First of all, let's think about it: It's not easy to sing while walking, imagine dancing They didn't spend years training to debut like other kpop groups, they debuted quickly They improved, especially Gabi
All of this. It’s gonna be a while, but they’ll be a lot better so long as their label invests the time and training into them. We know that they can sing because we’ve heard them when many other times when they didn’t have to move and dance. Plus, they’ve only JUST started actually performing this song a few weeks ago unlike “Karma”.
Also, most of the idols lip-sync all the time. These girls are really brave for singing live as always as they can. This is one of the things that are making them improve so quickly.
It's really hard to sing a song like this and dance at the same time. Gabi and Fatou did so well and I'm pretty sure Nvee and Sryia will do better in the future. They are all very talented, just need to improve their stability.
For me is: First off all: Fatou (she has bit lines, but always stable) Gabi (she has a good breath control and clear Voice) Nvee (she has a little problem with breath control, and some parts she doesn't sings) Shyria (she needs to improve, her has the same Nvee problem ) In the general, them are good, is really hard to sing and dance at the same time, them are fighting to get better.
It's crazy because you can tell they are all really good singers. They really just need to practice singing live. It doesn't help that the song is so high and wispy.
NVee and Shriya always have the highest and hardest parts in the songs and Blackswan choreo is generally fast but atleast they're singing. Other groups are just silent.
This is false. Most of the song is sang within the same vocal range of notes for all members accept a few notes that only Gabi and Nvee have. Sriya doesn't have any difficult notes. She just isn't focused on vocals but more dance focused. There is a reason she is Main dancer and doesn't have a singing position officially. The same with fatou, she is very rounded but she focuses her energy on rapping because she is the Main Rapper. Nvee is probably the only one who truly struggles in her position because she isn't used to having to sing and dance. As she gets more comfortable she will become more stable.
@@avantiprajan3472 being the youngest is not a group positions. It's a title based on age nothing more. Sriya is not the Lead vocalist on ANY official DR websites or platforms. She is listed as one on a kpop blog channel that most kpop fans refer to when talking about group positions however the blog owner literally has a disclaimer stating many group positions are based off what fans have said, or and personal opinions based on line distribution or solo activities. The Only Official positions stated by DR Entertainment and Blackswan Members are Fatou: Leader and Main Rapper Nvee: Main Vocalist Gabi: Visual Sriya: Main Vocalist and youngest There is no Lead vocalist and there is no Lead Dancer. These are not group positions that have to exist and currently don't exist within blackswan. And if one was given is certainly wouldn't go to sriya as she is probably thr least vocally developed member in blackswan. Of course that's not bad considering all the girls are decent but it just goes to shoe many fans are delusional and want to just pass around group positions for nearly no reason. Besides Main dancers Rarely Ever Hold A Lead vocalist position or even a Main vocalist position because they have to put all their energy and effort into dancing it would be unfair to them to expect them to be a Lead Vocalist and a Main Dancer even if they could be one. Because honestly fatou, Sriya, and Gabi could be a Lead Voclaist but basing it off vocal abilities amongst the memebr sriya is very lacking in vocal ability in comparison
A Fatou tem um vocal tão estável, desde o debut ela sempre teve o vocal mais estável entre as membros. E é claro, as outras meninas também fizeram um excelente trabalho.
Sim, ela canta muito bem sendo que ela tem um problema muito grande com o fôlego, ela não consegue cantar dançando, toda vez q ela vai cantar uma parte que exige muito vocal como em karma, quando elas foram no theshow lá pro final da música na ponte é perceptível que ela puxou muito ar pra conseguir fazer do high note
@@miyfleur6700 é verdade, eu ainda acho que a empresa só quer usar a voz dela… até no preparo não deram nem tempo direito dela aprender pelo menos um coreano melhor, e já estava sendo divulgada como nova integrante.
The actual problem is the chorus and most of the song having them sing in their head voice which makes it harder to sing steadily while moving a lot. The key of the song isn’t the problem because none of them are straining.
Nvee's my bias (Gabi is my bias wrecker). Nvee's a great singer, but she's definitely more of a ballad type, and so having to sing and dance simultaneously is new territory for her. She hasn't been active for long, though, so I'm sure she'll improve as she continues to work with BLACKSWAN.
i was worried about this song because its so high and the entire chorus is in falsetto which is SUUPER hard to sing in whilst dancing like they are. i think even this much is impressive and they're only going to improve more! blackswan fighting
Everyone did great because it is easy to comment but really hard to sing and dance together.. We luminas always going to support Blackswan 🖤🖤💖💖. They are working really hard to improve themselves.i have believe on them and i am always going to support them 💗🌸
I love this song, but this song is hard to sing IMO . Even in the song recording, I find that they seem to struggle with it. Much harder than karma due to constant high pitch . almost no one is ever singing in their actual range Im proud to see them singing live despite the difficulties. i do hope they improve
The actual problem is the chorus and most of the song having them sing in their head voice which makes it harder to sing steadily while moving a lot. The key of the song isn’t the problem because none of them are straining.
Cara, sou brasileiro e torço muito por todas e claro, dou ênfase a Gabi e nesse vídeo, pode se dizer que ela foi a melhor em dançar e cantar ao mesmo tempo mas, não se engane, a Nnve canta muito, ela já cantou em lives músicas muito difíceis sem nenhuma masterizaçao e perfeitamente, ela é afinada, tem boa projeção, dicção e sustentação e realmente, pode ser que dançar e cantar ao mesmo tempo, seja muito difícil e isso também, acontece porque praticamente nunca, os coreógrafos de K-Pop levam em consideração a melhor postura para se cantar desde que fique bonita . esse é também, o motivo pelo qual, os idols em geral usam playback com inclusive a voz principal e um sistema que quando elas cantam, o volume do playback baixa e quando apenas dublam, ele se destaca.
All of them did so well The only thing here is that Nvee and Sriya seems more bised towards dance. It happens because dancing with singing itself is a very huge challenge though.
Remember that being unstable while dancing doesnt make you a bad singer its normal to not be stable while dancing bc its almost impossible to be stable you can improve your voice but you will never be fully stable
It’s difficult to sing live with all tht choreo as a newbie they are doing a good job , not to forget to give it all in their dancing but they sure need a hella important in terms of breath control ! They need a lot of practice not to just sing but also sound good !
Gabi and fatou are the only ones that are actually singing the others barely sing and if so sing half the phrases, but theyre doing great i luv ma gurls ❤
![[CLEAN MR REMOVED] BLACKSWAN (블랙스완) - Roll Up | Mnet Mcountdown 240808 MR제거](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/hfFX2EchQpo/mqdefault.jpg)
![[안방1열 직캠4K] 블랙스완 가비 'Cat & Mouse' (BLACKSWAN GABI FanCam) @SBS Inkigayo 230917](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/gV40cQavgz4/mqdefault.jpg)
![[MR Removedㅣ엠알 제거] BLACKSWAN (블랙스완) - Karma (카르마) MR제거 230525](/img/1.gif)
First of all, let's think about it:
It's not easy to sing while walking, imagine dancing
They didn't spend years training to debut like other kpop groups, they debuted quickly
They improved, especially Gabi
All of this. It’s gonna be a while, but they’ll be a lot better so long as their label invests the time and training into them. We know that they can sing because we’ve heard them when many other times when they didn’t have to move and dance. Plus, they’ve only JUST started actually performing this song a few weeks ago unlike “Karma”.
Lol I can do it tho😎
Also, most of the idols lip-sync all the time. These girls are really brave for singing live as always as they can. This is one of the things that are making them improve so quickly.
@@brinocaldas yup!!!!
@@brinocaldas뭔소리 하냐 여기 전부 라이브 mr제거 버전인데 라이브가 아닌부분은 소리가 안나오는데 좋아하는가수 실드 칠려고 거짓말을 하면 안되지
Gabi sounds so good 😮
I know, right?😍
진짜 춤추면서 노래 부르기 힘들텐데 대단해요..
전 한국인이지만 한국 아이돌 덕질 안하는데 블랙스완은 뮤비랑 공연 챙겨봅니다.
Lots of love from luminas
a gabi é a mais estável
It's really hard to sing a song like this and dance at the same time. Gabi and Fatou did so well and I'm pretty sure Nvee and Sryia will do better in the future. They are all very talented, just need to improve their stability.
@@Eam07-xx6ggIts not because of that Fatou is always stable every time she performs same goes for Gabi most of the time she's stable.
For me is:
First off all:
Fatou (she has bit lines, but always stable)
Gabi (she has a good breath control and clear Voice)
Nvee (she has a little problem with breath control, and some parts she doesn't sings)
Shyria (she needs to improve, her has the same Nvee problem )
In the general, them are good, is really hard to sing and dance at the same time, them are fighting to get better.
They probably didn't have the same training time as other kpop groups, they debuted quickly
파투와 가비의 보컬이 안정적이네요~
@@BeccaMoranguinho Of course, them didn't, it is something can be improved.
It's crazy because you can tell they are all really good singers. They really just need to practice singing live. It doesn't help that the song is so high and wispy.
Yeah breath control. Nvee and sriya have a problem with that. I hope the company sees the problem and train them more
gabi and fatou ate
I like how RUclips translated this to "night and fatou sister!"
They ate and left no crumbs ❤
Gabi sang amazingly ❤
Fatou and Gabi here 💖
신나고경쾌한음아과안무감사합니다
Gabi is so amazing 🤩
NVee and Shriya always have the highest and hardest parts in the songs and Blackswan choreo is generally fast but atleast they're singing. Other groups are just silent.
And both of them sing so bad LMAO
This is false. Most of the song is sang within the same vocal range of notes for all members accept a few notes that only Gabi and Nvee have. Sriya doesn't have any difficult notes. She just isn't focused on vocals but more dance focused. There is a reason she is Main dancer and doesn't have a singing position officially. The same with fatou, she is very rounded but she focuses her energy on rapping because she is the Main Rapper. Nvee is probably the only one who truly struggles in her position because she isn't used to having to sing and dance. As she gets more comfortable she will become more stable.
@@avantiprajan3472 being the youngest is not a group positions. It's a title based on age nothing more. Sriya is not the Lead vocalist on ANY official DR websites or platforms. She is listed as one on a kpop blog channel that most kpop fans refer to when talking about group positions however the blog owner literally has a disclaimer stating many group positions are based off what fans have said, or and personal opinions based on line distribution or solo activities. The Only Official positions stated by DR Entertainment and Blackswan Members are
Fatou: Leader and Main Rapper
Nvee: Main Vocalist
Gabi: Visual
Sriya: Main Vocalist and youngest
There is no Lead vocalist and there is no Lead Dancer. These are not group positions that have to exist and currently don't exist within blackswan. And if one was given is certainly wouldn't go to sriya as she is probably thr least vocally developed member in blackswan. Of course that's not bad considering all the girls are decent but it just goes to shoe many fans are delusional and want to just pass around group positions for nearly no reason. Besides Main dancers Rarely Ever Hold A Lead vocalist position or even a Main vocalist position because they have to put all their energy and effort into dancing it would be unfair to them to expect them to be a Lead Vocalist and a Main Dancer even if they could be one. Because honestly fatou, Sriya, and Gabi could be a Lead Voclaist but basing it off vocal abilities amongst the memebr sriya is very lacking in vocal ability in comparison
@@Clearskies3848 and Nvee has asthma, so she finds it especially difficult because it's her first time dancing and singing at the same time.
This one is really Gabi's era
Gabi is my fav.
A Fatou tem um vocal tão estável, desde o debut ela sempre teve o vocal mais estável entre as membros.
E é claro, as outras meninas também fizeram um excelente trabalho.
Fatu did great!!!
Gabi did great
Nvee 😆😆😭😭 it's okay, we know it's tough to sing while dancing
Gabi foi a melhor
E justamente a vocalista do grupo é a q tá tendo mais dificuldade
Ela é minha favorita tbm
@@L_lazzaro_smas as partes dela são muito mais difíceis
@@Cheron88 a música é bem divididinha, e ela é a VOCALISTA ter uma boa estabilidade é oq se espera dela, entende?
@@L_lazzaro_sshe’s a rookie give her time. she’s a talented singer but dancing while singing is crazy hard!!
Omg Gabi did it like it was nothing to her lololol my princess😍
Yessss❤
Uh... Fatou can sing like that and we only get rapping usually?
well leave the other girls something would you xD
She has such a strong tone, I wanna hear her more too
Fatou did great
A nvee sofre bastante com fôlego, enquanto a Gabi melhorou bastante desde o debut
Sim, ela canta muito bem sendo que ela tem um problema muito grande com o fôlego, ela não consegue cantar dançando, toda vez q ela vai cantar uma parte que exige muito vocal como em karma, quando elas foram no theshow lá pro final da música na ponte é perceptível que ela puxou muito ar pra conseguir fazer do high note
@@miyfleur6700 é verdade, eu ainda acho que a empresa só quer usar a voz dela… até no preparo não deram nem tempo direito dela aprender pelo menos um coreano melhor, e já estava sendo divulgada como nova integrante.
A Nvee dá a vida dela dançando, é normal ficar sem fôlego. Nós, reles mortais, mal conseguimos falar se movimentando assim, imagina cantar afinado.
Damn this song is so high my girls vocal cords must be STRUGGLING😭
The actual problem is the chorus and most of the song having them sing in their head voice which makes it harder to sing steadily while moving a lot. The key of the song isn’t the problem because none of them are straining.
@@asxtro7145 ahhhh I get what you're saying, either way these girls need a medal for having to promote this song live😭
@@asxtro7145 The chorus is all falsetto , and the dance part during chorus is also very hard .
Beautiful lady 🔥💜
only gabi sung this well tbh
um no fatou and nvee sang well too
acting like fatou didn't eat bye
0:18 fatou ate her part up
Gabi queen of vocals and visuals, os vocais da Gabi e fatou estão tão estáveis em todas as suas apresentações amooo e tudo pra mim 😮
파투 안정적이다 ㅋㅋ
They get better every day! One of the best formations in the group! Gabi especially has grown A LOT
Nvee's my bias (Gabi is my bias wrecker). Nvee's a great singer, but she's definitely more of a ballad type, and so having to sing and dance simultaneously is new territory for her. She hasn't been active for long, though, so I'm sure she'll improve as she continues to work with BLACKSWAN.
its ok Nvee, u can improve , also Sriya, Fatou and Gabi ate
Fatou and Gabi were not hungry because they ate 🤭
Nvee sings so well when she's not dancing, she just needs to practice that. And her part of the chorus is not easy to sing
파투랑 가비가 보면볼수록 진국~~
Love you Blackswan 😘
i was worried about this song because its so high and the entire chorus is in falsetto which is SUUPER hard to sing in whilst dancing like they are. i think even this much is impressive and they're only going to improve more! blackswan fighting
Fatou best ❤
Everyone did great because it is easy to comment but really hard to sing and dance together..
We luminas always going to support Blackswan 🖤🖤💖💖.
They are working really hard to improve themselves.i have believe on them and i am always going to support them 💗🌸
Fatou sounds good for a rapper to rap, sing n dance at the same time ❤
Omg I got tired just from listening and doing the dance in my head 😅❤
Blackswan fighting ❤
I'm surprised they can do something so difficult even with such a short training period
I love this song, but this song is hard to sing IMO . Even in the song recording, I find that they seem to struggle with it. Much harder than karma due to constant high pitch . almost no one is ever singing in their actual range
Im proud to see them singing live despite the difficulties. i do hope they improve
yeah especially sriya and fatou who sing in lower registers
The actual problem is the chorus and most of the song having them sing in their head voice which makes it harder to sing steadily while moving a lot. The key of the song isn’t the problem because none of them are straining.
Cara, sou brasileiro e torço muito por todas e claro, dou ênfase a Gabi e nesse vídeo, pode se dizer que ela foi a melhor em dançar e cantar ao mesmo tempo mas, não se engane, a Nnve canta muito, ela já cantou em lives músicas muito difíceis sem nenhuma masterizaçao e perfeitamente, ela é afinada, tem boa projeção, dicção e sustentação e realmente, pode ser que dançar e cantar ao mesmo tempo, seja muito difícil e isso também, acontece porque praticamente nunca, os coreógrafos de K-Pop levam em consideração a melhor postura para se cantar desde que fique bonita . esse é também, o motivo pelo qual, os idols em geral usam playback com inclusive a voz principal e um sistema que quando elas cantam, o volume do playback baixa e quando apenas dublam, ele se destaca.
I think they sound amazing, some other groups have years and years of training and dont sound like that
Gabi is the most stable 🎉!
I mean I gotta give it to them for actually singing live.Something half of the 4th gen doesnt do.
They sound good
They'll improve cuz they get no rest and they keep on practicing so they'll improve
All of them did so well
The only thing here is that Nvee and Sriya seems more bised towards dance.
It happens because dancing with singing itself is a very huge challenge though.
파투 잘한다❤
Remember that being unstable while dancing doesnt make you a bad singer its normal to not be stable while dancing bc its almost impossible to be stable you can improve your voice but you will never be fully stable
É muito difícil cantar e dancar ao msm tempo, entao é completamente normal ter esses falhas
Quando elas cantam paradas elas dão um arraso
E tambem elas tao começando nao é como se fossem profissionais e quando editam pra remover a musica no fundo nao fica perfeito
1:37-1:41 Gabi sounds so similar to Jisoo 😍
Verdade 😮
1:02 so good
Es muy difícil cantar y bailar a la vez estoy segura de que mejorarán 😊
Even if they sang while dancing far better then many because many whould not even complete their song
It’s difficult to sing live with all tht choreo as a newbie they are doing a good job , not to forget to give it all in their dancing but they sure need a hella important in terms of breath control ! They need a lot of practice not to just sing but also sound good !
No big deal here. That's why playback is used, it's impossible to sing well if you are walking, running, moving or in this case, dancing. 😊😊
First
Gabi and fatou are the only ones that are actually singing the others barely sing and if so sing half the phrases, but theyre doing great i luv ma gurls ❤
❤
Fatou is the best live singer in this group, but idk why she didnt sing her line at 2:10 at all 😂😂
😲
Fatou is that bish !!!!!! That's on period its the stability for me !!!!
But in the seoul waterbomb event they sing😮?
Jajajajajaja 😂
Fatou can do no rong
😂😂😂😂
?
❤
❤
❤