How "Joanne" Redefined Lady Gaga's Career
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 25 июл 2024
- Welcome back to Pop Dissected! Today, we’re going to be discussing Lady Gaga’s “Joanne” and how this record reshaped her public image and rocketed her into new career heights.
Like this video and subscribe for more future content on all your favorite pop stars!
Instagram: @popdissected
Twitter: @pdissected
Check out our other video on Lady Gaga:
- Did Lady Gaga’s “ARTPOP” Really Flop? [ • Did Lady Gaga's "ARTPO... ]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Background Music: “I Know Better” by CAROLINE
[ • CAROLINE - I Know Bett... ]
Instagram: [ / carolines_m. . ]
Official Website: [ www.carolines-music.com/ ]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(All music, music videos and live performances are included solely for educational and entertainment purposes. All rights of live performances belong to their respective owners.)
Live Performances:
“Anything Goes” & “Cheek to Cheek” [ • Video ]
“Applause” [ • Lady Gaga - Applause -... ]
“Joanne” [ • Lady Gaga - Joanne LIV... ]
“Million Reasons” [ • Lady Gaga - Million Re... ]
“Paparazzi” [ • Lady Gaga - Paparazzi ... ]
“Perfect Illusion” [ • Lady Gaga - Perfect Il... ]
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
[ #LadyGaga #Joanne #AStarIsBorn ] 
Развлечения
I love when people appreciate LADY as much as they appreciate GAGA
She's incredible. Her career is just outstanding!
@@popdissected4400 absolutely!! Still amazes me that people can hate her so much :( Great video though!
@@nickymcthicky4871 I see no reason to hate her. She has a lot of talent in her. She can play multiple instrument and her vocals are just amazing. And when I imagine super bowl half time performances all I can think of is her who has surpassed all expectations in recent times. And I am not even American. But she is my favorite.
@@SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi agreed! She's so amazing
I love when people appreciate the opposite as well. I feel like people misunderstood Gaga before and that makes me sad. She has always been incredible. Even with the spectacle. Her theatrics were always on point and I will always love her for her earlier work.
Even though I think Art Pop is Gaga’s best work, Joanne was a needed album in her discography. People still called the Joanne era a flop yet it invigorated her career and gave her an additional demographic to her fan base. A Star is Born I believe was the biggest record for a female artist in 2018 overall if I’m not mistaken.
Yes it is ! ASIB sold 6M and it's followed by Invasion of Privacy ( 3.5M)
Great taste. I love ARTPOP & JOANNE
The thing ppl misunderstand about Gaga (and also about other pop artists) is that she is a person and her personality is multidimentional just as anyone else can be. Gaga didn't change her image and music, she just showed another side of her. Joanne's simplicity and vunerability doesn't mean that all her previous work were superficial or inauthentic, her music always had a meaning and art behind it, especially Born This Way. I mean, it's not that she also absolutely hates her work in ARTPOP either, the thing is that the era was associated with a dark moment in her life and with some decisions she deeply regrets, but still, that album was also good and artistic.
John Cooper everything that you said, i completely agree with. ARTPOP is her favorite album of mine.
Bellerz G I agree, she was showing a different side of herself, she's always had meaning behind her music, people still see her as Ally, when she's not Ally. Lady Gaga is the face, but Stephanie is the person beneath the surface, attempting to peek out and break free of this crazy pop superstar imafe, and it was successful, the people have started accepting Stephanie for who she is! She's an amzing iconic woman, and is trying to be true to herself.
Lady GaGa is now following the path of previous multi-genre divas: Judy Garland, Barbra Streisand, Liza Minnelli, Bette Midler, Cher etc etc. Talented lady.
Yes!!
bette midler omg 😍
You forgot Cher in the list! ;)
Julien Castle ahhhh I have indeed! She is indeed another legendary artist 😊
Linda Ronstadt too
I feel like Joanne and Cheek to Cheek were very important and necessary to Gaga's career. Without them, the SuperBowl and ASIB wouldn't have happened, nor would she have the respect she gained from the industry. With this authentic Gaga, I wonder what she'll do next. Will she return to her roots and make a crazy pop era? Cause I wonder how a post-Joanne Gaga would approach such a concept.
VERY TRUE! And as for what she'll do next, only time will tell! I'm excited to see what she does.
I feel like the general public finally realizes how amazing Lady Gaga is and she has shown how versatile she can be as a performer. The public got regain in an interest in her even further after ASIB. After, people probably go back and reminisces about Gaga's earlier work and would like her to go back to that genre. I'm for sure certain she'll come back even stronger the next decade with a very critically acclaimed album. And she's definitely going to venture on into acting further down the line!
She's very unpredictable with her albums but what I know for sure is that she'll come again with something different from what she did. She can "surprise" and come with a more mature version of that Gaga from the past (which she's currently doing at her Enigma residency) the posibilities are endless with her which is why is so fun and never boring to be a fan of her.
And this is a exactly what's so interesting about lady gaga. You never know what to expect from her. She could literally drop a classical, rock, metal, country, pop, electric, or jazz album. She can do anything. ❤️🤯
Scoobert Doobert respect from fatherless suicidal trash cans #artFlop
this channel is underrated af
Haha, I'll take that as a compliment 😂 ❤️
Pop Dissected aa
@@popdissected4400 it is!
okay but can i just thank you for taking the time to actually have an intellectual discussion about gaga instead of throwing around the word pokerface
There's nothing gained from being shady or obnoxious. I always try to be respectful to the artists I make videos on and have a construction discussion! Also, love the Gaga & Katy profile pic!
Pop Dissected thank you! you deserve an insane amount of respect for your dedication to pop music!!! your videos are a breath of fresh air from the scary side stan twitter and youtube
Nothing is wrong with Poker Face. Its one of her best songs.
Jennifer Cox i agree. i was just using it as a dramatic example to show that many people interpret her or automatically judge her just based off her early hits. I (and i cannot stress this enough) LOVE POKER FACE.
Haha...."the poker face singer".. 🙄
I’ll follow Gaga wherever her music takes her....also #JusticeForARTPOP
💙🔵
K Lu this comment!!
The thing ppl misunderstand about Gaga (and also about other pop artists) is that she is a person and her personality is multidimentional just as anyone else can be. Gaga didn't change her image and music, she just showed another side of her. Joanne's simplicity and vunerability doesn't mean that all her previous works were superficial or inauthentic, her music always had a meaning and art behind it, especially Born This Way. I mean, it's not that she also absolutely hates her work in ARTPOP either, the thing is that the era was associated with a dark moment in her life and with some decisions she deeply regrets, but still, that album was also good and artistic.
I loved the Joanne Era.The authenticity really jumped out! In a video she did with nikkie tutorials she described her new music as “colourful” I’m very excited to see what it means!
Yes!!! And I cannot wait for her new music, so excited!
I'm sooo curious. I mean you literally never know what to expect from GaGa. I personally wish the album would have disco and rock influences. It'd be very interesting.
@@ibra1000 electro rock would be perfect 😍😍😍
CHROMATICA B*CHES!
@@alicechromatica4540 well ofc ik that now…
I would say that Joanne also influenced Justin Timberlake's Man in the woods.
Oooh very interesting! How so?
Pop Dissected after Joanne came out many artists started to do more striped down images, for example Kesha, Justin Timberlake, Miley Cyrus, and others, it was deemed the Joanne effect
@@popdissected4400 In that specific case, I think it was more an aesthetic influence beyond the sound of Justin's record; country toned outfits and stripped down vibes.
Man of the Woods gave me more of a white man’s version of Lemonade vibes than Joanne
Kind of like how Beyonce inspired Rihanna, Ariana and the rest of the industry to ditch EDM and return to R&B while adopting trap pop in the process.
Her performance was met with “universal” acclaim.
Aliens in mars: omg yes that was such an iconic performance!
Totally
Everyone on Venus can agree
Ye
You forgot Jupiter, they said, "yes please! Iconic woman here! Make way for pop superstar."
True
I read the Elton John encouraged Gaga to really change her image after ArtPop....hiding behind a meat dress, and other outrageous costumes was becoming distracting...the best thing to ever happen to her...Elton himself had lavish costumes during his 70's, and had a similar transition...
Wow, I actually didn't see that when researching for this video! That's really interesting to know!
I actually recall her talking about it during an interview with Andy Cohen..she said it in passing, but I can definitely see the conversation happening..
That's something very significant and relevant to notify because lavish, eccentric and outrageous costumes kind of sometimes showcase how insecure some artists can be when it comes to their natural artistic gifts. There's nothing wrong with entertaining shows and stuff but it's always better when art helps you have your emotions connected to those of the artist. It's much more intimate and therapeutic.
I miss that Gaga. I liked her and her music. Yes maybe she shouldn't dress that edgy but her music was great. I don't find Joanne or ASIB as interesting.
@King C.....I know it would be great to keep our favorite musicians the way we remember, but in order to sustain a long career, you've got to evolve...imagine if Gaga was still wearing meat dresses?..She'd be a laughing stock....she always talked about becoming an actress, and with her stint in American Horror Story, winning a Golden globe, and ASIB, and winning an Oscar....she's making smart decisions about her future and longevity....
Her earlier albums will always be remembered, but Joanne has served as one of the best examples of how pop has come since the start of the decade. I love how raw and simplistic many songs from the album are. I skip some but I dont consider them bad at all.
Yes, very good point!
I think cheek to cheek was the turning point, Joanne was an evolution of this and a star is born solidified her as a multi-talented respectable artist. (Art pop deserved better)
Joanne is Gaga's finest work imo. I have so much respect for her for daring to change her style so much for something more genuine. Most pop artists avoid doing that. I was obsessed with The Fame and The Fame Monster back in college, and I didn't think she could top it, but she did. Joanne blew me away at first listen.
Yes!!!
Hey i think I know you from the Melanie video
ay piper’s here
Joanne is a very satisfying album. I hope that this is a sign of how she'll evolve as an artist and continue to grow as she matures through the years and as she progresses in her career.
Yesss!!!
I'm a simple man. I love stanning Oscar winner, Lady Gaga. She is immensely talented and a genuine and pure soul. ❤
Yessss!
A star is born is what really set her apart from the rest of her peers. She gained many new fans that had no idea she was as talented as she was….that her fans already knew through her acoustic performances. People finally took her seriously….a million reasons started the transition. Ending with Shallow becoming the most awarded song in history.
If she is able to scale down her production, yet maintaining shock factor, weirdness and quality, she could become a legend.
She already is!
She was a legend in 2009, she's been called Queen of pop since the beggining. Now she is Queen of Music
I love Gaga's career narrative especially during the Joanne era. Everyone counted her out after ArtPop but Gaga stayed focused on her craft/talent.. which led to her renaissance during the A Star Is Born era.
YES!!
TBH not many people is familiar w her work after born this way, only her fandom and some other gays. Of course a star is born is a total hit but not many people know the song because of gaga, they just like the song
Arnold Garcia you’re really pulling your own leg with this one mate
LUKE I’m not sure what you mean bro
Arnold Garcia GAGA has been earning millions more and more after 2011 Are you sure that no one knows Applause or Million Reasons?
I grew up with “GAGA” and although wasn’t the biggest fan of her in the Joanne era in the beginning, I listened to the album and fell in love right away. It was so different and beautiful. The fact that my favorite song of her entire career is the Joanne piano version is amazing, because I LOVED her pop records. But this song was just so beautiful and it stuck with me because a family member of mine passed away in 2018, almost close to the songs release. I loved this era so much.
Joanne world tour deserves a DVD release, the stage desing was incredible, the costumes, the set list.
it's crazy how in 2013 people were talking about her in a completely different way than they are now
she's a very respected Icon to the general public now & an OSCAR winner
i'd love to see a movie based on her life and career cos that's a one hell of a Career
Remember when everyone said she was a satanic she male? Yea good times huh?
@@NobleWolf33 she male?
@@Qwerty-lq2op they thought she had a penis and was a ‘transvestite’
@@jesuusch also they said and it doesn't matter still love her. Which was also nice to see.
I wouldn't want that cause she isnt a massive star and although talented doesn't have an impressive career worth making a whole movie on, the movie would flop . Pls and no offence but dont overhyped her due to you being a fan because look around. She isnt a pop star just a pop musician. If this was back in 2009 and 2010 then yes but not now
It was expected...as much as older fans fell in love with Gaga in her 20s we have to understand that she is now a woman in her 30s...it's time to grow up and evolve and be just as real as in the Fame era but in a different yet authentic way...the 'fans' who can't let go of the 'old Gaga' should get a grip move on as well.
I've been a fan of her since 2010 and even thought I love her peak days when she was all about the spectacle, unique outfits and "crazy" performances and her being at the very top of the charts and so on, I think her 2nd part of her career (2014-2019) is better. The way she picked herself from the ground and re-branded herself after ARTPOP to this day is literally one of the best comeback stories from the music industry. With every era she showed what an amazing artist she truly is and Joanne really did contribute a lot and got more people behind her. She's also an amazing person aswell. She'll allways be "Gaga" but she found a ballance between herself and that Gaga (which is also a part of herself) during this time.
You forgot to mention her Netflix movie, that also helped show another side of her
I loved Joanne, but Artpop was indeed my jam and I don't know why people don't like it
Because it was more of the same, and by that point it had become boring.
@@Melkac I like your profile pic. It reminds me of Saga. Personally, I didn't think it was more of the same. I feel like Gaga was always doing something different or trying to experiment. I didn't think any of the songs on Artpop had a similar sound, but managed to tell a cohesive "story"
People hate Artpop because it didn't had the commercial success Born This Way had, because of that people labeled as a flop even though it wasn't, I think Artpop its one of the best albums of Gaga
Artpop was a horribly managed era and unfortunately, due to some decisions Gaga did with Do What You Want, working with 2 guys involved with rape just made matters worse. Also, in that year dancepop/EDM was just not the thing in mainstream pop music. Which is really sad, bc ARTPOP is a fenomenal album.
It’s because of the prejudice or how the negative controversies impacted People’s perception of the album. If only people gave it a chance. The album’s production is insane. Applause, Gypsy, Dope, DWUW, Sexxx Dreams should’ve been the singles.
I just took a DNA test, turns out I'm a 100% waiting for LG6!
Piorun CHROMATICA (LG6) OUT APRIL 10th! STUPID LOVE OUT NOW!
5/29
Out now
Joanne is literally one of my favourite albums. But I need lg6 right now
Hhh we need to stop whining we already got ASIB soundtrack last year
@@yuhuuuu123 It's a soundtrack, not a personal studio album, u fish.
We have to wait because of haus labs
Yeah...and hopefully, it'll be more like her previous works (e.g. The Fame, Fame Monster). One thing I don't get, WHY hasn't she collaborated with RedOne? He was the one who produced Just Dance, Poker Face, and Bad Romance
@@vincaalkaloids6732 I heard that she did in Lg6
perfect illusion could also be about lady gaga's breakdown and disappointment in the music industry (it was a perfect illusion, it = fame), and million reasons about healing through god and/or family/friends/love
Joanne is such an amazing and deep album. It showed the world that she’s more than just crazy costumes and wild interviews i love her so much
The massive shift from GAGA to LADY was really a monumental move for Lady Gaga herself and exposes us to her more diverse and wide range of her talent.
This talks about everything in the album! Awesome!!
I tried my best to cover so many things about the record! I'm glad I got everything 😃
Well we little monsters know that gaga had always talent from the day she was born and we first heard it on the fame era in 2008
I miss Gaga's outlandish videos and her avant garde costumes.
Have you noticed how 2016 brought the most artistic albums?
Lemonade
ANTI
Untitled Unmastered
Joanne.
A seat at the table
The life of pablo (the album is amazing minus its controversy).
Blond
Facts!
Bruno Mars’ 24K Magic came out in 2016 as well
Invasion of privacy :OOO
Berkay that was 2018 and that’s an album full of radio hits.
Drake views & K Michelle more issues than Vogue
you should do P!nk’s new album and how even after 20 years of her being in the industry it still hit number 1
I've been considering covering it actually :)
Pop Dissected it’s actually pretty cool considering the lead single only peaked at 49 on the billboard hot 100 and the next two singles failed to chart at all
@@skylaratlas I know! Singles really can dictate a record's success, but she still pulled through! I loved P!nk's "Truth About Love" record, but I honestly haven't listened a lot to her most recent releases, so a video on "Hurts 2B Human" would be a great reason to listen to her new music!
Pop Dissected i’m a really big p!nk fan and even tho hurts 2b human isn’t her best record it still pulls through with standout tracks like “courage” (co written by sia) and the title track featuring khalid. i recently rediscovered it when i got given it on vinyl and it’s actually a really good album despite being quite more pop than her previous works
Now that’s a legend!!! She has obtained a loyal fanbase who focuses on her full discography rather than singles on a heavy singles-driven era, which itself is an achievement.
When Gaga reached peak saturation during ARTPOP the public were sick of the messy era and all gimmicks and bullshit
C2C and Joanne reinvented her as a real vocalist and it opened her up to huge opportunities like the Oscars. C2C Gaga was being invited to tribute to Julie Andrews, ARTPOP Gaga wasn’t. Also, belting those
jazz standards on tour did WONDERS for her voice
I find it very interesting that people love her for her grounded image in reccent years. Honestly, I miss the Lady Gaga that just wanted to have fun and make us dance with pop music. Intellectual stimulation is great but so is dancing.
GnSt4vo true
she's still crazy and fun, she's just more comfortable being an adult woman who sometimes wants glamour over avant garde just to impress others
@@RyanRipley69 And there's nothing wrong with that. I just happen to miss it. Sometimes I don't want a meaningful lyrical song, sometimes I want to forget about everything and and enjoy the upbeat melody.
@@gushernandez25 i know, i miss parts of her too but she served upbeats with ASIB and a lot of pessimistic fans seem to think her last pop song was in 2013
@@RyanRipley69 She never left pop, but her recent approach is rather boring because it dwells too much on lyrics and not on dance pop sounds.
bobby is such an incredible manager, the work he has done post-artpop has done more than save her career. she's been catapulted into legendary status among multiple generations and not everybody has that
Lady Gaga is one in a generation artist that brings so much depth and complexities to her art that takes time to understand her. Even though ARTPOP may be my least favorite album of Gaga's (no album of hers I hate I love them all) I feel that ARTPOP never was given a chance to blossom like it should. Gaga has a beautiful way of reworking her material to provide different sides to her songs. For example, she can do a stripped down version of the Edge of Glory, Judas, Poker Face, etc.. and the songs take a whole new meaning. I felt that ARTPOP didn't have that. I felt that ARTPOP came in with the intention of providing flavor to the music scene but was really distracted by chart performance. If I would have chosen the singles I would do:
1. Applause (It was a perfect lead single. The Video was amazing)
2. Venus (It was her first record where she did the producing)
3. Do What U Want (This song is everything. I know the R. Kelly would cause a controversy but focusing on the remix with Christina Aguilera would completely elevate the song. When she performed it in the AMAs at the end she did a stripped down performance and releasing it like that would become a bigger hit but also a personal one a shot at the media)
4. Gypsy (this song and a stripped down version would build off Do What U Want and have a 2013/14 version of Edge of Glory)
5. Sexxx Dreams
When Joanne era came in I fell in love. What drew me in was the lead single Perfect Illusion. She performed it as a stripped down version and it was so heartbreaking. Joanne was a very personal record with so much depth and I wish it would have been explored more. Singles I would have chosen:
1. Perfect Illusion/Acoustic
2. Diamond Heart
3. Million Reasons
4. Hey Girl (this didn't need to be a hit it just needed to be exposed more)
5. Joanne
Joanne was a shift to a balanced gaga/stefani record.
As for a star is born. I love that Shallow got all the recognition but I felt that the whole experience would be bigger if Heal Me, Always remember Us This Way, and Why did you do that? were released as a follow up to Shallow in the level that shallow was pushed.
OMG. Same. Sexxx Dreams, Gypsy and Dope should have chosen as singles too.
I always disliked the false dichotomy that people sometimes project onto eccentric artists like Gaga: the "real" (i.e. stripped-down) vs. the "unreal" (i.e. surrealist theatricality). I think Gaga's earlier eras were authentic and fully representative of where she was during those periods of her life (even when adapting to the expectations of the commercial pop industry). I strongly believe that the fantasies we gravitate to and the stories we conjure can be just as revealing of our true nature as the cold hard facts of our everyday reality and Gaga's musical evolution is no different. With each album leading up to Joanne, Gaga was peeling back the layers of her enigmatic self through an abstract, psychedelic pop lens. I do agree that the frankness, sincerity, and autobiographical nature of Joanne allowed Gaga to showcase a different side of her artistry which in turn helped reshape the perception the general public may have had of her up until that point. However, I think it's important to acknowledge the instrumentality of Gaga's previous records in facilitating the effectiveness of Joanne. The contrast in aesthetic, songwriting style, and musical direction may not have been regarded as notable had she adopted this approach from the get go, but you eloquently discussed this in your video. Overall, I love Joanne. It's a beautiful, heartfelt body of work that illustrates Gaga's versatility as a musician, as well as her emotional complexity as a young woman. As a longtime fan, I was aware of this nuance and authenticity from the beginning, so it's sometimes frustrating to me that it took so long for the rest of the world to catch up. Excellent video, thank you for your work! 👍
Lady Gaga is such a passionate and hands on artist. I don't think she'll ever actually flop... she'll just succeed from another perspective really
You didn't mention her spectacular National Anthem performance. That probably helped focus public perception on her talent more than the Oscars or the Album.
I love Joanne
Me too!
Joanne was a masterful piece of music & songwriting, not to mention how sincere it was. Now we need BTW 2.0, an album showcasing another generation's need for rebellion and self-expression in new times, as Born This Way was in 2011.
Gaga is literally the most talented person of our generation, I have no idea how she survived show business with the depth of her emotion and the need to create real art. I think it caused her a lot of pain but she came on top in the end.
Amazing analysis, in recent years i´ve come to really appreciate Joanne and it truly is mind blowing lyrically and the way it showcases her talent.
Beautifully explained. I knew this as soon as the record came out that she had cemented herself as *the* next diva with longevity.
The album Joanne got me into Gaga.
I probably Wouldn’t have ever discovered her without it. I absolutely love it
A clear, intelligent and perceptive commentary on the evolution of the unique music genius of Lady Gaga. Kudos to Pop Dissected 👍👍 👍
Yes! I've been waiting for this one. I love your analysis videos, I always look forward to them.
Thank you so much, you're amazing!!
Everything you do is meaningful and well thought out. As someone who works in the music industry, I really appreciate your work. Keep it up. Forever.
Lady Gaga has been one of my biggest insperations throuout my entire life so far. I really really love her first three albums. they are all masterpieces in my opinion. true artworks. when the singles for Joanne came out I listened to them and was kinda half disappointed. I've only listened to the track Joanne a few times. it is a touching story and i dont think there is anything wrong with it. its just not usually what im "looking for" when I listen to Gaga (and other po-ish artists). I'm glad shes happy and everything but it's just not very interesting to me. I like the over the top super show artform thing more. i mean its interesting to get a very personal album but I woudnt wanna listen to several albums like that if they dont also "bring something else/interesting to the table" ;)
Joanne succeeded while Artpop failed at showing Gaga's vulnerability. For me, her vulnerable and honest songs were always my favorites. Songs like Brown Eyes, Speechless, Dope, and Swine always stuck out to me. So when Joanne dropped, it was great to have more of my favorite aspect of Gaga. Don't get me wrong, I LOVE the shock rock inspired performances and the iconic costumes, but the stripped back authenticity is what makes her so loveable. Cheek to Cheek and Joanne made it easier for a mainstream audience to see her great vocal ability and authenticity that many people missed from her previous eras, although some of the songs on Joanne are just as shallow (haha) as her previous albums, like John Wayne and Dancin' In Circles. I'm also glad she didn't go overboard with the vocals on Joanne because it makes listening to it easier and a more causally fun experience. I struggle with really getting into a Mariah Carey or Beyoncé album because of the heavy vocal delivery. I think Gaga did it just right on Joanne.
Yes!! Very good points!
Thank you so much for creating this channel. I am always looking for contents in your channel because it's very informative and entertaining.
I love watching your videos! They speak facts and give artist they’re tens. You did a great job at explaining this era!
Thank you so much!!!
I am so thrilled that over the past week you have been pumping out videos for me to binge on!!! I am already a huge fan of your channel! Please keep up the great content and thank you so much!!! 💜
I’m watching this video again in preparation for your video on Chromatica! I’m so excited to hear what you think about this 6th studio album of hers! So far, as a Gaga fan, I’m in love. Can’t wait to see your video on her new album!!!!!! 😘💜
I love Gaga so much!!! I am so upset that ARTPOP wasn't received overly well. It's my favourite album ever! Am I the only one here?
Gaga will always be a talented singer/actor and incredible artist of the decade. Always a Gaga fan since day one. 👍😊😘
The song (Joanne) could’ve been a huge hit but Gaga didn’t really send it to radios. It could’ve went #1 on adult contemporary
I think your forgot to mention the Superbowl Halftime Show, which was the most important moment of this era. Before the Superbowl Joanne was half-flopping, with Perfect Illusion missing the top 10. Only after she nailed the Superbowl, showcasing her vocal and performing abilities at their best, the era became a success, with Million Reasons reaching number four and becoming a streaming hit. It was the Superbowl Halftime Show that reignited her career and led to A Star Is Born.
Thank You For Posting This Omg 😙😻💕🐾
Hope you enjoy ❤️
I love your videos so much, I really appreciate your mature analysis of Gaga over the past 6 or so years. The woman has or well on her way to solidifying herself with the greatest Chanteuse’s ever...Celine, Whitney, Cher, Judy, Bette, Liza, Barbara, Aretha, Diana, Mariah....Gaga....she is in that conversation now. “I’ll never love again” needs more appraisal and awards too lol, reminds me so much of Whitney’s “I will always love you” and Des’ree’s “Kissing you”....some of the most iconic love songs ever.
I hope Gaga sees this video! She is strong, but maybe many tend to forget that she's a person, especially a very emotional and sensitive person... She needs to hear positive "critics" like yours, I'm sure that it would put a smile on her face and always new energy.
P.S. Also, ARTPOP is SO GOOD, I appreciate it even more now that I'm older then when it came out. I'm not actually able to get the people who still, year after year, claim to miss the Fame era (= the hits without even understanding its own profundity and importance).
joanne was the first full record i listened to of gaga's and it was such a wonderful album and a very special era to me. it's what made me a full fan of hers and was the first time i saw her live. she's AMAZING live btw! i think everyone should try to see her on tour or at her vegas residency at least once.
It always makes me sad that people don't get that the art and artifice of Gaga's earlier eras were just as authentic and honest as her pared-back music. She goes into that idea in the intro of the "Marry the Night" video, when she talks about the lie being more honest than what actually happened. And that's part of the idea behind "Born This Way" too, how she wears prosthetics while talking about being born that way - that you create your own truth.
I'm glad that with Chromatica she's gone back to a bombastic pop sound, but the lyrics are very personal and open. I hope people can see that Gaga can be authentic and pop at the same time.
In the UK, Million Reasons only peaked at No 39. Gaga followed it up with a track called The Cure which got to No 19 but had a lot more radio play than the three actual singles from Joanne. I found that very interesting that she effectively put out a new track during the promotion campaign of an album when there was no way that was going to become part of a deluxe edition. Joanne was then released but didnt chart in the Top 40.
Yes, very interesting indeed!
Read it somewhere that The Cure was supposed to be part of ASIB, but somehow didn't make the cut (?)
Great videos bud. You've delved into some unique info, that I have wondered about many times, on several video. Ie xtina bionic and Katy perry breakdown.
This is the content I subscribed for, period.
Thank you for doing Gaga!
Lady Gaga is my inspiration and the artist I adore so much. 😘🥰
This was an amazing video!!! Kudos my friend
Thank you so much! I appreciate it ❤️
Simply I just love this channel
Amazingly good
About time, this video makes New Year even more exciting! 🎆
LOOOVED your channel. Your analyzes are great: so detailed, but understandable at the same time.
I partcularly love the tone of your speech.
Now, personally, I think that Artpop's "flop" had to happen for Gaga to kind break through once more, and with that she let the world really know about her talent and what she is capabe of. Joanne, with every single fault, is a work of art and since its release, it set a standard in the industry.
And no matter what, the woman has always been successful. I really think that this decade was hers, with all her achievements and what we'd call mistakes included.
I love how she made two completely different singles with complemented videos and then just made the third part with a non single pop track just for the fans (John Wayne)
Beautiful analysis, as always.
amazing video as always!
Thank you so much!! ❤️
this is my favourite album of gaga by all the reasons you mentioned in this video. i loved to see lady gaga's vulnerability and raw vocal talent in this album in a way never shown before
Another amazing video!
Thank you so much!!! ❤️You're awesome!
Your channel as grown so much! Good work.
Love your take on this 💖
Great video. You really have well explained and informative content. Love it! Just a little correction however, she won the golden globe in 2016 and the Oscars tribute performance of The Sound of Music was 2015. So she didn't win the golden globe within weeks of that performance. But she did perform 'Til It Happens To You' at the Oscars in 2016, the year she was first nominated at the Oscar's and the year she won her first golden globe.
I like Joanne but I like Artpop too. I'm sorry it gave her depression and lack of self confidence but true fans appreciate all the different aspects of her music. I struggled with depression too for most of my life so I know what it means and how it's difficult to stand up again and live again. So I love her even more for her strength
Another great video.
My favorite album of her after Born This Way. The lyricism and the passion in the voice 🔥
I love these Gaga videos cuz I love her.
Can u please make more in the future?
The Joanne era holds a special place in my heart I was a senior in hs when it came out and I played it everyday for months. I love all of her eras tho I can't wait to see what she does next.
JOANNE SHOULD HAVE WON BEST POP VOCAL ALBUM! HOW DARE THE SCAMMYS GIVE IT TO DIVIDE.
This has been your best video to date.
Thank you :)
ur channel is so good
Thank you so much ❤️
an icredible video, thanks for making it
BLESS YOU FOR APPRECIATING HER ART AND DOING IT JUSTICE
Emily Tressa period
Belle I spilled
Emily Tressa period pooh
Loved this. Huhu.
Gaga is an iconic legend that will be remembered thru the centuries 😍
You deserve more views bro:(
Awww, thank you 😭 ❤️
I remember reading that Gaga wrote an in-depth thesis on pop history with Bowie and Madonna as the main catalysts and their rapid transition through reinvention .. knowing that Gaga is pop historian, Cheek to Cheek and Joanne made me remember Madonna’s transition to the more subdued This Use To Be My Playground, Something To Remember and Evita (including a golden globe) stages .. just thinking now does Sex/Erotica = ArtPop ? .. anyways, just dance it’ll be okay
Gaga was one of the earliest pop queens of this decade to show the decline in EDM pop/dance pop in the industry through Artpop.
Great video! Could you possibly to a video essay on why The Fame Monster era is such a timeless classic after 10 years?
She went from Rara to yeeyee period