So the theory revolves around the fact that IU in the beginning kind of got amnesia/lost her memories so she is downloading them. The animation is the memory being installed of a girl in white, who people think is meant to represent Sulli, while the dragon/lizard is meant to be Jonghyun. The animation shows that the two in the end are together happy in another world almost as if the plane is the real world while everywhere else is heaven. IN the end IU, the woman in the plane, is happy and crying a tear of joy because she knows her two friends are forever together in a happy memory.
Yeah, your thought but after see a article and find what is a mean of this song, it is not related for Lee Ji Eun (IU)'s friends (kinda). It's about go back to memory (like Good or bad experience of life). Whenever is good or bad, these experience will never forget.
Yes, and at the end she looks sad, then smiles a little bit, then goes back to a kind of lost expression. It's heart wrenching. I hope she finds peace in some way through this song.
As someone who used to promote during same era with IU and the fellow idols, Sera can get the hidden message without much thinking, it's all in her face, her eyes when she's thinking as she listened to the lyrics, and her eyes when she finally gets it. Beautiful reaction. Love u
The most powerful moment for me in this music video is at the very end, where IU looks at the camera with a pained expression before giving us a thin smile, which then quickly fades away again. My Korean is quite basic, but the first time I was listening to this song, I felt the emotion in her singing. It was quite touching.
I feel that mix of emotions too. Suga and the other producer did a really good job of explaining the emotions with the arrangement. These are exactly the feelings I get when I look back at memories I have of friends who are no longer with us. Which is the main idea IU is expressing here. TL;DR: Great arrangement and fulfills the main idea IU is pushing about remembering those who are not longer with us.
Joseph Rice ps. IU was also the producer, she also arranged the song, and wrote the melody and lyrics. She was the one that came up with the whole concept of the song and video.
I don't think IU has publicly acknowledged the fan theories. But I recall the first time I watched (without subtitles) I gasped at one scene and exclaimed 'She's dressed like Sulli!'
The overall theme you can take away from the MV is that even though bad things can happen in life, its not a reason to turn into someone with no memories and to instead cherish those happy memories and live thru them in a happy and joyous way
I cried to when i listened to it while reading the lyrics.. it sounds so happy but has such a deep and sad meaning... ㅠㅠ All sad and good memories came back while listening ..
Every single time i watch the mv and listen to the song, i start tearing up. I literally have to excuse myself during the video and just breathe and let the tears flow. Her voice is so beautiful and so full of emotion. Bless iu, i hope nothing hurts her ever again.
Here is a little explanation for those who don't know IU lost her three friends.The lizard is goo hara.The dragon is jonghyun.The girl riding the dragon is sulli.She forgets her memories and goes to that machine to remember it again.'Where their is no shadow' means that spirits don't have shadows.And her friends died when they were young so that is why she said forever young.
yeah, i feel the sadness from the first time hearing it...the tone of her voice and how she is singing... even with that upbeat music her sadness still comes through... i really like this song, the mix of happy and sad is amazing
I never though i would want to know what Sera's comfort food was , now i not only want to know but i want to make sure she always has enough comfort (food) loved it Sera, thank you so much
Every time I watch the video, I cry so hard that I can’t even breathe anymore. So beautiful and moving, it’s amazing how you managed to do so well in keeping it together.
blueming and this are my favorite songs of IU. Every song she does has impressive lyrics and vocals and very few songs can make me tear up every single time. What an amazing artist
On the first play you can see Sera trying to react to the MV, but as the song progresses and the meaning of the song becomes clear and who the song represents, Sera becomes exactly like we do, stunned, sad and speechless. And Sera's comments on how IU actually sings about the sadness in such a calm zen way while making the listeners even more sad is spot on, cos thats exactly how i feel when I hear this!
sera did so well to hold in her emotions at the end. the first time i listened i just burst out ugly crying. it evokes so much feeling, a heartache masterpiece truly!
I like to believe that in the beginning when she asks "are you happy now?" and declares that I hope they are happy...she's talking to people who are hateful for whatever reason, however justified. She's asking that with a sad expression to inquire if all this at least brought them something... because she herself doesn't feel any fulfilment and find her only solace in the thought that people whom she cared about are atleast...happy now.
Oh I thought she was asking if her friends were happy now that they don’t have to see the hate but when writing it out that sounds a lot less cute then it sounded in my head
Definitely hit the Feels, especially when I read the lyrics... I did feel a strange "Sadness" listening to the song for the first time... Love the Song, because it's beautiful... But it definitely hits some Feels...
when I watched this mv while knowing what it represents I cried so much, you can totally feel the sadness and emotion in IU's voice... I love the song and I loved seeing you react to it! thank you!
Very good reaction! We can definitely see you go through stages of reaction as you put together more of the pieces of the video and song lyrics. Beautiful to see you and your heartfelt, respectful reaction.
there’s a theory that this song was for jonghyun, sulli, and goo hara (close friends of hers). you probably already know that they passed away. if you want to know about the theory, there’s a whole video about it by dkdktv :)
@@riceboks She just stated that it wasn't a happy song at all in an interview when she was told it it "sounded so happy and nostalgic". Didn't confirm about the Jonghyun and Sulli theory, but she was close to them both as far as we know.
It's possible she'll never publically admit that it's about them. Idols sometimes have to be very cagey about this stuff because there are people who will accuse them of trying to use the memory of the dead for their own benefit. Whether she admits to it or not, though, I think a critical reading of the lyrics makes it pretty obvious what she's talking about.
this was not a ballad song coming from IU but then the lyrics of it is sad enough to make you cry so what if this song was a ballad one for sure you will cry everytime you will hear this song
Sera you don’t have to worry about being late to upload the video reaction your content always comes on the right time. Also i felt so heartbroken seeing you cry please don’t be sad love you so much 💕
This is such a gorgeous and bittersweet song. Whoever or whatever it might be about we can all relate to feelings of loss and mourning that which is past. Huge props to IU, Suga and everyone else who had a hand in making it because it is brilliantly executed. And thank you for your reaction, Sera. Your expressions say more than words ever could.
Yeah this is song about her best friend Sulli,Go hara and my angel Jonghyun❤..I got to know about this song after watching it's explainnation..I hope these three are not forgotten..well I will never forget❤..I am so thankful for this song..
Thinking about the popular painful fan theory of this song, reading the translations of the lyrics being sung in that calm way you mentioned it is incredibly sad.
Sera you're such a perfect human being. I love your reactions and your music. IU touched my soul with this song, she really has power in her art. I wish the best for both you and her
This song is really good. One of my favorite songs in recent years. Thank you for your reaction video. I hope that singers and fans should be happy and healthy, and do n’t let the cruelty of reality knock down yourself!
뮤직비디오 처음 장면이 "당신의 모든 기억을 저장하시겠습니까?" 아이유는 "예"를 누르고 기계 위에 눕습니다. 노래 첫마디에 아이유는 먼저 세상을 떠난 세명에게 이렇게 말합니다. "So are you happy now? 그래서 너는 지금 행복하니? Finally happy now are you? 마침내(결국) 행복해졌니?" 그리고 노래가 시작되죠. "뭐 그대로야 난 다 잃어버린 것 같아 모든 게 맘대로 왔다가 인사도 없이 떠나" 뮤직비디오 속에 복숭아(Peach)는 설리를 의미하고 도마뱀(Lizard)은 구하라를 의미하고 용(Dragon)은 종현을 의미합니다. 뮤직비디오 속의 애니매이션에서 하얀색 원피스를 입은 소녀(설리)가 오렌지 섬으로 보이는 곳에서 자유를 향해 달려갑니다. 집에서 사라졌던 도마뱀(구하라)은 결국 용(종현)이 되어 나타나 소녀를 태우고 비행기에 있는 아이유에게 마지막 인사를 남기고 하늘위로 사라집니다. 비행기속의 아이유는 그 모습을 보고 안도와동시에 슬픈 표정으로 그들을 바라보죠.. 대충 이런 슬픈 이야깁니다.
우와! 아이유 너무 좋아하는 가순데 에잇 노래 나오고 리뷰영상 안올라오길래 아닌가부다.....싶었는데 늦게라도 올라와서!!! 좋아요!!!! 노래 뭔가 아련하고 슬프고 그래서.....ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ 진짜 언니 말대로 담담하게 불러서 더 슬프고 그래요 언니 중간중간에 흥얼거리는 거도 너무 좋고.... 언니 노래 커버 (ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ) 기다려도 되나요....??? 오랜만에 랩세라도 보고 싶고..ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ
You pick up on melodies really fast :) I feel like as sad this song is, it is equally as hopeful. On the one hand we are sad because of the people that we lost, because of the memories that we can't go back to. On the other hand, we are happy knowing that they are in a much better place and we will always cherish our happy memories. IU and Suga hit as with some real stuff in this song
While I’d rather not tie myself down to the theories whether or not the girl, dragon and iguana are direct representations of particular individuals, I think it would be more appropriate to see that IU does have people that she cares about, despite the fact that she’s often said her social circles are fairly small. I can see those connections the theories point out myself, but I think the message IU is going for is part of a bigger picture, and bigger than herself.
Don't worry Sera. Most of us were about to cry too. It is a beautifully sad song.
Yes True
So the theory revolves around the fact that IU in the beginning kind of got amnesia/lost her memories so she is downloading them. The animation is the memory being installed of a girl in white, who people think is meant to represent Sulli, while the dragon/lizard is meant to be Jonghyun. The animation shows that the two in the end are together happy in another world almost as if the plane is the real world while everywhere else is heaven. IN the end IU, the woman in the plane, is happy and crying a tear of joy because she knows her two friends are forever together in a happy memory.
Yeah, your thought but after see a article and find what is a mean of this song, it is not related for Lee Ji Eun (IU)'s friends (kinda). It's about go back to memory (like Good or bad experience of life). Whenever is good or bad, these experience will never forget.
Also Go HARA represent by the Iguana.
@@DaCollectaholic is there any proof? I'm curious
@@nashazri go hara's nickname is iguana
Yes, and at the end she looks sad, then smiles a little bit, then goes back to a kind of lost expression. It's heart wrenching. I hope she finds peace in some way through this song.
As someone who used to promote during same era with IU and the fellow idols, Sera can get the hidden message without much thinking, it's all in her face, her eyes when she's thinking as she listened to the lyrics, and her eyes when she finally gets it.
Beautiful reaction. Love u
I love Sera’s reactions. Happy or sad, she wears her emotions on her face. She doesn’t have to say a word and you understand her.
The most powerful moment for me in this music video is at the very end, where IU looks at the camera with a pained expression before giving us a thin smile, which then quickly fades away again.
My Korean is quite basic, but the first time I was listening to this song, I felt the emotion in her singing. It was quite touching.
Why can't we have nice things like this in Canada/USA? I am hard pressed to remember the last english song the evokes this much emotion.
It's a song that weirdly makes me both sad and happy haha
I feel that mix of emotions too. Suga and the other producer did a really good job of explaining the emotions with the arrangement. These are exactly the feelings I get when I look back at memories I have of friends who are no longer with us. Which is the main idea IU is expressing here.
TL;DR: Great arrangement and fulfills the main idea IU is pushing about remembering those who are not longer with us.
bittersweet
Joseph Rice ps. IU was also the producer, she also arranged the song, and wrote the melody and lyrics. She was the one that came up with the whole concept of the song and video.
That’s what makes for a good song. A song that can make you feel different feelings
its one those nostalgic kinda songs, my favourite type HAHA
11 days old and I still cry each time :( such a painfully beautiful song.
This was written just after she lost her close friends Sulli, Go Ara and Jonghyun. Hits home hard when she sings "are you happy now"
I don't think IU has publicly acknowledged the fan theories. But I recall the first time I watched (without subtitles) I gasped at one scene and exclaimed 'She's dressed like Sulli!'
As someone who does drawing for work, the girl in the white dress is definitely drawn like Sulli.
I know it's 2years late. It remind me of Sulli's last appearance in Hotel de Luna where sho wore a white dress.
The overall theme you can take away from the MV is that even though bad things can happen in life, its not a reason to turn into someone with no memories and to instead cherish those happy memories and live thru them in a happy and joyous way
I cried to when i listened to it while reading the lyrics.. it sounds so happy but has such a deep and sad meaning... ㅠㅠ
All sad and good memories came back while listening ..
Every single time i watch the mv and listen to the song, i start tearing up. I literally have to excuse myself during the video and just breathe and let the tears flow. Her voice is so beautiful and so full of emotion. Bless iu, i hope nothing hurts her ever again.
Here is a little explanation for those who don't know
IU lost her three friends.The lizard is goo hara.The dragon is jonghyun.The girl riding the dragon is sulli.She forgets her memories and goes to that machine to remember it again.'Where their is no shadow' means that spirits don't have shadows.And her friends died when they were young so that is why she said forever young.
이 영상을 왜 지금봤는지 모르겠지만..
세라님 활동했을때.. 아이유님뿐만 아니라 그 3명 같은시기 활동 해서 그런지.. 세라님 많이 슬퍼..하시는게..공감됩니다..
Some songs don't need words as a reaction, they'll just call forth the emotions
When she said
Shall we watch again?
I literally got goosebumps
that moment when you realise Sera is crying... and you’re crying too ❤️
yeah, i feel the sadness from the first time hearing it...the tone of her voice and how she is singing... even with that upbeat music her sadness still comes through... i really like this song, the mix of happy and sad is amazing
세라 같이들어서좋아요 ❤❤
I never though i would want to know what Sera's comfort food was , now i not only want to know but i want to make sure she always has enough comfort (food)
loved it Sera, thank you so much
Every time I watch the video, I cry so hard that I can’t even breathe anymore. So beautiful and moving, it’s amazing how you managed to do so well in keeping it together.
blueming and this are my favorite songs of IU. Every song she does has impressive lyrics and vocals and very few songs can make me tear up every single time. What an amazing artist
On the first play you can see Sera trying to react to the MV, but as the song progresses and the meaning of the song becomes clear and who the song represents, Sera becomes exactly like we do, stunned, sad and speechless. And Sera's comments on how IU actually sings about the sadness in such a calm zen way while making the listeners even more sad is spot on, cos thats exactly how i feel when I hear this!
한번에 다 이해했지만.. 말을 아껴주신듯한, 사랑해요.
sera did so well to hold in her emotions at the end. the first time i listened i just burst out ugly crying. it evokes so much feeling, a heartache masterpiece truly!
I like to believe that in the beginning when she asks "are you happy now?" and declares that I hope they are happy...she's talking to people who are hateful for whatever reason, however justified. She's asking that with a sad expression to inquire if all this at least brought them something... because she herself doesn't feel any fulfilment and find her only solace in the thought that people whom she cared about are atleast...happy now.
Oh I thought she was asking if her friends were happy now that they don’t have to see the hate but when writing it out that sounds a lot less cute then it sounded in my head
Definitely hit the Feels, especially when I read the lyrics... I did feel a strange "Sadness" listening to the song for the first time... Love the Song, because it's beautiful... But it definitely hits some Feels...
when I watched this mv while knowing what it represents I cried so much, you can totally feel the sadness and emotion in IU's voice... I love the song and I loved seeing you react to it! thank you!
Very good reaction! We can definitely see you go through stages of reaction as you put together more of the pieces of the video and song lyrics. Beautiful to see you and your heartfelt, respectful reaction.
there’s a theory that this song was for jonghyun, sulli, and goo hara (close friends of hers). you probably already know that they passed away. if you want to know about the theory, there’s a whole video about it by dkdktv :)
what does IU say?
@@riceboks She just stated that it wasn't a happy song at all in an interview when she was told it it "sounded so happy and nostalgic". Didn't confirm about the Jonghyun and Sulli theory, but she was close to them both as far as we know.
It's possible she'll never publically admit that it's about them. Idols sometimes have to be very cagey about this stuff because there are people who will accuse them of trying to use the memory of the dead for their own benefit. Whether she admits to it or not, though, I think a critical reading of the lyrics makes it pretty obvious what she's talking about.
🥺🥺💜💜💜 I love this collab song so much
Always love the way you dive into the message of each song you react to. You are so good at sensing the central theme.
this was not a ballad song coming from IU but then the lyrics of it is sad enough to make you cry so what if this song was a ballad one for sure you will cry everytime you will hear this song
Sera you don’t have to worry about being late to upload the video reaction your content always comes on the right time. Also i felt so heartbroken seeing you cry please don’t be sad love you so much 💕
This is such a gorgeous and bittersweet song. Whoever or whatever it might be about we can all relate to feelings of loss and mourning that which is past. Huge props to IU, Suga and everyone else who had a hand in making it because it is brilliantly executed. And thank you for your reaction, Sera. Your expressions say more than words ever could.
I’m crying 😢 this song is so precious !!!😔😔😔😔😔😔
멜로디는 신나는데 슬퍼지는 노래... 이미 많이 들엇지만 들을 때마다 먹먹해져요
Yeah this is song about her best friend Sulli,Go hara and my angel Jonghyun❤..I got to know about this song after watching it's explainnation..I hope these three are not forgotten..well I will never forget❤..I am so thankful for this song..
I allways loved sera's reaction she's so expresive, i'll support her like in 9muses
One of THE best songs! The genius of IU and the pouring out of her feelings after so much loss. Appropriate given our current dark times. ❤️😰
I absolutely love this song and the video is so beautiful. IU is one of a kind as are you beautiful lady. Stay safe and eat sleep and rest well.
Thinking about the popular painful fan theory of this song, reading the translations of the lyrics being sung in that calm way you mentioned it is incredibly sad.
unnie dont cry.....i am there for you asa friend,family and sopporter
OMG. When you were start crying I was crying too.
Sera you're such a perfect human being. I love your reactions and your music. IU touched my soul with this song, she really has power in her art. I wish the best for both you and her
i had a breakdown after reading the lyrics
I really liked the song but till now i didn't understand it but now after seeing this video im starting to understand the feelings. Thank u
This song is really good. One of my favorite songs in recent years. Thank you for your reaction video. I hope that singers and fans should be happy and healthy, and do n’t let the cruelty of reality knock down yourself!
"ohhhh Lizards I love lizards" little does she know
Jaret Fraley I think the lizard died and grow wings in heaven
@@kevinarie5678 if that represent jonghyun thats mean charmander have evolve to become big . Pokemon can evolve right like pikachu to raichu
처음 봤을땐 기르던 도마뱀을 위한 곡인줄 알았다는..
그래도 영상이 슬퍼서 눈물 한방울 흘렸는데
알고보니 눈물 두방울
세번짼 눈물 세번 터뜨림 ㅠㅠ
IU Is a Very Special Lady.
This song is so sad. I feel like Sera feels this song so well.
Heartbreaking this song, I always feel a lump in my throat when I watch this MV.
Finally!!!!! I've been waiting since the song dropped!!
You just gained a subscriber ❤😭
세라님 울지 마요 ㅠㅠ
저도 처음 보고 울었어요
뮤직비디오 처음 장면이
"당신의 모든 기억을 저장하시겠습니까?"
아이유는 "예"를 누르고 기계 위에 눕습니다.
노래 첫마디에 아이유는 먼저 세상을 떠난
세명에게 이렇게 말합니다.
"So are you happy now?
그래서 너는 지금 행복하니?
Finally happy now are you?
마침내(결국) 행복해졌니?"
그리고 노래가 시작되죠.
"뭐 그대로야 난
다 잃어버린 것 같아
모든 게 맘대로 왔다가 인사도 없이 떠나"
뮤직비디오 속에
복숭아(Peach)는 설리를 의미하고
도마뱀(Lizard)은 구하라를 의미하고
용(Dragon)은 종현을 의미합니다.
뮤직비디오 속의 애니매이션에서
하얀색 원피스를 입은 소녀(설리)가
오렌지 섬으로 보이는 곳에서
자유를 향해 달려갑니다.
집에서 사라졌던 도마뱀(구하라)은
결국 용(종현)이 되어 나타나 소녀를 태우고 비행기에 있는 아이유에게 마지막 인사를 남기고 하늘위로 사라집니다. 비행기속의 아이유는 그 모습을 보고 안도와동시에 슬픈 표정으로 그들을 바라보죠..
대충 이런 슬픈 이야깁니다.
the girl and dragon is sulli and jonghyun
우와! 아이유 너무 좋아하는 가순데 에잇 노래 나오고 리뷰영상 안올라오길래 아닌가부다.....싶었는데 늦게라도 올라와서!!! 좋아요!!!! 노래 뭔가 아련하고 슬프고 그래서.....ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ 진짜 언니 말대로 담담하게 불러서 더 슬프고 그래요 언니 중간중간에 흥얼거리는 거도 너무 좋고.... 언니 노래 커버 (ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ) 기다려도 되나요....??? 오랜만에 랩세라도 보고 싶고..ㅎㅎㅎㅎㅎ
Beautiful reaction... Your face just tells everything. You're a beautiful person Sera
아이유 ❤같이들어서좋아요 😂
Thank you for watching this Sera! I felt the same way at the end (although I cried more than you did)
yes I agree this was very sad 😔
This is making me crying
Imagine that this songs is talk about that time she lost her friends... Wake up in the midnight n realize that they gone...
You pick up on melodies really fast :)
I feel like as sad this song is, it is equally as hopeful. On the one hand we are sad because of the people that we lost, because of the memories that we can't go back to. On the other hand, we are happy knowing that they are in a much better place and we will always cherish our happy memories. IU and Suga hit as with some real stuff in this song
waiting for Sera to cover this song xD
Nice reaction to Eight, I think you got the underlying meaning to this song as expressed by your reaction to the flying dragon clip.
thx for the reaction...
Sera 💜 love you 💜
MARAVILHOSA
Some people are saying the lizard is Jonghyun and the girl in White is Sulli....
IU y Suga supieron representar muy bien las sus emociones en esta canción
I cried too, I remembered Sulli and Jonghyun
this is the 4th time listening to this..1st time was brilliant ... then i got to know the meaning. The other 3 times, tears just welts up
thank you.
i hope you cover this song! 🙏
While I’d rather not tie myself down to the theories whether or not the girl, dragon and iguana are direct representations of particular individuals, I think it would be more appropriate to see that IU does have people that she cares about, despite the fact that she’s often said her social circles are fairly small. I can see those connections the theories point out myself, but I think the message IU is going for is part of a bigger picture, and bigger than herself.
💜💜
I would love if you can cover this song. I believe you have the sentiment that will still do justice to this song ❤
I was today years old when i found out you were leader of nine muses
sera is so sensitive. she's a baby. ♡
My reaction was same like you Sera 🥺
React to the acoustic version 🙏
Sera - you are wonder
베프였던 친구들 기억 저장하는 얘기래요
설리 구하라 종현
형님💕
pls cover this song
세라님 뮤비리뷰 잘 보고 있습니다. 류수정님 20일에 솔로데뷔시라 타이거아이즈 뮤비리뷰 해주세영 😀
FINALLY
SERA can U watch IU - Eight ( Acoustic version)🤗
Happy IU day and Congratulations on UR 1st win for EIGHT.🏆🎉🎊
we always love Sulli, Go hara and jonghyun
New MV 공민지 (minzy) - lovely mv
해석에 따르면 이구아나가 구하라고 하얀소복입은 소녀가 설리래요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ
사실 뮤비에 나오는 도마뱀은 이구아나가 아닌게 함정... 그리고 종현의 별명도 파이리였죠
영상에 나오는 도마뱀이 용이랑 비슷하게 생겨서 인기가 많은 종이죠 ㅎ
Sulli music...
So my theory about the mv on why suga didn't appear in the mv is because suga was the lizard and thats it
Plz react on TXT Can't you see me
Official MV... 💜💜
SAY HI TO BRAZIL SERAAAA!! 🇧🇷💗
first!
Please react to one of Ha:felt new videos she dropped 5 this comeback 😳they’re all good so not sure which to recommend but maybe sweet sensation mv