What Keir Starmer must tell Britain to win the general election | Andrew Marr | The New Statesman

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 23 май 2024
  • The Labour leader has launched his general election campaign with his
    "six first steps". But where do they lead?
    Subscribe on RUclips: / @newstatesman
    Rishi Sunak has accused Keir Starmer of having no plan. Andrew Marr argues that Keir Starmer and the Labour party need more than "first steps" or five missions, and lays out the key issues he believes will inspire voters to cast their ballot for Labour.
    Read Andrew's column here: www.newstatesman.com/politics...
    --
    Andrew Marr is Political Editor for the New Statesman, and is one of the UK's most senior political journalists. He spent over 20 years at the BBC where he was Political Editor and hosted the wildly successful Andrew Marr show. He is now based in Westminster where he brings his deep experience of political reporting to his analysis of the most important events in UK politics. He also hosts Tonight with Andrew Marr on LBC Radio.
    Watch more New Statesman videos from Andrew Marr in this playlist: • Andrew Marr
    --
    The New Statesman brings you unrivalled analysis of of the latest UK and international politics. On our RUclips channel you’ll find insight on the top news and global current affairs stories, as well as insightful interviews with politicians, advisers and leading political thinkers, to help you understand the political and economic forces shaping the world.
    With regular contributions from our writers including Political Editor Andrew Marr and Anoosh Chakelian - host of the New Statesman podcast - we’ll help you understand the world of politics and global affairs from Westminster to Washington and beyond.
    Sign up to Morning Call, the daily UK politics newsletter from the New Statesman: morningcall.substack.com
    Subscribe to the New Statesman from just £1 per week: www.newstatesman.com/podcasto...

Комментарии • 561

  • @TheSuperPsychoKiller
    @TheSuperPsychoKiller 23 дня назад +60

    When you don’t have an umbrella in the rain during a public event, how can anyone trust you to have a brain?

    • @olaflieser3812
      @olaflieser3812 22 дня назад +1

      He just can't multitask. Hold an umbrella and talk at the same time...that's all.
      I could do it. Can I become prime minister?

    • @mayerrathore8132
      @mayerrathore8132 21 день назад

      His brain was super hot like an engine and need cooling in the rain and it didn't work .

    • @TheStubertos
      @TheStubertos 6 дней назад

      Especially when he says "If you can't have a plan, then how can we trust you to lead our country?". Literally couldn't plan to bring an umbrella...

  • @stuartgraca
    @stuartgraca 23 дня назад +105

    I tell you the basic problem in British politics is a lack of rational concern for life and social cohesion. The politics that exist are content with the format of acceptable change, even when it moves 180 degrees in 5 years. Labour will mix and match policies in order to be elected, the Tories will move to the far right in orfer to sound forceful, it as no bearing on public needs or commercial reality. The home policy is much like the Israel v Palestine issue, devoid of honest concern.

    • @fightthepowerman
      @fightthepowerman 23 дня назад +16

      Yeah its weird, its like our elites serve capital and not the people who voted for them. Sometimes it almost feels like theres an obvious and unreconcilable problem at the very base of our system. Sometimes it feels weird that our politicians are so against any kind of actual change. Almost as if they are part of a class of people who has wholly different incentives to both us and to what they claim to have. Almost.

    • @reuben8140
      @reuben8140 22 дня назад

      @@fightthepowerman Also why Reform is a doomed project, if they even came close to dislodging the Tories their inbox would filled with donors promising the world yet oh so concerned with the property values, cheap labour and subsidised research underpinned by current immigration levels. The libertarians would seize upon such an opportunity and the nationalists would be left with their d*cks out, relegated to window-dressing projects like Rwanda. Same issue if the Tories pivoted far right themselves - traditional nationalist talking points like heritage, family, community and local industry simply aren’t profitable for today’s efficiency-mad globally-concerned donors.

    • @Hamilton-kz2xw
      @Hamilton-kz2xw 22 дня назад

      only here for the money. save a lot pixels and blah blah. do you honestly think the average voter has the mental ability to read or want to read so much "bollocks". if some dozy bint on eastenders repeated your words imagine the backlash.

    • @fredmercury1314
      @fredmercury1314 22 дня назад +2

      The Tories? Far right..? That's literally hilarious...

    • @craigmurray3483
      @craigmurray3483 22 дня назад

      @@fightthepowerman If voting changed anything, they'd make it illegal - Emma Goldman. What was true then seems to be true now.

  • @tonychinnery
    @tonychinnery 21 день назад +12

    These First Steps are ridiculous. Britain is Europe's most unequal economy (and the biggest prison population to match), these steps do nothing to address this glaring problem. They are aspirations rather than steps. The only concrete thing in them is the setting up of a public energy company. Other than that they represent a Conservative continuation policy, including the typical right wing obsession with border security and anti-social behaviour (a product of inequality). The very best outcome in the general election would be a minority Labour victory with the smaller parties insisting on PR as a condition for their support. A bid Labour majority will encourage Starmer's authoritarian instinct, someone who carried out a ruthless purge of Labour's progressives, and welcomed a hard right Tory turncoat.

    • @theJACKATIC
      @theJACKATIC 19 дней назад

      Bulgaria, Russia, lithuania, Italy, portugal, Latvia, Montenegro, Romania, Spain, Switzerland, North Macedonia, Serbia, Bosnia, Greece and Luxembourg all have worse gini coefficients the UK.

  • @emer67
    @emer67 23 дня назад +27

    Sunak's speech made a big splash....drench war fare

  • @annbretagne2108
    @annbretagne2108 23 дня назад +13

    Hope Keir Starmer watches this and takes it on board.

  • @Kavala76
    @Kavala76 23 дня назад +17

    Missions? Steps?
    They'll go the same way as Starmer's "pledges" - binned and forgotten.

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад

      Don't be too proud of your Keir Starmer bashing, the Tory ability to destroy a country pales in significance to the power of hope.

  • @prideofdurham4776
    @prideofdurham4776 23 дня назад +14

    Michael Penfold Gove is not standing in the election.The news gets better , maybe we will have a good Summer.😊

    • @alisdairmclean8605
      @alisdairmclean8605 22 дня назад +1

      Actually I would like to see Gove stand for election but get ignominiously rejected by the electorate. A Portillo moment.

    • @Chris-xv2gm
      @Chris-xv2gm 22 дня назад

      ​@@alisdairmclean8605you show great intellect!

    • @kevinu.k.7042
      @kevinu.k.7042 22 дня назад

      @@alisdairmclean8605 Yes, the writing is on the wall for his Tory seat.

  • @MrTzimisces
    @MrTzimisces 23 дня назад +4

    This sounds like more projection of Andrew wants Labour to be, rather than what they actually are. What Starmer's Labour is all about is protecting the status quo and not upsetting rich people

  • @fozzyami
    @fozzyami 23 дня назад +12

    We need to be voting for parties and NOT personalities. We don't have presidents. Our PM can, and probably will, change during a term of government. So we need to be changing this pushed narrative of voting for a person, we don't do it so we shouldn't be talking like we do.

    • @jonsmith5058
      @jonsmith5058 22 дня назад

      The current Labour party is based on Starmers personality. He’s robbed them of any discussion, stamped out any left wing passion and suspends anyone who wont say exactly what he wants.

    • @richardjones7984
      @richardjones7984 22 дня назад

      We are being MK Ultra mind controlled by the media for the nefarious purposes of the US intelligence agencies. They run all our political parties apart from Laurence Fox's one man party.

    • @dafyddroff8084
      @dafyddroff8084 21 день назад

      We should be voting for policies instead of Parties or People.
      The parlimentary system has been a failure

  • @rafaeldegiacomoaraujo8778
    @rafaeldegiacomoaraujo8778 23 дня назад +38

    I'm not hard left but I have witnessed a labour party that bans long serving MPs with an amazing record of being correct like JC and DA while accepting hard right MP that voted against everything that the Labour Party stands for. I think you are gaslighting us here.

    • @adamc973
      @adamc973 23 дня назад +3

      They're not standing them as MPs come the next parliament... it's just an act of symbolism

    • @Splooshua.
      @Splooshua. 23 дня назад +4

      Totally agree, starmer also didn’t need to “compromise” on policies like re-nationalisation of public services or his commitment to taxing the rich (especially because a worse economy means you need to raise more taxes!) they’re sensible and popular moves that need to be implemented.

    • @fredmercury1314
      @fredmercury1314 22 дня назад +2

      What has DA been correct about, specifically?

    • @enemywithin1295
      @enemywithin1295 22 дня назад +4

      What has Corbyn achieved? The man has been an MP longer than I've been alive, and as far as I can see there's no Private Members Bills from him, nor any Select Committees he's chaired or let alone sat on. The man has squandered an opportunity.

    • @jontalbot1
      @jontalbot1 22 дня назад +3

      JC is a man who voted against his own government over 500 times. He should never have been a member of the party in the first place, let alone an MP. You don’t belong either so join a party which represents your views

  • @briandelaney9710
    @briandelaney9710 23 дня назад +4

    Unfortunately , there is no one on the Labour front bench who inspires

    • @dizkoztu
      @dizkoztu 22 дня назад +1

      Why you not inspired by man of the people multimillionaire Sir Kier?

  • @markjoseph196
    @markjoseph196 23 дня назад +18

    NHS is tories Achilles heel

    • @jonrotten31
      @jonrotten31 23 дня назад +5

      And immigration

    • @julieclonan2427
      @julieclonan2427 23 дня назад +4

      DEI Officers on £100.000 a Year must Go First, then the Unqualified that can't speak English, that Cost Millions in Compensation.

    • @StyledObject
      @StyledObject 23 дня назад +4

      and GDP growth, productivity, house building, wealth inequality, workers rights, real wage growth, infrastructure, industrial strategy, corruption...

    • @Eltener123
      @Eltener123 23 дня назад

      ​@@julieclonan2427 There's no DEI roles on anywhere near that salary the public sector and it would be a ridiculous anti-free-market policy to ban them from the private sector

    • @thetragicyouth
      @thetragicyouth 23 дня назад

      You Wes Streeting wants to accelerate the privatisation of NHS services?

  • @danielholmes-nj5nq
    @danielholmes-nj5nq 23 дня назад +16

    The truth would be a good start, although this is Keir Starmer we're talking about so that could be a problem.

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад +6

      He's an honest chap, he'll be far more radical than you realise.

    • @danielholmes-nj5nq
      @danielholmes-nj5nq 23 дня назад +4

      @@user-sf7kl9uh7k Giving diametric opposite answers to the same questions in separate interviews does not an honest man make.

    • @dominicchallis2928
      @dominicchallis2928 23 дня назад +4

      @@danielholmes-nj5nqIn a print media climate which fosters deep disdain for outspoken advocacy of human decency and sense, it can be punitive to give a consistently empathetic opinion on important matters as seen with Jeremy Corbyn. On that basis, I have some faith that these contradictions are mostly damage limitation to curtail media smear campaigns against Starmer, and that once in government with a thumping majority he can finally say, to some extent, what the Left have been wanting to say for 14 years: the truth. Then again, I could be wrong.

    • @HiveFleetOni
      @HiveFleetOni 21 день назад +1

      @@dominicchallis2928I think you are right. If you look at some of the speeches he has given where he has spoken for longer than needed to just deliver sound bites, he starts to get energised when he is talking about social injustices. I see that as a good sign of what sits behind the iron-cast discipline.

  • @hypedude6120
    @hypedude6120 22 дня назад +5

    Spot on again Andrew. I'll be voting Labour but I despair at their lack of ambition.

    • @jennifercardy3616
      @jennifercardy3616 21 день назад

      So I am what about Clemence Atlie Aneurin Beven I think Keir would be the answer. What about us we must invest in Children and Families first x

    • @eoin8156
      @eoin8156 21 день назад

      As a Labour Party member for 30 years I’m extremely doubtful. Remember our last majority government under Blair was a bloody centre right political reign . Invading Iraq as well as privatisation of areas of the nhs .

  • @dogzero1
    @dogzero1 21 день назад +3

    The Conseravtives have done all this:
    1. Highest energy bills in Europe.
    2. Highest taxes in 70 years.
    3. Highest interest rates since 2008.
    4. Highest train fares in Europe.
    5. Longest waiting lists in NHS history.
    6. Raw sewage pumped into rivers.
    7. Lowest corporate taxes in 50 years.
    8. Lowest State Pension in Europe.
    9. Highest Immigration both legal and illegal ever.
    10. Destroyed the NHS dentist service.
    11. Brought the Brexit vote and ruined the country.
    12. Oane failed Prime Minister after another.
    13. Worlds shortest in post Prome Minister.
    14. More corrupt MP's than any other party in parliament.
    15. Europes longest Austerity for the loewr paid.
    16. Highest Council Tax rates in the World.
    17. Reduced our Armed Forces more than any other G8 country.
    18. Highest number of MP's that have been arrested for sexual offences.
    19. Highest number of MP's that have been sacked for corruption and Fraudulent acts.
    20. Voted to allow Bankers to have unlimited bonus's even though the bankers caused the crash of 2008.
    21. More libraries closed due to council cuts than any other modern country.
    22. Ruined and destroyed the Train services by giving private companies tax payers money as subsidies.
    23. Voted against Labours creation of the minimum wage.
    24. And finally, wasted billions of Tax payers money on crony PPE contracts for their friends and other Tory donators.

  • @alex_zetsu
    @alex_zetsu 22 дня назад +2

    All he needs to say to Britain to win the general election is "I'm Not Liz Truss, Rishi Sunak, David Cameron, Nigel Farage, or Jeremy Corbyn" and he'd win.

  • @Natterz101
    @Natterz101 23 дня назад +7

    No shooting the messenger please but what happened to Labours plan of public ownership of the whole railways within 5 years in the ‘We own it’ site? just curious 🧐

    • @andybrice2711
      @andybrice2711 23 дня назад +4

      I think that’s still on. Last I heard they would renationalize them into “Great British Railways” as the franchises expire.

    • @jennifercardy3616
      @jennifercardy3616 21 день назад

      You must listen and not comment on the negative He said he would do this gradually Rome was not build in and day, And we have 14 years of failure and broken promises from the Conservatives and they have conserved too much money and not have invested in the Bristish forces the NHS and public services too little to late at the dawn of a election vote Labour !

  • @stevenwilliamson6236
    @stevenwilliamson6236 23 дня назад +44

    Rachel Reeves said that the Labour party is not a party for the unemployed.

    • @BrianMartin-ph7pt
      @BrianMartin-ph7pt 23 дня назад +12

      If labour con their way in most of us will be..

    • @catherinemartin6258
      @catherinemartin6258 23 дня назад +28

      @@BrianMartin-ph7pt
      Absolute nonsense

    • @jamesprice4647
      @jamesprice4647 23 дня назад +9

      Reeves is a shocker.

    • @TOP.FOX.
      @TOP.FOX. 23 дня назад +8

      ​@catherinemartin6258 you clearly have not lived under labour but you will learn.

    • @ilokivi
      @ilokivi 23 дня назад +8

      The proper course of action would be for the next UK government to prepare to #RejoinEU. Trying to 'make Brexit work' is like attempting to drive a car with the handbrake on.

  • @johnrichards2508
    @johnrichards2508 22 дня назад +1

    The two elephants in the room are Brexit and Gaza. The silence on both issues brings daily shame on the British establishment.

  • @colinthompson3111
    @colinthompson3111 23 дня назад +4

    Enjoyed this video. Hope to see more of Andrew Marr videos during the election.
    Has Anoosh delivered yet?😊

  • @ronseymour4976
    @ronseymour4976 23 дня назад +4

    This is an excellent synopsis of the current impasse that we are in.
    There are so many serious issues out there and they don't have enough time or money to tackle any of them. The goals that they are trying to achieve are unattainable. Successive governments have been so obsessed with their raison d'etre that they have achieved little other that bolstering their egos and alienating the public.

  • @angelalacey1060
    @angelalacey1060 23 дня назад +6

    Thankyou sir ive enjoyed listening to you and i agree with what your saying goverment sould not interfear with changing pip benifits people need cash to pay bills rent food also child benifits needs to remain as it is!!!! Vouchers are a massive mistake more councill houses to be built for british people who are homeless😊🎉

  • @JohnnyinMN
    @JohnnyinMN 21 день назад +1

    Sunak and his speech: ‘A Day Of Wettening.’ Didn’t know he was attending a Stones concert during the speech.

  • @mediastudiesnetwork
    @mediastudiesnetwork 23 дня назад +3

    Wonderful insightful commentary

  • @michaelc821
    @michaelc821 21 день назад +1

    Sunak speech in the rain was the sign its all over.

  • @heliopolis
    @heliopolis 22 дня назад +6

    I don’t think we’re trying to save the planet, Andrew. The planet will be fine in the long run. We’re trying to save ourselves.

  • @olaflieser3812
    @olaflieser3812 23 дня назад +27

    I believe Keir Starmer will just want to avoid big mistakes and run down the clock now. As if, in a game of football, your side is leading 3-0 at half time. Don't go on the offensive, just run down the clock.

    • @sofajockeyUK
      @sofajockeyUK 23 дня назад +2

      This. When you have a 20-25% poll advantage, give yourself the space to deal with what you find in power. The current admistration have been running 'scorched earth'.

    • @chrishardy3473
      @chrishardy3473 23 дня назад +6

      @@sofajockeyUKyou watch the polls tighten when it gets closer to the election then. Him saying nothing and relying on the tories being abysmal isn't enough.

    • @hugodrax71
      @hugodrax71 23 дня назад +1

      In truth, he's been doing this the last 18 months. He's not actually needed to do anything to be on the cusp of entering number 10.

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад +2

      I'm just PRAYING he doesn't do a Kinnock, get over enthusiastic at a rally or some other event and blurt out "well alright, well alright, well alright!"
      That would suck massively

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад +2

      ​@@chrishardy3473Labour will secure a 160 seat majority MINIMUM!!!! I've bet all of my holiday money on it, so they'd better do well!!! 😮 (£800, Majorca 7 days)

  • @dereks1264
    @dereks1264 23 дня назад +1

    "Economic stability" should mean economic stability for the population. When the public has such stability they will spend not just on the basics of life but on the extras that grow the overall economy. It's "bubble up" economics rather than the fallacy of "trickle down" economics.

  • @johnbridger5629
    @johnbridger5629 21 день назад +1

    Saving the planet and long term economic benefit go hand in hand, and that is the message that needs sending out.

  • @vivakidocelot8948
    @vivakidocelot8948 22 дня назад +2

    Andrew Feinstein Independent to dispatch Stammer in his own constituency!!!
    Vote for the Citizen Independents or The Workers Party of Britain to end the reign of the Uniparty Crime Collective!!!

  • @paulsmith1981
    @paulsmith1981 22 дня назад +1

    The British people keep electing the uniparty over and over again expecting a different result.

  • @tatata1543
    @tatata1543 23 дня назад +5

    Every time I see Pat McFadden I think David Icke might have a point about lizard people.

  • @MarI-Posa
    @MarI-Posa 21 день назад

    No one can articulate what matters better than Andrew Marr

  • @E_Rex_Sean
    @E_Rex_Sean 22 дня назад +1

    *The choice between Tory or Labour is like a choice between a slow end or a quick end.*
    *At least with Labour they’ll finish off the UK quickly then.*

  • @j.johnson3520
    @j.johnson3520 21 день назад

    Thank you Andrew for a great in-depth analysis that's remarkably insightfull.
    Really appreciated.

  • @grahamjones5400
    @grahamjones5400 19 дней назад

    UK politics is like a family sitcom when compared to USA where people argue about how old the esrth is and vote based on that.

  • @mattwright2964
    @mattwright2964 22 дня назад +1

    I agree. This Govt really has to go but I do want someone to get a grip on where we are taking the country. For me I want to hear that Labour fundamentally understand where the system is going wrong and how they might approach solving it ( one exmaple is poor structtral economic performance for decades under both parties). I don't expect every bit of detail (although in truth after 14 years of a failed Govt they have had chance in opposition to develop quite a lot). I get that we don't want false expectations and that people have become cynical about political promises but there is a danger here for Labour that they really don't shine at all in the campaign.

  • @whackiey
    @whackiey 22 дня назад +1

    UK governments have been messing about patching up child benefit for decades, its a symptom of the battle between capital and labour. People are not being paid a "living" wage on which they can raise their families. Just patching that up, yet again, is an elastoplast. It does not make sense to subsidise consumer spending with government spending. While the Conservative/Unions war had bad players on both sides, the total destruction of unionised labour has led to exploitation. The whole austerity drive, following de-industrialisation without capital re-investment has made it factorially worse

  • @pastyman001
    @pastyman001 19 дней назад

    Marr explained One Nation Conservatism, better, deeper and more intuitively than I have ever heard it

  • @QuantumInspired
    @QuantumInspired 20 дней назад

    In Cambridgeshire, they completely ignore the fact that people even could have kids. Nothing is available, not for new businesses or children , all around narcissists in golf courses.

  • @kevinu.k.7042
    @kevinu.k.7042 22 дня назад +1

    As always a very good piece.
    The issue is you are asking Starmer and the Labour Party to stand up and start doing positive leadership of the country and the people. It just seems not to be his almost middle management way.
    That is to his detriment and our loss.

  • @_xeere
    @_xeere 21 день назад

    Here's to hoping. Sadly, I doubt it will happen. We're in for 5 more years of austerity with a fresh coat of paint and little more.

  • @jamiewillis6511
    @jamiewillis6511 19 дней назад

    Andrew Marr absolutely on point as always. The UK needs a vision and needs optimism. Keir Starmer is just too timid and concillitary, if the Labour Party win then it's a conservative failure, not a Labour triumph, they have nothing to be proud of.

  • @jamesadey8744
    @jamesadey8744 22 дня назад

    "I'm not the vacuous slimeball you think I am."

  • @patcampton7163
    @patcampton7163 21 день назад +1

    Those bloody flags.

  • @sharonwashington8150
    @sharonwashington8150 22 дня назад +1

    They will say whatever it takes to make THEM great! but when it comes to serving the actual people they will do very little other than put themselves FIRST! talking out of ones backside is a regular trait with Labour for one example. Tories have had 14 years of doing just so! and BROWN was an absolute DISASTER for BRITAIN another UNELECTED waste of space.

  • @sofajockeyUK
    @sofajockeyUK 23 дня назад +4

    Watching how Reevenomics plays out will be fascinating.

  • @notjustforhackers4252
    @notjustforhackers4252 22 дня назад

    'The Investigatory powers act' breaks Article 8 of the ECHR.
    'The Online Safety bill" breaks Article 10 of the ECHR.
    He must tell Britain he will repeal these two.

  • @nigelcox4234
    @nigelcox4234 19 дней назад +1

    “Corduroy wearing Britain” what the fvck is Andrew Marr talking about?

    • @paulmcallister4546
      @paulmcallister4546 18 дней назад

      Its a lazy way of identifying a certain type of person (usually male, late middle aged, conservative and a tad rural in aspect). I love my corduroy levi trucker jacket....I dont think he meant me, but who knows!

  • @captaintorch983
    @captaintorch983 23 дня назад

    They lead downwards to the depths of despair.

  • @user-ke2ui4eh9d
    @user-ke2ui4eh9d 21 день назад

    It's not about compromising your way into power that's the problem. Abandoning all your pledges within a couple of years makes people doubt they can trust anything you say

  • @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh
    @MarjorieStoker-oj8fh 23 дня назад +3

    I wonder if Starmer would look into the slave labour of women prisoners in England for the company ecardo on line shopping owned by unscrupulous shareholders

    • @julieclonan2427
      @julieclonan2427 23 дня назад

      What about the Pakistani Owned Factories Employing Illegals?

  • @AlanTufrey
    @AlanTufrey 21 день назад

    Let's get a campaign started. Can't Vote Won't Vote. None of them know what we really think. Pass it on.

  • @trampertravels
    @trampertravels 22 дня назад

    In Parliament we do not, in reality, have parties, what we have are basically two large factions, those who want to control everything - the Authoritarians - and those who want to be free of everything - the Libertarians - and then two smaller factions: there are those who want to turn back history to some golden age that never existed - the Reformers - and finally there is the faction for those who do not want to join anything - the Independents.

  • @stephenkerensky710
    @stephenkerensky710 22 дня назад

    The only really effective way of getting cheap or free energy is hydro-power generated from the tides. It might take five years or more to pay off the set-up costs but once that is done there are only cheap maintenance costs to pay for. Clearly the big energy companies are dead-set against anything that will reduce their huge profits.

  • @chriswright3179
    @chriswright3179 21 день назад

    Has Rishi ruined an expensive suit?

  • @richardanson2445
    @richardanson2445 23 дня назад +1

    I’m resigning. 😂

    • @maikotter9945
      @maikotter9945 22 дня назад

      Have fun beeing the "Admimistrator of the Chilton Hundreds"!

  • @DubStudioCreateVinyl
    @DubStudioCreateVinyl 22 дня назад

    Nailed it

  • @davidbarlow350
    @davidbarlow350 23 дня назад +1

    Nett zero a solution to a problem that doesn't exist ,but will cost YOU a lot of money.

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад +1

      Even if you don't believe in man accelerated Global Warming, you have to accept we can't carry on drilling oil out of the ground, in increasingly remote and environmentally damaging locations.
      I would agree that just taxing people who are trying to get to work and heat their homes isn't the way forward however. Or punishing the working man who wants to go on a family holiday once a year.

    • @davidbarlow350
      @davidbarlow350 23 дня назад

      @@user-sf7kl9uh7k
      In 70 years of predictions not one has materialised.
      What has happened is a generation is brainwashed and people like Al Gore are very rich.
      Watch a few of Tony Heller's videos.

  • @Afterthoughtbtw
    @Afterthoughtbtw 20 дней назад

    I actually think there is something much simpler that Keir Starmer needs to find an answer to: what does trying to provide a cohesive Britain (and England in particular) mean from a societal point of view? He needs to provide a meaty, compelling idea that can unite the population away from the kind of increasing sectarianism that can get multiple local councillors elected based on a platform regarding international events in a region completely disconnected to the UK. The very fact that that can even happen shows that there is no cohesion whatsoever here. And Labour are the party most at risk of seeing something like this happen in the general election.

  • @KevIn-qy7ps
    @KevIn-qy7ps 22 дня назад

    It’s quite simple, I intend to push through policies that benefit the UK people and not pander to the media, minorities and woke brigade.

  • @andrewalston1
    @andrewalston1 20 дней назад

    It’s no good telling us what Kier must say it’s suggesting what Kier must do in order to invest. Does he borrow or tax to raise the money.

  • @patcampton7163
    @patcampton7163 21 день назад

    Well said Andrew.

  • @Its.all.a.game.m8
    @Its.all.a.game.m8 23 дня назад +1

    How does having more children help child poverty?

    • @user-sf7kl9uh7k
      @user-sf7kl9uh7k 23 дня назад

      Good point, but it's not always a simple choice that's made deliberately. Plus some women just can't bring themselves to abort. The maternal draw is just too strong. Sad, horrible situations people find themselves in really.

  • @patcampton7163
    @patcampton7163 21 день назад

    They are as gagged just as much as members are, which makes them all look shifty and untrustworthy.

  • @francisravenscroft-dw6gi
    @francisravenscroft-dw6gi 17 дней назад

    Labours five steps are as nebulous as Sunaks pledges. No content at all.

  • @rolansmith9951
    @rolansmith9951 22 дня назад

    Have you seen the price of tikka masala these days i thought we was getting a price reduction

  • @garycannon2887
    @garycannon2887 22 дня назад

    I thought most people despised the stereotypical corrupt liar politicians, it’s not a “hard left” position.
    Starmer’s behaviour has gone way beyond “compromising” for power.

  • @stephenhill545
    @stephenhill545 21 день назад

    Should talk about all the corruption they have been found engaging in. They are rotten.

  • @michaelc821
    @michaelc821 21 день назад

    The tories are so bad, Starmer doesn't need to talk his junk.

  • @MagicE13
    @MagicE13 22 дня назад

    If you close your eyes, Kier Starmer speaks like a Darlek.

  • @marklanahan7289
    @marklanahan7289 23 дня назад +4

    As soon as his bum hits the seat, those 6 points and 5 missions will be chip paper.

  • @andrewwebb9426
    @andrewwebb9426 22 дня назад

    Great talk, as always! Will Starmer-Reeves listen, though? They seem so small minded and short-termism.
    I admire Gordon Brown of all the New Labour lot and I’m sure he’s right about the two child limit as regards child poverty but I think we also need look to reducing birth rate and, yes, dependency on the state. My suggestion is that it should only apply from now on, I.e. those with bigger families already should get the help they need but there will be no allowances for third and subsequent children in future.
    The two big planks Starmer-Reeves should concentrate on after their timid six steps should be cheap council housing and far wider and more available tertiary education. Cheap housing to get this stulifying burden off young people’s shoulders and allow them to spread their wings and ambitions. I always thought the target to get everyone a university education was missing the point. Yes, we need excellent tertiary education available for all but the old tech colleges and proper apprenticeship schemes are far better for most of us. Most important of all, we should be able to retrain later in life at a reasonable cost.

  • @macsmiffy2197
    @macsmiffy2197 22 дня назад

    Let’s face it. Debate via social media is dire.

  • @existentialvoid
    @existentialvoid 22 дня назад

    if the UK went carbon 0 - the impact would be less than .02% of global emissions.
    While I understand the concerns the public has - the change has to come from China and India - not from the UK, the EU or the US. These countries have been effectivly carbon neutral since 2014 - about 10 years.
    So if you really want to make an impact - stop buying Chinese and Indian products and start to impose a tariff on trade with these countries until they meet climate goals. This is the only way Brittan can have an impact on global climate change.

  • @Hithrae
    @Hithrae 20 дней назад

    The polls will not narrow

  • @jonsmith5058
    @jonsmith5058 22 дня назад +1

    You said it clearly, Starmers Labour is trying to satisfy nimby Tories. They are now right wing conservatives.
    Its nice to hope for some inspiring left wing support, but you might aswell have hoped Camerons government would also be Left wing.
    Abandon Labour, vote green.

  • @fredmercury1314
    @fredmercury1314 22 дня назад

    I wonder if they called for the General Election to avoid dealing with the petition to close the borders for 5 years, which already has 44,000 signatures?

    • @jonsmith5058
      @jonsmith5058 22 дня назад

      What utter nonsense.
      All the petition will do is cause them to debate it, where they’ll all agree its a moronic idea and move on.

    • @fredmercury1314
      @fredmercury1314 22 дня назад

      @@jonsmith5058 It's not a moronic idea, it's a very very sensible idea.
      The fact that you don't see that speaks volumes about how far in the sand your head is.

  • @jyap22
    @jyap22 21 день назад

    Hey Andrew, your ideas are good and meaningful. The problem is UK Government has NO MONEY. It is well and good to say that we need to do this and that. Are you going to pay for it yourself?

  • @crayontom9687
    @crayontom9687 22 дня назад

    I personally enjoy how Andrew labels mild social democrats who want the absolute bare minimum of a functioning country ‘the hard left’

  • @Existential_Bengali
    @Existential_Bengali 21 день назад +1

    Universal free health care and education for all citizens of a country is a must, an unhealthy and unskilled labour force is a nightmare for any kind of long term economic development.

  • @anonymouse68
    @anonymouse68 21 день назад

    There is no way I will ever support Labour again.

  • @maryfitzpatrick9639
    @maryfitzpatrick9639 23 дня назад +5

    Andrew, please tell me, why are so many people afraid of Labour? The party which transformed the country after the second world war? It mystifies me, as I child of that era. Please do a podcast on that.

    • @julieclonan2427
      @julieclonan2427 23 дня назад

      Old Labour Died with the Champagne Marxist Blair, who is now Klaus Schwab 's Replacement. Starmer is Bliar's Puppet, like Biden is Obama's.

    • @jrobs1133
      @jrobs1133 23 дня назад

      They started the cultural destruction of Britain through mass immigration. The Tories have followed on from that work. Voter apathy will win Labour the election. Lowest turnout for decades on the cards.

    • @karenlp5867
      @karenlp5867 22 дня назад +2

      I’m no expert, and I too would like to hear Andrew’s opinion on the matter because I’m not sure if I’m right about this, but it seems to me that people are afraid of Labour because the mainstream media have taught them to be. Most people don’t have either the time or inclination to look into the issues for themselves, and it’s the right wing that have the money and power to control the narrative and influence public opinion. I think the only way to resolve this is through press reform.

    • @jrobs1133
      @jrobs1133 22 дня назад

      @@karenlp5867 It's because Labour destroyed British cultural identity when they brought in multiculturalism the likes of which this country has never seen. Now we have Jews v Muslims, Pakistani grooming gangs etc. The country of the United Kingdom was then fractured under devolution? The last Labour government also went all tyrannical and started invading countries too. Plus Brown sold our Gold at $262 per ounce. Gold's spot price is currently at $2,000. Labour didn't transform the country. They committed a gross act of cultural genocide on the British people.

    • @maryfitzpatrick9639
      @maryfitzpatrick9639 22 дня назад

      Well said; thanks for your reply. 👍

  • @i-am-vonnegut
    @i-am-vonnegut 22 дня назад

    As a Scot, one big family does not exist. Neither do I want it to. England deserves its parliament back. Time for a federation of kingdoms, Westminster should not have say north of the border. English politics for English people!

    • @stephenhill545
      @stephenhill545 21 день назад

      Who do you have more in common with, a Scottish millionaire, or an English person who has the same occupation, salary, and life chances as you?

  • @Lionfish-Hunting
    @Lionfish-Hunting 23 дня назад

    Tax the super rich (assets of £20M+) - WHY let them off????
    Because a lot of our politicians are rich and/or in the pockets of the super rich!!!!!

  • @oliverlaw02
    @oliverlaw02 22 дня назад

    You couldn't fit a Rizla paper, between both their policies.

  • @danielcreamer9669
    @danielcreamer9669 23 дня назад +24

    I understand that Labour is tacking centrist, compromise is a vital part of democracy. But I also hope Starmer can walk that Biden line of centrist appeal and some solid progressive moves. Letting some of that creep in to the campaign would probably be a good thing!

    • @andybrice2711
      @andybrice2711 23 дня назад +5

      Please let’s go economically progressive though. And not neoliberalism plus divisive identity politics.

    • @stevenwilliamson6236
      @stevenwilliamson6236 23 дня назад

      He's got the genocide down already.

    • @catherinemartin6258
      @catherinemartin6258 23 дня назад +1

      I hope so too

    • @peteratkinson922
      @peteratkinson922 23 дня назад

      Probably too late to drop the identity politics if last year's conference is a guide​@@andybrice2711

    • @TheSuperPsychoKiller
      @TheSuperPsychoKiller 23 дня назад +1

      Who gets to define what center is? I thought Jeremey Corbyn was center.

  • @drasticplasticaustin
    @drasticplasticaustin 22 дня назад +1

    Both leaders are heavily reliant on pumped up flabby soundbites and
    mantra's devoid of substance. Any time they attempt to talk a good fight it all sounds very amateurish. The whole sorry circus is on the slide and it merely leaves our baffled and punch drunk electorate wearing cartoon question marks above their heads.

  • @lordchutney9000
    @lordchutney9000 23 дня назад

    Clear Tory tells everyone what a non-Tory needs to be to be not-be, and be Tory.

  • @drd6416
    @drd6416 22 дня назад

    Both sides of the same wef workforce. Neither will actually do anything for the public, or the country. Nobody has mentioned stopping the boats. Ever.

  • @anthonysullivan3238
    @anthonysullivan3238 23 дня назад +8

    God bless Gordon Brown

    • @fredmercury1314
      @fredmercury1314 22 дня назад +1

      The guy who sold Britain's gold at a record low, costing the UK taxpayer BILLIONS?

    • @JohnDavis-gu9jx
      @JohnDavis-gu9jx 22 дня назад +1

      How much would our gold reserves be worth now? About 30 Billion and rising.... Why do the serially incompetent run countries?

    • @maikotter9945
      @maikotter9945 22 дня назад

      There can NEVER be >= 1 "God"!
      Change the British national anthem, to "Grace saves our land!", please ... [or so]

  • @lw1zfog
    @lw1zfog 22 дня назад

    Sir CPS $türmer of the Trilateral Commission sez you should most definitely trust him ! 😂

  • @JanetJames-dw6xo
    @JanetJames-dw6xo 22 дня назад

    I remember the tories had a plan but i dont remember them actually following through with it. All of them talk too much with no action.

    • @dizkoztu
      @dizkoztu 22 дня назад

      Actually Tories plan was to get Brexit done. They did deliver on that. Made a complete mess of it to be fair, but on paper they delivered. 😂

  • @davidhall7744
    @davidhall7744 23 дня назад

    Andrew, all Starmer has to say is - ‘we arent tbe Tories’ - that is enough for me and I suspect many more as well.

  • @stevethornhill3304
    @stevethornhill3304 22 дня назад

    There's a brexit sized elephant in the room

  • @TarlachOakleaf
    @TarlachOakleaf 23 дня назад

    Starmer doesn't have to say one damn thing to win the election; it's already won. Matter of fact there is an argument that keeping his mouth shut would be the best strategy.

  • @elizabethanderson2968
    @elizabethanderson2968 23 дня назад

    Who cares? It is already a trait of his to say anything on the day, then renege... that's all you CAN trust him to do

  • @zhanruide84
    @zhanruide84 22 дня назад

    I wonder what GE result you would get if the electorate was exclusively people that commented on ‘New Statesman’ and ‘The Spectator’ RUclips videos. Certainly not many seats for Labour or the Conservatives.

  • @RedJadeArt
    @RedJadeArt 21 день назад

    Yeah I agree. Maybe labour can win an election by appealing to middle England but it can’t keep power without any real ambition for working people in the U.K.

  • @kitcat4512
    @kitcat4512 23 дня назад +13

    He'll do whatever his darlinng Davos tells him to do.