Why geography helps Bayern Munich dominate the Bundesliga

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024

Комментарии • 28

  • @andrijnovak6367
    @andrijnovak6367 Месяц назад +23

    As a bavarian and also Bayern fan it makes me sad that there isn't a real bavarian rivalry anymore. No serious 1860 and no serious 1.FC Nürnberg. It's true that Bayern doesn't have much competition when it comes to huge local sponsorship deals. This situation makes the whole Bundesliga one sided :/

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  Месяц назад +6

      Yeah it’s a real shame what’s happened at 1860. They seem to constantly shoot themselves in the foot. It would be great to have Nürnberg back in the Bundesliga one day. So we can stop pretending Augsburg are in Bavaria!

    • @rockerfarm6445
      @rockerfarm6445 Месяц назад +2

      @@StefanBienkowski but isn't Illertissen playing international?^^

    • @Korianderboy
      @Korianderboy Месяц назад +1

      Ja das liegt an der steilen Umverteilung. Das spaltet die Liga.
      Die sollte viel ausgeglichener sein.
      Die guten Clubs werden ja tritzdem durch CL/EL Geld viel mehr verdienen
      Das gäbe eine spannendere Lifa werden, die theoretisch eirklich jeder Erstligist gewinnen könnte

  • @hannatheguy
    @hannatheguy Месяц назад +8

    Great video.
    I'd like to add one more point which probably does not affect their finances but their attractiveness to local talent.
    The lack of top clubs around them means they virtually have no competition in attracting this talent.
    If someone like Muller was born in the Ruhr area, his club of choice wouldn't have been as easy as picking Bayern.

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  Месяц назад +2

      Yeah that’s a great point. They have Austria right on their doorsteps and even the Balkans, which Bayern have taken advantage of a LOT over the decades. Definitely something that should be considered too due to their geography.

    • @dermunz9478
      @dermunz9478 Месяц назад +1

      Wouldnt say thats true when it comes u-teams. There are no real chances for young talents to make the teams, so they either go on loan or do not even come to bayern in the first place. But its true, that the only real club they are competing there is Nuremberg in the North and some teams in the west. Its not that easy for them as it may seem. And since Nuremberg does mostly play in 2. BL and do not have money to spend on experienced players they have a real good reputation of integrating talents to their pro team

  • @kokotheclown
    @kokotheclown Месяц назад +8

    Why not mention Augsburg? On Munich's doorstep.

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  Месяц назад

      Because they’re not a big club.

    • @UMS-dj3sx
      @UMS-dj3sx 22 дня назад

      @@StefanBienkowski Yet you included Freiburg and Mainz? I guess, you somewhat had to make your argument work by cherry picking clubs and data to do this video lmao. How many people from say the Stuttgart region are going to consider supporting one of the clubs from Hessen or Rheinland-Pfalz? Not many, that's certain and therefore you let's call it "congested areas argument" is pretty weak and falling apart. You also did not take the Bundesliga 2 clubs into account properly. Someone from Hamburg certainly won't support Werder, if there are a bunch of local clubs in Hamburg. Go get that RUclips paper king lmaoooo

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  22 дня назад

      @@UMS-dj3sx I didn't cherry-pick anything. The video clearly states that the clubs on the map are the top clubs based on membership.

  • @footygoatz7552
    @footygoatz7552 Месяц назад +3

    A really insightful video and well editing,excited to see your growth as a youtuber

  • @han8nes287
    @han8nes287 Месяц назад +1

    Very good video ❤

  • @bigc9142
    @bigc9142 Месяц назад +8

    saying 1860 is rubbish is disrespectful, what bayern has in player quality 1860 has in culture

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  Месяц назад +6

      It’s not disrespectful. It’s true. They are rubbish.

    • @hallo23779
      @hallo23779 Месяц назад

      they are in the 3rd tier its not even a debate they are rubbish rn although in the past (long before majority of the earth's population was born) they were the best club in munchen

  • @JohnMushitu
    @JohnMushitu Месяц назад +1

    Interesting perspective

  • @DEJRRMA
    @DEJRRMA Месяц назад +1

    King Stefan keep teaching me 🍻

  • @travislevison6074
    @travislevison6074 Месяц назад +3

    This was really interesting. As someone from England it’s a fascinating perspective to their dominance.

    • @StefanBienkowski
      @StefanBienkowski  Месяц назад

      Thanks Travis. I reckon it's something we're not really used to in the UK. Can probably count on one hand how many cities or even large towns have one decent-sized club. Can you imagine a Manchester or Liverpool only having one club? Newcastle the only obvious example I can think of

    • @travislevison6074
      @travislevison6074 Месяц назад +1

      ⁠exactly that, and even then Newcastle are only like that more so in recent years due to Sunderlands downfall.

  • @JGldmn333
    @JGldmn333 Месяц назад +2

    VFB Stuttgart will win the Bundesliga this year! Sorry to rain on your parade....

  • @jansvatek5029
    @jansvatek5029 Месяц назад +1

    the rheinland is one of the richest parts of germany, too.