I LOVE this. Melissa theories are my favorite. she is connected to every major event/mystery on this show (the night Ali disappeared, Bethany Young, the Halloween train, the lodge fire, ect). and she and Charlotte definitely had some kind of weird partnership going on we need to more about. there names are always popping up together. and one of the biggest things I can't get over.. in season 4 when Mona showed the girls her RV to prove she wasn't the queen of hearts she looks at Spencer and says its your sister. but it got deleted before she could prove it. Charlotte was A at this time.. why protect Melissa? something fishy with those two, for sure.
RIght! Her sister was just shot, hospitalized and she is nowhere to be found. Same thing with her dad. LIke, where are these people at? Won't be surprised if the dad is helping Melissa be A.D. You just never know with this show.
Amanda Spurrell MK can shock on her lies, she also said that Mona was 100% dead in season 5 while also saying that she want make A Trans because it's a sensitive subject
Great video and theory! I think maybe Melissa found out a while back about Spencer being a Drake and has been a part of things along the way. Hopefully she will be revealed with good answers to all the questions we have about her and how she has been involved with Wilden, Wren, Cece, Jenna etc. Great job as always 👍🏻😀
Thanks! Glad you liked it. Melissa has to be involved somehow. I almost don't want her to be bad because Spencer has been betrayed by almost everyone in her life especially her family. She deserves at least one family member on her side.
Paul Gomez Yes that will be the catch if she is involved it's another blow for Spencer. Her mum ( Veronica) though seems pretty determined to not let this get between them so that's something at least! I think deep down Spencer knows Melissa is not who she seems.
This is absolutely brilliant. I've wanted them to bring things full circle with Bethany----and I desperately want Katherine to be her. I think your theory covers a lot of crucial points in the overall story. Love it!
Awww...Thanks! Glad you like it! I agree...Bethany has to be involved somehow for it to come back full circle. There has to be a reason why she was hit and buried that night just like Alison. I don't buy that she was hit by accident.
I totally agree. I shared the link to your theory on my PLL page (Once A Liar, Always A Liar) i hope you don't mind. I made sure to give you credit. I just wanted more people to come and watch this because it's among the absolute best theories that i've ever come across.
Mona was always the original A, not CeCe. Marlene (the creator) herself tweeted this. CeCe just took over the game after Mona was put in Radley. I do believe Melissa is AD though.
I will say from Reddit spoilers that I've seen. Ezra and Paige had nothing to do with it. Plus Ezra was so torn when Nicole was found because he knew he needed to help her, but he loves Aria very much. Paige loves Emily too much to put her through that too.
Yes, I know Mona was original A. But it was known that she was working with someone. The same thing with Cece. When Cece took over there is no way she could have done all those things by herself. The liars blamed Melissa for just about everything. From being A to killing Charlotte. Melissa is always involved in some shape way or form. Her being A.D. would make sense to me.
I totally agree with that. She has to be. Some people have already seen it somehow, and claim she is, but I don't want to believe what those people say till I see it. Everything does fit so well for Melissa beig AD though, and everything in this video lines up so perfectly 🙂.
IKR! We are always misled to believe someone is A but then it changes. I have my suspicions of who A.D. is besides Melissa but I also want to be shocked. I just hope it is someone we know. The way they explain it as 'someone we have never met....you kind of have but when you see it you'll understand'. I just don't know what that means. Bethany Young? IDK...I'm just hoping it's someone good!
woahh iv been thinking for weeks how the hell is a and d a clue as marlene said i knew ali would be too obvious but you read between the lines literally ...you deserve way more subscribers than you already have so heres one from me :)
Thanks so much! I appreciate the sub. I want to make another theory before the finale but just can't think of who else A.D. could be that I haven't mentioned or covered yet.
hmm maybe doing an opposite video like instead of concentrating on who is maybe who isnt like crossing suspects off li listing the suspects and saying why they definatly cant be AD then being left with the few that can if that makes sense haha
that sounds like a good idea but I tried making one like that before and somehow couldn't cross anyone off because they all somehow had reason to be a.d. I got mad and deleted it...LOL This show is making me crazy I may have to check into Radley/Welby after the finale. LOL
hahahaha im ready to be admitted for radley too ermm maybe do like a show unanswered question like if aria has ever been to radley before as she was showin some mental health behaiviour today or something like that?
Right! She seemed really odd to me in this episode. Talking to herself was really shady to me. Part of me thinks that maybe all these messages/facetimes from A.D. were just a figment of her imagination. She was the only one to see them. Just like with Rollins body, she sees it in her trunk. When she goes to show it to Ezra, it just disappears and the trunk is wiped clean. We definitely need a whole season with just answers.
Yes, I know that. She was pretending to be Alison calling Charlotte.You have to read/listen between the lines. Marlene has said we have to pay attention to every detail/conversation. Like my theory suggests, we may find out Melissa and Charlotte are related. That is why they met up that night Ali 'disappeared'.
Marlene confirmed that Ian killed himself, he was never murdered. And Cece discovered the A game from Mona in Radley, but Melissa could have definitely killed Charlotte.
It could've also been Melissa that got to Mona to help get Charlotte out of Welby to kill her. But I think you should watch rosewoodspoilerpll video about Bethany and Charles about being A.D (After Death) regarding what you said about the letters between A and D. Basically says Sara is Charles and Charlotte is Bethany
I really like the Melissa is AD theory. Your video made me think what if Mrs. Hastings couldn't have children. We know they adopted Spencer (Mary & Peter's daughter) maybe Melissa was adopted too. This may be a far reach but what if she is Mary's daughter, for some reason i think Mary was raped when she was in Radley. Maybe by Scott Montgomery ( Byron's brother). Mary did say that her and Melissa looked like they could be twins. Maybe it's not because they have the same father, but the same mother. Another thought came to me after watching this past episode. Mona told Hannah that the Game was more mechanical than electronic and the patch of the bridge on Hannah's jacket made me think of an Engineer. Melissa is very smart so she could of built the game.
Hmm! That sounds interesting to me. I wouldn't put it past this show for it to turn out like that. With all the stuff happening lately (Alison having Emily's baby for example), nothing seems far fetched to me. Melissa could have been adopted too. Maybe that is the connection between Melissa and Charlotte, same mother?
I believe Melissa could be A.D. I just hope if Mona killed Charlotte that it was self-defense or something. I think Mona isn't bad anymore. With Bethany Young, she has always been an important part of the show yet we know little to nothing about her other than her knowing Alison and killing Toby's mom. I hope we learn more about her before this show is done.
0:11 no, the "burning questions" is not who killed cece and who's A.D, the main questions is why cece story made no sense, had 272636 plot holes and totally was trash and low budget episode. The show is pure trash after 6x10, how can you guys seriously act the show is good even tho when Ali returned she never explained anything about those two kissing rock videos which each one was different, how she met Cyrus, and why she was about to send a text accidentally singed by A and then deleted it, also ali never told the girls who gave her the brused lips, MK acts like she answered everything while she didn't answer shit.
I totally agree with you on certain things. There are so many plotholes its ridiculous. I do like certain aspects of the show still and will watch til the end. I didn't watch the show when it first aired just to not know how it ends. It is kind of like a movie franchise. The original is always best and then it all goes down hill but you still watch just to see how the story ends. I'm pretty sure we will get some answers but obviously not all of them. That is just how it goes, sadly.
She should have known that people weren't gonna forget all those plotholes. I mean i'm still questioning how the liars forgot that Mona told them about Alison luring Bethany to Rosewood right before Mona was 'killed' and put in the dollhouse. They have simply forgotten all the things Alison has done to them. The major plotholes in Charlotte's story is still a mystery. We just learned that Peter Hastings claims Mary killed Jessica and buried her in their back yard. However, In Charlotte's story, she says she found Jessica dead. Also, Cece tells Emily that Jason did see her 'that night' because she was there but then tells Alison that she was never there that it had to be Bethany. OMG...I can go on forever with these plotholes. LOL
Paul Gomez same I can go forever and what bother me is that they used Mary as a twin sister plot so you won't find any plot hole since she's a new character and wasn't in previous seasons ...like oh btw Mary killed her. Pls I could go on and on it's exhausting
Yes! Well, Marlene does like to take inspiration from other films/tv/books. Maybe Gossip Girl is A.D. Wouldn't thought it at this point! XOXO Kisses, -A! LOL
hahahah xoxo kisses-A does have a ring to it id personally love if the person we know as gossip girl (didnt wanna leave a gg spoiler) makes a cameo im a huge fan of both shows
Loved this theory. I think its foggy because there are so many A's that we loose track of which A did what to which Liars. I did notice in the video you thought Melissa was related to Charlotte because of the phone all as in Melissa and Charlotte are sisters. But she was ringing trying to impersonate Alison.
Glad you like this theory! It wasn't just the phone call that made me think about Melissa and Charlotte being sisters. I know she was impersonating Alison. I just know that we are meant to notice small things like that in order to find out the truth on who A.D. is. Since Spencer and Charlotte are all related because of Mary Drake, I wouldn't be surprised if Melissa was too. By the time this show is over, I'm pretty sure everyone will be related to each other. LOL
Paul Gomez yes i agree! and I wouldnt be surprised if they made a prequel PLL with the parents sleeping around and making their own secrets and lies 😂😂
I LOVE this. Melissa theories are my favorite. she is connected to every major event/mystery on this show (the night Ali disappeared, Bethany Young, the Halloween train, the lodge fire, ect). and she and Charlotte definitely had some kind of weird partnership going on we need to more about. there names are always popping up together. and one of the biggest things I can't get over.. in season 4 when Mona showed the girls her RV to prove she wasn't the queen of hearts she looks at Spencer and says its your sister. but it got deleted before she could prove it. Charlotte was A at this time.. why protect Melissa? something fishy with those two, for sure.
There is definitely a connection between Melissa and Charlotte. I hope we will soon find out!
agreed
I believe in every "Melissa-A.D theory"... That girl is so shady and never honest...
RIght! Her sister was just shot, hospitalized and she is nowhere to be found. Same thing with her dad. LIke, where are these people at? Won't be surprised if the dad is helping Melissa be A.D. You just never know with this show.
Paul Gomez Yep...My Money is on Melissa...
Yep me too Adilene...I've been thinking from season 1 but I am convinced at the season-2 end that Melissa is A
Yes A and Dad X
Marlene King has comfirmed that we have seen AD before and that AD is someone Spencer knew right from the beginning.
Amanda Spurrell A twin maybe? Might be a twist
Amanda Spurrell MK can shock on her lies, she also said that Mona was 100% dead in season 5 while also saying that she want make A Trans because it's a sensitive subject
Great video and theory! I think maybe Melissa found out a while back about Spencer being a Drake and has been a part of things along the way. Hopefully she will be revealed with good answers to all the questions we have about her and how she has been involved with Wilden, Wren, Cece, Jenna etc. Great job as always 👍🏻😀
Thanks! Glad you liked it. Melissa has to be involved somehow. I almost don't want her to be bad because Spencer has been betrayed by almost everyone in her life especially her family. She deserves at least one family member on her side.
Paul Gomez Yes that will be the catch if she is involved it's another blow for Spencer. Her mum ( Veronica) though seems pretty determined to not let this get between them so that's something at least! I think deep down Spencer knows Melissa is not who she seems.
I really want Melissa to be AD!
Must be a hastings thing lolz so true!!!!! 😂😂
This is absolutely brilliant.
I've wanted them to bring things full circle with Bethany----and I desperately want Katherine to be her. I think your theory covers a lot of crucial points in the overall story. Love it!
Awww...Thanks! Glad you like it! I agree...Bethany has to be involved somehow for it to come back full circle. There has to be a reason why she was hit and buried that night just like Alison. I don't buy that she was hit by accident.
I totally agree. I shared the link to your theory on my PLL page (Once A Liar, Always A Liar) i hope you don't mind. I made sure to give you credit. I just wanted more people to come and watch this because it's among the absolute best theories that i've ever come across.
Thanks so much!! You're too sweet :) I appreciate you sharing it.
I'm kinda thinking Cece is Bethany and Sara Harvey that we seen is the real Charles. The one really dead is Sara Harvery buried in the backyard.
this theory is amazing. Love it
'must be a hastings thing' 😂
I love this!
Mona was always the original A, not CeCe. Marlene (the creator) herself tweeted this. CeCe just took over the game after Mona was put in Radley. I do believe Melissa is AD though.
I will say from Reddit spoilers that I've seen. Ezra and Paige had nothing to do with it. Plus Ezra was so torn when Nicole was found because he knew he needed to help her, but he loves Aria very much. Paige loves Emily too much to put her through that too.
Yes, I know Mona was original A. But it was known that she was working with someone. The same thing with Cece. When Cece took over there is no way she could have done all those things by herself. The liars blamed Melissa for just about everything. From being A to killing Charlotte. Melissa is always involved in some shape way or form. Her being A.D. would make sense to me.
I totally agree with that. She has to be. Some people have already seen it somehow, and claim she is, but I don't want to believe what those people say till I see it. Everything does fit so well for Melissa beig AD though, and everything in this video lines up so perfectly 🙂.
IKR! We are always misled to believe someone is A but then it changes. I have my suspicions of who A.D. is besides Melissa but I also want to be shocked. I just hope it is someone we know. The way they explain it as 'someone we have never met....you kind of have but when you see it you'll understand'. I just don't know what that means. Bethany Young? IDK...I'm just hoping it's someone good!
Paul Gomez Excellent thoughts! There is total bad vibes with Kathrine. She feels majorly like Bethany to me.
11:35 comment: Ezra = Board Shorts
Dang...I almost forgot about him being Board Shorts. Thanks for reminding me!
melissa is A.D.
woahh iv been thinking for weeks how the hell is a and d a clue as marlene said i knew ali would be too obvious but you read between the lines literally ...you deserve way more subscribers than you already have so heres one from me :)
Thanks so much! I appreciate the sub. I want to make another theory before the finale but just can't think of who else A.D. could be that I haven't mentioned or covered yet.
hmm maybe doing an opposite video like instead of concentrating on who is maybe who isnt like crossing suspects off li listing the suspects and saying why they definatly cant be AD then being left with the few that can if that makes sense haha
that sounds like a good idea but I tried making one like that before and somehow couldn't cross anyone off because they all somehow had reason to be a.d. I got mad and deleted it...LOL This show is making me crazy I may have to check into Radley/Welby after the finale. LOL
hahahaha im ready to be admitted for radley too ermm maybe do like a show unanswered question like if aria has ever been to radley before as she was showin some mental health behaiviour today or something like that?
Right! She seemed really odd to me in this episode. Talking to herself was really shady to me. Part of me thinks that maybe all these messages/facetimes from A.D. were just a figment of her imagination. She was the only one to see them. Just like with Rollins body, she sees it in her trunk. When she goes to show it to Ezra, it just disappears and the trunk is wiped clean. We definitely need a whole season with just answers.
in 8:12 about she telling "can I talk to my sister" it's because she said before "hi, it's alison dilaurentis, (...)"
Yes, I know that. She was pretending to be Alison calling Charlotte.You have to read/listen between the lines. Marlene has said we have to pay attention to every detail/conversation. Like my theory suggests, we may find out Melissa and Charlotte are related. That is why they met up that night Ali 'disappeared'.
Marlene confirmed that Ian killed himself, he was never murdered. And Cece discovered the A game from Mona in Radley, but Melissa could have definitely killed Charlotte.
True on the Ian part. But, can we really trust Marlene? She is the biggest liar of all...LOL
Her hints and clues drive me insane, it's as if she actually wants to mess with us
It could've also been Melissa that got to Mona to help get Charlotte out of Welby to kill her. But I think you should watch rosewoodspoilerpll video about Bethany and Charles about being A.D (After Death) regarding what you said about the letters between A and D. Basically says Sara is Charles and Charlotte is Bethany
Also Shay mentioned Bonnie and Clyde in her recent instagram pic.
I really like the Melissa is AD theory. Your video made me think what if Mrs. Hastings couldn't have children. We know they adopted Spencer (Mary & Peter's daughter) maybe Melissa was adopted too. This may be a far reach but what if she is Mary's daughter, for some reason i think Mary was raped when she was in Radley. Maybe by Scott Montgomery ( Byron's brother). Mary did say that her and Melissa looked like they could be twins. Maybe it's not because they have the same father, but the same mother. Another thought came to me after watching this past episode. Mona told Hannah that the Game was more mechanical than electronic and the patch of the bridge on Hannah's jacket made me think of an Engineer. Melissa is very smart so she could of built the game.
Hmm! That sounds interesting to me. I wouldn't put it past this show for it to turn out like that. With all the stuff happening lately (Alison having Emily's baby for example), nothing seems far fetched to me. Melissa could have been adopted too. Maybe that is the connection between Melissa and Charlotte, same mother?
Melissa is AD, but Mona killed Charlotte. Mary's 2nd child is Bethany Young, which would be Spencer's sister.
I believe Melissa could be A.D. I just hope if Mona killed Charlotte that it was self-defense or something. I think Mona isn't bad anymore. With Bethany Young, she has always been an important part of the show yet we know little to nothing about her other than her knowing Alison and killing Toby's mom. I hope we learn more about her before this show is done.
0:11 no, the "burning questions" is not who killed cece and who's A.D, the main questions is why cece story made no sense, had 272636 plot holes and totally was trash and low budget episode.
The show is pure trash after 6x10, how can you guys seriously act the show is good even tho when Ali returned she never explained anything about those two kissing rock videos which each one was different, how she met Cyrus, and why she was about to send a text accidentally singed by A and then deleted it, also ali never told the girls who gave her the brused lips, MK acts like she answered everything while she didn't answer shit.
I totally agree with you on certain things. There are so many plotholes its ridiculous. I do like certain aspects of the show still and will watch til the end. I didn't watch the show when it first aired just to not know how it ends. It is kind of like a movie franchise. The original is always best and then it all goes down hill but you still watch just to see how the story ends. I'm pretty sure we will get some answers but obviously not all of them. That is just how it goes, sadly.
Paul Gomez the thing is she killed off cece right after 6x10 so that people will move on from all her plot holes and wonder who killed her.
She should have known that people weren't gonna forget all those plotholes. I mean i'm still questioning how the liars forgot that Mona told them about Alison luring Bethany to Rosewood right before Mona was 'killed' and put in the dollhouse. They have simply forgotten all the things Alison has done to them. The major plotholes in Charlotte's story is still a mystery. We just learned that Peter Hastings claims Mary killed Jessica and buried her in their back yard. However, In Charlotte's story, she says she found Jessica dead. Also, Cece tells Emily that Jason did see her 'that night' because she was there but then tells Alison that she was never there that it had to be Bethany. OMG...I can go on forever with these plotholes. LOL
Paul Gomez same I can go forever and what bother me is that they used Mary as a twin sister plot so you won't find any plot hole since she's a new character and wasn't in previous seasons ...like oh btw Mary killed her. Pls I could go on and on it's exhausting
Right! I can make a whole "Plothole Theory' video that is a good two hours long!! LOL
and also the chuck and blair reference on the last episode of gg the song bonnie and clyde is playing on a scene with chuck and blair
Yes! And, the first time I heard time I heard the PLL theme song was in an episode of Gossip Girl! And PLL wasn't even on at the time.
yes i remember that at that ball its called cotillian or something haha this is crazy i might rewatch some gg episodes get some clues haha
Yes! Well, Marlene does like to take inspiration from other films/tv/books. Maybe Gossip Girl is A.D. Wouldn't thought it at this point! XOXO Kisses, -A! LOL
hahahah xoxo kisses-A does have a ring to it id personally love if the person we know as gossip girl (didnt wanna leave a gg spoiler) makes a cameo im a huge fan of both shows
Loved this theory. I think its foggy because there are so many A's that we loose track of which A did what to which Liars. I did notice in the video you thought Melissa was related to Charlotte because of the phone all as in Melissa and Charlotte are sisters. But she was ringing trying to impersonate Alison.
Glad you like this theory! It wasn't just the phone call that made me think about Melissa and Charlotte being sisters. I know she was impersonating Alison. I just know that we are meant to notice small things like that in order to find out the truth on who A.D. is. Since Spencer and Charlotte are all related because of Mary Drake, I wouldn't be surprised if Melissa was too. By the time this show is over, I'm pretty sure everyone will be related to each other. LOL
Paul Gomez yes i agree! and I wouldnt be surprised if they made a prequel PLL with the parents sleeping around and making their own secrets and lies 😂😂
YAS!! It will be called: "Peter, Little Liar". Because we know he has more liars than everyone on the show combined. LOL
name of the song?
Digital Daggers - The Devil Within