If you don't what sex you are you definitely don't have any right to tell me how to do anything as you yourself are very confused in one of the most simple things in life. Which is life.
I'm with Peterson on this. These people ask you to be kind, but these people are anything but kind when you accidentally address them incorrectly, by their standards. It's absurd.
This woman keeps interrupting Dr Peterson after already being asked to let him speak! She is also very contradicting in what she says! I don’t know how Dr Peterson keeps his cool with these fools
This is so ridiculous. I can’t believe adults are even discussing this. Agree with you Dr. Peterson. This trans woman is ridiculous expecting our language to be altered to suit her delusion. You have the right to be called the proper noun you want but you don’t get to choose any other part of speech. A dog is called a dog, yoi don’t get to call it something else because you don’t like reality. It’s craziness.
It’s ironic that this guy, who demands respect for everyone, disrespectfully refers to his superior as “Peterson”. As Dr. Peterson noted, it is more important to be truthful. A common theme among detransitioners is that they have lied to; that nobody told them the truth. It’s terrifying that people listen to this guy because he’s a tenured professor. Thank you Dr Peterson!
1:33 there are only 2 GENDERS. Male and female. I applaud the professor who is standing up for truth!! God created man and woman was created by God using a rib from Adam.
If there are only two genders, then how do you explain people that have attributes of both and how do you explain people that genetically should be one, but have the attributes of the other, and how do you explain people that are genetically neither? The real world is a lot more complex than the simple rules you learned in grade school.
@@scytaleghola5969 That is a strawman. There are only male and female. Thiose who suffer from a DSD are still either male (testes) or female (ovaries). Those who suffer from a DSD are about .03% of the population.
@@davidprince1138 There are a number of issues with what you said. First and foremost, your definition of male and female is the presence of testes and ovaries. When babies are born, what percentage of them have their sex determined by an analysis of their testes or ovaries? Close to zero. So what good is your rule if it's not what is used? Also, while it is rare, there are people born with both testes and ovaries and people born with neither. Therefore, any rule that says everyone is either A OR B, is proven false by people that are A AND B and people that are NOT A AND NOT B. There are other issues, as well, but I will save them for later... if we go there. Look up the credentials of the guy you got your lowball percentage of people with DSDs. He's a high school teacher that never even did a study and he chose to redefine the categories such that he didn't include a lot of people that even you would agree have a DSD. As long as we're throwing out logical fallacies, I call cherry picking.
@@scytaleghola5969 Motile gamete or ovum gamete. The point is, that there are only 2 sexes in our species. For simplicity sake, sex is identified by genitalia, since 99.9+% of the time, that is correct. Ambiguous genitalia, such as those suffering from CAIS, do cause a misinterpretation The activists redefined "intersex" to include any aberration in genitalia, such as a larger than average clitoris or a urethra that does not exit the tip of the penis. Those with a DSD despise being used as a TRA talking point, as well as many consider the term "intersex" offensive. "Disorder of sex development (DSD) is defined as congenital condition in which the development of chromosomal, gonadal or anatomic sex is atypical (1). The incidence of DSD is 1:4500 to 1:5000 live births " - NCBI\NIH Also, you refer to an hermaphrodite, which is a form of an extremly rare DSD. This is an abnormal condition, such as those with more than 5 fingers on each hand or more than 2 legs. Again, your are using a strawman to prove some nonexistant point.
The tip with "programming" the pronouns next to the persons name... It makes it even more ridiculous. These people live in their own world. That's OK. But leave the rest of society alone! Thank god we have people like Dr. Peterson.
There is no explanation. There is no such thing as “transgender”. It is a fictional concept used by deluded people. The word “non binary” is meaningless if not a lie. People are binary by nature. Male or female. I hope this professor does not teach biology.
Commom courtesy asks that we use the preferred names? Okay.... The majority of women dont want trans in their spaces. That's our preference.... Be courteous 😊
If they were so strong in their own identity, they would not care about how people adress them, it would not make a difference to them. Therein lies the whooe woke problem. Let them deal with their own personnal stuff instead of making their stuff the problem of everyone else. They're making us guilty of their own dis-ease with themselves. INSANE!
I could not agree more with all he says. This transgender ideology is total madness. You just don"t invent pronouns that don't exist, to please somebody's "feelings".
Why are those people who always smiling and “encouraging” you to be kind and sympathetic soon becoming judgemental and start segregating you as an outdated bigot minority ending up being oppressive with bitter face? Guess you know which side I’m talking about.
Forcing me or anyone else to call you anything but male if you are genetically male or female if you are genetically female is unfair to me or anyone else. What you decide to call yourself should not be forced upon me or you anyone else just because you choose to call yourself something you clearly are not!
I am 55 Years and I don't own a smart phone and don't intend on getting one.That idiot wants you to buy a device some to remember someone's pronouns? I have a hard enough time remembering Pin#'s, Password's. I have a difficult Eastern European Surname that contains one vowel, people mispronounce it all the time and I have to correct them, I don't lose sleep over it. Should I force people to take Language classes to learn how to pronounce my name? What about all other Languages and have people jailed if they mispronounce names?
How about transgenders acomodate the non transgenders for once? How about the transgenders show kindness towards the non transgenders for once? It takes two to tango!
People need to just get over it. There's only 2 sexes, man and woman, and I'm not changing my way of speech. This is America. I thought people go to college so they can learn. So they could be successful In life, not sit around and try to change our english language.
This "discussion" actually took place with a Professor and a Much smarter sane man. Why? Mr. Peterson is playing the game of Abject Reality and this Professor of "Banal, Woke Nonsense" is playing Three Card Monte with one card.
He says "I do this and that and this on my phone and therefore you must be compelled by law to do the same" These narcissist's can't imagine that there are diverse views on this, and many other subjects, while simultaneously marching in the streets demanding more diversity.
Here’s one for this guy. Prove we have a gender identity. Scientifically and biologically. It’s like proving we have a soul. I believe we have a soul can’t prove it though
Side on Peterson always...obviously. in nature there are 2 genders. So this confusion in the head of some people do not justify any of their request to bring confusion and mayem on others. Not sure if it the same legal teaching in other countries, but in Italy..until they not go crazy, and I'm Italian, the freedom of the others ends where my freedom start. I mean that no one can make me accept the absurdity of even hear this useless issue.
And this is a problem because this whole pronounce ideology is racist, because it can only somehow be used in English, this ideology will not work in my native language, Polish,
The professor from New Zealand just utters banal catch-phrases. If "we have two ears and one mouth" why doesn't he listen when Jordan Peterson is answering?
There is no law that one has to be "kind". Particularly when doing so denies the truth. So the old woman in the tie is saying I should abandon what I KNOW to be true just so she can feel "safe" or good about herself. As far as being lazy, guess what lady? Its perfectly fine to be lazy if someone wants to be. Again, she is asking people to act in a way contrary to how they are naturally just because she wants us to.
Lets go back to basics. What is the medical determination for someone "ze". If someone is Ze, then they can walk into any medical facility and the doctors can clearly determine a "ze" person from medical observations or tests. If it comes down to what someone "feels" and there is no medical docuemation to determine that or back that position, then it is clearly a "want" and not a need.
The professor says we have two ears and one mouth for a reason, but he himself does not hear what Jordan has to say (what we all also think)... snce when do we solve an opression issue by opressing the other side?
Игры
Dr. Peterson speaks for most of us.
Agreed. I will NOT be forced to use compelled speech.
@@livingart2576 JP is fair on the forced pronoun issue; but people conflate that to assume he is a brilliant intellectual. He isn't.
@@jerrygreene1493I would bet he is way smarter than you give him credit for. I’m an armchair scholar too. Lol
@@theguitarguy8760 JP said something smart in this video? What?
Thank you, Professor Peterson for NOT backing down!
It’s easy for him because he has tenure which means he’s untouchable unless he breaks the law.
You have the right to live in a fantasy world however you don't have the right to force me to live in it with you ‼️
Exactly
Precisely
Absolutely. F theses Kooks.
If you don't what sex you are you definitely don't have any right to tell me how to do anything as you yourself are very confused in one of the most simple things in life. Which is life.
Can I get a witness? I'm a 74 year old white Canadian man. I'm glad I'm old.
How can you be non-binary and transgender simultaneously?
Because it's all rubbish and they make it up as they go along
U can b anything if ur delusional
Non binary idiots constantly tell us what they're not but they can't tell us what they are..
There is a difference between “ courtesy” and “delusion”.
Agree!
Peterson rocks!
Dr Peterson makes his point repeatedly but no-one here is listening.
All we can do is pray that as we all just stand on the Word of God that it will impact some to truly hear the truth and their hearts would be changed.
Precisely
This professor from New Zealand is nonsensical.
Embarrassing
Certifiably crazy
He's a bloody imbecile
Jordan Peterson is speaking the truth.
I'm with Peterson on this. These people ask you to be kind, but these people are anything but kind when you accidentally address them incorrectly, by their standards. It's absurd.
Those pronoun garbage words are absolutely ridiculous!!!!
Good toy you Prof Peterson, keep telling the truth
You can not require me to speak the way you wish. You can not impose your will on others !!!
Where I grew up we knew a boy from a girl. The government should not make a law on genders.
This woman keeps interrupting Dr Peterson after already being asked to let him speak! She is also very contradicting in what she says! I don’t know how Dr Peterson keeps his cool with these fools
Mr. Peterson speaks truth and the majority of Canadians agree with him!
I prefer being lazy than dellusional
No to legislation regulating pronouns -
You go Jordan!
That geezer on the right is a Professor..... We're ALL DOOMED...!!!!!!! Ahhhhhhh..
How in the Word are we supposed to remember all that pronoune garbage?
And more importantly “why”
I agree with Jordan Peterson!!! You can be anything you want to be, but I do not have to participate!! Sorry but not sorry!!
This is so ridiculous. I can’t believe adults are even discussing this. Agree with you Dr. Peterson. This trans woman is ridiculous expecting our language to be altered to suit her delusion. You have the right to be called the proper noun you want but you don’t get to choose any other part of speech. A dog is called a dog, yoi don’t get to call it something else because you don’t like reality. It’s craziness.
It’s ironic that this guy, who demands respect for everyone, disrespectfully refers to his superior as “Peterson”. As Dr. Peterson noted, it is more important to be truthful. A common theme among detransitioners is that they have lied to; that nobody told them the truth. It’s terrifying that people listen to this guy because he’s a tenured professor. Thank you Dr Peterson!
It's a she
My bad….
Didn't she say she was a transgender??
Oh shit she tricked you!!!😂😂😂,
Excuse me ma'am
1:33 there are only 2 GENDERS. Male and female. I applaud the professor who is standing up for truth!! God created man and woman was created by God using a rib from Adam.
If there are only two genders, then how do you explain people that have attributes of both and how do you explain people that genetically should be one, but have the attributes of the other, and how do you explain people that are genetically neither?
The real world is a lot more complex than the simple rules you learned in grade school.
Precisely
@@scytaleghola5969 That is a strawman. There are only male and female. Thiose who suffer from a DSD are still either male (testes) or female (ovaries). Those who suffer from a DSD are about .03% of the population.
@@davidprince1138 There are a number of issues with what you said. First and foremost, your definition of male and female is the presence of testes and ovaries. When babies are born, what percentage of them have their sex determined by an analysis of their testes or ovaries? Close to zero. So what good is your rule if it's not what is used?
Also, while it is rare, there are people born with both testes and ovaries and people born with neither. Therefore, any rule that says everyone is either A OR B, is proven false by people that are A AND B and people that are NOT A AND NOT B.
There are other issues, as well, but I will save them for later... if we go there.
Look up the credentials of the guy you got your lowball percentage of people with DSDs. He's a high school teacher that never even did a study and he chose to redefine the categories such that he didn't include a lot of people that even you would agree have a DSD. As long as we're throwing out logical fallacies, I call cherry picking.
@@scytaleghola5969 Motile gamete or ovum gamete. The point is, that there are only 2 sexes in our species. For simplicity sake, sex is identified by genitalia, since 99.9+% of the time, that is correct. Ambiguous genitalia, such as those suffering from CAIS, do cause a misinterpretation The activists redefined "intersex" to include any aberration in genitalia, such as a larger than average clitoris or a urethra that does not exit the tip of the penis. Those with a DSD despise being used as a TRA talking point, as well as many consider the term "intersex" offensive.
"Disorder of sex development (DSD) is defined as congenital condition in which the development of chromosomal, gonadal or anatomic sex is atypical (1). The incidence of DSD is 1:4500 to 1:5000 live births "
- NCBI\NIH
Also, you refer to an hermaphrodite, which is a form of an extremly rare DSD. This is an abnormal condition, such as those with more than 5 fingers on each hand or more than 2 legs.
Again, your are using a strawman to prove some nonexistant point.
I side with Peterson….
I'm not going to play their games !!!
Yup!! 100% agree
Totally agree!
Good Peterson!
That woman can't even put on a tie properly and demands people to use incorrect grammar, the audacity
Lol, thought something else looked off.
The tip with "programming" the pronouns next to the persons name... It makes it even more ridiculous. These people live in their own world. That's OK. But leave the rest of society alone!
Thank god we have people like Dr. Peterson.
Amen
Harassment is one thing but forcing someone to use certain words when refering to them for the sake of not hurting feelings is absurd..
How can one be Transgender and Non Binary. I would like an explanation.
Because neither of those words means anything. Just crap they made up.
There is no explanation. There is no such thing as “transgender”. It is a fictional concept used by deluded people. The word “non binary” is meaningless if not a lie. People are binary by nature. Male or female. I hope this professor does not teach biology.
You’re playing make pretend with all these fake words. It’s out of control!!!
Commom courtesy asks that we use the preferred names? Okay.... The majority of women dont want trans in their spaces. That's our preference.... Be courteous 😊
I believe most people, myself included, agree with Dr. Peterson.
I agree Dr. Peterson is speaking the truth for most of us what he says is the truth
If they were so strong in their own identity, they would not care about how people adress them, it would not make a difference to them. Therein lies the whooe woke problem. Let them deal with their own personnal stuff instead of making their stuff the problem of everyone else. They're making us guilty of their own dis-ease with themselves. INSANE!
Agree only, can’t make me guilty!
omg this woman is out of her mind , I can't believe she actually thinks that what she is saying makes sense.
I could not agree more with all he says. This transgender ideology is total madness. You just don"t invent pronouns that don't exist, to please somebody's "feelings".
So disgusting!!! Satan in full swing but in the end, GOD WILL PREVAIL!!!
Yes GOD WINS!!!
Why are those people who always smiling and “encouraging” you to be kind and sympathetic soon becoming judgemental and start segregating you as an outdated bigot minority ending up being oppressive with bitter face? Guess you know which side I’m talking about.
They are delusional and depressed
Peterson is absolutely right. One of the most brilliant man I have ever studied
What a bunch of crap. It's sad that Jordan Peterson has to make this argument to individuals who have no more sense than God gave a pee.
And they are a professor god help us.
Forcing me or anyone else to call you anything but male if you are genetically male or female if you are genetically female is unfair to me or anyone else. What you decide to call yourself should not be forced upon me or you anyone else just because you choose to call yourself something you clearly are not!
Miss Jane Hathaway from the Beverly Hillbillies?
Totally! Nailed it
I am 55 Years and I don't own a smart phone and don't intend on getting one.That idiot wants you to buy a device some to remember someone's pronouns? I have a hard enough time remembering Pin#'s, Password's. I have a difficult Eastern European Surname that contains one vowel, people mispronounce it all the time and I have to correct them, I don't lose sleep over it. Should I force people to take Language classes to learn how to pronounce my name? What about all other Languages and have people jailed if they mispronounce names?
This is about restriction of speech and consequences for using unapproved words .
How about transgenders acomodate the non transgenders for once? How about the transgenders show kindness towards the non transgenders for once? It takes two to tango!
No one has the right to distort reality
People need to just get over it. There's only 2 sexes, man and woman, and I'm not changing my way of speech. This is America. I thought people go to college so they can learn. So they could be successful In life, not sit around and try to change our english language.
Exactly!
Leftist insists "we have two ears and one mouth for a reason"! hahaha...implying we should listen twice as much as we talk! 🤣 Yes, mommy.
Frankly, I'm sick of this. He/ she works for me.
This "discussion" actually took place with a Professor and a Much smarter sane man. Why?
Mr. Peterson is playing the game of Abject Reality and this Professor of "Banal, Woke Nonsense" is playing Three Card Monte with one card.
That poor little old lady
"you are just being lazy Jordan." No he is just being reasonable.
"I've told the truth at every turn. I'm a zie." The irony of a liar.
He says "I do this and that and this on my phone and therefore you must be compelled by law to do the same" These narcissist's can't imagine that there are diverse views on this, and many other subjects, while simultaneously marching in the streets demanding more diversity.
Its name was AW pete is that what he said. Does that stand for a A women pete.
What a load of crap
Why the intermission?
Just not worth the headache....just no
If something doesn’t make sense then it’s not true-Judge Judy.
Now they want to regulate how we talk??
just call folks by first names . easier to remember. no smart phone needed . 😮😮😮
Y’all need to leave the English language these are not words!!!
How about everyone being civil and polite to each other, forget legislation!
How bout we already tried it. It doesn't work they just keep wanting more.
@@covidisevent201 yup
A. W. Peet pushes childhood transitioning and the arrogance is in the breeding.
There are only two sexes male and female
Rather than sex and gender, can't it just be called Identities?
This guy is nuts in my opinion
Not a guy
Here’s one for this guy. Prove we have a gender identity. Scientifically and biologically. It’s like proving we have a soul. I believe we have a soul can’t prove it though
We don't _have_ souls. We _are_ souls.
The solution for the so called professor is to "straighten up" and fly right as the old timers used to say.
Good for you Jordan...
Genesis 1:27...Truth is absolute
How do you know if someone is non binery and transgender?
They keep telling us they are!
Why can't trans be kind to CIS? It works both ways. Sorry if my Karma ran over your dogma!
NOT BY LAW!!
Keep up the good work peterson CANADA LOVES You
Side on Peterson always...obviously. in nature there are 2 genders. So this confusion in the head of some people do not justify any of their request to bring confusion and mayem on others. Not sure if it the same legal teaching in other countries, but in Italy..until they not go crazy, and I'm Italian, the freedom of the others ends where my freedom start. I mean that no one can make me accept the absurdity of even hear this useless issue.
Love this Dr Peterson guy. He is so right! Common sense!
Not going to cruelly support a delusion either.
If I was to go to the shop for a chicken pie and later I find it’s a steak pie…I’d be upset
And this is a problem because this whole pronounce ideology is racist, because it can only somehow be used in English, this ideology will not work in my native language, Polish,
How dare these people want us to follow their stupidity let them live in la la land but the rest of us live in the real world
Considering I don’t find many in agreement with the Professor and the like, on most forums, let’s me know that this is a lot of nonsense for a few.
This so called professor is so delusional. Be whatever but don't force me to support it or pay for it.
The professor from New Zealand just utters banal catch-phrases. If "we have two ears and one mouth" why doesn't he listen when Jordan Peterson is answering?
Fundamental issues of this nature should be decided by a referendum based on 2/3 majority.
There is no law that one has to be "kind". Particularly when doing so denies the truth. So the old woman in the tie is saying I should abandon what I KNOW to be true just so she can feel "safe" or good about herself. As far as being lazy, guess what lady? Its perfectly fine to be lazy if someone wants to be. Again, she is asking people to act in a way contrary to how they are naturally just because she wants us to.
Him and her is it
There's no drama as the man on right suggests. Let's go to basics and reality.
peterson is just awesome fighting for our rights
So, which one of these is Dr. Peterson isn't apparent until he speaks.
That’s not a man…..it’s a woman
i'll call anybody whatever they want but don't expect me to know in advance.
Lets go back to basics. What is the medical determination for someone "ze". If someone is Ze, then they can walk into any medical facility and the doctors can clearly determine a "ze" person from medical observations or tests. If it comes down to what someone "feels" and there is no medical docuemation to determine that or back that position, then it is clearly a "want" and not a need.
For anyone wondering whatever happened to Jane Hathaway from the Beverly Hillbillies, here you go.
Quite evident that the host of power and politucs, was triggered by Dr. Petterson's comments, maybe time for another hist for this show.
The professor says we have two ears and one mouth for a reason, but he himself does not hear what Jordan has to say (what we all also think)... snce when do we solve an opression issue by opressing the other side?