Palestinian-Israeli Knesset Member describes Israel’s targeting of Palestinian citizens of Israel
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- “It was, and still is, tough days for Palestinian citizens of Israel."
Palestinian-Israeli Knesset Member Ahmad Tibi describes the oppression experienced by Palestinian citizens of Israel at the hands of the Israeli police as being "hunted down" over social media posts “empathising with the children of Gaza” or “saying no to the war”.
In contrast, he highlighted the lack of accountability faced by Jewish citizens of Israel who have engaged in different forms of hate-speech towards Palestinians including calls to “kill all Arabs”, “destroy all of Gaza” and “use nuclear weapons”.
Subscribe to our channel: ow.ly/AVlW30n1OWH
Subscribe to MEE Telegram channel to stay up to date: t.me/MiddleEas...
Middle East Eye Website: middleeasteye.net
Follow us on TikTok: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Instagram: / middleeasteye
Like us on Facebook: / middleeasteye
Follow us on Twitter: / middleeasteye
He is correct. Those extreme right hand leaders in the government, must be prosecuted as well. The ICC still has a huge job ahead.
Not only the leaders but whole Israeli Jews
@@lvi25 true jews support palestine in protests
Recall that it wasn't the right "hand" leaders that ethnically cleansed Palestinians back in 1948, but rather the "leftist" Labor Party.
@@Pale_Kingg they exist in miniscule sadly
@@lvi25
Absolutely correct. IT is appalling!!!
In describing the Genocide in Gaza, President Lula De Silva of Brazil said this: "This is a war of a well trained and armed army against women and children."
they'll find some reason to.dismiss his statement..
what genocide???
@@Just_Car_Spotting where is Palestine? GHETTO WARRIOR
@@Just_Car_Spotting the one in gaza (they've said 'no gazan is innocent', meaning all r potential targets for being 'palestinian', aka not jewish or euro settlers), but keep defending its 'cowardice', since as a presumable foreign settler u don't 'identify' with palestinians, neither in language or backgrounds, thus seek to 'invalidate' them..
@allcatall3931
There is no Law of war that says Palestine van start a war and keep crying when they start to lose that war
Every living person counts: men, women, children! Children need their mothers, fathers, grandparents, community members, etc.
ABSOLUTELY, 100%.
We’ve always known of this evilness only lately it has become more blatant for all to witness !
And then they call themselves a democracy...What a joke 🤣
Can you show us another democracy in the area? You have some nerve.
@@ianhunter6418 it's your double standards that is disgraceful. Leave my nerves alone. Other countries do not claim to be democracies when they aren't. They know themselves or what they are. It's Israel that doesn't.
Go back to sleep now. @@ianhunter6418
True Jews stand with you Sir. No one is above another.
You decide on that?
@@rajarsi6438go away h@teful bjp bot.
@@rajarsi6438 Don't need to, The Covenant of God did.
❤
A Jew is a Jew, they play both sides I don't trust them
Tensions are very high
You think?
Brave gentlemen for speaking out. Hopefully he does not get harassed by the Israelis or even his so called colleagues in the Israeli government.
This gentleman has no Israeli collègues..And is an undesirable occupant for Zioniste Colonists…Chalom Chalom…
The colonialist apartheid state fighting with women and children.
Dont you know God is always and everywhere Almighty in the material world? Ah, that's why you're babbling like a small child.
An apartheid state that lets a palestinen be in the israeli parlement and also letting him say his dumb bullshit aginst israel without putting him in jail?
Check the definition of an apartheid dummy
they are so proud is the scary part.
the chicken will come home to roost soon ☝️
nasty skeletons hiding in the colonial west's closet.. they're 'cute' about it,
Hypocrisy at its peak & evil is enjoying impunity after all the war crimes in the name of self-defense
Great comment - 100% true 👍
The dead children don’t affect me like they used to.
The images. The videos. They still disturb and horrify, but not like they did in the beginning. Not anywhere close.
And, honestly, I hate it. I hate that that part of me has been stolen.
As much as I hated having my heart kicked around all day and having nightmares all night, I’d rather have that than this decreased sensitivity.
People should not become desensitized to such horrors. People should not become accustomed to decapitated babies and small, mangled bodies. To corpses run over by tanks. To body parts carried in plastic bags by loved ones.
These things should jar you. They should rattle you to your core. But they don’t anymore. Not here.
I held onto it for as long as I could. It felt like a solemn duty, to hold on to that part of me that still screamed with an appropriate mixture of grief and outrage at the latest tiny shredded body. But desensitization sets in whether you want it to or not. That’s how they create soldiers, after all.
I hate that these pricks have amputated that part of me, and I hate that I know it will never grow back. I have been permanently disfigured inside, mutated by atrocities, all the way down here safe in the Melbourne suburbs.
And I hate that this is happening all around the world to everyone else who’s kept their gaze fixed on Gaza. All around the world humanity is being mutated. All around the world something sacred is being stolen from the hearts of good people. All around the world people are finding callouses where there used to be tenderness.
And I want my tenderness back, god damn it. I want my tenderness back.
Give me back the nightmares. Give me back the tears. Give me back the dry retching over the toilet, and the shaking under the blankets. Give me back the collapsing onto the couch and not moving for several hours until my system can recover from what my eyes just saw.
I’ll take it. I’ll take it all back again. Just give me back that soft, tender part of myself that has been withered to dust by a live-streamed genocide.
I will take good care of it. I will feed it good things. I’ll give it plenty of sunshine, cupping it delicately in my hands by the window. I will take it for walks, and let it rejoice at the children running and playing, with their parts all together and their insides on the inside.
Don’t leave me hardened and darkened like a soldier. Give me back that soft, sacred part of myself that weeps at the corpses of children, so I can behold the world gently again.
Wow that was deep and very honest. And sadly true
If we want out children and grandchildren to not see, feel, or experience what we see today, we must stop wars.
Such a great expression of what it means to be a decent human being
Every paragraph starts with I or me. You need to get beyond that honestly.
The same, but I haven't stopped with the sickness in my mouth, and not being able to get on with the day until I've caught up with Israel latest actions, however hard they may be. But the headache & earache don't let much In. I have to bring some light into my life. AND I FEEL SO GUILTY BEING BROUGHT DOWN BY NEWS REPORTS OF THIS HORROR. It's not as I'm Palestinian. 💔💔💔💔🤮🤮🤮
The truth sir. Please keep speaking up for 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Still, he is a knesset member.
So he is one of the pillars of apartheid.
What a moronic comment you made!
The fact that this Palestinian gentleman is a member if the Knesset shows that in Israel Palestinians can be in parliament. And it shows your ignorance. You're a bit to keen to blame...@@mdabdullah4379
@@mdabdullah4379 To know the enemy, you must be the enemy to defeat them
You mean Israel is not a democracy???
...
🙄
Freedom and justice for Palestinians 🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Ridiculous
Free free free Palestine from Israel,
whats a palestine?
@@Just_Car_Spotting it what is being genocided
@@roystonmason9125 no its not
@@Just_Car_Spotting what is then ? smartass
Ahmad Tibi has a terrible reputation among many "moderate" Israelis. I went to hear him once, to see the devil in the flesh (Round Room, Truman Institute, Hebrew U). An informal talk with the small group that showed up. I was really impressed, I thought people missed a great opportunity (it was moved from a larger room) and since then I've always hoped to hear him again. MK Dr Ahmad, it was worth coming that day!
As a Jew,do you think your word would be believed more than that of a Palestinian?
If so, please use it to speak out against this genocide
@@harimauindia5775
As a Jew, I think Palestinians are silenced or self-censored in many ways, not only on Gaza, not only by Israel. Eg "What will the neighbors say?" or PA/Hamas govt.
Re Gaza, to accuse one side is not to acquit the other. No way.
My own views are no secret. But Jewish opposition can also be dismissed. Self-hating Jew, terror supporter, leftist, Arab lover, elite...
@@danielreiss-cy4zr even so, being a Jew in a Jewish supremacist state means you have a privilege that was given to you by injustice. Don't discard it,but rather use it to obtain justice
@@harimauindia5775
I'm white and male, too.
Can we talk about Muslim Indians?
Sad reality.
Not only the colonists, but their supporters. Germany stated if they found any refugee liked a post that supports Palestine, they may risk deportation..
Germany was always the slave of "those people".
Good. No one needs Islamic Fascists in their country.
Netanyahu was born in Poland he even changed his name to live in Israel so are many of the European zoinest doing
So you mean Arabs in EU must be deported ?
נתניהו נולד בישראל בשנת 1948 אחרי קום מדינת ישראל.
אבא של בנימין נתניהו נולד בוורשה ולא בפולין ועבר לישראל בשנת 1920.
כלומר משפחת נתניהו כבר יותר מ 100 שנה בארץ ישראל.
@@user-to2eu5tt4gas per our saying" living in stolen land doesn't mean he belongs there" people living there from many decade are the real one
@@user-to2eu5tt4g Warsaw is a city in Poland and in 1920 it was called British Palestine not Israel .
@@mohdkausar2136
אז לפי זה האמריקאים צריכים לעזוב את ארצות הברית.
האוסטרליים את אוסטרליה, וגם העמים שחיים באירופה חצי מהם פלשו לאירופה בימי הביניים.
ואם הולכים עוד אחורה, אז בכלל מגיעים לזה שהיהודים צריכים להיות בישראל.
אז כמה אחורה צריך להסתכל?
100 שנה אבל לא 1000?
אולי צריך להסתכל 2000 שנה?
אגב,
אני אישית ממשפחה שחיה בירושלים יותר ממאתיים שנה.
גם אני צריך לחזור לאירופה?
Free Palestine 🇵🇸🇱🇧✌️🇾🇪🇿🇦✌️
Yup, Israel's IDF is working on it. Now go back to sleep.
@@frwansie Please keep up your callous comments denigrating Palestinians. You reveal the hatred and contempt at the heart of Zionism and bring more people to the Palestinian cause. Thank you! Freedom for Palestine!
Palestine will be free from Hamas soon
Only Israel allows like that.
arrest satanyahoo - i mean Benzion Mileikowsky who is from poland
🇵🇸FREE FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
Just like Apartheid South Africa.
Much worse in fact.
Don't forget the Apartheid in eg Pakistan, Egypt, Iran, Morocco and Turkey.
@@rajarsi6438where
@@rajarsi6438You mean india Right
@@rajarsi6438 they forgot the worst one 💀
(Hint: it's right beside morocco)
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Free 🌍, free Jews+israel 🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
It is all Palestine from the river to the sea🇵🇸
what river and what sea???
@@Just_Car_Spotting brown river to yellow sea
@@roystonmason9125 incorrect
The 7th October would never have happened if the European zoinest had 😂in Britain where they came from 😳 what is the European zoinest doing in the middle east 😳 from South Africa
60% Israeli are from muslem arab countries
😢😢😢INNOCENT PEOPLE KIDS WOMEN OLD-AGE EVERY ONE MURDER IN PALASTINE 😢😢😢 PLEASE HELP MY INNOCENT PEOPLE 🙏
were the people raped murdered and abducted on 7 October not innocent you fool?
But we allow Israel to do this with impunity; why? Are we so afraid of the US?
Apartheid
Ils y a que l'Unité des peuples contre l'injustice et l'hypocrisie de ceux qui nous gouvernent.
🇵🇰❌🇵🇰❌🇵🇰❌🇵🇰❌
Pray for Innocent Balochistan Family😔..
Pakistan🇵🇰stop kidnapped and killed innocent Muslim Balochistan Brother Sister😔 all innocennt Family😔..
May Allah protect innocent Balochistan Famiily😔
Does it not remind us of the Gestapo ?
Hamas is much worse.
Horrifying... and Israel is supposed to be a civilized place.
It was never civilized.
The situation of Arabs in Israel today reminds me of that of Jews in the USSR in 1953. Of course the details are different, but there's that atmosphere of imminent danger.
Then why don't they go? 😂
@@Борис-ш3т4ф Why should they? Who are you to tell them to leave?
@@danielreiss-cy4zrBecause in Israel they enjoy all the rights and freedoms they do not have anywhere else.
Und die Erde ist eine Scheibe und dreht sich zugleich um die Sonne...Israel ist eine Herrenvolkdemokratie, wie alle Rassisten dieser Welt sie lieben.... @@Борис-ш3т4ф
@@Борис-ш3т4ф Was I talking about "anywhere else"? Nor are you right about "anywhere else".
'Democratic' state... my foot
Unfortunately in this world there will be conflicts. There are problems between Muslim countries and Jewish communities, especially in Israel and the US. But hate and discrimination aren't part of any religion or culture. They often come from historical and political issues.
Jewish people have faced persecution, and Palestinians have faced displacement and human rights issues. Ideally we should understand and respect each other, and work towards peace and justice for all.
“Let's build bridges, not walls!"
I have to disagree. Hate and discrimination are very much a part of Islam. I saw an Imam on YT just recently: “They can convert or be taxed as the dhimmie they are. We have given them two good options! Only if they reject both will we take further action.” Depraved and medieval.
Israel dnt have any remorse just hatred
May Allah keep you safe
Allah couldn't even protect the Palestinians. Can you guarantee that he will protect him?
The only democracy in the Middle East? 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Free Palestine!!!
🇵🇸🕊
he is there as an outsider and used as a show... bro wish intelligence do they want to fool ? 😉
#FreePalestine
Looks like no democracy in zio land 🤣🤣☝️
How many democracy exist in arab countries
@@awal541 Better than Israel and the West at least. The guy is a Knesset member and yet his opinions are cancelled by the Knesset. Very democratic. And also, no Arab country claimed that they are democratic. Israel is saying it all over the place. Don't claim democracy when you don't have it lol.
@JohnMartin-pjasca
Install democracy in the arab world first before blaming/criticizing Israel 🇮🇱 .
Israel is a beacon of light in a pool of barbarism in the Middle East.
What have you done to Save the Womens Childeren and Old Mans in Gaza and Westbank?
save gaza
Great democracy!
Stop the war
Bull
Did this Knesset Member call out Egypt🇪🇬 for TRAPPING vulnerable babies, children, mothers of small children, pregnant women, the sick and elderly in a WAR ZONE? President Sisi and the Egyptian people rejected the setting up a "secured" humanitarian camp just inside Sinai where innocent people could be safety cared for. It's despicable...🤮
isn't this same guy who pride himself being palestinian in israel only a few months ago? saying so many good things about israel? things must have changed quickly. duh!
When the freedom of speech went away, yeah, I’d say things changed.
@@lookbovine i was more pointing out his hypocrisy. he was praising how good palestinian had it in israel. to your point about freedom of speech, i would argue he never had it. he's a politician and these instincts kicked in. he thought he was protected if he played nice.
@@lookbovine freedom of speech is allowed if you are saying what they want you to say... ;)
Never stop talking about Palestine .....Israels too evil ......Free free Palestine❤❤❤
The Suzerain of Sheol can have Nazrael in its entirety. Humanity cares not for its excuses and justifications.
yeah we all know that. Nothing new. Then what? Almost 9 months still tallking endlessly about this
Then you should do something to stop this madness
Please realise that his allegations are absurd: an army chasing after citizens that write 'naughty words'... absurd or worse: malicious slander.
Arabs in Israel were always free to move to Gaza and they didn't and made a wise choice. Why move to a place that so strongly opposes freedom? Would you?
IDF told civilians to leave targeted areas of Gaza. If Hamas forces them to become shields at gunpoint is their death Israel's fault or Hamas'?
All lie what this man talking, Muslim like to twist the setuation. By the way, what you doing in Israel knaset ? You are to be blamed for Israel setuation.
As much as act of Hamas , as they say it 's act of terror , IDF been doing more horror things against Palestinian Civilians .
Apartide state that has a palestinian in their parlament lol😂
Yes, and persecuted thought crimes. Not funny.
@@lookbovine not for thought, for expression,there is no country in the world that wold allow someone to threaten its own citizens...
You're not an honest actor, you're a two-bit propagandist.
@@therearenostringsforme The United States of America. I live there. Thought crimes are not illegal here.
@@therearenostringsforme How dare you lock up people and torture them for speaking out about killing their relatives.
And the Israeli government have the cheek to say that the IDF is the most moral army in the world.😂😂app
Child and woman and what sbout the man arent they humans
F IZRAEL
What did he expect? When you became a Israelis citizen did you think you would be listened to?
Divided Palestinians didn’t achieve anything. You did what the Israeli govt were wanting and now they have destroyed Gaza they now will come for the Palestinians living in the West Bank and the other area's.
Wel you don’t expect to be tortured for your opinions, do you? That’s Soviet type stuff, not democracy type stuff.
Stop Hamas and palestinian people would be safe.
Other than that, no way out.
I don't even hear what he trying to say, can he tell me how many Hamas fighters killed??
Walker Cynthia Hall Sarah Johnson Sharon
Yet they say they are the most moral army in the world and that the Palestine people are the ones who don’t want t the Jews I think it the opposite I think the Jews made them like that other wise they would be leaving fine in pease together
Harmful situation in gaza
40k dead. 2 million without shelter. Harmful is an understatement.
Bro 7th Oct will be costly. The ball is on your court...😅
Please remember israel 🇮🇱 i the only terriest democracy in the middle east lol 😅😅.
This isn't right. Separately, how many Jews or Christians are Political leaders or officials in any Muslim country.
Are you genuinely stupid? You have Coptic ministers in Egypt. The President of Lebanon is a Christian. You have Assyrians in Iraq as ministers, you have a Jewish lobby in Morocco, the ambassador and foreign minister of PLO in Palestine is a Syriac Christian, they hold power under Bashaar Al Asaad in Syria, they thrived under King Hussein of Jordan, and so on. You are just trying to deflect and sugar coat because you are a liar.
Ok,why hamas still keeping the hostages?
Если боль других твоей не стала , прожита напрасно жизнь твоя
Where are the Jewish members of Parliament of Arab/Muslim countries acting as a 5th column?
They exist in Morocco FYI, and this is one of the reasons Israel is helping Morocco against Spain. Plus, your Jewish virtual library says that Arab states didn't expel the Jews, the Jews sold their possessions and left for Israel due to the Zionist agencies. Know your own history before you talk.
Free free Palestine from river to sea
Ouvrir les frontières aux mondes
Theres no such Place as PALESTINE SAINAI BELONGS TO EGYPT
WEST BANK BELONGS TO JORDAN THEYRE EGYPTIAN ARABS AND JORDANIAN ARABS
WATCH VIDEOS OF ISRAELI ARABS WHEN ASKED WHERE THEY WANT TO LIVE TO LIVE
SEE VIDEOS OF THE SON OF HAMAS
EDUCATE YOURSELVES STOP BEING LIED TO
he speaks the truth.
But did anyone notice that this Indian guy is a knesset member??
😂😂😂 he's an Arab Palestinian
1 he's not Indian, he's Palestinian
2 if the Palestinians citizens of Israel don't join the Knesset,they won't have a voice,and what little ability they have to change Israel will be gone
You forgot who started this war haven’t you!! Quit trying to blame others..
1948 rings a bell!?
Let there be peace in the middle east
Ahmed Tibi, member of the Knesset of the apartheid state.. Something is not right here. There is apartheid or there is not.
Apartheid comes in many different flavours. As an example, the apartheid state of Rhodesia required a quota of its parliamentarians to be black, while simultaneously disenfranchising blacks with high taxes and segregated neighbourhoods.
You are a hypocrite
They try to convince you that palestinian in Israël havé thé same right
Quote me a LAW in which Israel #discriminates on the basis of race? I can only find one and it *benefits* the Arab Israelis. They don't have to undergo mandatory military service.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Of course israel would never attack without usa agreeing
Wrong. There was a Western embargo during the 1967 war.
This guy is sitting in the Isrseli parlament and bashes Israel at every opportunity. I want to see a Jew in any Arab country's parlament critisizing the policy of its country and speaking favorably about Israel.
Did u see why he bashed them? They burned down houses with the families still inside them before oct 7. If Isreali Parliment had any common sense & listened to him instead of just ego… oct 7 wouldn’t have happened.
You have that in Morocco, and you have a Jewish lobby in Morocco lol. And You even have Muslim Arab ministers that talk in favor of Israel like in UAE and Saudi. I question the existence of your brain. Also, he is an Israeli citizen. He wants Israel to thrive, but he believes that war isn't the solution. He wants a one state solution where Arabs and Jews share equal rights. He is against two-state solution as well. His stance is against what a lot of Arabs want. Know what you are saying before you speak lol.
😂😂😂😂😂😂 tibi a liar
Womp womp
🇵🇸
There is no such thing as Israel as a country bro
The Arabs fight with demons and spirits
but it is not an apartheid start, the only democracy in the mid east, the villa in the jungle, yer right!
Ethnostate. If you were one ethnicity and had a certain opinion you went to jail…an ethnostate.
If I trust the devil, I will trust the West.
Everyone is strangled in kicking each other butt's.
Uk is shifting sides.
No body had the gots to point fingers at UK.
if youre not calling for palestinians to be evacuated after their socety ending atrocity you arent pro palestinian. Youre just pro islamist.
You are in the Kneset saying whatever you want, we are too much of a democracy
He is kicked out lol and he can't say whatever he wants. Israelis are talking about kicking out the Arabs INSIDE OF ISRAEL and not the Palestinians.
@@JohnMartin-pjasca in Gaza you don't have even 1 jew... We have 2 milion!!!!
They aren't safe from Allah's promise
And what is Allah's promise??
@@danielavila5081 "كتب الله لأغلبن أنا و رسلي إن الله قوي عزيز"
This is taken from Qur'an.
Means that Allah has written he would be the victorious and his prophets.
@@danielavila5081 بأن لا يفسيدوا في الارض
Is he describing Germany 33-45?
Just fucking talking
This is weird coz he refers to Palestinians as citizens of Israel. Never. Get it right luv.
He was talking about the nearly 2 million Palestinians who have Israeli citizenship and live within what is considered "Israel proper".
Tactic...
Amine yarab 💔