Why Disney’s Wish Fails on Every Level
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 20 июн 2024
- SUBSCRIBE To The Channel!
www.youtube.com/@isaacmurdock...
Disney’s Wish isn’t great… What happened? Will Disney ever make a good movie again? Let’s talk about it!
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
Intro - 0:00
The Protagonist - 0:36
The Villain - 1:15
The Side Characters - 2:00
Sabino - 3:07
The Music - 4:16
The Animation - 7:55
Conclusion - 8:40
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
🔽 Stuff I Talked About In This Video
My Brother's Channel ► / @yarcopolo
At All Cost's (Demo) ► • Benjamin Rice, Julia M...
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
🔽 Follow Me On Other Platforms
TIKTOK ► / isaac_murdock
INSTAGRAM ► isaacmurdoc...
SPOTIFY ► open.spotify.com/artist/5b9R1...
APPLE MUSIC ► / isaac-murdock
AMAZON ► music.amazon.in/artists/B0846...
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
🔽 Music
Brinstar - Super Smash Bros.
Sunshine Seaside - Super Mario 3D World
Dire Dire Docks - Super Mario 64
Hyrule Castle [Outside] - Legend of Zelda: Breath of The Wild
Air Man Theme - Super Smash Bros.
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
🔽 Watch MORE Videos
Will the Mandalorian Save Star Wars? ► • How The Mandalorian & ...
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
🔽 Subscribe to All My RUclips Channels!
🎥 @isaacmurdock
🎵 @isaacmurdockmusic
🎮 @Nurdock
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
#disney #wish #disneyplus #videoessay #disneywish #chrispine #animation #film #filmmaking #3danimation #disneystudios #pixar #sony #dreamworks #spiderverse #pussinbootslastwish #frozen #moana #encanto #isaacmurdock #streaming #theaters #newmovies #kingmagnifico #asha #wishreview 
Кино
![Lainey Wilson - Out of Oklahoma (From Twisters: The Album) [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1TsZH__etDA/mqdefault.jpg)
My butt found the subscribe button.
ima sub too
You’re a legend 🙏
Your butt has good taste.
Apparently, star boy got cut because “it just didn’t play as well as we wanted” which basically means “we were too lazy to make it work, and we wanted some plushies”
Yeah, I wonder if the disney execs interfered and/or the studio just didn’t give the animators enough time to make it work and they had to opt for something easier AKA the star we have in the final movie.
@@isaacmurdockthere was also a scene where the grandpa sang “A wish worth making”. It was almost completely animated too, but then the higher ups forced them to cut it out for some reason
More like they didn't want to make them a romantic pair and the LBGT alternative would've bombed the movie even more
it was a straight pairing what do you mean
it was a straight pairing what do you mean
The songwriter Julia Michaels was done dirty. They literally gave her a description with three weeks to write and then that’s it they didn’t let her revise anything. Songwriters are usually involved in the entire process just look at Alan Menken and Lin Manuel Miranda. As for the animation they had the perfect 2D and 3D blend that they used for the short Paperman
That’s so frustrating. She’s clearly a talented producer, I don’t think most people could do much better with a timeframe like that.
@@isaacmurdock the best song At All Cost went to waste and they wasted Chris Pine’s singing ability. If they wanted to keep At All Cost then why not at least make it between the King and Queen
Maybe if the grandpa had gotten his wish and "Inspired the future generations with his music" the songs would have been better.
Justice for my man Sabino! 🥲
😂😂
A film "100 years in the making" that feels like it didnt even have five minutes of thought.
"When it comes to the universe we're all shareholders" the worst lyric in the movie
I did I not mention this one!!!
“Get that through your system, solar”
"I'm a star! Watch out world here I are!" What does that even mean!??!?
Basically King Magnifico is the bad guy because he won't making every wish come true... And I understand him and support him because there are lots of really bad wishes and evil wishes and one should never grand them
I kind of have been mildly thinking about this while running today. Even good wishes could end badly. So for instance what if someone wishes they could be really good at physics and then later made the atom bomb. Or someone wishes to be good at biochem and then accidentally creates an incurable disease. On paper being good at physics or biochem can lead to great things like nuclear energy or medicines. But it doesn’t always end up alright.
@@ninjagirl226 Just like Noble invented dynamite
When I saw Wishes being released back to people who are selfish for asking more. Not only Good Wishes, there are BAD Wishes are being released back to the same people as well. Even if the people forgot after they gave up their wishes, those wishes are based on their DESIRES and the Desires are based on their emotions and thoughts. If people suddenly remembered what they actually wished for when WISHES, even the vague ones, returning to them. It can means they will decide to act on their WISHES with Magic or without Magic.
Even worse, that idiot girl become a Fairy God Mother who will granted their Wishes that will bringing the life of every villains alive to the Disney World. We all have seen all of those familiar villains (probably years later) after the Magic Mirror incident.
I wonder if Asha actually feel regret years later and would visited Magic Mirror Magnifico who would say "I TOLD YOU SO" to her.
@@deaflizard9721 I was thinking of her Grandfather’s wish and how kind of in the wrong hands how evil that wish could be. He wants to inspire the next generation through music…inspire them to do what?
Like Scar inspired the Heyna’s in “Be prepared” to kill Mufasa. In Descendants, Maleficent has a song number to inspire Mal to steal the wand called “Evil like me”. Mother Gothel sings about how Rapunzel should never leave the tower due to all the scary things in the world in “Mother Knows Best”.
Like the ability to influence people can easily be used for evil just as much good.
@@ninjagirl226 - I can think of several things how her Grandfather's wish can go wrong. Remember "Coco" movie? (raise an eyebrow) Humans can be inspired to do anything to twist her grandfather's wish, with magic or without magic. Or as far as they could go to murder him for his song. Or tricked him into a signed paper that stole his song. Greed does interesting thing to black their hearts - that's where Wishes based on their desires are.
When your villain is decent because everyone else sucks, you know they got ONE BIG problem!
He's not even a villain, the movie gaslights you to think he is
@@Nour-qr3sv *Brainwash. That's not gaslighting.
@redpanda6497 It is gaslighting AND brainwashing, gaslighting as the movie tries to make it seem like he's at fault when he didn't fulfill her father's or mother's wish i dont remember
He’s not even the villain. The city is literally his. He built it. Using his powers but he still built it. And he let people live there for free, giving them everything they needed. In the beginning we see that he’s kind. What happens to him is the result of the Caregiver personality taken to extremes and suddenly no one appreciates everything he’s trying to do. All because one WOMAN decides he’s wrong.
@@CearaIvory I agree, but why did you point out that she's a woman?
I'm not even a native speaker and even I was horrified by this atrocious display of poor lyricism. You'd think Disney would hire the best of the best for every single task involved in production. It's not like they can't afford it. And it was the hundredth anniversary, for heaven's sake 😖
I know right!?! 😂
At this point it's not on the hire.. it's on the condition or ecosystem they provided. May be the artists they hired are capable.. they just werent given the time or possibility to deliver
Disney forgot the message of one of their own characters "You can't rush art"
Even the people who translated the song into German couldn't fix it. They also used Yoda sentences. At every over movie they did a pretty good job.
Wish will forever go down as one of those movies where people, ironically, will wish that they'd gone with the original idea rather than the final product 😟
When you make a movie that’s a celebration of what you have done, you don’t do anything original that hasn’t been done better.
I honestly cannot tell if this comment is for or against the movie.
@@isaacmurdock I’m confused. How exactly would my comment be for the movie?
Looking at your comment now, I understand what you were getting at. Lol I was just being dumb.@@ironicallyedgy7234
I predict that "Here I are." will become this generation's equivalent of "Conglaturation!!!" and "You're winner!"
Or; "All your base are belong to us."
@@fluffykittenscrafts Or; "I feel asleep!!"
It just occurred to me that the Fairy Godmother from Shrek 2 is basically what King Magnifico should have been
The only problem is they forgot to, you know, actually make him evil
Omg you're right!
Disney screwed up worse than I thought on the characters here.
Also, I'm so disappointed that the Queen turns her back on the King at the end. Like, I thought y'all were married and loved each other? Why wouldn't you want to try to save him? Nah, she saw her way to having the crown for herself.
Yeah, earlier on she seemed to genuinely love him and keep him from succumbing to "the Dark Side" (copyrightLucasFilmLLC,allritesreversed), but once he crosses the horizon line of evil (or some other trope-y description) and pays for it, she's all like, "ehh, he got what he deserved."
@@joestrike8537 He was a great husband, why did she suddenly move on that quick? He was POSSESSED BY A MAGIC BOOK, YET HE GETS IMPRISONED FOR IT??
imagine if the guy left the girl like she did to him, how would the internet react?
I was pissed too. So all what she said; her love for him was just BS then. She is much as a villain as Asha is.
The one good thing about this movie is that it united writers and artists to create their own version of how Wish should be. And I have loved every video/art piece! Everyone's creativity has really inspired others to create stories and express their creative freedoms- including your video! Thank you!😁I agree with your brother, grandpa was great😌
This comment is awesome, also my brother wants me to tell you thank you! 😂
My standards when it comes to music are really low, and I STILL visibly cringed while listening to "This is the Thanks I Get?!"
ahahahahaha this comment made me laugh.
I wouldn't be surprised if she said that line the same way every time because a) the directors told her to say it the same way or b) she thought she was rerecording the same lines over again but with a few changes, because apparently this movie was still being written while it was recorded.
Yeah, I wouldn’t say that it’s her fault. She’s clearly a good singer, I think the directing is to blame.
@@isaacmurdock I think that basically summarizes the entire movie. Everyone who worked on it could have done amazing, the directors ruined it.
raise your hand if you wanna see a disney 2d animation again
with animals focused on more than people
like 101 dalmatians, fox and the hound, oliver and company, brother bear, lion king, lady and the tramp, detective mouse, etc
heck yeah we need to make that happen
or just a full hand-drawn 2d animated movie by disney is seriously mine and everyone's wish
Thank God Miyazaki blessed us with another piece of his magic (that probably *will* be his last film) so we can see what someone with actual talent and vision can do without a corporation full of "note-givers" burying the creative team under poor decsions
✋✋✋✋✋✋
Wasn't there a more recent commercial that contained 2d animation with the Dalmatians?
@@karathewolfsfanficchannel933 yeah i think it was amazon or walmart
I realized the lyric “throw caution to every warning sign” although it sounds off, kinda makes sense. When I see a warning sign, I use caution, but the similarity to the expression “throw caution to the wind” which has the opposite meaning causes a lot of confusion.
Something that makes Asha's 7 companions look even worse.
Encanto had 11 side characters and we can remember them all and all of them had memorable personalities and were all very fun on screen and many of them even had story arcs that we cared for, Bruno, Isabella, Luisa, Dolores, Antonio, Abuela... heck all of them, the entire Madrigal family, had memorable parts in the story and even story arcs despite their limited individual time on screen.
you could not take them out of the movie without taking an important part of the movie with them.
This movie had so much potential to be a Disney Classic, and they seriously wasted it.
Maybe not a classic, but up there with Disney’s better films.
8:58 the incongruity of seeing Disney's Wish with my eyes but hearing the masterpiece of Hyrule castle music in the background gave me vertigo
This comment actually has me cackling 😂😂😂
We could have had villain couple 😭
Would’ve been much more interesting than what we got!
Reporter: tell us Disney what inspired to tell the story of wish?
Disney: my butt found it
Disney: money
The lyric "Here I are" had the Abeka grammar student in me scream in agony
I’m right there with you 😭😂
Especially, since it'd have been so easy to fix: "Here WE are" - sung by all animals or smth.
Duuuuhhhh
Waitt that was real??? I wasnt dreaming??
Wdym abeka grammar?
It's a school curriculum
I love strong female leads, but I also love romance, and Asha with the star boy could have been such an adorable ship 😩
True but desniy is woke now and sadly right now woke people don’t like romance only if she was gay then they would do it
@@changingpeopleslivesmoon2993Define woke
@@changingpeopleslivesmoon2993 There hasn’t been a gay Disney character yet so idk what you’re complaining about.
@@horseluver4ever623 Race-swapping. They're having a Hispanic woman play Snow White.
AND they're making a sixth installment of Pirates of the Caribbean, (WITHOUT Jack Sparrow even though he carried the whole franchise and is the fan favorite) and they used an Irish female historical figure and made her black. It's the Cleopatra thing all over again.
@@fem1n1new3nd1goRachel Zegler got replaced
Were the people who made this movie even HUMAN?? We have redundancies, improper grammar, THE INABILITY TO RHYME, a complete lack of understanding of what EVIL is, a complete misunderstanding of what GOOD is, and shamefully utilized memberberries.
I cried when I heard “My bUtt FOUnd iT”
😂😂😂
Magnifico: I got these genes from outer space!
Nobody:
absolutely nobody:
Me: SPACE PANTS
No seriously what if the direcors watched the Space Pants song and put in that lyric cos they were drunk and thought it was funny?
😂😂😂
The villain song was my biggest disappoimtment, because Chris Pine is so good ar singing, he could pull out a great villain song. Just listen to Agony from Into the Woods
I know! Chris Pine is awesome!
Everyone in this movie is genuinely more than decent at singing, even the ones that don't sing. Ariana Debose and Chris Pine have backgrounds in musicals too. But how good the singer is doesn't matter when what they are singing isn't. The songs really brought down the whole movie.
I 100% agree with you Of what you said, in the video, the potential for this movie was squandered by the writers crew and directive decisions The music Is garbage the characters are flat and boring and for me, I like the animation and art style and feel like that it’s very unique, but wish the animation was in 2D Since the movie was gonna be animated in 2D I just feel bad at this movie was just squandered by Disney and it does not live up to the title of a 100 year celebration for me. It’s my worst movie of 2023 because of the wasted potential and directive decisions behind the scenes justice for Asha X Starboy and the evil king and queen, Disney villain couple
This is a great comment!
Jennifer Lee said she wanted Disney to do a story about a mom...was "Rumplestiltskin" not good enough? And LMM or the Anderson-Lopez team needed to do the music.
The funniest thing is that my younger brother hated Sabino and said he was annoying as well for wasting his wish on inspiring others by playing guitar. His words: “What a stupid wish. If I was the king I would’ve crushed it in front of the girl.” LOL (Shoutout to your brother tho)
Anyways… watch out subscribe button, here I are. Great Video. sOLaR! (ok I’ll stop bye)
That’s hilarious! 😂😂😂
OMG THE GOAT TALKS WITH A DEEP VOICE OMG DATS SO RANDOM AND FUNNY!!!!!!!!!11111one
Hellfire. Now there is an epic villain song. Disney has fallen a long way down.
It's just a little bit of a whiplash because encanto was so good. And I'm pretty sure a decent front of that production was during the pandemic too which was probably a bit challenging.
They try to reference Snow White, but only six of the seven dwarves? I'm confused. Why did they cut one out?
Magnifico was the hero, Asha the villain. Change my mind.
You never really spent time on the story; unless I misunderstood the basic plot, you "give" your wish to not-Doctor-Strange, you won't remember what it was...in the hope that *maybe* he'll grant the wish you don't remember??? In the words of Aristotle, "whaaaaaaaaa?"
Fun Fact: Netflix made a movie that combined 2d and 3d art style and it actually looked really good, the thing was that Netflix made 2d look 3d and Disney *tried* making 3d look like 2d
what movie are you talking about? THey've commissioned some very good animated featuers
@@joestrike8537 "Klaus"
@@maciekw.7923 Oh yes, that was super-impressive - not just its design style/animation, but the story was wonderful. What did you think of "Over the Moon"?
@@joestrike8537 haven't watched it yet
7:22 "TO have something more for us than this" doesn't invite multiple line deliveries because it is absolutely INANE and devoid of meaning. It's the crystallization of everything wrong and generic and confusing about this movie. I do not blame Ariana DeBose for a moment. (Besides, it's entirely likely that she DID give it different line deliveries, and simply that the producers/music team are responsible the ones that made it into the final film.)
Oh for sure, this is definitely a directing/producing issue.
@@isaacmurdock yes! and writing, bc that lyric is just maybe the emptiest in Disney history
When It comes to music, I honestly love the "Welcome to Rosas" song.
"The thanks" would have been nice for the goat, or one of A's boring friends
I’m a Star sounds like they’re trying to use Ebonics but they’re not good at it.
Wish was basically a bad Once Upon a Time episode
I'm sorry, I agree with 'star as a magical shapeshifting boy' as much as the next person but you cannot look me in the eyes and tell me he isn't a blond Danny Phantom. You just can't.
Oh myyyyy! Why did you have to say that I can’t unsee it!
Encanto was the last good Disney movie after moana. Moana is quite a few years old now. Disney now sucks arse
9:38 That’s Deadpool 3
The animation looks along the lines of Sofia the First and other Disney Jr tv shows that somehow had better nuanced storytelling, in-depth character backgrounds, and actual character development. 😂
I love how the critics are acting like disappointed parents and I’m honestly all for it 😅
The Disney references to older properties really shine through in this movie! They even reference the lack of good comedy from Home on the Range with that “deep voice little man” joke that they revised for the goat!
I’ve been saying that star is a discount Luma and I think you’re the first RUclipsr to make that connection that I’ve seen.
688 subscriber, Don’t forget when you get to the top broski.
Aww thanks I won’t forget you @letsbereal9850
We couldve had star boy and villian couple. Disney robbed us
Lmao the song lyrics😹
They definitely aren’t… the best. 😅
the first time i heard the songs from the movie on the internet, i really thought it was a voice over for the memes
Star boy kinda looks like Bill from Gravity Falls (human version)
I love the voice actor that voiced the protagonist, I love her role in West Side Story, but jeez, this time around she got involved in a horrible thing. And underperformed, it's sad honestly.
Ariana Debose is very talented, she definitely deserves better material than this.
4:37 I know with The Flash and The MCU and stuff we've already seen enough sci-fi multiverse stuff but I have an idea. What if it was a multiverse story where maybe there would be a villain and every single Disney princess would come together to stop him anyone like my idea?
Disney sabatoged this movie 100%.
Matpat 2.0 new sub!:D
Awww that means a lot! 🥲
@@isaacmurdockalso good editing🎉
I've wondered since they first announced this movie and its title/premise if it was their attempt to overtake the new puss in boot's success
Are they afraid of romance or something?
5:25
I really didn’t think that an album could be more repetitive than weezer green until I actually listened. 💀
Imagine if disneys net movie trailer starts with the words: "wish was made by drunk people now heres the actual story of disneys universe"
8:25 Trying something doesn't give you the right of doing it right.
How does bro ONLY HABE 596 SUBS? SO UNDERRATED
Awww that is so nice 🥲
If there was any Disney movie that I could agree needed a remake, it would be this one. Seriously. Remake it. With Star Boy.
I will say my five year old regularly quotes “ my butt found it” and it was the only true lol the movie got from her 😂
Ahahahahaha 😂
El Maleficio He's Definitely Has Some of Dr.Facilier Jafar and Judge Frollo in him
The most incredible thing about this movie honestly is that fucking RALPH BREAKS THE INTERNET got a BEST ANIMATED FILM NOMINATION… *RAPLH BREAKS THE INTERNET*…and this didn’t even get a passing mention. Their naked lame cash grab effortless sequel was more successful than their 100 year legacy celebration… Bob Igor needs to get fired already.
I agree the king is the best part of the movie.
Why Ahas friends are so boring.
Hello Issac congrats for beating us in subs well deserved ❤ -cousin Ellie
After i watched this i literally convinced all my friends to go watch this because i didnt want to suffer alone.
You're evil. 😈
I think Disney realy missed out on the idea of blending 2D and 3D as we could have gotten a movie like spirit stallion of the Cimarron which marred both 3D and 2D so well that its hard to notice the difference if you don't work in animation or didn’t know it beforehand so it looks like it was all done in 2D animation and i would have loved to see something like that in wish.
2:55 yeah totally that's a LUMA.
I have no complaints about this movie. After watching and rewatching it, I personally find it a fairly good movie with a great storyline, fun characters, and catchy songs. Plus they did a great job contributing to 100 Years of Disney Magic
Wish had so much potential. I saw it in theaters and when it was done I just thought "That was mediocre." I liked the hand painted feel of the background but the animation of the characters didn't fit in as well as it could have. The plotline wasstupid and I don't think the ending payed off as well as it could have. I do however, love peppy and upbeat villain songs, but an unnerving slow-paced villain song that wasn't motivated by self-absorbedness (or genes from outerspace) would have really made Wish feel like an 100 year celebration. I'm sad Disney scrapped the villain couple and star-boy plotline.
"Wish" happened to be the biggest Disney movie since "Frozen II" in Japan and topped the box office in Argentina and Uruguay.
It also did well in countries as diverse as France, Spain, United Kingdom, South Korea, Australia and Brazil.
How can you say then that "it failed on every level"?
It is clear that only North Americans have a problem with accepting this movie, but the world is much bigger than just the US and Canada.
I see you with the Zelda music
😉
Wish is like if you get all the traits thats in all Disney movies with about 88% less budget.
I actually rewrote some of the songs lol, I rewrote “this wish” “at all cost” and “this is the thanks I get.”
When I rewrote “this wish” I accidentally called it “I wish” because I forgot the title had “this” in it lol.
Here’s my version of “this wish.”
*Context:*
In my version of this story, Asha got adopted by king Magnifico and queen Amaya. She starts singing about how upset she is because she misses her real parents and no one will tell her what happened to them and why they left her, (they left her because her real mum passed away, and that made her dad get depressed so he decided to put Asha up for adoption because he couldn’t take care of her anymore.
I didn't think that life could be even more confusing than this, I thought growing up was going to be fun but I guess I thought wrong.. I thought that we would always be with each other, together forever..but you just drifted away from me like the wind.
I wish that I could see you again, I wish that I could understand everything that's been happening so far instead of wishing on a star, begging for something brand new.
I've always looked up at the stars so they can guide me, but all they do is shine and haven't given me a sign to work with..Nobody has ever answered my questions that I desperately needed to know. I've had many dreams but whenever I try to achieve them they all turn to dust..Could this mean that my life has no meaning at all? Is this the universes way of telling me to give up on my dreams? I always ask the stars to tell me why i'm here and to tell me what will come next, but I get no response..
Maybe the next day will be fun, maybe the next day i'll feel happy, maybe the next day i'll feel like I matter. If anyone or anything could give me a sign then maybe everything will be just fine for me!!! ...
I wish someone could give me a sign to tell me if I should trust them. I wish to believe that I matter.. I wish that life wasn't so confusing and difficult.. All I want is some hope but I can't find any at all. If nothing ever works out for me, then why should I pretend to be happy? Why should I keep trying to chase my dreams? Why should I stay here when all I do is suffer?!
How can I find my future when I have all of these obstacles in my way everyday?
All they do is try to bring me down and sometimes it feels impossible to get back up..
I wish..I wish..I wish~ I WISH!!!~~ I wish to have a normal life! I wish to feel happy and feel like I matter!!~
I've always looked up at the stars so they can guide me..But all they do is shine and haven't given me a sign to work with..How can I feel happy when it feels like no one listens or cares? How can I feel happy when nothing ever works out anymore..
I wish..
I wish..
I WISH!!!~~
I wish that I could see my family again.
All I can say don't assign Jennifer Lee as head writer again.
5:37 The grammar in this line infuriates me!
2:49 😂😂😂😂😂
I had to agree with you
I think everyone should boycott Disney movies in theatres. They all go onto Disney+ a month or two later anyway, and that's a hell of a lot cheaper than a movie ticket.
I think realy king magnifico become evil because she wish for it.
First off, wonderful analysis! Yes, perhaps Wish has gotten its fair share of criticism already, but I still think there's something to be said for good-faith critique of it, particularly considering that it seems like a studio that's made animated musical film projects, both in short cartoons and feature films, for 100 years really should've been able to produce something better. It really is a perfect example of something being more than the sum of its parts -- there were good things in this movie, but they couldn't come together in a good, cohesive whole and they often were overshadowed by elements that fell short.
One thing I would like to just touch on, though, about the song At All Costs...the theory that it was about the Star Boy and Asha singing it as a love duet is sadly just fan conjecture. Nothing in the Wish art book or the released deleted scenes ever really insinuate that any incarnation of Star was going to be Asha's love interest -- at one point Star was even supposed to take a physical form that resembled a younger version of her grandfather (deceased in that version of the story). And really, looking at the last ten years of Disney projects, it isn't unlikely Disney had envisioned a more platonic relationship between those versions of the characters a la Nick and Judy in Zootopia or Moana and Maui in Moana. The real backstory that can be pieced together about At All Costs is sadly almost MORE depressing -- as is discussed in a Variety article, Julia Michaels really wanted to write a love song, but since Wish didn't feature any romance in its story, she wrote the song deliberately as something that could be taken seamlessly out of the film's context and played at people's weddings or used as a lullaby for one's kids. The songwriter was *literally* writing a song for a film musical that had nothing to do with the film's story, themes, or characters so that it could be repackaged as something completely different. This was how little the songs in this film were written to help tell the story -- one was explicitly written in such a way that it had no real connection to anything going on in the movie.
Probably was best for me not to go watch Wish in theatre at all from the review I've been seeing at any videos review of Disney's Wish
Whenever i see bad episodes or movies, i always think, "man they should redo this."
Then i remember that its a production of film and that costs a lot of mone.y
I think the single side affect of poorly fitting lyrics timing wise is that you end up with some really cool syncopation, but there’s kinda too much of it, and the nonsensical lyrics are funny and entertaining, but just because they’re so odd
King Magnifico is really the best character in this movie 🙂👍❤️
As for the villain, CARE BEARS DID IT!
Apologies for leaving so many separate comments, but I noticed that “this wish” especially alternates between 3/4 timing and 4/4 (or 6/4). Wish is set in the 1200s, and it 100% fits that; fluid time signatures and the selected instruments seem very specifically chosen and well though out.
I enjoy your comments, thank you! 😊
This is so off topic but I appreciate the Hyrule Castle theme in the background lol
I feel bad for the art style, because it's honestly not bad. But my expectations were also TOO high JUST because I know of a series that did something similar and all they did was add what looks like lines like the 3D was hand drawn.
Look for *Final Fantasy Tactics: war of the lions cutscenes"
THAT is what I thought of when they said a mix of 2D and 3D. They could have made a more vibrant version of that.
And maybe improve on in some more because FFT is A DACADE OLD.
Yeah you’re right! It isn’t the worst thing ever, I just think we’ve been spoiled with things like spider verse and puss and boots.
@@isaacmurdock Even if they don't do the line sketches in Final Fantasy Tactics. The way they make it seem like the coloring had different brush strokes to show that "frames" was a GREAT touch.
Although Disney NEVER did that it still gives this nice "2D" touch to it.
Did you see Wish? What did you think about it?
It's not that bad they tried their best and it wasn't the animators fault its the executives fault they forced them to scrap all the concepts that made this film amazing
I’m planning on watching it to do a review about it on my other channel
@@julianestebanarroyave9509Totally agree! The animators are not to blame, they have a ton of talent. It’s just unfortunate that the movie wasn’t better.
@@theprofessorteacher955You should, I’d love to see it!
I watched it in theaters with my 4 year old niece. While she loved it, I found it pretty boring and lackluster. I was disappointed to find myself not able to remember ANY of the songs only 20 minutes after seeing it. I felt there were so many things they could have shown and not told us.
This is a song that I am singiiiing...
And I hope it's hope this song is bringiiing...
To your heart
So you feel like you are winniiing ~
The songs be something like that, yeah? (Note: Haven't seen it).
Here. I. Are.
I actually loved the show. Its sorta authentic......since it had alot of disney puns like peter pan building a plane. And the main character isnt a princess or any way related to royalty unlike most disney shows. Thanks I get .... was my fav soundtrack in the show too on that we on the same page. I support your critism though.
I’m glad you liked the movie! Your opinion is valid! :)
I haven't watched the movie yet, so I can't say much about it, but I listened to the soundtrack. Lemme tell you, it takes a lot for me to truly dislike something. I loved The Marvels despite what everybody else says. I can ironically enjoy the likes of The Room or The Twilight Saga. I supported the Prequels even when people clowned on it, even when I admit to its glaring flaws. But that fucking soundtrack just fills me with such disappointment and resentment that it made me spiral to an obsession over it because I just can't comprehend how it can exist. Oh, I still listen to it, but not because of a sense of "so bad, it's good". No, I just listen to it because I'm a masochist apparently and those excuses for songs fill me with so much pain.
I know. This movie is so bad and it makes me wince as it had potential to be great but it’s… meh….
As for King Magnifico, I feel sorry for that character. I compare him to Prince Hans in a sense that you can tell that the writers were forcing them to be villains because the story needed villains and it had to be “the light skin evil man”.
King Magnifico could have been great if he had been straight up bad from the beginning or!!!
Or!!! Been a twist hero. Had they gone the twist hero it would have been both amazing and a breath of fresh air as it’s something Disney had never done before and overall it would have made the story better as the movie portrays King Magnifico as a good reasonable guy with flaws, the whole turning evil came as a “what the f?” Kind of move that just did not work.
As for Asha, I did not like her. I blame the writers. It is clear they live in a bubble and have not seen the outside world.
Have they been outside!? Also they sell this to the USA mostly and if you do not know the USA is having a crisis, we are having the highest rates of homelessness in years, people are living paycheck to paycheck and struggling to put food on the table.
Combine this and the movie it really makes Asha look like a spoiled brat who is throwing a temper tantrum because she did not get what she wants.
The movie is just really tone deaf. Like read the room! Go outside and experience the real world!