With all due respect but it is not because of one simple reason that we CANNOT have separate tawaf area for men and women. Allah SWT has a reason behind everything. Islam promotes modesty and decency over segregation. These places form a perfect example of how Allah created these two rituals where men and women are allowed to pray together with decency and keep in mind that women are not allowed to cover their faces during hajj and umrah. Allah knows best.
Covering the face for women using face veil is prohibited by Mohammad SAW in the state of ihram (Agreed upon by scholars). Although they can cover their faces using a head cover down (ghunghat). It was narrated that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) said: The riders used to pass us when we were with the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) in ihram. When they drew close to us, one of us would let down her jilbaab from her head over her face, and when they had passed us we would uncover it again. Narrated by Ahmad, 23501; Abu Dawood, 1833; classed as hasan by al-Albaani And Allah Knows best
@@farhanmalikson Hadees you mentioned also giving same result that woman can cover their face in Ihram. Also Molana Ishaq RA said only stylish type of abaya is prohibited not the real one
I’ve seen this on documentaries about Hajj, sisters will Group together and pray together. I’d assume some sister wait to protect other sisters while they pray too…
@@Ayzeekween it’s a cramped area so we pray fardhu together with everyone, or sunat prayer after tawaf. Then move on with next ibadah. No time wasted with unnecessary things.
My humble opinion is that, during the last Hajj that Prophet Mohammed performed, he decided to preserve Prophet Ismael AS legacy and decided not to interfere with how his bloodline had evolved in that region, and kept some things undisturbed out of respect.
Ya it's true but wen we r in kabaah no gender .. Allah is testing you wit your decency sincerity diversion n your true faith ...same as we al wil be facing him during judgment day without diversion for our final results
At prayer time ok...ulbut in kaaba tawaf n all way whole unrah all will be rushing touching pushing etc happens hw is it right..I had the Q when I visited first time.. hw can it be all together like this
Aslmalkm Waraghmatullah Hiewabaraaqtu Dr Abdul Karim Zakir Naik. Shukkerieyah for Sharing Alhamdulielah yeah. Because of Zaghmah (amount of people) it is impossible to separate the males and females who are sircumbulating around the holy Kabah 7 times Alhamdulielah yeah. Nb. Each and every Hajji intend to reach out to kiss the Gajjeral Aswatt( the black stone on the Kabah) yeah. Secondly each person also Istielaam when they reach the corner of the Rukulyamanie Alhamdulielah yeah. After the Tawaaff they make 2 Rakaats Salaah at the Makaam Ebrahim and the ladies stand behind the men Alhamdulielah. Super lecture spot on 100 %mashaa Allah Dr. Zakir Naik yeah. May Allah SWT bless U and family with strong health, increased Riziek, Yaqeen, Taqwa, Imaan and true Tawaqul Allalah always In Shaa Allah. Ameen Thumma Ameen. Fia Maniella Kareem. Ma Assa Lama. 💐🤗😇🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👍🏻
@@Krkak4985thats because there were many women who had to take care of their toddlers or infants and would find it difficult to reach them during Salah
NO THE SHEIKH IS WRONG THE MOSQUE IS NOT FOR MEN ONLY ISLAM MEN PRAY IN THE FRONT WOMEN PRAY IN THE REAR THAT IS ISLAM ISLAM IS GOD GIVEN .. ISLAM IS NOT WHAT MUSLIMS MAKE IT BE FOLLOWER OF THE ISLAM AS GIVEN TO US BY THE PROPHET DO NOT SET UP SEPERATE ROOM FOR THE LADIES
are you lost? segregation is a must between men and women in islam, have you not read the quran? “And when you ˹believers˺ ask his wives for something, ask them from behind a barrier. This is purer for your hearts and theirs.” (33:53) also it’s better for women to pray at home There is no doubt that a woman’s prayer in her house is better for her than praying in the mosque, as is indicated by the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him). He said: "Do not prevent your women from going to the mosque, even though their houses are better for them." (Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Bab ma ja-a fi khuruj al-nisa ila’l-masjid: Bab al-tashdid fi dhalik. See also Sahih al-Jami‘, no. 7458) Whenever a woman prays in a place that is more private and more hidden, that is better for her, as the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: "A woman’s prayer in her house is better than her prayer in her courtyard, and her prayer in her bedroom is better than her prayer in her house." (Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Bab ma ja-a fi khuruj al-nisa ila’l-masjid. See also Sahh al-Jami‘, no. 3833).
Its called SAVING SPACE, if you follow Prophet Muhammad literally without minding the on going situation, then all mosques will then have long design to accommodate the prophet teaching of salah position What important is the core message, not exactly how it is done, not everything has to be like what prophets muhammad taught, but we will always try to be as close as possible, be a little smarter la Like for example, prophet Muhammad do fast on monday n Thursday, did you do it? He always wake up at night and do tahajud, did you do it???? How misguided are you now??? Think a little
@imranmazzarulli5293 no, my point is we don't have to do everything our prophets did, but we will always try our best to follow his teaching Not everything our prophets did is god given
If the prophet had wanted to do a seperation he would have done it. Whats wrong in making the women do tawaf in the back and the men in the front? All the things you said can also be applied to makkah. And if the authorities has decreed that segregation is necessary it is just their fatwa and not of Allah, the prophet, or the sahabas.
There is no respect during tawaf, men touching women and vice versa. I never understand how it's halal and when you come out of hiram, it's all Haram. How it's allowed that anybody can touch everyone, when they are non mahram
Most of women come with mahram like brother, husband,father so when they perform tawaf their family men guard them with their hands forming circle with hand and other men around perform tawaf with care keeping distance from non-mahram. Because you see Muslim performing tawaf from far distance like video it's look like their is no segregation but there is proper care from men and women. And all people who are performing tawaf don't have bad intension at all.
@@mohdadnankhan8281 brother I did two Ummrah myself, second one in Oct 23 so I know what I am talking about. I don't have any doubts about any body's intentions but not caring who you are touching makes me feel uncomfortable. It was so difficult not to rub shoulders with na mahram during tawaf as women didn't care. It's all has been commercialised, people were more interested in live video calls and photos. They should ban phones, same experience in Riaz ul Jannah, selfishly people were more interested in taking photos. We are commercialising our prayers exactly as our Christians brothers did.
@@Chowdhry75bro don't bother too much about someone intentions very much Allah knows well about men and women who performs haj and will get reward accordingly. If you are aware of not everyone's haj and Umrah will benefit. Them on the day of judgment.
Allah knows best of your intentions. If you saw a beautiful women then you intentionally get near her with bad intentions during tawaf, do you think Allah wouldn't know this? Allah knows everything, even what's in your heart. You can fool everyone in this world, but not Allah SWT.
It's not allowed to touch non haram no matter what the situation, but of course there is evil people that try to take advantage in crowded places and Allah will punish them heavily
That is not the answer in religion no Dalila given even of this explanation only consideration us men stand in front of women. Nowhere in Quran is it specified separation it is to ease of prayer and respect of men and women , non interference and peaceful coexistence.
,zakir sahib, aap jab mard/aurat ki ebadat alag/ karne ki baat karte hain Mirasion ko aag lag jati hay, inka bas challay tu aik doosray ki goud mein baith kr ebadat karein
Usually, Hindus go to the temple for *Murti Darshan* (viewing the deity's idol), but in a mosque, there is no idol or image to view or perform darshan. For women, going to the mosque is not obligatory; however, if the mosque has a separate area for women, they may attend. The mosque itself is like a room or a large hall where all Muslims stand in rows, facing one God.
Seperate arrangements should be made for women for pray,, In some towns, seperate places are provided.. In islamic istemas, seperate places or curtains provided..
^exactly like are you saying there's no women there ? In mosques they are with their families ...3-4 ladies together and sometimes even 6-8 ladies along with kids 😮 both needs space and wants space ...watch the end part of the video to understand better
How do you know he never try to help? Is it possible that most dalit just don't want to change their way of life? It's how their religion regulates them all their life How if Indian government won't let any help reach dalit? The current gov has Islamophobia no? Too many possibilities to create a certain conclusion
But mixing gender breaks the rules of Islam isn't it? Allah should have created a different platform for the women. Allah already knows the population will increase and the area for hajj is limited ... Has Allah got wrong? (What if this is the question of a non Muslim)
@@luffytaro5951 brother,,I know Allah knows best,,,,, I'm just asking what if a non Muslim ask this question,,, you have to give him a convincing answer right
Jesus was just w prophet not a God. He himself bowed down and pray to the one God. God in the language of Jesus was alao said as "illah" (in Aramaic language)
Whoever reads this please pray for health of Sabiha and Rasheed, Jazakallah
Who are they?
What happened to them ?
May Allāh the As Salaam grant them complete shifaa.
With all due respect but it is not because of one simple reason that we CANNOT have separate tawaf area for men and women. Allah SWT has a reason behind everything. Islam promotes modesty and decency over segregation. These places form a perfect example of how Allah created these two rituals where men and women are allowed to pray together with decency and keep in mind that women are not allowed to cover their faces during hajj and umrah.
Allah knows best.
you are correct
on covering of women face there are different openions. Some people covered the face
Covering the face for women using face veil is prohibited by Mohammad SAW in the state of ihram (Agreed upon by scholars). Although they can cover their faces using a head cover down (ghunghat).
It was narrated that ‘Aa’ishah (may Allah be pleased with her) said: The riders used to pass us when we were with the Messenger of Allah (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) in ihram. When they drew close to us, one of us would let down her jilbaab from her head over her face, and when they had passed us we would uncover it again.
Narrated by Ahmad, 23501; Abu Dawood, 1833; classed as hasan by al-Albaani
And Allah Knows best
@@farhanmalikson Hadees you mentioned also giving same result that woman can cover their face in Ihram. Also Molana Ishaq RA said only stylish type of abaya is prohibited not the real one
@@farhanmalikson
I’m a woman and we pray separately in front of kaabah in mekah
I’ve seen this on documentaries about Hajj, sisters will Group together and pray together. I’d assume some sister wait to protect other sisters while they pray too…
@@Ayzeekween it’s a cramped area so we pray fardhu together with everyone, or sunat prayer after tawaf. Then move on with next ibadah. No time wasted with unnecessary things.
Sir Your Holy Journey
Is Never ENDING One
Mashallah...
May God bless you always❤
We pray separately in Mecca and while doing tawaaf we do with our family members Alhamdulillah
Alhamdulillah Dr Zakir put on God is with you
I also think about it.
Thanks for asking Sir, God bless you!
The thumbnail
Me - now that’s a good question brother
My humble opinion is that, during the last Hajj that Prophet Mohammed performed, he decided to preserve Prophet Ismael AS legacy and decided not to interfere with how his bloodline had evolved in that region, and kept some things undisturbed out of respect.
Because we are all the Same. No color, appearance, Status or gender has Any meaning infront of allah
@imranmazzarulli5293 did you restart your computer brother
@imranmazzarulli5293 Read the Hadith with Aisha (r) lying in front of the prophet while he was praying.
Thank you for the explanation
Ya it's true but wen we r in kabaah no gender .. Allah is testing you wit your decency sincerity diversion n your true faith ...same as we al wil be facing him during judgment day without diversion for our final results
This is the best reply so far. Bārakallāhu feek
Love you Dr Zakir Naik sir
At prayer time ok...ulbut in kaaba tawaf n all way whole unrah all will be rushing touching pushing etc happens hw is it right..I had the Q when I visited first time.. hw can it be all together like this
Then I thought the judgement day is also same may me everybody in white running taking their deeds with them
Ma sha Allah
How about two different families sharing same room during hajj does shariat permit this
No, its an individual act and its forbidden, its a sin.
May ALLAH reward you ameen.May ALLAH forgive and accept us ameen.
Aslmalkm Waraghmatullah Hiewabaraaqtu Dr Abdul Karim Zakir Naik. Shukkerieyah for Sharing Alhamdulielah yeah. Because of Zaghmah (amount of people) it is impossible to separate the males and females who are sircumbulating around the holy Kabah 7 times Alhamdulielah yeah. Nb. Each and every Hajji intend to reach out to kiss the Gajjeral Aswatt( the black stone on the Kabah) yeah. Secondly each person also Istielaam when they reach the corner of the Rukulyamanie Alhamdulielah yeah. After the Tawaaff they make 2 Rakaats Salaah at the Makaam Ebrahim and the ladies stand behind the men Alhamdulielah. Super lecture spot on 100 %mashaa Allah Dr. Zakir Naik yeah. May Allah SWT bless U and family with strong health, increased Riziek, Yaqeen, Taqwa, Imaan and true Tawaqul Allalah always In Shaa Allah. Ameen Thumma Ameen. Fia Maniella Kareem. Ma Assa Lama. 💐🤗😇🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻👍🏻
During the time of the prophet there was no segregation.
Really ?
@@abcdefghij2724 The best row for men was front row. And for women was back row
@@Krkak4985thats because there were many women who had to take care of their toddlers or infants and would find it difficult to reach them during Salah
@@Krkak4985 Yes, but if she wanted to ask the prophet something, she could come directly to his prayer place. She wasn't excluded in an own room.
@@MrStark-zy6cd Nah! It was for a different reason. One way of segregation actually
NO
THE SHEIKH IS WRONG
THE MOSQUE IS NOT FOR MEN ONLY
ISLAM
MEN PRAY IN THE FRONT
WOMEN PRAY IN THE REAR
THAT IS ISLAM
ISLAM IS GOD GIVEN ..
ISLAM IS NOT WHAT MUSLIMS MAKE IT
BE FOLLOWER OF THE ISLAM AS GIVEN TO US BY THE PROPHET
DO NOT SET UP SEPERATE ROOM FOR THE LADIES
are you lost? segregation is a must between men and women in islam, have you not read the quran?
“And when you ˹believers˺ ask his wives for something, ask them from behind a barrier. This is purer for your hearts and theirs.”
(33:53)
also it’s better for women to pray at home
There is no doubt that a woman’s prayer in her house is better for her than praying in the mosque, as is indicated by the Sunnah of the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him). He said: "Do not prevent your women from going to the mosque, even though their houses are better for them." (Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Bab ma ja-a fi khuruj al-nisa ila’l-masjid: Bab al-tashdid fi dhalik. See also Sahih al-Jami‘, no. 7458)
Whenever a woman prays in a place that is more private and more hidden, that is better for her, as the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) said: "A woman’s prayer in her house is better than her prayer in her courtyard, and her prayer in her bedroom is better than her prayer in her house." (Reported by Abu Dawud in al-Sunan, Bab ma ja-a fi khuruj al-nisa ila’l-masjid. See also Sahh al-Jami‘, no. 3833).
stop misguiding people, the one who misguides carries the sin of the one who follows
Its called SAVING SPACE, if you follow Prophet Muhammad literally without minding the on going situation, then all mosques will then have long design to accommodate the prophet teaching of salah position
What important is the core message, not exactly how it is done, not everything has to be like what prophets muhammad taught, but we will always try to be as close as possible, be a little smarter la
Like for example, prophet Muhammad do fast on monday n Thursday, did you do it? He always wake up at night and do tahajud, did you do it???? How misguided are you now??? Think a little
@imranmazzarulli5293 no, my point is we don't have to do everything our prophets did, but we will always try our best to follow his teaching
Not everything our prophets did is god given
Women are rewarded more for praying at home, while men it's the opposite.
If the prophet had wanted to do a seperation he would have done it. Whats wrong in making the women do tawaf in the back and the men in the front? All the things you said can also be applied to makkah. And if the authorities has decreed that segregation is necessary it is just their fatwa and not of Allah, the prophet, or the sahabas.
There is no respect during tawaf, men touching women and vice versa. I never understand how it's halal and when you come out of hiram, it's all Haram. How it's allowed that anybody can touch everyone, when they are non mahram
Most of women come with mahram like brother, husband,father so when they perform tawaf their family men guard them with their hands forming circle with hand and other men around perform tawaf with care keeping distance from non-mahram. Because you see Muslim performing tawaf from far distance like video it's look like their is no segregation but there is proper care from men and women. And all people who are performing tawaf don't have bad intension at all.
@@mohdadnankhan8281 brother I did two Ummrah myself, second one in Oct 23 so I know what I am talking about. I don't have any doubts about any body's intentions but not caring who you are touching makes me feel uncomfortable. It was so difficult not to rub shoulders with na mahram during tawaf as women didn't care. It's all has been commercialised, people were more interested in live video calls and photos. They should ban phones, same experience in Riaz ul Jannah, selfishly people were more interested in taking photos. We are commercialising our prayers exactly as our Christians brothers did.
@@Chowdhry75bro don't bother too much about someone intentions very much Allah knows well about men and women who performs haj and will get reward accordingly. If you are aware of not everyone's haj and Umrah will benefit. Them on the day of judgment.
Allah knows best of your intentions. If you saw a beautiful women then you intentionally get near her with bad intentions during tawaf, do you think Allah wouldn't know this? Allah knows everything, even what's in your heart. You can fool everyone in this world, but not Allah SWT.
It's not allowed to touch non haram no matter what the situation, but of course there is evil people that try to take advantage in crowded places and Allah will punish them heavily
not satisfactionary answer
there is no segregation in islam proper
That is not the answer in religion no Dalila given even of this explanation only consideration us men stand in front of women. Nowhere in Quran is it specified separation it is to ease of prayer and respect of men and women , non interference and peaceful coexistence.
,zakir sahib, aap jab mard/aurat ki ebadat alag/ karne ki baat karte hain Mirasion ko aag lag jati hay, inka bas challay tu aik doosray ki goud mein baith kr ebadat karein
Not correct answer, Dr. Just move the question to other way and confused people
He clearly answered the question you listen properly or may you do not hold complete knowledge
Indian has asked this question but he should have asked why women don't come to the prayers in Indian subcontint.
Because there is no space for women in majority masjids in india and plus the maulana here prevent women from coming to masjid and say to pray in home
Usually, Hindus go to the temple for *Murti Darshan* (viewing the deity's idol), but in a mosque, there is no idol or image to view or perform darshan. For women, going to the mosque is not obligatory; however, if the mosque has a separate area for women, they may attend. The mosque itself is like a room or a large hall where all Muslims stand in rows, facing one God.
Seperate arrangements should be made for women for pray,, In some towns, seperate places are provided.. In islamic istemas, seperate places or curtains provided..
Why women Are not allowed in subcontinent.
^exactly like are you saying there's no women there ? In mosques they are with their families ...3-4 ladies together and sometimes even 6-8 ladies along with kids 😮 both needs space and wants space ...watch the end part of the video to understand better
Its all wrong!!!!! Its sooooo wrong what they have put there may not where religion!!!!! Also the mosque ate not mosques
Get to the point brother...can understand ur language
mouse ate mosque?
Drunk?
are you high?
Kehna kya chahtay ho😂
Mekka is universal gathering 3rd gender
why mr zakir never help dalit people, he will be questioned in hereafter for that
You can approach him for that .
He will direct you who can help.
What kind of help
@@Zoeee93 religion of course, because hindu put them there.
How do you know he never try to help?
Is it possible that most dalit just don't want to change their way of life? It's how their religion regulates them all their life
How if Indian government won't let any help reach dalit? The current gov has Islamophobia no?
Too many possibilities to create a certain conclusion
his voice has become squeaky.
But mixing gender breaks the rules of Islam isn't it? Allah should have created a different platform for the women. Allah already knows the population will increase and the area for hajj is limited ... Has Allah got wrong? (What if this is the question of a non Muslim)
Allah knows best, do you know better than Allah?
it's meant to be done like that, having another platform?? there cant be two kabahs..
@@syedyousafbukhari2213 exactly, couldn't have said it better myself.
@@luffytaro5951
@@luffytaro5951 brother,,I know Allah knows best,,,,, I'm just asking what if a non Muslim ask this question,,, you have to give him a convincing answer right
You’re full of lies, this doesn’t is answer the question gentleman asked.
Jesus Christ inviting all Humans to become the Spiritual Children of the True God... Because True God is the Spiritual Father of Christians...!!!
Astagfirullah 😔😔😔😔
Stop this false talk........
Jesus was just w prophet not a God. He himself bowed down and pray to the one God. God in the language of Jesus was alao said as "illah" (in Aramaic language)
@@GalaxyTraveller1Yes exactly...
Without any doubt...
Maa shaa Allah