The most major adjustable wrench manufacturer in Japan It's "Lobtex". Makita is a power tool manufacturer, not a hand tool manufacturer. I wanted you to go with "Lobtex" if you want to compare
Sadly they are not the same superb quality as when they were made in Enköping Sweden...... Its the same with their screwdrivers.......i guess the Special steel made by Sandvik was to expensive for Snap-On that owns the brand Bahco nowadays. 🥺
Where are you getting 783 for Taiwan? I know YOU put on the screen that it was 783, but the reader clearly said 683. How was the same mistake made twice?
Copy and paste. But it doesn't really defy the verdict, it's less than half of the price but as good or better than the German/Japanese ones. And also the American ones are overpriced and slightly worse
In the Netherlands is this tool commonly known as a “Bahco”, named after the most used brand here. I’m a bit surprized that this particular brand wasn’t part of your testpanel?
Doesn't really matter which wrench you have, you'll never be able to spread the jaws applying force by hand. It's only when you start using bits of pipe or a hammer on them that you'll notice any difference, which is not what they are designed for anyway!
I broke 3 wrenches in my 80 years and I am by no means strong. One - the little pusher- turner broke and fell out. Two - the upper part of the jaw broke off and Three - the handle broke off straight after the roller. Two were Japanese and the last one was German (Hazet)
The lobster is considered a "light weight wrench", maybe the KTC. 🤷 Also it's kinda sad that only sk and milwuakee still make adjustable wrenches in the usa. 🥲
Doesn't Crescent still exist? When I worked they were ubiquitous and I assumed they were the original. We just called that type of wrench a Crescent wrench. It is sad that these venerable brands are just that now - brands. 15 pieces of crap pressed out in China and mounted on a piece of cardboard to sell for $20.@@nocturnal0072
I couldn't watch as the adjustable wrenches were mounted upside down! Force needs to be applied whilst pushing the load instead of pulling the load which easily damages the adjustment mechanism. You should repeat the test using the wrenches with the correct side up!
senseless destruction, each of these tools could serve for 50 years ! I have a 70-year-old wrench that was used by my grandfather and is still in use ...
An interesting video but. let's be honest, you couldn't apply hundreds of kilos of force to an adjustable wrench in any practical application, so they were all easily strong enough. Usually, the biggest problem with these wrenches is getting them in to the available space.
How about situation where you have to use an extension, like a 1 meter tube? Personally I’ve never trust an adjustable wrench to be strong enough for this, anyway, there is too much « flex » in the mechanism to ensure a good grip
@@sebcam9498 Never underestimate the (brain) power of your average worker. You can fix a chain on the wrench and pull it with a stock wind that lifts several tonnes.
@@Enzo661100 That is what Taiwan do best, but Taiwan also has wide variety of industries. I used to know that we export lots of hand tools, but I always thought that is because of the value is good. Not aware that the quality is also pretty good.
I have a 10 ton hydraulic press at home. I was planning to do the same test but when I saw the warning in the beginning of the video, I changed my mind.
NO CONOZCO A NINGUN HUMANO QUE PUEDA PRESIONAR A MAS DE 50 KG, ENTONES CON ESA REGLA TODAS ESTAS HERRAMIENTAS MANUALES Y PARA EL HOGAR ESTAN PERFECTAS !!!😊😊😊
The test presses on the middle of the handle. That means you can break it by roughly half the force pressing at the end side, which 125 kg is not that hard to exceed.
@@jyunnheikusada7003 You ain’t putting 125kg on the tip of the handle, without risking injury. And who is going to use a wrench on a nut with that sort of torque?
Az öreg német jó konstrukció. A fix, és a menetes köracél közé kellene hegeszteni mégegy összekötő erősítést, és akkor nem tudná elhajlítani. Szerintem jó anyagból talán az lehetne a leg erősebb! Majd a kínaiak megcsinálják 10$-ért. :-D
This test is not feasible. There is a difference between the strength of the metal and its hardness. It is not a known criterion. The more the hardness of the metal is subjected to fracture more than the ductile metal.
if most of your garage work only needs no more than 200kg torque and all these wrenches meet that spec, then which one you will most likely buy, the 5$ or 45$ ?
broke 3 wrenches in my 80 years and I am by no means strong. One - the little pusher turner broke and fell out. Two - the upper part of the jaw broke off and Three - the handle broke off straight after the roller. Two were Japanese and the last one was German (Hazet)
Bonjour, très instructif comme expérience mais normalement ce type de clé s'utilise dans l'autre sens, la force doit s'exercer le plus près de l'articulation pour diminuer le bras de levier
I’d like to see Crescent, Proto, Craftsmen, Bahco, Snap on, and Armstrong adjustable wrenches tested as well….I’ve got Wright, Channelock, Mac and others, but they last because I take care of the tools. Thanks for the test.
I remember i had a half inch stainless steel plug stuck in the instrument holder because somebody did not use teflon tape. In the workshop nobody could get it out with a wrench like this. I put a foot up and pulled with all my weight and 120kg of myself and with a screeech it started moving. hehe. Became hot too.
I would like to see Urrea from México 🇲🇽 among the adjustable wrenches tested here, I know that not only would it is a worthy competitor but it could very well win.
DEFINITIVAMENTE ESAS COMPANIAS DEVERIAN DE PAGARTE POR ESTAS PRUEVAS QUE HAS HECHO, AHORA SABEN CUAL HERRAMIENTA ESCOGER PARA CUALQUIER TRABAJO FELICIDADES POR ESTO.
No hay una comparación en esta prueba, ya que prueba una herramienta de 5 de Rusia contra una de 45 de Estados Unidos, eso genera una idea falsa de que lo de Estados Unidos es mejor que lo ruso, pero el precio dice otra cosa.
私は日本人で、バスの整備をしています。一時期新興国の安い工具を使っていましたが、高い負荷を掛けるため、すぐに壊れてしまい、安物買いの銭失いになってしまいました😭そんな中台湾の工具だけが生き残っています👍お値段以上の物ありがとうございますm(_ _)m工具作りは、人柄、国柄を表しているかも知れません‼️良い工具を作れる国は、良い物も作れます👍
最近は台湾のSK11などもかなりいいですよね。しかし、この動画でのマキタは無いわｗ
どう考えてもTOP工業持って来るべき。しかし、あれは軽量もすごい考えられてるけどね。フジヤかなぁ。
謝謝你們的肯定👍KAWASAKI NO.1
The most major adjustable wrench manufacturer in Japan
It's "Lobtex".
Makita is a power tool manufacturer, not a hand tool manufacturer.
I wanted you to go with "Lobtex" if you want to compare
I am from Germany and never hear here from Gross Tools???
The most famous here is Hazet.
Gross Tools is here a *NO NAME BRAND*
lobtex and TOP KOGYO
Lobster wrenches are amazing.
@@NudelAug WERA, GEDORE, WIHA, ... die Liste ist lang
@@NudelAug ドイツ製品でも同じような感じですねｗ日本製もマキタは有名ではないｗ
Bacho wrenches are by far the best. I’ve got a Bacho wrench I was given as an apprentice over 45 years ago and it still does the job.
Sadly they are not the same superb quality as when they were made in Enköping Sweden...... Its the same with their screwdrivers.......i guess the Special steel made by Sandvik was to expensive for Snap-On that owns the brand Bahco nowadays. 🥺
Yes old Bahco is very good
That old German wrench was too cool to crush
He should have given it to someone who can restorate it.
nothing is too cool to crush 😀
Thought same
filthy wef wrench good riddance.
4:53
The device panel tells 682kg but red color number is 783!
Its not a mistake?
Yes
I recommend leaving relic tools out of it.
We all groaned when the ancient wrench was crushed. But it will hopefully be preserved as visual digital science now.
Thank you for not trying to include "climate change" in your videos. I love your channel...its cathartic . 🙂
Where are you getting 783 for Taiwan? I know YOU put on the screen that it was 783, but the reader clearly said 683. How was the same mistake made twice?
They make a lot of mistakes
Copy and paste. But it doesn't really defy the verdict, it's less than half of the price but as good or better than the German/Japanese ones. And also the American ones are overpriced and slightly worse
The Taiwanese still NO.1. No doubt.
omg...I'm Japanese but it's first time to see Makita wrench. Nobody know Makita makes and sales hand tools in Japan🤣🤣🤣🤣
ほんまに、マキタの凄みは電動工具なのにな
Lol . I'm from Ukraine l, and i see in stores "makita" tools, like a drill, from $20😂😂😂
マキタがレンチ作ってるの知らなかった。
@@SarenArterius1987
ドリルではなく、レンチの話をしているのではないでしょうか？
I agree 😂
Makita wrenches are made by SATA tools, not sold in Japan.
モンキーならTOPかフジヤだろって話。
The old German key could have been cleaned, as a historical memory
Nie niszczyć.
it is. the filthy wef wrench was solved.
you don't apply the force at the same points, so some of the mechanisms are subjected to higher loads
The wrenches are all ergonomically different, it's inevitable to have variance in load distribution.
No german quality anymore 😞
@@sskingdom7181
Ehhez az USA igencsak hozzájárult.
Germany has been one of the most important and the oldest poles of industries in the world...
Salut to Germany from Iran 🙏 ❤️ 🌹
Definitely given me a newfound respect for crescent wrenches from now on. Thank you for doing this
三日月レンチって何か知らないが、jpの一般的にはモンキーレンチだが、
サイズの違うののを捕獲する意味は何だろうか。
モンキーレンチのサイズは長さで表されるが、サイズがバラバラだ。 10:08
China 50,2 kg/$
Russia 42,83 kg/$
Taiwan 31,32 kg/$
Poland 31,07 kg/$
Japan 30,1 kg/$
Germany 17,08 kg/$
USA 13,76 kg/$
All of them are made in China😂
Not really fair...2 $ vs 45 $
But please don't destroy Things like the Wrench from 1885😢
Yes
Very good
Yes, there is no contest for metallurgy processing of today
まさに。投稿者は工具愛が無い。
这个视频当然无耻，拿婴儿车与顶级跑车来比赛公路赛跑。
I wanna see a hydraulic press in a hydraulic press next 😊
In the Netherlands is this tool commonly known as a “Bahco”, named after the most used brand here. I’m a bit surprized that this particular brand wasn’t part of your testpanel?
It was actually the founder of Bacho who invented the adjustable wrench as we know it some 130 years ago.
Szacunek za dodanie polskiego produktu:)
Gdzie Ty tu widzisz Polski produkt?
10:06
"Högert" - faktycznie, staropolska nazwa
prawie mieszko pierwszy tylko troche skosny@@patrykg3120
😂😂😂😂😂
Next up, ancient Roman carriage axle wrench.
Doesn't really matter which wrench you have, you'll never be able to spread the jaws applying force by hand. It's only when you start using bits of pipe or a hammer on them that you'll notice any difference, which is not what they are designed for anyway!
I broke 3 wrenches in my 80 years and I am by no means strong. One - the little pusher- turner broke and fell out. Two - the upper part of the jaw broke off and Three - the handle broke off straight after the roller. Two were Japanese and the last one was German (Hazet)
Fiyat performans olarak
Taiwan force. En doğru seçim
It is strange that the Japanese representative is Makita. A monkey wrench would be either Lobster or KTC.
The lobster is considered a "light weight wrench", maybe the KTC. 🤷 Also it's kinda sad that only sk and milwuakee still make adjustable wrenches in the usa. 🥲
TOP工業は絶対に忘れてはいけない。おそらく日本製最高のモンキーレンチ。しかし最近では軽量化が盛んなので、この動画では妥当ではないかも。
Doesn't Crescent still exist? When I worked they were ubiquitous and I assumed they were the original. We just called that type of wrench a Crescent wrench. It is sad that these venerable brands are just that now - brands. 15 pieces of crap pressed out in China and mounted on a piece of cardboard to sell for $20.@@nocturnal0072
Also interesting that the Russian tool failed miserably, but at least tried to kill the tester.
Taiwan Force is absolutely top, i have it in work and its very good tools for good prices
I'm really amazed at how much the tools can withstand. Especially the cheap ones. But what always amazes me most is Taiwan.
Most is coming from the east. Is the German backo maibe a Taiwan import backo?
Mâlesef Taiwan malı ürünün değerini yanlış girmişler 100 puan fazla
@@fatihkubilay17 very helpful that the typical turkish egotrip is visible here
During my 80 years of life I found Taiwanese tools excellent, that coming from a German 😄😄
I don't see where the Taiwan got 783.
It didn’t: it tied with Germany. The 783 is a typo.
4:50
683
683* typo I guess
I think he wrote it by mistake, he was supposed to write 683 instead of 783
04:53 & 10:07 TAIWAN 783 ?，Should be 683,
But I am very proud to see products from my own country that can perform like this, and the price is right
Shut up and take my money!
Indeed, it is 683!
Canadian here... Seen some old tools in my time - but none as old-world cool as that 1883 job. Lot of twisted memory in that old iron. Respect eh
Taiwan didn't do 783... It did 683
Just why destroy the German wrench? It was so cool
Hello everyone, I am Taiwanese. Taiwan and Thailand are not the same country. Thank you.
I couldn't watch as the adjustable wrenches were mounted upside down! Force needs to be applied whilst pushing the load instead of pulling the load which easily damages the adjustment mechanism. You should repeat the test using the wrenches with the correct side up!
That's true 👍 Glad someone noticed that fact 👏
Super cool 😎 ❤I love your video 📹
工具をある程度、触ってきた日本人としては、台湾製品が思った以上に頑丈で、しかも安くて素晴らしかった👍
日台友好
I’m Japanese.
I’ve never seen a Makita wrench.
For some reason,it is not sold in Japan.
ちょっと調べただけだけど販売されてはいるみたい でもあんまり出回ってないのかな？って感じだった
@@SnowButter 並行輸入品かと思われます。
正規に国内向けとしては販売されてはいないようです。
Why ?
senseless destruction, each of these tools could serve for 50 years ! I have a 70-year-old wrench that was used by my grandfather and is still in use ...
Russia and China seem to be keeping the traditions of the 1800s
An interesting video but. let's be honest, you couldn't apply hundreds of kilos of force to an adjustable wrench in any practical application, so they were all easily strong enough. Usually, the biggest problem with these wrenches is getting them in to the available space.
How about situation where you have to use an extension, like a 1 meter tube? Personally I’ve never trust an adjustable wrench to be strong enough for this, anyway, there is too much « flex » in the mechanism to ensure a good grip
@@sebcam9498 Never underestimate the (brain) power of your average worker.
You can fix a chain on the wrench and pull it with a stock wind that lifts several tonnes.
使用鐵管加力或其他，瞬間斷掉或變形鬆脫，很危險的，測試其實有參考加值！
it hurts me when you destruct old tools that belong on a museum :-(
10:15 thoughts and prayers for those that fought and battled hard to the very end. We salute you
that belongs to a museum!
There is a brand called Izeltaş in Turkey. It is the most prominent brand in Turkey. Please include that brand in your tests.
Not correct teste, distans from centre to pressing place is different. Must be same.
Don't think my hands are gonna torque a bolt at 1300 lbs. with a wrench anytime soon. 😖
Al final de tus videos ,deberías poner una lista y así más fácil saber cuál es el resultado, cuál fue mejor.
By Taiwan force the peak was 682 but you wrote 783 😅
+1
If you use the spanner up the other way it will handle more pressure!
No ,pressure on setwheel will break
It matches my impression about right. You buy Germany brands or Japan brands when it comes to hand tool.
But I am amazed how Taiwan do well too.
I thought Taiwanese people only manufactured high-tech chips,
but I didn't expect they could also produce tools.
@@Enzo661100 That is what Taiwan do best, but Taiwan also has wide variety of industries. I used to know that we export lots of hand tools, but I always thought that is because of the value is good. Not aware that the quality is also pretty good.
We pay tribute to the old German wrenches.
Bahco claims to have invented that type of adjustable spanner. Would like to see you test one
The modern adjustable spanner: Todays design is the little Swede of 1891-1892, pat. 4066 (1892), of inventor Johan Petter "JP" Johansson.
They all did good. I'm not that strong. 😁
انت فنان ورائع❤استمر🎉
面白い動画でした、次はKTCやスナップオンも加えてください！
I have a 10 ton hydraulic press at home. I was planning to do the same test but when I saw the warning in the beginning of the video, I changed my mind.
NO CONOZCO A NINGUN HUMANO QUE PUEDA PRESIONAR A MAS DE 50 KG, ENTONES CON ESA REGLA TODAS ESTAS HERRAMIENTAS MANUALES Y PARA EL HOGAR ESTAN PERFECTAS !!!😊😊😊
I think you need to face the fact, that thing is never coming undone.
Yep. Has to turn the other way!
In fact, all wrenches are made in China.According to the price, China will provide products of various qualities.
Why isn´t the Swedish original wrench, patented 1891 from Bahco tested? It was called "Swedish wrench key" in US.
Murphy Wrench: the square bolt on the test rig wrung off before the press hit 100 kg.
ابزارهای قدیمی قابل احترام و ارزشمند هستند برای مقایسه نباید تاریخ را له کنید
Let’s face it, even the cheapest wrench won’t let you down
The test presses on the middle of the handle. That means you can break it by roughly half the force pressing at the end side, which 125 kg is not that hard to exceed.
@@jyunnheikusada7003 You ain’t putting 125kg on the tip of the handle, without risking injury. And who is going to use a wrench on a nut with that sort of torque?
@@fanfeck2844 Using a hammer to hit the end point is a pretty common practice when the screw is jammed. I think the impact can exceed 125 kg.
Never heard of the company "Cross" in germany. Next time try Stahlwille or Hazet...
Makita.. standart price but great quality...
Az öreg német jó konstrukció. A fix, és a menetes köracél közé kellene hegeszteni mégegy összekötő erősítést, és akkor nem tudná elhajlítani. Szerintem jó anyagból talán az lehetne a leg erősebb! Majd a kínaiak megcsinálják 10$-ért. :-D
Interesting presentation of information. And what is the purity of the experiment do you know? Although, it depends on what goals you have followed.
'Do not try at home' dude no one expect you has hydraulic press at their home 😂
Conclusion: Never buy expensive and overpriced wrenches from the USA.
American one had good result
@@arya3261Worse than polish one for 1/3rd of a price
Just buy German things
Made in germany 🫡
شما احتمالا از ابزارهای آمریکایی با برندهای ریجید، پوروتو،دیاموند، اسنپ اون آشنایی ندارید که بهترین در جهان هستن
Está al revés la llave, es invertida, la carga, o el peso, se pone en la cabeza, tienen que repetir Las pruebas los resultados son diferentes.
I thought the same thing as well.
That Taiwan held up pretty nice
This test is not feasible. There is a difference between the strength of the metal and its hardness. It is not a known criterion. The more the hardness of the metal is subjected to fracture more than the ductile metal.
if most of your garage work only needs no more than 200kg torque and all these wrenches meet that spec, then which one you will most likely buy, the 5$ or 45$ ?
Very impressive!
Can you try the İZELTAS which is produced in Türkiye?
broke 3 wrenches in my 80 years and I am by no means strong. One - the little pusher turner broke and fell out. Two - the upper part of the jaw broke off and Three - the handle broke off straight after the roller. Two were Japanese and the last one was German (Hazet)
Sorry, but I didn't see the 783 kg on the clock with Taiwanese one, just 683.
Imagining that they were repairing German tanks with him. 😔
Are you sure you choose high grade equipment for all country?
Taiwan reached 683 not 783 still good though.
Bonjour, très instructif comme expérience mais normalement ce type de clé s'utilise dans l'autre sens, la force doit s'exercer le plus près de l'articulation pour diminuer le bras de levier
Je ne suis pas d'accord de votre idee de sens de direction.
@@nigelrg1 chacun fait à ça convenance, j'ai déjà cassé trois clé, en l'utilisant dans ce sens je je ne l'ai pas encore cassé.
Absolutně nesmyslný test ! Kdo z vás dokáže vyvinout sílu 250 kg a více ?? S největší pravděpodobností nevydrží povolovány šroub!
Total waste for the old German wrench, but glad to see that the newer German wrench only had some scratches...it wa structury intact. 😊
I’d like to see Crescent, Proto, Craftsmen, Bahco, Snap on, and Armstrong adjustable wrenches tested as well….I’ve got Wright, Channelock, Mac and others, but they last because I take care of the tools.
Thanks for the test.
SK is a really good one too
Любой каприз за ваши деньги 😅
why don't you try bahco spanner ?? a famous brand
I remember i had a half inch stainless steel plug stuck in the instrument holder because somebody did not use teflon tape. In the workshop nobody could get it out with a wrench like this. I put a foot up and pulled with all my weight and 120kg of myself and with a screeech it started moving. hehe. Became hot too.
I'm Japanese, and Makita is a company famous for its power tools.
I credit China. No one use it more than 20kg but price is the best.
Why not chose the original Cresent brand for USA ?
I would like to see Urrea from México 🇲🇽 among the adjustable wrenches tested here, I know that not only would it is a worthy competitor but it could very well win.
Свяжитесь с автором и договоритесь об отправке посылки в его адрес
4:54 с каких пор 682 стало... 783?
Actually, all of them are made in China. Different price with different quality😂
DEFINITIVAMENTE ESAS COMPANIAS DEVERIAN DE PAGARTE POR ESTAS PRUEVAS QUE HAS HECHO, AHORA SABEN CUAL HERRAMIENTA ESCOGER PARA CUALQUIER TRABAJO
FELICIDADES POR ESTO.
No hay una comparación en esta prueba, ya que prueba una herramienta de 5 de Rusia contra una de 45 de Estados Unidos, eso genera una idea falsa de que lo de Estados Unidos es mejor que lo ruso, pero el precio dice otra cosa.
From now on I will buy every Taiwan products first lest of my life .
I have an adjustable wrench like the old one with the twisted handle, its in good nick with russian writing on it.
harga menentukan kualitas💪
1883 year didn't brake. It still bite the bolt
The poster seems to like Japanese-made Makita. For adjustable wrenches, TOP Kogyo or Fujiya would be the better choice.
In fact,Most of them MADE IN CHINA, Different prices, different qualities😂😂
yep
milwaukee and "Russian" are from china
which, however, does not negate the presence of original Russian and American wrenches of good quality
La llave taiwanesa no marcó 783 marzo 683 porque yo lo puse en cámara lenta y no llegó hasta 7