Happy New Year for y'all!! If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any content!! Tyy guys!!
Coming here after all vocal scandals in kpop. The main thing I have to say it's fans shouldn't be blind, vocally this performance is terrible. I know they're dancing (it seems very tiring) and they didn't make the choreography but damn, it's quite bad. Long time ago I thought performances were really sung (and I was so shocked because choreographies got harder) but then I noticed it's impossible to sing with this crazy dancing, but I know it's not all fault on them. Companies and choreographers were the problem because subconciously they kept rising standars that don't exist. Anyways, what I want to say is fans shouldn´t lower standars either because of this, people must know how to difference between a real live performance though...
I am not surprised that Nako is the most stable singer in this group. If you remember produce48, everyone who went there during their live performances stated that Nako has the clearest voice out of everyone else. It's such a pity that she didn't get as much lines as she deserves
Nako has been really consistent with her live vocals, too! I see people in this comment section saying that she's stable bc she's not moving as much for her parts as other members are, but that doesn't explain all the other live performances she's done. Nako has a clear, well-supported live singing voice and I'm proud of her!
@@potatopotatopotato4901 that's just an excuse. They must feel jealous because their biases are not stable like Nako. I'm not even her fans, but I agreed that she deserves the COMPLIMENT 100%%
other members are probably tired since sakura said they during cb they don't get much sleep, that's why they're struggling, not saying hitomi and nako aren't tired too but hitomi and nako always get the least like (with sakura and hyewon) and doesn't sing as much as other (they should really give jline + hyewon more line😭) so I could understand why other members are struggling..
@@yooh1785 tired it's not a excuse for them if they skip only high note and when only hard choreo then it's much acceptable but some of them never sing at all this means they are dancing not performing
@@JYC_1110 they're human too 🙄 they're busy with comeback promotion and they also have special stages and collab stage (except yujin, chaewon, hyewon, yena and jline) , being an idol isn't as easy as you think so it's okay if they lipsync sometimes.
All these girls can hit what they sing, it’s your fitness to be able to dance this hard hitting number whilst singing! Nako and Hitomi are up there dancing just as hard as everyone else but are still singing every single line and is on key! It’s really difficult to be able to sing well whilst dancing as hard as IZ*ONE is dancing so I understand why some were pitchy or not singing at all... but WE NEED to give probs to Nako and Hitomi for singing their lines on key even after doing all them tiresome dance moves!
@@amnedits4898 Also add the back-to-back schedules within those weeks. Fatigue gonna pile on them quickly too. Heck I even sweat when I just dance for 20 seconds, what's more if its about 4 minutes while singing.
@@anomonyus-57 okay haha Nako & Yena had the same parts and Nako could easily phrase F5’s aswell, Nako is not better than the others but she is most arguably the best live performer bc of her excessive stamina which was always highlighted but never noticed or praised other than that one produce video.
This song is too high pitched... Only nako and hitomi are able to sang they part correctly when they dance... It's too difficult to vocal line ( as chaewon, Yuri, yujin, yena, eunbi, chaeyeon)
For me,chaeyeon lines has low pitch which is not suitable to her voice I noticed it she is stable but struggling in low pitch And rest of vocal line has very high pitch
Honestly, Nako and hitomi's line suits their range. The chorus(which sung by the vocal line) is still in the vocal line's range, but is way on the limit. Believe me when i say nako won't also be able to sing the chorus because it's full of f5 and e5, that is not in nako's range. If you remember in pd48, Nako tried to sing 'to reach you' highnote but wasn't able to do so because it's not her range. Take note its f5-f#5. Meanwhile yuri still nailed the highnote.
The song most suits Nako and Hitomi’s very high voices. Everyone else has to go outside their ‘comfortable’ range when dancing their insane choreo. So props to Chaeyeon, Chaewon, Yujin and Yuri for singing as much as they did, we stan hard work and talent✌️Get to hear them perfectly in the encore so happy out 🥰
More like nako and hitomi's line suits their range. The chorus(which sung by the vocal line) is still in the vocal line's range, but is way on the limit. Believe me when i say nako won't also be able to sing the chorus because it's full of f5 and e5, that is not in nako's range. If you remember in pd48, Nako tried to sing 'to reach you' highnote but wasn't able to do so because it's not her range. Take note its f5-f#5. Meanwhile yuri still nailed the highnote.
근데 이번 노래는 뭐랄까.. 음원 자체를 들어도 성대가 다 머리위에 떠있는 느낌? .. 혹시 아실까요 그런 느낌이 들었어요 이미 곡 자체가 본인들의 음역대의 한계치라는 느낌이었어요 격한 안무를 하면서 노래를 부르면 당연히 더 힘드니.. 꾸준한 라이브 연습을 통해서 호흡을 찾아가면 안정이 되긴 할 부분이지만.. 그냥 이건 노래 자체가 힘들다는 느낌이 들더라구요.. 노래도 좋고, 다들 너무 이쁘고 무대도 완성도 높아서 항상 기분 좋게 보는데 매순간 평가당하는 아이돌들이 조금 안타깝긴 하네요ㅜㅜ 근데 저는 유진양이 이쁘다는 생각외에는 별 생각 해본적 업는데 이번곡에서는 일본친구들(실력이 부족해도 소리내고 즐긴다는 나라의 특색이 있으니!) 제외하고 가장 안정적이라서 노래실력이 꽤 좋거나.. 연습을 참 열심히 했구나 싶어 이뻐보이네요..
ㄹㅇ 지금까지 올라왔던 다른 mr들은 대부분 ar이 깔려있어서 그렇거나 제대로 제거가 안된거일듯. 멤버들 모두가 다 저렇게 격하게 춤을 추면서 노래를 다 부른다고? 나코처럼 중간중간 부를 수 있는 사람이 있으면 모를까 전체멤버 모두의 폐활량이 그렇게 짱짱한 그룹은 세상에 몇 없을듯...
wow Nako and Yujin are so stable. I’m kinda surprised about the members who usually are stable but their parts are really high and the choreo is so powerful, at least they tried
Nako, Yujin, Hitomi and Chaeyeon eats this CD I'm worried about Yena, Yena was one of the most stable in IZ*ONE, I guess it's because of the dance, her parts are somewhat complicated and tired:(
@@imjustthin4698 Yes, honestly I love IZ*ONE's choreo but they have that typical problem of the 4th gen where they put too much effort for the choreo but less for their vocals/rap.
Not just the dance...The song is really Highpitch...Actually This sing is not really suit for their vocal tone...But it would be nice for Nako and Hitomi because they have Highpitched voice
nako is the most stable member in this performance. stop saying bc she got little lines. if she got little lines thats mean she had to dance more. and thats even tiring
Not counting that CY once mention that when nako dance she needs to make her move more WIDER than everyone do to her being short so she can match everyone moves which is WAY MORE TIRING 🙂
@@rose-ne1iv yea...but i'm sorry...i just want to said,everyone not stable here sweetie Because this was not a singing live performance Sorry if there's any wrong word🙏 My english is bad too🙏 Oh and one more thing... panorama choreo dance is tiring and hard...so every member will not sing to their lines seriously It happen to other kpop boy and girl group too
Nako and Hitomi sing every their lines very well, good job! Yujin almost sing her all lines too! and im impressive to Minju bcs she's tried to sing live this time!
Yujin is amazing. And considering how young she is, she’s only going to get better with experience and age. I can’t wait to see how she progresses in the future !
Honestly praise to Nako, Hitomi, Yujin and Chaewon. Nako and hitomi sang all of their lines, and yujin and chaewon were the only ones who sang their chorus parts. Oops I forgot Yena also sang her chorus part sorry 😚
they’re really tired:( hope they rest well. -nako yujin hiichan literally did a great job💖 (it’s really hard to sing this while dancing because it’s too high pitch)
@@nufarnyon for their concerts they obviously sing live. since there’s so many of them their voices blend so they sound better/ you won’t be able to hear many mistakes collectively
@Samrat Gurung You can have it your way. I'll have mine. Cause I can clearly hear Minju's raw vocal, my expectations was not really high for her since she isn't part of the vocal line, but she exceeded it.
@Samrat Gurung Mindy sang her part live. And somehow stable before first chorus She even tried to sing after Chaeyeon part which is after the first chorus where everyone started to become exhausted.
I can fully understand why most of them aren't singing their lines, as you can see their choreography is hard and and the notes are mostly at high pitched. I'm happy to hear nako and hitomi improving every single performance, i just hope that they will be given much more lines next time. Also yujin,chaewon,yuri,minju and yena along with the other members I can hear them catching their breath just to sing their parts damn it must've been so hard for them but still BIG SALUTE FOR THEM THEY ALL DID WELL!!
Panorama is way too high. If they lipsync I'm not gonna blame them singing an F5 note with E5 while dancing what the heck this song is way too hard. The choreography is hard especially the chorus.
@@ei5859 they sometimes sing live sometimes don't. I think it's actually okay to not sing live sometimes so that they won't ruin their voice especially yuri her voice was badly damaged :
lets acknowledge the fact that the dance has no proper break, the song is high asf, they’re wearing high heels and if u watch the encore stage u can see that they are fully capable of hitting the notes. honestly if there was someone who could sing and dance this perfectly at the same time they aint no human
Honestly if Chaewon had parts other than the chorus, I’m sure she would do a lot better, those chorus parts are too high to sing while dance singing😭 but Yujin, Nako, and Hitomi did a really good job here!
@@gigiv5138 ummm no hun. Nako and hitomi are singing in their normal singing tones. The other members have to make their voice higher cuz the song is higher pitched. If chaewon had parts where she doesn't have to dance much and sing higher pitched, she would've done better.
@@jklmneojklmneo8801 again you don't know music lol Nako Hii and the other girls sing the same high notes If i follow what you're saying that's mean Chaewon Yuri can't sing high notes like this as Nako and Hiichan then ?
I think Yujin has a lot of potential, she is clearly stable enough to sing and make her voice not crack, but I think she just can't reach her notes without making a funny face or risking a voice crack.
On the original video of this performance, people were arguing with me that all the members were singing live even though it was obviously not true, and now the MR removed shows the truth. Even members who usually kill it live couldn't keep up this time. Gotta give props to Hitomi and Nako for slaying their lines and props to Yujin, Yuri, Chaeyeon, Minju, Chaewon, and Yena for trying their best. The girls still did really well with this performance overall, even if the vocals were lacking.
@@an_3692 Hmmm, I disagree that Yena had the most difficult dance parts while singing, but I did edit my comment to add her to the list of people who tried their best 😊
@@potatopotatopotato4901 Thank you, also in your opinion who you think got most difficult parts? I think it's Yena because she is always adding little details as well which we might not notice on the first watch, also because she is a powerfull dancer and always does her moves pretty quick.
@@an_3692 I think Chaewon's moves during the first and second chorus are more difficult to sing through bc they involve multiple chest pops and torso movements! But that's just my opinion. Regardless, I remain really proud of Nako, even if she had a more stationary torso during her parts. Like, she still did the same tiring choreography as everyone else, but somehow managed to stay clear and have good breath control when she sang!
Dancing alone is hard but dancing AND singing is on another level especially Panorama has such a high key plus with their busy schedule but they still did so well! I'm so proud of my girlies.
im pretty sure they can sing this perfectly while just standing. But the dancing restricts them from doing such notes. We already know they all can sing, but they have become dependent on the loud background track that they focus more on the dancing. :
And she always at least tried to sing live! That's why I love her sm and now I'm happier since she is now doing that!! In IVE she has songs on her range, and she is SLAYINGGGG yujin is such a queen
This song is high af and the fact that they have to sing this while dancing to that choreo is amazing. Oh they also have been working nonstop with their full schedules
They did their best, this is so hard to do. Big praise for nako and hitomi. And for chaewon yena yujin yuri they're trying even they know that it's too high .
![[Clean MR Removed] IZONE (아이즈원) - 환상동화 (Secret Story of the Swan) Performance Film](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/ZZNKdKjym8g/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Clean MR Removed] IZONE (아이즈원) - 환상동화 (Secret Story of the Swan) Performance Film](/img/tr.png)
![[CLEAN MR REMOVED] IZ*ONE (아이즈원) - "PANORAMA" ENCORE STAGE [Mr제거] @MNET COUNTDOWN](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqU1oH_RQlc/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Ep.03] 'MAI, SON JUWON, JEONG SAEBI, CHOI SOUL, CHOI JUNGEUN, KOKO' ♬Panorama - IZ*ONE @SeeSaw Game](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DKVWiWcElq4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[CLEAN MR Removed] 201212 IZ*ONE (아이즈원) PANORAMA](/img/1.gif)
Happy New Year for y'all!!
If you are new in this channel, subscribe, like and turn on your bell of notifications for you not lose any content!! Tyy guys!!
Hi 👋
Hello
HAPPY NEW YEAR TO YOU TOO!
Also, can you try to do Twice ICSM performance in this day too? They also singing live!
@@si_multifandom_ch_5099 Unfortunately I couldn't do it this time, there are several cuts in their performances
my top 3 most stable vocals
-Nako
-Hitomi
-Yujin
I love yujin❤❤
Exactly
so true
the only stable people in Iz*one but yeah this song is highpitched and exhausting but c'mon now
Coming here after all vocal scandals in kpop. The main thing I have to say it's fans shouldn't be blind, vocally this performance is terrible. I know they're dancing (it seems very tiring) and they didn't make the choreography but damn, it's quite bad. Long time ago I thought performances were really sung (and I was so shocked because choreographies got harder) but then I noticed it's impossible to sing with this crazy dancing, but I know it's not all fault on them. Companies and choreographers were the problem because subconciously they kept rising standars that don't exist. Anyways, what I want to say is fans shouldn´t lower standars either because of this, people must know how to difference between a real live performance though...
I am not surprised that Nako is the most stable singer in this group. If you remember produce48, everyone who went there during their live performances stated that Nako has the clearest voice out of everyone else. It's such a pity that she didn't get as much lines as she deserves
Nako has been really consistent with her live vocals, too! I see people in this comment section saying that she's stable bc she's not moving as much for her parts as other members are, but that doesn't explain all the other live performances she's done. Nako has a clear, well-supported live singing voice and I'm proud of her!
@@potatopotatopotato4901 that's just an excuse. They must feel jealous because their biases are not stable like Nako. I'm not even her fans, but I agreed that she deserves the COMPLIMENT 100%%
other members are probably tired since sakura said they during cb they don't get much sleep, that's why they're struggling, not saying hitomi and nako aren't tired too but hitomi and nako always get the least like (with sakura and hyewon) and doesn't sing as much as other (they should really give jline + hyewon more line😭) so I could understand why other members are struggling..
@@yooh1785 tired it's not a excuse for them if they skip only high note and when only hard choreo then it's much acceptable but some of them never sing at all this means they are dancing not performing
@@JYC_1110 they're human too 🙄 they're busy with comeback promotion and they also have special stages and collab stage (except yujin, chaewon, hyewon, yena and jline) , being an idol isn't as easy as you think so it's okay if they lipsync sometimes.
被せなし生歌で歌う前提のキーと振り付けの激しさじゃないと思うけど、食らいついててすごいなぁ
柔らかめの発声で地声高めの奈子、ひぃちゃんがよく聞こえるのは想像できるけどユジンもめっちゃ食いついててすごい
Nakooo.. that's why she did Love Whisper high note easily..
yeppp. Her natural tone makes it easier to hit high notes~
Little body, big voice ❤️
Which part was nako's? 🥺
@@heyitsme2824 0:31 and 2:04
she’s off key as fuck but sure
なこちゃん音源すぎるしそれほど自分の安定にあった所歌えてるのに他のメンバーの音程もっと考えて欲しいなぁ、ただでさえダンスこんなこなしてるのに苦しいよ、、、
Nako and Hitomi is stable here because the song is in high key it is suitable in their voice. Even Yuri can't be stable and some vocalists here..
Becausw Yuri's part is not only higher but also have a harder coreography.
All these girls can hit what they sing, it’s your fitness to be able to dance this hard hitting number whilst singing! Nako and Hitomi are up there dancing just as hard as everyone else but are still singing every single line and is on key! It’s really difficult to be able to sing well whilst dancing as hard as IZ*ONE is dancing so I understand why some were pitchy or not singing at all... but WE NEED to give probs to Nako and Hitomi for singing their lines on key even after doing all them tiresome dance moves!
especially with that choreography and it's just one performance
@@amnedits4898 Also add the back-to-back schedules within those weeks. Fatigue gonna pile on them quickly too. Heck I even sweat when I just dance for 20 seconds, what's more if its about 4 minutes while singing.
@@amnedits4898 _
stability ranking in this performance
1. Nako
2. Hitomi
3. Yujin
4. Yuri
5. Chaeyeon
6. Chaewon
7. Minju
8. Hyewon (I think she actially sang but she's really quiet)
9. Yena
10. Sakura
11. Eunbi
12. Wonyoung
yena should be higher
Minju I think is more more good than yuri (more stability)
왜 히토미가 더 높은건지….유진이가 1등가는게 정상인듯
@@raiseup5955 because she was stable
AKBグルの中で1番生歌でステージに立つ機会が多いチーム8
声量あったり音程安定してるメンバーに任せてほとんど歌わないメンバーもいるけど、声質が目立つ分ひぃちゃんずっとマジメに踊りながら歌ってきたもんね…😭努力報われてて泣くしかないファンはこちらです😭💕
なこちゃん、ひいちゃん、ユジン、チェウォンが凄いって印象
めちゃくちゃ息が切れててとっても辛そう…この高度なダンスと歌の組み合わせは鬼畜過ぎますよね…アンコールとか見てたら踊ってない状態だと結構みんな歌歌えてるし
激しいダンス踊りながらでもめちゃめちゃ安定してるなこちゃんとひぃちゃんすごすぎる
Despite Nako already impressed me last time but she impressed me even more in this performance
Although* not despite!!
I just don’t wanna lose my heart😃
Nako is one of my favorite member in Iz*One honestly because of this reason too! So glad she did well again!
Nako is one of my favourites. She definitely kills her parts. But in the vocal line members' defence, their parts are much harder.
@@anomonyus-57 okay haha
Nako & Yena had the same parts and Nako could easily phrase F5’s aswell, Nako is not better than the others but she is most arguably the best live performer bc of her excessive stamina which was always highlighted but never noticed or praised other than that one produce video.
@@anomonyus-57 i see you everywhere defending the vocal lines. Let people enjoy and appreciate Nako's voice won't you?
why is no one talking about hitomi's stable vocals
bc she has no lines
@@gzalcala wtf no lines???
@@gzalcala she has lines lol
@@gzalcalalol wut?
@@gzalcala u deaf or smth?
This song is too high pitched... Only nako and hitomi are able to sang they part correctly when they dance... It's too difficult to vocal line ( as chaewon, Yuri, yujin, yena, eunbi, chaeyeon)
For me,chaeyeon lines has low pitch which is not suitable to her voice
I noticed it she is stable but struggling in low pitch
And rest of vocal line has very high pitch
True. I guess that it is because Nako’s and Hitomi’s voices are naturally high, so pulling those notes off is kinda easier for them than the others.
i have trouble singing this song even without dancing-
Honestly, Nako and hitomi's line suits their range. The chorus(which sung by the vocal line) is still in the vocal line's range, but is way on the limit. Believe me when i say nako won't also be able to sing the chorus because it's full of f5 and e5, that is not in nako's range. If you remember in pd48, Nako tried to sing 'to reach you' highnote but wasn't able to do so because it's not her range. Take note its f5-f#5. Meanwhile yuri still nailed the highnote.
@@jamilavillanueva7356 bruh, pd 48 is like years ago, I think nako is absolutely improving, she can show it maybe because otr won't do that
ウリムズが歌ってるパートとかは専門家の人も高すぎて声出ないって言ってる程だから歌いながら出すのはさすがにつらいんだろうな、
踊りながら？
ヘウォンは言い方悪いけどちゃんと音が外れてるのが聞こえてるから聞こえづらいだけでちゃんと歌ってるよね
RUclipsやってるトレーナーのかたもいってたけど歌うだけだって高音多くてきつすぎるのにテンポが早くて移動も多い。格段に難易度高くなってるよ。だからステージプレレコードかとおもって聞いてたけど二つ声あってこんな殺しに来てる曲歌ってるんだってビックリした。
The song most suits Nako and Hitomi’s very high voices. Everyone else has to go outside their ‘comfortable’ range when dancing their insane choreo. So props to Chaeyeon, Chaewon, Yujin and Yuri for singing as much as they did, we stan hard work and talent✌️Get to hear them perfectly in the encore so happy out 🥰
More like nako and hitomi's line suits their range. The chorus(which sung by the vocal line) is still in the vocal line's range, but is way on the limit. Believe me when i say nako won't also be able to sing the chorus because it's full of f5 and e5, that is not in nako's range. If you remember in pd48, Nako tried to sing 'to reach you' highnote but wasn't able to do so because it's not her range. Take note its f5-f#5. Meanwhile yuri still nailed the highnote.
@@jamilavillanueva7356 Nako if it reaches F5 and E
1番サビのチェウォンのくそ高くなるとことかボーカルメンのめっちゃ高いところ歌おうとしてくれてるところが嬉しくて嬉しくて仕方ないファンだからって庇いすぎと言われるかもしれないけど個人的に私は歌おうとしてくれてるその事実だけで十分感動するし嬉しい。私はプロでも専門家でもないから何も分からないけどパフォーマンスしてくれるだけで嬉しいって気持ちはあるんだわ。
Nako, hitomi, yujin sang well
Honorable mention to joyuriz for still trying to sing their insanely high parts
minju too, she sang most of her parts
この激しさのダンスを踊りながら歌えるような曲じゃないから、被せの中で少しでも歌おうとしてるメンバーに拍手だし、ひぃなこはいい意味で頑張りすぎてて天晴れ🥳🥳
奈子ちゃんがコメントで褒められてるだけで涙が出る😭
Nako eat CD and didnt sound flat... the hidden gem..
ひいなこはもちろん、ユジンすごく好印象
ユリ、チェウォン、チェヨン、ミンジュ、イェナもがんばってるの伝わる
まじひいなここんなに安定して歌えるのに最後まで歌割り少なかったの何故、、、、
韓国の方は日本と声の好みが違うからです
宮脇、ウォニョン、へウォン、ウンビ…
@@shushu5580 ウンビがだめなのは珍しかったな... 難易度高いからなぁ。
推しの奈子が音源すぎるし、たくさん褒めてもらえてるの泣いちゃう。ひいちゃんとユジンも声出てて凄いわ、、、、
今回音程高くてダンスもきついから声出てない子もいるけどそれでも出そうとしてるの凄いなと思う😭
初っ端から歌ってないのはよく分からんけど
サビとラストあたり(ユリ、チェウォン、ウンビ、イェナ)は最高音のFがあるので歌えないのはまじで仕方ないと思う
他の曲だとウォニョンも結構歌っとるよ
(今更失礼)
@@user-ok6ex5rq2h ウォニョン歌ってるか、、？
デビューから歌ってるイメージ全くないけど。
なんせIZ*ONE音程クソ高い
Nako and hiichan Who?
I only know Nakoria carey and Hitomiyoncé
LOL
HAHAHAHAHHAHA
top comment material lmao HAHAHAHAHA
Lol😹
literally so far, they need her own name
なこってプデュの時から安定感がすごい、、、、歌唱力で言ったら上はメンバー内に沢山いるけど安定感は一番だと思う！！
근데 이번 노래는 뭐랄까..
음원 자체를 들어도 성대가 다 머리위에 떠있는 느낌? .. 혹시 아실까요 그런 느낌이 들었어요
이미 곡 자체가 본인들의 음역대의 한계치라는 느낌이었어요
격한 안무를 하면서 노래를 부르면 당연히 더 힘드니..
꾸준한 라이브 연습을 통해서 호흡을 찾아가면 안정이 되긴 할 부분이지만..
그냥 이건 노래 자체가 힘들다는 느낌이 들더라구요..
노래도 좋고, 다들 너무 이쁘고 무대도 완성도 높아서 항상 기분 좋게 보는데
매순간 평가당하는 아이돌들이 조금 안타깝긴 하네요ㅜㅜ
근데 저는 유진양이 이쁘다는 생각외에는 별 생각 해본적 업는데
이번곡에서는 일본친구들(실력이 부족해도 소리내고 즐긴다는 나라의 특색이 있으니!) 제외하고 가장 안정적이라서
노래실력이 꽤 좋거나.. 연습을 참 열심히 했구나 싶어 이뻐보이네요..
오히려 나코 히토미가 더 안정적인데 물론 음이 도 낮은 파트긴 하지만
나코 히토미가 제일 잘하는데
이때 엠알 제거 올린 다른 영상에서는 다 그 영상 하나만 보고 아이즈원 실력을 완전히 평가하는데 너무 기분이 나쁘더라구요...
奈子ちゃんとひとみちゃんは日本の誇りです
이렇게 헥헥거리고 노래를 차마 다 부를수 없는게 진짜 mr제거 맞음
ㄹㅇ 지금까지 올라왔던 다른 mr들은 대부분 ar이 깔려있어서 그렇거나 제대로 제거가 안된거일듯. 멤버들 모두가 다 저렇게 격하게 춤을 추면서 노래를 다 부른다고? 나코처럼 중간중간 부를 수 있는 사람이 있으면 모를까 전체멤버 모두의 폐활량이 그렇게 짱짱한 그룹은 세상에 몇 없을듯...
@장효은 아직 목소리가 완성 안되서 그럴거에요 요즘 원영이 목소리가 갈라서서 못했을거에요
@장효은 다른멤버는 그렇다 치면서 꼭 장원영한테만 그렇다 못쳐줌ㅎㅎㅎ
@장효은 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ글쎄 격한 춤 아닌파트가 장원영 뿐이냐고ㅎㅎ
혼자서 풀발하더니 갑자기 욕하고 난리ㅜ가정교육이 시급하다 ㅜㅜ
ウォニョンペンだけど最初のパートのところは歌ってほしかったな、、、
あのチェウォンが苦戦してる、珍しい...
それくらい難しいんだろうな、声出てるだけでも凄い
みんな頑張って歌ってるんだなっていう努力が伝わる😭💓
wow Nako and Yujin are so stable. I’m kinda surprised about the members who usually are stable but their parts are really high and the choreo is so powerful, at least they tried
Nako, Yujin, Hitomi and Chaeyeon eats this CD
I'm worried about Yena, Yena was one of the most stable in IZ*ONE, I guess it's because of the dance, her parts are somewhat complicated and tired:(
When you watch her fancam of that day it is not the same as the others, she seemed very tired.
@@an_3692 true
Yena's part Choreography is not the problem
The problem is she is too tired
Also minju, yuri and Chaewon because she is out of breathe
@@imjustthin4698
Yes, honestly I love IZ*ONE's choreo but they have that typical problem of the 4th gen where they put too much effort for the choreo but less for their vocals/rap.
@@an_3692 yeah like they produce songs that doesn't fit izone's voice
Izone fiesta and panorama are so high with challenging Choreography
Not just the dance...The song is really Highpitch...Actually This sing is not really suit for their vocal tone...But it would be nice for Nako and Hitomi because they have Highpitched voice
음 높은건 둘 째 치고 홉흡 할 시간 도 없이 노래 박자가 너무 빨라...
노래가 저러면 춤이라도 좀 잔잔해야 할 텐데
춤도 빠르고, 노래도 빠르고...
채연이랑, 예나가 노래 못 부르는거 보고 좀 충격;;;
체원이랑 유리도
예나가 첫파트는 못불렀지만 다음파트부터는 부르고 노력하는데 평소에잘하던 멤버들이 헥헥될정도면 많이 힘든노래임..
게다가 이 무대는 앞에 인트로 무대도 했었어서..
이건 안무 격한것도 감안해서 봐야함 ㅜㅜ
그래도 앵콜때는 다 잘부르는거 보니 호흡하면서 노래하는게 빡세긴 한가봄
토미 나코 유진 유리 채원 채연 더 호감됌 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 이렇게 힘든데 열심히 라이브하려고 노력하네 ㅜㅜ
됌이란 단어 없어 ㅈㅂ 됨이야 됨
@@도획-e4v 알아먹긴 뭘 알아먹어 답글이 하나도 없어서 알려준건데
민주도 ㅜㅜ
なこちゃんとひぃちゃん安定してる…！特になこちゃん高音すごい。
この曲ダンス激しい上に高音
辛すぎるから、口パクでも仕方ない。
そんな中でもなこちゃんとひーちゃん
がちゃんと歌えてるのはすごいと思う。
高音域の曲は2人にもっとパートあげてもいいんじゃないかな？
7ヶ月前のコメントに失礼します
知っているかもしれませんが、声が特徴あるからこういう優雅なかっこいい曲だとなかなか多く使えなかったんだと思います。かわいい曲だと表題曲よりパート増えていたので。
nako is the most stable member in this performance. stop saying bc she got little lines. if she got little lines thats mean she had to dance more. and thats even tiring
Not counting that CY once mention that when nako dance she needs to make her move more WIDER than everyone do to her being short so she can match everyone moves which is WAY MORE TIRING 🙂
@@starry_night3738 YES THIS! Even Chaeyeon praised her for this in one of her PM during Fiesta cb I think
@@jjjjj1339 you shut up ❤
@@rose-ne1iv yea...but i'm sorry...i just want to said,everyone not stable here sweetie
Because this was not a singing live performance
Sorry if there's any wrong word🙏
My english is bad too🙏
Oh and one more thing...
panorama choreo dance is tiring and hard...so every member will not sing to their lines seriously
It happen to other kpop boy and girl group too
@@jjjjj1339 it was live
ひーなこちゃんが褒められてて嬉しい😭
1. Nako
2. Hitomi
3. Yujin
4. Others...
Nako and Hitomi sing every their lines very well, good job! Yujin almost sing her all lines too! and im impressive to Minju bcs she's tried to sing live this time!
Props to Chaewon for still trying to sing her notes
You can really hear it around 1:27 especially...she really did try, but the vocals just didn't come out just 🌬️
Yeah her parts are all hard, notes that are very high + hard choreo
she sounds exhausted but still tried singing aaah :(
wanna ask, why yujin literally can't sing😂
Yaps her part is hard
ガチで歌うのキツそう、逆によくこんな音程出るな
ねね！僕これ出る全部！ほめて！
@@user-vs7qv9mj7q ダンス練習してやってみようかなって思うけど動画あげるは違うわァ
逃げちゃったあは！
@임내동 草
@@임태랑-r1u 凄い！！！優秀！！！
@@kyo-tyan
ありがとう！
大好き！
みんな高くて声出てないけどこれが現実だよね😂よっぽど楽な音域じゃないとこんだけ踊って歌うのは不可能でしょう😔少しでも歌おうとしてくれる、ダンスで最高なパフォーマンスを見せてもらえてるので感謝です😭💕
Yujin is amazing. And considering how young she is, she’s only going to get better with experience and age. I can’t wait to see how she progresses in the future !
うちのなこちゃんはどんどん上手になるんです、、、、🥺💞
どのメンバーもこんなに激しいダンスこなしながら歌ってて凄すぎる。
この中でもチェウォン、ユジン、なこ、ひーちゃん凄いなあ。パートもあるかもだけど、本当になことひぃは口から音源🥺
I BELIEVE IN NAKO SUPREMACY
WE ALL DO
(1)
このダンスと歌の難しさで声出そうとしてくれるだけでもすごいと思う。ひぃなこ尊敬。
hitomi and nako stability is god tier
and also, yujin and chayeon's stability is also good
sorry, her name is hitomi
Hitomo wkwkw
woop
minju too, i can hear her voice
The title should be HiNako mukbang CDs.
LMFAOOOOOO
ft Yujin
u made me laugh there buddy
あのチェウォンがちょっと辛そうなんだもんね、、でもめちゃいい曲だしこんなに踊って歌えるのすごい
たまになんで歌ってないの？って怒る人いるけど高音出す時って大変だから歌えたとしても踊ってるし顔が引きつっちゃうし自分の顔の見せ方とかパフォーマンスが上手くいかないからあえて口パクと歌うとこ分けたりしてるかもしれないし、でもその中で頑張ってるユジンは凄いな応援したい！って思うけど（さくかん推し）そゆ風に思って頂きたいなら本人も歌えばいいし、パフォーマンスを見て欲しいとかそれはメンバーそれぞれだから別に口パクであろうと何であろうとキレる必要はないと思う笑そもそもパートによって歌いやすさが違うからしょうがないと思うし、それが嫌なら応援しなければいいと思うし、私はなんであろうとそれぞれのメンバーの実力は違ったとしても本人なりに全力で頑張ってる姿を応援したいからIZ*ONEのメンバーみんなが大好きです♥️
ユジンは毎回めちゃめちゃ声出してるイメージ！
ユジンってなんでも出来るしほんとすごい！
Honestly praise to Nako, Hitomi, Yujin and Chaewon. Nako and hitomi sang all of their lines, and yujin and chaewon were the only ones who sang their chorus parts.
Oops I forgot Yena also sang her chorus part sorry 😚
What do you mean about yena??!
@@Ptr867 I forgot that yena also sang her chorus part well
Only nako and Hitomi rlly sang all of their lines, yujin almost all of her lines
Chaeyeon also sang all her lines
WTF mean is oops?🤗
ウンビのパート全部音程高いよね
This is the craziest choreography, I wouldn’t sing either. Either way they tried their best for us and that’s what matters. I’m proud as a WIZ*ONE.
Yes 😭
you can literally hear them just catching their breathes most of the time, theres little to no room to even breath let alone sing.
さくちゃんが…頑張ってる…
ひぃちゃんが…安定してる…
感動…
逆にこの振り付けとキーで声出てる方が凄いわ...........
特にチェウォン、なこ、ひーちゃんはどの動画見ても絶対声出てて好きだなあ
Legends say if u hear closely u can hear “rEbeCcA bLinK MR rEmoVeD”
Only legends can hear LOL
LMAO AHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAH
SHOOT HAHAHAHAHAHAHA DUDE WHY-- 💀💀💀
lmao
LMAOKSHSHAHS
they’re really tired:( hope they rest well.
-nako yujin hiichan literally did a great job💖
(it’s really hard to sing this while dancing because it’s too high pitch)
これ歌ってるのに聞こえてないとこあるよね
ひぃなこめちゃくちゃ声出てるな
Nako and Yujin WOW
激しいダンスでみんな高いパートばかりなのにこんなにもダンスが揃ってて難しいのに安定して歌ってる子もいてパフォーマンスが美しい🤦♀️💗
こんな激しいダンスかつ高い音程。そんな中歌おうとしているところすごく感動した。
全く歌っていなかったクラが歌っていてホントに嬉しかったし最高のパフォーマンスを見せてくれて涙が出ました😭
Nako and Hitomi did well. Sakura and Hyewon improved a lot. Omgggg!
My 4 j-line haha tho hyewon is korean hehe
@@francisjaycallao2660 shes an otaku, it counts lol
@@Waender lol I love u HAHAHAHA
@@Waender love uuu
나코 히토미가 라이브 열심히 한당
i’m not even surprised that nako and hii are stable i mean for akb groups they mostly always had to sing live
they absolutely ate this tho 😌 as they should
Fyi, 48 groups are almost never sing live in Japan. Usually they're doing lipsync
@@nufarnyon no they are sing live when doing theater show, especially when in unit song
@@alyawicaksono9794 in the theatre? I'm a fan but no, they always use a back track
@@nufarnyon for their concerts they obviously sing live. since there’s so many of them their voices blend so they sound better/ you won’t be able to hear many mistakes collectively
This stage Nako, Hitomi, Yujin, Chaeyeon, Minju, Chaewon and ofc Yuri vocals really stand out.
@Samrat Gurung You can have it your way. I'll have mine. Cause I can clearly hear Minju's raw vocal, my expectations was not really high for her since she isn't part of the vocal line, but she exceeded it.
@Samrat Gurung Mindy sang her part live. And somehow stable before first chorus She even tried to sing after Chaeyeon part which is after the first chorus where everyone started to become exhausted.
これは全然酷くない。今回音程高すぎだしダンスも激しい。からしょうがない。被せで歌おうとしてくれただけありがたいです。
just smile and nod yall
アイドルやって曲出してる以上しょうがないは通じませんよ。
@@ikirntrkne
どのグループのことを言っているのか分かりませんが最近は逆に口パクで出てるヨジャグルは少ないと思いますが。
私の知ってる限りのヨジャグルの中ではかなり低レベルですよ。
@@ikirntrkne
雑食なので有名、人気と言われているグループからあまり有名じゃないグループまで色々見てます。
あなたと同じくらい色んなグループ観ていると思うので多分上手い下手の感覚が違うみたいです。
ダンス激しいのも音程高いのも分かってるけどあまりに歌わなすぎです、、、、少女時代のMR除去見てみてください。全員が音程高かろうがダンスで飛んだり激しくてもちゃんと歌ってます、、、。庇いたいのはわかるけどさすがに酷いし悲しいなって思いました。
I can fully understand why most of them aren't singing their lines, as you can see their choreography is hard and and the notes are mostly at high pitched. I'm happy to hear nako and hitomi improving every single performance, i just hope that they will be given much more lines next time. Also yujin,chaewon,yuri,minju and yena along with the other members I can hear them catching their breath just to sing their parts damn it must've been so hard for them but still BIG SALUTE FOR THEM THEY ALL DID WELL!!
Nako performed very well. Her voice was the most stable. Some members even didnt sing their parts
奈子&ひぃちゃんすごい✨
Yujin Nako deserves more lines and chorus part.
ひぃちゃん、奈子、ユジンすげぇ
ダンスが激しいんだから当然こんな感じになるよね！にしてもなこたん笑顔で踊りながら音程しっかり取れててすごいわ
Nako is pretty stable even in high key.
She should sing high-pitched chorus parts...
Okay next give nako yujin and hitomi more lines '•'
Yujin is a queen
Or give the vocal line a song in their range....
@@fgdh2460 okay but also Nako and Hitomi can get more lines tho
NAKO THAT IS THE COMMENT!!
Happy new year everyone, for me it’s still 2020 but I hope 2021 will be a very good year for all of us!
Panorama is way too high. If they lipsync I'm not gonna blame them singing an F5 note with E5 while dancing what the heck this song is way too hard. The choreography is hard especially the chorus.
Nako did it
@@gigiv5138 obviously
They always lipsync tho(not that I'm saying they are not singing live). Even i their other song pike violeta, la vie en rose
@@ei5859 true it was only in violeta and la vie en rose but they gained confidence in fiesta ssots and panorama era I'm so proud
@@ei5859 they sometimes sing live sometimes don't. I think it's actually okay to not sing live sometimes so that they won't ruin their voice especially yuri her voice was badly damaged :
チェウォン絶対しんどいのに頑張っててすごい🥲
They did really well, but they just do even better on ENCORE STAGES. IZONE ENCORE QUEENS
2:16 キー高いのにこの声量すごい😭
lets acknowledge the fact that the dance has no proper break, the song is high asf, they’re wearing high heels and if u watch the encore stage u can see that they are fully capable of hitting the notes. honestly if there was someone who could sing and dance this perfectly at the same time they aint no human
Girls generation did it what stopped them
Honestly if Chaewon had parts other than the chorus, I’m sure she would do a lot better, those chorus parts are too high to sing while dance singing😭 but Yujin, Nako, and Hitomi did a really good job here!
The notes are higher than their normal tones. So it would be harder for them. Nako and hitomi naturally have a high pitched voice.
chaewon mentioned how hard her part is, she said she coudn't find a way to breath bc the notes are high and fast
Hmmm Nako has the same notes in her parts and Hiichan too but they both sing it so it's not an excuse
@@gigiv5138 ummm no hun. Nako and hitomi are singing in their normal singing tones. The other members have to make their voice higher cuz the song is higher pitched. If chaewon had parts where she doesn't have to dance much and sing higher pitched, she would've done better.
@@jklmneojklmneo8801 again you don't know music lol Nako Hii and the other girls sing the same high notes
If i follow what you're saying that's mean Chaewon Yuri can't sing high notes like this as Nako and Hiichan then ?
I think Yujin has a lot of potential, she is clearly stable enough to sing and make her voice not crack, but I think she just can't reach her notes without making a funny face or risking a voice crack.
On the original video of this performance, people were arguing with me that all the members were singing live even though it was obviously not true, and now the MR removed shows the truth. Even members who usually kill it live couldn't keep up this time. Gotta give props to Hitomi and Nako for slaying their lines and props to Yujin, Yuri, Chaeyeon, Minju, Chaewon, and Yena for trying their best. The girls still did really well with this performance overall, even if the vocals were lacking.
yena as well she has the most difficult parts with all her dance moves etc.
@@an_3692 Hmmm, I disagree that Yena had the most difficult dance parts while singing, but I did edit my comment to add her to the list of people who tried their best 😊
@@potatopotatopotato4901
Thank you, also in your opinion who you think got most difficult parts?
I think it's Yena because she is always adding little details as well which we might not notice on the first watch, also because she is a powerfull dancer and always does her moves pretty quick.
@@an_3692 I think Chaewon's moves during the first and second chorus are more difficult to sing through bc they involve multiple chest pops and torso movements! But that's just my opinion. Regardless, I remain really proud of Nako, even if she had a more stationary torso during her parts. Like, she still did the same tiring choreography as everyone else, but somehow managed to stay clear and have good breath control when she sang!
@@MissyxAkunai I'm not sure what you're trying to say?
Dancing alone is hard but dancing AND singing is on another level especially Panorama has such a high key plus with their busy schedule but they still did so well! I'm so proud of my girlies.
Plus they look so tired
Yep totally agree they move a lot so thats why some are unstable
@So What agree... they all did good ..the moves is very hard ..its powerful.
im pretty sure they can sing this perfectly while just standing. But the dancing restricts them from doing such notes. We already know they all can sing, but they have become dependent on the loud background track that they focus more on the dancing. :
咲良が少しでも歌ってることに感動した
I only hear Chaeyeon and Yujin along with Nako and Hitomi singing
all of them tried to sing but Nako and hitomi is on another level
@@lemonjuice8834 yes youre right. Besides, the dance steps are so energetic, that's why they didnt manage to sing while dancing
And a bit of yena, a bit of yuri and a bit of chaewon
chaeyeon?????????
@@agoy7314 응
Yujin would so slay in low ranged key songs. Her voice range is almost the same as Jisoo, Jeongyeon or even Yuqi and they make her sing this high wow
And she always at least tried to sing live! That's why I love her sm and now I'm happier since she is now doing that!! In IVE she has songs on her range, and she is SLAYINGGGG
yujin is such a queen
No judging; they are humans not robots.... they do their best
ㅗ
nope lol
also 김야매공방님 means fuck you
@@나는-o3l uh what are you tryna say
@@chae1ida662 if that is doing the best there the worst singers I saw before
chaewon’s lines are HIGH AF but she still tries her best to sing them all 🥺🥺🥺
Im proud🥺
ㅠㅠ
ㅠㅠ
This song is such a high register and to add the difficult choreo of course it would be difficult to sing
This song is high af and the fact that they have to sing this while dancing to that choreo is amazing. Oh they also have been working nonstop with their full schedules
Nako ranking 6th is probably the most mysterious shit of the whole show lol
We all know she was at least top 3
They did their best, this is so hard to do. Big praise for nako and hitomi. And for chaewon yena yujin yuri they're trying even they know that it's too high .