I do not agree with everything Hamza says but you are off here and misunderstood the context and angle of his response. He meant that by being a Muslim he will get to keep the believe in all prophets and scriptures.
Well, he said that in response to a specific question of how one can be a Jew, Christian and Muslim simultaneously. You can't be all three at the same time, because they all have different set of opposing beliefs and practices. So either he didn't answer the question or he wasn't clear in his answer and made general vague statements in order to appease Jordan and his audience, which is deception.
@@ivviiv6763 He could have just said no, that's not possible. But he chose to answer this sly question for what it was and with follow up statements that are true: You get to keep the faith in all scriptures and prophets. So in that way you can still be "Jew" or "Christian". Yes it was to appeal to him while still answering and making him feel inclusive without crossing the line. That was his nature of intent by he should have approached this differently, one should be very clear and concise with statements when it comes to deen, especially aqeedah.
Hamza Yusuf means by this to say that when you recognize all prophets regardless of origin, then you are universal as a Muslim. Hamza Yusuf does not want to exclude anyone in this way of explanation, it is an intelligent answer.
He is deludere a soufi that doesn’t have the correct Aqeeda. Believes Allah is everywhere Aootu billah and believes in shirk and innovation. Nothing intelligent about what he says or does.
And what was the outcome of his “intelligent answer”? Nothing but confusion which was apparent in Jordan Peterson’s video. May Allah guide Humza Yusuf - Islam is not a religion where we need to play with words to make it sound appealing. Be proud of the truth of Islam and say it as it is and you will see the people entering Islam in droves. Not because of how we worded it, but because of the truth of the religion
Yes but he could have been more explicit on that because people who are not familiar with Islam can get a wrong image, it is very important to be correct and if we make mistakes that our brothers and sisters point that out to prevent spreading falsehood. It’s good that Shamsi pointed that out but it is always important not to attack someone personally and proceed like our beloved prophet salallahu wa Allahi wa salam with highest emotional intelligence.
So he didn't answer Peterson's question which was how he can be a Jew, Christian and a Muslim simultaneously. So he answered a question which he wasn't even asked. So, how is it intelligent?
Hamza Yusuf shouldn't have been apologetic about it and should have just straight out said that all these religions contradict each other therefore you can't be all at the same time, and should have started explaining that Judaism is practically about a tribal god, Christianity is about a man-god dying on a cross, and Islam is about the Supreme, King of Kings.
Wallahi, I was disappointed when no one was criticizing Hamza being there. For him to be even taken as any kind of authority in Islam is from the greatest of jokes in the world.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
@@SaidB1n no, it’s just people who do not have a higher educational standpoint should not be listening to his talks otherwise you will confuse it. He uses very high level words and wording.
You don't really understand. He's talking to a non-muslim so it's not as easy to explain it to him as explaining it to a Muslim. I'm not attacking you brother but you are extremely aggressive and your aggression made you misunderstand.
Love from Kashmir Brother Shamsi..i watched dt video of Hamza yousuf and jordan peterson..you didnt correct only Hamza yousuf you also corrected me as well...thanks bro..May Allah bless you
We all understand the question, no matter how the answer is rebranded it is still wrong. Had it been Judaism and Christianity are entirely based upon the pristine teachings of the books that were given to Prophet Musa and prophet Īsa which will eventually make their followers to be Muslims and neither Jew nor christian, then his answer would've been close to being correct and not still fully right because there wouldn't have been Judaism and Christianity in the first place .
The ‘Christians’ before Muhammad (صل الله عليه وسلم) were Muslims. So why describe a believer in Allaah’s final messenger as a Jew, a Christian and Muslim combined in one when the prophet said: "May Allah's Curse be on the Jews and the Christians for they build places of worship at the graves of their prophets." (Al Bukhari)
My advice to you and any Muslim brothers and sisters let not quickly jump to conclusions by judging people without understanding their context on any point of their speaks. We not to judge, but to correct them and must not be in public also. Please
With Islam - You dont get the Old Testament & New testament. Those are corruptions of the original revelations given to Jesus and Musa (Peace Be Upon Them).
JP asked "How do I become a muslim, a christian and a jew at the same time?" Hamza said "Become a Muslim" Which means, being a muslim is the best way to have all those religions at once While he should've said "You can't do that, you can only be a Muslim" Which means you can't have all those religions at once, being a Muslim is the only way
For those who are defending Hamza Yusuf, HAVE YOU LOST YOUR MIND?! Go back to Quran and the Sunnah. That is not how prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) called to Islam. Nor was it how he (peace be upon him) told his companion to call to Islam. It was narrated from Ibn 'Abbas that the Prophet sent Mu'adh bin Jabal to Yemen and said: "You are going to some people from among the people of the Book. Call them to bear witness that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that I am the Messenger of Allah. If they obey you in that, then teach them that Allah has enjoined upon them five prayers every day and night. If they obey you in that, then teach them that Allah has enjoined upon them Sadaqah (Zakah) from their wealth, to be taken from their rich and given to their poor. If they obey you in that, then do not touch the most precious of their wealth, and fear the supplication of the one who has been wronged, for there is no barrier between it and Allah, the Mighty and Sublime." أَخْبَرَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ الْمُبَارَكِ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا وَكِيعٌ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا زَكَرِيَّا بْنُ إِسْحَاقَ، - وَكَانَ ثِقَةً - عَنْ يَحْيَى بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ صَيْفِيٍّ، عَنْ أَبِي مَعْبَدٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم بَعَثَ مُعَاذَ بْنَ جَبَلٍ إِلَى الْيَمَنِ فَقَالَ " إِنَّكَ تَأْتِي قَوْمًا أَهْلَ كِتَابٍ فَادْعُهُمْ إِلَى شَهَادَةِ أَنْ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ اللَّهُ وَأَنِّي رَسُولُ اللَّهِ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ فَأَعْلِمْهُمْ أَنَّ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ افْتَرَضَ عَلَيْهِمْ خَمْسَ صَلَوَاتٍ فِي كُلِّ يَوْمٍ وَلَيْلَةٍ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ فَأَعْلِمْهُمْ أَنَّ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ قَدِ افْتَرَضَ عَلَيْهِمْ صَدَقَةً فِي أَمْوَالِهِمْ تُؤْخَذُ مِنْ أَغْنِيَائِهِمْ فَتُوضَعُ فِي فُقَرَائِهِمْ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ لِذَلِكَ فَإِيَّاكَ وَكَرَائِمَ أَمْوَالِهِمْ وَاتَّقِ دَعْوَةَ الْمَظْلُومِ فَإِنَّهَا لَيْسَ بَيْنَهَا وَبَيْنَ اللَّهِ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ حِجَابٌ " . it is not that Muslims are Jewish. Rather before Jewish went astray, they were upon tawheed. So they were Muslim: - they worshiped Allah alone without associating partner with Him. That is what prophet Musa (peace be upon him) was upon, that is what prophet Jesus (peace be upon him) was upon. and that is what ALL THE PROPHETs called to: To single out Allah in all act of worship and not associate any partner/deity with Him. They were All Muslims. Also Hamza Yusuf is a Sufi!! Not someone to take the knowledge of Quran and the Sunnah from because he isn't even upon the correct teaching of Islam. May Allah guide us and protect us from these types of deviated speakers.
Shamsi I love your videos but if you can get a better microphone that can provide clearer audio that will be better as sometimes I'm driving and it's hard to understand without reading your lips when I'm not watching the video directly
Hamza yusuf was trying to answer from a different perspective. There was nothing wrong with his answer in my opinion and he’s not to be blamed in the least.
Your opinion is rejected BaarakAllaahu feekum. You can't become a muslim without denouncing all the other religions, because Islam is the only religion that will lead you to Allaah's mercy, Judaism and Christianity are clear distortions, one can not be a muslim without denouncing them, and once he does he is no longer a Jew or a Christian but rather a Muslim like Abraham, Musa, Isa and all the other prophets. So the idea that Islam somehow contains Judaism and Christianity is a false statement, the truth is the absolute opposite. The deserving answer to the question that was asked would be, 'no, you can't be a Jew, a Christian and a Muslim at the same time, because truth mixed with falsehood is not truth.'
No one cares about your opinion or that deviant Hamza Yusuf. People are fallible and limited in their knowledge, whereas Allaah سبحانه و تعالى is All-knowing. He is perfect and so is His revelation (the Qur'an and the Sunnah). Hence, we measure everything with the Book and the Sunnah, and if you're pathetic opinion doesn't go in line with it, it belongs in the bin.
Jordan Peterson spoke with the wrong people Hijab and Hamza Yousef so he got exposed to a distorted vision of islam. One of the educated salafi brothers should speak to him and teach him about islam
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
I understand what Hamza Yusuf is trying to say but it came out wrong. He should of said “Truly the religion with Allah is Islam” and no other religion would be accepted from him. But as usual he’s pandering
ليت تترجم هذه الحلقة فيه بضع مقاطع ما فهمتها...للاسف كنت معجبة بحمزة يوسف ثم وجدته يلمز في السعودية ثم تتبعته و وجدته انه درس عند الصوفيه وانه تبنى فكرهم فطبيعي هؤلاء الناس يكرهون اهل السنة والجماعة
To all of those justifying the error of Hamza Yusuf, Questions define answers and answers don't define questions because question always give way to answer unless the answer is talking about another thing entirely and that won't make it fit for the question. I assume everyone understands the question and I'm sure the asker understands the fundamental differences between the three religions to some extent and that's why he said “ I'm trying to figure out ”. Islam recognizes the books that were given to Prophet Musa and prophet Īsa but Judaism and Christianity branched out of the pristine teachings of those books which eventually made them into another religion entirety. So it'll be Impossible to unite the three religions because the books they rely upon differ and don't try to look it from the angle of the fact that Islam recognizes the books that were given to those before us because Judaism and Christianity are not based on the pristine teachings of those books, but look it from the angle of what Judaism and Christianity in their entirety are based upon .
نعم حمزة يوسف واحد اشعري صوفي ضال لكن عندما قال لجوردن ان الطريقة لتصبح يهودي ومسيحي ومسلم في ان واحد هو ان تكون مسلم ، لم يكن كما فهمته يا اخ شمسي بارك الله فيك ، انا جات في بالي انه يقصد في اليهودية يحبون موسى ويتبعون موسى وفي المسيحية يحبون عيسى ويتبعون عيسى ، فبكونك مسلم فانت تحبهما وتتبعها ، وليس المقصود الشرائع المحرفة طبعاً. والله أعلم.
أخي الكريم لو أجابتنا ماذا قال الله عن إبراهيم ؟ يهودية و النصرانية ليس لها علاقة بدين الرسل عليهم الصلاة و السلام فالمسلم يجب أن يقول لا يقبل الله دين إلا الإسلام و اليهودية و النصرانية مخالف للإسلام في الأصول فضل عن الفروع فجواب حمزة جواب رجل منبطح.
أخي الكريم لو أجابتنا ماذا قال الله عن إبراهيم ؟ يهودية و النصرانية ليس لها علاقة بدين الرسل عليهم الصلاة و السلام فالمسلم يجب أن يقول لا يقبل الله دين إلا الإسلام و اليهودية و النصرانية مخالف للإسلام في الأصول فضل عن الفروع فجواب حمزة جواب رجل منبطح.
@@DUSDawah نعم كلامك سليم وصحيح بلا شك بخصوص إن اليهودية والنصرانية لا علاقة لها بدين الرسل لكن لعل طريقة حمزة يوسف في إجابته أو في صياغة إجابته هي المشكلة هنا، أنا لم يخطر لي أبداً إن حمزة يوسف يتحدث عن الديانة الإبراهيمية في إجابته تلك ولم أسمع أحد ينتقد إجابته من الدعاة المشاهير الذين تتكلم عنهم لإني توقعت المقصد واضح من طريقة جريان هذه المحادثة بين حمزة وجوردن ، فبالنسبة لجوردن ومتابعيه من غير المسلمين فاليهودي هو الذي يتبع موسى والنصراني الذي يتبع عيسى ، فنعم سؤال جوردن كان عن الدين الابراهيمي بدون التصريح بذلك علناً ولكن كانت اجابة حمزة يوسف بمعنى ان لا تكون متبعاً للدين الابراهيمي الجديد بل تكون مسلم فقط ، وهذه الطريقة لتجمع فيها محبة هؤلاء الرسل وتتبعهم ، لان المسلم يتبع إبراهيم وموسى وعيسى ومحمد عليهم الصلاة والسلام فالدين عند الله هو الإسلام وهؤلاء رسل الإسلام وليست هذه الشرائع المحرفة مثل اليهودية والنصرانية. نفس ما يقول ذاكر نايك في محاضراته : المسلمين أكثر نصرانية من النصارى أنفسهم إن كانت النصرانية إتباع عيسى عليه الصلاة والسلام. والله أعلم.
Beware from Hamza Yusuf and from defending him, in the past he has praised the west (secularism) and then proceeded into mocking the Islamic Shari'ah (Hudud). This is only a brief example of his deviancy, but there are much more. الله المستعان.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
I like brother hamza but shamsi is right. He could of just stuck to explaining islam but he keeps on trying to connect islam with christianity and Judaism. We have the best and most truthful religion we don't say we're Judaism for gentiles we're Muslims period.
سورة آل عمران مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَٰكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ ﴿٦٧﴾ Surah Aali 'Imran 67. Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was a Monotheist, a Muslim. And he was not of the associators.
@@إلياسابننورالدين brother ilyas I agree alhamdulillah. What i was saying is don't pick on brother hamza if you could understand my point there may allah bless you and your family.
The religion is not up to interpretation. The call of the Prophets and Messengers is the call to Tawheed, the worship of one God alone without any partners. What the brother Hamza said is entirely wrong and is not something the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم ever called to (The uniting of religions). The religion of all the Prophets and Messengers is Islam and they all called their people to "Laa Ilaaha Illallah", never uniting corrupted beliefs with the pure revelation they received. As the brother Shamsi mentioned, the meaning of what Allah says in the Qur'an; "Truly, the religion with Allah is Islam. Those who were given the Scripture (Jews and Christians) did not differ except, out of mutual jealousy, after knowledge had come to them. And whoever disbelieves in the Ayat (proofs, evidences, verses, signs, revelations, etc.) of Allah, then surely, Allah is Swift in calling to account" [3:19]. So we cannot unite our pure Islam with other corrupted beliefs. As it pertains to da'wah, the meaning of the verses in the Qur'an; "Your companion (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) has neither gone astray nor has erred. Nor does he speak of (his own) desire." [53:2-3]. Da'wah is not given from desires rather, it is given how the Prophet gave it with evidence from the Qur'an and the Sunnah. This is also how the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, gave da'wah and so we should follow their way. Barakallahu feekum
" Islam is a universalized Judaism". Hamza Yusuf has clearly lost his mind. This is not the teaching of the Qur'an or from the Sunnah. What was the religion of Adam, Seth, Noah, Saleh, Hud and every other prophet?
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
رَضيـتُ بِاللهِ رَبَّـاً وَبِالإسْلامِ ديـناً وَبِمُحَـمَّدٍ نَبِيّـاً . (ثلاث مرات) Raḍītu billāhi Rabba, wa bil-Islāmi dīna, wa bi-Muḥammadin (ṣallallāhu `alayhi wa sallama) nabiyya.I am pleased with Allah as my Lord, with Islam as my religion, and with Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) as my Prophet. (Recite three times in Arabic.)Reference:"Allah has promised that anyone who says this three times every morning or evening will be pleased on the Day of Resurrection." Ahmad 4/ 337, An-Nasa'i, 'Amalul-Yawm wal-Laylah p. 4, Ibn As-Sunni (no. 68), At-Tirmidhi 5/465. Its chain of transmission is good (Hasan), Ibn Baz, p. 39. Reference : Hisn al-Muslim 87
لا إلهَ إلا اللهُ وَحْدَهُ لا شَرِيكَ لَهُ ، لَهُ المُلْكُ وَ لَهُ الحَمْدُ يُحْيِي وَ يُمِيتُ وَ هُوَ حَيٌّ لا يَمُوْتُ بِيَدِهِ الخَيْرُ وَ إليهي مصير وَهُوَ عَلَى كل شيء قادر وأشهد أن محمدا عبده ورسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم اللهم صل على سيدنا محمد النبي الأمي وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم اللهم لا سهل إلا ما جعلته سهلا وأنت تجعل الحزن إذا شئت سهلا إن شاء الله الله يهدنا 'علامات الساعة في الدين الاسلامي هي مجموعة من الظواهر والاحداث يدل وقوعها على قرب وقوع يوم القيامة ،قسم العلماء المسلمون العلامات إلى قسمين : علامات الساعة الصغرى. علامات الساعة الكبرى. علامات الساعة الصغرى بعثة النبي محمد بن عبد الله . انشقاق القمر وكان هذا في 14 ذو الحجة من السنة الخامسة قبل الهجرة على قول كثير من العلماء. وفاة النبي محمد . ظهور الفحش والتفاحش. قطيعة الرحم. سوء المجاورة. أن يؤتمن الخائن. أن يخون الأمين. أن يصدق الكاذب. أن يكذب الصادق. هلاك الوعول ( الأئمة الكبار). إسناد الأمر إلى غير أهله. قوم بأيديهم سياط كأذناب البقر. انتشار النساء الكاسيات العاريات. خدمة نساء المسلمين نساء الكفار. الصبغة بالسواد ( الشعر واللحية). نزع البركة من الوقت. أن تكلم السباع الإنس. نقص المكيال والميزان. منع الزكاة. نقض عهد الله وعهد رسوله عدم الحكم بكتاب الله. انحسار الفرات عن جبل من ذهب. انتشار الدين وعمومه كافة الأرجاء. مقتل عثمان بن عفان. محاربة اليهود. انتشار الفتن. التنافس على الدنيا. انعدام الأمناء. نزع الأمانة من القلوب. رفع العلم. ظهور الجهل. انتشار الزنا. انتشار شرب الخمر. موت العلماء. استشارة الجهلاء. نقض العهود. كثرة الخيانة. أسعد الناس بالدنيا لكع بن لكع. كثرة الخبث. ظهور القينات والمعازف. إتباع سنن الأمم الأخرى. الخسف. المسخ. القذف. أن يصير السلام للمعرفة. فشو التجارة. كتمان الشهادة. شهادة الزور. قطع الأرحام. ظهور القلم. أن تلد الأمة ربتها (انقلاب الموازين). التطاول في البنيان. إمارة السفهاء. بيع الحكم. الاستخفاف بالقتل. كثرة الشرطة. من لا فقه له يؤم الناس. اتخاذ القرآن مزامير (إمامة المغنى). استتباب الأمن. فتح كنوز كسرى بن هرمز. كثرة المال. ارتكاب الفاحشة على الطريق العام. زخرفة المساجد. تحلية المصاحف وزركشتها. عدم تقسيم الميراث. عدم الفرح بالغنيمة. أن يصبح الولد غيظا. أن يصبح الشتاء قيظا. أن يفيض اللئام فيضا ( أن يكثر اللئام). أن يغيض الكرام غيضا ( أن يقل الكرام) إظهار العلم وتضييع العمل. الحب بالألسن والتباغض بالقلوب. أن يتولى الشرار الأمر. أن يكون الأمر للنساء. أن تكون الأموال في أيدي البخلاء. لا أحد يقول الله الله. أن تعود أرض العرب مروجا خضراء. افتراق الأمة إلى 73 شعبة. أن يتقاتل الناس على المال والدنيا لا على الدين. تدافع الناس للإمامة فلا يجدون من يصلى بهم. إماتة الصلاة. كثرة الطلاق. بيع الدين بالدنيا. موت الفجأة. إطالة المنابر وعلوها. تعطيل الحدود. خراب القلوب. تشبه النساء بالرجال والرجال بالنساء. شهادة المرء من غير أن يستشهد. علو أصوات الفسقة في المساجد. أن يكون المؤمن في القبيلة أذل من النقد. من عمل بعشر ما أمر به نجا. كثرة القذف. ان يفاض المال فلا يقبله أحد. علامات الساعة الكبرى طلوع الشمس من مغربها. خروج الدابة. الدخان. هدم الكعبة وإختفاء القرآن الكريم. المسيخ الدجّال ظهور سيدنا عيسى بن مريم . خروج يأجوج ومأجوج. ظهور الامام المهدي المعركة الفاصلة. خروج ريح طيبة تقبض على أرواح المؤمنين ترتيب العلامات الكبري (يرجى عدم النشر عن الأمور الدينية من غير علم أو من دون التأكد, الريح آخر علامات الساعة و الله أعلم) المعركة الفاصلة. الامام المهدي. المسيح الدجال. ظهور سيدنا المسيح عيسى بن مريم. ظهور يأجوج ومأجوج. موت سيدنا المسيح عيسى بن مريم. خروج الدابة. خروج ريح طيبة تقبض ارواح المسلمين. طلوع الشمس من مغربها ثلاث ايام. اختفاء القران الكريم و هدم الكعبة. خروج نار عظيمة تجمع الناس إلى محشرهم. أرسله للآخرين هـــو ۞ الله ۞ الرحمن ۞ الرحيم ۞ الملك ۞ القدوس ۞ السلام ۞ المؤمن ۞ المهيمن ۞ العزيز ۞ الجبار ۞ المتكبر ۞ الخالق ۞ البارئ ۞ المصور ۞ الغفار ۞ القهار ۞ الوهاب ۞ الرزاق ۞ الفتاح ۞ العليم ۞ القابض ۞ الباسط ۞ الخافض ۞ الرافع ۞ المعز ۞ المذل ۞ السميع ۞ البصير ۞ الحكم ۞ العدل اللطيف ۞ الخبير ۞ الحليم ۞ العظيم ۞ الغفور ۞ الشكور ۞ العلي ۞ الكبير ۞ الحفيظ ۞ المقيت ۞ الحسيب ۞ الجليل ۞ الكريم ۞ الرقيب ۞ المجيب ۞ الواسع ۞ الحكيم ۞ الودود ۞ المجيد ۞ الباعث ۞ الشهيد ۞ الحق ۞ الوكيل ۞ القوي ۞ المتين ۞ الولي ۞ الحميد ۞ المحصي ۞ المبدئ ۞ المعيد ۞ المحيي ۞ المميت ۞ الحي ۞ القيوم ۞ الواجد ۞ الماجد ۞ الواحد ۞ الأحد ۞ الصمد ۞ القادر ۞ المقتدر ۞ المقدم ۞ المؤخر ۞ الأول ۞ الآخر ۞ الظاهر ۞ الباطن ۞ الوالي المتعالي ۞ البر ۞ التواب ۞ المنتقم ۞ العفو ۞ الرءوف ۞ مالك ۞ الملك ۞ ذو ۞ الجلال ۞ والإكرام ۞ المقسط ۞ الجامع ۞ الغني ۞ المغني ۞ المانع ۞ الضار ۞ النافع ۞ النور ۞ الهادي ۞ البديع ۞ الباقي ۞ الوارث ۞ الرشيد ۞ الصبور ۞ اللهم صل وسلم وبارك علي سيد الخلق سيدنا محمد صل الله عليه وسلم إستغفرالله العظيم رب العرش العظيم واتوب اليه 🌼اللهم صل على سيدنا 🌼محمـــــــــد🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد🌼 كما صليت على سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 في العــــــالمين إنك ميد مجيد وبارك على سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد 🌼كما باركت على سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم 🌼وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 في العــــــالمين إنك حميد مجيد 🌼ربي رجوتك في هذا اليوم ان تسعد قلوب أهلي وأحبابي وأصدقائي وكل من يعـرفنيwa la ya3rofouni وتعطيهم ما يتمنـونه وعطّر صـدرورهم بالإيـمان وارزقـهم الخلــود فـي الجــنان وانا معهم يا رحمن... يارب اجعلنا من أهل الرحمة والمغفرة ومن عتقائك من النار اللهم آمـــــين يارب العالمين. اللهم ارزقنا الجنة بغير حساب ولا سابقة عذاب السلام عليكم نصيحة لا تترك صلاتك رغم ذنوبك الله يغفر كل الذنوب
True say, cah he didn’t clarify to Jordan that the previous religions and books have been changed, And Allaah sent Islam and the Quran to clarify the changes and a complete guidance for all mankind, May Allaah guide jordan peterson, all his fan girls (wannabee alpha males) getting to his head and him need some real guidance inna his blood!
Are you open to the possibility that when it comes to intellectual discussions being held in English, you may not be picking up on all the subtle subtexts and linguistic devices being employed? I'm a native English speaker & have been through higher education in English and I didn't understand that part of the discussion the same way you did. Generally speaking, when we aren't totally proficient in a language (at an academic level), we can tend to miss a lot and can get stuck on literal meanings - you'd know yourself that students of Arabic may still miss the meaning of idioms & poetry despite being 'fluent'. I actually don't care much for Hamza Yusuf, but it does appear that your dislike of his actions (not him as a person) has driven you to comment more than anything & you're 'grasping at straws' here?
Could you kindly explain how is it that Mr.hamza's answer conveys a certain meaning yet Shamsi is understanding another? I surely am keen to know what linguistic device and subtext would change the interpretation of "be a Muslim" as an answer to "I want to figure out how to be a Muslim, Jew, and Christian at the same time".
It is amazing how muslims defend hamza yusuf. Alhamdulillah these people who defend hamza yusuf were the people alive at the times of the Salaf because if they were, Islam would have been destroyed. How are you defending the man when he said ‘islam is a universal judaism’. Im sorry what?!! Read the Quran O defenders of Hamza yusuf
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Muslim - is the submission to Allah by following the teachings and revelations of Prophet Muhammad. This automatically cancels out any relations of being a jew and a christian since they have thier own and unique teachings. its again the 3 in 1 thing🤦♂
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Shamsi you should try to get on to Jordan Peterson. I know you wouldn't fold or sugar coat anything. Forget trying to make them believe that all the religions are the same when they're not. Just explain islamic ways and if he likes it great and if he doesn't oh well it's his loss not the muslims loss.
For those saying Shamsi misunderstood Hamza Yusuf answer, was not Peter Jordan question literal? He said he is trying to figure out how to become a jew/Christian/Muslim? You can't be.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Is this guy for real? He clearly misinterpreted what Hamza Yusuf said and just going on a rant as usual. This is actually so ignorant and disrespectful.
@@nancy4615 Muawiyah and all those with him. Revolting against a rightly guided caliph is a Bid'ah. He also instituted family rule and tried to make it like a kingdom.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Sorry but you have completely twisted what Hamza Yusuf was saying. He never said you can combine. Go back and see what Sheik Hamza Yusuf said... he said be a Muslim in response to " how can you be Jewish and Christian. " and then he gave examples of similarities like ghusl. Just because he did not clarifiy the differences between the religions doesn't mean he said you can combine the religions. Because he clearly did not. Seriously wish you would have had a video call with Hamza Yusuf and asked him to clarify. As Muslims thats what we should do. Instead of jumping to conclusions. There's clearly room for further explanation here. The statement are not clear cut as you are saying....
السلم عليكم وبارك الله فيك اخي شمسي واصل وبين لهم المنهج الصحيح الذي لا نحيد عنه ابدا كما قال الشيخ الالباني رحمه الله نحن على الكتاب الله وسنة رسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم وعلي منهج السلف الصالح هذا هو المنهج الصحيح (بارك الله فيك)كما يرددها كثيرا الشيخ ربيع حفظه الله.اقصد كلمة بارك الله فيك .اصدع بالحق ولا تدعهم يشوهون ويلقون الشبه كي يدخلوننا في حيرة ولسنا في حيرة ولسنا في شك واصل و ندعو الله عز وجل ان يعينك ويثبتك و يهدي بك كثير من الناس والله نفرح كثيرا عندما نسمعك تستدل بالكتاب والسنة و اقوال السلف الصالح المتقدمين منهم والمتاخرين امثال ابن باز و الالباني وابن عثيمين و الربيع والفوزان ومحسن العباد و النجمي ومقبل وامان الجامي وعبيد الجابري وعبد الله البخاري وغيرهم كثير من علماء السلف الصالح رحم الله من مات منهم وحفظ الله الحي منهم وسلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته .
May Allaah protect us from ever thinking we can combine the Religions.
That’s not what Hamza Yusuf meant 🤦♂️
@@nouyt9144
Wouldn’t it be better to say: “Aameen?”
Amiin
Nou YT replied you according to your intentions.
Of course will say Ameen if this is general speaking.
آمين
May Allah Guide Jordan Peterson to Islam ! Ameen
and May Allah Guide Hamza Yusuf to the right path!
Ameen
May Allah guide us all... you included.
Aameen
I do not agree with everything Hamza says but you are off here and misunderstood the context and angle of his response. He meant that by being a Muslim he will get to keep the believe in all prophets and scriptures.
Well, he said that in response to a specific question of how one can be a Jew, Christian and Muslim simultaneously. You can't be all three at the same time, because they all have different set of opposing beliefs and practices. So either he didn't answer the question or he wasn't clear in his answer and made general vague statements in order to appease Jordan and his audience, which is deception.
@@ivviiv6763 true
@@ivviiv6763 He could have just said no, that's not possible. But he chose to answer this sly question for what it was and with follow up statements that are true: You get to keep the faith in all scriptures and prophets. So in that way you can still be "Jew" or "Christian". Yes it was to appeal to him while still answering and making him feel inclusive without crossing the line. That was his nature of intent by he should have approached this differently, one should be very clear and concise with statements when it comes to deen, especially aqeedah.
The religion accepted to Allah is only Islam
Yeah cuz Jordan obviously knows you can’t be all 3 at once and he didn’t mean that literally
Jazakallāhu khairan wa barakatuhu Feekum.
Make series on Sharh Sunnah of Imam Barbahari
Also Khallq ul Afal lil Ibad of Imam Bukhari, it will be much appreciated.
Jazza Kallah Khairn.
Watch the video again, you haven’t learned much I see
Or usool assunnah of imaam al humaidi رحمه الله
thanks for the explanation shamsi..barokAllahu fiikum...
أسأل الله العفوا و العافية
جزاك الله خير اخي شمسي
Hamza Yusuf means by this to say that when you recognize all prophets regardless of origin, then you are universal as a Muslim. Hamza Yusuf does not want to exclude anyone in this way of explanation, it is an intelligent answer.
He is deludere a soufi that doesn’t have the correct Aqeeda. Believes Allah is everywhere Aootu billah and believes in shirk and innovation. Nothing intelligent about what he says or does.
And what was the outcome of his “intelligent answer”? Nothing but confusion which was apparent in Jordan Peterson’s video. May Allah guide Humza Yusuf - Islam is not a religion where we need to play with words to make it sound appealing. Be proud of the truth of Islam and say it as it is and you will see the people entering Islam in droves. Not because of how we worded it, but because of the truth of the religion
Yes but he could have been more explicit on that because people who are not familiar with Islam can get a wrong image, it is very important to be correct and if we make mistakes that our brothers and sisters point that out to prevent spreading falsehood. It’s good that Shamsi pointed that out but it is always important not to attack someone personally and proceed like our beloved prophet salallahu wa Allahi wa salam with highest emotional intelligence.
So he didn't answer Peterson's question which was how he can be a Jew, Christian and a Muslim simultaneously. So he answered a question which he wasn't even asked. So, how is it intelligent?
No you are wrong his response was not intelligent.
Hamza Yusuf shouldn't have been apologetic about it and should have just straight out said that all these religions contradict each other therefore you can't be all at the same time, and should have started explaining that Judaism is practically about a tribal god, Christianity is about a man-god dying on a cross, and Islam is about the Supreme, King of Kings.
inferior complex, tell them what they desire and lose your hereafter.
Perhaps Jordan Peterson learnt wrong about islam because these ikhwanis have reached out to him.
Jordan Peterson asked this question on purpose, coz I'm sure he knows you can't be a Muslim, Christian and a Jew at the same time.
Wallahi, I was disappointed when no one was criticizing Hamza being there. For him to be even taken as any kind of authority in Islam is from the greatest of jokes in the world.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
@@sharifhaque4722 so scholars make matters even more confusing?
@@SaidB1n no, it’s just people who do not have a higher educational standpoint should not be listening to his talks otherwise you will confuse it. He uses very high level words and wording.
I also noticed this and the water baptism !! Machallah brother shamsi don't miss 👌 😍 ❤️
Shamsi you should make a second video further explaining for all the people who didn’t understand since there seems to be a lot of them.
This brother doesn't miss 👏🏾
Never!!!!! He is so real wallahi
May Allah keep him firm and may he give him reward him
But he missed on this one cause thats not what he meant.
@@redman1300
That's what he means , hamza Yusuf been dragged over this for years, he believes in such heresies.
@@redman1300 He didnt miss lmao
Everyone misses
SubhanAllah, MashaAllah
Great video my brother , beautiful message and response
جزاكم الله خيرا
Great explaination from you.
Barakallah oufikum
You don't really understand. He's talking to a non-muslim so it's not as easy to explain it to him as explaining it to a Muslim. I'm not attacking you brother but you are extremely aggressive and your aggression made you misunderstand.
So you reject the way of the Prophet Muhammad, just to please the non-muslims?
The prophet also called to non Muslims, but he didn’t mix religions with them
He wants one but not at the price of the other *
Allaahumma barik wa barakallaahu feek my dear brother may Allaah give you Jannatul Firdows so beautifully explained.
Love from Kashmir Brother Shamsi..i watched dt video of Hamza yousuf and jordan peterson..you didnt correct only Hamza yousuf you also corrected me as well...thanks bro..May Allah bless you
جزاك الله خيراً أخي شمسي
بارك الله فيك
I don't think hamza yusuf is saying it literally. The old torah zabor injeel were all old books of a muslim a mumin.
We all understand the question, no matter how the answer is rebranded it is still wrong. Had it been Judaism and Christianity are entirely based upon the pristine teachings of the books that were given to Prophet Musa and prophet Īsa which will eventually make their followers to be Muslims and neither Jew nor christian, then his answer would've been close to being correct and not still fully right because there wouldn't have been Judaism and Christianity in the first place .
The ‘Christians’ before Muhammad (صل الله عليه وسلم) were Muslims. So why describe a believer in Allaah’s final messenger as a Jew, a Christian and Muslim combined in one when the prophet said:
"May Allah's Curse be on the Jews and the Christians for they build places of worship at the graves of their prophets." (Al Bukhari)
This guy has absolutely no wisdom and had completely missed the point.
I don't think Hamza Yusuf meant that literally. He was talking about the fact we follow the truth from all those religions.
*إِنَّ ٱلدِّينَ عِندَ ٱللَّهِ ٱلْإِسْلَٰمُ ۗ*
السلام عليكم
Does Abu Iyad حفظه الله have his own website were lectures, series etc are gathered? Question to anyone.
Just subscribed
My advice to you and any Muslim brothers and sisters let not quickly jump to conclusions by judging people without understanding their context on any point of their speaks. We not to judge, but to correct them and must not be in public also. Please
Jazakallahu khayr Shamsi for speaking the truth.
جزاك الله خيرا
❤❤❤❤
With Islam - You dont get the Old Testament & New testament. Those are corruptions of the original revelations given to Jesus and Musa (Peace Be Upon Them).
Brother your 100% correct! Don't compromise Islam to please the none Muslims
Shamsi Khutbah from yesterday at Daar us-Sunnah:
ruclips.net/video/HGMU6g-sVqY/видео.html
Jazakallahu khair
That's exactly what Hamza Yusuf said, Become a Muslim...
JP asked "How do I become a muslim, a christian and a jew at the same time?"
Hamza said "Become a Muslim"
Which means, being a muslim is the best way to have all those religions at once
While he should've said "You can't do that, you can only be a Muslim"
Which means you can't have all those religions at once, being a Muslim is the only way
hamza yusuf is professional bidah promotor
For those who are defending Hamza Yusuf, HAVE YOU LOST YOUR MIND?! Go back to Quran and the Sunnah. That is not how prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) called to Islam. Nor was it how he (peace be upon him) told his companion to call to Islam.
It was narrated from Ibn 'Abbas that the Prophet sent Mu'adh bin Jabal to Yemen and said:
"You are going to some people from among the people of the Book. Call them to bear witness that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that I am the Messenger of Allah. If they obey you in that, then teach them that Allah has enjoined upon them five prayers every day and night. If they obey you in that, then teach them that Allah has enjoined upon them Sadaqah (Zakah) from their wealth, to be taken from their rich and given to their poor. If they obey you in that, then do not touch the most precious of their wealth, and fear the supplication of the one who has been wronged, for there is no barrier between it and Allah, the Mighty and Sublime."
أَخْبَرَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ الْمُبَارَكِ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا وَكِيعٌ، قَالَ حَدَّثَنَا زَكَرِيَّا بْنُ إِسْحَاقَ، - وَكَانَ ثِقَةً - عَنْ يَحْيَى بْنِ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ صَيْفِيٍّ، عَنْ أَبِي مَعْبَدٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عَبَّاسٍ، أَنَّ النَّبِيَّ صلى الله عليه وسلم بَعَثَ مُعَاذَ بْنَ جَبَلٍ إِلَى الْيَمَنِ فَقَالَ " إِنَّكَ تَأْتِي قَوْمًا أَهْلَ كِتَابٍ فَادْعُهُمْ إِلَى شَهَادَةِ أَنْ لاَ إِلَهَ إِلاَّ اللَّهُ وَأَنِّي رَسُولُ اللَّهِ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ فَأَعْلِمْهُمْ أَنَّ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ افْتَرَضَ عَلَيْهِمْ خَمْسَ صَلَوَاتٍ فِي كُلِّ يَوْمٍ وَلَيْلَةٍ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ فَأَعْلِمْهُمْ أَنَّ اللَّهَ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ قَدِ افْتَرَضَ عَلَيْهِمْ صَدَقَةً فِي أَمْوَالِهِمْ تُؤْخَذُ مِنْ أَغْنِيَائِهِمْ فَتُوضَعُ فِي فُقَرَائِهِمْ فَإِنْ هُمْ أَطَاعُوكَ لِذَلِكَ فَإِيَّاكَ وَكَرَائِمَ أَمْوَالِهِمْ وَاتَّقِ دَعْوَةَ الْمَظْلُومِ فَإِنَّهَا لَيْسَ بَيْنَهَا وَبَيْنَ اللَّهِ عَزَّ وَجَلَّ حِجَابٌ " .
it is not that Muslims are Jewish. Rather before Jewish went astray, they were upon tawheed. So they were Muslim: - they worshiped Allah alone without associating partner with Him. That is what prophet Musa (peace be upon him) was upon, that is what prophet Jesus (peace be upon him) was upon. and that is what ALL THE PROPHETs called to: To single out Allah in all act of worship and not associate any partner/deity with Him. They were All Muslims.
Also Hamza Yusuf is a Sufi!! Not someone to take the knowledge of Quran and the Sunnah from because he isn't even upon the correct teaching of Islam. May Allah guide us and protect us from these types of deviated speakers.
Shamsi I love your videos but if you can get a better microphone that can provide clearer audio that will be better as sometimes I'm driving and it's hard to understand without reading your lips when I'm not watching the video directly
Waalaikumussalam. Aamiin
Camera quality is looking good Masha'Allah
Mashaa Allah akhi
Hamza yusuf was trying to answer from a different perspective. There was nothing wrong with his answer in my opinion and he’s not to be blamed in the least.
Masha Allah.
Everyone has an opinion nowadays
We shouldn't look at our opinions. We follow Allah and His prophet ﷺ. We have scholars today, so take from those that know if you do not know
A different perspective from what/who exactly?
opinions… blame?!
Your opinion is rejected BaarakAllaahu feekum. You can't become a muslim without denouncing all the other religions, because Islam is the only religion that will lead you to Allaah's mercy, Judaism and Christianity are clear distortions, one can not be a muslim without denouncing them, and once he does he is no longer a Jew or a Christian but rather a Muslim like Abraham, Musa, Isa and all the other prophets. So the idea that Islam somehow contains Judaism and Christianity is a false statement, the truth is the absolute opposite. The deserving answer to the question that was asked would be, 'no, you can't be a Jew, a Christian and a Muslim at the same time, because truth mixed with falsehood is not truth.'
No one cares about your opinion or that deviant Hamza Yusuf. People are fallible and limited in their knowledge, whereas Allaah سبحانه و تعالى is All-knowing. He is perfect and so is His revelation (the Qur'an and the Sunnah). Hence, we measure everything with the Book and the Sunnah, and if you're pathetic opinion doesn't go in line with it, it belongs in the bin.
Context is important my brother.
Jordan Peterson spoke with the wrong people Hijab and Hamza Yousef so he got exposed to a distorted vision of islam. One of the educated salafi brothers should speak to him and teach him about islam
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
حفظكم الله أخي شمسي
I understand what Hamza Yusuf is trying to say but it came out wrong. He should of said “Truly the religion with Allah is Islam” and no other religion would be accepted from him.
But as usual he’s pandering
ليت تترجم هذه الحلقة فيه بضع مقاطع ما فهمتها...للاسف كنت معجبة بحمزة يوسف ثم وجدته يلمز في السعودية ثم تتبعته و وجدته انه درس عند الصوفيه وانه تبنى فكرهم فطبيعي هؤلاء الناس يكرهون اهل السنة والجماعة
He responded to be a Muslim because Muslims believe in the prophets of the Jews and Christian’s.
To all of those justifying the error of Hamza Yusuf, Questions define answers and answers don't define questions because question always give way to answer unless the answer is talking about another thing entirely and that won't make it fit for the question.
I assume everyone understands the question and I'm sure the asker understands the fundamental differences between the three religions to some extent and that's why he said “ I'm trying to figure out ”.
Islam recognizes the books that were given to Prophet Musa and prophet Īsa but Judaism and Christianity branched out of the pristine teachings of those books which eventually made them into another religion entirety.
So it'll be Impossible to unite the three religions because the books they rely upon differ and don't try to look it from the angle of the fact that Islam recognizes the books that were given to those before us because Judaism and Christianity are not based on the pristine teachings of those books, but look it from the angle of what Judaism and Christianity in their entirety are based upon .
The term HY was trying to utter was Unity of Religion, because it goes in hand with the doctrine of Unity of Existence.
Was Hamza Yusuf being literal? Was he making similarities between the religions for the non Muslim to comprehend?
For a newbie the choice of words can be misleading though
Lol. He said islam is a universal judaism. Your comment makes no sense
نعم حمزة يوسف واحد اشعري صوفي ضال لكن عندما قال لجوردن ان الطريقة لتصبح يهودي ومسيحي ومسلم في ان واحد هو ان تكون مسلم ، لم يكن كما فهمته يا اخ شمسي بارك الله فيك ، انا جات في بالي انه يقصد في اليهودية يحبون موسى ويتبعون موسى وفي المسيحية يحبون عيسى ويتبعون عيسى ، فبكونك مسلم فانت تحبهما وتتبعها ، وليس المقصود الشرائع المحرفة طبعاً.
والله أعلم.
أخي الكريم لو أجابتنا ماذا قال الله عن إبراهيم ؟ يهودية و النصرانية ليس لها علاقة بدين الرسل عليهم الصلاة و السلام فالمسلم يجب أن يقول لا يقبل الله دين إلا الإسلام و اليهودية و النصرانية مخالف للإسلام في الأصول فضل عن الفروع فجواب حمزة جواب رجل منبطح.
أخي الكريم لو أجابتنا ماذا قال الله عن إبراهيم ؟ يهودية و النصرانية ليس لها علاقة بدين الرسل عليهم الصلاة و السلام فالمسلم يجب أن يقول لا يقبل الله دين إلا الإسلام و اليهودية و النصرانية مخالف للإسلام في الأصول فضل عن الفروع فجواب حمزة جواب رجل منبطح.
@@DUSDawah نعم كلامك سليم وصحيح بلا شك بخصوص إن اليهودية والنصرانية لا علاقة لها بدين الرسل لكن لعل طريقة حمزة يوسف في إجابته أو في صياغة إجابته هي المشكلة هنا، أنا لم يخطر لي أبداً إن حمزة يوسف يتحدث عن الديانة الإبراهيمية في إجابته تلك ولم أسمع أحد ينتقد إجابته من الدعاة المشاهير الذين تتكلم عنهم لإني توقعت المقصد واضح من طريقة جريان هذه المحادثة بين حمزة وجوردن ، فبالنسبة لجوردن ومتابعيه من غير المسلمين فاليهودي هو الذي يتبع موسى والنصراني الذي يتبع عيسى ، فنعم سؤال جوردن كان عن الدين الابراهيمي بدون التصريح بذلك علناً ولكن كانت اجابة حمزة يوسف بمعنى ان لا تكون متبعاً للدين الابراهيمي الجديد بل تكون مسلم فقط ، وهذه الطريقة لتجمع فيها محبة هؤلاء الرسل وتتبعهم ، لان المسلم يتبع إبراهيم وموسى وعيسى ومحمد عليهم الصلاة والسلام فالدين عند الله هو الإسلام وهؤلاء رسل الإسلام وليست هذه الشرائع المحرفة مثل اليهودية والنصرانية.
نفس ما يقول ذاكر نايك في محاضراته : المسلمين أكثر نصرانية من النصارى أنفسهم إن كانت النصرانية إتباع عيسى عليه الصلاة والسلام.
والله أعلم.
Beware from Hamza Yusuf and from defending him, in the past he has praised the west (secularism) and then proceeded into mocking the Islamic Shari'ah (Hudud). This is only a brief example of his deviancy, but there are much more. الله المستعان.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Expected this type of reaction and understanding from this gentleman..
Lacking nuance..
may allah sobhanutala make us stay away from these people barakallah fiqum
Brother hamza just tried to give dawah on his own perspective. He said in the way he understood and please don't pick on him.
I like brother hamza but shamsi is right. He could of just stuck to explaining islam but he keeps on trying to connect islam with christianity and Judaism. We have the best and most truthful religion we don't say we're Judaism for gentiles we're Muslims period.
سورة آل عمران
مَا كَانَ إِبْرَاهِيمُ يَهُودِيًّا وَلَا نَصْرَانِيًّا وَلَٰكِنْ كَانَ حَنِيفًا مُسْلِمًا وَمَا كَانَ مِنَ الْمُشْرِكِينَ ﴿٦٧﴾
Surah Aali 'Imran
67. Abraham was neither a Jew nor a Christian, but he was a Monotheist, a Muslim. And he was not of the associators.
Your brother hamza yusuf is utterly and absolutely deluded May Allah guide him to the correct Aqeeda and manhaj
@@إلياسابننورالدين brother ilyas I agree alhamdulillah. What i was saying is don't pick on brother hamza if you could understand my point there may allah bless you and your family.
The religion is not up to interpretation. The call of the Prophets and Messengers is the call to Tawheed, the worship of one God alone without any partners. What the brother Hamza said is entirely wrong and is not something the Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم ever called to (The uniting of religions). The religion of all the Prophets and Messengers is Islam and they all called their people to "Laa Ilaaha Illallah", never uniting corrupted beliefs with the pure revelation they received. As the brother Shamsi mentioned, the meaning of what Allah says in the Qur'an; "Truly, the religion with Allah is Islam. Those who were given the Scripture (Jews and Christians) did not differ except, out of mutual jealousy, after knowledge had come to them. And whoever disbelieves in the Ayat (proofs, evidences, verses, signs, revelations, etc.) of Allah, then surely, Allah is Swift in calling to account" [3:19]. So we cannot unite our pure Islam with other corrupted beliefs. As it pertains to da'wah, the meaning of the verses in the Qur'an; "Your companion (Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم) has neither gone astray nor has erred. Nor does he speak of (his own) desire." [53:2-3]. Da'wah is not given from desires rather, it is given how the Prophet gave it with evidence from the Qur'an and the Sunnah. This is also how the Companions, may Allah be pleased with them, gave da'wah and so we should follow their way. Barakallahu feekum
" Islam is a universalized Judaism".
Hamza Yusuf has clearly lost his mind. This is not the teaching of the Qur'an or from the Sunnah.
What was the religion of Adam, Seth, Noah, Saleh, Hud and every other prophet?
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
رَضيـتُ بِاللهِ رَبَّـاً وَبِالإسْلامِ ديـناً وَبِمُحَـمَّدٍ نَبِيّـاً .
(ثلاث مرات)
Raḍītu billāhi Rabba, wa bil-Islāmi dīna, wa bi-Muḥammadin (ṣallallāhu `alayhi wa sallama) nabiyya.I am pleased with Allah as my Lord, with Islam as my religion, and with Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) as my Prophet. (Recite three times in Arabic.)Reference:"Allah has promised that anyone who says this three times every morning or evening will be pleased on the Day of Resurrection." Ahmad 4/ 337, An-Nasa'i, 'Amalul-Yawm wal-Laylah p. 4, Ibn As-Sunni (no. 68), At-Tirmidhi 5/465. Its chain of transmission is good (Hasan), Ibn Baz, p. 39.
Reference : Hisn al-Muslim 87
It's Shaikh Hamza Yusuf ..... Have some respect.
For someone who's supposedly knowledgeable. Hamza should be able to answer these simple questions better
It doesn't matter, he's a deviant. And nobody should be taking knowledge from a deviant.
@@ivviiv6763 of course I agree. Its a shame the sufis hold him in such high esteem
True talk
لا إلهَ إلا اللهُ وَحْدَهُ لا شَرِيكَ لَهُ ، لَهُ المُلْكُ وَ لَهُ الحَمْدُ
يُحْيِي وَ يُمِيتُ وَ هُوَ حَيٌّ لا يَمُوْتُ بِيَدِهِ الخَيْرُ وَ إليهي مصير وَهُوَ عَلَى كل شيء
قادر
وأشهد أن محمدا عبده ورسوله صلى الله
عليه وسلم اللهم صل على
سيدنا
محمد النبي الأمي
وعلى آله وصحبه وسلم
اللهم لا سهل إلا ما جعلته سهلا وأنت تجعل
الحزن إذا شئت سهلا
إن شاء الله الله يهدنا
'علامات الساعة في الدين الاسلامي هي مجموعة من الظواهر والاحداث يدل وقوعها على قرب وقوع يوم القيامة ،قسم العلماء المسلمون العلامات إلى قسمين :
علامات الساعة الصغرى.
علامات الساعة الكبرى.
علامات الساعة الصغرى
بعثة النبي محمد بن عبد الله .
انشقاق القمر وكان هذا في 14 ذو الحجة من السنة الخامسة قبل الهجرة على قول كثير من العلماء.
وفاة النبي محمد .
ظهور الفحش والتفاحش.
قطيعة الرحم.
سوء المجاورة.
أن يؤتمن الخائن.
أن يخون الأمين.
أن يصدق الكاذب.
أن يكذب الصادق.
هلاك الوعول ( الأئمة الكبار).
إسناد الأمر إلى غير أهله.
قوم بأيديهم سياط كأذناب البقر.
انتشار النساء الكاسيات العاريات.
خدمة نساء المسلمين نساء الكفار.
الصبغة بالسواد ( الشعر واللحية).
نزع البركة من الوقت.
أن تكلم السباع الإنس.
نقص المكيال والميزان.
منع الزكاة.
نقض عهد الله وعهد رسوله
عدم الحكم بكتاب الله.
انحسار الفرات عن جبل من ذهب.
انتشار الدين وعمومه كافة الأرجاء.
مقتل عثمان بن عفان.
محاربة اليهود.
انتشار الفتن.
التنافس على الدنيا.
انعدام الأمناء.
نزع الأمانة من القلوب.
رفع العلم.
ظهور الجهل.
انتشار الزنا.
انتشار شرب الخمر.
موت العلماء.
استشارة الجهلاء.
نقض العهود.
كثرة الخيانة.
أسعد الناس بالدنيا لكع بن لكع.
كثرة الخبث.
ظهور القينات والمعازف.
إتباع سنن الأمم الأخرى.
الخسف.
المسخ.
القذف.
أن يصير السلام للمعرفة.
فشو التجارة.
كتمان الشهادة.
شهادة الزور.
قطع الأرحام.
ظهور القلم.
أن تلد الأمة ربتها (انقلاب الموازين).
التطاول في البنيان.
إمارة السفهاء.
بيع الحكم.
الاستخفاف بالقتل.
كثرة الشرطة.
من لا فقه له يؤم الناس.
اتخاذ القرآن مزامير (إمامة المغنى).
استتباب الأمن.
فتح كنوز كسرى بن هرمز.
كثرة المال.
ارتكاب الفاحشة على الطريق العام.
زخرفة المساجد.
تحلية المصاحف وزركشتها.
عدم تقسيم الميراث.
عدم الفرح بالغنيمة.
أن يصبح الولد غيظا.
أن يصبح الشتاء قيظا.
أن يفيض اللئام فيضا ( أن يكثر اللئام).
أن يغيض الكرام غيضا ( أن يقل الكرام)
إظهار العلم وتضييع العمل.
الحب بالألسن والتباغض بالقلوب.
أن يتولى الشرار الأمر.
أن يكون الأمر للنساء.
أن تكون الأموال في أيدي البخلاء.
لا أحد يقول الله الله.
أن تعود أرض العرب مروجا خضراء.
افتراق الأمة إلى 73 شعبة.
أن يتقاتل الناس على المال والدنيا لا على الدين.
تدافع الناس للإمامة فلا يجدون من يصلى بهم.
إماتة الصلاة.
كثرة الطلاق.
بيع الدين بالدنيا.
موت الفجأة.
إطالة المنابر وعلوها.
تعطيل الحدود.
خراب القلوب.
تشبه النساء بالرجال والرجال بالنساء.
شهادة المرء من غير أن يستشهد.
علو أصوات الفسقة في المساجد.
أن يكون المؤمن في القبيلة أذل من النقد.
من عمل بعشر ما أمر به نجا.
كثرة القذف.
ان يفاض المال فلا يقبله أحد.
علامات الساعة الكبرى
طلوع الشمس من مغربها.
خروج الدابة.
الدخان.
هدم الكعبة وإختفاء القرآن الكريم.
المسيخ الدجّال
ظهور سيدنا عيسى بن مريم .
خروج يأجوج ومأجوج.
ظهور الامام المهدي
المعركة الفاصلة.
خروج ريح طيبة تقبض على أرواح المؤمنين
ترتيب العلامات الكبري
(يرجى عدم النشر عن الأمور الدينية من غير علم أو من دون التأكد, الريح آخر علامات الساعة و الله أعلم)
المعركة الفاصلة.
الامام المهدي.
المسيح الدجال.
ظهور سيدنا المسيح عيسى بن مريم.
ظهور يأجوج ومأجوج.
موت سيدنا المسيح عيسى بن مريم.
خروج الدابة.
خروج ريح طيبة تقبض ارواح المسلمين.
طلوع الشمس من مغربها ثلاث ايام.
اختفاء القران الكريم و هدم الكعبة.
خروج نار عظيمة تجمع الناس إلى محشرهم.
أرسله للآخرين
هـــو ۞ الله ۞ الرحمن ۞ الرحيم ۞ الملك ۞ القدوس ۞ السلام ۞ المؤمن ۞ المهيمن ۞ العزيز ۞ الجبار ۞ المتكبر ۞ الخالق ۞ البارئ ۞ المصور ۞ الغفار ۞ القهار ۞ الوهاب ۞ الرزاق ۞ الفتاح ۞ العليم ۞ القابض ۞ الباسط ۞ الخافض ۞ الرافع ۞ المعز ۞ المذل ۞ السميع ۞ البصير ۞ الحكم ۞ العدل اللطيف ۞ الخبير ۞ الحليم ۞ العظيم ۞ الغفور ۞ الشكور ۞ العلي ۞ الكبير ۞ الحفيظ ۞ المقيت ۞ الحسيب
۞ الجليل ۞ الكريم ۞ الرقيب ۞ المجيب ۞ الواسع ۞ الحكيم ۞ الودود ۞ المجيد ۞ الباعث ۞ الشهيد ۞ الحق ۞ الوكيل ۞ القوي ۞ المتين ۞ الولي ۞ الحميد ۞ المحصي ۞ المبدئ ۞ المعيد ۞ المحيي ۞ المميت ۞ الحي ۞ القيوم ۞ الواجد ۞ الماجد ۞ الواحد ۞ الأحد ۞ الصمد ۞ القادر ۞ المقتدر ۞ المقدم ۞ المؤخر ۞ الأول ۞ الآخر ۞ الظاهر ۞ الباطن ۞ الوالي المتعالي ۞ البر ۞ التواب ۞ المنتقم ۞ العفو ۞ الرءوف ۞ مالك ۞ الملك ۞ ذو ۞ الجلال ۞ والإكرام ۞ المقسط ۞ الجامع ۞ الغني ۞ المغني ۞ المانع ۞ الضار ۞ النافع ۞ النور ۞ الهادي ۞ البديع ۞ الباقي ۞ الوارث ۞ الرشيد ۞ الصبور ۞ اللهم صل وسلم وبارك علي سيد الخلق سيدنا محمد صل الله عليه وسلم إستغفرالله العظيم رب العرش العظيم واتوب اليه 🌼اللهم صل على سيدنا 🌼محمـــــــــد🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد🌼 كما صليت على سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 في العــــــالمين إنك ميد مجيد وبارك على سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد🌼 وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 محمـــــــــد 🌼كما باركت على سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم 🌼وعلى آل سيدنا🌼 إبراهيم🌼 في العــــــالمين إنك حميد مجيد 🌼ربي رجوتك في هذا اليوم ان تسعد قلوب أهلي وأحبابي وأصدقائي وكل من يعـرفنيwa la ya3rofouni وتعطيهم ما يتمنـونه وعطّر صـدرورهم بالإيـمان وارزقـهم الخلــود فـي الجــنان وانا معهم يا رحمن...
يارب اجعلنا من أهل الرحمة والمغفرة ومن عتقائك من النار
اللهم آمـــــين يارب العالمين.
اللهم ارزقنا الجنة بغير حساب ولا سابقة عذاب
السلام عليكم
نصيحة لا تترك صلاتك رغم ذنوبك
الله يغفر كل الذنوب
True say, cah he didn’t clarify to Jordan that the previous religions and books have been changed, And Allaah sent Islam and the Quran to clarify the changes and a complete guidance for all mankind, May Allaah guide jordan peterson, all his fan girls (wannabee alpha males) getting to his head and him need some real guidance inna his blood!
Shamsi is the most brilliant Muslim apologist!
You clearly are on some kind of medication!
Are you open to the possibility that when it comes to intellectual discussions being held in English, you may not be picking up on all the subtle subtexts and linguistic devices being employed? I'm a native English speaker & have been through higher education in English and I didn't understand that part of the discussion the same way you did. Generally speaking, when we aren't totally proficient in a language (at an academic level), we can tend to miss a lot and can get stuck on literal meanings - you'd know yourself that students of Arabic may still miss the meaning of idioms & poetry despite being 'fluent'. I actually don't care much for Hamza Yusuf, but it does appear that your dislike of his actions (not him as a person) has driven you to comment more than anything & you're 'grasping at straws' here?
lol. if he did not understand what sheikh hamza said i doubt he will understand what you are saying.
Could you kindly explain how is it that Mr.hamza's answer conveys a certain meaning yet Shamsi is understanding another? I surely am keen to know what linguistic device and subtext would change the interpretation of "be a Muslim" as an answer to "I want to figure out how to be a Muslim, Jew, and Christian at the same time".
Bro. You misunderstood Hamza Yusuf. Ppl that listened to him already understood his point.
It is amazing how muslims defend hamza yusuf. Alhamdulillah these people who defend hamza yusuf were the people alive at the times of the Salaf because if they were, Islam would have been destroyed. How are you defending the man when he said ‘islam is a universal judaism’. Im sorry what?!! Read the Quran O defenders of Hamza yusuf
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
and all you saying he should've said this and that, try to arrange your own interview and show the world your brilliance.
Muslim - is the submission to Allah by following the teachings and revelations of Prophet Muhammad. This automatically cancels out any relations of being a jew and a christian since they have thier own and unique teachings. its again the 3 in 1 thing🤦♂
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
this takes is embarassing, either you have something against Hamza Yusuf or just struggles with basic english that you lost the context of his answer
Its the first part , trust me
Shamsi you should try to get on to Jordan Peterson. I know you wouldn't fold or sugar coat anything. Forget trying to make them believe that all the religions are the same when they're not. Just explain islamic ways and if he likes it great and if he doesn't oh well it's his loss not the muslims loss.
This brother totally missed the point of the original comment from HY
This brother is just speaking blindly i don't understand this people now
Nothing wrong with what he said
I wanted to listen, but your mic is distorting so much I couldn’t handle it.
For those saying Shamsi misunderstood Hamza Yusuf answer, was not Peter Jordan question literal? He said he is trying to figure out how to become a jew/Christian/Muslim? You can't be.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
Baraklahoufik
Brother Shamsi some advise ... please get audio quality better. Alot of audio is 'clipping'. Try to perserve you message for the long term.
You sadly misunderstood Hamza's point.
This is the problem with the Muslim ummah. Look at all the idiots jumping on the bandwagon in the comment section.
Jesus is the Word -Holy Quran 3:45 True or False?
Is this guy for real? He clearly misinterpreted what Hamza Yusuf said and just going on a rant as usual. This is actually so ignorant and disrespectful.
I guess not ignorant but a very short view.
That’s the problem when Someone from the bidah tries to represent the believe of the salaf
You think no one from the salaf did any Bid'ah? Lol
@@blackflag6976
Who from the Salaf committed a Bid'ah?
@@blackflag6976 😅erm the salaf were not mubtadiah my guy
@@blackflag6976 audhubillah just to excuse this people of falsehood, you accuse the Sahaba Subhanallah. May Allah guide you
@@nancy4615 Muawiyah and all those with him. Revolting against a rightly guided caliph is a Bid'ah.
He also instituted family rule and tried to make it like a kingdom.
Where did Shamsi study?
Because they try and water down the deen akhi barakhlpifiq
You should really slow on talking. Try to sound clear so listeners can hear you well.
كم من عائب قولا صحيحا * واّفته من الفهم السقيم
You just jump without knowing the context of his point
👍 fame versus truth. Smashed it.
Storm in a teacup
well hamza yusuf is sufi, what do you expect from him.
Sorry I I think u misunderstood what Sh. Hamza yusuf meant. When he speaks, he speaks very intellectually and DYNAMICALLY, there are many meanings behind it. That’s why some advanced scholars you might not understand what they are saying because there is a lot of context behind it as he carefully chooses what word he uses. He knows exactly what he is saying.
I think you misunderstood him brother
Honestly I thought Abraham was neither a Jew nor Christian And not Muslim Rather an Arab?
Islam is the third testament right was it already before the Prophet? Bless them
How is what he said = combining religions??
You misunderstood him
Brother, I'm your fan but definitely misunderstood Hamza
Sorry but you have completely twisted what Hamza Yusuf was saying. He never said you can combine. Go back and see what Sheik Hamza Yusuf said... he said be a Muslim in response to " how can you be Jewish and Christian. " and then he gave examples of similarities like ghusl. Just because he did not clarifiy the differences between the religions doesn't mean he said you can combine the religions. Because he clearly did not.
Seriously wish you would have had a video call with Hamza Yusuf and asked him to clarify. As Muslims thats what we should do. Instead of jumping to conclusions. There's clearly room for further explanation here. The statement are not clear cut as you are saying....
He is obv jealous of hamza yousafs success
In short, What you are saying is right but u have a narrow vision of giving Dawa.
السلم عليكم وبارك الله فيك اخي شمسي واصل وبين لهم المنهج الصحيح الذي لا نحيد عنه ابدا كما قال الشيخ الالباني رحمه الله نحن على الكتاب الله وسنة رسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم وعلي منهج السلف الصالح هذا هو المنهج الصحيح (بارك الله فيك)كما يرددها كثيرا الشيخ ربيع حفظه الله.اقصد كلمة بارك الله فيك .اصدع بالحق ولا تدعهم يشوهون ويلقون الشبه كي يدخلوننا في حيرة ولسنا في حيرة ولسنا في شك واصل و ندعو الله عز وجل ان يعينك ويثبتك و يهدي بك كثير من الناس والله نفرح كثيرا عندما نسمعك تستدل بالكتاب والسنة و اقوال السلف الصالح المتقدمين منهم والمتاخرين امثال ابن باز و الالباني وابن عثيمين و الربيع والفوزان ومحسن العباد و النجمي ومقبل وامان الجامي وعبيد الجابري وعبد الله البخاري وغيرهم كثير من علماء السلف الصالح رحم الله من مات منهم وحفظ الله الحي منهم وسلام عليكم و رحمة الله و بركاته .