I think Jake's story is interesting and hope they don't screw up the big reveal of what he did, if we ever see it. I think it's obvious that Cole killed home girl in jail. I don't think anything happened to Bronwyn I think it's just a tease to keep us guessing. Perhaps there was some kind of altercation that caused her necklace to fall off. And it looks really clean so it's safe to assume it's not her blood. There are always multiple suspects involved. I wonder if Simon is really dead because he's the only one whose body we never saw.
Also Keelys ex (forgot his name) said he would take care of Cooper and in the ending scene in the school when it was graduation and we saw coopers trophy on the floor with blood on it. It could be connected
Dude FIONA ADMITTED SHE KILLED GISELLE? She was finding too much out and was about to mess up her plan?? That’s why Fiona tried to get rid of her by paying her first
Too obvious now. They had their chance to make her the villain, it would be silly if they keep pulling uno reverse cards with the same character that's just my opinion.
Honestly, I was mad at her for tipping Fiona off but I also felt bad for her at the same time because she saved them by letting TJ rot in jail. Although, I’m really hoping Addy and TJ actually get together.
Did anyone else think the possible people hurt are either Bronwyn or Cooper. Bronwyn cause of the necklace but Cooper because of the smashed trophy case and bloody trophy, which could have been alluding to Cooper since he was the athletic one or the "jock"
I totally agree! But who says it’s someone from the murder club who gets hurt? After all they want to make them suffer killing rojas sister after she refused to forgive her would make more sense framing them again??? Maybe????
@@novafox1986 Maybe the crime was to frames Nate, and makes that he rots in jail, planned possibly by Maeve, out of spite the Murder club and her sister.
@@giovanni6174 Maybe. Nevertheless, i still think that the fact that the Murder club expelled Maeve from their group for good in the end of Season 2, could has consequences for them, like that Maeve could be somehow involved with the crime, like that she has some knownledge about it. But as result of the outcome of Season 2, Maeve could simply refuses to helps the Murder club anymore, out of spite them, making their situation more harder than in the previous Seasons, in that Maeve helped them notably.
2:49 I really hope it isn't maeve / maeve would never be a antagonist in this show but, she does seem very fitting to be one. Treated unfairly, very very smart, morale compass may not be the strongest. But also she has the most reasons not to do so as her girlfriend and sister are both in the murder club
If Maeve was the responsible from this, maybe she only caused this crime to frames Nate as murderer and makes that he rots in jail, as payback against her sister, and out of spite the Murder club.
@@amara920 Meave was annoying as hell. I agree not everyone should hate her like that because she did save all of their lives but Bronwyn has every right to react that way. Knowing your own sister could manipulate and trick you to the extent that a psychopath can is scary. We can see that Addy seems like she forgave Meave but we didn't see her reach out to her at the end of season 2. She def has the potential to be the antagonist if everyone is still ostracising her.
I feel like Bronwyn's necklace might have been planted there, maybe to set her up as the culprit of a crime... I really want to find out what Jake did to get into rehab though, and also AAAAAAAA, Bronwyn X Nate forever, please don't let Bronwyn be dead or something
This is a spoiler alert....but in the 3rd book by Karen, we learn Jake killed his biological father and Simon knew it. Jake HAD to co-operate with Simon's plan bcz Simon would otherwise reveal it.
They should make the S3 ASAP omg wtf is Jake's secret gd. Not surprised when I saw the yellow tape. But literally stood up when I saw Bronwyn's necklace like nononono fk no.
I think that Jake killed someone or was molested as a kid, I suspect he was molested by someone from his own family like his father, grandpa or even his brother.
@@GiGiLGS I don't think he was molested by his brother, because is he was, then Cole would have been dead already. But its obvious the secret is really bad and it may involve his brother.
Remember what jake told fiona before he told fiona his secret. 'This secret you are going to have to take to your grave.' And boom fionas dead. So only 3 or possibly 4 people know about jakes secret: Jake (himself), Cole (his brother), Fiona and his mother. Which of them are dead? Fiona and Jake. His mother hasn't really been involved so that leaves us with Cole. And cole just found out that fiona knew, so unless he could orchestrate something quite quickly to poison fiona then someone else must know jakes secret. Or cole could have got her poisoned, because he wanted revenge for jake and was already convinced fiona killed jake before he met with fiona.
@ashishmj230 thats why jake didn't go with simon's original plan. Which probably just mean to get them all a "attempt to murder case". But jake got rid of all the epipens. For simon to die. He got rid of simon to keep his secret safe
I agree with alot of your ideas but you forgot to mention Zach also has a vendetta and the girl that found out Cooper lied to her also now has a problem with him and didn't want to help them.
Am i the only one who thinks simon is alive? They never showed a body and Simon would never be that stupid to trust a friend that completely left him especially bcs he was so smart (getting peoples secrects) comment bellow if u agree
I think that this would be kinda stupid, his supposed comeback would take off much stuff off Janae's and maybe even Maeve's character work. A big part of Janae's character is her guilt and denial over Simon's death, something that she didn't really got time to work on. Also, from a 'adaptation point of view' that would break the original concept of the story, since the most intriguing aspect of the book was Simon killed himself, but even after death could control everything around Bayview. If he's actually alive then the point of the first season just gets crashed (even tho the series didn't really adapted this characteristic of the story, or atleast didn't give it enough focus).
- i don’t think bronwyn will be hurt, because it would be too obvious and she was the one that got hurt this season. maybe she and nate had a fight and she gave the necklace back to him, so he’s the one that’ll get hurt. that said, all of our theories are kinda irrelevant because the show runners (i believe it was erica saleh) literally said they don’t know yet what’s going to happen and they just wanted to write an ending that’s shocking and gripping, so… - for some reason i suspect wheeler to be involved somehow.
Perhaps the crime was planned by Maeve, to frames Nate as murderer and makes that he was arrested, as way to punishes Bronwyn by the outcome of the Season 2.
i’m thinking about the final scene, maybe somebody from the bayview 4 will be missing which explains why the police were taking samples of the blood on the floor. from the scene itself it does not look like a body was there, instead the blood was just scattered..? 🤔 Cole may have also a part as to why Jake was in rehab, when he knew Fiona knew about it - fiona was then killed. that’s why he didn’t tell the police about it. he’s a prime suspect for this i think…
I don’t think rojas is hurt I think she’s a prime suspect in whoever has died because there’s no blood on the necklace somebody may have snapped it from her neck!!!
True, and if someone was going to hurt her why would they take the necklace off (cuz that means they would have had to touch it and then that would leave their finger prints on the necklace)
@@lollipoplola8350 exactly it would make more sense for a fight to happen and rojas get caught in the middle of it causing her necklace to fall off, then someone loosing their temper and lashing out hurting a fellow student when failing to hurt rojas 🤷🏻♀️
I think that Evan, Zack, and Keely are definitely going to return as well. Evan may end up getting in a committed relationship with Vanessa. Plus, I’m if correct, he applied to Yale like Bronwyn did so we may see something about whether or not he got accepted. Zack said that he got “better plans for Cooper Clay”, and I believe that he may know even more about the night that Jake got k!lled. Keely used to date both Zack and Cooper and she goes to Bayview High so I expect to see her as well.
I strongly believe Murder Club will escape death again. They’ve done it twice, why can’t they do it a third time? Plus, I think Bronwyn’s necklace fell off and she left it at the school for the police to find. Besides, they main protagonists never die.
bro tokyo…. the MAIN MAIN character it seems like she died to me how can her necklace fall in movies protagonists rarely died but thats not true abt series especially when there are 5 protagonists
I just finished the season 2 and I want ses 3 imeadiatly bc I love this serial. I love Nate and Rojas’s relationship but rojas is hurt and I hope si will be not dead in season 3 . I’d be miss her
I don't know why but i feel that Simon is alive. We never saw his body and we was rich and influent because of his mother. I think he realize about the jake's real plan and decidid to fake his own death. After he wakes in the hospital he payed the doctors to say everyone he was dead, and in the morgue he payed the workers to do a fake autopsy, and after that he used his family's money to keep hidden in the City. He could return at season 3
I had the same theory that Simon never died.. And as he knew everyone's secret he might as well know why jake was at the rehabilitation centre.. But idk they didn't show him S2 . Dk much about him returning in S3
I think this is all a bit complicated. Simon says is used by two people. Once by Fiona and once by Simon himself, but Fiona doesn't know that. As for Jake's Secret: Jake is portrayed as a sick sociopath all the time, but I don't think that's true. I think Simon is the sick sociopath and Jake going into therapy has something to do with Simon; I think he was blackmailed into something by Simon and took responsibility for something that Simon did. (That's what Jake told Fiona too, and that's why she had to die). But when Jake witnessed Simon beating up Fiona, he promised her he would get his just punishment and so he decided to kill him. The bad thing is that Simon knew it and I say he's not dead. You see him in the cinema on the big screen and it wasn't Fiona because I don't think she knows anything about it; She doesn't generally have anything to do with blackmailing the four with messages, she only wanted the one who shot Jake. Unfortunately, it wasn't Addy at all, but Simon, who was standing somewhere in the woods in the background. Giselle came into play because she saw Vanessa's post, because she was just a crazy staker. And Giselle was also killed by Simon because she was dangerous to him; after all, she too was in therapy with Jake and didn't know if she might know his secret, too. And I think the prom victim is Principal Gupta. She was writing a book about the incidents and may have found something that prompted Simon to kill her too.
So are we just going to ignore the fact that when Cole asked Cooper to take off his watch, Simon Says didn't get mad? And Fiona received the tip about almost being found out AFTER Vanessa confronted Cole about Jake being at rehab. Maeve could've tipped off Fiona the soonest they found out thag Fiona and Jake met at rehab but she didn't.
As much as I don't want it to be, I think Maeve should be the next antagonist, or at least play a part of it. I dunno, the sister vs sister thing between her and bronwyn is getting boring for me so I just hope she gets a better storyline. I won't count TJ as a potential antagonist, he's just not too smart to be. Cole is the most likely to be as of now. I hope we get to see more Vanessa tho. Her episode did a good job making her a bit more likeable.
As theory regarding the Season 3, maybe was Maeve the responsible from the crime in the end of the Season 2, out of spite the Murder club for treated her badly, despite of that she was whom saved them from jail. And regarding to others reasons to became an antagonist, maybe Maeve could start to think that the Murder club were the culprits from "corrupted" her sister Bronwyn, particulary Nate, to considers that Bronwyn started to showcase a more criminal side since that she started to hang with him, making that Maeve chose to planned a way to makes that her sister ended separated from Nate, and to accomplishes this, Maeve could plan to commit a murder and pinned this to Nate. And regarding the crime itself, maybe Maeve killed Vanessa, as she could be the perfect victim to frames him, to considers that Vanessa knows a lot information about the Murder club, giving a reason to Nate to kills her, especially to considers his criminal past. Adding that Maeve could want to get rid her to prevent that Vanessa can exposes her framing. And regarding some evidence, like the collar, maybe Maeve could plans a way to that Nate get the collar from Bronwyn during the graduation, and that many people can see this detail, to makes them witnesses, and after that Vanessa be killed, Maeve could snatches the collar from Nate, and planted it in the crime scene, to frames Nate as the murderer, and makes that he rots in jail, out of spite the Murder club for treated her badly, and out of spite her sister, as payback for be ungrateful with her support previously. At least as theory.
I think a suspect can be the guy who Vanessa is hooking up with. He had more screen time towards the end but didn't really have a plot on his own. Also he wanted to have burgers with Vanessa after the interview, maybe he would have kidnapped her then as revenge for going through with the interview
Makes sense, especially the way he ran afterwards, and the look on his face like oh shit they took her!, plus the message he sent was like, where are you more than “leave her alone” makes lots of sense!
I was reading through the comments and found a few good theories. Though peacock said s3 was being cancelled I still have a theory of my own. Zach said that “Cooper has something coming”, the blood on the trophy may represent Cooper as the jock and how great he was to Bayview. But I think zach may of hurt or killed Cooper because of the last scene of s3. We did see Bronwyns necklace that she received from Nate in the last episode in a puddle of blood. I may think Bronwyn was included in maybe because she saw what happened to Cooper, resulting in her getting hurt. I wish s3 was coming out!
I SWEAR IF NATE AND BRONWYN ARE NOT TOGETHER OR ONE OF THEM IS DEAD IM DELETING NETFLIX AND IF ROHAS DOESNT FORGIVE HER SIS AND MAKE HER A PART OF THE CLUB I WILL FOR REAL UNSUBSCRIBE
I wonder if there would be a way that this major bloody event actually frames the murder club and they have to go on the run. Bronwyn's necklace maybe fell off in the struggle or the new villain planted it. Maybe other evidence is planted to frame the others. And the real perpetrator (or maybe a group) wore masks. Like, what if Jake had a whole crew at rehab? On a side note, I would also love for Addy and Janae to be a thing. I really loved Janae and Maeve together, but damn. Addy and Janae have chemistry. I also think next season will be Maeve and the murder club working on getting back on good terms. She's a genius who's plan worked, but I get that so many things could have gone wrong. Addy, Cooper, AND Bronwyn almost died.
Okay here me out, the main suspect is probably gonna be a character we don't know yet. This character has something to do with both Simon and the reason why Jake went into rehab. This new character will be introduced with information that will come from Cole. But who's dead? Well What I believe is that the whole murderclub survived and that the neckless just might have fell off Bronwyns neck or anything like that. It wouldn't make sense for the show to make an end to the main protagonist(s). One thing is sure, somwbody died at the graduation. And I think it could be some of the side characters.. Like Keely and Evan. I believe Maeve and Kris are too important side characters to come to an end like this. We know that the real Simon Says is still alive. How do we know? Well, in EP 7 we see Fiona receiving a text from somebody which we don't have an idea who that would be. What we do know is that this person is afraid to get exposed by murderclub so he sends Fiona on a mission to make murderclub think she's Simon Says. My own conspiracy: Simon is still alive and his body is nowhere in his grave. He's the actual Simon Says. Let me know your thoughts on this please!
I definitely think Simon is still alive. I was waiting for him to come back towards the end of the season (thinking he is Simon says) but it didn’t happen. Maybe season 3 🤷🏾♀️
I was thinking Simon's alive too! Because in the book, it was really Simon that killed himself and blamed his death on the Bayview 4. Although the book was all in season 1 already, we never know. They could come up with more shocking twists
Yeah...i found it odd when they showed her in the 1st episode of S1 and never showed her again the season... When she was back in s2...as a more screen time character... I knew something was fishy... They just didn’t introduced a girl who stabbed her teacher and then never talked about it again...
Guys ! Omg listen i know who the suspects it is maeve whonwe know and the other is kris . Do u remember in last episode of s2 Fiona was talking to nate about how she could have also played with maeve and kris.
Also we can suspect kris bcoz he had the costume from the Halloween night and when Addy ig asked kris he said he burned them, but it might have been a lie coz he might have given it to fiona
Maybe Jake killed his dad and Cole doesn't want anyone to know , glad Fiona is dead can't believe waited for so long just to find out she was Simon says that's lame hahahha
I hope Janae and Maeve work through there crap bc in my opinion they are sooo cute together and they are my fav couple and I hope brodwin (sorry don’t know how to spell it) doesn’t die
@@kirankohli4381 I'm sure Bronwyn is more of a suspect than victim here really. Because she was still very relevant in s2, so I don't think they'll make the decision to move away from her for now, and there's also no other prominent character that would be fitting to take the lead role after Bronwyn. Maybe maeve but maeve would fit the antagonist more
@@xsomili5501 I wishhh but the nerdy trophy was covered with blood and so was the Nate's gifted necklace ..... ''Stay'' and I dont think being a suspect she will leave all that there bcs anyone of the murder club members would obviously have seen it other wise if not....maeve then......
Lots are saying Rojas killed someone’s but she’s smart she wouldn’t leave evidence such as a necklace and blood and she’s too sweet to murder but I think she’s dead I hope not as I loved her character and if she is I’m suing Netflix 😭
The process of making that happen would turn this show into something resembling a straight up comic book story. His whole family, the police, the hospital and the media would have to be in on it and he would have to be brainiac level smart and have a plan and motive as intricate and cunning as darth sidious. Its just too unrealistic for this show.
duz any1 else have their conscious villian in s3 being either bronwyn or nate? btw addy n jenae were pretty sus 4 me half of s2 so im keeping my gut on them
Am I the only one who thought "Good that the bitch's dead" at the end? XD I really don't like Bronwyn's character in the series, even more after seeing her attitude towards Maeve.
@@BrainPilot But if something happens to her younger sister, all she thinks about is how she could've prevent it from happening. I believe that's responsibility for her sister.
@@Jaaman54 yeah her sister did something SO RECKLESS. I would react the same way as Bronwyn and I like her the best. I do think the others should forgive her though but Bronwyn can take a whole year to forgive her or something like that
Honestly mave is annoying she should stay in her place tired of her always wining and crying to be part of the group obviously she not part and it should stay like that
What do you think is going to happen in One Of Us Is Lying Season 3? Comment your thoughts below!
I think they are going to take a long time to learn to trust Maeve again. (I think they should forgive her, she ment well.)
I think Jake's story is interesting and hope they don't screw up the big reveal of what he did, if we ever see it. I think it's obvious that Cole killed home girl in jail.
I don't think anything happened to Bronwyn I think it's just a tease to keep us guessing. Perhaps there was some kind of altercation that caused her necklace to fall off. And it looks really clean so it's safe to assume it's not her blood. There are always multiple suspects involved.
I wonder if Simon is really dead because he's the only one whose body we never saw.
Also Keelys ex (forgot his name) said he would take care of Cooper and in the ending scene in the school when it was graduation and we saw coopers trophy on the floor with blood on it. It could be connected
1. Who killed giselle and fiona
2. Secret of jake
3. Cole (bro of jake) is hiding something.
4. Ex boyfriend of keeley is also a suspect
Dude FIONA ADMITTED SHE KILLED GISELLE? She was finding too much out and was about to mess up her plan?? That’s why Fiona tried to get rid of her by paying her first
Cooper’s dad and Addy’s mom are probably dating, they are getting ready to go on a date on the same day
Yeah it does seem like that!
I said the same thing.
@@honeybrookadook9345 woahhh I didn't realize but you're probably right. That's actually pretty cool. Cooper and Addy gonna be step siblings
Fr
I feel bad for Maeve. After everything the group still leaves her out of everything. It would be nice to see her be a villain next season
Too obvious now. They had their chance to make her the villain, it would be silly if they keep pulling uno reverse cards with the same character that's just my opinion.
She deserves much more....btr ....she is d technical brain of d group 👍
Honestly, I was mad at her for tipping Fiona off but I also felt bad for her at the same time because she saved them by letting TJ rot in jail. Although, I’m really hoping Addy and TJ actually get together.
Maeve deserves better
Did anyone else think the possible people hurt are either Bronwyn or Cooper. Bronwyn cause of the necklace but Cooper because of the smashed trophy case and bloody trophy, which could have been alluding to Cooper since he was the athletic one or the "jock"
I totally agree! But who says it’s someone from the murder club who gets hurt? After all they want to make them suffer killing rojas sister after she refused to forgive her would make more sense framing them again??? Maybe????
or maybe the trophy is the murder weapon
@@novafox1986 Maybe the crime was to frames Nate, and makes that he rots in jail, planned possibly by Maeve, out of spite the Murder club and her sister.
Completely disagree, I think the writers are smarter than that
@@giovanni6174 Maybe. Nevertheless, i still think that the fact that the Murder club expelled Maeve from their group for good in the end of Season 2, could has consequences for them, like that Maeve could be somehow involved with the crime, like that she has some knownledge about it. But as result of the outcome of Season 2, Maeve could simply refuses to helps the Murder club anymore, out of spite them, making their situation more harder than in the previous Seasons, in that Maeve helped them notably.
BRO IF ROJAS DEAD, I WILL UNSUB MY NETFLIX
On god. Everyone is saying she killed someone but I think she is dead
SAME OMG THAT NECKLACE GAVE ME CHILLS
Me too 😭 but she's main character , hope someone just set a trap for her
Same😭😭😭 because no!!!!
@@hamishmathison1231 she better not be fucking dead omg
2:49 I really hope it isn't maeve / maeve would never be a antagonist in this show but, she does seem very fitting to be one. Treated unfairly, very very smart, morale compass may not be the strongest. But also she has the most reasons not to do so as her girlfriend and sister are both in the murder club
I don't think she has girlfriend anymore. And her sister really treated her very badly throughout s2.
If Maeve was the responsible from this, maybe she only caused this crime to frames Nate as murderer and makes that he rots in jail, as payback against her sister, and out of spite the Murder club.
@@amara920 Meave was annoying as hell. I agree not everyone should hate her like that because she did save all of their lives but Bronwyn has every right to react that way. Knowing your own sister could manipulate and trick you to the extent that a psychopath can is scary. We can see that Addy seems like she forgave Meave but we didn't see her reach out to her at the end of season 2. She def has the potential to be the antagonist if everyone is still ostracising her.
@@josecuestas7246 I feel like she could be that petty
I feel like Bronwyn's necklace might have been planted there, maybe to set her up as the culprit of a crime... I really want to find out what Jake did to get into rehab though, and also AAAAAAAA, Bronwyn X Nate forever, please don't let Bronwyn be dead or something
This is a spoiler alert....but in the 3rd book by Karen, we learn Jake killed his biological father and Simon knew it. Jake HAD to co-operate with Simon's plan bcz Simon would otherwise reveal it.
@@afrinatasneem375 thank you you are one of the only people that read the books they are so good
@@sophietrimdewd i dont have time to finish the books but does it say in the book that who was killed at the end and how was fiona killed?!
5:32 the second season was definitely much better, I agree
Glad you agree!
They should make the S3 ASAP omg wtf is Jake's secret gd. Not surprised when I saw the yellow tape. But literally stood up when I saw Bronwyn's necklace like nononono fk no.
I think that Jake killed someone or was molested as a kid, I suspect he was molested by someone from his own family like his father, grandpa or even his brother.
@@GiGiLGS I don't think he was molested by his brother, because is he was, then Cole would have been dead already. But its obvious the secret is really bad and it may involve his brother.
Dude Bronwyn's an absolute tank. I don't think anyone can kill her 😂
could brownyn be dead...
Unfortunately everyone is lying is cancelled
I just finished the series and I’m so mad that there’s no season 3! Netflix or another company better make one as I’m desperate!
Same here
@@ellagrace9544 why was it canceled? Any idea?
@@raiman11low ratings is what was said
Remember what jake told fiona before he told fiona his secret. 'This secret you are going to have to take to your grave.' And boom fionas dead. So only 3 or possibly 4 people know about jakes secret: Jake (himself), Cole (his brother), Fiona and his mother. Which of them are dead? Fiona and Jake. His mother hasn't really been involved so that leaves us with Cole. And cole just found out that fiona knew, so unless he could orchestrate something quite quickly to poison fiona then someone else must know jakes secret. Or cole could have got her poisoned, because he wanted revenge for jake and was already convinced fiona killed jake before he met with fiona.
I think simon also knew jake's secret
@@pinkkittycornnessa7181 yea thats true
@ashishmj230 thats why jake didn't go with simon's original plan. Which probably just mean to get them all a "attempt to murder case". But jake got rid of all the epipens. For simon to die. He got rid of simon to keep his secret safe
I agree with alot of your ideas but you forgot to mention Zach also has a vendetta and the girl that found out Cooper lied to her also now has a problem with him and didn't want to help them.
Keely is the girls name
Who’s Zach?
Am i the only one who thinks simon is alive? They never showed a body and Simon would never be that stupid to trust a friend that completely left him especially bcs he was so smart (getting peoples secrects) comment bellow if u agree
I think that this would be kinda stupid, his supposed comeback would take off much stuff off Janae's and maybe even Maeve's character work. A big part of Janae's character is her guilt and denial over Simon's death, something that she didn't really got time to work on.
Also, from a 'adaptation point of view' that would break the original concept of the story, since the most intriguing aspect of the book was Simon killed himself, but even after death could control everything around Bayview. If he's actually alive then the point of the first season just gets crashed (even tho the series didn't really adapted this characteristic of the story, or atleast didn't give it enough focus).
I also think his still alive, because he not that dull not to have a backup plan
- i don’t think bronwyn will be hurt, because it would be too obvious and she was the one that got hurt this season. maybe she and nate had a fight and she gave the necklace back to him, so he’s the one that’ll get hurt. that said, all of our theories are kinda irrelevant because the show runners (i believe it was erica saleh) literally said they don’t know yet what’s going to happen and they just wanted to write an ending that’s shocking and gripping, so…
- for some reason i suspect wheeler to be involved somehow.
Perhaps the crime was planned by Maeve, to frames Nate as murderer and makes that he was arrested, as way to punishes Bronwyn by the outcome of the Season 2.
i’m thinking about the final scene, maybe somebody from the bayview 4 will be missing which explains why the police were taking samples of the blood on the floor. from the scene itself it does not look like a body was there, instead the blood was just scattered..? 🤔
Cole may have also a part as to why Jake was in rehab, when he knew Fiona knew about it - fiona was then killed. that’s why he didn’t tell the police about it. he’s a prime suspect for this i think…
Very good point
I don’t think rojas is hurt I think she’s a prime suspect in whoever has died because there’s no blood on the necklace somebody may have snapped it from her neck!!!
True, and if someone was going to hurt her why would they take the necklace off (cuz that means they would have had to touch it and then that would leave their finger prints on the necklace)
@@lollipoplola8350 exactly it would make more sense for a fight to happen and rojas get caught in the middle of it causing her necklace to fall off, then someone loosing their temper and lashing out hurting a fellow student when failing to hurt rojas 🤷🏻♀️
@@novafox1986 I agree ☝🏻
I think that Evan, Zack, and Keely are definitely going to return as well. Evan may end up getting in a committed relationship with Vanessa. Plus, I’m if correct, he applied to Yale like Bronwyn did so we may see something about whether or not he got accepted.
Zack said that he got “better plans for Cooper Clay”, and I believe that he may know even more about the night that Jake got k!lled.
Keely used to date both Zack and Cooper and she goes to Bayview High so I expect to see her as well.
our theories are perfectly the same
I strongly believe Murder Club will escape death again. They’ve done it twice, why can’t they do it a third time? Plus, I think Bronwyn’s necklace fell off and she left it at the school for the police to find. Besides, they main protagonists never die.
Walking dead
@@saurabhsuralkar8496 I don’t watch walking dead, but I do know it has deaths.
Elite season5...the main protagonist died
I just pray Bronwyn is okay
bro tokyo…. the MAIN MAIN character it seems like she died to me how can her necklace fall in movies protagonists rarely died but thats not true abt series especially when there are 5 protagonists
I just finished the season 2 and I want ses 3 imeadiatly bc I love this serial. I love Nate and Rojas’s relationship but rojas is hurt and I hope si will be not dead in season 3 . I’d be miss her
Season 3 got cancelled
@@alexmorrison5753 I know but I love that serial
BRING BACK SEASON 3 how could they let us hang with a weird cliffhanger but I have a feeling that lMEAVE DIT SOMETHING TO HER SISTER
whenever they cancel a season, they need to tell us what tf was supposed to happen in that season LIKE
@@hashcrap for reallll we still waiting on it
I don't know why but i feel that Simon is alive. We never saw his body and we was rich and influent because of his mother. I think he realize about the jake's real plan and decidid to fake his own death. After he wakes in the hospital he payed the doctors to say everyone he was dead, and in the morgue he payed the workers to do a fake autopsy, and after that he used his family's money to keep hidden in the City. He could return at season 3
season 3 is cancelled
@@jingyisdiary what!
I had the same theory that Simon never died.. And as he knew everyone's secret he might as well know why jake was at the rehabilitation centre.. But idk they didn't show him S2 . Dk much about him returning in S3
@@jingyisdiarywhy??
I know that the comment is from 1 year ago and that season 3 was canceled but if it came back with season 3 and Simon is alive maybe he killed Bronwyn
I think this is all a bit complicated. Simon says is used by two people. Once by Fiona and once by Simon himself, but Fiona doesn't know that. As for Jake's Secret: Jake is portrayed as a sick sociopath all the time, but I don't think that's true. I think Simon is the sick sociopath and Jake going into therapy has something to do with Simon; I think he was blackmailed into something by Simon and took responsibility for something that Simon did. (That's what Jake told Fiona too, and that's why she had to die). But when Jake witnessed Simon beating up Fiona, he promised her he would get his just punishment and so he decided to kill him. The bad thing is that Simon knew it and I say he's not dead. You see him in the cinema on the big screen and it wasn't Fiona because I don't think she knows anything about it; She doesn't generally have anything to do with blackmailing the four with messages, she only wanted the one who shot Jake. Unfortunately, it wasn't Addy at all, but Simon, who was standing somewhere in the woods in the background. Giselle came into play because she saw Vanessa's post, because she was just a crazy staker. And Giselle was also killed by Simon because she was dangerous to him; after all, she too was in therapy with Jake and didn't know if she might know his secret, too. And I think the prom victim is Principal Gupta. She was writing a book about the incidents and may have found something that prompted Simon to kill her too.
We love bronwyn and nate😍we just can't stoped watching them together😍their love story😍they are both so cute😍😍😍
Ikrrr
Ok so what if they wanted us to think Fiona is dead but she was saved and came back for revenge? Bit twisted but imo cool theory and plot twist
Best show on netflix Soooo exciting
THE DETECTIVE guys, there's something fishey about her
Yess!
So are we just going to ignore the fact that when Cole asked Cooper to take off his watch, Simon Says didn't get mad? And Fiona received the tip about almost being found out AFTER Vanessa confronted Cole about Jake being at rehab. Maeve could've tipped off Fiona the soonest they found out thag Fiona and Jake met at rehab but she didn't.
So I think Cole has something to do with all of this. And involves Jake's secret.
Also principal Gupta writing that book about them
Im watching this all after they cancelled season 3 😢😢 i guess we will never know what happened.
Sadly we wont
@@BrainPilot I just saw the trailer yesterday and decided to binge watch it as I finished both seasons today they said cancelled ☹️😭😭😞
As much as I don't want it to be, I think Maeve should be the next antagonist, or at least play a part of it. I dunno, the sister vs sister thing between her and bronwyn is getting boring for me so I just hope she gets a better storyline. I won't count TJ as a potential antagonist, he's just not too smart to be. Cole is the most likely to be as of now.
I hope we get to see more Vanessa tho. Her episode did a good job making her a bit more likeable.
Am sure Fiona was not working alone... Maybe The people working with Fiona would like to take revenge from the murder club
As theory regarding the Season 3, maybe was Maeve the responsible from the crime in the end of the Season 2, out of spite the Murder club for treated her badly, despite of that she was whom saved them from jail.
And regarding to others reasons to became an antagonist, maybe Maeve could start to think that the Murder club were the culprits from "corrupted" her sister Bronwyn, particulary Nate, to considers that Bronwyn started to showcase a more criminal side since that she started to hang with him, making that Maeve chose to planned a way to makes that her sister ended separated from Nate, and to accomplishes this, Maeve could plan to commit a murder and pinned this to Nate.
And regarding the crime itself, maybe Maeve killed Vanessa, as she could be the perfect victim to frames him, to considers that Vanessa knows a lot information about the Murder club, giving a reason to Nate to kills her, especially to considers his criminal past. Adding that Maeve could want to get rid her to prevent that Vanessa can exposes her framing.
And regarding some evidence, like the collar, maybe Maeve could plans a way to that Nate get the collar from Bronwyn during the graduation, and that many people can see this detail, to makes them witnesses, and after that Vanessa be killed, Maeve could snatches the collar from Nate, and planted it in the crime scene, to frames Nate as the murderer, and makes that he rots in jail, out of spite the Murder club for treated her badly, and out of spite her sister, as payback for be ungrateful with her support previously.
At least as theory.
I think a suspect can be the guy who Vanessa is hooking up with. He had more screen time towards the end but didn't really have a plot on his own. Also he wanted to have burgers with Vanessa after the interview, maybe he would have kidnapped her then as revenge for going through with the interview
Makes sense, especially the way he ran afterwards, and the look on his face like oh shit they took her!, plus the message he sent was like, where are you more than “leave her alone” makes lots of sense!
I was reading through the comments and found a few good theories. Though peacock said s3 was being cancelled I still have a theory of my own. Zach said that “Cooper has something coming”, the blood on the trophy may represent Cooper as the jock and how great he was to Bayview. But I think zach may of hurt or killed Cooper because of the last scene of s3. We did see Bronwyns necklace that she received from Nate in the last episode in a puddle of blood. I may think Bronwyn was included in maybe because she saw what happened to Cooper, resulting in her getting hurt. I wish s3 was coming out!
i just finished s2. is it true s3 is cancelled?
Sadly it is!
I KNOW WHAT THE SECRET IS... It all makes sense now, and is all connected
What is it please tell me
WE NEED A SEASON 3 ASAP!...it's 2024.
It's been cancelled!
I hate that it was cancelled after ending like that. I know that some cancelled shows have cane back and I hope it happens with this show. 😢
@@Faithfulgirl30same pention to bring it back
@@BrainPilot we have to do something to bring it back what there isn't anything we can do can we ?...
NOBODY TALKING ABOUT THE FUCKING ALLERGIC REACTION OF FIONA IN THE JAIL BRO AM SO LATER ISTG 1 YEAR
Guys what's the name of the Song in Ep 3 season 2 at the start?? Im really freaking out i dont find It nowhere
I SWEAR IF NATE AND BRONWYN ARE NOT TOGETHER OR ONE OF THEM IS DEAD IM DELETING NETFLIX AND IF ROHAS DOESNT FORGIVE HER SIS AND MAKE HER A PART OF THE CLUB I WILL FOR REAL UNSUBSCRIBE
I wonder if there would be a way that this major bloody event actually frames the murder club and they have to go on the run. Bronwyn's necklace maybe fell off in the struggle or the new villain planted it. Maybe other evidence is planted to frame the others. And the real perpetrator (or maybe a group) wore masks. Like, what if Jake had a whole crew at rehab?
On a side note, I would also love for Addy and Janae to be a thing. I really loved Janae and Maeve together, but damn. Addy and Janae have chemistry.
I also think next season will be Maeve and the murder club working on getting back on good terms. She's a genius who's plan worked, but I get that so many things could have gone wrong. Addy, Cooper, AND Bronwyn almost died.
Okay here me out, the main suspect is probably gonna be a character we don't know yet. This character has something to do with both Simon and the reason why Jake went into rehab. This new character will be introduced with information that will come from Cole.
But who's dead? Well What I believe is that the whole murderclub survived and that the neckless just might have fell off Bronwyns neck or anything like that. It wouldn't make sense for the show to make an end to the main protagonist(s). One thing is sure, somwbody died at the graduation. And I think it could be some of the side characters.. Like Keely and Evan. I believe Maeve and Kris are too important side characters to come to an end like this.
We know that the real Simon Says is still alive. How do we know? Well, in EP 7 we see Fiona receiving a text from somebody which we don't have an idea who that would be. What we do know is that this person is afraid to get exposed by murderclub so he sends Fiona on a mission to make murderclub think she's Simon Says.
My own conspiracy: Simon is still alive and his body is nowhere in his grave. He's the actual Simon Says.
Let me know your thoughts on this please!
That’s Maeve
ep 7 text was sent by maeve
Oh Allright, I missed the memo that the message came from Maeve
I definitely think Simon is still alive. I was waiting for him to come back towards the end of the season (thinking he is Simon says) but it didn’t happen. Maybe season 3 🤷🏾♀️
I was thinking Simon's alive too! Because in the book, it was really Simon that killed himself and blamed his death on the Bayview 4. Although the book was all in season 1 already, we never know. They could come up with more shocking twists
so sad taat season 3 was cancelled:(
It was!
Is there a way that s3 will be renewed/ taken over by another company pls respond I am desperate
Sadly nothing is happening
And the majority of people started to forget about this show
Few ppl like us still care 😢😢
@@Mokhoben this show is too good to give up on
@@MokhobenSame like please anyone make this show happen I will DO aNYthing to make it happen 😢
@@spxrkys5343I am I have been waiting for half year i will wait more mm
Who all guessed fiona was simon says ...back when she started tutoring 👀
Yeah they don’t just add new characters for nothing
Yeah...i found it odd when they showed her in the 1st episode of S1 and never showed her again the season... When she was back in s2...as a more screen time character... I knew something was fishy... They just didn’t introduced a girl who stabbed her teacher and then never talked about it again...
is there any site u can watch season 3 , i watched the whole series in 2 days but on netflix its only the first 2 seasons...
But… peacock canceled season 3, guys we MUST make aperiodischem of another season 3 NOW ! please think about it
I would love it if addy’s mom and coopers are gonna be together in season 3
Why tf isn't anyone talking about Death of Fiona?
Guys ! Omg listen i know who the suspects it is maeve whonwe know and the other is kris . Do u remember in last episode of s2 Fiona was talking to nate about how she could have also played with maeve and kris.
Also wasn't it sus that whoever tried to know about Jake's death for example Vanessa also had to play with Simon says but kris and maeve didnt
Also we can suspect kris bcoz he had the costume from the Halloween night and when Addy ig asked kris he said he burned them, but it might have been a lie coz he might have given it to fiona
We were so dumb to believe maeve . We could have suspected her on the night of Jake's murder of her spying on "the murder club"
Please pin this @BrainPilot I wanna know others opinion
Maybe Jake killed his dad and Cole doesn't want anyone to know , glad Fiona is dead can't believe waited for so long just to find out she was Simon says that's lame hahahha
So there will be seasson 3?
Apparently not I’m so mad
@@Jtw929 ohh😭😭
I hope Janae and Maeve work through there crap bc in my opinion they are sooo cute together and they are my fav couple and I hope brodwin (sorry don’t know how to spell it) doesn’t die
Is it possible that Bronwyn is dead and her necklace was next to her...
Maybe nate because fiona told roja .that you dont know nate and secondly simon is still alive because he was techie and rich and chyscopath
I want a season based off of One Of Us Is Next.
It’s cancelled🥲
@@foreverxplays
but whyyy??!😭😭😭😭
What says Cole is not the mastermind??
I don’t understand why Jake killed Simon
Because Simon recorded everything on his Xbox so Jake didn’t want that to get out so he had to change the plan and ratted out simon
Is there any chance we get a s3?
Nah this has been canceled!
@@BrainPilot nof even a slight chance ? 🥲
JUST FINISHED MY FRICKING SERIES AND I HAVE A STOMACH ACHE BECAUSE OF ROJAS DEATH.OR WHATEVER IT WAS.I WANT HER A.L.I.V.E.
I really don't think they'd kill the lead character
@@xsomili5501 jack died in titanic....😭 also it wouldn't have been a crime scene unless someone was dead right???
@@xsomili5501 I AM SO DAMN SAD THOU WHATEVER HAPPENED
@@kirankohli4381 I'm sure Bronwyn is more of a suspect than victim here really. Because she was still very relevant in s2, so I don't think they'll make the decision to move away from her for now, and there's also no other prominent character that would be fitting to take the lead role after Bronwyn. Maybe maeve but maeve would fit the antagonist more
@@xsomili5501 I wishhh but the nerdy trophy was covered with blood and so was the Nate's gifted necklace ..... ''Stay'' and I dont think being a suspect she will leave all that there bcs anyone of the murder club members would obviously have seen it other wise if not....maeve then......
Lots are saying Rojas killed someone’s but she’s smart she wouldn’t leave evidence such as a necklace and blood and she’s too sweet to murder but I think she’s dead I hope not as I loved her character and if she is I’m suing Netflix 😭
Hey here's a thought what if Simon is still alive?
That would be the ultimate twist!
I know right
Bruh didn't Fiona literally told Nate that Simon says he has to kill one of his group mates. 😳
Where in the season did she say that? I didn’t hear that 🫣😅
He said he has to turn in addy
We love bronwyn and nate😍😍😍we love to see them together😍😍😍
can you believe that they cancelled season 3? On a cliff hanger too
Such a shame as it was such a large cliff hanger!
@@BrainPilot ikr
Let's get a petition going for season 3 😂
It will get realest in 2023 march
What makes you say that?
The process of making that happen would turn this show into something resembling a straight up comic book story. His whole family, the police, the hospital and the media would have to be in on it and he would have to be brainiac level smart and have a plan and motive as intricate and cunning as darth sidious. Its just too unrealistic for this show.
@@keelobrown4991 wrong comment I think
Show is cancelled so no season 3
When will season 3 is released?
duz any1 else have their conscious villian in s3 being either bronwyn or nate? btw addy n jenae were pretty sus 4 me half of s2 so im keeping my gut on them
It’s cancelled y’all
Such a shame!
I think Because Rojas’s necklace & Cooper’s trophy are there Because Nate did something. Or Keely. That’s can happen.
should be book 3 some of us is back.
WHEN ?
I was in a lil bit of the series’s I litros y gest drains Juse but I got like a lot of money becouse of the covid test
They cancelled it I thought
Yeah it's a real shame!
Am I the only one who thought "Good that the bitch's dead" at the end? XD I really don't like Bronwyn's character in the series, even more after seeing her attitude towards Maeve.
My guess is Keely
I think the cancelled the show
Yeah they did!
I don't get why people like Bronwyn😭😭😭. She is literally my least favorite character
I know what you mean! She needs to realise how helpful her sister is!
@@BrainPilot But if something happens to her younger sister, all she thinks about is how she could've prevent it from happening. I believe that's responsibility for her sister.
@@Jaaman54 yeah her sister did something SO RECKLESS. I would react the same way as Bronwyn and I like her the best. I do think the others should forgive her though but Bronwyn can take a whole year to forgive her or something like that
Pls not Bronwyn dead
Honestly mave is annoying she should stay in her place tired of her always wining and crying to be part of the group obviously she not part and it should stay like that
there’s a lot to talk about on season 3 🫣
Wait. This came out on Netflix??? I've seen both seasons on peacock 🦚 only
Yeah it's on Netflix too!
@@BrainPilot we're do you live? I'm in the us and it's only on peacock.
@@joshua7293india