A huge thanks to Dean for checking some comments and replying with a link to the container he used. If you want to give them a try: Trays - amzn.to/2GfJOrb Rigid Airline - amzn.to/2B9tR2v
@@KevinsCaninesAndAquatics water circulates from a pump in the tank under the trays, he cleans them out by washing and I believe some hydrogen peroxide
@@BentleyPascoe Sorry I meant how does he get the water into the trays? I loved how he has his trays for the system but didn't really learn a ton else. Air is from the central air system he has in his fish room but what about getting water up into the trays? I think he mentioned he used a circulation pump to agitate the bottom of the 20 long so no debris settles and gives the sponge filter a chance to pick it up. Does he use another circulation pump to add water to the trays? I believe he has water going into each individual tray as opposed to having it flow through each of them in a line.
This...this right here is the kind of old school years of success knowledge that we don't want to lose from the hobby. So glad you did this interview on this subject.
I love going into the “archives” and finding videos that I haven’t seen. Dean is a tremendous wealth of information. Thanks again, for sharing with us!
From this video, I have learned that Dean isn't only a master breeder, but also a master builder. He is able to build exactly what he has in mind with great skill and purpose. Thank you for this video!
Wow, what a great video! The first of two, you say? Yaaaaay! He really is a master breeder, man. I don't have the money or space for that kind of DIY, but someday, i hope to! I loooove breeding fish. Space is just the ultimate dream killer lol. I'm glad you got us a look at this. Oh, and I super enjoyed your guest spot on Joel's show. Love seeing fishfam collaborating!
Dear Bentley, thanks so much to get this video from the Master Breeder Dean with his awesome, unthinkable ideas. His creativities look so 'simple', but they have such workable systems. So amazing
Bentley, I think you did a fantastic job in both the interview with just the right questions and the format. Excellently done so the rest of us could learn! Thank you!
Holy cow that was an awesome interview and great topic I learned so much I think I’ll have to watch it a couple of times to soak it in. Thank you Bentley for doing that
This is exactly what i've been trying to figure out for ages, i've been sketching ideas while searching for months on youtube cause i knew EVENTUALLY i'd find someone that already worked it out for me haha! I'm excited to try this soon, so many ways to adjust this, very versatile and buildable :D
Love, love, loved this video topic! I really appreciate you asking and Dean answering, the detailed questions and answers, all about the fry system! It’s a genius system and loved hearing all about it’s evolution and the current one. Kudos!
How the duck did I only discover this video in 2020? Dean is an absolute jedi master. And good on Bentley for making this happen. Solid content. What a legend! Cheers from South Africa.
I’ve wanted this video for ages!!! I’ve watched the segment on Deans fry setup that Cory did over and over. Thanks for getting all the nitty gritty details :D
Bentley great video of choice mate. You are 110% right about Deans fry setup, such an intelligent man. One thing that always stands out when Dean is on camera is how humble he seems. I'm sure interviewing someone that you look up to would make you nervous Bentley, I know I would be lol. I'm heading straight to your You tube channel to watch some more of your videos. I subscribed straight before the video ended. Again awesome work and looking forward to watching more. Thanks Jarrod
Great instructional video ... thanks to both you, Bentley & Dean, for collaborating and sharing this. My one related question is: how do people with 8-5 jobs manage the food supply for fry, when the fry are at their most fragile early stages?
Depending on the size of the fry, this is where some of the better live foods come into play - vinegar eels for example stay in the water column and are very tiny, so you have a little extra in the water and the fry can feed on them throughout the day. Other examples like paramecium and infusoria cultures also work well, unfortunately unless the fry are larger by nature its hard to apply this to powder/flake type foods as auto feeders dose a lot more than you typically want for a group of fry.
Great video! I used an adaptation of this system for about 6 months, but eventually got tired of trying to keep the tray screens clean and overflowing them. Goldfish fry just seem to require more feeding than the trays allow
I like using those guppy breeding nets for keeping fry in a similar way, if you have some peppered cories or similar in the main tank they come up to the net and suck uneaten food right through the net.
Great video! I use the same zebra fish tanks LRB Aquatics uses. That allows multiple racks above the sump. You could do the same with Deans system. Just change the slot to pvc bunghole and pipe the return to the sump allowing vertical expansion. Combining this and LRB’s gives you the best of both. I will for sure be stealing the zip tie hard line air system though. Deans will maintain closer temp tolerance for sensitive species. Again great video!
Yep, Dean and I shortly mention that system. We've actually discussed it at length a few times with the biggest concern being keeping them clean. As I recall Lucas had some diatom issues in them, but I will say its a really good system if you need maximum density. Gary has some augmentations to it in Lucas' recent visit which are very smart that I like quite a bit. Both systems are good, I just personally see a few more benefits in Dean's system that make me love it as much as I do, especially for rainbows.
I have not had those issues but have not tried putting lights so close. Mine also has never been over 10 trays with a 29 gallon sump. I used plastic tubbing for the returns as well so there is no standing water in the system. It works really well for trying Guppy variations and selective breeding. But I don’t keep them in longer than about a month before going to a grow out tank. In my larger 5 gallon fry tanks they may stay longer. Those I use a pvc (siphon) overflow and so far so good. I’m sure with more time and practice it will tune in nicely. I worry about clogging and overflows stopping but using Aquaclear sponges they have done well. But alas if I had the room Deans is sweet. I just have to stay more compact as I rent and can’t devote the space I would like too. Thanks again for information it will for sure improve what I have going!
I was right there with you about wanting to know more about this system when I first saw his room. How does he go about cleaning the trays though? Great job Bentley.
Considering the constant drip there's likely almost no need to clean, just the sponge when he moves the batch of fish. Careful feeding is key here, but you can also use a small pipette to suck out detritus
Awesome setup! Thanks for making this video Bentley, it's been really helpful. You should talk to Dean about doing a series on breeding Cory's scoot n' fruity puffers for his youtube channel debut video! Those fish are so cool but too expensive, we need to get more and more people breeding them in the states! Cheers Bentley, hope your weekend is great.
Honestly I think the best bet there is Preston John. He's been so successful, it's likely the best source of info in the US. Over time I might get to do more with Dean, we shall see. Cory kinda has priority on a lot of that content.
@@BentleyPascoe I've been excitedly waiting on Preston John's website to really get going. I signed up asap hoping for possible shipping in the spring when the little guys and girls have some size to them. I geek out at the thought of keeping and breeding Schoutedeni puffers like you do to rainbowfish. Just wish there was a video of someone who was 100% confident in their pronunciation of "Schoutedeni." Lol
Bently, after some trial and error, I made my own derivative of Dean's system. Its working great for me. Details here johnsaquatics.com/wp/2019/03/19/my-fry-tray-system/
Awesome system, love dean, and love that the link for the trays was shared. May seem like a silly question but I'm still learning, is the tank its self actually used for fish too or is it just water change volume for the trays.
Tell Dean if he wants to make breeding dishes he could get plexiglas, a form and a heat gun. Cut the plexiglas to the right size and lay it in the form then heat it until it forms around the form. Then he could spray paint it. Then he can get it the size he wants it.
@~27:00 Even if you used a 40 breeder that was deeper, bracing could be used on the top of the tank to adjust the depth at the surface of the water at the top of the tank, so that those trays would still fit the same way. Loved your video. Very informative.
This is an amazing video! I went to the Container Store and picked up some of those containers for my setup. My question is how did he cut the holes in the plastic where the sponge goes?
I taped off the area that I wanted to cut out, then drilled a hole at each end of the slot, then like others said, I used a dremel to cut in between. Cleaned it all up with a fingernail sanding stick.
Hi! Love your videos. So, you use coffee filters in your small, fry boxes to hatch eggs so that you can insert a bubbler and get some serious tumbling going on, I assume? Then, once the eggs hatch, you turn them loose into the box?
10:30 " I Don't have emergency overflows in these and i haven't had that problem, yet.... *Nervously scans room to double check nothing's flooded* " Omg every fish keepers nightmare, nobody wants to jinx themselves haha.
Also... sorry I'm asking so many questions! But, how do you collect your Ram eggs? My mated pair, in a 29g, lay on rocks and before I notice, they've moved them and buried them in a little pit! I tried gathering the free-swimming fry with a turkey baster, but they did not survive in my fry box (and I can work on that). But I'd like to see my Ram parents raise their fry in their tank. It's just hard to get the food to them in such a large tank (live baby brine shrimp, some fry food from Aquarium Co-op, infusoria from catappa leaves already in the tank).
Dean has told me it's a much larger pump than needed. You would likely be just fine with a much smaller pump like something you'd use on a 3-5g tank. The more important part is having a great prefilter to the pump to remove particulates from the tubing.
on another topic, how often should I add Seachem Stability to my 75 gallon Discus tank? Ph is 7. My fish store guy has me adding 8 capfuls daily for a month or longer. Is this justified? Thanks
Typically you only need it post water changes, once a tank is established it should have a solid bacteria culture and you should no longer need it unless you did a really deep cleaning of your filter
Personally, I like to let fish spawn in a tank and then move them out so that the fry have an established tank to graze on. I find that rainbow and tetra fry are much less sensitive when they are in an established tank rather than a small container.
What works best for you should always come first, but often when breeding for taw volume, moving the parents often can be very stressful. If you do it only a few times a year, it's no problem!
For certain don't worry about membership, human malware has been rough and I'd never want someone affected to use their money my way, you have me your time and that's pretty precious in its own right.
hi bently ,hope you well , sorry this is off topic . will keep it very short . my water out the blue , became milky i guess, and today that milkyness has turned into what looks like white strands of cotton. Any thoughts on what it is and how i can get rid of it Thanks Jason
It sounds like a rather extreme bacterial bloom. I would be doing a lot of testing of the water to see parameters and see if it's tied to spikes of any kind.
@@BentleyPascoe thank you kindly . To say my testing kit is inadequate , would be the understatement of the year . i will take a sample of my water to my local store ASAP ..Can a bacterial bloom be harmful to my fish ? Its now 21 33 Sunday evening , all my fish seem fine , but will remain in the tank for atleast 10 hrs before the store opens , Is there anything you would do to try ensure their good health . i did do a 50%water change .THANKS
@@BentleyPascoe hi Bentlry , hope you well . thought i would just follow up with you as i think i finally resolved the issue . and what seems to have been source of my bacterial bloom issue was the plastic flower pot that no longer had plants growing from it but still had that white fertlizer enriched material in it . i removed it yesterday and this morning my water is almost back to perfect . thanks once again for your valuble feedback
Anther question: I have used Seachem ParaGuard when hatching eggs, somewhat successfully, but you use methylene blue until wiggling stage. Do you really do only a 50% water change when they wiggle, leaving some of the blue in? I've been afraid that any methylene blue would kill wigglers. Also, I've been experimenting with just catappa leaves in egg boxes, with extreme bubbling agitation, and it has worked well with Cories. Less well with Bolivian Rams... Cories, in my experience, are very hardy little dudes.
The amount of methylene blue that Dean is using in his setup is so minimal we're talking like one to two drops in one of those large specimen containers so it's just enough to barely stay in the water.
This is used normally with egg layers, so the eggs are moved to trays, hatched then raised until a certain size depending in fish, then moved from trays to grow out tanks.
@@BentleyPascoe Thank you, Bentley, I think I've watched this like 3 or 4 times trying to figure out how he did a lot of the things he has. Also, If you could have him show how he made the vinegar eel harvesting system I'd appreciate that too! Thank you for doing a video on this it was so helpful and so useful thank you!!! I really wish that he makes videos :-( . Thank you for doing the video!!!
Pretty certain these are the trays he's using, or perhaps the shallower version of this: www.containerstore.com/s/kitchen/refrigerator-freezer/interdesign-deep-fridge-binz/12d?productId=11000497
They are actually these containers www.amazon.com/dp/B00WSO2E8C?pf_rd_p=7ebdab82-de3b-42f2-8032-aa63ae38b0fa&pf_rd_r=5CPAGKKMV9GJFB8T7AB5&pd_rd_wg=XjZ5X&pd_rd_i=B00WSO3B3O&pd_rd_w=nY56n&pd_rd_r=0827dad1-9cae-4307-a4b1-d5a08f777529&ref_=pd_luc_rh_crh_rh_sbs_02_03_t_img_lh&th=1 They are made by InterDesign, the difference is these have the smooth corners in the bottoms.
I can answer some, there is the fine sponge on the intake of the pump and some other sponges down within. He then pushes from that pump up into the PVC which delivers the regulated stream of water into the trays using the valves. I will in the future do a full step by step build of this set up - look forward to it!
Bentley Pascoe good man, I'm really looking forward to it. I like his system and understand how to use it but I have no idea how to set up the actual mechanics. I would love a super detailed tutorial on building it. The parts, the process, the mechanics. Tks again.
@bentleypascoe So I have watched this several times in the past. I am doing a new breeding project with non-annual killifish. I am curious about the size of fry that could be used in this type of system, does it all come down to managing flow and very fine/high ppi sponge? Curious if you have any insight.
Bentley, the other day I was listening to a podcast about the misused words, "Awesome" and "Genius." So the narrator gave the actual description for each word. Dean certainly qualifies as someone with an idea that is genius, without a doubt. I am always impressed that Dean encourages others with his information and you care enough to help him share. I don't think you talk over him as much as you are both different people and Dean is a bit soft spoken. All in all a great video that I hope will help some folks out.
Well to be fair, I was born/grew up in an era where awesome took a different portion of the English vernacular. Is it textbook? No, but slang does that as our speech evolves. For certain, Dean is much more soft spoken than I am, the radio person in me just can't stay quiet forever - old habits die hard.
@@BentleyPascoe no criticism intended I was defending you from a previous comment. Dean is a Genius, you are both awesome. Do my comments sound offensive? I never, ever have intended to offend or criticize you or Dean or anyone, yet people seem to feel defensive. I really have to work on this apparently. I'm Canadian I am not confrontational. We have been described as the world's designated driver....except Joey, I love him but I'll drive. Anyway if you can tell me why I seem to make people think I am criticizing them I would really appreciate it. I am a writer, you are a radio person, communicating should be easy for us.
@@kerrypitt9789 Oh no Kerry, not at all - I should have clarified that what I meant is that some words evolve, so our (we people that is) use of the words often leave the textbook side of things and become more of slang. Cheers my friend!
A huge thanks to Dean for checking some comments and replying with a link to the container he used. If you want to give them a try:
Trays - amzn.to/2GfJOrb
Rigid Airline - amzn.to/2B9tR2v
What about the waterproof black lever control valves... any chance amazon has them?
What about the sterilize bowls and how does he circulate water?
@@KevinsCaninesAndAquatics water circulates from a pump in the tank under the trays, he cleans them out by washing and I believe some hydrogen peroxide
@@BentleyPascoe Sorry I meant how does he get the water into the trays? I loved how he has his trays for the system but didn't really learn a ton else. Air is from the central air system he has in his fish room but what about getting water up into the trays? I think he mentioned he used a circulation pump to agitate the bottom of the 20 long so no debris settles and gives the sponge filter a chance to pick it up. Does he use another circulation pump to add water to the trays? I believe he has water going into each individual tray as opposed to having it flow through each of them in a line.
@@KevinsCaninesAndAquatics the pump. He describes it in the video
I love how Dean spreads his knowledge to the rest of us. So much to learn from him. Great job Bentley
This...this right here is the kind of old school years of success knowledge that we don't want to lose from the hobby. So glad you did this interview on this subject.
I love going into the “archives” and finding videos that I haven’t seen. Dean is a tremendous wealth of information. Thanks again, for sharing with us!
From this video, I have learned that Dean isn't only a master breeder, but also a master builder. He is able to build exactly what he has in mind with great skill and purpose. Thank you for this video!
Nice job Bentley, that was a fun day! Hope everyone enjoys!
It was an honor to get to sit down and an absolute blast chatting fish with you!
Incredible interview, buddy! This is great info to be captured for the hobby at large! Thanks Bentley.
I was fascinated by the trays... and how customizable they are to the fish you are breeding.
Excellent educational video on breeding techniques.
Very interesting, I’m just getting into fish raising, a lot I didn’t understand but shows what I still need to learn, thank you for the insight
that Dean the chef was eating TV microwave dinners to get the trays in the early 90's :) great video Dean is awesome :)
Wow, what a great video! The first of two, you say? Yaaaaay! He really is a master breeder, man. I don't have the money or space for that kind of DIY, but someday, i hope to! I loooove breeding fish. Space is just the ultimate dream killer lol.
I'm glad you got us a look at this.
Oh, and I super enjoyed your guest spot on Joel's show. Love seeing fishfam collaborating!
Dear Bentley, thanks so much to get this video from the Master Breeder Dean with his awesome, unthinkable ideas. His creativities look so 'simple', but they have such workable systems. So amazing
Thanks so much for doing an in-depth video on this. This system is the thing that stood out the most to me as well from watching fish room tours.
Bentley, I think you did a fantastic job in both the interview with just the right questions and the format. Excellently done so the rest of us could learn! Thank you!
Holy cow that was an awesome interview and great topic I learned so much I think I’ll have to watch it a couple of times to soak it in. Thank you Bentley for doing that
This is exactly what i've been trying to figure out for ages, i've been sketching ideas while searching for months on youtube cause i knew EVENTUALLY i'd find someone that already worked it out for me haha! I'm excited to try this soon, so many ways to adjust this, very versatile and buildable :D
How did it go? Did you try making the fry system?
i love the accessibility on the top and the volume of water.
Love, love, loved this video topic! I really appreciate you asking and Dean answering, the detailed questions and answers, all about the fry system! It’s a genius system and loved hearing all about it’s evolution and the current one. Kudos!
How the duck did I only discover this video in 2020? Dean is an absolute jedi master. And good on Bentley for making this happen. Solid content. What a legend! Cheers from South Africa.
Glad you enjoyed it!
@@BentleyPascoe Here you go sir, you have my subscription. Keep it up.
I’ve wanted this video for ages!!! I’ve watched the segment on Deans fry setup that Cory did over and over. Thanks for getting all the nitty gritty details :D
Happy to get it out to everyone! Thanks for watching!
Cool idea with letter box weir design 👍
Ain't nobody got $#@& on Dean!!! This guy is my hero!!! So much to learn from this old timer!
8:56 that's what she said. :-P
Dean is the man! Thanks Bentley, enjoyed the video.
Great video, thank you for sharing Dean's innovative setup. I love how simple it is!
That is such an amazing systems. Fish keepers are truly innovative!
Thank you so much for sharing! I'm planning my fish room and it's inspirating 🤩 👍
Great job Bentley! Thanks for giving us an in depth look at this brilliant system!
Excellent video Bentley! I wanna be just like Dean when I grow up!
wow so much experience, expertise, and wisdom in this video!
Bentley great video of choice mate. You are 110% right about Deans fry setup, such an intelligent man.
One thing that always stands out when Dean is on camera is how humble he seems.
I'm sure interviewing someone that you look up to would make you nervous Bentley, I know I would be lol.
I'm heading straight to your You tube channel to watch some more of your videos.
I subscribed straight before the video ended.
Again awesome work and looking forward to watching more.
Thanks Jarrod
Thank you Jarrod, and he is, humble and awesome is basically the perfect description of Dean
Awesome video🤙🏻🤙🏻very informative going to try this breeding technique with my guppies very
Very informative, thanks for sharing Bentley!
Awesome loved every min of it thanks
Great system. Thanks for sharing
Great instructional video ... thanks to both you, Bentley & Dean, for collaborating and sharing this.
My one related question is: how do people with 8-5 jobs manage the food supply for fry, when the fry are at their most fragile early stages?
Depending on the size of the fry, this is where some of the better live foods come into play - vinegar eels for example stay in the water column and are very tiny, so you have a little extra in the water and the fry can feed on them throughout the day. Other examples like paramecium and infusoria cultures also work well, unfortunately unless the fry are larger by nature its hard to apply this to powder/flake type foods as auto feeders dose a lot more than you typically want for a group of fry.
Thanks for posting!!
Great video! I used an adaptation of this system for about 6 months, but eventually got tired of trying to keep the tray screens clean and overflowing them. Goldfish fry just seem to require more feeding than the trays allow
Pretty awesome fry setup!
Genius!
A 29 gallon has the same frame as the 20 long
Awesome 👌
I like using those guppy breeding nets for keeping fry in a similar way, if you have some peppered cories or similar in the main tank they come up to the net and suck uneaten food right through the net.
Very cool tip, thank you!
Great job Bentley keep it up!
In the 90's, I raised Livebearer fry in plastic canvas boxes, styro-edges to float.
impressive system need to watch a few times
Dude you're in Kent?? Thats awesome man I work in Kent lol
I'm so confused Wikipedia says gemco closed in 1986. Am I missing something? Wanting to buy the valves if they are available. Or similar
Jehmco.com
Great video!
Great video! I use the same zebra fish tanks LRB Aquatics uses. That allows multiple racks above the sump. You could do the same with Deans system. Just change the slot to pvc bunghole and pipe the return to the sump allowing vertical expansion. Combining this and LRB’s gives you the best of both. I will for sure be stealing the zip tie hard line air system though. Deans will maintain closer temp tolerance for sensitive species. Again great video!
Yep, Dean and I shortly mention that system. We've actually discussed it at length a few times with the biggest concern being keeping them clean. As I recall Lucas had some diatom issues in them, but I will say its a really good system if you need maximum density. Gary has some augmentations to it in Lucas' recent visit which are very smart that I like quite a bit. Both systems are good, I just personally see a few more benefits in Dean's system that make me love it as much as I do, especially for rainbows.
I have not had those issues but have not tried putting lights so close. Mine also has never been over 10 trays with a 29 gallon sump. I used plastic tubbing for the returns as well so there is no standing water in the system. It works really well for trying Guppy variations and selective breeding. But I don’t keep them in longer than about a month before going to a grow out tank. In my larger 5 gallon fry tanks they may stay longer. Those I use a pvc (siphon) overflow and so far so good. I’m sure with more time and practice it will tune in nicely. I worry about clogging and overflows stopping but using Aquaclear sponges they have done well. But alas if I had the room Deans is sweet. I just have to stay more compact as I rent and can’t devote the space I would like too. Thanks again for information it will for sure improve what I have going!
Tnk you for showing what he “really” does.
Could you have daphnea and plants in the base tank? Pros/Cons?
Fertilizer and light requirements could cause issues for the babies in the trays, otherwise I think it's ok
I was right there with you about wanting to know more about this system when I first saw his room. How does he go about cleaning the trays though? Great job Bentley.
Considering the constant drip there's likely almost no need to clean, just the sponge when he moves the batch of fish. Careful feeding is key here, but you can also use a small pipette to suck out detritus
I would like to hear about the sump underneath and how the drip system works. The bowls I think I understand
So it's just a 20L with a filter using a pump to cycle water up to the trays
Thanks! Good job ...good subject.🐟🌿🐠😎
That is very cool, innovative.
Awesome setup! Thanks for making this video Bentley, it's been really helpful. You should talk to Dean about doing a series on breeding Cory's scoot n' fruity puffers for his youtube channel debut video! Those fish are so cool but too expensive, we need to get more and more people breeding them in the states! Cheers Bentley, hope your weekend is great.
Honestly I think the best bet there is Preston John. He's been so successful, it's likely the best source of info in the US. Over time I might get to do more with Dean, we shall see. Cory kinda has priority on a lot of that content.
@@BentleyPascoe I've been excitedly waiting on Preston John's website to really get going. I signed up asap hoping for possible shipping in the spring when the little guys and girls have some size to them. I geek out at the thought of keeping and breeding Schoutedeni puffers like you do to rainbowfish. Just wish there was a video of someone who was 100% confident in their pronunciation of "Schoutedeni." Lol
How do you get the eggs out of the tanks and how do you transfer eggs and fry?
Eggs are either I. Spawning mops or on surfaces, depends on species. They're moved as eggs or carefully with a turkey baster as hatchlings
I have something similar. I used nylon nuts and "bolts" that I was able to pick up at my local Ace Hardware store.
Bently, after some trial and error, I made my own derivative of Dean's system. Its working great for me. Details here johnsaquatics.com/wp/2019/03/19/my-fry-tray-system/
@@johnstoller4898 Just got a chance to check it out, very nice! Let me know how it works out over time - email: bentley.pascoe@gmail.com
Awesome system, love dean, and love that the link for the trays was shared. May seem like a silly question but I'm still learning, is the tank its self actually used for fish too or is it just water change volume for the trays.
Volume and filtration
Tell Dean if he wants to make breeding dishes he could get plexiglas, a form and a heat gun. Cut the plexiglas to the right size and lay it in the form then heat it until it forms around the form. Then he could spray paint it. Then he can get it the size he wants it.
What kind of paint was used that was alright to submerge? I'm familiar with painting a lot of things, but I've never sprayed tubs to drop into water.
Krylon Fusion as I recall
@~27:00 Even if you used a 40 breeder that was deeper, bracing could be used on the top of the tank to adjust the depth at the surface of the water at the top of the tank, so that those trays would still fit the same way.
Loved your video. Very informative.
That's actually a really good idea - thanks for the comment!
Congratulations
What kind of shelving units are they that hold the weight of the water
They are a knock together style industrial shelving meant for warehouses
I see Jemco as been sold out of the water valves any where they can be bought ?
I've been trying to source an alternative with little luck.
Great vid, by the way!
This is an amazing video! I went to the Container Store and picked up some of those containers for my setup. My question is how did he cut the holes in the plastic where the sponge goes?
Left Coast Fish most likely a router
think he used a dremmel.
Most likely a dremel. The right router would work too if you were careful.
I taped off the area that I wanted to cut out, then drilled a hole at each end of the slot, then like others said, I used a dremel to cut in between. Cleaned it all up with a fingernail sanding stick.
Hi! Love your videos. So, you use coffee filters in your small, fry boxes to hatch eggs so that you can insert a bubbler and get some serious tumbling going on, I assume? Then, once the eggs hatch, you turn them loose into the box?
It depends on the eggs. Not all eggs do well under heavy tumbling. Mostly that's just cories and plecos.
10:30 " I Don't have emergency overflows in these and i haven't had that problem, yet.... *Nervously scans room to double check nothing's flooded* "
Omg every fish keepers nightmare, nobody wants to jinx themselves haha.
What are the brackets he is using to hold the pvc pipe up across the tank
Pretty sure they're just some screw in rounds. Forgetting the proper name for them
@Bentley Pascoe I mean the flat ones that leaning against the tank
Not to toot but dean and I are alike. Thanks Bentley!!
You could use a Frag tank for your fry.
You get a sub just for this.
Also... sorry I'm asking so many questions! But, how do you collect your Ram eggs? My mated pair, in a 29g, lay on rocks and before I notice, they've moved them and buried them in a little pit! I tried gathering the free-swimming fry with a turkey baster, but they did not survive in my fry box (and I can work on that). But I'd like to see my Ram parents raise their fry in their tank. It's just hard to get the food to them in such a large tank (live baby brine shrimp, some fry food from Aquarium Co-op, infusoria from catappa leaves already in the tank).
He just has a lot of flat surfaces that he uses and as soon as he sees eggs he pulls them out and then puts a new flat stone in.
What size watwr pump does he use to run water to trays
Dean has told me it's a much larger pump than needed. You would likely be just fine with a much smaller pump like something you'd use on a 3-5g tank. The more important part is having a great prefilter to the pump to remove particulates from the tubing.
when using the coffee filters does he put the air bubbler inside the coffee filter with the eggs? or just in the box next to coffee filter?
In the box I believe
on another topic, how often should I add Seachem Stability to my 75 gallon Discus tank? Ph is 7. My fish store guy has me adding 8 capfuls daily for a month or longer. Is this justified?
Thanks
Typically you only need it post water changes, once a tank is established it should have a solid bacteria culture and you should no longer need it unless you did a really deep cleaning of your filter
Can I use these trays on a 20 High all that I have
as long as the front to back is the same distance or you alter the screw length - should do.
Personally, I like to let fish spawn in a tank and then move them out so that the fry have an established tank to graze on. I find that rainbow and tetra fry are much less sensitive when they are in an established tank rather than a small container.
What works best for you should always come first, but often when breeding for taw volume, moving the parents often can be very stressful. If you do it only a few times a year, it's no problem!
Love your stuff wish i could be a meb but cov 19 is killing my job>
For certain don't worry about membership, human malware has been rough and I'd never want someone affected to use their money my way, you have me your time and that's pretty precious in its own right.
hi bently ,hope you well , sorry this is off topic . will keep it very short . my water out the blue , became milky i guess, and today that milkyness has turned into what looks like white strands of cotton. Any thoughts on what it is and how i can get rid of it Thanks Jason
It sounds like a rather extreme bacterial bloom. I would be doing a lot of testing of the water to see parameters and see if it's tied to spikes of any kind.
@@BentleyPascoe thank you kindly . To say my testing kit is inadequate , would be the understatement of the year . i will take a sample of my water to my local store ASAP ..Can a bacterial bloom be harmful to my fish ? Its now 21 33 Sunday evening , all my fish seem fine , but will remain in the tank for atleast 10 hrs before the store opens , Is there anything you would do to try ensure their good health . i did do a 50%water change .THANKS
@@BentleyPascoe hi Bentlry , hope you well . thought i would just follow up with you as i think i finally resolved the issue . and what seems to have been source of my bacterial bloom issue was the plastic flower pot that no longer had plants growing from it but still had that white fertlizer enriched material in it . i removed it yesterday and this morning my water is almost back to perfect . thanks once again for your valuble feedback
How he controls pest like hydra in his breeding setup with feeding out that much brine. I’ve been killing loads of fish feeding out bbs
He feeds very careful amounts, so there is not enough left overs for hydra to form
Very helpfull thank you !😍😎
Anther question: I have used Seachem ParaGuard when hatching eggs, somewhat successfully, but you use methylene blue until wiggling stage. Do you really do only a 50% water change when they wiggle, leaving some of the blue in? I've been afraid that any methylene blue would kill wigglers. Also, I've been experimenting with just catappa leaves in egg boxes, with extreme bubbling agitation, and it has worked well with Cories. Less well with Bolivian Rams... Cories, in my experience, are very hardy little dudes.
The amount of methylene blue that Dean is using in his setup is so minimal we're talking like one to two drops in one of those large specimen containers so it's just enough to barely stay in the water.
You can make any tray from acrylic?
You could in theory make one yes
How about getting Cory from the Co-oP to get his Chinese connections to make some of these things for sale in the shop.
Tugger
Edinburgh
Scotland
Will growing bettas like this will give good results
I am not sure, but potentially
hi there , how do you move the fry from the breeding tank and put them into the breeding trays??
This is used normally with egg layers, so the eggs are moved to trays, hatched then raised until a certain size depending in fish, then moved from trays to grow out tanks.
What shelving unit is this? Need to find a good rack for 40 breeders and 2 20 longs. How does water get circulated into the fry trays?
The video explains everything for water circulation and how that system works. The racks are a fairly common knock-togethet industrial rack
For the two aquariums the one with methylene blue and the one with the fry trays what size are they?
Fry trays 20L, meth blue is a small container, about a gallon as I recall
Bentley could you do a video with Dean on how to DIY fry system equipment please?
We're trying to get our schedules to align to do a full build tutorial, it's coming as soon as I can!
@@BentleyPascoe Thank you, Bentley, I think I've watched this like 3 or 4 times trying to figure out how he did a lot of the things he has. Also, If you could have him show how he made the vinegar eel harvesting system I'd appreciate that too!
Thank you for doing a video on this it was so helpful and so useful thank you!!! I really wish that he makes videos :-( . Thank you for doing the video!!!
@@BentleyPascoe I also love all of his DIYs and wish he made a video so PLEASE do ONE!!!
What was the depth of the white/clear trays? I realize the tank is a 20L so the trays can't be very deep but by chance do you know the dimensions?
Pretty certain these are the trays he's using, or perhaps the shallower version of this: www.containerstore.com/s/kitchen/refrigerator-freezer/interdesign-deep-fridge-binz/12d?productId=11000497
They are actually these containers www.amazon.com/dp/B00WSO2E8C?pf_rd_p=7ebdab82-de3b-42f2-8032-aa63ae38b0fa&pf_rd_r=5CPAGKKMV9GJFB8T7AB5&pd_rd_wg=XjZ5X&pd_rd_i=B00WSO3B3O&pd_rd_w=nY56n&pd_rd_r=0827dad1-9cae-4307-a4b1-d5a08f777529&ref_=pd_luc_rh_crh_rh_sbs_02_03_t_img_lh&th=1
They are made by InterDesign, the difference is these have the smooth corners in the bottoms.
What is it that he bought from Jehmco?
The metal valves
Where does he buy the pieces of sponge used to cover the hole from?
He cuts them, I believe they are just some sheets of poret foam from Swiss Tropicals
What are the containers dean uses?
Wow I missed the link. 🤦
No worries! Glad you found it
I learnt I still have a ton of questions. It's a 20long right? I would like more of a breakdown I how the filtration is plumbed into that 20long.
I can answer some, there is the fine sponge on the intake of the pump and some other sponges down within. He then pushes from that pump up into the PVC which delivers the regulated stream of water into the trays using the valves. I will in the future do a full step by step build of this set up - look forward to it!
And yes, the tank is a 20L.
Bentley Pascoe good man, I'm really looking forward to it. I like his system and understand how to use it but I have no idea how to set up the actual mechanics. I would love a super detailed tutorial on building it. The parts, the process, the mechanics. Tks again.
@@lithabelle8001 A long term goal is to do a full build tutorial, possibly with Dean in the future.
@@BentleyPascoe Has this build video happened yet? Regards from South Africa.
@bentleypascoe So I have watched this several times in the past. I am doing a new breeding project with non-annual killifish. I am curious about the size of fry that could be used in this type of system, does it all come down to managing flow and very fine/high ppi sponge? Curious if you have any insight.
Dean has done discus, cories, rainbows, Rams, plecos, and a lot more, just get a fine sponge and be careful with flow
Bentley, the other day I was listening to a podcast about the misused words, "Awesome" and "Genius."
So the narrator gave the actual description for each word.
Dean certainly qualifies as someone with an idea that is genius, without a doubt. I am always impressed that Dean encourages others with his information and you care enough to help him share.
I don't think you talk over him as much as you are both different people and Dean is a bit soft spoken.
All in all a great video that I hope will help some folks out.
Well to be fair, I was born/grew up in an era where awesome took a different portion of the English vernacular. Is it textbook? No, but slang does that as our speech evolves. For certain, Dean is much more soft spoken than I am, the radio person in me just can't stay quiet forever - old habits die hard.
@@BentleyPascoe no criticism intended I was defending you from a previous comment. Dean is a Genius, you are both awesome.
Do my comments sound offensive? I never, ever have intended to offend or criticize you or Dean or anyone, yet people seem to feel defensive. I really have to work on this apparently. I'm Canadian I am not confrontational. We have been described as the world's designated driver....except Joey, I love him but I'll drive.
Anyway if you can tell me why I seem to make people think I am criticizing them I would really appreciate it. I am a writer, you are a radio person, communicating should be easy for us.
@@kerrypitt9789 Oh no Kerry, not at all - I should have clarified that what I meant is that some words evolve, so our (we people that is) use of the words often leave the textbook side of things and become more of slang. Cheers my friend!
@@BentleyPascoe agreed! Totally it is like Sic or Sick or however you spell it now.
Thanks Bentley I was stressing.
What size is the tank to the left of the fry system where he hatches the eggs? Also, What containers is he using to hatch the eggs in that tank?
Containers are linked, that's a large specimen container for the eggs in methylene blue
@@BentleyPascoe what size tank is he using methylene blue in?
@@KevinsCaninesAndAquatics it's a large specimen container floating in a 10g tank.