I was so ready to be mad if Vanessa wasn’t number 1 🤣 I totally agree with your order... but I think una/Rochelle are interchangeable depending on the performance.
Totally agree, I prefer Una's overall tone. Rochelle has a more generic and manufactured tone to her voice, when she hits the high notes shes good, shes not so great on the lower range. Molly and Frankie were always weak vocalists.
Agreed! their songs just had this fun beat to them straight from the get go, that already prepared my brain for "right this is gonna be awesome" if that makes sense hehe ;) some of the dolls i review on my channel actually remind me a bit of some of the members x #teamsatsforever
I'm absolutely no expert, but my favourite voice from the group was always Una's. She's by no means the best singer out there, but I've always just liked her.
For me it was Vanessa but she lost her vocal range during the "on your radar" period,so now I see rochelle more of a lead in the later songs. I love frankie she adds a sparkle to the group.
It was hard to choose between Una and Rochelle, I think Una may edge it for me because of her tone, but completely agree with the rest of the list! Vanessa had some troubles, but when she was on it, she was one of the strongest vocalist of UK pop at that time
Interesting. Rochelle edges out Una for me because of her tone and control. I do love Una's rasp and edge, but her voice isn't as stylistically versatile as Rochelle's either.
I feel it started out with 1.) Vanessa 2.) Una 3.) Rochelle and as time went on it became 1.) Vanessa 2.) Rochelle 3.) Una and then by the end it was 1.) Rochelle/Vanessa equally with Una next. Rochelle should've ended up going solo but she clearly never intended on doing music any longer. lol She became lead more frequently near the middle and end. Vanessa never left her 1 or 2 spot but sometimes I feel Rochelle shined more depending on the era. Una really edged out Rochelle at the very very beginning and first album.
I loved this group! It’s such a shame none of them have had a big solo career post-break up. They’re all good vocalists and definitely have that it factor
I really wish we could have another Saturdays album, I miss them so much. I agree with your line up of choices when it comes to strongest to weakest generally speaking. Although Frankie has a more beautiful higher register than Mollie as she's usually the one in the highest harmonies. Mollie does function well as Vanessa's support with her high harmonies as well. But you can see Frankie's strongest vocals have been on their song 'Faster' which the other girls have difficulty covering her parts due to how high they are. I think what also hampered Frankie in the past was her battle with depression. Overall my personal list has changed depending on the time period, initially it was Vanessa > Una / Rochelle > Mollie > Frankie and for their later albums you can see that the lead singer was switched from Vanessa to Rochelle. After a certain period Rochelle began carrying the hardest parts in the songs vocally and belting more as Vanessa's voice weened. The final vocal line-up for me is Rochelle > Vanessa/Una > Frankie=Mollie.
I used to be OBSESSED with The Saturdays. I have all of my merch/etc. in my closet boxed up still 😂😂 Personally, I think Vanessa is the best because Vanessas voice is pretty much the sound/brand of the group. Her voice is so present/heavy in most choruses. Like a good 90% of their discography is Vanessa vocal heavy. If you took her voice out of the biggest Sats hits we know,, then they would not sound right. Example: Higher, Ego, My Heart Takes Over, Forever Is Over, Disco Love and so on.
Great ranking!!! I would put Frankie above Mollie ONLY because Ive heard more impressive notes from her in the bands time... I agree though Frankie is 100% the most pitchy, but she just nails some good ones here and there unlike Mollie that plays it safe. Agreed with Vanessa being #1
Frankie - She never really developed enough confidence to improve her vocals much over the Saturdays’ time unfortunately. I think the selling point of her voice is her vibrato, which is really satisfying when she’s able to use it. I think her and Una’s voices have the rocky edge. But sometimes it’s kind of obvious that she falls back on problematic technique. She could’ve used a lot more help developing her voice. A couple of songs which showcase her vocals best are Golden Rules and No One. Mollie - Her voice reminds me of Kylie Minogue’s, she has that airy nasal sound. She was actually pretty consistent over the course of their career, she wasn’t a belting type or anything but she was able to hold her own. I think her head voice had pretty great potential and they could’ve explored that a lot more. Her problem mostly is that her pitching isn’t perfect and she can lose it when she struggles. Some of her best vocals are in Here Standing and No One. Una - Una has great musicality which shines through in her voice, she seems best at improvising. Her solo music showcases a lot of her country, folky and rocky aspects. Her chest register is arguably the best in the group and she can connect it through her higher register with her distinctive rasp. Her problem is that her distinctive sound is achieved with sometimes strenuous technique, which can make her crack or pitchy. The end of All Fired Up shows her using her higher and lower registers really well. Rochelle - I agree that she improved a lot. She shines a lot in acoustic performances, where she can showcase her dynamics without nerves. Her range was pretty impressive, she had a lot of grasp on different aspects of her voice, such as her chest voice, lower register and head voice, and she could perform pretty great runs too. Her problem was that she often used too much tension, particularly when growing from low to high, which could make her kind of sharp. Her vocals were arguably at their best in the Living For The Weekend era. Vanessa - It’s like she went from being the best singer, to the problematic singer to be in the best singer again. Even though she’s known for her belting, I’d argue that she didn’t always use great technique to achieve the twangy sound, which is part of what blew her out during the On You Radar era. I thought her head voice and falsetto could’ve used more developing so she could fall back on that with more ease. Her vocals were at her best during the Chasing Lights and Wordshaker eras, and then she recovered a lot of her voice in the Greatest Hits Tour and developed a more solid technique. My order would be Chasing Lights/Wordshaker Era: 1 - Vanessa 2 - Una 3 - Rochelle 4 - Mollie/Frankie Headlines Era 1 - Una 2 - Rochelle 3 - Vanessa 4 - Mollie 5 - Frankie On Your Radar era 1 - Rochelle/Una 2 - Vanessa 3 - Mollie 4 - Frankie Living For the Weekend Era 1 - Rochelle 2 - Una 3 - Vanessa 4 - Mollie 5 - Frankie Greatest Hits era 1 - Vanessa 2 - Rochelle/Una 4 - Mollie 5 - Frankie
Don't think anyone could disagree with your opinion: 5-frankie...lacked vocal confidence which affected her ability and development potential....nice dresses...cute hair and the only one to be considered a dancer in the group. 4-molly...limited range but could carry a note to varying pitchy degrees in her 1.5 octave range. Pretty back up singer with much vocal limitations. 3-una ...most out of place better suited as a struggle soloist. Would be better behind the scenes...song writing etc. . she has artistical potential but lacks any real star substance to stand out further than molly or frankie. 2-rochelle...developed considerably the most...strongish voice...bigger range but lacks agility and dimensional tone. 1-vanessa...the most versatile...vocally competent but sometimes unreliable and generally inconsistent. The most vocally dynamic with the best tone on her better days. That said... they're a mediocre group ...with some good songs and a diverse set of singers with very very varied vocal capabilities. At least their vocals and aesthetics was far better than their choreography. To be fair when they perform live they made more noise than what would be considered music.
My opinion was 5.venessa as I felt she thought she was better then the whole band,4 Frankie as I liked the mellow tone of her voice and I liked her in s club juniors 3,Mollie ,2 Una 1, Rochelle
I do agree... Vanessa is the mel c, Una is the Emma, Rochelle is a more better Mel B. The low tone... Mollie has the Victoria vocal. And Frankie the geri vocal. But that just vocally thinking
They all have songs that suit them more, Frankie during missing you would be 1st every day of the week. Love all 5 but it’s clear Una Rochelle and Vanessa were top 3, then Frankie and Mollie depending on the song, but still contributed plenty
I think Vanessa had confidence issues during her time with the Sats but, in my opinion, she is truly a top notch vocalist. Definitely one of the best (if not the best) vocalists from any UK girl group. She lacked consistency during live performances, but her overall vocal abilities surpass the majority by a long shot.
Absolutely love your videos, their so respectful of the artists and their voices, you give really good constructive criticism, I would love for you to react to the band Haim, especially show me love and hallelujah in the live lounge at BBC, ❤❤
Girls aloud and the Saturdays were similar in ways it why they didnt out beat them. Sugababes and Girl's Aloud ruled the charts in this era really with input from Atomic Kitten too. The Saturdays were good talent though with some great songs.. Gentlemen era was like what are you doing.. terrible stuff. Stick to the good pop ffs
I think The Saturdays have better harmonies than Girls Aloud, as a whole group their voices blend really nice. They had bad promotion and management thats maybe why they didnt went far. I love The Saturdays
@@18mestar Individual voices girls aloud beat them in every single way. Harmony yes i agree GA don't fit in too well because of Nicola and cheryl. Girls aloud are overall more likeable and their songs are really amazing unlike Saturdays(meh they've no great songs)
I completely understand why Vanessa was the 1st but to say the likes of Frankie isn't a lead singer....she was actually the lead singer in S Club Juniors. All the girls are very much loved. It's people like you that make people feel rubbish about themselves
This group was amazing!!! But I disagree between Una, Vanessa and Rochelle. The powerful voice (IN STUDIO) 'cause in live she sound soooo out of breath and never reach the high note like the record sound is Vanessa, she is good singer but not the great one. To me she desirve #3 then Una #2 'cause she have this unique sound and raspy tone that is sooooo Una and Rochelle #1 'cause she have more control with her voice and have a powerful voice record sound and performances. They are great group but sometimes people blind themself for voices that are fix in studio but the reality is when we watching performances live they are totally disaster.
![The Saturdays - Ego [Headlines Tour DVD]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/atODKOejI7Y/mqdefault.jpg)
I was so ready to be mad if Vanessa wasn’t number 1 🤣 I totally agree with your order... but I think una/Rochelle are interchangeable depending on the performance.
Totally agree, I prefer Una's overall tone. Rochelle has a more generic and manufactured tone to her voice, when she hits the high notes shes good, shes not so great on the lower range. Molly and Frankie were always weak vocalists.
We need a reunion so badly. Radios haven’t been the same since they left
Agreed! their songs just had this fun beat to them straight from the get go, that already prepared my brain for "right this is gonna be awesome" if that makes sense hehe ;) some of the dolls i review on my channel actually remind me a bit of some of the members x #teamsatsforever
Vanessa all the way, her voice in the bridge of Ego is incredible!
I'm absolutely no expert, but my favourite voice from the group was always Una's. She's by no means the best singer out there, but I've always just liked her.
Vanessa’s and Una’s voice 🙌🏽
For me it was Vanessa but she lost her vocal range during the "on your radar" period,so now I see rochelle more of a lead in the later songs. I love frankie she adds a sparkle to the group.
It was hard to choose between Una and Rochelle, I think Una may edge it for me because of her tone, but completely agree with the rest of the list! Vanessa had some troubles, but when she was on it, she was one of the strongest vocalist of UK pop at that time
100% agree. I personally prefer una and was way more impressed with her
Interesting. Rochelle edges out Una for me because of her tone and control. I do love Una's rasp and edge, but her voice isn't as stylistically versatile as Rochelle's either.
@@AllGreyEverything the best? Nadine was the best
I feel it started out with 1.) Vanessa 2.) Una 3.) Rochelle and as time went on it became 1.) Vanessa 2.) Rochelle 3.) Una and then by the end it was 1.) Rochelle/Vanessa equally with Una next. Rochelle should've ended up going solo but she clearly never intended on doing music any longer. lol She became lead more frequently near the middle and end. Vanessa never left her 1 or 2 spot but sometimes I feel Rochelle shined more depending on the era. Una really edged out Rochelle at the very very beginning and first album.
I loved this group! It’s such a shame none of them have had a big solo career post-break up. They’re all good vocalists and definitely have that it factor
Rochelle had a big solo career post-break up, just not about music tho.. xd
In my opinion weakest to strongest is mollie, frankie, rochelle, una and then vanessa! Loved your vids though
100% agree!! No other way x
The Saturdays need to reform for a tour, they have a strong singles catalogue and seem to have a great spotify following so would probably do well.
I would love that to happen but I do not think it would xx
But be only una frankie & mollie as roch an ness stated they would never go back xx
For me it’s
5. Frankie
4. Mollie
3. Rochelle
2. Una
1. Vanessa
Lets be honest.
Una Rochelle and Vanessa do all the work.
They can work as trio
I really wish we could have another Saturdays album, I miss them so much. I agree with your line up of choices when it comes to strongest to weakest generally speaking. Although Frankie has a more beautiful higher register than Mollie as she's usually the one in the highest harmonies. Mollie does function well as Vanessa's support with her high harmonies as well. But you can see Frankie's strongest vocals have been on their song 'Faster' which the other girls have difficulty covering her parts due to how high they are. I think what also hampered Frankie in the past was her battle with depression. Overall my personal list has changed depending on the time period, initially it was Vanessa > Una / Rochelle > Mollie > Frankie and for their later albums you can see that the lead singer was switched from Vanessa to Rochelle. After a certain period Rochelle began carrying the hardest parts in the songs vocally and belting more as Vanessa's voice weened. The final vocal line-up for me is Rochelle > Vanessa/Una > Frankie=Mollie.
Vanessa's voice stands out. It's so strong 💓
Vanessa was defo the best, no question
I used to be OBSESSED with The Saturdays. I have all of my merch/etc. in my closet boxed up still 😂😂 Personally, I think Vanessa is the best because Vanessas voice is pretty much the sound/brand of the group. Her voice is so present/heavy in most choruses. Like a good 90% of their discography is Vanessa vocal heavy. If you took her voice out of the biggest Sats hits we know,, then they would not sound right. Example: Higher, Ego, My Heart Takes Over, Forever Is Over, Disco Love and so on.
Great ranking!!! I would put Frankie above Mollie ONLY because Ive heard more impressive notes from her in the bands time... I agree though Frankie is 100% the most pitchy, but she just nails some good ones here and there unlike Mollie that plays it safe. Agreed with Vanessa being #1
Do you think Frankie's voice changed as she got older? She was the lead female singer in S Club Juniors
100% agree with your picks. Anyone see Vanessa on a Opera show years back. She was incredible!
Singing ability wise, it’s completely agreed but Una has the most unique voice out of 5, and her solo album was so beautiful made😍
Frankie - She never really developed enough confidence to improve her vocals much over the Saturdays’ time unfortunately. I think the selling point of her voice is her vibrato, which is really satisfying when she’s able to use it. I think her and Una’s voices have the rocky edge. But sometimes it’s kind of obvious that she falls back on problematic technique. She could’ve used a lot more help developing her voice. A couple of songs which showcase her vocals best are Golden Rules and No One.
Mollie - Her voice reminds me of Kylie Minogue’s, she has that airy nasal sound. She was actually pretty consistent over the course of their career, she wasn’t a belting type or anything but she was able to hold her own. I think her head voice had pretty great potential and they could’ve explored that a lot more. Her problem mostly is that her pitching isn’t perfect and she can lose it when she struggles. Some of her best vocals are in Here Standing and No One.
Una - Una has great musicality which shines through in her voice, she seems best at improvising. Her solo music showcases a lot of her country, folky and rocky aspects. Her chest register is arguably the best in the group and she can connect it through her higher register with her distinctive rasp. Her problem is that her distinctive sound is achieved with sometimes strenuous technique, which can make her crack or pitchy. The end of All Fired Up shows her using her higher and lower registers really well.
Rochelle - I agree that she improved a lot. She shines a lot in acoustic performances, where she can showcase her dynamics without nerves. Her range was pretty impressive, she had a lot of grasp on different aspects of her voice, such as her chest voice, lower register and head voice, and she could perform pretty great runs too. Her problem was that she often used too much tension, particularly when growing from low to high, which could make her kind of sharp. Her vocals were arguably at their best in the Living For The Weekend era.
Vanessa - It’s like she went from being the best singer, to the problematic singer to be in the best singer again. Even though she’s known for her belting, I’d argue that she didn’t always use great technique to achieve the twangy sound, which is part of what blew her out during the On You Radar era. I thought her head voice and falsetto could’ve used more developing so she could fall back on that with more ease. Her vocals were at her best during the Chasing Lights and Wordshaker eras, and then she recovered a lot of her voice in the Greatest Hits Tour and developed a more solid technique.
My order would be
Chasing Lights/Wordshaker Era:
1 - Vanessa
2 - Una
3 - Rochelle
4 - Mollie/Frankie
Headlines Era
1 - Una
2 - Rochelle
3 - Vanessa
4 - Mollie
5 - Frankie
On Your Radar era
1 - Rochelle/Una
2 - Vanessa
3 - Mollie
4 - Frankie
Living For the Weekend Era
1 - Rochelle
2 - Una
3 - Vanessa
4 - Mollie
5 - Frankie
Greatest Hits era
1 - Vanessa
2 - Rochelle/Una
4 - Mollie
5 - Frankie
Love this !!
I always wondered why Frankie was the lead girl in S Club Juniors and then mainly just harmonies in The Saturdays has her voice not matured well?
I love seeing the RUclips award in the background! It’s so well deserved!
Loved this series on the sats! I think Rochelle has the strongest voice
3rd not as strong as Vanessa or Una, she improved alot around the All Fired Era though.
Una was in a rock band before the sats
I LOVE THEM ALL BECAUSE THEY WORK SO GREAT AS ONE. BUT VANESSA HAS ALWAYS BEEN MY FAVE NO MATTER WHAT
nadine coyle 🤝 vanessa white
We want the next episode to be about Fifth Harmony
Love the Saturdays and think you got them in the right order. Would you consider looking at some steps performances please?
Couldn't have been anyone but Vanessa, she was the Nadine of the group.
Agree
Vanessa is hands down the best singer in this group, consistently the best! Una is a close second followed by Rochelle the other 2..... meh
I’m SO disappointed this series has ended & I never got to hear you say how weirdly Mollie pronounces the word law in “Notorious” LOL
I'm a OUTLOR. Drives me nuts!
Yessss lol she always says Lawr
5. Frankie 4. Mollie 3. Una 2. Vanessa 1. Rochelle (tough choice between 1&2)
Georgina makes me happy
Vanessa - Theater
Rochelle - Ballad
Una - Rock
Mollie - Pop
Frankie - Pop
This series was so short, why there wasn't any solo videos ? :( Btw. my 3 favs are Mollie, Una and Vanessa.
Rochelle never tried it solo
5 - Frankie
4 - Molly
3 - Una
2 - Rochelle
1 - Vanessa
Hey, great vid! I love the sats, they were my favourite girlband of all time :) funnily enough i'd rank them voice wise in the same order x
Vanessa is my favourite and best
They really have good songs.
DEFINETLY ITS UNA!!!!! ❤️❤️❤️ she is the one that has more vocal range and have the best lower notes and highest
100% agree with the ranking. Exactly how I would rank them. Big love to the group though x
Don't think anyone could disagree with your opinion:
5-frankie...lacked vocal confidence which affected her ability and development potential....nice dresses...cute hair and the only one to be considered a dancer in the group.
4-molly...limited range but could carry a note to varying pitchy degrees in her 1.5 octave range. Pretty back up singer with much vocal limitations.
3-una ...most out of place better suited as a struggle soloist. Would be better behind the scenes...song writing etc. . she has artistical potential but lacks any real star substance to stand out further than molly or frankie.
2-rochelle...developed considerably the most...strongish voice...bigger range but lacks agility and dimensional tone.
1-vanessa...the most versatile...vocally competent but sometimes unreliable and generally inconsistent. The most vocally dynamic with the best tone on her better days.
That said... they're a mediocre group ...with some good songs and a diverse set of singers with very very varied vocal capabilities. At least their vocals and aesthetics was far better than their choreography. To be fair when they perform live they made more noise than what would be considered music.
Lol.....you are shady boots!!!
disagree with you on Una and Vanessa's vocals
Im dying ....
“they made more noise than what coupd be considered music”......oh dear!!!
😂
Great video, Georgina!
My opinion was 5.venessa as I felt she thought she was better then the whole band,4 Frankie as I liked the mellow tone of her voice and I liked her in s club juniors 3,Mollie ,2 Una 1, Rochelle
I think Frankie is above Mollie but she really suffers with anxiety and nerves
Great Video! Love The Saturdays Music Too! Vanessa & Rochelle Do Have The Best Voices For Sure! Take Care & Have An Awesome Week!
Vanessa is definitely the best vocalist. Rochelle is my favorite vocalist. My list would be
1 Vanessa
2 Rochelle
3 Una
4 Mollie
5 Frankie
After The Saturdays,do a reaction to The Sundays too
ha haaaaa!
Georgina replied to my comment about The Sundays..I really didn't expect it😃
I'm loving the focus more on the girl bands again. 👍👍. I've missed this. You can tell you love the girlbands side of things. Definitely a favourite 😁
Mollie’s voice kind of reminds me of Kylie Minogue a little.
I do agree... Vanessa is the mel c, Una is the Emma, Rochelle is a more better Mel B. The low tone... Mollie has the Victoria vocal. And Frankie the geri vocal. But that just vocally thinking
They all have songs that suit them more, Frankie during missing you would be 1st every day of the week. Love all 5 but it’s clear Una Rochelle and Vanessa were top 3, then Frankie and Mollie depending on the song, but still contributed plenty
Totally agree with your Top5.
But I love them all I seen all the 4 UK tours
For me its frankie mollie rochelle una and vanessa #1
No way did you say una voice is like sarah hardings you cant compare them una is on another level
Sarah harding is terrible. She cant sing for toffee
@@2007aleasha oh stfu. Una doesn't have the range of sarah
I've never heard of this group, this is interesting
lol same, I'm just watching the video
I’m obsessed with Mollie’s part when she’s singing ego. Does anyone have the full clip from that performance?
My honest opinion you rushed reviewing the saturdays you never done best individual vocals like how you did with little mix
There’s not many videos on each of the girls
I would but una 1st but with power Vanessa has the stronger vocal but in tune I feel una keep in tune more
I think Vanessa had confidence issues during her time with the Sats but, in my opinion, she is truly a top notch vocalist. Definitely one of the best (if not the best) vocalists from any UK girl group. She lacked consistency during live performances, but her overall vocal abilities surpass the majority by a long shot.
Absolutely love your videos, their so respectful of the artists and their voices, you give really good constructive criticism, I would love for you to react to the band Haim, especially show me love and hallelujah in the live lounge at BBC, ❤❤
I would honestly love to hear you sing a girl group song. Layer your voice for all of their vocals.
This is very nearly Flo Rida order! Just need to switch Vanessa and Rochelle there.
Kinda wish you went more in depth with this series had more potential on this. I hope you do Enteral
Yeeeees ❤️ Vanessa & Rochelle 😍😍
I loved this series. Thanks once more Georgina. Who’s next? 😁
It’s strange as it’s Vanessa who has done a total step back,
Girls aloud and the Saturdays were similar in ways it why they didnt out beat them. Sugababes and Girl's Aloud ruled the charts in this era really with input from Atomic Kitten too. The Saturdays were good talent though with some great songs.. Gentlemen era was like what are you doing.. terrible stuff. Stick to the good pop ffs
I think The Saturdays have better harmonies than Girls Aloud, as a whole group their voices blend really nice. They had bad promotion and management thats maybe why they didnt went far. I love The Saturdays
@@18mestar Individual voices girls aloud beat them in every single way. Harmony yes i agree GA don't fit in too well because of Nicola and cheryl. Girls aloud are overall more likeable and their songs are really amazing unlike Saturdays(meh they've no great songs)
dno why but i rlly like unas voice, might just be because i fancy her tho
Vanessa White !!!
Molly and Frankie sound amess live
Is GRL next i hope they are
Can you do the same with fifth harmony ?
Where is the Ego clip from?
Impulse gig
Do it to girls aloud too please
Una voice for me
Una is definitely better than Rochelle..she provides the other adlibs and high notes aside from Vanessa
Im disappointed you could of covered alot more videos of there live performances
Yeah I was am disappointed too
I completely understand why Vanessa was the 1st but to say the likes of Frankie isn't a lead singer....she was actually the lead singer in S Club Juniors. All the girls are very much loved. It's people like you that make people feel rubbish about themselves
Will Fifth Harmony be the next girl group? 🥺🖤
oh yesssss
Honest Vocal Coach yay!!!! I’m so exited !!!
The Saturdays wouldn't even be a vocal group if not for Vanessa. Lol. Let's be serious.
Vanessas voice is annoying to me. I like the group but they for me never really took off.
This group was amazing!!! But I disagree between Una, Vanessa and Rochelle. The powerful voice (IN STUDIO) 'cause in live she sound soooo out of breath and never reach the high note like the record sound is Vanessa, she is good singer but not the great one. To me she desirve #3 then Una #2 'cause she have this unique sound and raspy tone that is sooooo Una and Rochelle #1 'cause she have more control with her voice and have a powerful voice record sound and performances. They are great group but sometimes people blind themself for voices that are fix in studio but the reality is when we watching performances live they are totally disaster.
They're chronic
Mariah Carey is the greatest singer of all time
That's why she's not a girl band member. It's an episode about The Saturdays, so go and spam elsewhere, doll xd