@@emmanuelj670 I think it's on act 4, if you talk to Isabeau then keep quiet, they'll tell Siffrin a joke, and they'll tell a time loop joke on the third time you do it
Loop being disappointed when you said it doesn't matter, the person they were, the person they're holding onto, all of that not mattering, being unrecognisable to the party- Really sums it all up 😭
In my first playthrough I ended up figuring out loops identity the second I saw that you could guess that loop was you. I was wrong on the specifics though. I thought for some reason siffrin had cloned themselves somehow and Loop was the clone. I also thought that Siffrin themself was a clone of the king for some reason and that was why siffrin had no memories 💀💀boy was I wrong on that one I was waiting the whole damn game hoping I was right
i guessed it as soon as i saw the option too! i also thought that Loop was the clone, and after reading the book I felt vindicated and thought Siffrin subconsciously cloned himself at the start... woops..
I was originally thinking that loop was part of Sif like how [Slay the Princess spoilers below.] Different people but all one entity. [Each Princess is part of the Shifting Mound.]
Spoilers, duh. Both fortunately and unfortunately, I knew that Loop was Siffrin very, very early in. In the first loop in fact. I managed to catch that Loop said “Don’t make the same mistakes I did.” for a second during the zoning out tutorial. I briefly entertained Loop being the person responsible for the island’s disappearance somehow for a bit, but ultimately stuck with them being Siffrin. It got even more obvious when I saw the dagger dialogue.
my first playthrough i picked “doesn’t matter” because i didn’t know and i didn’t want to be wrong and get laughed at. i felt really bad and as it turns out they only would have laughed at me if i was correct
Interesting how loops reaction to being found out is the same as Siffrins to the time travel joke. Completely breaking down and laughing, almost manic, at the absolute absurdity of it all.
I clicked "ghost" the first time (I was pretty sure the answer was "Me" but I saw Jello's highlight reel and wanted to see different dialogue), and boy did it hurt!
when i first saw the jello stream for the game i had almost immediantly got their identity correct, but i had also thought the king was a clone, and at this point ive completely forgot the specifics of my theory
im kinda sad i spoiled myself after my first playthrough about loop. when i first got the prompt i said the "correct", and the option made me go "huh, that would explain everything" and assumed it was the case as loop was... well, he didnt deny it. plus one of the books in siff's language. i really should finish my second run through to see his event.
I just finished the game... Man, the "Me" answer should have been a giveaway to the ending, I saw Jello do it. But where is the part where Loop dies laughing and loops back?
![Boothill's Tragic Life Story [Honkai Star Rail Lore]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/LqFy8ySN5q8/mqdefault.jpg)
Loop's reaction to "me" is the same as Siffrin's reaction to Isabeau's timeloop joke: uncontrollable laughing
Isabeau made a time loop joke? Where?
@@emmanuelj670
I think it's on act 4, if you talk to Isabeau then keep quiet, they'll tell Siffrin a joke, and they'll tell a time loop joke on the third time you do it
They don’t deny the correct answer
Funny how if you guess correct, it is the only one you are not wrong, but since you normally can't guess again, you would not know that
Technically there's 2 correct answers
Yeah; I watched the Jelloapacalypse play through. I didn’t know that all other options had them saying you’re wrong
Loop being disappointed when you said it doesn't matter, the person they were, the person they're holding onto, all of that not mattering, being unrecognisable to the party- Really sums it all up 😭
How could I say that in my first playthrough.
I'm a monster.
THE GHOST DIALOGUE NOOOOOOOO
oh OW I hadn't seen the "ghost" dialogue before
I Guess you have to do something to make It happen.
Since my options were
The change God
Part of the Universe
Me
@@rich_gamer0667 I think its triggered after seeing at least one siff ghost in the house
@@ChronoMoth oh,makes sense.
I talled with Loop on every loop because i didn't want to esclude him
So i did that conversation very soon
In my first playthrough I ended up figuring out loops identity the second I saw that you could guess that loop was you. I was wrong on the specifics though. I thought for some reason siffrin had cloned themselves somehow and Loop was the clone. I also thought that Siffrin themself was a clone of the king for some reason and that was why siffrin had no memories 💀💀boy was I wrong on that one I was waiting the whole damn game hoping I was right
i guessed it as soon as i saw the option too! i also thought that Loop was the clone, and after reading the book I felt vindicated and thought Siffrin subconsciously cloned himself at the start... woops..
I was originally thinking that loop was part of Sif like how [Slay the Princess spoilers below.] Different people but all one entity.
[Each Princess is part of the Shifting Mound.]
tbf the "clone" bit is still thematically correct, more so a metaphor for the actual situation so the player doesnt clue in too fast
I thought it was a time paradox sorta situation where Sif becomes Loop at the end. I mean, I really wasn’t wrong lmao
God "Ghost" and "Doesnt Matter" sting
in my run, I guessed "me" and spent most of the rest of the run chewing over their reaction, haha
i guessed “me” but because loop laughed at me i was like “oh okay guess not” like the clueless fool i am
Spoilers, duh.
Both fortunately and unfortunately, I knew that Loop was Siffrin very, very early in. In the first loop in fact. I managed to catch that Loop said “Don’t make the same mistakes I did.” for a second during the zoning out tutorial. I briefly entertained Loop being the person responsible for the island’s disappearance somehow for a bit, but ultimately stuck with them being Siffrin. It got even more obvious when I saw the dagger dialogue.
I answered “one of my allies” thinking it was just a way to say they were an ally of mine, wished I could answer again so bad lol
1:16 AHHHHHHH AHHHH [truck crashes into milk factory] AAAAAHHH AUUUURRGGGGHHHH [debris spills everywhere] AAAAUUUUGGHH AAAAHHGG [tornado siren] MY LEG! MY LEG!
2:51 was the bonnie/sif grudge still unresolved in their timeline... fuck...
3:27 my other leg is gone
i guessed the Head Housemaiden on my first playthrough 💀
Ivory Wizard spotted
Love your videos
@@masiethespiral I'm so glad you enjoy my content!!!
@@ivorywizard of course, it's great content, hope you have a wonderful day
Me too.
It's alright I guessed the tree
my first playthrough i picked “doesn’t matter” because i didn’t know and i didn’t want to be wrong and get laughed at. i felt really bad and as it turns out they only would have laughed at me if i was correct
Interesting how loops reaction to being found out is the same as Siffrins to the time travel joke.
Completely breaking down and laughing, almost manic, at the absolute absurdity of it all.
I’m sad. I guessed “I don’t know…” in my playthrough ‘cause I was so focused on figuring out the cause of the loops. Damn. These are good.
I clicked "ghost" the first time (I was pretty sure the answer was "Me" but I saw Jello's highlight reel and wanted to see different dialogue), and boy did it hurt!
when i first saw the jello stream for the game i had almost immediantly got their identity correct, but i had also thought the king was a clone, and at this point ive completely forgot the specifics of my theory
Huh, they don’t deny it when you say they’re you. Interesting. I was curious about the other reactions.
im kinda sad i spoiled myself after my first playthrough about loop. when i first got the prompt i said the "correct", and the option made me go "huh, that would explain everything" and assumed it was the case as loop was... well, he didnt deny it. plus one of the books in siff's language. i really should finish my second run through to see his event.
foreshadowing is a narrative device
Hah.
Same eyes.
I just finished the game... Man, the "Me" answer should have been a giveaway to the ending, I saw Jello do it. But where is the part where Loop dies laughing and loops back?
I believe Jello edited that in there in the highlight reel; it doesn't happen in the game itself
@@Patch-lz9yi yeeah okay I watched his full playthrough and noticed that’s such a good edit 😆