they should have stocked more, they knew it would sell out. it took minutes. i was on at 10am, in "line" at 3 after, and one of the items sold out at 6 after, before i got to my turn to check out. i was so annoyed. thats poor planning from them. or intentional.
Thanks Amanda for doing the comparisons! It’s helped jog my memory of what other palettes, Colourpop or not, that can provide those pinky Valentine vibes. Between Nomad’s Verona Love and Death, Natasha Denona’s Love palette (and mini Love) and CP’s Ooh LaLa (which I never touch anymore and is old enough I am contemplating decluttering it), I think I’m set for pink tones. But I understand not everyone has every palette and sometimes it’s just hard to visualize when one is similar to another without the swatch comparison so please keep on doing them- it’s a public service even if your poor arm disagrees. If I pick up anything. I think it will be the middle Jelly Much shadow as I like that pinky purple and don’t think I have anything like it.
Thank you for the awesome review, such a cute collection! Im interested in the twilight highlighters but Im waiting for your comparisons first. Im wondering if the pink one is similar to the ones from the Aurora struck collection.
im totaly eyeing the jelly muchs and the cream blush... was hoping it comes to ulta because i want to see the cream blush shades in person to make sure i dont already have a shade similar... but now i see they all look the same.
I really want the All Love, sponge, Adore You… the lip and cheek balms surprised me. You stopped me from buying 2 lol They should’ve made the darker one even darker. The palette is pretty but it’s just missing maybe more pops of the peach or orange? I feel the same about it too. I actually don’t have any of the comparison palettes so I might pick it up! I don’t own any of their Valentine’s palettes either.
I love Colourpop & I love the heart shaped blushes & I super duper love cream blushes! I'm super excited about this one. I'm definitely disappointed to see how similar they look. I've been a huge fan of the Moira cream blushes. Hopefully Colourpop will take a note from them & expand their color range. Thanks for the video!
Well as a result of this video I purchased one balm blush, the trio of jelly much shadows, one gloss and oh Amanda I broke down and got the palette. But hear me out! I don’t have any of the other CP palettes like it or any eyeshadow palette at all with that color story. It is pretty and filled a gap in my collection rather reasonably. Thanks for the jelly shadow tip!❤
The sponge is adorable! I feel like I’d treat it more like a toy than an actual sponge. I want pieces but not the whole collection. I’m not a pink / red eyeshadow fan, but I think the theme is spot on.
The last few years I’ve been so excited about the Valentine’s Day collections but this is the first year that I didn’t get the palette. I just have so much in my collection and it didn’t speak to me as much. I ended up getting the cute sponge, the Lover Era Ultra Glossy Lip and the Cutesy Wootsy Cheek and Lip Blush. I’m glad that Colourpop listened to their fans and decided to release collections less frequently because I love Colourpop but it was really hurting my bank account! I have notes on all of my products so I can keep inventory and I have 4 palettes from 2018 or earlier, 18 from 2019, 29 from 2020, 47 in 2021, 14 from 2022, and only 6 from 2023! I felt like they’ve been pretty lackluster last year but it helped out my bank account lol. Still, I hope they release some really special collections this year! I usually love the collaborations and I can’t wait to see how they collaborate with next!
wow! I actually want a lot of the things in this collection, which never happens with color pop. I think I will get one of the lip and cheeks, the mid tone one, two of the jelly much shadows, and the sponge!
Thanks for posting the comparisons! I look forward to Valentine’s Day palettes every year because I love red makeup. However, I already have the It’s All Good palette and I like the colors better. Plus, it reminds me that I would love to find an affordable palette with a full red/berry/orange vibe. So, this helps me to love what I have and look for what I truly want.
Thank you for the critique on the blushes. It would be such a bummer to get three dupes. They should have done pink, red, plum and maybe a shimmery balm highlighter.
Pink is my favorite color, however I don't wear it on my eyes all the time. That being said, I already own the BH Cosmetics Mimosa palette, Huda Beauty Mercury Retrograde, Main Squeeze, Devinah Cosmetic singles, and have several pink super shock shadows. Therefore, I don't need anymore pink eyeshadows. But I still enjoy watching your reviews! 💖
Good afternoon, Amanda! Happy Wednesday! Excited to hear your thoughts. I only purchased the cream blush balm set and the Lovers Era gloss. I hope you have an amazing day 😊
I got sent this collection in PR and I completely agree about the blush balms - and my skintone is probably a bit lighter than yours! I sincerely hope that no one buys more than one. xD I agree that a coral or a deep burgundy would have been soooo gorgeous!
Love your eyeshadow look at around 10:33 when you're trying on the Cutesy Wootsy! Is that silvery eyeshadow also from ColourPop? Any recommendation of this similar colour from this brand? Thank you!
Do that many people do beige lip colors? Its always pink, a darker pink or cooler red and beige when a starter trio. A gloss I guess, but even lipstick seem to.
Nudes/beiges tend to be really popular in my experience but those are also my favorite kinds of colors to wear so maybe I have some confirmation bias there!
Things I want to see from Colourpop this year are more foiled metallics in palettes and no more pearlescent glitter 😂 (or not in every palette, at least.) I know it’s better than the old glitter but still, not a huge fan. Also hoping a new complexion product. Since they discontinued no filter line, I hope they have something new for people who like soft matte finish. I think matte finish is making a comeback this year! I was tempted by the Valentine’s Day palette because it just looks SO cute, but after seeing your swatches and comparison I decided I don’t need it! I agree with you, instead of satin shimmer I would want more foiled metallic, and more depth. Jelly much shadows look beautiful though! Maybe when they go on sale. Thanks for a thorough review as always ❤
I'd also rather wear blue eyeshadow than pink 😁 The only time I like pinks are used along purples 😀 BTW I wore a true blue look yesterday with ColourPop Antimatter and Lost And Found, which was strange but pretty 😀 Love your faaaaace ❤
I really like the palette! But admittedly that's because I think the packaging is so cute 😂 the hearts make me think of Travis Japan's Candy Kiss music video. I have so many similar shimmers though so I'm staying strong against the allure of the hearts lol. Since this palette doesn't come with eye safety warnings, does this mean the red shadows don't stain?
They did do nail polishes a long, long time ago 🤣 I know shipping is complicated for nail polishes because of restrictions so I wonder if that plays a role in their decision to discontinue those 😅
Waiting for the Twilight restock. Not because I like Twilight, but love that color story!!!
Yes!!! It's such a cool collection, although I'm a fan of the Twilight movies so I know I have some nostalgia bias there 🤣
I also have a Twilight bias but I think the palette is really interesting! I need that restock to come.
Same here
100% same!
they should have stocked more, they knew it would sell out. it took minutes. i was on at 10am, in "line" at 3 after, and one of the items sold out at 6 after, before i got to my turn to check out. i was so annoyed. thats poor planning from them. or intentional.
Amanda, you make any pallet look good!
Aww thank you! ❤️
This collection is so cute. I love the jelly much shadows
I agree! I'm really happy to see ColourPop starting off strong this year 😍
Looking good I admire you ❤️❤️😊😊
Thanks Amanda for doing the comparisons! It’s helped jog my memory of what other palettes, Colourpop or not, that can provide those pinky Valentine vibes. Between Nomad’s Verona Love and Death, Natasha Denona’s Love palette (and mini Love) and CP’s Ooh LaLa (which I never touch anymore and is old enough I am contemplating decluttering it), I think I’m set for pink tones. But I understand not everyone has every palette and sometimes it’s just hard to visualize when one is similar to another without the swatch comparison so please keep on doing them- it’s a public service even if your poor arm disagrees. If I pick up anything. I think it will be the middle Jelly Much shadow as I like that pinky purple and don’t think I have anything like it.
Thank you for the awesome review, such a cute collection!
Im interested in the twilight highlighters but Im waiting for your comparisons first. Im wondering if the pink one is similar to the ones from the Aurora struck collection.
The lip glosses do look fairly close and most definitely the blushes do! Very helpful, thanks!
Glad it was helpful!
Wow, it really resembles my It’s All Good, did not expect that. Very helpful, thank you!
I’m a red eyeshadow fiend, but, alas, I already own a few iterations of this palette from Colourpop. Thanks for the comparisons! ❤
I haven't tried anything from colourpop in a long time I want to try one of their jelly eyeshadows they look so pretty much 💙💛❤💚💜
I am most excited about all love, it remiinds me of desert days from the succulent collection and I am running out of it and love it
im totaly eyeing the jelly muchs and the cream blush... was hoping it comes to ulta because i want to see the cream blush shades in person to make sure i dont already have a shade similar... but now i see they all look the same.
Whoa! Love your nails!!
I really want the All Love, sponge, Adore You… the lip and cheek balms surprised me. You stopped me from buying 2 lol They should’ve made the darker one even darker. The palette is pretty but it’s just missing maybe more pops of the peach or orange? I feel the same about it too. I actually don’t have any of the comparison palettes so I might pick it up! I don’t own any of their Valentine’s palettes either.
I was waiting for this ❤
I love Colourpop & I love the heart shaped blushes & I super duper love cream blushes! I'm super excited about this one. I'm definitely disappointed to see how similar they look. I've been a huge fan of the Moira cream blushes. Hopefully Colourpop will take a note from them & expand their color range. Thanks for the video!
Well as a result of this video I purchased one balm blush, the trio of jelly much shadows, one gloss and oh Amanda I broke down and got the palette. But hear me out! I don’t have any of the other CP palettes like it or any eyeshadow palette at all with that color story. It is pretty and filled a gap in my collection rather reasonably. Thanks for the jelly shadow tip!❤
Yay! Happy to help you decide what will work best for you! 🥰
You are the only one who swatches all three blushes on your face! ✨Everyone else swatches on their arm and it’s been so hard so compare colors😭
The sponge is adorable! I feel like I’d treat it more like a toy than an actual sponge. I want pieces but not the whole collection. I’m not a pink / red eyeshadow fan, but I think the theme is spot on.
Your nail polish color 😍 ❤
I'm not usually a pink polish girlie, but this color is really fun!
The last few years I’ve been so excited about the Valentine’s Day collections but this is the first year that I didn’t get the palette. I just have so much in my collection and it didn’t speak to me as much. I ended up getting the cute sponge, the Lover Era Ultra Glossy Lip and the Cutesy Wootsy Cheek and Lip Blush. I’m glad that Colourpop listened to their fans and decided to release collections less frequently because I love Colourpop but it was really hurting my bank account! I have notes on all of my products so I can keep inventory and I have 4 palettes from 2018 or earlier, 18 from 2019, 29 from 2020, 47 in 2021, 14 from 2022, and only 6 from 2023! I felt like they’ve been pretty lackluster last year but it helped out my bank account lol. Still, I hope they release some really special collections this year! I usually love the collaborations and I can’t wait to see how they collaborate with next!
I hope these 3 releases from January (multi chrome liners, Twilight, and Lost in Love) are setting the tone for 2024!
wow! I actually want a lot of the things in this collection, which never happens with color pop. I think I will get one of the lip and cheeks, the mid tone one, two of the jelly much shadows, and the sponge!
They really are starting off strong this year!
Thanks for posting the comparisons! I look forward to Valentine’s Day palettes every year because I love red makeup. However, I already have the It’s All Good palette and I like the colors better. Plus, it reminds me that I would love to find an affordable palette with a full red/berry/orange vibe. So, this helps me to love what I have and look for what I truly want.
This is so pretty! I hope this comes to Ulta so I can more easily justify the splurge.
Thank you for the critique on the blushes. It would be such a bummer to get three dupes. They should have done pink, red, plum and maybe a shimmery balm highlighter.
Pink is my favorite color, however I don't wear it on my eyes all the time. That being said, I already own the BH Cosmetics Mimosa palette, Huda Beauty Mercury Retrograde, Main Squeeze, Devinah Cosmetic singles, and have several pink super shock shadows. Therefore, I don't need anymore pink eyeshadows. But I still enjoy watching your reviews! 💖
Good afternoon, Amanda! Happy Wednesday! Excited to hear your thoughts. I only purchased the cream blush balm set and the Lovers Era gloss. I hope you have an amazing day 😊
That's Freaky!!! Lol 😂😂😂 omh thanks for sharing about the check examples lol !!! Love the eyeshadow wow
They had free international shipping yesterday and I caved and got the palette. I usually wait for a sale but I couldn’t wait! I also used your code ❤
when i saw this collection being promoted i thought of you first. it seemed made for you as far as the types of formulas they were choosing.
when you apply the cheek balm do they emphasize your texture & pores
I got sent this collection in PR and I completely agree about the blush balms - and my skintone is probably a bit lighter than yours! I sincerely hope that no one buys more than one. xD I agree that a coral or a deep burgundy would have been soooo gorgeous!
Love your eyeshadow look at around 10:33 when you're trying on the Cutesy Wootsy! Is that silvery eyeshadow also from ColourPop? Any recommendation of this similar colour from this brand? Thank you!
I was about to post the same thing! LOVE that eye look! It looked great with the pink! Would love to know what you are wearing! Thanks!
Thank you! It's not ColourPop, it's a newer indie palette and I will have a video with tutorial for that look soon!
Do that many people do beige lip colors? Its always pink, a darker pink or cooler red and beige when a starter trio. A gloss I guess, but even lipstick seem to.
Nudes/beiges tend to be really popular in my experience but those are also my favorite kinds of colors to wear so maybe I have some confirmation bias there!
I have been stalking Ulta. The SA’s told me they “have not heard of any new Colourpop Collections scheduled for delivery/stocking”😢
I'll see if I can get some more info about Ulta releases + restocks 😄
I would really want it in Ulta but if it’s past January then I might not.
You may not care for the bright colors, but they are super flattering on you
Thank you! I love bright colors, just not a huge fan of pink on me 😅
Things I want to see from Colourpop this year are more foiled metallics in palettes and no more pearlescent glitter 😂 (or not in every palette, at least.) I know it’s better than the old glitter but still, not a huge fan. Also hoping a new complexion product. Since they discontinued no filter line, I hope they have something new for people who like soft matte finish. I think matte finish is making a comeback this year!
I was tempted by the Valentine’s Day palette because it just looks SO cute, but after seeing your swatches and comparison I decided I don’t need it! I agree with you, instead of satin shimmer I would want more foiled metallic, and more depth. Jelly much shadows look beautiful though! Maybe when they go on sale. Thanks for a thorough review as always ❤
You know that I am with you 100000% on that... I would trade every pearlescent glitter for foiled metallic from now on!
Your nails 😍
Very curious where you got your huge ring you're wearing on ur middle finger? It's gorgeous! What kind of stone is that?
Thank you! It’s a rainbow moonstone… I’ve had it for close to 20 years so I don’t remember where I got 😅
I like that at least there is a LITTLE variance. I felt like Cherry Crush and Lost in Love were the same color with no difference.
Boy, even though you didn’t love the color of those lip/cheek balms, you still made me want them BAD! 😂
I'd also rather wear blue eyeshadow than pink 😁 The only time I like pinks are used along purples 😀
BTW I wore a true blue look yesterday with ColourPop Antimatter and Lost And Found, which was strange but pretty 😀
Love your faaaaace ❤
Antimatter is such a good shade!!
@@MakeupJustForFun Right?! 😃 I had never thought to use it with Earthshine until you made that Zodiac Air sign BYOP... they were so pretty together ❤
When did Glam Right palette release? I don’t know that one but I like it…not sure how I missed it. Doesn’t look like it’s available anywhere. 😢
I really like the palette! But admittedly that's because I think the packaging is so cute 😂 the hearts make me think of Travis Japan's Candy Kiss music video. I have so many similar shimmers though so I'm staying strong against the allure of the hearts lol.
Since this palette doesn't come with eye safety warnings, does this mean the red shadows don't stain?
They didn't stain me but that usually isn't an issue for my lids, especially with the matte primer I use!
@@MakeupJustForFunThanks for responding! ❤
I would like an NHL palette launch like they did with NBA!
I don't think the NBA collection did super well, I know a lot of the stuff stuck around on sale for a long time 😰
@@MakeupJustForFun i know. That's why there will not be anything NHL related hahaha
I want the blush but not enough to pay shipping, so I'll only get them if it comes to Ulta
Etsy should really get a handle on their sellers. Drop shipping with cheap golds sucks
Especially for the amount of fees we pay as sellers, I wish some of that (or more of it) would be budgeted for cleaning up the drop ship junk!
What’s the best way to rehydrate the jelly much shadows? I have quite a few which are dried out
Just add water!
This is going to make me break out some old CP pallettes!
Yay! That is awesome!
How can the jelly much shadows be rehydrated?
Just add water!
I wish they would go back to the smaller pans. I don't need bigger pans. And I hope they completely ditch the matte with glitter formula.
Instead of glitter gels, why doesn’t Colourpop start doing nail polish strips or a nail polish line? I would love that glitter on my fingers!
They did do nail polishes a long, long time ago 🤣 I know shipping is complicated for nail polishes because of restrictions so I wonder if that plays a role in their decision to discontinue those 😅