Allah sent 124,000 prophets and messengers (peace be upon them all) throughout human history, there could have been a prophet sent to them for their era and time back then, nevertheless Prophet Muhammad pbuh is the last and final messenger during our current time and era
ATTENTION!! Where will you go when you die, Heaven or Hell? We can not hide our sins from God. Jesus Christ loves you and He died for our sins, three days later, He arose from the grave... Jesus is alive... REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Only the salvation of Jesus Christ can save you from the fires of Hell. ACTS 2:38 “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
@@youtube_chaplain God does not die get out of that mindset and start worshipping one God. Like how Jesus prayed. God of Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammed (place be upon them all)
but isn't this funny.. like god didn't make up his mind with earlier religions or he didn't protect his message or he was doing a trial and error or what ??? it is evident that there were all copying from a source.. all from one source and modifying the message as they went by.
God gave us the will to choose. Most people who recieved the truth twisted the truth to meet their desires. That was their choice. But God is also the disposer of all wills in existence. The turn of events that transpired is all part of his infinite wisdom on how everything gets ordained. There WERE true monotheists from the christians, jews, zoroastrians and most probably even buddhist believers from the very start. Any religion that delves into God's existence and his higher power all have the innate belief in him (fitra), its just that the adherent's parents and society raise them differently. Every child that is born with a clean unbias state already believes in one God as a higher power. There is an interesting verse in the quran in which God said "And had your Lord willed, those on earth would have believed - all of them entirely. Then, [O Muhammad], would you compel the people in order that they become believers?" 10:99 as well as 29:2 "Do people think once they say, “We believe,” that they will be left without being put to the test?" and "He who created death and life to test you as to which of you is best in deed, and He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving." (Quran 67:2) the very definition of Good is the absense of Evil, like wise with truth, which is the absense of falsehood. Thats why we have many religions and ways of life, but only Islam is the only path to salvation. Every other religion praises something created, or defiles God's attributes. islam is the only true monotheistic faith on earth in which no image or symbol takes precedence, only the One God (Allah) who is outside of our realm.
@@MAYONNAISEMOOSE well said! It was indeed a TEST for those nations to check their whims and desires if they are going to manipulate the word of The creator given to them! They did and failed, many times over the course of history, till Quran was finally revealed and was the final Message to Humanity to get back on track as the last chance, May Allah protect us all and guide us Ameen
@@KBH4ameen. As said Islam teaches that God sent prophets to guide all people throughout history, each bringing a message of truth and moral guidance. Instead of thinking that Islam was influenced by earlier religions, consider that God might have influenced many people to be prophets, each sent to different communities with a similar core message: to believe in one God and live righteously. In this view, figures like Zarathustra could be part of a broader, divine plan, where God reached out to all people in various ways, not just in the Middle East. Islam respects this concept, seeing itself as a continuation and preservation of this universal message.
So if all religions were sent by god why did the Arab Muslims invade Persia which was already practicing a religion sent by god and why did they force them to accept Islam or else face persecution?
The Zoroastrian religion is a curious one. When you read the Avesta, you get the sense that it switches from a pantheon based religion to a monotheist one where the Ashura who were described as Gods are now considered as angels. BTW the Mazda car brand takes it's name from Ahura Mazda, the name of God in Zoroastrianism
In QUran GOD said HE send Prophets to every Nation SO later after Prophets died people , Monks, Priests , Kings changes the word of GOD for their worldly gains and benefits SO it got mixed , lost , partially lost etc Thats why you will found the similarities in every religions and GOD in Quran never said Islam is new religion But it is old religion started from the first human Adam Pbuh But later people change it so GOD send Prophets through out human history now last revival of the Message has been done through the Last Prophet Muhammad Pbuh and the message has been protected by GOD , and this is the reason we have only One Quran since Prophet Muhammad pbuh time
Thats because Islam is based off of something that was based off of something that WAS the true relegion. Zoroastrianism was inspired by Daniel in ancient Persia. Daniel is a Israelite prophet in the Bible who predicted the Messiah and Savior Jesus Christ and the end of the world. So how can the Quran by the full truth if its origin is in the Bible?
Muslims already believe that some old gods were actually not gods but ancient prophets of Allah. Imagine mighty prophet Thor and his hammer, an artifact with importance similar to the staff of Moses, the ring of Solomon and the sword of Ali.
How come Islam only resembles religions in its direct environment like Christianity and Zoroastrianism? And why doesn’t it resemble religions in the Americas, Scandinavia or far East Asia? Wouldn’t the stronger case be that Islam is a copy of its surroundings, in stead of the last testament?
Certainly, what you share is a valid point. We Humans have the deveils-own-time working to keep our worshipful practices focused on Allah, but inevitably, they reflect our cultures and surroundings. Speaking only for myself, it has been difficult to strive to be a good Muslim and not necessarily a good Arab or even a good Salafi. Often times, I will counter-balance something I have heard about a Muslim practice, by investigating how the same practice is observed in, say, Malaysia or South America. You will agree, I think, that a belief such as Christianity or Judaism are much influenced by the areas and cultures in which they are practiced.
copy? there are many stories in Quran that you can't find in the bible or any scripture in the world. Not only that there are scientific miracle verse in Quran that you can't find in the Bible (it's not make sense because bible is full of scientific errors) or any science paper at the time.
@TheTruth. For myself, I have been content to believe that Holy Scriptures such as the Tanakh and the Quran are Not meant to be literally interpreted Intellectually, but interpreted Intuitively. I see this also in many Buddhist traditions (see: sutra) as well as Taoism and even Animism. In all of these traditions I find that trying to use Reason and Logic after the fashion of many Christian denominations only serves to distract and confuse from the Truths being expressed. IMVVHO.
ATTENTION!! Where will you go when you die, Heaven or Hell? We can not hide our sins from God. Jesus Christ loves you and He died for our sins, three days later, He arose from the grave... Jesus is alive... REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Only the salvation of Jesus Christ can save you from the fires of Hell. ACTS 2:38 “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
@@youtube_chaplain jesus❤ was a prophet. Jesus ate food and went to toilet. God doesn't go to toilet. God doesn't need human sacrifice to forgive. Open your heart and accept the truth. Deny the church, they follow falsehood.
@@DonDiiiii BEWARE!!! You are denying Christ Jesus as Lord, when you say that He was only a prophet. Jesus Christ is the only savior for the world, he is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. There will be no second chance for you then. Place your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Have a great day!
@@youtube_chaplain As a former Catholic, I'm denying Jesus Christ as God or a " God, divinity, etc... " and have no problem doing so. Hope this helps you trying to impose your faith on others. As many Christians tend to do so.
It is no secret that Salman Farsi, who used to be a Zoroastrian, was one of Muhammad's close friends. It is even mentioned in the Quran that some people said to Muhammad that there is a non-Arab person who teaches you these words (Quran)! That is why Islam has that many infusions from Zoroastrians!
Them praying 5 times a day was added to their religion after Islam so you cant say Islam is influenced by them and Many ayahs were already revealed at that time
The Quran is extremely filled with patterns and matematical miracles while conserving deep meaning and staying elocent. Moreover, those things weren’t even known by the compagnon because they lacked the knowledge to appreciate it . Only after modern history we start seeing this . If it was truly written by men, they would have boasted and show off those matematical patterns , but no one ever did. It is clearly a work of God impossible to be set with a human mind . God knew we will start seing the patterns years after and put them for our generation. This is one argument among many many others that Muhammad was a true prophet and the Quran is not from Him .
The interesting thing about the Avesta is that it contains both Pre-Zoroastrian (Yashts) and post Zoroaster (Vendidad) texts, which are not always representative of the original (and only) text by Zarathustra (Gathas). Hence, it has elements of Old Iranian religion (eg. Mithra)
@@shanepatrick4534 Gathas are the only known texts from Zarathustra himself. The rest are as far as scholars know, forever lost, or hopefully, not yet discovered/deciphered.
There are 124000 prophets in the past. Period changes, the revelation changes, the followers aren't adhere to original teaching. Then Allah sent Prophet Muhammad ﷺ as the last prophet. It is totally make sense. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ is unlettered and even if they accuse Prophet Muhammad took from others, how did he gets everything right about past, present, future, how such man know what to choose what is right if not he is being guided by God as he testified. Indeed he is the prophet of God peace be upon him. O believers! Have faith in Allah, His Messenger, the Book He has revealed to His Messenger, and the Scriptures He revealed before. Indeed, whoever denies Allah, His angels, His Books, His messengers, and the Last Day has clearly gone far astray. (4:136)
Can you give the names of 100 prophets…I bet you can’t.There weren’t any so called prophets in Australia,America,Africa,China,South America,India,south east Asia,etc..only Muslims seem to be dealing with these prophets,but these prophets were of no use as not a single prophet or their god ever abolished the disgusting practice of slavery.Muslims practiced this inhuman practice for full 1400 years .Abraham Lincoln was better than any prophet or god Ashe abolished slavery.There’s not a single verse in the Quran which orders Muslims to ban this disgusting practice immediately and forever.since there’s no such verses in the Quran,Muslims enjoyed sleeping with these helpless slaves without guilt for 1400 years till the UN forced Muslims to ban slavery.Saudi Arabia practiced slavery till 1962 and Mauritania till 1982…
I was thinking this recently. Islam can reconcile this similarity to an extent as you said, but it seems odd that Zoroaster isn't mentioned in the Qur'an. He seems to fit the mold of a prophet more than perhaps any other Biblical figure, and the early Muslims knew of Zoroastrians, Muhammad even had a disciple who was a former Zoroastrian, yet the Qur'an doesn't mention Zoroaster but mentions these other figures (Hud, Salih, Shu'ayb) that maybe no-one had ever heard of before. It just mentions Zoroastrians briefly without linking them to any previous prophet.
Zorasterianism and Judaism are very simular as well. The 2 probably influenced each other. In the OT it talks about the Persians allowing the Jews to rebuild their temple. It views King Cyrus positively. Cyrus was mostlikely Zorasterian and admired Judaism and saw them as worshipping the same God. I'm wondering, would Zorasterianism be viewed as people of the book like Jews and Christians?
Yes we are. The Qur’an in surah al hajj 22 ayat 17 says: Indeed, the believers, Jews, Sabians, Christians, Magi, and the polytheists-Allah will judge between them ˹all˺ on Judgment Day. Surely Allah is a Witness over all things. There, the Quran makes a distinction between 4 religions and those that are called polytheists, implying a different judgement between the believers and non believers, therefore recognizing Magi as people of the book. FYI, Magi are zoroastrians.
Allah has sent many Prophets and Anbiyas through time over 120 thousand from the time of Adam to the last prophet Muhammad Peace be upon them all. Some prophets have been mention by name and some not. And the people of the book has been mentioned but Zorostrian not. Therefore, Muslims go by what was revealed to them through the Quran and Sunnas. Though many prophets have been sent to mankind but also false religions have also been invented as well. Therefore to be on a clear side is what the prophet Muhammad pbuh said in a Hadith as they are many prophets sent to each nation to be guided through the right path and all that were sent were true guided but if we don't know the names and who they were presented to, that's why all those religions were meant to be on certain time and certain people and ends up so the only religion to be followed will be Islam as is the last and final religion for whole humanity not just one nation. Porophet Muhammad Pbuh is the last and the final and he was selected by Allah S.A.W to represent all humanity till the end of this world
I am Iranian Muslim (obviously Shia)! in general you were correct you just made one error, No one is equal to Ahoura Mazda, the existence of Evil is like the existence of Sheitan AhuraMazda is the God of the world he create he owns everything as You can see in Avesta -> Yasna -> Hat 29 -> vers 4 : "Mazda knoweth best the purposes that have been wrought already by demons and by mortals(in the past), and that shall be wrought(in the future and) hereafter. Ahura, is the only decider. So shall it be as he shall will " the true problem that I found is Zoroastrianism and why it is Wrong and Islam is the truth and last massage of God: 1. just like Christianity and Jews their Textbook has a lot of change and influence by unknown source to the point that it is safe to say it is croupt 2. the most Important thing which is wrong about Zoroastrianism is God's attributes are worshiped apart from God itself to the point that you can call them other deities which is something Quran clearly denys and our Imams perfectly described how this is wrong and why it wrong
@@shairsko9360 ok I understand now! Jew make their religion small, small groups but they controls the world “important matter from home inside the small group in Israel! They own banks and international banking systems that they created! Even china, all oil rich Muslims countries cannot buy or sell their oil unless they use the Israeli banking system, Russia ,Europe cannot buy or sell outside unless they go through the Jewish international banking system! Maybe that is why they don’t care to make Judaism big religion, the are already big, credit card is their latest invention to control and have power in your life, credit cards are all over the world and banking are all over the world Jew power! They love money.. Jesus kicked them out of the temple for that reason! They don’t care to make Judaism big bcz , the smaller the more powerful they are! The few controls the many is their devices! 1/billion is more powerful..1 over billions is more effective, like God dominate trillions and the whole universe alone! Judaism- Jew is doing like God! One bullet shot in one the heart or head is more powerful than Many bullet shot all over the boby…. They created and control the world banking, the world banks.. Israel, Jew, Judaism the world banks
Zoroastrianism was the first religion that told women to cover. First religion that spoke of a messiah being birthed of a virgin, and hints why the Zoroastrian Magi visited the birth of Jesus with gifts. Actually Persians were there at Jerusalem celebrating the birth of the messiah. Cyrus the great is the first messiah the Torah speaks of and he himself a Zoroastrian.
If you read Islamic texts and read Zoroastrian texts you will see that there is absolutely no resemblance between the two as I have mentioned above. The core of Zoroastrianism is uplifting for mankind. It equates man as almost a co-creator with Ahura Mazda (term for God). We are AM’s soldiers so to speak. Islam’s core is in ‘submission’. Zoroastrianism is about standing up with God. Zoroastrianism is not about conversion or expansion. That is why there only 200,000 people worldwide still practicing this faith. Zoroastrianism is about being sought. If people want to know about a way of life they are welcome. But no clergy will go to preach this religion … except when invited by Zoroastrians. There is no killing in Zoroastrianism. In practice this may translate to the exception of self defense. Taking of life in any form is considered unacceptable except in the normal cycle of life like eating meats or vegetables to live. The term Ahura Mazda translates to the Lord of Wisdom. It does not translate to some all powerful entity. Zoroastrianism holds 4 tenets. Truth, Rational thought, Wisdom and universal Love (scholars are not certain about the universal love which may be closer to universal love for truth). This ‘rational’ approach to life is unique to Zoroastrianism. You are meant to question everything, including the prophet Zarathustra. You are not to take any concept without a rational filter because that is the God given difference between mankind and any other living form of life - the ability to think, question, discern for ourselves. There are no dos and don’t. You rely on your own judgement. The three tools given to you to achieve the four tenets are given as - Good Thoughts, Good Words, Good Deeds. There is no concept of God’s punishment in Zoroastrianism. The principle is - If God is ALL GOOD how can there be punishment. God is full of compassion, love and forgiveness. This is closer to Christianity than any other religious belief. The concept of Hell does exist but not in a permanent way. That a soul is judged for its deeds and a fallen soul too will eventually rise and be one with God. In Zoroastrianism there is always Hope. No negativity is permanent. It is a powerful positive force for all. Many doctrines try and gentrify themselves by finding links to certain concepts. From a point of clarity and truth this needs to be clear.
@@CarlZend I think the way Iranian women cover their hair is the way Zoroastrians cover. I never compared it to Islam. I know the religion by the way. I’m Iranian myself. Most Iranians know their heritage, culture, and history very well, and are very enthusiastic about it.
Framing of the question is wrong. What if I asked why Islam and life are so similar? Is Islam copying life. It believes in other dimensions and realms, is it copying quantum physics? No, of course not. Islam is a guide for us and explains the truths of the universe. To say Islam is “copying” other religions is wrong
Yes Islam copied big part from Zoroasterian religion , eg. 7 sky , 5 prayings per day , cleaning and washing hands and face before praying , Esra and Mieraj , cold hell , Seerat bridge , virgin Hori in heaven ... etc .
Islam being last religion could have some similarties with other religion having a lot of prophets & religions .so nothing but a proof of last religion & prophet.
@@rajababy2009 you don't know Islam ,you believe in destiny, you re just trying to correct Islam and you still believe following the same religion can take any where apart from hell.
@@rajababy2009 bhai after reading the Quran 400,000 Pakistani Muslim quit Islam and their mullahs were seen crying on national television.This video has gone viral .millions of Muslims are leaving Islam in Iran,Jordan and the west.Saudi Arabia has a fastest growing population of atheists.5% of Saudi Muslims are atheists according to the survey made by Gallup…peace bhai
So in short if you remove the claim that Quran was recited to Maohammad by God, there is nothing new in Islam comparing to previous reliegions and since Zorastrianism, is the oldest of the three Abrahamic religeions, then what is new about them? In relaity, the differences are all in Sharia laws and traditions depending on people, geography and plotics, not in the theology. And then add to this the fact that Zoroastrianism is also based on older tradiotions and belief systems some of which was practiced throughut the human history which you may call unbeievers, then isn't it more reasonable to say that religeous ideas like anything lese evolved with the human sociites and took different shapes according to their needs? In other words, religeion like many things, like science for example, has a natural evolutionary traits made by humans and there is nothing devine about that.
@@SparkyWeeBro Hare Krishna 🙏 All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions. For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail. It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
Khordeh Avesta that has the 5 daily prayers in it for Zoroastrianism is from 1323 AD. This is 700 years after islam came to Persia. So a lot of these Zoroastrian books are redacted to resemble the Quran or the Islamic religion. Scientist are also unsure if these books are even reliable Parsi religious scriptures, and conclusions could be made they are not reliable sources.
There's cultural-religio discussion happen during that golden age of Middle East, where Zoroastrian, Manichaeism, Buddha, Islam, Christian, Judaism, Greek Philosophy, Sufism debates and cross culture.
Resemble the Quran? Do you mean the Quran resembles the Avesta? Why is it that anything that closely challenges Islam is either wrong or didn’t exist or is unreliable? Maybe you should read up on Salman Farsi and his role. You do realise that during the Muslim Arab conquest of Persia, the Arabs burnt as many copies of the Avesta that they couldn’t possibly find, especially the one In Persepolis! Ever wondered why? Why does one religion not only persecute people who already believed in god but also burn their knowledge? Why did the Zoroastrians migrate to India? All Abrahamic religions are based on Zoroastrianism and to deny that is called favouritism. Nothing can ever justify why Zoroastrians were persecuted for not accepting Islam unless that’s a hoax too.
Never pray to a dead gangster. Truth will come out and with logic people will ask questions and come to answers they must be willing to confront with. When you study Islam, Christianity, Zoroastriantism and Hebrew you start to see that the only right way to follow God is not by force and ignorance. The faith of true peace of others not their own will take over and other false teachings will perish.
Zoroastrianism is one of the sources for monotheistic religions (i.e., Semitic faiths - Judaism, Christianity & Islam). The other source is the Akhnatan's sect in Egypt. In addition, several stories in Semitic faiths have their origins in older cultures.
Allah has many names and most beutiful names belong to him, Allah is one of them. Why the Muslims uses Allah, because Allah does not have gender, plurality, associate with any partner....
We don't read the Qur'an, but it appears that we take fallacious human source and add to our Din - which Allah forbidden us to do in many places in the Qur'an. May Allah bring us back to Qur'an only as the source of our Din.
Thank you for the comparison video. I must correct a mistake in what was stated. Isaiah does not say that God created evil. You can read the book of Isaiah for yourself.
We don't have dualistic in zoroastrianism 🤦 ahura mazda is the one and only gad Ahriman or angra maniu that evil u mention litterly means bad thoughts 😶🌫️
So many religions say their way is the truth and give some proof. But they only can see the world and think through what their religion tells them to think and do. I've literally been told "You not should think and question such things. It is haram and kafir.". If critical thinking and questioning thinks is "Not allowed" then that religion is controlled through fear. If a person is so afraid of Allah out of fear of punishment that they can't even question Him. Then there is a problem. A simple one word question, "Why?". Nothing is stopping us from questioning Allah, Not even He can stop us from doing it. No one truly knows with 100% what is the one true religion from God. All are just how we humans think God acts and what He wants us to do, Anyone can just make up a religion and trick people into following it.
All of those so called religions have faded away , trhy are not practiced Significantly. Only Islam Is a practiced religion properly and Quran is unchanged for 1400 years dot by dot . There are prophecies made by Muhammad 14 centuries about future. events that have come true in recent decades for example Beduoins building large structures . Muhammad Propheicsed this 1400 years ago , Now look what the Arabs are building , Burj Khalifa and God knows what. I mean it's pretty clear . Only Islam remains. And if don't see prophecies , miracles in the Quran , Then what other proof do you want?
@@fahadabdulrashid7216 There is no compulsion in religion was a statement made by Muhammad telling Jews, “you have no right to force your children to stay in your religion by forbidden them to enter islam! That is the truth.. read the whole history to whom it is adressed! But when it is Muslims, there is compulsion in religion and whoever leave it, must be killed!..
Im shocked after read some comments that doesnt know what is zoroastrian and what type of religion of it and what are the practices. In Quran, Allah (The Almighty God) said about Majusi - Fire Worshipper. The word of Majusi derive from Persian word, Magus - member of priesthood. Today we know Majusi are pointed to Zoroastrian led by the priest by making huge fire to perform worshipping or praying. Its fascinating when in Quran Allah said about these 3 religion in one verse which is Judaism, Christian and Majusi. It is safe to say, old religion of persia was already a fire worshipper before Islam conquered them.
I was just researching today about Zoroastrianism when i saw some similiarties so i was curios, and out of nowhere this video popped up. Another sign of allah to anwser my question. In the end of my research I found out that: Zoarastianism has a god called ahura mazda and created an evil creation angra that became corrupted due to his own will to receive greater power and control. Ahura created then human beings like this: He created Gayomard first human and then angra killed him out of jealousy and from his bones rhubarb grew out and Mashya and Mashyana, grew out of the rhubarb plant they populate earth after a catastrophic winter caused by the evil spirit Angra Mainyu, ahura then gave them tools to and knowledge to cultivate the land and protect themselves from the elements, and they became the ancestors of all human beings. They also say the earth was flat and that angra created the mountains and valley because he tried to destroy earth. The way the earth is created sounds a bit unscientific source - www.zoroastriankids.com/creation.html Zoarastians were only in persia and then they wandered to india cuz arabs attacked persia, those were called the parsis. The Parsi community developed its own distinct practices and traditions, which differ in some ways from those of Zoroastrians in Iran and other parts of the world. In terms of changes to the religion's core beliefs and principles, there have been debates and differences of opinion among Zoroastrian scholars and practitioners throughout history. However, the core tenets of the religion, such as the belief in the dualistic nature of the universe and the importance of ethical behavior, have remained largely unchanged over time. Nobody can convert into their religion but then nowadays some zoarastians say u can convert into by changing the rules. However, like any other religion, Zoroastrianism has been subject to different interpretations, practices, and historical developments over time. Some modern Zoroastrians have criticized certain practices or interpretations that they believe deviate from the original teachings of the prophet Zarathustra, such as the use of ritualistic practices that were not originally part of the religion or the incorporation of non-Zoroastrian beliefs and practices. In Zoroastrianism, it is believed that Angra Mainyu is the source of evil and that he will be defeated by the Saoshyant at the end of time. However, the idea that nobody will have negative feelings after his defeat is not explicitly stated in Zoroastrian texts. The ultimate fate of human souls and the nature of existence after the end of time is not entirely clear in Zoroastrianism, as there are various interpretations and beliefs among different Zoroastrian communities. source chatgpt For me the religion is a bid unconvicing as there are changes between the zoroastrian communities, core belief seems to be the same but end of time core belief is unclear and not 100% certain. If allah send prophets everywhere to make them acknowledge whats right or wrong and there is no god but allah, then people got tricked by sheitan and made their own relgions and beliefs, then there is a need for a consistent religion. This is the reason why those religions werent preserved but the quran was: Previous prophets were sent to a particular group of people and their message was supposed to be followed for a particular time period. Since previous revelations were time-bound, God did not preserve them Himself. Muslims believe that the Quran cannot be compared with the previous Scriptures. The Quran is unique in many aspects. It is the final revelation to mankind. Previous scriptures were sent to their respective people only. The Quran is universal That is why quran contains topcics from scientific signs from astronomy to biology, aswell as the meaning of life to worship allah and this life is a test with good and bad deeds are accounted on the day of judgement.
@@Kielbitch you took that verse completely out of context and the story in which that chapter is describing. Read the whole chapter and learn a thing or two. It was describing a king who was travelling and came across a group of people who lived somewhere where the sunset (i.e. the horizon of the sunset) was on a spring of murky water.
Ma Sha Allah. Barakallah ❤️. I just revisit your old debate. Refreshing. May Allah grant us tranquility and strive for His sake and may Allah accept it.
Completely wrong zoroastrians don't have dualistic in zoroastrianism 🤦 ahura mazda is the one and only gad Ahriman or angra maniu that evil u mention litterly means bad thoughts 😶🌫️ When u study about zoroastrianism from Wikipedia
I understand your point Dr sabir Islam is like constructing a building.however the previous prophets and messengers are the sub structure and prophet Muhammad S.A.w is the final Roof and super structure as far as Islam is concerned.
May Allah (swt) guide me when I say that there have been thousands of Prophets across time and across the face of the Earth. We Humans are gifted by Allah to make whatever affiliation, association or attribution we care to regarding these prophets. For myself, I choose to follow the Quran and am guided by its message as revealed by the Messenger of God (pbuh). That does not mean that an American Indian is somehow wrong to follow, say, the Indian prophet Wa-voka. And if Christians want to elevate the prophet, Isa (pbuh) who am I to take umbarage. In my very very humble opinion, it is the decision to reject all prophets and the faith they guide us towards, which is the real danger (may Allah preserve us from such). For myself, the only challenge is that I am sure to convey to prophets other than Mohammed, their due regard and respect. Still working on that........
in Quran it is clear that as a Muslim we have to Believe in every Prophet send By GOD whether we know him by name or not , We have to believe that every nation had the prophet But later on people change the message , mixed it etc
Historians and academics claim, that Zroastrians came and originated in Persia ,though recent archeological discoveries showed, that the most ancient place of waship was discovered in Uighur autonomous region(xinjang)Turfan area aka East Turkistan.
Zoroastrians are the first Iranians/Aryans. They originated in Central Asia. Zoroaster prophet was believed to be born in Airyana Vaeja which is roughly located in modern day Tajikistan.
What the speaker overlooked is that Zoroastrianism changed over time and its sources are late in time, and the similarity between it and Islam and Christianity is due to its being influenced by them, not the opposite.
3:40 Wrong. We don’t look at it from the historical-critical point of view and Islam does NOT owe anything to Zoroastrianism. Spread only the point of view of Islam and not atheistic sciences such as historical naturalism. This man always tries to present a “balanced” perspective but invariably ends up as a latter-day Zindiq
We only know the Prophets Allah has informed us of. All the others are known to Allah alone at this point. We do not claim that Zoroaster is a prophet of Allah. Of course, all people were sent prophets. Only Allah knows which prophet was sent to the people whose descendants began practicing Zoroastrianism.
Quran does not specifically mention it but he could have been, Allah knows best! Allah sent 124000 prophets and messengers to all creeds and nations, the current Prophet and messenger for our current time and era is Muhammad s.a.w...and the revelation of Quran The Final Testament (Time to get the latest Windows Update) 🐱👍🏿
@@rajababy2009 bhai read their books and then compare..most of the stories,science,etc is all copied from bible, Torah and other religious texts…nothing is original
Q: Why Do Islam & Zoroastrianism Seem So Similar? A: Because Muhammad appropriated concepts, characters and stories from earlier sources such as Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Christianity etc. Even the Quran alludes to this, below are two verses that mention this, there are other verses in the Quran that allude to this too. Any intelligent, honest person capable of analytical, critical thinking can see this when they read the Quran and Sunnah, it's so painfully obvious! Quran 25:4: 'The disbelievers say, “This ˹Quran˺ is nothing but a fabrication which he made up with the help of others.” Their claim is totally unjustified and untrue!' Quran 25:5: 'And they say, “˹These revelations are only˺ ancient fables which he has had written down, and they are rehearsed to him morning and evening.” '
Nope, I am a critical thinker, and I see that the Quran is unique in many ways that you can't see, yet at the same time the message is very similar to the message of all religions. Whatever religion you choose, if you are following the good things of what remains of their Scripture (charity, fear God, etc.) then you have hope for salvation, otherwise if you're just following the idolatrous part of those religions and you forget all the wisdom and important teachings, then you're doomed
Again, to understand why it's possible to believe in Islam, and believe other revelations also contain the truth from God, pay attention to the following Quranic verses: 4:164 Some messengers We have already told you about, while some messengers We never told you about. [...] 16:63 By God, We sent messengers to communities before you, but Satan beautified their actions for them. [...] 16:36 We sent a messenger to every community: “Worship God, and avoid idolatry.” Some of them God guided, while others deserved misguidance. [...] In fact, this is the whole reason a more recent religion called Baha'ism exists. I don't specifically follow that religion, but I understand and acknowledge what the author of its books meant.
Hare Krishna 🙏 All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions. For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail. It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
read ir from Muslim sources not anti islam pages , It was a treaty between Muslims and Jews that during war they will protect the Madina together But Jews betray Muslims and give inside information to Pagans of Makkah against Muslims when it was clear that Jews betray then Prophet Pbuh ordered to to fight Jews, and no one killed Women and Children it is false , In Islam war ethics are no harm Children , Women or Vegetation , places of worship etc
Bhai angel Gabriel is as fictitious and imaginary as other gods and prophets..all there so called aayats or revalations were self pleasing aayats created by the prophet himself..there is zero evidence of any god or angels giving verses which orders to kill people,make them slaves,loot and plunder other tribes,marry small children,keep concubines,marry daughter in law ,kill critics and sell human beings in slave markets which is extremely disgusting
Hare Krishna 🙏 All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions. For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail. It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
I always asked myself about zoroastrianism as a muslim. But this video perfectly explained it, thank you may Allah be pleased with you now i understand it clearly❤❤❤❤❤
Madam & Sir, the similarity is in Monotheism: Ahur Mazda vs Allah, and yet Islam wiped out Zoroastrianism in Iran by swords in a short period of 10 years.
Muslims love a convenient answer. The problem is that we do have to take the historical analytic approach and suspend the divine element if we are not convinced in the god of abraham. So if we do indeed deny a divine element what we’re left with is a perfectly sensible and plausible transference of beliefs and practices from other “pagan” belief systems into the abrahamic ones. Its too convenient to say “anything we like and agree with we will say god’s revelation was preserved” “anything we disagree with we will say was corruptions added in to gods prior revelations”. Especially now the story of early Israel and the biblical patriarchs are no longer historically credible, we have to also see Islam as a product of its environment, not a special revelation from god. All Islam did was take pre-existing ideas and practices and direct them to a god of the arabs.
According to some scholars like Jay Smith, Islam has borrowed from : Judaism : Circumcision, no- pork, skull cap, Fasting, Monotheism etc Christianity : Psalms in Armaic, Virgin mother etc. Zorastrianism : Peacock tail of buraq etc.( Yazidi?) Paganism : Circambulating a structure, kissing black stone etc. 🤔
🤷🏼♂️There are no religious leaders that can place their right palm on the KJV and say these words once only in a calm coherent manner-> I refuse to be full of demons. Various bird species can mimic the words!👹🤡🌍🐣🐥🦜🤷🏼♂️ The birdy’s can say what the religious ppl cannot say 🤪😂😂😂🤪 …that time when you found out that religion filled you with demons and yet you continued to practice…religion 👀 SALVATION 👇🏻 Romans 10:13 For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord ✝️shall be saved. GOOGLE BORN AGAIN ASAP!!! ❤️✝️❤️
Why God sends so many religions,prophets,but none of them useful for humans ?. The world is not better after Moses,after Jesus,after Muhammad .Is God making mistakes by sending the wrong people ?.. Why doesn't God create a better world, taking off evil, temptations?.
No, God sent prophets to the people who Iblees (Lucifer) deceived. As it is said in Surah Aaraf that if Allah wills he (iblees) will deceive Allah's People and Allah willed. besides humans have free will we can do whatever we want but that's not humane.
During the first Persian empire 500 BCE nearly half of the world population lived within the empire. Although there was no imposition of Zoroastrianism, which is the first monotheistic religion of the world, the mostly pagan population must have become familiar with its monotheism and incorporated much of that into their thinking.
Very easy, Judaism kept the theology better, Christianity perhaps the moral character and compassion aspect, and other religions that also came from Islam may have preserved other aspects better. Islam as to mean the last revelation of Allah SWT unto us, is the perfection of a way of life for all humankind. It's the best spiritual path on Earth. Some people will die as Christians, Jews or Zoroastrians, and Allah SWT will forgive them and reward their deeds in the afterlife, we don't hold the belief that a random tribe in south america who never got the last message will necessarily burn in hell, Allah SWT doesn't judge unjustly, and he doesn't punish someone who doesn't know, be it by fitrah or by a previous law, that person will be judged justly in accordance to what it was given of guideance and parameters. Of course, if you do receive the last revelation of Islam, and you reject it, then that is the issue, and you probably have a disease in the heart, like shirk tendencies, you want creation to be God and it is made appealing to you when you lose patience and do evil... Allahu 3alam. I advise you my brothers and sisters, to not give ear to liars, if you do then you are inviting misguideance, and if you eventually are misguided, then on Judgement Day you wouldn't have a strong argument, because you actually acted towards it. It happened to me, and my imaan got weaker, Alhamdulillah it keeps getting stronger tho, because I know Allah SWT tests us sometimes like this, like when Musa was tested with Khidr, and it looked crooked but it all made sense with the context, here it's the same exact thing... You won't find a better path than this, the Quran truly is something else, and as it states: 77:50 فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَهُۥ يُؤْمِنُونَ ٥٠ So what message after this ˹Quran˺ would they believe in? - Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran The rest of scriptures on Earth, are either blatantly fabricated, with false prophecies and whatnot, or not preserved, full of contradictions and fabrications by the hand of scribes. Honestly this Quran is a miracle, and I can't be except grateful for it. Alhamdulillah.
So when the Muhammed received the revelation and recited to the listeners, they will most often say oh, we had already heard this one, you are reading from the old ancient book...
it should clearly be understood that Hadith says after Quran had been revealed the previous books of Allah almighty , Bible & Torah had been cancelled but monotheism توحید will remain till Qiamat #
Salams dear Dr's. Hope you are both well? I always agree with the stance that you give regarding the answers to all the topics presented to you. However with regards to this topic, I disagree with you. Allah would not have based any aspect of Zoroastrian rituals etc and included them in Islam. Zoroatrians may have a belief in one creator but they worship the Fire!. They have a Fire, an eternal flame that they bow down too. This bowing down, they call Zesdah. The whole worship ritual is called Namaz. This is a Persian word and literally means Fire worship. What I find strange is that the Muslims, mostly the Pakistanis call their prayers, Namaz!! How weird. Now, how is it that Islamic rituals appear similar to Zoroastrianism? It is because the Deen of Islam has been hijacked! The Persians from the time of Rasool found themselves defeated by the Muslims. They knew the only way to beat them would be to infiltrate Deen. So there was a systematic ideological attack on the Deen of Islam. Zorastrian ideology found its way into Islam. Now instead of Deen, we have a Mazhab!! Nowhere in the Quran will you find the word Mazhab/ Madhab. There is a vast difference between Deen and Mazhab. The Deen of Allah raises the status of Bani Adam and leads to a massive change within each person. Mazhab, in a nutshell is a fatalistic dogma that says that whatever happens to us, is down to Allah. Mazhab strongly keeps the heads of its followers firmly on the ground, with no outward change in themselves, nor their Society! Go to Masjid, pray, go home and carry on doing all the bad things you were doing. ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is the most basic misunderstanding about zoroastrianism. We DO NOT worship fire, we believe fire is the most pure manifestation of god’s power, and since no depictions of god exists, we pray towards god’s greatest creation. It’s the first thing you understand when you start as Mazdayasna. We DO NOT bow to the fire, we bow to god’s power and light. We pray towards the sun during daytime and we pray towards a fire during night. We have eternal flames simbolizing god’s eternal presence. WE ARE NOT FIRE WORSHIPPERS. Ashem vohu.
If you wish to have an honest answer, then the answer is that all religions are born out of one another, and the process still continues to this day. Judaism was made out of many Zoroastrian concepts with the addition of local legends and folklore. This was followed by Christianity, a trash can of Roman mythologies with the addition of Judaism and Zoroastrian leftovers. Then comes Islam, the so-called religion of PEACE and PURE 😂, which borrows and steals most of the main concepts of Judaism with additional Zoroastrian elements and other available legends and folklore at that time. This is the bitter truth, it's up to you to accept it or cling onto falsehood you are told. Truth always prevails itself no matter how much one tries to suppress it.
Shia Islam has similarities with Zorashtriansm in cultural,rituals and traditional aspects .Sunni Islam is radical there is no commonalities between Zorashtriansm..
God has no human helper... So God is capable enough to send messages by his own power and inspire human minds directly to their mind without any human help.. So No messengers for God..
No final ele diz que apenas o islã mantém intacta a revelação. Ou seja, falou, falou, e, no final disse o que cada um falaria de sua própria religião : que é a correta Fica a pergunta: se todas as anteriores perderam a verdade, por que o islã seria a única que a manteria intacta?. ... A fé Bahai veio depois do islã e a história continua...
Historically speaking the Persian King Cyrus the Great who was Zoroastrian defeated the Babylonians who had enslaved the Israelites. He to them to go back the Israel to build the second temple. Zoroastrianism introduced monotheism to the Israelites who at the time worshipped a number of Gods. The two horned one mentioned in the Quran is said to be Alexander the Great but it is most likely King Cyrus because he is revered in Judaism and Mohammed was in contact with a lot of Jews and Zoroastrians. The Muslims pray is almost identical to the Zoroastrian pray and also resembles that of early Syriac Christians so it was most like copied by them.
Dr Ally misquotes Isaiah (I believe he is referencing ch 45:7) and, inadvertently, blasphemes the Biblical concept of God by failing to distinguish between physical and moral evil. An earthquake, storm etc. are 'evils' because they cause harm but they are not moral evils. A lie is a moral evil. God makes use of the former for good purposes ie: to punish, or test/strengthen ones trust in Him, etc. But God can not make use of, or be the source of, a moral evil because that would be to contradict His very essence. The context of Isaiah 45 is that of using natural evils in order to punish oppressors to God's people so clearly natural evils are what is meant. So, Dr Ally needs to make this distinction in relation to Yaweh: He causes natural evils, He does not cause (but merely tolerates) moral evils.
So, if God sends different messages to humanity, means that there’s only ONE God who “speaks” to all humanity, through testaments and teachings, which have the same meaning and significance for all mankind … If so, why there’s so much division and hatred towards Christians and other religions, by muslims, towards “other” faiths ?? If it’s how this man describes it, we should all be united and respectful to each other, no matter if some are muslims, Christian or Jewish…. We have seen fanaticism, radicallity and racism everywhere, from muslims, especially the last few years !! It’s NOT other races avoiding mixing with the muslims, it’s muslims who avoid them, as they believe whoever is not of their faith is not worthy and rightful as they are!! It’s all about acceptance and respect for others, no matter what their “religion” is… If it all stems from the ONE creator, the teachings should be same for all !! So why such separation ?? Maybe muslim people are not taking Gods teachings seriously and they formed their own radical ideology and beliefs towards everyone else, who don’t follow their faith …
Muslims or Islam copied some philosophies from Zoroastrians but changed it as well, in a very bad way. It's too much to explain here. To say Zoroastrians has the same god or roots as islam is a joke. Allah is closer to ahriman than Ahura Mazda. Islam destroyed my peoples religion, culture, language, history, now they have the nerves to say Ahura maza is the same as the abrahamic gods.
However as I understand from scholars, after Islam came to this world, all monotheism religions should turn to accept Islam and prophet Muhammed (sal) as the last messenger since the previous faith scriptures are not in original form or Interpolation.
Not "exactly" right. Islam can be accepted as a "correction" of sorts for those monotheistic faithes that rather much got Off-track in what they were originally intended to accomplish. The Judaic Faith was doing just fine until the Covenant with Allah was taken to mean the formation of a nation-state under a Human King. In like manner, the prophet Isa (pbuh) was never expected to be elevated to a status as a god, but rather to correct the earlier mis-guided nation-state concept as well as the growing class system in Judea. Islam is a way in which we Humans can get back to the fundamental belief in a single Eternal and Absolute but we are still challenged by the addiction many have to power and control. FWIW.
@im.avesta Mohammed is a Messenger of God, yet, he is not the only Messenger to come to us, and there is no solid proof that he is the last we shall ever have. Our obligation is to Allah (swt ).
@im.avesta Exactly Right. The Whisperer of Evil constantly tempts us to put Judgements and Reason above Faith which is how he gets us chasing in circles. Nor does it help to have so many individuals bending truths to support their particular take on things. Allah, alone, determines what will be transmitted by whom.....when....and why. Such events are the "tools" he gives us to accomplish our work. For myself, I would rather not debate and discuss about the tools, but rather about the work I am suppose to be doing for His greater glory. FWIW.
The only similarity between zoroastrians and muslims is that both believe in one god. That is the only common thing. I'm however appalled with the way zoroastrians conduct the last rights of the deceased. No offence.
Are you kidding me???!!! You clearly show absolute zero knowledge, and because of that, you have made an absolute baseless claim. All Abrahamic faiths have been influneced by Zoroastrianism. Paradise Life after death 1 god Good v evil Angels Demons Ethics Hell Heaven Pray 5 times a day Judgement day Messiah Virgin birth Return of the messiah Good deeds vs bad deeds will be judged Free will The List goes on!!! If you do your research early Judaism before the Babylonians enslaved the Jews none of these concepts I listed was in there faith. It was when the Persian (Zoroastrianism) King Cyrus the great freed the Jews they returned with all of these new teachings. Judaism was under Zoroastrianism rule for hundreds of years and in turn heavily influneced and tought the Jews many things. Islam and Christianity have all been influneced by Judaism. ZOROASTRIANISM IS THE SOURCE OF ALL 3 ABRAHIM FAITHS.
Hare Krishna 🙏 All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions. For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail. It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
Dr sb.can u proce from any ayat that Quran,ayats,furqan,kitab or any mohjzaats were or any one was given to by name Prophet Mohammad? Just post or display one ayat. Be honest while speaking Quran.? This is challenge question for u n for all mullah like u of quom e hadees not quite Quran????. Dr sb,be realistic???
Now yes due to climate change and urbanisation, however, in ancient Zoroastrianism we used to leave those who died on the very top of a hill, for them to return to nature via vultures. The bones also used to vaporise by the sun.
They can do whatever they want in before sassanid they put them on tower of silent for the asha (the way of nature) in Sassanid they burn them cuz fire was important for Iranian they consider it purefaction but Zoroastr never said anything about it so ....
Zoroastrianism has concept of all powerful one God Ahura Mazda and evil force that exists albeit under Mazda is called Angra Mainyu. Quran espouses similar concept like Allah the all powerful God and Satan albeit under Allah. Throwing Stones. Praying five times ( Or three times a day) etc etc. By the by Zoroastrians never worship fire as popularly believed. It is just a natural example for knowledge and enlightement. By the By another mistaken belief is all Hindu sects believe in many Gods. Hindus also believe only in one God but concept of Deities ( not exactly similar to angels but a status higher than that of angels but not GOD himself) is alient to Abrahmic religions. Infact Vedantins and in some firqas of Hinduism say it is not just that there is one God But there is ONLY God everywhere. One and Only words are the difference from Abrahmic religions to Eastren religions. Why had to digress and write is because many Islamic scholars ( Including Dr Ally) Mis represent Eastren religion which is understandable as they have not studied these religions in a structured way under a Qualified master but derived some notions from books written by Westren Authors and lack of understanding of Sanskrit language
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Allah sent 124,000 prophets and messengers (peace be upon them all) throughout human history, there could have been a prophet sent to them for their era and time back then, nevertheless Prophet Muhammad pbuh is the last and final messenger during our current time and era
That hadith is made by zorastrians
ATTENTION!! Where will you go when you die, Heaven or Hell? We can not hide our sins from God. Jesus Christ loves you and He died for our sins, three days later, He arose from the grave... Jesus is alive... REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Only the salvation of Jesus Christ can save you from the fires of Hell. ACTS 2:38 “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
Where did you get the numbers? I believe prophet are many. Only God knows the number.
Its a lie. Where were they if its true?
@@youtube_chaplain God does not die get out of that mindset and start worshipping one God. Like how Jesus prayed. God of Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammed (place be upon them all)
but isn't this funny.. like god didn't make up his mind with earlier religions or he didn't protect his message or he was doing a trial and error or what ???
it is evident that there were all copying from a source.. all from one source and modifying the message as they went by.
This people are now trying their hard to justify that they didn't copy and their religion is somehow divine revelation 🤣
God gave us the will to choose. Most people who recieved the truth twisted the truth to meet their desires. That was their choice. But God is also the disposer of all wills in existence. The turn of events that transpired is all part of his infinite wisdom on how everything gets ordained. There WERE true monotheists from the christians, jews, zoroastrians and most probably even buddhist believers from the very start. Any religion that delves into God's existence and his higher power all have the innate belief in him (fitra), its just that the adherent's parents and society raise them differently. Every child that is born with a clean unbias state already believes in one God as a higher power.
There is an interesting verse in the quran in which God said "And had your Lord willed, those on earth would have believed - all of them entirely. Then, [O Muhammad], would you compel the people in order that they become believers?" 10:99 as well as 29:2 "Do people think once they say, “We believe,” that they will be left without being put to the test?" and "He who created death and life to test you as to which of you is best in deed, and He is the Exalted in Might, the Forgiving." (Quran 67:2)
the very definition of Good is the absense of Evil, like wise with truth, which is the absense of falsehood. Thats why we have many religions and ways of life, but only Islam is the only path to salvation. Every other religion praises something created, or defiles God's attributes. islam is the only true monotheistic faith on earth in which no image or symbol takes precedence, only the One God (Allah) who is outside of our realm.
the source was avesta but papers of it is in france and other looters and thieves of europe .
@@MAYONNAISEMOOSE well said! It was indeed a TEST for those nations to check their whims and desires if they are going to manipulate the word of The creator given to them! They did and failed, many times over the course of history, till Quran was finally revealed and was the final Message to Humanity to get back on track as the last chance, May Allah protect us all and guide us Ameen
@@KBH4ameen. As said Islam teaches that God sent prophets to guide all people throughout history, each bringing a message of truth and moral guidance. Instead of thinking that Islam was influenced by earlier religions, consider that God might have influenced many people to be prophets, each sent to different communities with a similar core message: to believe in one God and live righteously. In this view, figures like Zarathustra could be part of a broader, divine plan, where God reached out to all people in various ways, not just in the Middle East. Islam respects this concept, seeing itself as a continuation and preservation of this universal message.
So if all religions were sent by god why did the Arab Muslims invade Persia which was already practicing a religion sent by god and why did they force them to accept Islam or else face persecution?
They will say the scriptures of previous Religion got corrupted 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@satyamindnectar7052answered by yourself thanks
Strict monotheism, no religion believes in One all powerful diety other than Islam name me any religion you can think of.
@@hassanirfan5267 You do realise that Zoroastrianism is one of the world's oldest monotheistic religions, right?
@@hassanirfan5267 Vaishnava religions
The Zoroastrian religion is a curious one. When you read the Avesta, you get the sense that it switches from a pantheon based religion to a monotheist one where the Ashura who were described as Gods are now considered as angels. BTW the Mazda car brand takes it's name from Ahura Mazda, the name of God in Zoroastrianism
@@khashayar8989 whatever make you sleep well son..
@@justarshad8354Nicely refuted
@@khashayar8989 hihihi if someone doesn't know about Zoroastrianism, don't means uneducated . That religion is almost dead. Who cares..
@@hassendelft3907 "muslims like shabir ally"
In QUran GOD said HE send Prophets to every Nation SO later after Prophets died people , Monks, Priests , Kings changes the word of GOD for their worldly gains and benefits SO it got mixed , lost , partially lost etc Thats why you will found the similarities in every religions and GOD in Quran never said Islam is new religion But it is old religion started from the first human Adam Pbuh But later people change it so GOD send Prophets through out human history now last revival of the Message has been done through the Last Prophet Muhammad Pbuh and the message has been protected by GOD , and this is the reason we have only One Quran since Prophet Muhammad pbuh time
It just makes sense that all true religion would be similar.
My friend most of the religions say Obey One God and do good deeds. Now the priests and people have made their own principles.
Thats because Islam is based off of something that was based off of something that WAS the true relegion. Zoroastrianism was inspired by Daniel in ancient Persia. Daniel is a Israelite prophet in the Bible who predicted the Messiah and Savior Jesus Christ and the end of the world. So how can the Quran by the full truth if its origin is in the Bible?
I believe in, in this video they said, Zorasterianism came before Judaism. Zoraster preceded Abraham by over half a century
@@nafonieys4543 According to? You do realize Zoroaster is Baruch the scribe right?
With the exception that some humans hands manipulate it.
Muslims already believe that some old gods were actually not gods but ancient prophets of Allah. Imagine mighty prophet Thor and his hammer, an artifact with importance similar to the staff of Moses, the ring of Solomon and the sword of Ali.
Get off the Xbox g
Wait what? I'm confused. Could you elaborate 🤔
Shame on you for disrespecting 1. 6 billion Muslims.
Mocking and ridicule is the way of the losers.
False.Thor is nordic version of BAAL aka avatar of S A T A N.
@@keksi6844 yess
How come Islam only resembles religions in its direct environment like Christianity and Zoroastrianism? And why doesn’t it resemble religions in the Americas, Scandinavia or far East Asia? Wouldn’t the stronger case be that Islam is a copy of its surroundings, in stead of the last testament?
Which are religions in America except Christianity ?
What does Islam have in common with Christianity ??? Their basic creeds are completely different.
Certainly, what you share is a valid point. We Humans have the deveils-own-time working to keep our worshipful practices focused on Allah, but inevitably, they reflect our cultures and surroundings. Speaking only for myself, it has been difficult to strive to be a good Muslim and not necessarily a good Arab or even a good Salafi. Often times, I will counter-balance something I have heard about a Muslim practice, by investigating how the same practice is observed in, say, Malaysia or South America. You will agree, I think, that a belief such as Christianity or Judaism are much influenced by the areas and cultures in which they are practiced.
copy? there are many stories in Quran that you can't find in the bible or any scripture in the world. Not only that there are scientific miracle verse in Quran that you can't find in the Bible (it's not make sense because bible is full of scientific errors) or any science paper at the time.
@TheTruth. For myself, I have been content to believe that Holy Scriptures such as the Tanakh and the Quran are Not meant to be literally interpreted Intellectually, but interpreted Intuitively. I see this also in many Buddhist traditions (see: sutra) as well as Taoism and even Animism. In all of these traditions I find that trying to use Reason and Logic after the fashion of many Christian denominations only serves to distract and confuse from the Truths being expressed. IMVVHO.
Whatta coincidence, i was going to search about zoroastrianism.
I heard someone saying that they are also considered as the people of the book.
They're definitely not. Zoroastrians are pagan (mushrikeen).
ATTENTION!! Where will you go when you die, Heaven or Hell? We can not hide our sins from God. Jesus Christ loves you and He died for our sins, three days later, He arose from the grave... Jesus is alive... REPENT and put your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Only the salvation of Jesus Christ can save you from the fires of Hell. ACTS 2:38 “Repent and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins, and you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.
@@youtube_chaplain jesus❤ was a prophet.
Jesus ate food and went to toilet.
God doesn't go to toilet.
God doesn't need human sacrifice to forgive.
Open your heart and accept the truth.
Deny the church, they follow falsehood.
@@DonDiiiii BEWARE!!! You are denying Christ Jesus as Lord, when you say that He was only a prophet. Jesus Christ is the only savior for the world, he is the only one who can save you from the fires of Hell. Once you die, it will be too late to repent. There will be no second chance for you then. Place your faith in Jesus Christ as your Lord and Savior today, we are not guaranteed tomorrow. Have a great day!
@@youtube_chaplain As a former Catholic, I'm denying Jesus Christ as God or a " God, divinity, etc... " and have no problem doing so. Hope this helps you trying to impose your faith on others. As many Christians tend to do so.
It is no secret that Salman Farsi, who used to be a Zoroastrian, was one of Muhammad's close friends. It is even mentioned in the Quran that some people said to Muhammad that there is a non-Arab person who teaches you these words (Quran)!
That is why Islam has that many infusions from Zoroastrians!
Facts.
Them praying 5 times a day was added to their religion after Islam so you cant say Islam is influenced by them and Many ayahs were already revealed at that time
And by the way Prayers were already established before the conquest of Persia
The Quran is extremely filled with patterns and matematical miracles while conserving deep meaning and staying elocent. Moreover, those things weren’t even known by the compagnon because they lacked the knowledge to appreciate it . Only after modern history we start seeing this . If it was truly written by men, they would have boasted and show off those matematical patterns , but no one ever did. It is clearly a work of God impossible to be set with a human mind . God knew we will start seing the patterns years after and put them for our generation. This is one argument among many many others that Muhammad was a true prophet and the Quran is not from
Him .
It's weird that the Qur'an never mentions Zoroaster
The interesting thing about the Avesta is that it contains both Pre-Zoroastrian (Yashts) and post Zoroaster (Vendidad) texts, which are not always representative of the original (and only) text by Zarathustra (Gathas). Hence, it has elements of Old Iranian religion (eg. Mithra)
How about the Gathas of Zarathustra?
@@shanepatrick4534 Gathas are the only known texts from Zarathustra himself. The rest are as far as scholars know, forever lost, or hopefully, not yet discovered/deciphered.
There are 124000 prophets in the past. Period changes, the revelation changes, the followers aren't adhere to original teaching. Then Allah sent Prophet Muhammad ﷺ as the last prophet. It is totally make sense. Prophet Muhammad ﷺ is unlettered and even if they accuse Prophet Muhammad took from others, how did he gets everything right about past, present, future, how such man know what to choose what is right if not he is being guided by God as he testified. Indeed he is the prophet of God peace be upon him.
O believers! Have faith in Allah, His Messenger, the Book He has revealed to His Messenger, and the Scriptures He revealed before. Indeed, whoever denies Allah, His angels, His Books, His messengers, and the Last Day has clearly gone far astray. (4:136)
Can you give the names of 100 prophets…I bet you can’t.There weren’t any so called prophets in Australia,America,Africa,China,South America,India,south east Asia,etc..only Muslims seem to be dealing with these prophets,but these prophets were of no use as not a single prophet or their god ever abolished the disgusting practice of slavery.Muslims practiced this inhuman practice for full 1400 years .Abraham Lincoln was better than any prophet or god Ashe abolished slavery.There’s not a single verse in the Quran which orders Muslims to ban this disgusting practice immediately and forever.since there’s no such verses in the Quran,Muslims enjoyed sleeping with these helpless slaves without guilt for 1400 years till the UN forced Muslims to ban slavery.Saudi Arabia practiced slavery till 1962 and Mauritania till 1982…
I was thinking this recently. Islam can reconcile this similarity to an extent as you said, but it seems odd that Zoroaster isn't mentioned in the Qur'an. He seems to fit the mold of a prophet more than perhaps any other Biblical figure, and the early Muslims knew of Zoroastrians, Muhammad even had a disciple who was a former Zoroastrian, yet the Qur'an doesn't mention Zoroaster but mentions these other figures (Hud, Salih, Shu'ayb) that maybe no-one had ever heard of before. It just mentions Zoroastrians briefly without linking them to any previous prophet.
Zorasterianism and Judaism are very simular as well. The 2 probably influenced each other. In the OT it talks about the Persians allowing the Jews to rebuild their temple. It views King Cyrus positively. Cyrus was mostlikely Zorasterian and admired Judaism and saw them as worshipping the same God. I'm wondering, would Zorasterianism be viewed as people of the book like Jews and Christians?
Yes we are.
The Qur’an in surah al hajj 22 ayat 17 says: Indeed, the believers, Jews, Sabians, Christians, Magi, and the polytheists-Allah will judge between them ˹all˺ on Judgment Day. Surely Allah is a Witness over all things.
There, the Quran makes a distinction between 4 religions and those that are called polytheists, implying a different judgement between the believers and non believers, therefore recognizing Magi as people of the book.
FYI, Magi are zoroastrians.
Isaiah prophecy zyrus by name and said he will help Israel getting back to their homeland
Allah has sent many Prophets and Anbiyas through time over 120 thousand from the time of Adam to the last prophet Muhammad Peace be upon them all. Some prophets have been mention by name and some not. And the people of the book has been mentioned but Zorostrian not. Therefore, Muslims go by what was revealed to them through the Quran and Sunnas. Though many prophets have been sent to mankind but also false religions have also been invented as well. Therefore to be on a clear side is what the prophet Muhammad pbuh said in a Hadith as they are many prophets sent to each nation to be guided through the right path and all that were sent were true guided but if we don't know the names and who they were presented to, that's why all those religions were meant to be on certain time and certain people and ends up so the only religion to be followed will be Islam as is the last and final religion for whole humanity not just one nation. Porophet Muhammad Pbuh is the last and the final and he was selected by Allah S.A.W to represent all humanity till the end of this world
I am Iranian Muslim (obviously Shia)! in general you were correct you just made one error,
No one is equal to Ahoura Mazda, the existence of Evil is like the existence of Sheitan
AhuraMazda is the God of the world he create he owns everything as You can see in Avesta -> Yasna -> Hat 29 -> vers 4 : "Mazda knoweth best the purposes that have been wrought already by demons and by mortals(in the past), and that shall be wrought(in the future and) hereafter. Ahura, is the only decider. So shall it be as he shall will "
the true problem that I found is Zoroastrianism and why it is Wrong and Islam is the truth and last massage of God:
1. just like Christianity and Jews their Textbook has a lot of change and influence by unknown source to the point that it is safe to say it is croupt
2. the most Important thing which is wrong about Zoroastrianism is God's attributes are worshiped apart from God itself to the point that you can call them other deities which is something Quran clearly denys and our Imams perfectly described how this is wrong and why it wrong
Wich religion is racist?
@@cocoalfaridah5831 I think he was referring to religions that are exclusively for a certain community like Judaism and maybe Zoroastrian! 😮
@@shairsko9360 oh ok I understand
@@shairsko9360 ok I understand now!
Jew make their religion small, small groups but they controls the world “important matter from home inside the small group in Israel!
They own banks and international banking systems that they created!
Even china, all oil rich Muslims countries cannot buy or sell their oil unless they use the Israeli banking system, Russia ,Europe cannot buy or sell outside unless they go through the Jewish international banking system!
Maybe that is why they don’t care to make Judaism big religion, the are already big, credit card is their latest invention to control and have power in your life, credit cards are all over the world and banking are all over the world Jew power!
They love money.. Jesus kicked them out of the temple for that reason!
They don’t care to make Judaism big bcz ,
the smaller the more powerful they are!
The few controls the many is their devices!
1/billion is more powerful..1 over billions is more effective, like God dominate trillions and the whole universe alone!
Judaism- Jew is doing like God!
One bullet shot in one the heart or head is more powerful than Many bullet shot all over the boby….
They created and control the world banking, the world banks..
Israel, Jew, Judaism the world banks
@@cocoalfaridah5831 Zoroastrianism, No one can convert ! you can only born as a Zoroastrian!
Zoroastrianism was the first religion that told women to cover. First religion that spoke of a messiah being birthed of a virgin, and hints why the Zoroastrian Magi visited the birth of Jesus with gifts. Actually Persians were there at Jerusalem celebrating the birth of the messiah. Cyrus the great is the first messiah the Torah speaks of and he himself a Zoroastrian.
The religion has no restrictions on women covering.
The traditions of those times were different, nothing to do with religion.
@@CarlZend What do you mean?
If you read Islamic texts and read Zoroastrian texts you will see that there is absolutely no resemblance between the two as I have mentioned above.
The core of Zoroastrianism is uplifting for mankind. It equates man as almost a co-creator with Ahura Mazda (term for God). We are AM’s soldiers so to speak.
Islam’s core is in ‘submission’.
Zoroastrianism is about standing up with God.
Zoroastrianism is not about conversion or expansion. That is why there only 200,000 people worldwide still practicing this faith.
Zoroastrianism is about being sought. If people want to know about a way of life they are welcome. But no clergy will go to preach this religion … except when invited by Zoroastrians.
There is no killing in Zoroastrianism. In practice this may translate to the exception of self defense.
Taking of life in any form is considered unacceptable except in the normal cycle of life like eating meats or vegetables to live.
The term Ahura Mazda translates to the Lord of Wisdom.
It does not translate to some all powerful entity.
Zoroastrianism holds 4 tenets.
Truth, Rational thought, Wisdom and universal Love (scholars are not certain about the universal love which may be closer to universal love for truth).
This ‘rational’ approach to life is unique to Zoroastrianism. You are meant to question everything, including the prophet Zarathustra.
You are not to take any concept without a rational filter because that is the God given difference between mankind and any other living form of life - the ability to think, question, discern for ourselves.
There are no dos and don’t. You rely on your own judgement.
The three tools given to you to achieve the four tenets are given as -
Good Thoughts, Good Words, Good Deeds.
There is no concept of God’s punishment in Zoroastrianism. The principle is -
If God is ALL GOOD how can there be punishment. God is full of compassion, love and forgiveness.
This is closer to Christianity than any other religious belief.
The concept of Hell does exist but not in a permanent way. That a soul is judged for its deeds and a fallen soul too will eventually rise and be one with God.
In Zoroastrianism there is always Hope. No negativity is permanent. It is a powerful positive force for all.
Many doctrines try and gentrify themselves by finding links to certain concepts.
From a point of clarity and truth this needs to be clear.
@@CarlZend I think the way Iranian women cover their hair is the way Zoroastrians cover. I never compared it to Islam. I know the religion by the way. I’m Iranian myself. Most Iranians know their heritage, culture, and history very well, and are very enthusiastic about it.
@@agostocobain2729 Your name doesn’t sound Iranian
A very generalised answer to avoid answering the very serious and potent similarities between Zoro. and Islam. Wasted my time watching this
Framing of the question is wrong. What if I asked why Islam and life are so similar? Is Islam copying life. It believes in other dimensions and realms, is it copying quantum physics? No, of course not. Islam is a guide for us and explains the truths of the universe. To say Islam is “copying” other religions is wrong
Yes Islam copied big part from Zoroasterian religion , eg. 7 sky , 5 prayings per day , cleaning and washing hands and face before praying , Esra and Mieraj , cold hell , Seerat bridge , virgin Hori in heaven ... etc .
Thanks!
Zoroastrians were the true angels(Christianity).
If mental gymnastics was an Olympic discipline, Shabbir ally would take gold every time.
I was thinking the same thing.
Islam being last religion could have some similarties with other religion having a lot of prophets & religions .so nothing but a proof of last religion & prophet.
Exactly exactly exactly 💯
Shabir does Islam believe in free will? I don't think so ,have you read the discussion of Adam and Moses? There's no free will in Islam.
as a human you have free will to accept Islam or Not ? as a Muslim you have free will to follow Islam or not ?
@@rajababy2009 you don't know Islam ,you believe in destiny, you re just trying to correct Islam and you still believe following the same religion can take any where apart from hell.
@@warrentanquest1057 oh so you will teach us islam ? did you even read Quran ?
@@rajababy2009 how is reading Qur'an different from reading other books? What a question?
@@rajababy2009 bhai after reading the Quran 400,000 Pakistani Muslim quit Islam and their mullahs were seen crying on national television.This video has gone viral .millions of Muslims are leaving Islam in Iran,Jordan and the west.Saudi Arabia has a fastest growing population of atheists.5% of Saudi Muslims are atheists according to the survey made by Gallup…peace bhai
So in short if you remove the claim that Quran was recited to Maohammad by God, there is nothing new in Islam comparing to previous reliegions and since Zorastrianism, is the oldest of the three Abrahamic religeions, then what is new about them? In relaity, the differences are all in Sharia laws and traditions depending on people, geography and plotics, not in the theology. And then add to this the fact that Zoroastrianism is also based on older tradiotions and belief systems some of which was practiced throughut the human history which you may call unbeievers, then isn't it more reasonable to say that religeous ideas like anything lese evolved with the human sociites and took different shapes according to their needs? In other words, religeion like many things, like science for example, has a natural evolutionary traits made by humans and there is nothing devine about that.
Islam is a mixture Judaism, christianity , zorastrianism and and pagan faith.
Islam is the final Message of God
That's why it seems similar to the old ones
@@SparkyWeeBro Hare Krishna 🙏
All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions.
For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail.
It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
@@Eternal_Servant_Of_Vaiṣṇavas Appreciate your effort mate
@@SparkyWeeBro Hare Krishna 🙏 Are you Muslim?
What are your views on my comment? I would like to know.
Khordeh Avesta that has the 5 daily prayers in it for Zoroastrianism is from 1323 AD. This is 700 years after islam came to Persia. So a lot of these Zoroastrian books are redacted to resemble the Quran or the Islamic religion. Scientist are also unsure if these books are even reliable Parsi religious scriptures, and conclusions could be made they are not reliable sources.
There's cultural-religio discussion happen during that golden age of Middle East, where Zoroastrian, Manichaeism, Buddha, Islam, Christian, Judaism, Greek Philosophy, Sufism debates and cross culture.
Resemble the Quran? Do you mean the Quran resembles the Avesta? Why is it that anything that closely challenges Islam is either wrong or didn’t exist or is unreliable? Maybe you should read up on Salman Farsi and his role. You do realise that during the Muslim Arab conquest of Persia, the Arabs burnt as many copies of the Avesta that they couldn’t possibly find, especially the one In Persepolis! Ever wondered why? Why does one religion not only persecute people who already believed in god but also burn their knowledge? Why did the Zoroastrians migrate to India? All Abrahamic religions are based on Zoroastrianism and to deny that is called favouritism. Nothing can ever justify why Zoroastrians were persecuted for not accepting Islam unless that’s a hoax too.
Zoroastrianism predates Islam by centuries lol
Khorde Avesta is part of new avesta old Avesta is gathas the Core of zoroastrianism
@@DreamcastFarm I think hes saying that there were later additions to zoroastrianism during islamic rule.
Never pray to a dead gangster. Truth will come out and with logic people will ask questions and come to answers they must be willing to confront with. When you study Islam, Christianity, Zoroastriantism and Hebrew you start to see that the only right way to follow God is not by force and ignorance. The faith of true peace of others not their own will take over and other false teachings will perish.
Zoroastrianism is one of the sources for monotheistic religions (i.e., Semitic faiths - Judaism, Christianity & Islam). The other source is the Akhnatan's sect in Egypt. In addition, several stories in Semitic faiths have their origins in older cultures.
Zoorastrainism itself is Aryan or semetic ?
@@satyamindnectar7052Iranian, not Semitic.
If Islam worships the same God as Judaism? Then why can’t Muslims say Yahweh ? Simply substitute Yahweh for Allah?
Allah means God in Arabic
Allah has many names and most beutiful names belong to him, Allah is one of them. Why the Muslims uses Allah, because Allah does not have gender, plurality, associate with any partner....
We don't read the Qur'an, but it appears that we take fallacious human source and add to our Din - which Allah forbidden us to do in many places in the Qur'an. May Allah bring us back to Qur'an only as the source of our Din.
Your name seems hindu?Are you a revert like me?
Thank you for the comparison video. I must correct a mistake in what was stated. Isaiah does not say that God created evil. You can read the book of Isaiah for yourself.
We don't have dualistic in zoroastrianism 🤦 ahura mazda is the one and only gad Ahriman or angra maniu that evil u mention litterly means bad thoughts 😶🌫️
So many religions say their way is the truth and give some proof. But they only can see the world and think through what their religion tells them to think and do. I've literally been told "You not should think and question such things. It is haram and kafir.". If critical thinking and questioning thinks is "Not allowed" then that religion is controlled through fear. If a person is so afraid of Allah out of fear of punishment that they can't even question Him. Then there is a problem. A simple one word question, "Why?". Nothing is stopping us from questioning Allah, Not even He can stop us from doing it. No one truly knows with 100% what is the one true religion from God. All are just how we humans think God acts and what He wants us to do, Anyone can just make up a religion and trick people into following it.
I believe you meant to write "you should not think and question such things". Agree, you should. Ask and search"
All of those so called religions have faded away , trhy are not practiced Significantly. Only Islam Is a practiced religion properly and Quran is unchanged for 1400 years dot by dot . There are prophecies made by Muhammad 14 centuries about future. events that have come true in recent decades for example Beduoins building large structures . Muhammad Propheicsed this 1400 years ago , Now look what the Arabs are building , Burj Khalifa and God knows what. I mean it's pretty clear . Only Islam remains. And if don't see prophecies , miracles in the Quran , Then what other proof do you want?
Trust me I Questioned Islam , But there are enough proofs to keep me as practicing Muslim that God is real
Let there be no compulsion in religion, for the truth stands out clearly from falsehood. (Quran chapter 2)
@@fahadabdulrashid7216
There is no compulsion in religion was a statement made by Muhammad telling Jews, “you have no right to force your children to stay in your religion by forbidden them to enter islam!
That is the truth.. read the whole history to whom it is adressed!
But when it is Muslims, there is compulsion in religion and whoever leave it, must be killed!..
But still unfortunately a lot of my Zoroastrian brother's are killed by my Muslim brother's. So evil is not created by God. Evil rises from ignorance.
Im shocked after read some comments that doesnt know what is zoroastrian and what type of religion of it and what are the practices.
In Quran, Allah (The Almighty God) said about Majusi - Fire Worshipper. The word of Majusi derive from Persian word, Magus - member of priesthood.
Today we know Majusi are pointed to Zoroastrian led by the priest by making huge fire to perform worshipping or praying.
Its fascinating when in Quran Allah said about these 3 religion in one verse which is Judaism, Christian and Majusi. It is safe to say, old religion of persia was already a fire worshipper before Islam conquered them.
we ae not all children of Abraham through descent, but Abraham is the Father of all who have faith...
NO⚠
I was just researching today about Zoroastrianism when i saw some similiarties so i was curios, and out of nowhere this video popped up. Another sign of allah to anwser my question. In the end of my research I found out that:
Zoarastianism has a god called ahura mazda and created an evil creation angra that became corrupted due to his own will to receive greater power and control.
Ahura created then human beings like this:
He created Gayomard first human and then angra killed him out of jealousy and from his bones rhubarb grew out and Mashya and Mashyana, grew out of the rhubarb plant
they populate earth after a catastrophic winter caused by the evil spirit Angra Mainyu, ahura then gave them tools to and knowledge to cultivate the land and protect themselves from the elements, and they became the ancestors of all human beings.
They also say the earth was flat and that angra created the mountains and valley because he tried to destroy earth.
The way the earth is created sounds a bit unscientific
source - www.zoroastriankids.com/creation.html
Zoarastians were only in persia and then they wandered to india cuz arabs attacked persia, those were called the parsis.
The Parsi community developed its own distinct practices and traditions, which differ in some ways from those of Zoroastrians in Iran and other parts of the world.
In terms of changes to the religion's core beliefs and principles, there have been debates and differences of opinion among Zoroastrian scholars and practitioners throughout history. However, the core tenets of the religion, such as the belief in the dualistic nature of the universe and the importance of ethical behavior, have remained largely unchanged over time.
Nobody can convert into their religion but then nowadays some zoarastians say u can convert into by changing the rules.
However, like any other religion, Zoroastrianism has been subject to different interpretations, practices, and historical developments over time. Some modern Zoroastrians have criticized certain practices or interpretations that they believe deviate from the original teachings of the prophet Zarathustra, such as the use of ritualistic practices that were not originally part of the religion or the incorporation of non-Zoroastrian beliefs and practices.
In Zoroastrianism, it is believed that Angra Mainyu is the source of evil and that he will be defeated by the Saoshyant at the end of time. However, the idea that nobody will have negative feelings after his defeat is not explicitly stated in Zoroastrian texts. The ultimate fate of human souls and the nature of existence after the end of time is not entirely clear in Zoroastrianism, as there are various interpretations and beliefs among different Zoroastrian communities. source chatgpt
For me the religion is a bid unconvicing as there are changes between the zoroastrian communities, core belief seems to be the same but end of time core belief is unclear and not 100% certain.
If allah send prophets everywhere to make them acknowledge whats right or wrong and there is no god but allah,
then people got tricked by sheitan and made their own relgions and beliefs, then there is a need for a consistent religion.
This is the reason why those religions werent preserved but the quran was:
Previous prophets were sent to a particular group of people and their message was supposed to be followed for a particular time period. Since previous revelations were time-bound, God did not preserve them Himself. Muslims believe that the Quran cannot be compared with the previous Scriptures. The Quran is unique in many aspects. It is the final revelation to mankind. Previous scriptures were sent to their respective people only. The Quran is universal
That is why quran contains topcics from scientific signs from astronomy to biology, aswell as the meaning of life to worship allah and this life is a test with good and bad deeds are accounted on the day of judgement.
Quran remains a copy cap ..even five times prayer is from Zoroastrianism
Bro pls for sake of allah pls talk to me i have some doubts
Quran is amazing and definitely not a worldly thing.
Yes sure... according to the Koran the sun sets in a spring of murky water (Surah 18:86). Amazing!
@@Kielbitch you took that verse completely out of context and the story in which that chapter is describing. Read the whole chapter and learn a thing or two.
It was describing a king who was travelling and came across a group of people who lived somewhere where the sunset (i.e. the horizon of the sunset) was on a spring of murky water.
@@LOLsamiLOL123 this king was traveling on earth. Wasn't he?
Ma Sha Allah. Barakallah ❤️. I just revisit your old debate. Refreshing. May Allah grant us tranquility and strive for His sake and may Allah accept it.
Put the book down , only than can you find meanings in this life .
Completely wrong zoroastrians don't have dualistic in zoroastrianism 🤦 ahura mazda is the one and only gad Ahriman or angra maniu that evil u mention litterly means bad thoughts 😶🌫️
When u study about zoroastrianism from Wikipedia
I understand your point Dr sabir Islam is like constructing a building.however the previous prophets and messengers are the sub structure and prophet Muhammad S.A.w is the final Roof and super structure as far as Islam is concerned.
May Allah (swt) guide me when I say that there have been thousands of Prophets across time and across the face of the Earth. We Humans are gifted by Allah to make whatever affiliation, association or attribution we care to regarding these prophets. For myself, I choose to follow the Quran and am guided by its message as revealed by the Messenger of God (pbuh). That does not mean that an American Indian is somehow wrong to follow, say, the Indian prophet Wa-voka. And if Christians want to elevate the prophet, Isa (pbuh) who am I to take umbarage. In my very very humble opinion, it is the decision to reject all prophets and the faith they guide us towards, which is the real danger (may Allah preserve us from such). For myself, the only challenge is that I am sure to convey to prophets other than Mohammed, their due regard and respect. Still working on that........
in Quran it is clear that as a Muslim we have to Believe in every Prophet send By GOD whether we know him by name or not , We have to believe that every nation had the prophet But later on people change the message , mixed it etc
@@rajababy2009u mean Muslims of curse zoroastrianism message is clear
Historians and academics claim, that Zroastrians came and originated in Persia ,though recent archeological discoveries showed, that the most ancient place of waship was discovered in Uighur autonomous region(xinjang)Turfan area aka East Turkistan.
Panturk Inver historians said?🤣🤣
Cuz the last Sassanid king run to China they say he built atashkade in there 🤦 first read some history kid
Zoroastrians are the first Iranians/Aryans.
They originated in Central Asia.
Zoroaster prophet was believed to be born in Airyana Vaeja which is roughly located in modern day Tajikistan.
What the speaker overlooked is that Zoroastrianism changed over time and its sources are late in time, and the similarity between it and Islam and Christianity is due to its being influenced by them, not the opposite.
3:40 Wrong. We don’t look at it from the historical-critical point of view and Islam does NOT owe anything to Zoroastrianism. Spread only the point of view of Islam and not atheistic sciences such as historical naturalism. This man always tries to present a “balanced” perspective but invariably ends up as a latter-day Zindiq
Is Zoroaster a prophet of Allah?
Yes, absolutely
We only know the Prophets Allah has informed us of. All the others are known to Allah alone at this point. We do not claim that Zoroaster is a prophet of Allah. Of course, all people were sent prophets. Only Allah knows which prophet was sent to the people whose descendants began practicing Zoroastrianism.
@@Someguy1357 Even the Quran talks about Majoos people.
Quran does not specifically mention it but he could have been, Allah knows best! Allah sent 124000 prophets and messengers to all creeds and nations, the current Prophet and messenger for our current time and era is Muhammad s.a.w...and the revelation of Quran The Final Testament
(Time to get the latest Windows Update)
🐱👍🏿
@@Someguy1357 Muhammad hade the information he should have told us.. in Quran
The story of Miraz, buraq, Hell, heaven - so many things were copied from Zoroastrianism.
lol ? what is your evidences
@@rajababy2009 bhai read their books and then compare..most of the stories,science,etc is all copied from bible, Torah and other religious texts…nothing is original
This copied religion is still going strong. So why not follow the copy.
@@oscarcollier5141 A lot of Iranians(90%) hate Islam⚠
Is Cyrus The Great Dhu al Qarnayn?
I doubt it was Alexander the Great because he was mushrik.
Q: Why Do Islam & Zoroastrianism Seem So Similar?
A: Because Muhammad appropriated concepts, characters and stories from earlier sources such as Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Christianity etc. Even the Quran alludes to this, below are two verses that mention this, there are other verses in the Quran that allude to this too. Any intelligent, honest person capable of analytical, critical thinking can see this when they read the Quran and Sunnah, it's so painfully obvious!
Quran 25:4: 'The disbelievers say, “This ˹Quran˺ is nothing but a fabrication which he made up with the help of others.” Their claim is totally unjustified and untrue!'
Quran 25:5: 'And they say, “˹These revelations are only˺ ancient fables which he has had written down, and they are rehearsed to him morning and evening.” '
Nope, I am a critical thinker, and I see that the Quran is unique in many ways that you can't see, yet at the same time the message is very similar to the message of all religions. Whatever religion you choose, if you are following the good things of what remains of their Scripture (charity, fear God, etc.) then you have hope for salvation, otherwise if you're just following the idolatrous part of those religions and you forget all the wisdom and important teachings, then you're doomed
Again, to understand why it's possible to believe in Islam, and believe other revelations also contain the truth from God, pay attention to the following Quranic verses:
4:164 Some messengers We have already told you about, while some messengers We never told you about. [...]
16:63 By God, We sent messengers to communities before you, but Satan beautified their actions for them. [...]
16:36 We sent a messenger to every community: “Worship God, and avoid idolatry.” Some of them God guided, while others deserved misguidance. [...]
In fact, this is the whole reason a more recent religion called Baha'ism exists. I don't specifically follow that religion, but I understand and acknowledge what the author of its books meant.
Hare Krishna 🙏
All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions.
For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail.
It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
Was Angel gibrael came with advice to kill 800 Bonukoraiza
People included children. If you can answer.pls
read ir from Muslim sources not anti islam pages , It was a treaty between Muslims and Jews that during war they will protect the Madina together But Jews betray Muslims and give inside information to Pagans of Makkah against Muslims when it was clear that Jews betray then Prophet Pbuh ordered to to fight Jews, and no one killed Women and Children it is false , In Islam war ethics are no harm Children , Women or Vegetation , places of worship etc
Bhai angel Gabriel is as fictitious and imaginary as other gods and prophets..all there so called aayats or revalations were self pleasing aayats created by the prophet himself..there is zero evidence of any god or angels giving verses which orders to kill people,make them slaves,loot and plunder other tribes,marry small children,keep concubines,marry daughter in law ,kill critics and sell human beings in slave markets which is extremely disgusting
Will God send another prophet and will there be another religion after Islam?
Hare Krishna 🙏
All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions.
For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail.
It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
I always asked myself about zoroastrianism as a muslim. But this video perfectly explained it, thank you may Allah be pleased with you now i understand it clearly❤❤❤❤❤
God, the One & Only ❤
Madam & Sir, the similarity is in
Monotheism: Ahur Mazda vs Allah,
and yet Islam wiped out Zoroastrianism in Iran by swords in a short period of 10 years.
Muslims love a convenient answer. The problem is that we do have to take the historical analytic approach and suspend the divine element if we are not convinced in the god of abraham. So if we do indeed deny a divine element what we’re left with is a perfectly sensible and plausible transference of beliefs and practices from other “pagan” belief systems into the abrahamic ones. Its too convenient to say “anything we like and agree with we will say god’s revelation was preserved” “anything we disagree with we will say was corruptions added in to gods prior revelations”. Especially now the story of early Israel and the biblical patriarchs are no longer historically credible, we have to also see Islam as a product of its environment, not a special revelation from god. All Islam did was take pre-existing ideas and practices and direct them to a god of the arabs.
Ignorant beyond imagination.
@@oscarcollier5141 why?
According to some scholars like Jay Smith, Islam has borrowed from :
Judaism : Circumcision, no- pork, skull cap, Fasting, Monotheism etc
Christianity : Psalms in Armaic, Virgin mother etc.
Zorastrianism : Peacock tail of buraq etc.( Yazidi?)
Paganism : Circambulating a structure, kissing black stone etc.
🤔
Bruh you clearly know nothing about Islam
@@hassanirfan5267
Jay Smith @ Pfander films and Al Fahdi?
They do know more than you and me about Islam for sure !
😄
@@hassanirfan5267Neither do you.
@@ygcg8696 so chiristians pagan know more Islam than me brother go watch blogging theology then you'll get to know
@@anthonymcken6050 didn't ask
🤷🏼♂️There are no religious leaders that can place their right palm on the KJV and say these words once only in a calm coherent manner-> I refuse to be full of demons.
Various bird species can mimic the words!👹🤡🌍🐣🐥🦜🤷🏼♂️
The birdy’s can say what the religious ppl cannot say 🤪😂😂😂🤪
…that time when you found out that religion filled you with demons and yet you continued to practice…religion 👀
SALVATION 👇🏻
Romans 10:13 For whosoever shall call upon the name of the Lord ✝️shall be saved.
GOOGLE BORN AGAIN ASAP!!!
❤️✝️❤️
I guessed this is for an american public. Which should be said since youtube is an international plattform. USA is not the world.
5 times prayer.
Miraaj hadith all dound in Zoroastrianism mpra than 600 yer before Muhammad birth.😂. What a copy cat
God knows best, If it was found in Zoroastrianism before Muhammad PBUH it means that Muhammad PBUH is the true messenger and prophet of God
@@jenz_kenFollow the original*
Why God sends so many religions,prophets,but none of them useful for humans ?. The world is not better after Moses,after Jesus,after Muhammad .Is God making mistakes by sending the wrong people ?.. Why doesn't God create a better world, taking off evil, temptations?.
No, God sent prophets to the people who Iblees (Lucifer) deceived. As it is said in Surah Aaraf that if Allah wills he (iblees) will deceive Allah's People and Allah willed. besides humans have free will we can do whatever we want but that's not humane.
Why doesn't god create a better world? Because this world is temporary and it is a test.
@@jenz_ken It doesn't make any sense at all.
World is a test
Why there would be everything goody good ?,
@@satyamindnectar7052 Why do you want to be others good ?.Why is it a test ?.Why do bad people have good life ?.
During the first Persian empire 500 BCE nearly half of the world population lived within the empire. Although there was no imposition of Zoroastrianism, which is the first monotheistic religion of the world, the mostly pagan population must have become familiar with its monotheism and incorporated much of that into their thinking.
When will people break free from ancient myths
Excellent comment, thank you.
Very easy, Judaism kept the theology better, Christianity perhaps the moral character and compassion aspect, and other religions that also came from Islam may have preserved other aspects better.
Islam as to mean the last revelation of Allah SWT unto us, is the perfection of a way of life for all humankind.
It's the best spiritual path on Earth.
Some people will die as Christians, Jews or Zoroastrians, and Allah SWT will forgive them and reward their deeds in the afterlife, we don't hold the belief that a random tribe in south america who never got the last message will necessarily burn in hell, Allah SWT doesn't judge unjustly, and he doesn't punish someone who doesn't know, be it by fitrah or by a previous law, that person will be judged justly in accordance to what it was given of guideance and parameters.
Of course, if you do receive the last revelation of Islam, and you reject it, then that is the issue, and you probably have a disease in the heart, like shirk tendencies, you want creation to be God and it is made appealing to you when you lose patience and do evil... Allahu 3alam.
I advise you my brothers and sisters, to not give ear to liars, if you do then you are inviting misguideance, and if you eventually are misguided, then on Judgement Day you wouldn't have a strong argument, because you actually acted towards it.
It happened to me, and my imaan got weaker, Alhamdulillah it keeps getting stronger tho, because I know Allah SWT tests us sometimes like this, like when Musa was tested with Khidr, and it looked crooked but it all made sense with the context, here it's the same exact thing...
You won't find a better path than this, the Quran truly is something else, and as it states:
77:50
فَبِأَىِّ حَدِيثٍۭ بَعْدَهُۥ يُؤْمِنُونَ ٥٠
So what message after this ˹Quran˺ would they believe in?
- Dr. Mustafa Khattab, the Clear Quran
The rest of scriptures on Earth, are either blatantly fabricated, with false prophecies and whatnot, or not preserved, full of contradictions and fabrications by the hand of scribes.
Honestly this Quran is a miracle, and I can't be except grateful for it.
Alhamdulillah.
Good for you
So when the Muhammed received the revelation and recited to the listeners, they will most often say oh, we had already heard this one, you are reading from the old ancient book...
it should clearly be understood that Hadith says after Quran had been revealed the previous books of Allah almighty , Bible & Torah had been cancelled but monotheism توحید will remain till Qiamat #
Salams dear Dr's. Hope you are both well?
I always agree with the stance that you give regarding the answers to all the topics presented to you.
However with regards to this topic, I disagree with you.
Allah would not have based any aspect of Zoroastrian rituals etc and included them in Islam.
Zoroatrians may have a belief in one creator but they worship the Fire!.
They have a Fire, an eternal flame that they bow down too. This bowing down, they call Zesdah. The whole worship ritual is called Namaz. This is a Persian word and literally means Fire worship. What I find strange is that the Muslims, mostly the Pakistanis call their prayers, Namaz!! How weird.
Now, how is it that Islamic rituals appear similar to Zoroastrianism?
It is because the Deen of Islam has been hijacked!
The Persians from the time of Rasool found themselves defeated by the Muslims. They knew the only way to beat them would be to infiltrate Deen. So there was a systematic ideological attack on the Deen of Islam.
Zorastrian ideology found its way into Islam.
Now instead of Deen, we have a Mazhab!! Nowhere in the Quran will you find the word Mazhab/ Madhab.
There is a vast difference between Deen and Mazhab.
The Deen of Allah raises the status of Bani Adam and leads to a massive change within each person. Mazhab, in a nutshell is a fatalistic dogma that says that whatever happens to us, is down to Allah. Mazhab strongly keeps the heads of its followers firmly on the ground, with no outward change in themselves, nor their Society! Go to Masjid, pray, go home and carry on doing all the bad things you were doing.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
This is the most basic misunderstanding about zoroastrianism.
We DO NOT worship fire, we believe fire is the most pure manifestation of god’s power, and since no depictions of god exists, we pray towards god’s greatest creation. It’s the first thing you understand when you start as Mazdayasna.
We DO NOT bow to the fire, we bow to god’s power and light. We pray towards the sun during daytime and we pray towards a fire during night. We have eternal flames simbolizing god’s eternal presence.
WE ARE NOT FIRE WORSHIPPERS.
Ashem vohu.
If you wish to have an honest answer, then the answer is that all religions are born out of one another, and the process still continues to this day. Judaism was made out of many Zoroastrian concepts with the addition of local legends and folklore. This was followed by Christianity, a trash can of Roman mythologies with the addition of Judaism and Zoroastrian leftovers. Then comes Islam, the so-called religion of PEACE and PURE 😂, which borrows and steals most of the main concepts of Judaism with additional Zoroastrian elements and other available legends and folklore at that time. This is the bitter truth, it's up to you to accept it or cling onto falsehood you are told. Truth always prevails itself no matter how much one tries to suppress it.
No becuase god sent 124k prophets since the beginning of time
Shia Islam has similarities with Zorashtriansm in cultural,rituals and traditional aspects .Sunni Islam is radical there is no commonalities between Zorashtriansm..
are you Shiite ?
@@satyamindnectar7052 ofcource I am a Shia
THE VEDAS EMANATE FROM PERSIA???
Both Indo and Iranic aryans have their own tradition of Sprituality with some similarities of language and Early Aryan culture
No. The Vedas, Puranas, Itihasa and Upanishads are born from the breath of God.
Nope Vedas are much older
@@Shiva-nx1tn
Vedas are much older?
SO WHAT???
Primitives are much OLDER?
BAFS
God has no human helper... So God is capable enough to send messages by his own power and inspire human minds directly to their mind without any human help..
So No messengers for God..
Who's this for ?,,5 or 6 year Olds,,
THE TERM "TESTAMENT" IS WRONG!
No final ele diz que apenas o islã mantém intacta a revelação.
Ou seja, falou, falou, e, no final disse o que cada um falaria de sua própria religião : que é a correta
Fica a pergunta: se todas as anteriores perderam a verdade, por que o islã seria a única que a manteria intacta?.
... A fé Bahai veio depois do islã e a história continua...
Historically speaking the Persian King Cyrus the Great who was Zoroastrian defeated the Babylonians who had enslaved the Israelites. He to them to go back the Israel to build the second temple. Zoroastrianism introduced monotheism to the Israelites who at the time worshipped a number of Gods. The two horned one mentioned in the Quran is said to be Alexander the Great but it is most likely King Cyrus because he is revered in Judaism and Mohammed was in contact with a lot of Jews and Zoroastrians. The Muslims pray is almost identical to the Zoroastrian pray and also resembles that of early Syriac Christians so it was most like copied by them.
Sorry to say but the followers of these two religion people are not similar their differences is Extremely different like a mount and a hole hole
Dr Ally misquotes Isaiah (I believe he is referencing ch 45:7) and, inadvertently, blasphemes the Biblical concept of God by failing to distinguish between physical and moral evil. An earthquake, storm etc. are 'evils' because they cause harm but they are not moral evils. A lie is a moral evil. God makes use of the former for good purposes ie: to punish, or test/strengthen ones trust in Him, etc. But God can not make use of, or be the source of, a moral evil because that would be to contradict His very essence. The context of Isaiah 45 is that of using natural evils in order to punish oppressors to God's people so clearly natural evils are what is meant. So, Dr Ally needs to make this distinction in relation to Yaweh: He causes natural evils, He does not cause (but merely tolerates) moral evils.
Excellent video. I have question is there new dajil name Israels 'Messiah' The Yanuka Rav Shlomo Yehuda. Please explain next video
So, if God sends different messages to humanity, means that there’s only ONE God who “speaks” to all humanity, through testaments and teachings, which have the same meaning and significance for all mankind …
If so, why there’s so much division and hatred towards Christians and other religions,
by muslims, towards “other” faiths ?? If it’s how this man describes it, we should all be united and respectful
to each other, no matter if some are muslims, Christian or Jewish….
We have seen fanaticism, radicallity and racism everywhere, from muslims, especially the last few years !!
It’s NOT other races avoiding mixing with the muslims, it’s muslims who avoid them, as they believe whoever is not of their faith is not worthy and rightful as they are!!
It’s all about acceptance and respect for others, no matter what their “religion” is…
If it all stems from the ONE creator, the teachings should be same for all !!
So why such separation ?? Maybe muslim people are not taking Gods teachings seriously and they formed their own radical ideology and beliefs towards everyone else, who don’t follow their faith …
If there was a god we wouldn’t have 4000 different religions. Out of all those religions Islam has the most retrograded effect on its practitioners.
Muslims or Islam copied some philosophies from Zoroastrians but changed it as well, in a very bad way. It's too much to explain here. To say Zoroastrians has the same god or roots as islam is a joke. Allah is closer to ahriman than Ahura Mazda. Islam destroyed my peoples religion, culture, language, history, now they have the nerves to say Ahura maza is the same as the abrahamic gods.
My God did not told my prophet to kill the non believers.
By Shabir Ally's Biddah - Kufair logic, Thor is a Prophet, Laotzi Is a Prophet of Allaah Ellah, aka Odin???
Pls do not insult zoroastrian. Do not mention his name in the same breath with allah
Just a speculation. No evidence that there was such a prophet among the ancient Persians
However as I understand from scholars, after Islam came to this world, all monotheism religions should turn to accept Islam and prophet Muhammed (sal) as the last messenger since the previous faith scriptures are not in original form or Interpolation.
Not "exactly" right. Islam can be accepted as a "correction" of sorts for those monotheistic faithes that rather much got Off-track in what they were originally intended to accomplish. The Judaic Faith was doing just fine until the Covenant with Allah was taken to mean the formation of a nation-state under a Human King. In like manner, the prophet Isa (pbuh) was never expected to be elevated to a status as a god, but rather to correct the earlier mis-guided nation-state concept as well as the growing class system in Judea. Islam is a way in which we Humans can get back to the fundamental belief in a single Eternal and Absolute but we are still challenged by the addiction many have to power and control. FWIW.
@@BruceWSimsnop how someone can accept Qur'an while he don't believe Muhammad is the prophet
@im.avesta Mohammed is a Messenger of God, yet, he is not the only Messenger to come to us, and there is no solid proof that he is the last we shall ever have. Our obligation is to Allah (swt ).
@@BruceWSims indeed like Baha'i said I'm the last while Muslims don't believe in him nor in his teaching
@im.avesta Exactly Right. The Whisperer of Evil constantly tempts us to put Judgements and Reason above Faith which is how he gets us chasing in circles. Nor does it help to have so many individuals bending truths to support their particular take on things. Allah, alone, determines what will be transmitted by whom.....when....and why. Such events are the "tools" he gives us to accomplish our work. For myself, I would rather not debate and discuss about the tools, but rather about the work I am suppose to be doing for His greater glory. FWIW.
So Allah is the moon god?
No
I have been studying Islam and the Quran for sometime and I'm convinced that Muhammad was a Prophet of God
People really expect an all new religion coming from the same eternal God. This is not rocket science.
The only similarity between zoroastrians and muslims is that both believe in one god. That is the only common thing. I'm however appalled with the way zoroastrians conduct the last rights of the deceased. No offence.
Are you kidding me???!!! You clearly show absolute zero knowledge, and because of that, you have made an absolute baseless claim.
All Abrahamic faiths have been influneced by Zoroastrianism.
Paradise
Life after death
1 god
Good v evil
Angels
Demons
Ethics
Hell
Heaven
Pray 5 times a day
Judgement day
Messiah
Virgin birth
Return of the messiah
Good deeds vs bad deeds will be judged
Free will
The List goes on!!!
If you do your research early Judaism before the Babylonians enslaved the Jews none of these concepts I listed was in there faith. It was when the Persian (Zoroastrianism) King Cyrus the great freed the Jews they returned with all of these new teachings. Judaism was under Zoroastrianism rule for hundreds of years and in turn heavily influneced and tought the Jews many things. Islam and Christianity have all been influneced by Judaism. ZOROASTRIANISM IS THE SOURCE OF ALL 3 ABRAHIM FAITHS.
Hare Krishna 🙏
All religions are offshoots of the Vedic religion or Sanatan Dharma. In the kali yuga, the age of degradation and disputes, the population of Yavanas (meat eaters) and Mlecchas (those who don't follow the Vedas) increased. To preach to them about God, God sent many of His devotees to various parts of the world. Since the yavanas and mlecchas couldn't understand the Vedic scriptures as they are, the prophets or messengers sent by God preached the Vedic religion in an indirect form. What is found in other religions is found in Sanatan Dharma, but there are some things in Sanatan Dharma that can't be seen in other religions.
For example, in the Vedic scriptures, there is an elaborate description of the names ,forms, pastimes, and abode of God which is not described in any other religions. In Islam, it is forbidden to make an image of God because the Muslims don't know how God looks, but the scriptures of Sanatan Dharma allow worship of deities of God, because in those scriptures the exact form of God is described in great detail.
It would be interesting to note that as mentioned in the Bhavishya Purana, most of the mlecchas and yavanas are the descendants of Adam and Havyavati (Havva/ eve), and Judaism, Christianity and Islam start from Adam and Eve.
Very well organized and put forward
Dr sb.can u proce from any ayat that Quran,ayats,furqan,kitab or any mohjzaats were or any one was given to by name Prophet Mohammad?
Just post or display one ayat.
Be honest while speaking Quran.?
This is challenge question for u n for all mullah like u of quom e hadees not quite Quran????.
Dr sb,be realistic???
Do Zorastrians bury those who die?
Now yes due to climate change and urbanisation, however, in ancient Zoroastrianism we used to leave those who died on the very top of a hill, for them to return to nature via vultures. The bones also used to vaporise by the sun.
They can do whatever they want in before sassanid they put them on tower of silent for the asha (the way of nature) in Sassanid they burn them cuz fire was important for Iranian they consider it purefaction but Zoroastr never said anything about it so ....
God created everything good. Evil is a perversion of good that God created. This is possible due to the free will.
The people should go to the source, teachings of prophet Zarathushtra to know the pure messages of creator , Ahura Mazda for humanity!
Islam is from zorroaster not the other way around....
Prophet Mohammad
Teacher was zoradtrian priest
Please respeck to your prophet.. Di not tell peace upon him.. Just say salallahu alaihi wasallam.. 😊
They both mean the same things but different languages, doesn't matter.
Zoroastrianism has concept of all powerful one God Ahura Mazda and evil force that exists albeit under Mazda is called Angra Mainyu.
Quran espouses similar concept like Allah the all powerful God and Satan albeit under Allah.
Throwing Stones.
Praying five times ( Or three times a day) etc etc.
By the by Zoroastrians never worship fire as popularly believed.
It is just a natural example for knowledge and enlightement.
By the By another mistaken belief is all Hindu sects believe in many Gods.
Hindus also believe only in one God but concept of Deities ( not exactly similar to angels but a status higher than that of angels but not GOD himself) is alient to Abrahmic religions.
Infact Vedantins and in some firqas of Hinduism say it is not just that there is one God But there is ONLY God everywhere.
One and Only words are the difference from Abrahmic religions to Eastren religions.
Why had to digress and write is because many Islamic scholars ( Including Dr Ally)
Mis represent Eastren religion which is understandable as they have not studied these religions in a structured way under a Qualified master but derived some notions from books written by Westren Authors and lack of understanding of Sanskrit language
why do you always say MUHAMMAD PISS BE UPON HIM..?