Good video. Thanks Dr Das. It is always difficult to discern between the apt liars and the true mentally ill, however, they try but are soon caught out ..
I really love your hugely informative channel all the way down in little NZ🇳🇿.Hiphip hooray to 15k🥳I look forward to seeing your channel climb.Personally id like to see more true crime videos if possible. Truly fascinating stuff!!
I'd love to hear some wholesome stories about patients you've treated, who have gone on to live fulfilling and productive lives, if you have any at all. Does severe mental illness and personality disorders always stop people from living "normal" lives and becoming successful in their career of choice?
Thank you for answering my question, I've said it before but what a fascinating job you have. Even if I was smart enough to work in the field of psychiatry, I don't think I'd be mentally strong enough to do it.
I used to be addicted to self harm. I finally got a service dog in 2007 and she trained me out of it. Wish people would take psych service dogs more seriously and so many people hadn't abused the label. They are better at dealing with suicidal/self harm than any therapist I've had. (sorry doc) Dogs don't have judgement or say stupid things that even psych pros do. I literally live for my dogs and they are why I've survived. This is a serious solution that psych professionals won't look at enough which is sad because they actually are really annoying and prejudice and make it all worse when people are in crisis. Hospitals are expensive time wasting crap that don't teach people to deal with it. It's demeaning and not healthy because if people need help being locked in an institution with other people freaking out is not good... police being involved is even worse because of what they represent. I've had terrible things said and done to me in hospitals and it was more damaging. I still have urges but the idea of calling for help is off the table. My dog knows how to respond. We lock the world out and wait out the bad crap. It's a good solution but for now I have to accept social stigma and miss being able to do a lot of things because of ignorance about it and again...those fakers with "emotional support animals" really upped the stigma. (that never should have been allowed...if the dog has no task and if you don't need it 24/7 it's a pet. Leave it at home)
High profile are really interesting but then again every profile case is fascinating! I loved working with psychiatric patients and have been assulted by a couple too! However i have the love and dedication xx
I'm definitely a fan of the true crime cases but I don't mind when you speak on celebrity cases either. I'd love to hear your opinion on Charles Bronson and whether you think he should be released or not.
Just found you channel today while following the Depp/Heard trial and I’m hooked. I haven’t heard you talk about it but if you if you have watched a good portion of the trial I would be curious to know what you see, as a professional, in Amber’s behavior. Personally It’s all pretty difficult to watch but I would just be interested to see what someone who works with people sees. Thanks for doing what you do! I will be subscribing and will continue to watch your videos :)
Can you psychoanalize people that commit murder like the person who committed the Tylenol Murders that occurred in Chicago in the 80s? It's never been solved. I just can't wrap my mind around this type of crime. Do you have an psychoanalysis on Jack the Ripper?
Beneath all those grandiose narcissist jokes you are actually a caring, and dare I say funny 🙈😂professional. Thank you for being so honest with some difficult questions. Pleasantly surprised. Not had great experiences with psychiatry due to a very late in life adhd diagnosis (which I had to fight for many times)& possibly high functioning asd. Worked with some dangerous teenagers & loved it for many years. The key was easy 🔑 Speak to them with respect, firm but fair consistent boundaries, and never take it personally. No doubt some required doctors of your calibre & sadly wouldn’t have happened until adult crimes were committed. I am assuming that adhd was not taught when you were starting out in this career? If so, have you seen a change in recent years? Is there a difference between England and Scottish psychiatry training where Adhd is concerned?
Thanks so much for your honesty doc and I really look forward to reading your book. I sent you my address by private message on discord as well as the case I'd like to see you discuss. I think what you said about being a doctor is completely true. The pay has gone down by 30% for consultants and 24% for JDs and it's still going down. I love psychiatry - I worked in a CAMHS PICU for a year before med school and tbh I was ready to decline my offer as I found out the truth about UK medicine right now. But turns out I really enjoyed psychiatry and I want to pursue a career as a psychiatrist. However I'm definitely going to considering training in Australia over the UK with all the current problems and especially because nowadays we have 100k worth of debt :/ My parents actually encouraged me not to do medicine but I was adamant because idk I just enjoy the subject so much. Maybe I hate myself or maybe it's just a calling. At the very least I know I have plenty of experience to back it up. However I am also involved with DoctorsVote and we are trying to improve things through the BMA. We recently made a new ballot for strike action over pay official BMA policy for Junior Doctors! We are trying to improve things for everyone though and having a consultant like you help us would be great. If you'd like to help us improve things for doctors, restore pay and keep attracting the best talent into medicine, then please join us! Even just tweeting our infographics and your support would go really far! Not enough consultants do so, and brush off the current issues as if they don't matter when they do. Your help would be invaluable.
Congrats, my man. I will send you a copy off my book imminently Can you forward me by email what you would like me to post - psychforsoreminds@gmail.com cheers
Violent offenders would be more interesting than public figures. I do have a question, is the medication supposed to cure them or just make them more docile and easier to handle? The person who doesn't feel they have a problem will never be cured by any therapist.
Have to ask you about a case I’ve just seen? A couple have been charged with 2nd degree murder. Their grown up daughter who was autistic had died sometime ago & her body was in an advanced state of decomposition. They had sat in the front room with body for a considerable time? Salacious inventory of state of the body which appears to be normal decomposition? Surly this is a psychiatric matter? To not register or be able to deal with the death of a loved one is surly a severe mental health problem? Just wanted to know if you’ve come across this before, feel sure it must be a recognised illness??
I'd like to hear true stories about patients and thier disorders/crimes. Thier symptoms, behaviours and the reasons/ thought processes behind them. Thanks 🙂 I've just thought, interviews with people with particular disorders in order to educate, destigmatize and give a voice to sufferers. A bit like Chris from SBSK does. It's a channel on RUclips and he has people on with a vast array of mental and physical disorders ) I really like his approach. I'd be interested to hear what you think of him .
Your the bomb of fun that we need - information, silly ness & connection. Care to you & family for today. Kate from Australia Ps - if you were an Australian animal, you would be a Chuditch 😀
Never liked Frasier. I found the characters too much of a caricature and the jokes a bit too forced/obvious. I saw it years ago, way before I decided to become a psychiatrist.
Hi Das why do people with learning disabilities and autism get locked up for years Specifically in Scotland and what would be the reason why people with learning disabilities and autism get locked up for years. Can you please make a video on this.
Am appreciating your professionalism and detail of your replies. My question is: Would castration of rapists "cure" them or enrage them? And is it ethical as a treatment?
Haha I knew there was a repressed rapper in there! Nice rhymes :-) While I'm here I have a question. So, someone has an aquired brain injury caused by a satsuma sized tumour and is suffering from uncontrollable anger, rage and impulsive acts of violence caused by the tumour. Is this a basis for a 'diminished responsibilty' plea if they were a naughty boy or girl? Asking for a friend.....
hey. Almost any kind of mental disorder is potentially the basis for DR. It's about whether or not the specific legal criteria are met (as opposed to the type of disorder) x
@@APsychForSoreMinds ok cheers for the answer. Will try to keep my homicidal, er I mean my friend's homicidal urges to a minimum . Never sure if I'm classed as having a mental illness or a disability when it's brain tumour related. As a criminology/psychology student and someone who's always been incredibly interested in abnormal behaviour I'm loving your channel. Dr Grande eat your heart out!! Dr Das is in the house!!! x
I'm sorry, but as a doctor it is inappropriate to dress how you like on your own channel, as a doctor; speaking on your work. You are privy to sensitive information, and should act respectfully in public because of it. If you'd like a career in comedy, Harry Hill managed it. Sorry, but it's a matter of respect.
"Bullwark." Nice! You never hear that said anymore. Made my day. And the comment about your "guns" was just irritating. You're not in an office, in some professional building or institution, assessing patients or testifying. Why the need to dress "professional" on your own YT channel? It just seems trivial and judgemental. Hoping to hear my own question answered in the future. BTW, I like how you usually have a toy or something within your screenshot that reminds us that you are a father. It humanizes you, and it's a nice juxtaposition with your expertise in forensic psychiatry. Not just a doc, ya dig? 😂 Safety and good health to you and yours, Ominous Sohaminous. (Did I spell that right?)
I like the true crime cases, especially uk cases, thanks
Good video. Thanks Dr Das. It is always difficult to discern between the apt liars and the true mentally ill, however, they try but are soon caught out ..
I love the true crime videos that you do! I much prefer them but I enjoy all your videos. A
Mixture of different topics is great!
I must admit, I find myself exponentially drawn to your channel with the more content you post 👌🥰
I'm waiting for my copy of your book through Amazon in the US. They have August 9th of this year as the release date, however. I'm filled with rage.
Yo, Sohom xxx
15k nice one son.
Just brought your book! Should arrive by 10pm, im looking forward to reading it! 🎉
many thanks. Please leave a review on Amazon x
@@APsychForSoreMinds I absolutely will when I’ve finished it! X
Mr Black has nothing but good things to say about you . So here I am a new subscriber.
I really love your hugely informative channel all the way down in little NZ🇳🇿.Hiphip hooray to 15k🥳I look forward to seeing your channel climb.Personally id like to see more true crime videos if possible. Truly fascinating stuff!!
I'd love to hear some wholesome stories about patients you've treated, who have gone on to live fulfilling and productive lives, if you have any at all. Does severe mental illness and personality disorders always stop people from living "normal" lives and becoming successful in their career of choice?
I’d love to know more about the current therapies used in secure psychiatric units.
I Do have a video somewhere on my channel about therapy given to violent offenders.
"Shit Loads" is the clinical term, right? 😂😂 As a nurse, I've used it a time or two.
Thank you for answering my question, I've said it before but what a fascinating job you have. Even if I was smart enough to work in the field of psychiatry, I don't think I'd be mentally strong enough to do it.
Me neither!✊👍
I used to be addicted to self harm. I finally got a service dog in 2007 and she trained me out of it. Wish people would take psych service dogs more seriously and so many people hadn't abused the label. They are better at dealing with suicidal/self harm than any therapist I've had. (sorry doc) Dogs don't have judgement or say stupid things that even psych pros do. I literally live for my dogs and they are why I've survived. This is a serious solution that psych professionals won't look at enough which is sad because they actually are really annoying and prejudice and make it all worse when people are in crisis. Hospitals are expensive time wasting crap that don't teach people to deal with it. It's demeaning and not healthy because if people need help being locked in an institution with other people freaking out is not good... police being involved is even worse because of what they represent. I've had terrible things said and done to me in hospitals and it was more damaging. I still have urges but the idea of calling for help is off the table. My dog knows how to respond. We lock the world out and wait out the bad crap. It's a good solution but for now I have to accept social stigma and miss being able to do a lot of things because of ignorance about it and again...those fakers with "emotional support animals" really upped the stigma. (that never should have been allowed...if the dog has no task and if you don't need it 24/7 it's a pet. Leave it at home)
High profile are really interesting but then again every profile case is fascinating! I loved working with psychiatric patients and have been assulted by a couple too! However i have the love and dedication xx
Now you have 18k! Well deserved!! Hope for nothing but more growth!
He's brilliant 👏
I'm definitely a fan of the true crime cases but I don't mind when you speak on celebrity cases either. I'd love to hear your opinion on Charles Bronson and whether you think he should be released or not.
Just found you channel today while following the Depp/Heard trial and I’m hooked. I haven’t heard you talk about it but if you if you have watched a good portion of the trial I would be curious to know what you see, as a professional, in Amber’s behavior. Personally It’s all pretty difficult to watch but I would just be interested to see what someone who works with people sees. Thanks for doing what you do! I will be subscribing and will continue to watch your videos :)
It is really nice to see your channel grow, your videos provide a lot of info and I hope you continue to grow and flourish. 😁
Much obliged, Katie
Your channel, your guns 💪 get em told! 😅 Get em out - taps aff!
ha!
@@APsychForSoreMinds fight, flight, freeze, FAWN, please 🙏 will buy your book…
Thanks for the video. Could you do one on how we lay people could/should set boundaries?
I’m a fairly recent subscriber…I came from your video with Dr Mike! I enjoy your channel and really enjoyed this Q and A!
what video with Dr Mike?
@@APsychForSoreMinds he means your video with your mate dr grande ;)
Dr Das you truly found your vocation, I love true crime and weirdo’s, but not in a creepy way just fascinated,
Congrats on 15k and I hope your channel continues to grow ❤
Can you psychoanalize people that commit murder like the person who committed the Tylenol Murders that occurred in Chicago in the 80s? It's never been solved. I just can't wrap my mind around this type of crime. Do you have an psychoanalysis on Jack the Ripper?
Loved the AMA, loved the short story too!!
The only story I want the end of is from your stand up….did you and your wife chill on Sunday?!? 😂😂
No. I fell asleep on the sofa x
@@APsychForSoreMinds 😂 classic, premature snoozing, would’ve helped for sure!!
Beneath all those grandiose narcissist jokes you are actually a caring, and dare I say funny 🙈😂professional. Thank you for being so honest with some difficult questions. Pleasantly surprised. Not had great experiences with psychiatry due to a very late in life adhd diagnosis (which I had to fight for many times)& possibly high functioning asd. Worked with some dangerous teenagers & loved it for many years. The key was easy 🔑 Speak to them with respect, firm but fair consistent boundaries, and never take it personally. No doubt some required doctors of your calibre & sadly wouldn’t have happened until adult crimes were committed. I am assuming that adhd was not taught when you were starting out in this career? If so, have you seen a change in recent years? Is there a difference between England and Scottish psychiatry training where Adhd is concerned?
Thank you for your work❤
Thanks so much for your honesty doc and I really look forward to reading your book. I sent you my address by private message on discord as well as the case I'd like to see you discuss.
I think what you said about being a doctor is completely true. The pay has gone down by 30% for consultants and 24% for JDs and it's still going down. I love psychiatry - I worked in a CAMHS PICU for a year before med school and tbh I was ready to decline my offer as I found out the truth about UK medicine right now. But turns out I really enjoyed psychiatry and I want to pursue a career as a psychiatrist. However I'm definitely going to considering training in Australia over the UK with all the current problems and especially because nowadays we have 100k worth of debt :/
My parents actually encouraged me not to do medicine but I was adamant because idk I just enjoy the subject so much. Maybe I hate myself or maybe it's just a calling. At the very least I know I have plenty of experience to back it up.
However I am also involved with DoctorsVote and we are trying to improve things through the BMA. We recently made a new ballot for strike action over pay official BMA policy for Junior Doctors! We are trying to improve things for everyone though and having a consultant like you help us would be great. If you'd like to help us improve things for doctors, restore pay and keep attracting the best talent into medicine, then please join us! Even just tweeting our infographics and your support would go really far!
Not enough consultants do so, and brush off the current issues as if they don't matter when they do. Your help would be invaluable.
Congrats, my man. I will send you a copy off my book imminently
Can you forward me by email what you would like me to post - psychforsoreminds@gmail.com
cheers
Is there anything you don't do?!! Congrats on 15k ❤️
well, i'm A pretty terrible cook. And I suck at poker
@@APsychForSoreMinds me too 😂 poker bores me so I just 'all in' after a while 😊
Violent offenders would be more interesting than public figures. I do have a question, is the medication supposed to cure them or just make them more docile and easier to handle? The person who doesn't feel they have a problem will never be cured by any therapist.
Did you get to really like a patient who had done terrible things?
Have to ask you about a case I’ve just seen?
A couple have been charged with 2nd degree murder.
Their grown up daughter who was autistic had died sometime ago & her body was in an advanced state of decomposition.
They had sat in the front room with body for a considerable time?
Salacious inventory of state of the body which appears to be normal decomposition?
Surly this is a psychiatric matter?
To not register or be able to deal with the death of a loved one is surly a severe mental health problem?
Just wanted to know if you’ve come across this before, feel sure it must be a recognised illness??
This US matter is bizarre to say the least. There must be much more than what has been televised as there is much which makes no sense.
Love your show ❤
I'm getting your book btw,I'll let you know if it's any good 🤣
cool. thanks
I'd like to hear true stories about patients and thier disorders/crimes. Thier symptoms, behaviours and the reasons/ thought processes behind them. Thanks 🙂
I've just thought, interviews with people with particular disorders in order to educate, destigmatize and give a voice to sufferers. A bit like Chris from SBSK does. It's a channel on RUclips and he has people on with a vast array of mental and physical disorders ) I really like his approach. I'd be interested to hear what you think of him .
Your the bomb of fun that we need - information, silly ness & connection. Care to you & family for today. Kate from Australia
Ps - if you were an Australian animal, you would be a Chuditch 😀
I have no idea what a chuditch is, but I'm gonna take it as a compliment x
@@APsychForSoreMinds look it up - Fluffy-spotty-carnivorous-marsupial with nice faces 🤔 It is a compliment lol 😂
Do you like the comedy show Frasier? Or do you like any portrayals of psychiatrists in fiction?
Never liked Frasier. I found the characters too much of a caricature and the jokes a bit too forced/obvious. I saw it years ago, way before I decided to become a psychiatrist.
@@APsychForSoreMinds I’m in complete agreement with you doc,
Hi Das why do people with learning disabilities and autism get locked up for years Specifically in Scotland and what would be the reason why people with learning disabilities and autism get locked up for years. Can you please make a video on this.
Only been punched twice 🤣😂🤣
Luv u xxx
Am appreciating your professionalism and detail of your replies. My question is: Would castration of rapists "cure" them or enrage them? And is it ethical as a treatment?
Yo. I've actually done a whole video about chemical castration x
Tell us about the grooming gangs in the UK. Asking for a curious world. Ta and tara
Haha I knew there was a repressed rapper in there! Nice rhymes :-) While I'm here I have a question. So, someone has an aquired brain injury caused by a satsuma sized tumour and is suffering from uncontrollable anger, rage and impulsive acts of violence caused by the tumour. Is this a basis for a 'diminished responsibilty' plea if they were a naughty boy or girl? Asking for a friend.....
hey. Almost any kind of mental disorder is potentially the basis for DR. It's about whether or not the specific legal criteria are met (as opposed to the type of disorder) x
@@APsychForSoreMinds ok cheers for the answer. Will try to keep my homicidal, er I mean my friend's homicidal urges to a minimum . Never sure if I'm classed as having a mental illness or a disability when it's brain tumour related. As a criminology/psychology student and someone who's always been incredibly interested in abnormal behaviour I'm loving your channel. Dr Grande eat your heart out!! Dr Das is in the house!!! x
Do you like 'exponentially' better than 'dastardly'?
Sir... Your thumbnail pic makes you look like an evil mastermind from a James Bond film.
And who said that I wasn't? x
But you'll have to admit he's better looking than Klaus Schwab.
@@Isisbridge he's too handsome to watch sometimes. I be like.... He's married... He's married.... Move along. ..
@@APsychForSoreMinds I. Knew it.
You're 43?! I thought you were in your early thirties lol. You need to let us know your skincare routine asap!
i rub tramp sweat into my cheeks every morning x
@@APsychForSoreMinds Noted. 😃
You do not look like you are in your 40s I thought you were in your late 20s or early 30s
I'm sorry, but as a doctor it is inappropriate to dress how you like on your own channel, as a doctor; speaking on your work. You are privy to sensitive information, and should act respectfully in public because of it. If you'd like a career in comedy, Harry Hill managed it. Sorry, but it's a matter of respect.
"Bullwark." Nice! You never hear that said anymore. Made my day. And the comment about your "guns" was just irritating. You're not in an office, in some professional building or institution, assessing patients or testifying. Why the need to dress "professional" on your own YT channel? It just seems trivial and judgemental. Hoping to hear my own question answered in the future. BTW, I like how you usually have a toy or something within your screenshot that reminds us that you are a father. It humanizes you, and it's a nice juxtaposition with your expertise in forensic psychiatry. Not just a doc, ya dig? 😂 Safety and good health to you and yours, Ominous Sohaminous. (Did I spell that right?)
close enough x