🤩Our guys are super professional. That is why they are #1 right now. They love what they do. 🤗🥰💜
You are so chill and calm idk i love it. 💖💖 Nice video 🌺✨
Jimin's voica is amazing and beautiful high note！
the lyrics to magic shop hits me the most because whenever i feel down or in a bad mood this is a song i would play and while thinking about it again i try my beat to do the things i can
I like how you end the video... Hahahaha
Thanks for the reaction, so much information that helps me a lot.
Thank you, Chester! 😁
Their performance always makes songs better live. Their interaction with their audience is unmatched and very personal and often emotional.
Such a good song! Also loving the reactions to their concert videos!!
Thank you so much ! I loved it so much and smiled too ! Hello from a french 55 years old BTS fan ! 💜
Jimin singing... coaches be like "who's that guy"
me: that's high notes King, our BABY MOCHI
The song is a relaxing song. The song talk about don't be worried, just leave everything behind. Sit down, having a cup of tea in this "Magic shop".