The fact that you can see his hands shaking a bit as he reads that speech tells you Jonathan knew just how much hate and backlash he'd get for saying what he did. I respect this man's courage so much.
@@shesh_o And most of them are just some washed up random people, thankfully. I hope Jonathan is getting support from his peers in the industry and most of all his loved ones. I can't imagine how difficult it must be right now for him being villified by people from the Jewish community and getting threats.
Also Marlon Brando's protest move at the 1973 Oscars, where he was up for his Godfather performance, and had refused to go in person and instead had Sasheen Littlefeather go in his place to bring attention to the treatment of Native Americans in film & TV, and the ongoing struggle at Wounded Knee.
Right side of history is an illusion. Don't get me wrong I agree with you but you need to know we don't know if history will find actions you find right to be right. We need to push on even if we can be wrong for a better world not a vague promise of being proven right someday
@@CorneliusHerelle yeah, you right there are absolute right and absolute wrongs. But laws are still just takes on what is right and what is wrong. And my earlier comment was just pointing out that there is no "right side of history".
They know he talks some huge sh*t. Really, as a neutral person basically but with history and politic knowledge, me (and people like me in general) are strongly disagree.
Yes@@francescaeldridgeit all just goes to demonstrate that it was courageous. Not only were his hands shaking, but his posture, ... It was like he was kind of trying to shrink
@@GreenTimYoung Umm read up history. Being turned out of your home. It's colonisation all over again, but then again, it isn't until ages afterwards that we get all the ohhh I'm sorry we shouldn't have done that, colonised and such. It happened to native Americans, it's happening now and it'll happen again in a century or so. Humanity doesn't want to change or have the nerve to admit when it wrong during the event not after it's over. If u just read up on decades ago, of the millions of Palestinians who now live in Jordan and the middle east as there descendants where turned out of the homes. The coffee was still hot when the settlers came in after kicking out Palestinians from the homes. Stop reading Israeli propaganda and start actually looking for whats going on.
@@GreenTimYoung Free from the Israeli occupation for the last 75 years, free from the famine, war, death and racism Israel has imposed onto them. How bout that?
Can’t believe there’s so much backlash in response to a person taking a stand for the humane conscience, & saying what millions of people are feeling right now- that the loss of so many innocent lives has been beyond extreme & absolutely unconscionable.
Actually, he didn't keep it safe at all. What he's proposing is a change within ourselves that most people will struggle to accomplish. I find many people dehumanise Benjamin Netanyahu and the Israelis enacting and enabling the slaughter of thousands. We must not. It's imperative, above all, to acknowledge the humanity in all, even the "worst" of us.
@UndecidedCryptidI think you missed the part where he said "hijacked" just like some groups hijack Islam, just like some groups hijack Christianity (KKK) all these "hijacks" don't represent any of the groups they claim to belong to
@UndecidedCryptidno he didn’t. He said he refuted the his identity being used to justify the occupation. He did the exact opposite by showing not all Jews support political Zionism.
@UndecidedCryptid opps somebody offended cause he hit the nail on the head. Tell me have you been speaking aloud against the isreali goverment? Or like the theme of the movie you just go along n pretend it aint happening . Watch the movie
His hands were shaking. He knew they would defame him and tarnish his name. Yet he still spoke out against the genocidal war waged by the Israeli state.
Maybe Gazza shouldn’t have committed ethnic genocide inside of Israel. If they hadn’t done that and weren’t still holding hostages, maybe people wouldn’t be dying right now. I never knew people could be so innocent and pure until you see how supporters of Palestine talk about the decrepit state. Before the incident, how many Jews resided in Gaza? That’s right none. How many Muslims resided in Israel? 20%. Israel completely pulled out of Gaza in 2007. There was no occupation. Strange how the rest of the Arab world wants nothing to do with Palestine either. They’re quite vocal and decrying the violence, but none of them want to take in refugees not even Jordan. Surely has nothing to do with the radicalization of Gaza and the West Bank. They’re too anti-Semitic for the rest of the Middle East… that’s crazy
"I don't remember one occupation in which the occupier presented himself as the victim, we are the victims, we are forced to kill their children, poor us.” ~ Israeli journalist Gideon Levy
@@talia3363 she also said "I am Palestinian" the conflict won't end until bb loves the hostages as much as he hates Palestinians. The worst thing that could happen to him is if they all come back because he'd have nothing left. That's why he keeps rejecting all the deals, because they'll automatically lose their victimhood card
@@talia3363 Because.... they ll be scared to have their kids murdered by us. poor us. This is not how freedom is obtained. Also, Golda used to live in a stolen house from an Arab family, i wouldnt pay too much attention to a thief.
What? That’s a really huge leap to predicting the future. Did you know that always/never type of thinking is a cognitive distortion? You have no idea how this will affect his future. It may open doors that would’ve never been created, if he hadn’t spoken out. Be so careful about attempts to broadly control the future, it’s a sign of an unwillingness to let life be as it is. Predicting a terrible, fatalist, outcome, is a way to “be prepared” for the worst, it’s often a trauma thinking pattern. Many people have had a short backlash and went on to incredible things later. The Dixie Chicks were one such example. They were “canceled”, received threats, parties with their cd’s being destroyed and on and on…and they’re back, stronger than ever! We absolutely should speak up, no matter the imagined cost. Integrity is important and the right projects will likely come his way.
If he wants to go after “occupiers” and “oppressors”, he can start with a 1,500 year old warlord that did nothing but that. Reason I bring it up you may ask??…because Palestinians ( who are majority Muslim ) venerate and revere that warlord more than any other human to ever exist. Ironic, isn’t it.
I’m not a fan of Islam, but this is whataboutism at the expense of innocent people’s lives. Also, don’t forget that Moses’ god commanded the Israelites to commit genocide and the god of Jesus supposedly threatens us all with a fate infinitely worse than death. Islam does not have a monopoly on venerated warlords.
to give some context even though everyone might know. the actress in tears is german superstar sandra hueller. she never wanted to play a nazi in her career. before taking on the leading role in the zone of interest glazer himself said in an interview that he talked for month with hueller about the movie. she took her time to decide and finally agreed. glazer said that it got to the point where he was sure that only her could do it and that without her he might not have done the movie. you might say this is about the speech and not her but its worth noting that they all are aware about the impact of the movie and might share thoughts about current situations too since they talked for extended times about glazers intentions too
Nice of him to acknowledge the civilians one both sides of this conflict. A terrorist group and a far right wing political party are both not going to care about innocent casualties. If you pick sides and ignore the deaths of innocents on either side of a conflict, you are no better than the people committing those crimes.
@@thermophile1695 It's incredibly disingenuous to speak of the occupation of Palestine as "both sides" when one side can count lives lost in the tens of thousands and the other in the hundreds; when one side is fighting for the dignity of growing their crops, building their homes and to not risk torture or death crossing their own land - while the other side fights to deny them all these human dignities. It's absurd to speak of "adults" needing to step in when all the supposed guardians of democracy and human rights block even the mere symbolic call for ceasefire in the UN, and legislate to ban the protest or other democratic means of dissent such as boycotts in the face of the intentional starvation of children, women, elderly, the sick and oppressed.
@@thunder.perfectmind If the advantage flipped, the massacre would go right on, just in Israel. These people have been in a bloody feud for generations. Acting like only one side is at fault is insane.
One side is fighting against an occupation, against a colonial state that deny them free movement, their land, their water, their food; the other side is fighting to expand that colonial order through settlement and genocide - and has most of the powerful states backing them. You cannot deny that reality by simply conjecturing "what-ifs?", you cannot smooth over the facts on the ground by ahistoric meaningless terms like "bloody feud". There are real causes and a real history behind the violence; you can comfort yourself that this is some "natural state" for the levant, but you'd be denying more than century of European colonialism, invasion, terror and meddling.
It seems that everyone commenting on this clip has bought Hamas' propaganda hook line and sinker. I prefer to think that is the case over the alternative.
"He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you." - Nietzsche
@@aumelb Well apparently I'm prejudiced for simply having an opinion - that is your inferred metric - although it follows that I can just invoke Hitchen's Razor - that you have no evidence that I am prejudiced (I'm not) - so I don't need to have any evidence to accuse you of the same. You're an antisemite.
Making blanket statements about "terrorism" does nothing to minimize the reality of what's being done to a staggering number of innocent Palestinians in retaliation. In light of these present atrocities, Glazer's film does indeed remind us how history repeats itself not only in this modern genocide but in the rhetoric and mindset of those who would defend it. In the film, there is a scene in which a German radio broadcast condemns the "massacre" of "innocent" Germans at a school, rallying the German people in their fight against "the other." To the Germans, such an event could easily be used to justify the Nazi's campaign of unspeakable violence (in "self defense," etc). History, however, has made clear how comparably insignificant this "massacre" of German innocents remains in light of what we now understand to be a reprehensible genocide waged for a "cause" that seems so unjustifiable in retrospect. What will we say of Israel when enough time has passed to reflect soberly upon what was done? What museum will house the ephemera of how many tens of thousands of massacred Palestinians, putting their decimation in perspective? Glazer dares to ask these questions now, while our own media still spins an alternate take that attempts to justify the unjustifiable, as we go about the banality of our own lives on the other side of the wall. Bravo to him.
I agree. But this - "History has made clear how comparably insignificant this "massacre" of German innocents remains" - I think this is teetering on the very mindset the film is trying to combat. Why must you deemphasise the killing of these children? In one scene a plume of smoke in Berlin oddly mirrors those we see in shots of Auschwitz. Underneath the smoke a mutilated soldier is thrilled by the marching music from the bandstand - Rudolf and the Nazis, arguably many Germans, were as oblivious to the suffering of "their own people" as to the suffering they enacted. That's why we hear about the school bombing on the radio, their meaningless deaths are transformed into a tool to further fuel the war. We, or "history", must not squash one injustice for comparison's sake. We must not dehumanise, as Glazer says.
You people are ridiculous, people like him use their platforms all the time to promote their own interests. This isn’t the first time yet here you all are praising him like if that has never happened before. Hispanics for Israel!!
What about the hostages israel has, who has more and treats them WAY worse, including holding literal corpses as hostages and not allowing their families to hold funerals or even mourn them, or how they broke both of a kids arms for no reason before finally releasing him.
Truly brave man. Will watch his film, for sure. #1 on my watchlist. He is speaking for both the victims and relatives of the people who died on Oct 7th and for the 30,000 civilians and 10,000 children who have died needlessly in Gaza. The perpetrators of atrocities on both sides have dehumanised the other side. That is his message. No matter how much you hate or oppose the other side, no matter your thirst for vengeance - don’t fall into the trap of dehumanising your opponent completely. Because then you fall into the abyss, you lose your moral ground. You become worse than your enemy. Which is what Israel’s government and military has done by retaliating to the very extreme. They have now become as detestable as Hamas- no better, no worse, and no different. They had an option to show some restraint. But they decided to walk with the devil. Good luck to them with regaining their image in the eyes of those under age 30, for the next 25-50 years now.
Saw the film for a second time last night Glazer truly made an incredible film, that put me in a trance and shook me to my core Sandra and Christian were just incredible, what makes this film so horrifying is how everything is seen as so normal and when you realize what these people are doing is chilling, instead of using graphic imagery he lets our ears hear everything making it more uncomfortable and uneasy, thank you Jonathan for the film and this speech.
This will come to haunt him. My mother's uncle also thought that if he'd just assimilate enough... but it didn't help him. But I think he knows how twisted his speech is, otherwise he wouldn't be trembling like this.
He is trembling because he is afraid of backlash and that it may well (and probably will) end his career. But looks like he puts integrity and moral convictions above own personal comfort.
This isn't about "assimilation", this is about how humans can convince themselves to unleash unspeakable things, such as the massacre of children occurring currently in Gaza
@@Virolaxion If you can fathom it - those statistics are false. Look it up. Hamas have been publishing impossible figures. They are a terrorist organisation - you shouldn't believe them.
Off the bat from creating a totally alienating movie about the Holocaust, being a Jew and standing up for justice like this. Sexy beast, under the skin.
The fact that you can see his hands shaking a bit as he reads that speech tells you Jonathan knew just how much hate and backlash he'd get for saying what he did. I respect this man's courage so much.
Already 450 Jewish personalities in Hollywood have signed a letter condemning his words...
@@shesh_o And most of them are just some washed up random people, thankfully. I hope Jonathan is getting support from his peers in the industry and most of all his loved ones. I can't imagine how difficult it must be right now for him being villified by people from the Jewish community and getting threats.
@@shesh_othat literally anyone can sign
@@shesh_o That "petition" is literally a Google docs form with no requirement of proving you're in the industry. Try again.
Spielberg didn't sign by the way.❤
In 95 years of the Oscars history, first time someone did something worth doing.
Not the first time, watch Vanessa Redgrave’s Oscar speech 1978. both should be saluted.
Also Marlon Brando's protest move at the 1973 Oscars, where he was up for his Godfather performance, and had refused to go in person and instead had Sasheen Littlefeather go in his place to bring attention to the treatment of Native Americans in film & TV, and the ongoing struggle at Wounded Knee.
Not the first time. Joaquin Phoenix talked about animal liberation and human liberation.
Used the Oscar's platform for his political speech? Hmmm... Never happened before, right?
NOT the "FIRST" time. At, all.
To give that speech is a risky move to do. I congratulate him for his bravery before his Oscar award.
If It was on a E-sport premiation he would be banned for a year and lose the prise
(Thing that It is bad, fuck you blizard)
It is all about the military industrial complex $$$ power in the middle east, n. E. Africa, slavic lands🎯
Wow
Of course, not posted in any official channel. Easy way of knowing when you're on the right side of history. Hats off to these men
There is not a thing like a "right side of history", war has existed since always, and some civilization dies, and others rise
Right side of history is an illusion. Don't get me wrong I agree with you but you need to know we don't know if history will find actions you find right to be right. We need to push on even if we can be wrong for a better world not a vague promise of being proven right someday
You mean opposite side. Right and wrong are subjective in this context.
@DirtDev not always subjective. Sometimes there are absolute rights and absolute wrongs. The courts and the law agrees.
@@CorneliusHerelle yeah, you right there are absolute right and absolute wrongs. But laws are still just takes on what is right and what is wrong. And my earlier comment was just pointing out that there is no "right side of history".
Glazer: we should see the humanity in everyone and be mindful of our biases.
The internet: OMG what a raging anti-Semite!
You’d have to have major cognitive dissonance to watch Zone of Interest and conclude that it was anti-semite lol
Which is ridiculous because Jonathan Glazer is Jewish.
Why isn't he posted on the official channel of the academy? Oh wait i know why...
I can’t find the full speech anywhere. This is disgusting. Freedom of speech is a lie.
Cowardice
They know he talks some huge sh*t. Really, as a neutral person basically but with history and politic knowledge, me (and people like me in general) are strongly disagree.
@@monsieurgentil You bow to the Jews, we dont
@@monsieurgentileducate us then?
Finally, a voice.
Bark
@@veronicagutman9378 But you're the only one barking ☹️
@@veronicagutman9378doggy 😂
@@veronicagutman9378Keep barking, Karen.
@veronicagutman9378 what breed are you?
Did anyone see he was actually shaking and was trying to control his hand ….I AM SO PROUD OF HIM! 🎉
Noticed that too! Says a lot about the reaction he expected, I think....
Yes@@francescaeldridgeit all just goes to demonstrate that it was courageous. Not only were his hands shaking, but his posture, ... It was like he was kind of trying to shrink
Respect for Mr. Glazer. Free Palestine
Exactly, free from what?
@@GreenTimYoung Umm read up history. Being turned out of your home. It's colonisation all over again, but then again, it isn't until ages afterwards that we get all the ohhh I'm sorry we shouldn't have done that, colonised and such. It happened to native Americans, it's happening now and it'll happen again in a century or so. Humanity doesn't want to change or have the nerve to admit when it wrong during the event not after it's over. If u just read up on decades ago, of the millions of Palestinians who now live in Jordan and the middle east as there descendants where turned out of the homes. The coffee was still hot when the settlers came in after kicking out Palestinians from the homes. Stop reading Israeli propaganda and start actually looking for whats going on.
So yeah free Palestine from it's colonisers
@@GreenTimYoung Free from the Israeli occupation for the last 75 years, free from the famine, war, death and racism Israel has imposed onto them. How bout that?
@@GreenTimYoungThe occupation. He said it in the speech...?
Can’t believe there’s so much backlash in response to a person taking a stand for the humane conscience, & saying what millions of people are feeling right now- that the loss of so many innocent lives has been beyond extreme & absolutely unconscionable.
Those that are against his stand are on Israel’s payroll.
Takes balls to call them out on their own turf. Good for him.
Their own turf? I missed the part where the Oscars are held in Israel.
@@mud6992 it's like they don't know what they're talking about...
You really this ignorant & not know that Zionist rule and always have Hollywood @@mud6992
@@mud6992
One & the same buddy. How do you think Israel got so damn rich?
Disingenuous
You can see how hard that speech must have been to give, hands shaking, voice crumbling, that took some balls, fair play to Glazer!
You could tell how nervous he was. what a courageous man.
he kept it pretty safe, but still honest. good stuff
making a direct link between the holocaust and israel is not safe at all in hollywood lol
Yes, very tactful. And now the perpetrators and their allies swarm to silence him
Actually, he didn't keep it safe at all. What he's proposing is a change within ourselves that most people will struggle to accomplish. I find many people dehumanise Benjamin Netanyahu and the Israelis enacting and enabling the slaughter of thousands. We must not. It's imperative, above all, to acknowledge the humanity in all, even the "worst" of us.
@@Virolaxiontite
Love how he called out the Zionist occupation. What a great man :)
He did not.
@UndecidedCryptidI think you missed the part where he said "hijacked" just like some groups hijack Islam, just like some groups hijack Christianity (KKK) all these "hijacks" don't represent any of the groups they claim to belong to
@UndecidedCryptidno he didn’t. He said he refuted the his identity being used to justify the occupation. He did the exact opposite by showing not all Jews support political Zionism.
@@matthewgrech7131he did not what?
@UndecidedCryptid opps somebody offended cause he hit the nail on the head. Tell me have you been speaking aloud against the isreali goverment? Or like the theme of the movie you just go along n pretend it aint happening . Watch the movie
Why not a standing ovation? Now we see what you're made of Hollywood
His hands were shaking. He knew they would defame him and tarnish his name. Yet he still spoke out against the genocidal war waged by the Israeli state.
The Zone of Interest was such an astounding film, and absolute respect to Jonathan Glazer for this speech, clearly it took a lot to make it.
The Zone of Interest is in my zone of interest, thank you Jonathan glazar your a true star. ❤
This man has some balls. He knows he is playing with fire.
Those useless actors filing a complaint to the Oscars against him didn't like being called hypocrites to their support of Israel against Gaza.
Maybe Gazza shouldn’t have committed ethnic genocide inside of Israel. If they hadn’t done that and weren’t still holding hostages, maybe people wouldn’t be dying right now. I never knew people could be so innocent and pure until you see how supporters of Palestine talk about the decrepit state. Before the incident, how many Jews resided in Gaza? That’s right none. How many Muslims resided in Israel? 20%. Israel completely pulled out of Gaza in 2007. There was no occupation. Strange how the rest of the Arab world wants nothing to do with Palestine either. They’re quite vocal and decrying the violence, but none of them want to take in refugees not even Jordan. Surely has nothing to do with the radicalization of Gaza and the West Bank. They’re too anti-Semitic for the rest of the Middle East… that’s crazy
Some people don't support rapists and murderers. They are not monsters like you.
"I don't remember one occupation in which the occupier presented himself as the victim, we are the victims, we are forced to kill their children, poor us.” ~ Israeli journalist Gideon Levy
@@talia3363 she also said "I am Palestinian" the conflict won't end until bb loves the hostages as much as he hates Palestinians. The worst thing that could happen to him is if they all come back because he'd have nothing left. That's why he keeps rejecting all the deals, because they'll automatically lose their victimhood card
@@talia3363 Because.... they ll be scared to have their kids murdered by us. poor us.
This is not how freedom is obtained.
Also, Golda used to live in a stolen house from an Arab family, i wouldnt pay too much attention to a thief.
@@talia3363 Yeah that's a completely sane piece of rhetoric.
Yeah, because negotiating and caving to Al-Qaeda's demands following 9/11 is exactly what sane democratic countries do 🤦♂ @@nickmoore7598
@@nickmoore7598They only want their land back, stupid!
God bless Jonathan Glaze
Keep speaking truth. That was amazing.
Thank god they didn’t cut him off
They never would have lived that down. Anyone that could have done that knew there was nothing they could do.
free palestine 🇵🇸 a noble man on the right side of history !!
If the right side of history is terror and islamist extreamism, then yes his on the "right" side.
@@adish7275As opposed to genocide?
@@kotorandcorvid4968 there is no genocide..
@@adish7275 "There is no war in Ba-Sing-Se"
And the man will never get to make a movie again… it’s a shame because he is a true artist
What?
That’s a really huge leap to predicting the future.
Did you know that always/never type of thinking is a cognitive distortion?
You have no idea how this will affect his future.
It may open doors that would’ve never been created, if he hadn’t spoken out.
Be so careful about attempts to broadly control the future, it’s a sign of an unwillingness to let life be as it is. Predicting a terrible, fatalist, outcome, is a way to “be prepared” for the worst, it’s often a trauma thinking pattern.
Many people have had a short backlash and went on to incredible things later.
The Dixie Chicks were one such example. They were “canceled”, received threats, parties with their cd’s being destroyed and on and on…and they’re back, stronger than ever!
We absolutely should speak up, no matter the imagined cost. Integrity is important and the right projects will likely come his way.
He's made all of his films, bar Birth, outside of Hollywood.
If he wants to go after “occupiers” and “oppressors”, he can start with a 1,500 year old warlord that did nothing but that. Reason I bring it up you may ask??…because Palestinians ( who are majority Muslim ) venerate and revere that warlord more than any other human to ever exist. Ironic, isn’t it.
I’m not a fan of Islam, but this is whataboutism at the expense of innocent people’s lives.
Also, don’t forget that Moses’ god commanded the Israelites to commit genocide and the god of Jesus supposedly threatens us all with a fate infinitely worse than death. Islam does not have a monopoly on venerated warlords.
to give some context even though everyone might know. the actress in tears is german superstar sandra hueller.
she never wanted to play a nazi in her career. before taking on the leading role in the zone of interest glazer himself said in an interview that he talked for month with hueller about the movie. she took her time to decide and finally agreed. glazer said that it got to the point where he was sure that only her could do it and that without her he might not have done the movie.
you might say this is about the speech and not her but its worth noting that they all are aware about the impact of the movie and might share thoughts about current situations too since they talked for extended times about glazers intentions too
first time, someone really said something at this show.
Free Palestine from radical Jihadist Islam terrorists
Brave man!
Pathetic
Kapo
@@PhimbleG-d No, hero.
@@maltesetony9030 KAPO
@@PhimbleG-d Deaf, as well as daft.
All Jewish people must condemn this war; it is fought in their name!
How can a people so persecuted before now begins to persecute others!
Thank you for such a masterpiece ❤
Brave man
I hope he won't get blacklisted by Hollywood after this.
What movie is it?
There's no introduction.
Original sound, movie title??
I think this is about a movie called The Zone of Interest or something like that
Brilliant 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
Thank you ❤. Every person that stands ❤. Thank you. We will resist. This is resisting. We will stand and keep standing.
That's some badass speech, big respect. Really nice that he mentioned Aleksandra also
Nice of him to acknowledge the civilians one both sides of this conflict. A terrorist group and a far right wing political party are both not going to care about innocent casualties. If you pick sides and ignore the deaths of innocents on either side of a conflict, you are no better than the people committing those crimes.
Adults need to step in and force an end to this generational conflict on both sides.
@@thermophile1695 It's incredibly disingenuous to speak of the occupation of Palestine as "both sides" when one side can count lives lost in the tens of thousands and the other in the hundreds; when one side is fighting for the dignity of growing their crops, building their homes and to not risk torture or death crossing their own land - while the other side fights to deny them all these human dignities. It's absurd to speak of "adults" needing to step in when all the supposed guardians of democracy and human rights block even the mere symbolic call for ceasefire in the UN, and legislate to ban the protest or other democratic means of dissent such as boycotts in the face of the intentional starvation of children, women, elderly, the sick and oppressed.
@@thunder.perfectmind
If the advantage flipped, the massacre would go right on, just in Israel.
These people have been in a bloody feud for generations. Acting like only one side is at fault is insane.
One side is fighting against an occupation, against a colonial state that deny them free movement, their land, their water, their food; the other side is fighting to expand that colonial order through settlement and genocide - and has most of the powerful states backing them. You cannot deny that reality by simply conjecturing "what-ifs?", you cannot smooth over the facts on the ground by ahistoric meaningless terms like "bloody feud". There are real causes and a real history behind the violence; you can comfort yourself that this is some "natural state" for the levant, but you'd be denying more than century of European colonialism, invasion, terror and meddling.
You know who was left winged? The people hamas killed, but the so called progressives don't give a shit about.
Thank you Mr. Glaser....
It seems that everyone commenting on this clip has bought Hamas' propaganda hook line and sinker. I prefer to think that is the case over the alternative.
When everyone is hamas, no one is.
Israel isn't
@@davinciworksnashville Bibi funded Hamas. Why don't you go talk to him?
"He who fights with monsters might take care lest he thereby become a monster. And if you gaze for long into an abyss, the abyss gazes also into you." - Nietzsche
He is the monster. He has stared at Nazis too long and now pitties them... seems few of you saw his film.
Maybe look in the mirror first. You are unable to see your own hypocrisy and prejudice and calling someone else a monster.
@@aumelb and how is your mirror image doing if you apply your own logic? Sounds like you might be a hypocrite by your own metric.
@@PhimbleG-d and which "metric" that would be?
@@aumelb Well apparently I'm prejudiced for simply having an opinion - that is your inferred metric - although it follows that I can just invoke Hitchen's Razor - that you have no evidence that I am prejudiced (I'm not) - so I don't need to have any evidence to accuse you of the same. You're an antisemite.
God Allah bless you and open before you the doors of His mercy and make goodness easy for you wherever you are - Amen !
And show him the right bath to islam ameen❤
Why to set subtitles where cant read it
👏👏👏
Such a beautiful human, thank u
This could've been worded better
Lost lamb
Making blanket statements about "terrorism" does nothing to minimize the reality of what's being done to a staggering number of innocent Palestinians in retaliation. In light of these present atrocities, Glazer's film does indeed remind us how history repeats itself not only in this modern genocide but in the rhetoric and mindset of those who would defend it. In the film, there is a scene in which a German radio broadcast condemns the "massacre" of "innocent" Germans at a school, rallying the German people in their fight against "the other." To the Germans, such an event could easily be used to justify the Nazi's campaign of unspeakable violence (in "self defense," etc). History, however, has made clear how comparably insignificant this "massacre" of German innocents remains in light of what we now understand to be a reprehensible genocide waged for a "cause" that seems so unjustifiable in retrospect. What will we say of Israel when enough time has passed to reflect soberly upon what was done? What museum will house the ephemera of how many tens of thousands of massacred Palestinians, putting their decimation in perspective? Glazer dares to ask these questions now, while our own media still spins an alternate take that attempts to justify the unjustifiable, as we go about the banality of our own lives on the other side of the wall. Bravo to him.
I agree. But this -
"History has made clear how comparably insignificant this "massacre" of German innocents remains"
- I think this is teetering on the very mindset the film is trying to combat. Why must you deemphasise the killing of these children? In one scene a plume of smoke in Berlin oddly mirrors those we see in shots of Auschwitz. Underneath the smoke a mutilated soldier is thrilled by the marching music from the bandstand - Rudolf and the Nazis, arguably many Germans, were as oblivious to the suffering of "their own people" as to the suffering they enacted. That's why we hear about the school bombing on the radio, their meaningless deaths are transformed into a tool to further fuel the war.
We, or "history", must not squash one injustice for comparison's sake. We must not dehumanise, as Glazer says.
You people are ridiculous, people like him use their platforms all the time to promote their own interests. This isn’t the first time yet here you all are praising him like if that has never happened before. Hispanics for Israel!!
His "own interest" appears to be a call for an end to dehumanisation and the slaughter of innocents
This speech and 20 days in Mariupol were THE HIGHEST MOMENTS of the Oscars, but I am afraid we will remember more Gosling.
Aleksandra Bystroń-Kołodziejczyk ❤❤❤ I am so proud!
I’m feeling that pain 😢
respect for this man🫶🏼
How dare you! Who is responsible for this war?!!!! Enough hypocrisy!
Thousands of children, apparently?
Sorry if I sound stupid but what exactly is he talking about?
are you living under a rock?
@@jbeng001 no I know he's talking about Jews and all that but I don't really look into the film industry I'm sorry ☹️
@@jbeng001 since you know can you please inform me I'm actually interested
@@jbeng001 also I'm tryna figure out EXACTLY what he's talking about i already have a general idea
@@jbeng001 nvm I know now
Respect and honour Sir ❤❤❤
Anyone remember The Hostages .....??
Still held by Hammas.......??
What about the hostages israel has, who has more and treats them WAY worse, including holding literal corpses as hostages and not allowing their families to hold funerals or even mourn them, or how they broke both of a kids arms for no reason before finally releasing him.
Apparently not! He is a disgrace as a Jew and as a human being.
Likud and Bibi certainly don't.
Zionazi spotted
Israel doesn't have hostages, they have prisoners who committed crimes and are actually treated very well in the Israeli prisons.
5:30 we sure live in a land where free of speech is a thing...
Definitely going to watch his film
Bless him very brave 👏👏👏👏
free palestine 🇵🇸
What's the happy endpoint in this conflict to you? What scenario will make you happy with this conflict resolving?
@@trentstrickland3534 happy endpoint for me is for you to simply f*çk ōff and stop being a putrid debatelord on the internet ^-^
@@GreenTimYoung def from your genōcidal ziōnist a*s 🥰🥰
Free from Hamas
Free from their own misery.. free from their ingrown hate..
Bravo, very important speech and an incredible film.
I have so much respect for Jonathan Glazer for this speech.
Who is RDJ?
Honourable man, thank you Sir.
Thank you Jonathan Glazer. 🍉
This guy is why I never watch this garbage awards fiasco.
Thank you for using your platform to speak out against the genocide
0:12
This is some real king shit, I respect him so much for doing this
Many zionist people wrote hate speech towards him 😢
bravo, God blessed you ❤
Hats off. Glazer is the man
🌺💞 My Hero!
The courage & compassion to speak out what everyone was thinking.
Thank you Iron Man ❤
Truly brave man. Will watch his film, for sure. #1 on my watchlist. He is speaking for both the victims and relatives of the people who died on Oct 7th and for the 30,000 civilians and 10,000 children who have died needlessly in Gaza. The perpetrators of atrocities on both sides have dehumanised the other side. That is his message. No matter how much you hate or oppose the other side, no matter your thirst for vengeance - don’t fall into the trap of dehumanising your opponent completely. Because then you fall into the abyss, you lose your moral ground. You become worse than your enemy. Which is what Israel’s government and military has done by retaliating to the very extreme. They have now become as detestable as Hamas- no better, no worse, and no different. They had an option to show some restraint. But they decided to walk with the devil. Good luck to them with regaining their image in the eyes of those under age 30, for the next 25-50 years now.
So proud of this brave man. God bless him
That bravery
Good for you Jonathan ❤ free palestine
Free palestine. 🇵🇸🇺🇲🇵🇸🇺🇲🇵🇸🇺🇲✊✊✊
Good man ❤
Free Palastine🇵🇸🇵🇸
Free terrorists you mean
Rdj didn't clap.
Neither did Emma Stone
This week man and 99% of the comments tell me that we have arrived again …it is 1939 again.
Cry harder Zionazi.
As then, children continue to be killed in their thousands
WhY US Media ban this and is muted
Хамасу поевать намегототказтоттнврейсов😅
Free speech needs bravery
YEAHHHHHH BASED. Ofc it’s not posted anywhere official but yk what? this shit still goes hard. Free Palestine 🇵🇸 🇵🇸🇵🇸
Saw the film for a second time last night Glazer truly made an incredible film, that put me in a trance and shook me to my core Sandra and Christian were just incredible, what makes this film so horrifying is how everything is seen as so normal and when you realize what these people are doing is chilling, instead of using graphic imagery he lets our ears hear everything making it more uncomfortable and uneasy, thank you Jonathan for the film and this speech.
Brave man.
This could've been worded A LOT better
How
Lol, this won't age well at all.
Why
very shaky hands..
🫡❤
Bravo 👍
5:40 good speech, but wow i had a heart attack hearing it. I had to rewatch it multiple times to get it
In your face Genocides
This will come to haunt him. My mother's uncle also thought that if he'd just assimilate enough... but it didn't help him.
But I think he knows how twisted his speech is, otherwise he wouldn't be trembling like this.
He is trembling because he is afraid of backlash and that it may well (and probably will) end his career. But looks like he puts integrity and moral convictions above own personal comfort.
No kapo wins
This isn't about "assimilation", this is about how humans can convince themselves to unleash unspeakable things, such as the massacre of children occurring currently in Gaza
@@Virolaxion If you can fathom it - those statistics are false. Look it up. Hamas have been publishing impossible figures. They are a terrorist organisation - you shouldn't believe them.
Off the bat from creating a totally alienating movie about the Holocaust, being a Jew and standing up for justice like this. Sexy beast, under the skin.