This really hits home with me, because my Dad was an early 'Christian' Evangelical. But before he drank that Kool-Aid, he taught me how to read AND how to question authority (by giving me wrong answers and forcing me to correct him).
@@Ashley-lm4nv That is an excellent question! Because exercising doubt ensures that you understand the true things, as they will always be able to defend themselves, and avoid the false things, because they will fail or refuse to defend themselves. Accepting something which is not true as true can very easily kill you. Without being able to judge if something is true or not, you become totally at the mercy of anyone who tells you anything or any emotion you feel. You become incapable of figuring out what is dangerous and what is helpful.
I went through the same exact thing. And also a very specific man of god(clergyman) who not only helped my brain to convert to atheism but whooped its ass faster along the way. Going to Catholic school is the best way to convert devout believers into vehement atheists.
I agree with George 💯 I m an atheist but I was baptized and raised a Irish Roman Catholic. Catholism is actually the root of the problem.....for me as a critical thinking human being who subscribes to the scientific method as it is based on empirical evidence not "faith", all religions are nonsense.....relics of a time when humans needed to make sense of the world around them! Christianity is the biggest bullshit of them all for obvious reasons....
Well that's normal. Catholicism isn't Christianity. It's a secular organization that just wants your money and puts your life in mans hands not god. I dont need to light candles and say a hail mary etc a priest cannot absolve you of your sins nor can any of the patron saints of Catholicism 🤣🤣🤣 preach the bible without reading it. Just as bad as jehovah witnesses. Worship god and the bible, but doesn't believe in the holy trinity of the bible father, son, holy spirit. Big part of the bible nah we dont believe that. Sorry if you are Catholic you don't believe in god you believe in the church.
@@kobochy8108 I understand what you are saying but Catholicism is NOT SECULAR and it is a branch of Christianity just like the Protestant church of England. To say something is secular is to imply it is completely separate from the Church. Just like Government should be but is not in most countries... The Catholic Church is basically an extension of the Roman empire as it was them who established it!
@@buddhapilled1993 u basicly agree with napoleon xD by making poor people thinking that it prevents them to think about why not just murder the rich assholes, this "in ur next life ur better them then" makes them stay in line and be brave poor workerbees
I've always had problems with Catholicism, as well, in Sunday school. I asked the teacher where God came from and why there is so much evil in the world if God is defined to be 1. All-loving and 2. Omnipotent. They pretty much said, it's part of our faith and it's a mystery which isn't a compelling answer at all. But I still believed in this nonsense to some degree until the year 2010 when I started watching videos from the atheist experience. At the same time, I was arguing for the existence of God in the comments section, but the replies seemed more potent and robust than the spectacularly weak arguments that I put forth. So, that was the initiation of my deconversion.
I was raised Irish Catholic. I was kicked out of Catkism. Sorry cant spell. In 4th grade. Why? When my mother found out she was not mad at me. She just wanted to know why. We went to the school and the teacher told her that i disrupted the class because i asked to many questions. I was not that smart. All i knew was the story i am getting makes no sense.
I was also raised Catholic, it's amazing how many people it manages to turn away without any outside influence. I wasn't convinced by anybody or anything except my own mind, working opposite of what I was being "taught"
Witnessing the youth experiencing Self reflection is amazing. Lol She was speechless. Thumbs up for inspiring critical thinking!! The world needs more of this right now.
That's what happens to kids when you propagate such a major lie upon them. I can't believe that black people especially still cling to this bullshit story that was foist on them by the white man trying to keep them down.
@@dangr123 and you're full on triggered 😂. Dude honestly I just came here to say I thought she took it well anyways. She laughed and was open minded. 🙄 before you go full on blog on me I'm an agnostic atheist who has a good foot in the anti theist camp myself. Oh who am I kidding. You won't read it this far. Not like it matters anyways =) I'm just trolling a troll, and today that's you my friend. Just settle down a little and vent it on the Jehovah's Witnesses that wake you up knocking on your door like an adult.
Agreed. She's, what, 20-ish years old? Two decades and not ONCE has she even HEARD the idea that her particular religious beliefs might not be true. So much so that even reading the title "Religion is Bullshit", it never crossed her mind that it might be about how religion itself -- not just the people who practice it -- is bullshit. Like... that's just keeping her chained to Plato's cave...
I figured it out when I was 11. On my own. By reading the entire bible and concluding it was not something I was going to base my belief on. Made no sense.
Perle Demenia perhaps I would’ve figured it out earlier had I actually had the determination to read all of it like I had planned to many times in elementary school
Survivor Soul I was trying to decide if I wanted to push my parents to let me go to public school instead of the strict religious school I was in all my life. I switched in 6th grade after reading the Bible over the summer (and becoming an atheist). I had to read (and learn) the entire science and social studies text books the first few weeks of school as my knowledge was so lacking. Thankfully I’d been taught mathematics and English (just the basics, no literature). Luckily I was well read in fiction and history so I knew quite a bit from that. IMO religion is a cult. I decided that 40 years ago and haven’t changed my mind.
@@Codex7777 Not just some Irish ancestry. If you look up Carlin's ancestry, you will see that all of his grandparents were immigrants from Ireland. So yes, he was American, but he was also Irish. Not in nationality, but in ethnicity.
Ignoto Uno I’m Christian and i love George. Doesn’t mean what he said didn’t hurt at some point because obviously he’s directly insulting something that we’ve come to love and circulate our lives around... but half of it was legitimately true and the truth doesn’t always feel good.
I'm Christian and some of the the thing he did hurt me a little on the inside. But there are somethings he said that made me laugh. Like that "all those prayers happen on Sunday...his day off". Jokes like that are fine with me...but I thing on some of the others jokes he goes to far. I get it there are supposed to be jokes but just because it's a "joke" don't mean its ok. But I don't hate him for saying all of that this is a place of Freedom and Democracy. I know George was raised Catholic but I think he changed his mind with time. But on that note I liked the reaction keep it up.
@Curious George George Carlin was telling jokes. Anyone who took him seriously doesn't understand comedy nor religion. Anyone who gets hurt feelings from comedians clearly shouldn't be watching them. Carlin's jokes are very clearly exaggerations and distortions, that's what makes them funny. But for those who thought he was profound, I'll debunk his routine. 1. First distortion - God is not an invisible man, He's a Spirit who has no gender. The bible uses he so that we can relate. Now if Carlin was talking about Jesus, he's not invisible either. We can't see him because he's in heaven and we ain't, duh. 2. Second distortion - God doesn't have a list of 10 things he doesn't want us to do. He has a list of 1; if you want his presence, don't sin. Sin isn't allowed in his presence. 3. God doesn't send you to hell. Like sin, hell is a choice. If you like to sin then you choose to go where sinners go. Meanwhile God has given us the antidote for sin. Blaming him if you don't take it is like blaming the doctor for your death because you rejected his medical advice. 4. God doesn't need money. Blaming God because men use religion to get rich is like blaming a car manufacturer because someone purposely hit you with their car. 5. War, disease, death, poverty, hunger etc... are the result of man choosing sin. Wipe out sin, all this stuff goes away. We have the remedy. 6. You can see the sun but you can't explain how it came to exist. So you believe in an invisible explanation to the origin of the universe. Good for you. 7. God literally tells us to pray without ceasing. How is it impolite to pray when he actually tells you too? 8. Prayer is in the divine plan. We are supposed to pray according to God's word. "Thy kingdom come, thy will be done." If you pray against his will he's not obligated to give you what you ask for. 9. Prayer is not a grocery list nor a letter to Santa. Prayer is communication with God by which you get to know him and find his will. Clearly the Joe Pesci part was made up but let's say Joe Pesci did get rid of your neighbor problem. How do you know God didn't send Joe Pesci with the baseball bat? It could have been in the divine plan. 10. Considering that the objective of prayer isn't about getting what you want but is about getting to know God, there is no way of measuring it's success rate. 11. Why would God strike the audience dead in answer to an atheist's prayer? God isn't in the business of filling atheists' request. 12. Carlin challenging God to strike him dead is like a 6 year old kid challenging the President of the United States to nuke him. Why would POTUS respond to a kid's death wish?
It's wonderful seeing people trying to sit down and watch something that literally is in complete contradiction to their entire world view, it's really quite brave. Big love xx
Nothing brave about watching a comedian. I used to watch Carlin all the time when he was alive.If you don't know the difference between jokes and theology that's on you.
@Balder I remember studying early Buddhist atheist philosophy and thinking to myself, "hmmm this dude says about the same thing as Jesus, but tosses most of the religious metaphysics and oppression, is way more clear and direct, said way more, and his intellectual descendents not only weren't all dicks but many actually advanced Buddhist philosophy, hmmm I think it's time for a change."
Literally everyone who ever existed sinned lmao everyone but Jesus! He had to die! GOD PAID the price himself to get us into heaven! Look at the world lmao there are a lot of bad people but honestly the vast majority are getting saved "my father's kingdom has many mansions"! They are for us even the lgbt Jesus died for your sins too 😂😂😂😂😂 and if anyone ever says he didn't just ask them? Are you calling Jesus a liar! Cause that's literally blasphemy and should put their self righteous ass in there place! Lmao! Jesus died for the sins ALL SINS! God did not create us to torture us forever lmao! But if your one of them rich man and Lazarus types! MR burns, Lex Luthor type ass motherfucker! You better REPENT! OR YOUR GONNA FRY FOREVER.
organized religion, sucks I agree. Jesus is where its at... and the fact that he gave his life for you, to forgive your sins that washes you white as snow. all you have to do is believe and accept the gift of salvation that he offers. carlin denies christ's death on the cross, that's obvious. the second carlin breathed his last on this planet, is the second he realized that he made a poor decision.. an afterlife apart from christ- exactly where you don't want to be... think beyond your life here and now ladies and gents.. believe on the name of the lord Jesus Christ and be a new person, with the assurance of living forever in heaven worshipping the king of kings. don't think for a second carlin was correct in his opinions, read the book of John in the new testament and see for yourselves-- peace
@@kdesjarlais8200 And that is your opinion. And you are free to believe it. But just because you believe it doesn't mean it's true. But if you're belief in a deity helps you to be a good person, then I am happy for you. Because in the end, being a good person is what this world truly needs (but, no god(s) are necessary to be a good person).
@@kdesjarlais8200 Any god that says "Love me and do what I want or suffer forever until the end of time" isn't worth worshiping in my eyes. That's not love, thats just a threat. Plus being the all knowing deity that god is, he already knows every single person that ever has and ever will sin. He knows this, but he creates these people, and then when they sin exactly the way he already knew they would beforehand because he is all knowing, he punishes them with eternal torture anyway. Please explain how that is love in any way, because it seems kind of fucked up to me.
Christianity began as sun worship, the stories about Jesus are symbolic. He is just a personification of the sun, made into a god figure later on. The sun "dies" for 3 days on December 22nd, the winter solstice, when it stops its movement south, to be born again or resurrected on December 25th, when it resumes its movement north. In some areas, the calendar originally began in the constellation of Virgo, and the sun would therefore be "born of a Virgin" The sun rising in the morning is "the saviour of mankind" The sun is "The light of the World" The sun "walks on water" is just the reflection of the sun on water/the sea. "He cometh on clouds, and every eye shall see him", is just sun rays. Jesus' "crown of thorns" is just the sun's glare, also know as a halo. The sun's "followers", "helpers" or "disciples" are the 12 months and the 12 signs of the zodiac or constellations, through which the sun must pass. The sun at 12 noon is in the house or temple of the "Most High": thus.."he" begins "his Father's work" at "age" 12. The sun enters into each sign of the zodiac at 30 degrees, hense, the "Sun of God" begins his ministry at "age" 30. The sun is hung on a cross or "crucified", which represents its passing through the equinoxes. The vernal equinox being Easter, at which time it is then resurrected. The reason why saviour myths are so similar with a godman who is crucified and resurrected, who does miracles and has 12 disciples, is that these stories were based on the movements of the sun through the heavens, an astrotheological development that can be found throughout the planet, because the sun and the 12 zodiac signs can be observed around the globe. In other words, Jesus Christ and all the others upon whom this character is predicated are personifications of the sun, and the Gospel fable is merely a rehash of a mythological formula revolving around the movements of the sun throug the heavens. .
@@marshallc.t.2554 No, dropping religion is never the wrong decision. Religion is the state of mind of believing in something without proof. Science is the state of mind believing in something we CAN prove.
The light is coming on in her head and that's what's scaring her she's starting to get it. she's starting to understand what he was talking about. He on the other hand is concentrating on the comedy aspect of it and is totally ignoring the context of what George is saying., he's in deep and for him it will be a long journey to the surface. It's like when your kid when it's younger it's always asking why it's not 2 pester you it's just because they actually want to understand., the problem is we don't have the answers.
The part that really had her thinking was when George talked about prayers not being answered and people saying, well, it was Gods will. Well, if it's Gods will why are you praying to begin with? Which is a very good analogy.
@@gurujr Nope. Man created both. Thousands upon thousands of gods, for as long as there have been people, everywhere there have been people. Making up gods is just something people do in a vain attempt to explain something they have no understanding of. Every single god is just peoples unwillingness to accept their own ignorance.
@@SarthorS In fact in the beggining we invented animisim, worshiping the forces of nature like animals, rivers, forests, lightnings, etc. Then came the gods, in many shapes and forms, usually in groups called pantheons, polytheism (greek pantheon, roman pantheon, Phoenician pantheon, etc... these gods were almost human with flaws like us and there were things you could learn from them. Then came God (hebrews, christians and muslims, yes all these people follow the same god, funny right?), all was set in stone, almighty, all knowing, nothing to learn from it, and all went to shit.
@@thekageryuu776 I was with you till the end. As bad as the Abrahamic religions are, there were many that came before (and after) that were so much worse.
Christian’s do question it. I mean I guess they just haven’t told you. But they do. I questioned it for decades and turned from it while knowing it is true. Finally I returned recently. Don’t think people are just ignorant
Ex-muslim here, my only comment is, just watch religious comedy, as much as you can. As long as you're thinking and laughing like in this video, that's the main thing.
@@hareecionelson5875 everyone is a regular person until they have a tittle, dosent matter if is a belive or job, but point is, that saying that youre an ex-something is a bit odd, i dont find much people that does that, but whatever
@@redscul129 Are you so surprised that in the comments section of a video mocking religion there are people who talk about how comedy caused them to become atheist? And even people with titles are still regular people, it's not an "either or". Nor is it odd for people who were once religious to refer to themselves as 'ex'.
It's a hard pill to swallow. Took me 25 years to fully accept my loss of faith. Every time I heard an argument that flew in the face of The Bible, I simply told myself "I can find an explanation for this, gotta keep my faith" or simply ignore it until, well, I couldn't anymore.
@@Serai3 literally their written "word" that has been blindly followed for thousands of years. There are similarities, but the contradictions are even worse. How could a Christian or Catholic say that Gandhi will never be allowed into Heaven because he was Hindu and had a different belief system, yet did more for thousands upon thousands of his people PEACEFULLY than anyone of ANY other religion???
@@jasonholtzapfel9635 None of what you said answers my question. But that's okay. You're clearly more interested in showing off what you think you know about religion rather than answering what I asked.
Yeah you could literally have faith in anything because it requires no backing. Such an insulting way to undermine your own intelligence, if you ask me
@@andyfrancis1048 You realize that science is entirely built on faith also... there are many many assumptions that are at the very basis of science. Doesn't make it any less valid..
My man, a Christian, just laid out the whole “gotta have faith” reasoning and followed it up with “that’s the hustle.” Even got that look from his girl. That’s the hustle, indeed.
Haha, yeah, she had no idea that was going to be the ending comment! First, she looked nervous and concerned about what Carlin said, then he explains the "gotta have faith" and she seemed calmed and convinced, then he drops the last comment and the terror creeps back in.
@@christaylor7916 He's a true religious person, and understands what religion is all about. That's rare. You just gotta pick to either believe it even though there's no evidence, or not. There's no debating or countering arguments, when there are none that can prove it or disprove it. People that use arguments for this are not reasonable, the guy in this video is.
@@christaylor7916 What's the problem? You either believe it or not, that's really all there is to it. There's no proof for either god's existence or not, that is known to man. All the fancy and gruesome details people invent around it is superfluous. They do it as a group/identity thing, not as a religion, per se.
OMG, he doesn't ACTUALLY pray to Joe Pesci. He was just trying to make a point. That said, kudos to both of you for watching something with at least a little bit of an open mind. Many believers would not be willing to do that. If faith can't stand up to the slightest bit of scrutiny, it must be pretty flimsy to begin with.
As a kid I saw him as an atheist and the thought process is he is going to hell and those who listen to him is in danger of joining him. I no longer see it that way but that's how I use to view George and none believers. Now I am more agnostic in my views.
Girls reaction was hilarious "who hurt them" because she think if you don't believe in god you are broken in some way. I come from religious family and grew out of it when i was teenager because realized it was only my emotional side that needed it for not feeling lonely etc. When i saw that it was only feelings based and stopped caring so much how other people would maybe guilt trip me for not believing, it was easy to let go and move on.
*People disagree with her* "What's wrong with these people? Who hurt them?" It's a comedy show honey, they aren't hurt. They're having a good ass time.
Its the same as if we said "what is wrong with these people?" For believing the bs that is religion. As someone not from there it amazes me how many Americans still believe all that crap to this day.
The literal definition of faith is the complete abdication of logic. Read something else that isn't the bible, and question everything you read and learn.
@Ai7A The Grey Jedi It's hard to believe in a god who is supposed to be the most enlighted being and sees eveyone in every level when he's so ensecure that he would send anyone who praise "fake gods" instead of him. This sound more like a freakn Light Novel where the "god" or "gods" are just people who are extremely powerful that needs "faith" as some sort of power source for their abilities so that's why they are mad on anyone of his followers that praise other "gods". And yes any "good christian" can refute GC but as he said, the only evidence they can present is the bible itself. Which defeat the purpose since the bible isn't an evidence, it's a claim of something.
heard that, but not sure if that is really true, if you replace religion with ideology (which religion is for me) then it would be correct.... just my opinion
@@markspencer4385 You are quite correct, some good books on how average Germans, every day people, came to do evil things as Nazi's. Same thing under Lenin too no doubt, or Mao etc.
" We can contend with the evil that men do in the name of evil, but may the heavens protect us from the evil that men do in the name of good", Herrodias ancient Greek scholar, his words ring as true today as they did in his times.
This might be the most astonishing reaction video I've ever seen. One person who's been around, been a Christian for a long time, thought about stuff and worked it out, and a young person who's never been confronted with these ideas before, each bringing their own perspective to this very confrontational bit. I've watched it multiple times, and it's eye-opening every time. Really cool video.
I was raised irish catholic. Got kicked out of catycism?. When i was in 4th grade. Why? Cause i asked to many questions. I was a normal kid. I was being told a story that didnt nake sense. When my mother asked why i was kicked out. My asking questions upset the class. So i was being punished cause the bs that i am being told is lame.
Losing one's faith is the most liberating experience possible. It's like clearing fog from a window that's been fogged for years. Carlin is doing god's work here 😉
More George Carlin, he was raised Irish catholic in Hell’s Kitchen NY.all of his art is gold. He makes you look at things from a different perspective. Great reaction guys 👊👊
mrscary3105 He was for me and my father as well. I’ve been watching his standup since my dad introduced me to him in 1994 when I was only 10. I actually had tickets to see him live for the first time ever in October 2008. It felt like losing a family member but I’m so glad his wisdom lives on in his books, interviews and specials. He was one of a kind! RIP George 😢
Irish comedian Dave Allen (huge in the UK in the 70's) also questioned the ridiculousness of religion. Father Ted was even more biting but in a hilarious way. There SHOULD be questions on religion because religion is responsible for more war death than any other reason,so its kind of important to not only question it,but examine it thoroughly. Faith in stories from a 2000 year old book proclaiming a supreme creator is in very short supply these days and people are increasingly believing their eyes. I cannot put a case for ANY religion and i was raised Church of England. George was right....question EVERYTHING.
It was so refreshing to see a christian who can empathise with other opinions, understand other perspectives while still talking about their personal spirituality. I feel like I could have a theological conversation with you, without being told "I need to be saved". I really wish more christians were like you.
“I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours.” -Stephen Roberts
@@brendanmilligan7778 let her believe what she wants.. it isn’t hurting anyone. I just don’t understand the people here who are getting joy out of someone else’s pain
More than anything, Carlin loved to make people think. He would say anything, frequently offending people, just to make them open their minds and question the world around them. Sometimes it was religion, frequently it was politics, nothing was off limits. He was a true genius.
@Reischa Parker "it's got no God , religion is hypocrisy. Cause I'm not easy come easy go , Jesus's followers were a little high on that weed though, Anyway the wine smells it doesn't really matter to meeeeeeee, to meeeeee"
_“My best advice to anyone who wants to raise a happy, mentally healthy child is: Keep him or her as far away from a church as you can.”_ - Frank Zappa
But you should explain to them why we don't believe in that stuff. Otherwise they'll never develop skepticism and may fall into the religion trap as an adult.
That seems a bit arrogant, why? If you don’t tell them why, (and it needs to be a reasonable why) then they most likely will be religious whether you like it or not.
When I was a kid I struggled with religion. First I couldn't understand why god would make my brother disabled. Then I couldn't understand why, if there is only one god, why are there SOOOOO many religions and why can't we agree on how to worship god. Then I learned in school that slave owners in the US taught specific bible verses to slaves to justify slavery so black people would accept their position. I also learned that black people were not allowed to practice their religion, know their country of origin, or anything about their culture. that was the day I gave up Christianity because I didn't feel it was a religion compatible with black people. it also didn't make sense to me to pray to my oppressor's god for salvage from oppression. Then I learned in school about manifest destiny, the crusades, the Spanish inquisition, and world war ii, and I lived with horrible actions by my government in the name of god and religion. I realized man used the bible, religion, and religious differences to justify their atrocities. I felt even if there was a god, man was too corrupt to be his messenger. I wanted to believe in god, but I saw to much pain in the world. crime, poverty, excessive wealth, war, murder, and death, etc. finally I took a philosophy class in college and one question we debated was is the world the way it is because there is no god, because there is a god who makes the world a world of pain and despair, or because god gave man free will and man creates pain and despair. and if god gave man free will, is this what he intended with that free will. Today, i believe in science and nature. I can see those things and I know they exist. i do not need faith to believe in things i can clearly see and feel. i do not believe in god
For me it was the concept of hell. Imagine you have a daughter that you love more than life. Then if she doesn't obey you or disowns you, you send her to some cellar where people torture her eternally. Why tf would you do that?!? What does that give to you? And this creature that made hell is supposed to be the embodiment of love. Just doesn't work.
@dyuloose thanks. I have beem atheist for 25 years. Religion makes zero sense. But when you are raised with it, you have to go on a journey sometimes to get away from it
I love how people are welcoming me to being an atheist when I am 43 and have been atheist for almost all of my adult life 😂🤦🏾♀️😂🤦🏾♀️😂 i didn't just get here folks 😂😂😂😂 And why welcome me? Being atheist isn't a religion. You guys crack me up 😂😂😂
6:16 George Carlin always makes sense, simply because he's telling the truth, the inconvenient truth that the huge majority of people in this people are terrified of. People would rather live a comfortable lie than an inconvenient truth. This is how sad and pathetic our world is. R.I.P. George. You were right about everything you said.
"The man who prays is the one who thinks that god has arranged matters all wrong, but who also thinks he can instruct god how to put them right" - Christopher Hitchens
Best comedian ever, may he RIP. He was an extremely intelligent man who told it like it is but in a way that had you on the floor laughing your ass off.
Thanks for hosting. I had a good time. The laughter was strong in me. I enjoyed listening to your moderation. Good job. I look forward to my next visit. Be safe and have fun.
@@arbogast4950 You can find self loathing angry people on every part of this planet, "faith" abounds. As an accepting nihilist I find myself consistently more well adjusted than any conflicted theist
Bad evidence or none. It's funny, my friend just moved and a few days ago while unpacking, she found her old high school yearbook. My senior quote was "Belief without evidence is faith; belief against evidence is foolish." How appropriate the timing! :)
@CALEB ALVAREZ You are right that the word has multiple different meanings. When you talk about putting your faith in God the word takes the meaning of trust. You can indeed use faith as a synonymous of trust and be correct, but I often find people trying to switch back and forth between those meanings in the course of an argument when is convenient. I'm specifically referring to faith as when is used as a justification for a belief. In that context faith takes the place of the evidence and becomes the evidence itself. The "evidence of things unseen" I believe is what's mentioned in the bible. In this context, when people have a good reason to believe something, they always use that reason. Its only when this falls short that people start to saying they take things on faith.
They’re both awkward because they know George is talking sense and they can’t refute any of it with logic. See reason guys. Being raised in a religion, is no excuse to stick with it when you’re an adult.
Indeed: tradition and learned doctrine is simply a means to power. There is no truth in something so old ad christianity. It’s all a load of shit. Now how are we supposed to deal with all the misery and torment we have to deal with? Simply accept it as a fact of life. It is ofcourse possible to will yourself free of sin. #sarcasm
What I love about this woman is you can see her thinking, she’s not offended. She’s not upset, she’s thinking, and the fact that she’s still listening is fantastic. I love when people do this.
Except for the "Irish" and the "Catholic", that's me, too. I think the last time I believed in the biblical god I was seven. It took me a few more years to work my way past "well, the bible is clearly bullshit, but someone had to have created all this, so I guess I'm a deist now", to "I guess the Big Bang is no more ludicrous than a creator popping into existence out of nowhere - either way you have the same problem with the first uncaused cause", to "man, evolution sure makes a lot of sense", to "everything makes sense if it's just nature, and nothing makes sense if you add gods to the mix, so how does anyone sustain a belief in the divine in the age of information? Every single thing has a better scientific explanation than a religious one, and the natural view of the world doesn't suffer from half the inconsistencies plaguing the religious view." I finally landed on "organised religion is a bunch of evil, power hungry cunts exploiting the vulnerable, and it must be kept separate from the state at any cost. Also, tax the bastards."
@Alberto Garcia Looking back on this comment to Donald Bird: Perhaps, I was rude. I think it's because I found Voltaire being misrepresented all over this thread. If you're wondering about my own level of Voltaire literacy/awareness, I refer you the post by @zaraki119 kenpachi119 in this same thread. He quotes Voltaire as having said something which was actually written by an online troll in 2009. The same appears to be true with this guy's citation. Where does it come from? He doesn't know. He went to "brainy quotes" .com! Ha! As if brainy people need a website! Real brainy people quote things they've actually read. "Voltaire firmly believed in God." - Daniel Gordon (scholar/expert) see (The Bedford Series in History and Culture: Boston, 1999. Part One: The Duality of Voltaire, Religion, p. 13.) Further, I did searches, peer-reviewed scholarly searches, and I can find no such quote (freeing fools) from Voltaire. However, as stated in the @zarak comment/reply mentioned above, I've only read "Candide," a few scholarly treatments of Voltaire, and a handful of Voltaire's personal letters. Therefore, I could be wrong. Maybe Voltaire said this thing about "freeing fools;" however, a contextual understanding of Voltaire's philosophy makes it obvious that he would be including atheist in such a statement. True skeptics know...they don't know. Fools, well, we see what fools do.
One last note, Donald Bird is exactly why Donald Trump and fake news rule the day. Billy Bob Thornton pointed out to Travis Smiley on an episode of Smiley's old PBS program (which is no longer available online so you'll have to take my word for it) that RUclips and Facebook has mislead morons, making them believe that just because every fool has a voice/platform they should use it. Wrong! Some people should stay quiet. Like Voltaire, I'll keep doing my part to correct this nonsense when I see it.
I like how honest analytical and strong emotionally you both are; I'm an Atheist now but when I was a Christian, many years ago, I found that video looking for comedy on RUclips and found it deeply offensive, because it was true but always thought it'd be better to use other approaches and choice words, but it's Comedy and Genius Georgy always went for the guts, so now it makes sense why he choose that way
The problem is most people raised Christian haven't actually read the whole bible, the making of the Bible and how it was used to justify things like slavery in the early days of America.
Exodus 21,Instructions on how to own another human being as property.And the best part is listening to them bend over backwards to try and justify it,Its laughable.
And Native Americans used what book to justify owning slaves? We know what book the Muslims use for the same purpose. The Romans, Greeks, Egyptians, Incas, Numidians and every civilisation/empire that ever existed practised slavery (btw some still do - apart from the Christians who, after the enlightenment, campaigned against and eventually abolished it!). No credit for that though...
I read the bible 4 times at confirmation camp and came out as satanist XD Holy shit he book of kings was brutal XD Lutherian evencelist bible, don´t know any of catholic or protestant or one of them fucked up cults that belive that islam is catholic hoaxs.
FWPIII How is it sad? She is young. Now she’s heard of it, which that I believe to be sad. I don’t know your age or anything, but I am 100% certain lets say 5 years down the road or something you will have heard of this idea for the first time, but it’s been around for a long time. For that I will say “it’s sad you just heard of it”. Who cares she just heard of it. People learn different view points at different points in there lives. Seriously... Who cares! I’m willing to bet you just learned about Juneteenth? Come on be honest I am 100% sure you have. If not then fine, but you know good and well millions of Americans just learned about it.
@@Nebraska2927You answered your question - It's sad that she's just heard of "it". The options weren't laid out and explained to her when she was a child. If they were she wouldnt be so surprised. At a very young age my parents broke it down for me and gave me a choice. She was indoctrinated as most people are.
As an ex-muslim (atheist now), that’s how the world is sadly. Nothing I could do about not discussing other perspectives with my extremely religious family. So I don’t like putting people like her down.
This was funny to watch... the face of a religious person listening to a guy who’s logic is so good that you just decide to figuratively “ear muff” yourself
This video in a nutshell: - George Carlin: *Making loads of sense* - The girl: *being absolutely oblivious of anyone else's walk of life* - The dad: "How do you do fellow kids?"
Maybe, but at least they are not faking their reaction. Which is a lot better than most channels who you can tell force their "liking" of a person in the video.
Sounds a bit like wishful thinking, my friend. You can't know that. :) I'm an atheist, but as we can see here in the comment section, people often don't loose bias, faith and wishful thinking, just because they got rid of religion. Unfortunately there are a lot of atheists who behave just like the religious. Still a lack of rational arguments and objectivity. :>
It’s a shame people are believing all this nonsense. God gave people “Free Will” and with that there comes destruction. If God wanted everything to be “perfect” God would have to remove the free will aspect and all of us would be perfect robots. God gave us the choice to either believe or not to. Either to do drugs or not to. Either to murder someone or not to. It’s our choice.
@@Nebraska2927 if free will cant exist without evil then it follows that there is no free will in heaven, doesn't it? or do people believe there is evil in heaven? im not trying to be a dick, I am actually curious
Flin Grin Flin Grin Well I would say evil was tolerated at one point in heaven. God did cast Satan and his angels from heaven. Also in 1 Kings 22:19-23 we read of an event happening and evil being tolerated. Revelation 12:5-10 talks about God purging the evil out of heaven. Revelation 21 talks about Heaven after the evil has been purged. Way I see it is there is still free-will, but the intent or desire of evil won’t be there like there was in 1 Kings 22:19-23. To give an example from a worldly perspective is this. For my experience being a Christian when I went to a Christian school or when I’m around Christian friends I can honestly say I never had any kind of desire to do evil or more generically to sin. The only free-will I desired was to do good. The way I see it is this... Yes evil was tolerated at one point in time in heaven. God basically cleaned things up by casting Satan and his angels out of heaven. Now yes there is still free will, but now purity around people the desire won’t be there to sin. Revelation 21:4 says there is no more pain, sorrow, or death.
@@Nebraska2927 wow, what a response! thanks =) "Way I see it is there is still free-will, but the intent or desire of evil won’t be there like there was in 1 Kings 22:19-23." - doesnt this imply that we can have free will AND be free of evil?
to believe in the religion he's talking about and have such an open mind to at least hearing what he has to say without dismissing it immediately is very impressive. good video, and the audio sounds great with headphones!
And a quick Google search reveals.. "Technically, “Catholic” (when capitalized) refers to the Christian Church founded by Our Blessed Lord on the Apostle Peter, and his successors (the Popes in Rome); while “Roman Catholic” only refers to a Catholic in the diocese of Rome." I also grew up Catholic and I've heard it called Roman Catholic many times, although technically it's incorrect...
@Dl hello ? is anybody there ? the light doesn't seem to be on in the house things ARE answered , just putting a god in the singularity ... isn't a fucking ''answer'' the rest is all cooked and served , my friend ... don't need to know where the gas comes from yet , but we'll get the answer to that one too
And Carlin wasn't "testing his faith": he was an Atheist who had no faith in religion. He was making the point that it doesn't matter if you pray to anyone/anything or not: sometimes you'll get what you want and sometimes you won't. In that regard, prayer is completely useless.
As an agnostic, I distance myself from atheists. People who are convinced that god exists, don't like to be made a laughing stock of from people who basically rubbish religion. Sarcastic witty piss taking is not something a believer can associate with. Many atheists ridicule god squaders because logic and reality of life, over-ride fantasy figures. but if you rub people's noses in it, you'll never get them to think freely, they will only put their guard up, and turn on the ignorant light.
@@garthreid7114 I'm an Agnostic Atheist, not a pure Atheist, and was a Christian for 20 years of my life. I am respectful to Theists when they're respectful to me. Sadly, most (particularly Christians) are not and have a stereotype of who I am built into their heads (likely from their places of worship). It's only gotten worse over the years as being a "Loud Evangelical Christian" is all the more socially acceptable in rural America where I live in.
Not impressed or just not enjoying the thought train that she'll later tackle. If she stays religious or not its a mental discussion that every human needs to have.
As an atheist, I really appreciated both of your open-minded and thoughtful approach to this subject. Though there were parts of this that visibly made your daughter uncomfortable she never got mad or stopped thinking and her acknowledgment of problems within the church is refreshing and telling of how bright and aware she is. Just found this channel but I'm already a big fan.
You have to understand the eternal purpose. Satan and Christ was in the garden Mankind chose Satan. Tree of life. Tree of knowledge of good and evil. Man messed everything up. Free will
@@randygraham7693 You don't know if any of those statements are true. A HUMAN told you that, and that human was told by a different human, and so on. It's a game of telephone, and we all know how well that goes!
@@randygraham7693 so you mean to say the almighty all-knowing all powerful god didn't know that bloodline of Cain should be stopped. Secondly shouldn't Cain's bloodline end after the flood when only Noah and his family survived so for past 12000-6000(whatever is the consensus on the flood) everything should be as it is in heaven...
@@zgjfinance2796 He's smart. He probably just doesn't want the church ppl coming for him by agreeing TOO much with Carlin. But he's a bit subversive for giving her another perspective. She's a young lady who grew up within church indoctrination. I could be wrong, but I'm guessing that was probably enforced by her mother, her grandparents... her whole family & community. This girl isn't dumb, she's just young and brainwashed. But her dad is doing his part to expand her mind a little. Don't shit on that. I am athiest/agnostic. Please don't give us a bad name by bad mouthing ppl who are just being introduced to the very possibility that they've been fed a big fat lie their whole life. Especially young people.
IKR, was thinking the same thing today. Imagine where the human species would've been if all that manpower, workforce, time and funds were invested in science , smh
@@wesbaumguardner8829 The absolute "blind faith" that religion requires is nothing like government. Usually when faith is discussed as a horrible method to attain knowledge, the "faithful" get butthurt and say something like "everyone believes in something" because they want to falsely conflate belief and faith.
@@JC-jo9bf The blind faith of government is much worse because people do not even realize that they have it and many more people die as a result of government than other religions. People do not recognize the occult symbolism behind government as religious, when in fact, it is. They do not see the black gowns of judges as a high priest's garb. They do not see the judges box as a podium which the God of government's words (law) are espoused to the sinners (defendents.) They do not see elections, inaugurations, addresses, etc. as religious rituals. They do not see the prison terms and executions for what they are: human sacrifice. They do not see the casualties of the foreign peoples whose countries we invade for what it is: human sacrifice. The human sacrifice that is proudly acknowledged is the sacrifice of the lives of the soldiers (soul-diers) we send to invade. As if going halfway across the world and crossing some fictional national border with the consent of a group of corrupt politicians whom profiteer from resources stolen from other people could make it morally correct and good to kill people and plunder their resources. That is the tragedy of the religion of government.
And the only divine plan is that "faith moves mountains"... Doesn't matter which "God"... In fact there's only one... Jehovah, Allah, Shiva are all different names because people in the world speak different languages.
I love that you 2 tackled this....I mean this is SENSITIVE stuff and you tried to come at it objectively. I loved George Carlin because he cracked jokes about everything and anything but he did it intelligently.
She's, what, 20-something? And she's never in her life crossed paths with the idea that God isn't real? I mean I'll believe her if she says that, but I find that surprising. I'm not making fun of her, but she didn't have any response. She was completely unprepared to be confronted by that possibility. Is she aware that atheists exist?
No, he's not, unfortunately. I believe he said in another video (I want to say the Ill Mind Of Hopsin 7 video, but I don't fully recall) he's actually studying to join the clergy or something equally religious like that.
@@0pyrophosphate0 She is now 😂 But after 20-ish years of never being exposed to any ideas that differ from what she was taught over and over again the entire time.... it'll be hard for her to truly analyze these beliefs.
As an Atheist, I can see the rational wheels begin to turn in her head. Although she "appears" incredulous I believe a huuuge seed of doubt has been planted in her beliefs. Wait until she reads Exodus 21 and also realizes the 10 commandments comes after it, lol! Or that "God" instructed Moses to commit Genocide but keep all the "untouched" girls for themselves. Ya done did it dad, it's a wrap!
The best cure for faith is Bible eh? Atheist from poland here I love seeing belivers for the firs time listening to hard brake down of their faith The cogs that are mooving on their own Truly If there is hope for human race It is in those moments Cheers!
@@stephenireland3816 No it doeas not Inteligent desing needs inteliget desiner And this desiner - acording to what you have just said - need to be desin too And you have paradox going into infinity In other words - stop useing bullshit arguments for bullshit ideas The evolution was already prooven - stop clinging to dumb magic book - and move on
@@stephenireland3816 For the love of every black hole in the galaxy You are 100% clasic creationist Eternal god? Bulshit If god is eternal - and have no begining and the end - he/ she/ it - cannot exist, cuz everything must have beggining, as a start of its existance. Logic. Gravity is also a theory - we can only see efects of gravity, not gravity itself Just like evolution - WE SEE EFECTS - and DNA science had proven we have about 90% dna from apes. Soo - yeah - "inteligent desing" my ass If it was inteligent our bodies would be much better than are now. Like you know - they would look as they were desinged, and not evolved from other organizms. Have you heard of nightmare that is birth? Have you seen the god damm numbers of females who died in childbirth before modern medicine? Yahwe must be a total fuckall desiner if he desined this shit. Time travel is imposible - that another point for yal stupid ass But - i will humor you Let say that god do exist What - *ACTUAL* prove you have - that it is YOUR GOD And bible dont count - its was created by nomadic tribe in the desert few milenia ago, just like many others holy books and myths - so this magic book is worth shit in any logical argument. And even better - how can you prove that the real god is not Allah? After all muslims also claim that their god is eternal, alfa i omega, without beginig or the end. And have magic book to prove it. How can you disprove, something that cant be proven? I could say that universe was created by "Star Dragon" - who is eternal, without begining or the end *AND YOU HAVE NO WAY TO DISPROVE THIS* After all, my dragon isint material being, and does not show itself to filfy non-belivers - like yourself I live acording to his laws, and you will be damed for beliving in other uprovable gods ... See the scale of bullshit you were raised to belive in? Chalange yoursef and your faith - if you think it is strong enought. Watch and listen - actualy listen - atheist arguments Or - much simpler - read bible with critical eye - all of it - that helped me God that allows: slavery, genocide, incest and need blood sacrifaces - is boolshit god - and that kind of god Yahwe and many others is presented as. A non-material psyho terrorist - that what your god is. For fucks sake - why people cant find nicer gods? Like of wine and sex? Of freedom and maybe even fun? Why those psyho, blood loving bastards are soo popular? Ah yeah - i know. *THEIR BELIVERS MURDERED THE COMPETITION*
@@hatter3555 lol this whole God BS has Evolved and Grown over the Ages and for it to go away would require maybe about the same Time. Then Again maybe Humanity will never cease their worship of Greater Beings and who knows its God in our Era but Thousand years later something else will take its place and so on till we die out. JUST MAYBE
It's interesting to see when someone is visibly questioning their beliefs. The girl on the right is seriously questioning hers as she's watching this video of George Carlin. Which is absolutely fantastic because without people like George Carlin, people would be mindless toward one perspective and point of view.
Same applies for black muslims. Look up the Arab slave trade if you think otherwise. You just don't talk about it much because it's easier to bash someone who has already admitted the wrongdoing, taken the blame and the shame and doesn't threaten to kill you if you offend their god and religion.
@@cuttight Actually, I think people don't talk about it as much because here in the US, Christianity is the most common religious belief, and has the most influence on people's behavior, education, and national legislation. Of course people will focus on tearing down the institutions that hurt people the most where they live instead of focusing on the ones hurting people elsewhere in the world.
religion is so bullshit , look at the pope and other leaders in what kinda cathedrals they live in with all the goods ,no taxes , really ? the biggest scam in human history !
It's hilarious to me when people like Carlin or the idiots in these comments use the same tired worn out talking points as a case against God. Why is there evil, wars, famine or disease??? All really pathetic talking points and if you actually read the Bible, those are addressed time and again. People want to couple religion and faith into the same thing and it's not by any means. Religion is a creation of man to serve the interest of men, that is a point addressed in the Bible and it also tells you how to know the true intentions of a person. Faith is the knowing that there is a higher power and a reason for everything under the sun. Not to believe in something more important than yourself is a arrogant really pathetic existence to live.
She’s young, indoctrinated, and she’s watching this WITH HER DAD! That in itself is a difficult dynamic, full of tension, need to prove oneself, be obedient, respectful, etc. But she’ll get it, she’s smart. She’ll start asking better questions of herself, various belief systems, religion’s hypocrisy, critical thinking, personal freedom, etc.
Well honestly if people educated themselves on religion, many religions, the history of religion they would realize how similar they are to each other and how many times the Christian story alone has been done, there are at least 2 previous religions with the exact same story, one from east Africa, during the Egyptian era, and an Asian religion hundreds of years before the Egyptian one, they are literally the same story, god sent his son to sacrifice himself for his children of Earth and he was betrayed by close friend, and rose 3 days later to prove himself the son of god.
I really wish you were my youth pastor growing up. You’re very open minded and you also accept and incourage youth to think for themselves even tho you’re Christian. That’s very admirable and you’re doing it right my man 🙌🏼
![Jack Harlow - Hello Miss Johnson [Official Music Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Q86_nlRoIGw/mqdefault.jpg)
"Don’t just teach your children to read,
Teach them to question what they read. Teach them to question everything." - George Carlin
True
This really hits home with me, because my Dad was an early 'Christian' Evangelical. But before he drank that Kool-Aid, he taught me how to read AND how to question authority (by giving me wrong answers and forcing me to correct him).
- Question erverything!!
Me: Why?
"Children must be taught how to think not what to think". ~ Margaret Mead
@@Ashley-lm4nv That is an excellent question! Because exercising doubt ensures that you understand the true things, as they will always be able to defend themselves, and avoid the false things, because they will fail or refuse to defend themselves. Accepting something which is not true as true can very easily kill you. Without being able to judge if something is true or not, you become totally at the mercy of anyone who tells you anything or any emotion you feel. You become incapable of figuring out what is dangerous and what is helpful.
George was actually raised Catholic and even went to Catholic school. He actually credited Catholicism for making him not believe in God
I went through the same exact thing. And also a very specific man of god(clergyman) who not only helped my brain to convert to atheism but whooped its ass faster along the way. Going to Catholic school is the best way to convert devout believers into vehement atheists.
I agree with George 💯 I m an atheist but I was baptized and raised a Irish Roman Catholic. Catholism is actually the root of the problem.....for me as a critical thinking human being who subscribes to the scientific method as it is based on empirical evidence not "faith", all religions are nonsense.....relics of a time when humans needed to make sense of the world around them! Christianity is the biggest bullshit of them all for obvious reasons....
Well that's normal. Catholicism isn't Christianity. It's a secular organization that just wants your money and puts your life in mans hands not god. I dont need to light candles and say a hail mary etc a priest cannot absolve you of your sins nor can any of the patron saints of Catholicism 🤣🤣🤣 preach the bible without reading it. Just as bad as jehovah witnesses. Worship god and the bible, but doesn't believe in the holy trinity of the bible father, son, holy spirit. Big part of the bible nah we dont believe that. Sorry if you are Catholic you don't believe in god you believe in the church.
@@kobochy8108 ah the trusted old no true scotch man fallacy. Well done......
@@kobochy8108 I understand what you are saying but Catholicism is NOT SECULAR and it is a branch of Christianity just like the Protestant church of England. To say something is secular is to imply it is completely separate from the Church. Just like Government should be but is not in most countries... The Catholic Church is basically an extension of the Roman empire as it was them who established it!
"Religion is here so the poor don't murder the rich." -Napoleon Bonaparte
Jesus taught that rich people go to hell
@@buddhapilled1993 u basicly agree with napoleon xD by making poor people thinking that it prevents them to think about why not just murder the rich assholes, this "in ur next life ur better them then" makes them stay in line and be brave poor workerbees
@@buddhapilled1993 Word. Not ALL but it is very difficult near impossible.
George one in life time-all class.
You'll see the truth on judgement day!
I was raised Catholic, I became an atheist on my own. Always questioned everything. George helped me to realize I wasn't alone, thanks George!
I've always had problems with Catholicism, as well, in Sunday school. I asked the teacher where God came from and why there is so much evil in the world if God is defined to be 1. All-loving and 2. Omnipotent. They pretty much said, it's part of our faith and it's a mystery which isn't a compelling answer at all. But I still believed in this nonsense to some degree until the year 2010 when I started watching videos from the atheist experience. At the same time, I was arguing for the existence of God in the comments section, but the replies seemed more potent and robust than the spectacularly weak arguments that I put forth. So, that was the initiation of my deconversion.
Though I'm not Christian since my country (Thailand) majority is Buddhism. But one thing I can agree on is religion is BS
I was same way. The Catholic Religion is a religion of doubt.
I was raised Irish Catholic. I was kicked out of Catkism. Sorry cant spell. In 4th grade. Why? When my mother found out she was not mad at me. She just wanted to know why. We went to the school and the teacher told her that i disrupted the class because i asked to many questions. I was not that smart. All i knew was the story i am getting makes no sense.
I was also raised Catholic, it's amazing how many people it manages to turn away without any outside influence. I wasn't convinced by anybody or anything except my own mind, working opposite of what I was being "taught"
Daughter is about to have an existential crisis
She's thinking about it for sure goddangit!!!lol
Witnessing the youth experiencing Self reflection is amazing. Lol
She was speechless.
Thumbs up for inspiring critical thinking!! The world needs more of this right now.
not at all
@@UpInYourFeelings
Wow, that was nitpicky as hell.
She's definitely experiencing cognitive dissonance... And fighting it hard.
I love how he's laughing and joking while she's having a full blown existential crisis.
Welcome to adulthood, sis! lol
That is exactly what I thought, " welcome to adulthood", hon.
That's what happens to kids when you propagate such a major lie upon them.
I can't believe that black people especially still cling to this bullshit story that was foist on them by the white man trying to keep them down.
@@dangr123 and you're full on triggered 😂. Dude honestly I just came here to say I thought she took it well anyways. She laughed and was open minded. 🙄 before you go full on blog on me I'm an agnostic atheist who has a good foot in the anti theist camp myself. Oh who am I kidding. You won't read it this far. Not like it matters anyways =) I'm just trolling a troll, and today that's you my friend. Just settle down a little and vent it on the Jehovah's Witnesses that wake you up knocking on your door like an adult.
@@zer-op2gq The irony being you went full on blog lol
@@moderusprime hey a silver lining almost everywhere =)
Lol she's never thought about god's existence before. No one in her life has ever questioned that aloud to her. That's... deeply troubling.
Child indoctrination at its finest
Agreed. She's, what, 20-ish years old? Two decades and not ONCE has she even HEARD the idea that her particular religious beliefs might not be true. So much so that even reading the title "Religion is Bullshit", it never crossed her mind that it might be about how religion itself -- not just the people who practice it -- is bullshit. Like... that's just keeping her chained to Plato's cave...
I figured it out when I was 11. On my own. By reading the entire bible and concluding it was not something I was going to base my belief on. Made no sense.
Perle Demenia perhaps I would’ve figured it out earlier had I actually had the determination to read all of it like I had planned to many times in elementary school
Survivor Soul I was trying to decide if I wanted to push my parents to let me go to public school instead of the strict religious school I was in all my life. I switched in 6th grade after reading the Bible over the summer (and becoming an atheist). I had to read (and learn) the entire science and social studies text books the first few weeks of school as my knowledge was so lacking. Thankfully I’d been taught mathematics and English (just the basics, no literature). Luckily I was well read in fiction and history so I knew quite a bit from that. IMO religion is a cult. I decided that 40 years ago and haven’t changed my mind.
"But he loves you" always gets them.
Carlin was 100% Irish and born in the 30’s. He was absolutely raised religiously lol
Nope, he was American, with some Irish ancestry... ;)
He was raised catholic.
@@Codex7777 Not just some Irish ancestry. If you look up Carlin's ancestry, you will see that all of his grandparents were immigrants from Ireland. So yes, he was American, but he was also Irish. Not in nationality, but in ethnicity.
@@Sabersquirl so part Spanish, is what you're saying.
He went to catholic school he told a story about the hispanic priest.
I always appreciate a Christian who can be open-minded, doesn't take everything to serious, and actually listen to what he has to say. Respect.
Agreed. He's not uptight about it.
Ignoto Uno I’m Christian and i love George. Doesn’t mean what he said didn’t hurt at some point because obviously he’s directly insulting something that we’ve come to love and circulate our lives around... but half of it was legitimately true and the truth doesn’t always feel good.
I'm Christian and some of the the thing he did hurt me a little on the inside. But there are somethings he said that made me laugh. Like that "all those prayers happen on Sunday...his day off". Jokes like that are fine with me...but I thing on some of the others jokes he goes to far. I get it there are supposed to be jokes but just because it's a "joke" don't mean its ok. But I don't hate him for saying all of that this is a place of Freedom and Democracy. I know George was raised Catholic but I think he changed his mind with time. But on that note I liked the reaction keep it up.
@Curious George George Carlin was telling jokes. Anyone who took him seriously doesn't understand comedy nor religion. Anyone who gets hurt feelings from comedians clearly shouldn't be watching them. Carlin's jokes are very clearly exaggerations and distortions, that's what makes them funny. But for those who thought he was profound, I'll debunk his routine.
1. First distortion - God is not an invisible man, He's a Spirit who has no gender. The bible uses he so that we can relate. Now if Carlin was talking about Jesus, he's not invisible either. We can't see him because he's in heaven and we ain't, duh.
2. Second distortion - God doesn't have a list of 10 things he doesn't want us to do. He has a list of 1; if you want his presence, don't sin. Sin isn't allowed in his presence.
3. God doesn't send you to hell. Like sin, hell is a choice. If you like to sin then you choose to go where sinners go. Meanwhile God has given us the antidote for sin. Blaming him if you don't take it is like blaming the doctor for your death because you rejected his medical advice.
4. God doesn't need money. Blaming God because men use religion to get rich is like blaming a car manufacturer because someone purposely hit you with their car.
5. War, disease, death, poverty, hunger etc... are the result of man choosing sin. Wipe out sin, all this stuff goes away. We have the remedy.
6. You can see the sun but you can't explain how it came to exist. So you believe in an invisible explanation to the origin of the universe. Good for you.
7. God literally tells us to pray without ceasing. How is it impolite to pray when he actually tells you too?
8. Prayer is in the divine plan. We are supposed to pray according to God's word. "Thy kingdom come, thy will be done." If you pray against his will he's not obligated to give you what you ask for.
9. Prayer is not a grocery list nor a letter to Santa. Prayer is communication with God by which you get to know him and find his will.
Clearly the Joe Pesci part was made up but let's say Joe Pesci did get rid of your neighbor problem. How do you know God didn't send Joe Pesci with the baseball bat? It could have been in the divine plan.
10. Considering that the objective of prayer isn't about getting what you want but is about getting to know God, there is no way of measuring it's success rate.
11. Why would God strike the audience dead in answer to an atheist's prayer? God isn't in the business of filling atheists' request.
12. Carlin challenging God to strike him dead is like a 6 year old kid challenging the President of the United States to nuke him. Why would POTUS respond to a kid's death wish?
@@TheMeefive 1-12 made up bs just like your buybull. None of it provable or believable.
It's wonderful seeing people trying to sit down and watch something that literally is in complete contradiction to their entire world view, it's really quite brave. Big love xx
Truth
Nothing brave about watching a comedian. I used to watch Carlin all the time when he was alive.If you don't know the difference between jokes and theology that's on you.
The genius of Carlin was his ability to make people laugh at themselves.Liten-up.You,re going to be here for a relatively short period of time.
@@TheMeefive The joke is that theology is a joke. lol
@@Cthulhoop And you have evidence that supports your conclusion?
Being raised in Christianity, going to Christian school, and studying it academically in college is what led me to atheism and philosophy. Lol 😆
College : another scam.
@@goldenruletv7301 a capitalist scam perhaps, but books are still books. Pick up a few.
Studying it and thinking critically about it would make anyone an atheist.
@Balder I remember studying early Buddhist atheist philosophy and thinking to myself, "hmmm this dude says about the same thing as Jesus, but tosses most of the religious metaphysics and oppression, is way more clear and direct, said way more, and his intellectual descendents not only weren't all dicks but many actually advanced Buddhist philosophy, hmmm I think it's time for a change."
Literally everyone who ever existed sinned lmao everyone but Jesus! He had to die! GOD PAID the price himself to get us into heaven! Look at the world lmao there are a lot of bad people but honestly the vast majority are getting saved "my father's kingdom has many mansions"! They are for us even the lgbt Jesus died for your sins too 😂😂😂😂😂 and if anyone ever says he didn't just ask them? Are you calling Jesus a liar! Cause that's literally blasphemy and should put their self righteous ass in there place! Lmao! Jesus died for the sins ALL SINS! God did not create us to torture us forever lmao! But if your one of them rich man and Lazarus types! MR burns, Lex Luthor type ass motherfucker! You better REPENT! OR YOUR GONNA FRY FOREVER.
As an atheist myself, I really respected your objective look at Carlin. Much love for the channel fam.
Same here... Dad's objectiveness, and Daughter's self-control! She deserves a trophy for that "Gameface". =)
organized religion, sucks I agree.
Jesus is where its at... and the fact that he gave his life for you, to forgive your sins that washes you white as snow. all you have to do is believe and accept the gift of salvation that he offers.
carlin denies christ's death on the cross, that's obvious.
the second carlin breathed his last on this planet, is the second he realized that he made a poor decision.. an afterlife apart from christ- exactly where you don't want to be...
think beyond your life here and now ladies and gents..
believe on the name of the lord Jesus Christ and be a new person, with the assurance of living forever in heaven worshipping the king of kings.
don't think for a second carlin was correct in his opinions,
read the book of John in the new testament and see for yourselves-- peace
@@kdesjarlais8200 And that is your opinion. And you are free to believe it. But just because you believe it doesn't mean it's true.
But if you're belief in a deity helps you to be a good person, then I am happy for you. Because in the end, being a good person is what this world truly needs (but, no god(s) are necessary to be a good person).
@@kdesjarlais8200 Any god that says "Love me and do what I want or suffer forever until the end of time" isn't worth worshiping in my eyes. That's not love, thats just a threat. Plus being the all knowing deity that god is, he already knows every single person that ever has and ever will sin. He knows this, but he creates these people, and then when they sin exactly the way he already knew they would beforehand because he is all knowing, he punishes them with eternal torture anyway. Please explain how that is love in any way, because it seems kind of fucked up to me.
Christianity began as sun worship, the stories about Jesus are symbolic.
He is just a personification of the sun, made into a god figure later on.
The sun "dies" for 3 days on December 22nd, the winter solstice, when it stops its movement south, to be born again or resurrected on December 25th, when it resumes its movement north.
In some areas, the calendar originally began in the constellation of Virgo, and the sun would therefore be "born of a Virgin"
The sun rising in the morning is "the saviour of mankind"
The sun is "The light of the World"
The sun "walks on water" is just the reflection of the sun on water/the sea.
"He cometh on clouds, and every eye shall see him", is just sun rays.
Jesus' "crown of thorns" is just the sun's glare, also know as a halo.
The sun's "followers", "helpers" or "disciples" are the 12 months and the 12 signs of the zodiac or constellations, through which the sun must pass.
The sun at 12 noon is in the house or temple of the "Most High": thus.."he" begins "his Father's work" at "age" 12.
The sun enters into each sign of the zodiac at 30 degrees, hense, the "Sun of God" begins his ministry at "age" 30.
The sun is hung on a cross or "crucified", which represents its passing through the equinoxes.
The vernal equinox being Easter, at which time it is then resurrected.
The reason why saviour myths are so similar with a godman who is crucified and resurrected, who does miracles and has 12 disciples, is that these stories were based on the movements of the sun through the heavens, an astrotheological development that can be found throughout the planet, because the sun and the 12 zodiac signs can be observed around the globe.
In other words, Jesus Christ and all the others upon whom this character is predicated are personifications of the sun, and the Gospel fable is merely a rehash of a mythological formula revolving around the movements of the sun throug the heavens.
.
I gave up on religion about 12 years ago. Best decision of my life.
Same
Wrong decision.
Ong bruh I grew up in a religious house hold but I dropped cause I realized everything was bullshit
@@marshallc.t.2554 No, dropping religion is never the wrong decision. Religion is the state of mind of believing in something without proof. Science is the state of mind believing in something we CAN prove.
religion has served its purpose in history. now its over. people who still cling to religion are pulling humanity backwards.
She is young. She has a lot to process. And it's a good experience.
She's lovely - she'll be fine, there's clearly a lot of laughs in that household.
Kania Dinda It would be interesting to see her in a year or so and see if this experience has had any effect on her. It definitely got her thinking.
Yeah, this must've set them straight. Definitely did to me
The light is coming on in her head and that's what's scaring her she's starting to get it. she's starting to understand what he was talking about. He on the other hand is concentrating on the comedy aspect of it and is totally ignoring the context of what George is saying., he's in deep and for him it will be a long journey to the surface. It's like when your kid when it's younger it's always asking why it's not 2 pester you it's just because they actually want to understand., the problem is we don't have the answers.
George spoke the truth 100 % 👍🏼
The part that really had her thinking was when George talked about prayers not being answered and people saying, well, it was Gods will. Well, if it's Gods will why are you praying to begin with? Which is a very good analogy.
I've thought the same thing - so I assume I'm not understanding what it actually is
Prayer is for communciation. Not getting things. You establish a relationship by trying to best align your will with Gods
We pray for things that aren't God's will cos we're human, not God. He's not stuck in the flesh like we are
“I was catholic till I reached the age of reason, five years old” George Carlin. That’s my story.
Me too.
"Religion was created when the first charlatan met the first fool."
- Voltaire -
Nice quote.
Yep, God created man but man created hyped up religion.
@@gurujr Nope. Man created both. Thousands upon thousands of gods, for as long as there have been people, everywhere there have been people. Making up gods is just something people do in a vain attempt to explain something they have no understanding of. Every single god is just peoples unwillingness to accept their own ignorance.
@@SarthorS In fact in the beggining we invented animisim, worshiping the forces of nature like animals, rivers, forests, lightnings, etc. Then came the gods, in many shapes and forms, usually in groups called pantheons, polytheism (greek pantheon, roman pantheon, Phoenician pantheon, etc... these gods were almost human with flaws like us and there were things you could learn from them. Then came God (hebrews, christians and muslims, yes all these people follow the same god, funny right?), all was set in stone, almighty, all knowing, nothing to learn from it, and all went to shit.
@@thekageryuu776 I was with you till the end. As bad as the Abrahamic religions are, there were many that came before (and after) that were so much worse.
the fact that a lot of christians and religious people in general follow the religion for ages without questioning it , seems so mind blowing to me
Christian’s do question it. I mean I guess they just haven’t told you. But they do. I questioned it for decades and turned from it while knowing it is true. Finally I returned recently. Don’t think people are just ignorant
It's also the same thing that happens around the world with political candidates.
They get a reward of eternal servitude without a rest. Oh, wait.
She is sitting there thinking “oh shit, this is all true, but I can’t say anything”
Exactly!
She did not seem to find this funny. Carlin was a genius
She may not be able to listen because she found it so upsetting that the words made no sense, it takes some people a while.
@@lordbrianrobertofevans5239 but the words make lots of sense.
exactly!! she knows religion is just something to instill fear and force people to do "right and wrong"
Ex-muslim here, my only comment is, just watch religious comedy, as much as you can. As long as you're thinking and laughing like in this video, that's the main thing.
So true.
Ex-muslim?? Arent that just a regular person??
@@redscul129 I mean, muslims are regular people too. Regular person is a very non-specific phrase
@@hareecionelson5875 everyone is a regular person until they have a tittle, dosent matter if is a belive or job, but point is, that saying that youre an ex-something is a bit odd, i dont find much people that does that, but whatever
@@redscul129 Are you so surprised that in the comments section of a video mocking religion there are people who talk about how comedy caused them to become atheist?
And even people with titles are still regular people, it's not an "either or". Nor is it odd for people who were once religious to refer to themselves as 'ex'.
Religion was invented when the first con man met the first fool" - Mark Twain.
thats like the shell game
🤣🤣🤣 love it!
WOW
@@BeyondAverageSkilled what's that game?
@@ryanolsen294 3 cups covering a ball and shuffle the cups around and have audience paid to pick one wity ball.
It still amazes me that religious people when confronted with the total absurdity of thier beliefs, still can't see just how ridiculous it is.
It's a hard pill to swallow. Took me 25 years to fully accept my loss of faith. Every time I heard an argument that flew in the face of The Bible, I simply told myself "I can find an explanation for this, gotta keep my faith" or simply ignore it until, well, I couldn't anymore.
Most of these people aren't ready to be unplugged. - Morpheus
Right! Which is why it's called "faith", not knowledge. And "faith" is never a path to truth.
Lol it won’t be ridiculous the day you all take your last breath. You’ll instantly believe.
@@JB-ej8zy You seem pretty damn confident for someone who's never seen God face-to-face nor can present him to others.
Religion: They can't all be right. But they can all be wrong.
Who says they can't all be right?
@@Serai3 They do by contradicting each other...?
This is the most logical quote ever. Religion fucking hates that!!! 🤣👍
@@Serai3 literally their written "word" that has been blindly followed for thousands of years. There are similarities, but the contradictions are even worse. How could a Christian or Catholic say that Gandhi will never be allowed into Heaven because he was Hindu and had a different belief system, yet did more for thousands upon thousands of his people PEACEFULLY than anyone of ANY other religion???
@@jasonholtzapfel9635 None of what you said answers my question. But that's okay. You're clearly more interested in showing off what you think you know about religion rather than answering what I asked.
If religion had facts & solid evidence they wouldn’t need faith whatsoever
Language and Programming Channel
Why don’t You explain to me what faith means
Faith is the exact opposite of fact
TheAxel65
Exactly I rest my case..!
belief that is not based on proof:
Yeah you could literally have faith in anything because it requires no backing. Such an insulting way to undermine your own intelligence, if you ask me
@@andyfrancis1048 You realize that science is entirely built on faith also... there are many many assumptions that are at the very basis of science. Doesn't make it any less valid..
"And he needs MONEY!" That's the line that always gets me laughing.
And wouldn't you think a the god of the Jews would be good with money?
For me it's always "...But he loves you"
Why so shocked? When you come out of your sheltered life as a christian, the REAL world actually sees things George's way.
My man, a Christian, just laid out the whole “gotta have faith” reasoning and followed it up with “that’s the hustle.” Even got that look from his girl.
That’s the hustle, indeed.
Haha, yeah, she had no idea that was going to be the ending comment!
First, she looked nervous and concerned about what Carlin said, then he explains the "gotta have faith" and she seemed calmed and convinced, then he drops the last comment and the terror creeps back in.
Yeah christians like these, who aren't prepared for debates or countering arguments on this subject makes us look bad...
@@christaylor7916 He's a true religious person, and understands what religion is all about. That's rare. You just gotta pick to either believe it even though there's no evidence, or not. There's no debating or countering arguments, when there are none that can prove it or disprove it. People that use arguments for this are not reasonable, the guy in this video is.
@@ivanjelenic5627 You can't be serious....right?
@@christaylor7916 What's the problem? You either believe it or not, that's really all there is to it. There's no proof for either god's existence or not, that is known to man. All the fancy and gruesome details people invent around it is superfluous. They do it as a group/identity thing, not as a religion, per se.
Carlin was a genius. You have to see his "it's a big club", it's so spot on it's scary.
This is amazing. Highly recommended.
Do "its a big club" next
....and we ain't in it
haven't seen that one yet. will look it up. thanks
@@aimmy79 Be prepared for some hard truth's in that one haha
OMG, he doesn't ACTUALLY pray to Joe Pesci. He was just trying to make a point. That said, kudos to both of you for watching something with at least a little bit of an open mind. Many believers would not be willing to do that. If faith can't stand up to the slightest bit of scrutiny, it must be pretty flimsy to begin with.
I would agree that religion and faith is definitely flimsy.
What's wrong with praying to Joe?
At the very end he says "Thank you! Joe Pesh-you!" (like god bless you) LOL
I've been saying for years, if you have to violently defend your belief, how strong is it?
As a kid I saw him as an atheist and the thought process is he is going to hell and those who listen to him is in danger of joining him. I no longer see it that way but that's how I use to view George and none believers. Now I am more agnostic in my views.
Girls reaction was hilarious "who hurt them" because she think if you don't believe in god you are broken in some way.
I come from religious family and grew out of it when i was teenager because realized it was only my emotional side that needed it for not feeling lonely etc. When i saw that it was only feelings based and stopped caring so much how other people would maybe guilt trip me for not believing, it was easy to let go and move on.
*People disagree with her* "What's wrong with these people? Who hurt them?" It's a comedy show honey, they aren't hurt. They're having a good ass time.
Three funniest thing about the video is watching her get triggered over every single joke he makes and taking everything too literal
@@nathanbuchanan5487 hey she's trying lol
Its the same as if we said "what is wrong with these people?" For believing the bs that is religion.
As someone not from there it amazes me how many Americans still believe all that crap to this day.
@@gcg8187 God is real that's a fact.
@@kevinangel7289 Heh, if it's a fact... Prove it.
"As long as you have faith, forget everything else you see"
Sounds like you're being fooled homie
Word
The literal definition of faith is the complete abdication of logic. Read something else that isn't the bible, and question everything you read and learn.
@Ai7A The Grey Jedi Explain!
@Ai7A The Grey Jedi imagine writing that and not seeing how it sounds like Tolkien novel
@Ai7A The Grey Jedi It's hard to believe in a god who is supposed to be the most enlighted being and sees eveyone in every level when he's so ensecure that he would send anyone who praise "fake gods" instead of him. This sound more like a freakn Light Novel where the "god" or "gods" are just people who are extremely powerful that needs "faith" as some sort of power source for their abilities so that's why they are mad on anyone of his followers that praise other "gods".
And yes any "good christian" can refute GC but as he said, the only evidence they can present is the bible itself. Which defeat the purpose since the bible isn't an evidence, it's a claim of something.
“There are good people who do good things, and there are evil people who do evil things, but for a good person to do evil things that takes religion.”
heard that, but not sure if that is really true, if you replace religion with ideology (which religion is for me) then it would be correct.... just my opinion
@@markspencer4385 You are quite correct, some good books on how average Germans, every day people, came to do evil things as Nazi's. Same thing under Lenin too no doubt, or Mao etc.
" We can contend with the evil that men do in the name of evil, but may the heavens protect us from the evil that men do in the name of good", Herrodias ancient Greek scholar, his words ring as true today as they did in his times.
Biggest bullshit i ever heard. People through history did bad things do to two major factors. The desire for power and influence.
@@Guciom and that is exactly what religion is about power and influence.
This might be the most astonishing reaction video I've ever seen. One person who's been around, been a Christian for a long time, thought about stuff and worked it out, and a young person who's never been confronted with these ideas before, each bringing their own perspective to this very confrontational bit. I've watched it multiple times, and it's eye-opening every time. Really cool video.
I was raised irish catholic. Got kicked out of catycism?. When i was in 4th grade. Why? Cause i asked to many questions. I was a normal kid. I was being told a story that didnt nake sense. When my mother asked why i was kicked out. My asking questions upset the class. So i was being punished cause the bs that i am being told is lame.
@@shawnyoung8752
If you actually read and really study the Bible, you start to realize how nonsensical it is really fast...
@@AlexHernandez-ee5hd Truly, the easiest path to atheism is reading the bible.
Losing one's faith is the most liberating experience possible. It's like clearing fog from a window that's been fogged for years. Carlin is doing god's work here 😉
Lol. I see what you did there.
Magic mushrooms and then Alan Watts. Problem solved haha
I believe in God but religion not so much
Once the fear of death, hell, heaven and jesus is gone. You are compltely liberated 😎
Legit! I lost faith after being part of a Christian cult. I was so done after that and I swear it felt like a million pounds was lifted off me.
Carlin is more of a philosopher than a comedian. Still one of the GOATs
for sure.... the evidence of this is that he is not funny
That's a dumb thing to say !!
Not Important to you
@@fayetopias that's right
@@notimportant3686 well that's your opinion which is "not important" because it's just wrong. Truth is a real bitch..
More George Carlin, he was raised Irish catholic in Hell’s Kitchen NY.all of his art is gold. He makes you look at things from a different perspective. Great reaction guys 👊👊
He was raised near Spanish Harlem by Columbia University
Passed on June 22 2008... he was family.
mrscary3105 He was for me and my father as well. I’ve been watching his standup since my dad introduced me to him in 1994 when I was only 10. I actually had tickets to see him live for the first time ever in October 2008. It felt like losing a family member but I’m so glad his wisdom lives on in his books, interviews and specials. He was one of a kind! RIP George 😢
He used to be Irish Catholic, then he was an American. You know, you grow...
Irish comedian Dave Allen (huge in the UK in the 70's) also questioned the ridiculousness of religion.
Father Ted was even more biting but in a hilarious way.
There SHOULD be questions on religion because religion is responsible for more war death than any other reason,so its kind of important to not only question it,but examine it thoroughly.
Faith in stories from a 2000 year old book proclaiming a supreme creator is in very short supply these days and people are increasingly believing their eyes.
I cannot put a case for ANY religion and i was raised Church of England.
George was right....question EVERYTHING.
It was so refreshing to see a christian who can empathise with other opinions, understand other perspectives while still talking about their personal spirituality.
I feel like I could have a theological conversation with you, without being told "I need to be saved". I really wish more christians were like you.
Don't expect that from a Born again. They will just tell you your wrong, your misunderstanding what God does, and join us or your going to hell.
“I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours.”
-Stephen Roberts
I love that George ruined this girls whole perspective on religion. She looks so upset I love it 😂😂
You love that she is upset?
@@Dman425 reality sucks. It's easier to feel better about yourself than to face reality
@@brendanmilligan7778 let her believe what she wants.. it isn’t hurting anyone. I just don’t understand the people here who are getting joy out of someone else’s pain
@ADcrooze what proves God’s existence?
@ADcrooze I never said anything you are accusing me of. You are getting defensive. Answer my question
More than anything, Carlin loved to make people think. He would say anything, frequently offending people, just to make them open their minds and question the world around them. Sometimes it was religion, frequently it was politics, nothing was off limits. He was a true genius.
"didn't grow up in it."
George Carlin grew up in the catholic church, was an alter boy, and went to catholic school. She assumed he is ignorant.
The daughter is like,
"Is this the real life?
Is this just fantasy?
Caught in the landslide
With no escape from reality"
Nice!👍
@Reischa Parker "it's got no God , religion is hypocrisy.
Cause I'm not easy come easy go ,
Jesus's followers were a little high on that weed though,
Anyway the wine smells it doesn't really matter to meeeeeeee, to meeeeee"
@Reischa Parker thanks
thats a beaut
I’m just a poor boy
I need no sympathy
Because I’m, easy come eat go.
_“My best advice to anyone who wants to raise a happy, mentally healthy child is: Keep him or her as far away from a church as you can.”_
- Frank Zappa
A effing men!
But you should explain to them why we don't believe in that stuff. Otherwise they'll never develop skepticism and may fall into the religion trap as an adult.
That seems a bit arrogant, why? If you don’t tell them why, (and it needs to be a reasonable why) then they most likely will be religious whether you like it or not.
My favourite Zappa quote "The mind is like a parachute. It doesn't work unless it's open"
@echidnasarf housewife en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Zappa
When I was a kid I struggled with religion. First I couldn't understand why god would make my brother disabled. Then I couldn't understand why, if there is only one god, why are there SOOOOO many religions and why can't we agree on how to worship god. Then I learned in school that slave owners in the US taught specific bible verses to slaves to justify slavery so black people would accept their position. I also learned that black people were not allowed to practice their religion, know their country of origin, or anything about their culture. that was the day I gave up Christianity because I didn't feel it was a religion compatible with black people. it also didn't make sense to me to pray to my oppressor's god for salvage from oppression. Then I learned in school about manifest destiny, the crusades, the Spanish inquisition, and world war ii, and I lived with horrible actions by my government in the name of god and religion. I realized man used the bible, religion, and religious differences to justify their atrocities. I felt even if there was a god, man was too corrupt to be his messenger. I wanted to believe in god, but I saw to much pain in the world. crime, poverty, excessive wealth, war, murder, and death, etc. finally I took a philosophy class in college and one question we debated was is the world the way it is because there is no god, because there is a god who makes the world a world of pain and despair, or because god gave man free will and man creates pain and despair. and if god gave man free will, is this what he intended with that free will.
Today, i believe in science and nature. I can see those things and I know they exist. i do not need faith to believe in things i can clearly see and feel. i do not believe in god
For me it was the concept of hell. Imagine you have a daughter that you love more than life. Then if she doesn't obey you or disowns you, you send her to some cellar where people torture her eternally. Why tf would you do that?!? What does that give to you? And this creature that made hell is supposed to be the embodiment of love. Just doesn't work.
Welcome to the club!!! Welcome to the REAL WORLD!!!!
@dyuloose thanks. I have beem atheist for 25 years. Religion makes zero sense. But when you are raised with it, you have to go on a journey sometimes to get away from it
“Religion is excellent stuff for keeping common people quiet. Religion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.”
― Napoleon Bonaparte
I love how people are welcoming me to being an atheist when I am 43 and have been atheist for almost all of my adult life 😂🤦🏾♀️😂🤦🏾♀️😂 i didn't just get here folks 😂😂😂😂 And why welcome me? Being atheist isn't a religion. You guys crack me up 😂😂😂
6:16 George Carlin always makes sense, simply because he's telling the truth, the inconvenient truth that the huge majority of people in this people are terrified of. People would rather live a comfortable lie than an inconvenient truth. This is how sad and pathetic our world is.
R.I.P. George. You were right about everything you said.
Beautifully put
He's not literally praying to Joe Pesci. He's being facetious to make his point.
"The man who prays is the one who thinks that god has arranged matters all wrong, but who also thinks he can instruct god how to put them right" - Christopher Hitchens
But doesn't "the man" already think that about everyone and everything? Just asking....
Hitchens didnt say that...he wouldnt be so deliberate or clumsy in his language. ..
@Born an Atheist! Happy Heathen! shit quotes...the literarry genuises would puke at your clumsy use of their words.. you fkn idiot
Carlin on this topic... 'What about God's perfect plan?... Any schmuck with a prayer book can come along fuck it up!' :)
@Artoria Pendragon do enlighten us lmao
Best comedian ever, may he RIP. He was an extremely intelligent man who told it like it is but in a way that had you on the floor laughing your ass off.
Why wouldn't he rest in peace he's dead so not much else to do......because he's dead!!!!
Thanks for hosting. I had a good time. The laughter was strong in me.
I enjoyed listening to your moderation. Good job. I look forward to my next visit.
Be safe and have fun.
She’s never heard these arguments before? Welcome to atheism, it’s great in here!
Rather...
ruclips.net/video/AaJGVYaO3Z4/видео.html
No, it sucks. When we die, we die forever. But hey, at least I don't have to worry about my atheist friends "dooming themselves to hell" anymore.
Its really not. Its usually filled with a bunch of self loathing angry people.
@@arbogast4950 You can find self loathing angry people on every part of this planet, "faith" abounds. As an accepting nihilist I find myself consistently more well adjusted than any conflicted theist
Theres a pretty good chance they live in a bible belt with not many atheists around them
“Faith” means believing in something with bad evidence. Having faith in something is not a virtue.
Bad evidence or none. It's funny, my friend just moved and a few days ago while unpacking, she found her old high school yearbook. My senior quote was "Belief without evidence is faith; belief against evidence is foolish." How appropriate the timing! :)
Worse. Faith means believing something in the absence of evidence and despite of evidence to the contrary.
@CALEB ALVAREZ Since the first con man met the first fool, as far as I can tell.
Not "bad evidence". "NO evidence".
@CALEB ALVAREZ You are right that the word has multiple different meanings. When you talk about putting your faith in God the word takes the meaning of trust. You can indeed use faith as a synonymous of trust and be correct, but I often find people trying to switch back and forth between those meanings in the course of an argument when is convenient.
I'm specifically referring to faith as when is used as a justification for a belief. In that context faith takes the place of the evidence and becomes the evidence itself. The "evidence of things unseen" I believe is what's mentioned in the bible.
In this context, when people have a good reason to believe something, they always use that reason. Its only when this falls short that people start to saying they take things on faith.
They’re both awkward because they know George is talking sense and they can’t refute any of it with logic.
See reason guys. Being raised in a religion, is no excuse to stick with it when you’re an adult.
Facts my G
Indeed: tradition and learned doctrine is simply a means to power. There is no truth in something so old ad christianity. It’s all a load of shit.
Now how are we supposed to deal with all the misery and torment we have to deal with? Simply accept it as a fact of life. It is ofcourse possible to will yourself free of sin.
#sarcasm
@@digimankompaman9577 they Need to wake up to reality, nothing ever goes as planned in this accursed world...
@@arian141 well, checkmate christians!
@delonix regia these are all good points, but the concept of free will is what really convinces me of the existence of God.
What I love about this woman is you can see her thinking, she’s not offended. She’s not upset, she’s thinking, and the fact that she’s still listening is fantastic. I love when people do this.
"I used to be Irish-Catholic until I reached the age of reason."- George Carlin; apart from the "Irish" this quote describes me quite accurately...
Except for the "Irish" and the "Catholic", that's me, too. I think the last time I believed in the biblical god I was seven. It took me a few more years to work my way past "well, the bible is clearly bullshit, but someone had to have created all this, so I guess I'm a deist now", to "I guess the Big Bang is no more ludicrous than a creator popping into existence out of nowhere - either way you have the same problem with the first uncaused cause", to "man, evolution sure makes a lot of sense", to "everything makes sense if it's just nature, and nothing makes sense if you add gods to the mix, so how does anyone sustain a belief in the divine in the age of information? Every single thing has a better scientific explanation than a religious one, and the natural view of the world doesn't suffer from half the inconsistencies plaguing the religious view." I finally landed on "organised religion is a bunch of evil, power hungry cunts exploiting the vulnerable, and it must be kept separate from the state at any cost. Also, tax the bastards."
@@austenhead5303 couldn't agree more!
@Language and Programming Channel Except they know one more thing than the religious ones: that religion isn't true.
"It is difficult to free fools from the chains they rever." - Voltaire
Have read Voltaire? Obviously not!
@Alberto Garcia ?
@Alberto Garcia Looking back on this comment to Donald Bird: Perhaps, I was rude. I think it's because I found Voltaire being misrepresented all over this thread. If you're wondering about my own level of Voltaire literacy/awareness, I refer you the post by @zaraki119 kenpachi119 in this same thread. He quotes Voltaire as having said something which was actually written by an online troll in 2009.
The same appears to be true with this guy's citation. Where does it come from? He doesn't know. He went to "brainy quotes" .com! Ha! As if brainy people need a website! Real brainy people quote things they've actually read.
"Voltaire firmly believed in God." - Daniel Gordon (scholar/expert) see (The Bedford Series in History and Culture: Boston, 1999. Part One: The Duality of Voltaire, Religion, p. 13.)
Further, I did searches, peer-reviewed scholarly searches, and I can find no such quote (freeing fools) from Voltaire. However, as stated in the @zarak comment/reply mentioned above, I've only read "Candide," a few scholarly treatments of Voltaire, and a handful of Voltaire's personal letters. Therefore, I could be wrong. Maybe Voltaire said this thing about "freeing fools;" however, a contextual understanding of Voltaire's philosophy makes it obvious that he would be including atheist in such a statement. True skeptics know...they don't know.
Fools, well, we see what fools do.
One last note, Donald Bird is exactly why Donald Trump and fake news rule the day. Billy Bob Thornton pointed out to Travis Smiley on an episode of Smiley's old PBS program (which is no longer available online so you'll have to take my word for it) that RUclips and Facebook has mislead morons, making them believe that just because every fool has a voice/platform they should use it. Wrong! Some people should stay quiet. Like Voltaire, I'll keep doing my part to correct this nonsense when I see it.
After his death Voltaire's house was used to print Bible's and store Christian literature. God had the last word as he always will.
She looked so uncomfortable, I was laughing my ass off.
I felt sorry for her. The mental anguish she was experiencing is painful.
I like how honest analytical and strong emotionally you both are; I'm an Atheist now but when I was a Christian, many years ago, I found that video looking for comedy on RUclips and found it deeply offensive, because it was true but always thought it'd be better to use other approaches and choice words, but it's Comedy and Genius Georgy always went for the guts, so now it makes sense why he choose that way
"I thought it was gonna be something I can agree with immediately, not something that would make me think"... 🤦♂️
Right?! 🤣🤣🤣
I fucking died
The problem is most people raised Christian haven't actually read the whole bible, the making of the Bible and how it was used to justify things like slavery in the early days of America.
Exodus 21,Instructions on how to own another human being as property.And the best part is listening to them bend over backwards to try and justify it,Its laughable.
And Native Americans used what book to justify owning slaves? We know what book the Muslims use for the same purpose. The Romans, Greeks, Egyptians, Incas, Numidians and every civilisation/empire that ever existed practised slavery (btw some still do - apart from the Christians who, after the enlightenment, campaigned against and eventually abolished it!). No credit for that though...
stevejpm1 Slavery in the Bible is the prime example that Christians constantly engage in time scale moral relativism.
I read the bible 4 times at confirmation camp and came out as satanist XD Holy shit he book of kings was brutal XD Lutherian evencelist bible, don´t know any of catholic or protestant or one of them fucked up cults that belive that islam is catholic hoaxs.
And it is very sad.
It's quite telling, & sad, when she says she's never heard this perspective before
FWPIII How is it sad? She is young. Now she’s heard of it, which that I believe to be sad. I don’t know your age or anything, but I am 100% certain lets say 5 years down the road or something you will have heard of this idea for the first time, but it’s been around for a long time. For that I will say “it’s sad you just heard of it”. Who cares she just heard of it. People learn different view points at different points in there lives. Seriously... Who cares! I’m willing to bet you just learned about Juneteenth? Come on be honest I am 100% sure you have. If not then fine, but you know good and well millions of Americans just learned about it.
@@Nebraska2927You answered your question - It's sad that she's just heard of "it". The options weren't laid out and explained to her when she was a child. If they were she wouldnt be so surprised. At a very young age my parents broke it down for me and gave me a choice. She was indoctrinated as most people are.
FWPIII I don’t know what your even talking about. I didn’t even have a question.
@@Nebraska2927 lol wow ok
As an ex-muslim (atheist now), that’s how the world is sadly. Nothing I could do about not discussing other perspectives with my extremely religious family. So I don’t like putting people like her down.
Dealing with a bad headache right now too, watching this made it a bit better at least, thanks guys. Love the videos and glad I found this channel
This was funny to watch... the face of a religious person listening to a guy who’s logic is so good that you just decide to figuratively “ear muff” yourself
I really love how open minded the dad is, i wish i had a dad like that, mad respects sir
She looks at him a little worriedly when he laughs so hard
haha!! facts.
Kind of like a "Dad... should we really be laughing at this? Isn't it too immoral to be funny?" look.
I don't think they know that George Carlin was born and raised Catholic...
It is so fun watching religious people see the truth, but still denying it. Maybe someday they will open their eyes.
Prayer:
Carlin is showing that prayer works at the same rate as chance. Praying to Joe was metaphorical.
exactly lol
This video in a nutshell:
- George Carlin: *Making loads of sense*
- The girl: *being absolutely oblivious of anyone else's walk of life*
- The dad: "How do you do fellow kids?"
Exactly, perfect description of it
Maybe, but at least they are not faking their reaction. Which is a lot better than most channels who you can tell force their "liking" of a person in the video.
Could see the cognitive dissonance in her face.
Fax
Gawd....couldn't have said it better...its like a sledge hammer lolll
Soooo true! Was thinking the samw
@Ai7A iRAL don't pretend to use logic in your beliefs you larping fool
Sounds a bit like wishful thinking, my friend. You can't know that. :) I'm an atheist, but as we can see here in the comment section, people often don't loose bias, faith and wishful thinking, just because they got rid of religion.
Unfortunately there are a lot of atheists who behave just like the religious. Still a lack of rational arguments and objectivity. :>
Religion - People killing each other trying to decide who has the best imaginary friend.
"If this is the best God can do, I am not impressed."
That one registered with her.
It’s a shame people are believing all this nonsense. God gave people “Free Will” and with that there comes destruction. If God wanted everything to be “perfect” God would have to remove the free will aspect and all of us would be perfect robots. God gave us the choice to either believe or not to. Either to do drugs or not to. Either to murder someone or not to. It’s our choice.
@@Nebraska2927 Agreed. People really believe that nonsense you spouted.
@@Nebraska2927 if free will cant exist without evil then it follows that there is no free will in heaven, doesn't it? or do people believe there is evil in heaven?
im not trying to be a dick, I am actually curious
Flin Grin Flin Grin Well I would say evil was tolerated at one point in heaven. God did cast Satan and his angels from heaven. Also in 1 Kings 22:19-23 we read of an event happening and evil being tolerated. Revelation 12:5-10 talks about God purging the evil out of heaven. Revelation 21 talks about Heaven after the evil has been purged. Way I see it is there is still free-will, but the intent or desire of evil won’t be there like there was in 1 Kings 22:19-23. To give an example from a worldly perspective is this. For my experience being a Christian when I went to a Christian school or when I’m around Christian friends I can honestly say I never had any kind of desire to do evil or more generically to sin. The only free-will I desired was to do good. The way I see it is this... Yes evil was tolerated at one point in time in heaven. God basically cleaned things up by casting Satan and his angels out of heaven. Now yes there is still free will, but now purity around people the desire won’t be there to sin. Revelation 21:4 says there is no more pain, sorrow, or death.
@@Nebraska2927 wow, what a response! thanks =)
"Way I see it is there is still free-will, but the intent or desire of evil won’t be there like there was in 1 Kings 22:19-23." - doesnt this imply that we can have free will AND be free of evil?
I've watched this comedy act at least 30 times. It still hasn't gotten old. He makes more sense than anyone else I've ever heard. 😎
I grew up listening to Carlin with my Father. My favorite comedian that makes sense and is hilarious 😂😆😆😆
He makes more sense as society evolves.
to answer the question, "Who is praying for this stuff?"...…Christians.
We pray for all kind of stuff, things most people will consider trivial.
to believe in the religion he's talking about and have such an open mind to at least hearing what he has to say without dismissing it immediately is very impressive. good video, and the audio sounds great with headphones!
George was actually raised Roman Catholic, and was a big part of his early life.
Check out his “Ten Commandments”... very funny!
Do you mean Catholic? There is no such thing as Roman Catholic.
@@PanglossDr there is Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox. If you don't know what you're talking about you should shut up.
@@chriswincek8672 I have been a Catholic 75 years. I can assure you I know the name of mt religion. Patronising idiot.
And a quick Google search reveals..
"Technically, “Catholic” (when capitalized) refers to the Christian Church founded by Our Blessed Lord on the Apostle Peter, and his successors (the Popes in Rome); while “Roman Catholic” only refers to a Catholic in the diocese of Rome."
I also grew up Catholic and I've heard it called Roman Catholic many times, although technically it's incorrect...
@@NovaNinja_ Catholics worship the sun god .
You do realise that the Joe Pesci part is part of his joke. He doesn't actually pray to Joe Pesci. He's trying to make you see his point.
Religion belongs to the Bronze age, and should have stayed there.
Go figure...
ruclips.net/video/AaJGVYaO3Z4/видео.html
@Dl hello ? is anybody there ? the light doesn't seem to be on in the house
things ARE answered , just putting a god in the singularity ... isn't a fucking ''answer''
the rest is all cooked and served , my friend ... don't need to know where the gas comes from yet , but we'll get the answer to that one too
@Dl I hope not
exactly, ancient history
@Dl A Universe comes from Nothing (Lawrence Krauss)
And Carlin wasn't "testing his faith": he was an Atheist who had no faith in religion.
He was making the point that it doesn't matter if you pray to anyone/anything or not: sometimes you'll get what you want and sometimes you won't. In that regard, prayer is completely useless.
As an agnostic, I distance myself from atheists. People who are convinced that god exists, don't like to be made a laughing stock of from people who basically rubbish religion. Sarcastic witty piss taking is not something a believer can associate with. Many atheists ridicule god squaders because logic and reality of life, over-ride fantasy figures. but if you rub people's noses in it, you'll never get them to think freely, they will only put their guard up, and turn on the ignorant light.
@@garthreid7114 I'm an Agnostic Atheist, not a pure Atheist, and was a Christian for 20 years of my life. I am respectful to Theists when they're respectful to me. Sadly, most (particularly Christians) are not and have a stereotype of who I am built into their heads (likely from their places of worship). It's only gotten worse over the years as being a "Loud Evangelical Christian" is all the more socially acceptable in rural America where I live in.
Oh she was NOT IMPRESSED 😂😂😩 I love her openness even though she has her personal beliefs.. Great Job Joy and Van 👑
Not impressed or just not enjoying the thought train that she'll later tackle. If she stays religious or not its a mental discussion that every human needs to have.
@@Jamer767 That looks more of a forced smile like I would have if I ate taco hell before a job interview.
The point where she looked at Pops like "You're goin' to church TWICE on Sunday" as he lost it was priceless. =)
I love her closed-minded openness! Makes for a good reaction.
common logic No doubt, Pops was really enjoying himself. His glee was contagious!
As an atheist, I really appreciated both of your open-minded and thoughtful approach to this subject. Though there were parts of this that visibly made your daughter uncomfortable she never got mad or stopped thinking and her acknowledgment of problems within the church is refreshing and telling of how bright and aware she is. Just found this channel but I'm already a big fan.
You have to understand the eternal purpose. Satan and Christ was in the garden Mankind chose Satan. Tree of life. Tree of knowledge of good and evil. Man messed everything up. Free will
so by that logic and to carlins point, if there is a god he's at least incompetent or doesnt give a shit
@@randygraham7693 You don't know if any of those statements are true. A HUMAN told you that, and that human was told by a different human, and so on. It's a game of telephone, and we all know how well that goes!
@@Chloe7270But i do know. Bloodline of Cain has corrupted everything
@@randygraham7693 so you mean to say the almighty all-knowing all powerful god didn't know that bloodline of Cain should be stopped. Secondly shouldn't Cain's bloodline end after the flood when only Noah and his family survived so for past 12000-6000(whatever is the consensus on the flood) everything should be as it is in heaven...
"...so he really worships Joe Pesci...?"
Me: *Not having enough hands to palm my face*
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🙌🏽
They’re very religious people; what made you think they’re smart?
@@zgjfinance2796 He's smart. He probably just doesn't want the church ppl coming for him by agreeing TOO much with Carlin. But he's a bit subversive for giving her another perspective. She's a young lady who grew up within church indoctrination. I could be wrong, but I'm guessing that was probably enforced by her mother, her grandparents... her whole family & community. This girl isn't dumb, she's just young and brainwashed. But her dad is doing his part to expand her mind a little. Don't shit on that.
I am athiest/agnostic. Please don't give us a bad name by bad mouthing ppl who are just being introduced to the very possibility that they've been fed a big fat lie their whole life. Especially young people.
@@themaggattack He's smart? The title says he's Christian.
@@eikuva8189 yes you're very smart. no one's impressed by you.
God and religions are holding us back as a species..
IKR, was thinking the same thing today. Imagine where the human species would've been if all that manpower, workforce, time and funds were invested in science , smh
@@hotshot9691 yup exactly. I can only imagine what we could be doing with the time we would have on our hands
This was really funny to watch.
The look on her face was priceless.
There's a reason faith is only ever demanded by religions and con men.
You forgot government, but I suppose it is just splitting hairs as all governments are composed of con men and government is a religion.
@@wesbaumguardner8829 whataboutism abounds.
@@JC-jo9bf That is not whataboutism. I was not deflecting anything. All of these lying manipulators belong in the same boat.
@@wesbaumguardner8829 The absolute "blind faith" that religion requires is nothing like government. Usually when faith is discussed as a horrible method to attain knowledge, the "faithful" get butthurt and say something like "everyone believes in something" because they want to falsely conflate belief and faith.
@@JC-jo9bf The blind faith of government is much worse because people do not even realize that they have it and many more people die as a result of government than other religions. People do not recognize the occult symbolism behind government as religious, when in fact, it is. They do not see the black gowns of judges as a high priest's garb. They do not see the judges box as a podium which the God of government's words (law) are espoused to the sinners (defendents.) They do not see elections, inaugurations, addresses, etc. as religious rituals. They do not see the prison terms and executions for what they are: human sacrifice. They do not see the casualties of the foreign peoples whose countries we invade for what it is: human sacrifice. The human sacrifice that is proudly acknowledged is the sacrifice of the lives of the soldiers (soul-diers) we send to invade. As if going halfway across the world and crossing some fictional national border with the consent of a group of corrupt politicians whom profiteer from resources stolen from other people could make it morally correct and good to kill people and plunder their resources. That is the tragedy of the religion of government.
He doesn't "pray" to Joe, He's showing the folly of praying to anything.
EXACTLY!! 💯👍
Bro that anology went miles above so many heads
I pray to Batman. If my prayers aren't answered, well then maybe Mr Freeze is being extra evil today
@@Sleepgarden Or Killer Croc. He's always making a scene.
That look when a young person realizes they really don’t know much. Lol
N9njoke man, she had the cat butt face of existential crisis
Lol. Yes
It was like hearing a 10 year old talk. But maybe she will educate herself
When she said "But your putting your faith in a another person though..." It made me think about Jesus.
Actually he's explaining Hindu philosophy... Hindu Gods don't give a shit... You're responsible for your own karma... You reap what you sow...
And the only divine plan is that "faith moves mountains"... Doesn't matter which "God"... In fact there's only one... Jehovah, Allah, Shiva are all different names because people in the world speak different languages.
I love that you 2 tackled this....I mean this is SENSITIVE stuff and you tried to come at it objectively. I loved George Carlin because he cracked jokes about everything and anything but he did it intelligently.
My guy is an atheist already. Girl hasn’t thought about any of this for 10 seconds ever in her life and this is hard
Keep her existential crisis going: react to How the universe is way bigger than you think and History of the entire world, I guess...
She's, what, 20-something? And she's never in her life crossed paths with the idea that God isn't real?
I mean I'll believe her if she says that, but I find that surprising. I'm not making fun of her, but she didn't have any response. She was completely unprepared to be confronted by that possibility. Is she aware that atheists exist?
No, he's not, unfortunately. I believe he said in another video (I want to say the Ill Mind Of Hopsin 7 video, but I don't fully recall) he's actually studying to join the clergy or something equally religious like that.
@@0pyrophosphate0 She is now 😂 But after 20-ish years of never being exposed to any ideas that differ from what she was taught over and over again the entire time.... it'll be hard for her to truly analyze these beliefs.
As an Atheist, I can see the rational wheels begin to turn in her head. Although she "appears" incredulous I believe a huuuge seed of doubt has been planted in her beliefs. Wait until she reads Exodus 21 and also realizes the 10 commandments comes after it, lol! Or that "God" instructed Moses to commit Genocide but keep all the "untouched" girls for themselves. Ya done did it dad, it's a wrap!
The best cure for faith is Bible eh?
Atheist from poland here
I love seeing belivers for the firs time listening to hard brake down of their faith
The cogs that are mooving on their own
Truly
If there is hope for human race
It is in those moments
Cheers!
@@stephenireland3816
No it doeas not
Inteligent desing needs inteliget desiner
And this desiner - acording to what you have just said - need to be desin too
And you have paradox going into infinity
In other words - stop useing bullshit arguments for bullshit ideas
The evolution was already prooven - stop clinging to dumb magic book - and move on
@@stephenireland3816
For the love of every black hole in the galaxy
You are 100% clasic creationist
Eternal god? Bulshit
If god is eternal - and have no begining and the end - he/ she/ it - cannot exist, cuz everything must have beggining, as a start of its existance. Logic.
Gravity is also a theory - we can only see efects of gravity, not gravity itself
Just like evolution - WE SEE EFECTS - and DNA science had proven we have about 90% dna from apes. Soo - yeah - "inteligent desing" my ass
If it was inteligent our bodies would be much better than are now. Like you know - they would look as they were desinged, and not evolved from other organizms. Have you heard of nightmare that is birth? Have you seen the god damm numbers of females who died in childbirth before modern medicine? Yahwe must be a total fuckall desiner if he desined this shit.
Time travel is imposible - that another point for yal stupid ass
But - i will humor you
Let say that god do exist
What - *ACTUAL* prove you have - that it is YOUR GOD
And bible dont count - its was created by nomadic tribe in the desert few milenia ago, just like many others holy books and myths - so this magic book is worth shit in any logical argument.
And even better - how can you prove that the real god is not Allah?
After all muslims also claim that their god is eternal, alfa i omega, without beginig or the end. And have magic book to prove it.
How can you disprove, something that cant be proven?
I could say that universe was created by "Star Dragon" - who is eternal, without begining or the end
*AND YOU HAVE NO WAY TO DISPROVE THIS*
After all, my dragon isint material being, and does not show itself to filfy non-belivers - like yourself
I live acording to his laws, and you will be damed for beliving in other uprovable gods
...
See the scale of bullshit you were raised to belive in?
Chalange yoursef and your faith - if you think it is strong enought.
Watch and listen - actualy listen - atheist arguments
Or - much simpler - read bible with critical eye - all of it - that helped me
God that allows: slavery, genocide, incest and need blood sacrifaces - is boolshit god - and that kind of god Yahwe and many others is presented as.
A non-material psyho terrorist - that what your god is.
For fucks sake - why people cant find nicer gods?
Like of wine and sex?
Of freedom and maybe even fun?
Why those psyho, blood loving bastards are soo popular?
Ah yeah - i know.
*THEIR BELIVERS MURDERED THE COMPETITION*
@@hatter3555 lol this whole God BS has Evolved and Grown over the Ages and for it to go away would require maybe about the same Time. Then Again maybe Humanity will never cease their worship of Greater Beings and who knows its God in our Era but Thousand years later something else will take its place and so on till we die out. JUST MAYBE
@@donniesmith3902
Aint no better time to keep pushing that boat to the raging storm. to be broken apart and sink, eh?
I like the dad. He is trying to make her understand things even though he might not 100% agree in these things
U're a amazing father. When you speak and stop to let her think by herself, oh man, thats GOlD.
It's interesting to see when someone is visibly questioning their beliefs. The girl on the right is seriously questioning hers as she's watching this video of George Carlin. Which is absolutely fantastic because without people like George Carlin, people would be mindless toward one perspective and point of view.
somone said: "if you're a black christian you have a real bad short term memory"
Same applies for black muslims. Look up the Arab slave trade if you think otherwise. You just don't talk about it much because it's easier to bash someone who has already admitted the wrongdoing, taken the blame and the shame and doesn't threaten to kill you if you offend their god and religion.
@@cuttight I didn't talk about it because that wasn't the topic of the video.
@@malotschino I'm just extrapolating.
@@cuttight oh, OK. Sorry then.
@@cuttight Actually, I think people don't talk about it as much because here in the US, Christianity is the most common religious belief, and has the most influence on people's behavior, education, and national legislation. Of course people will focus on tearing down the institutions that hurt people the most where they live instead of focusing on the ones hurting people elsewhere in the world.
Props to them for actually giving it a watch. I understand how hard it is to face the truth
not everyones truth is the same
@@josipbandic9948 subjective truth yes, objective truth no
religion is so bullshit , look at the pope and other leaders in what kinda cathedrals they live in with all the goods ,no taxes , really ? the biggest scam in human history !
@@knight0582 you worship the god not the pope im pretty sure all of us know how many pastors are pedophiles
@@josipbandic9948 erm, no. There is no my or your truth. Theres my opinion, my pov, but the truth is not subjective
Bravo to the two of you for having fun with this. Most religious folks I know would’ve turned their eyes the second they saw any of it.
"Faith is believing what you know ain't so." - Mark Twain
Yeah but Mark Twain also said "there once was a big black guy named Niggr Jim".
@@nkrav7160 but Twain was right
@@bryanpayne3793 I'm sure there was a big black guy named Jim, yes.
@@nkrav7160 Am talking about the faith quote
Faith is evidence of things hoped for and the substance of things that are not (yet)
George was in a world of his own, we miss him dearly and could really use him now
It's hilarious to me when people like Carlin or the idiots in these comments use the same tired worn out talking points as a case against God. Why is there evil, wars, famine or disease??? All really pathetic talking points and if you actually read the Bible, those are addressed time and again. People want to couple religion and faith into the same thing and it's not by any means. Religion is a creation of man to serve the interest of men, that is a point addressed in the Bible and it also tells you how to know the true intentions of a person. Faith is the knowing that there is a higher power and a reason for everything under the sun. Not to believe in something more important than yourself is a arrogant really pathetic existence to live.
He’s regretting his decision for sure.
She’s young, indoctrinated, and she’s watching this WITH HER DAD! That in itself is a difficult dynamic, full of tension, need to prove oneself, be obedient, respectful, etc.
But she’ll get it, she’s smart. She’ll start asking better questions of herself, various belief systems, religion’s hypocrisy, critical thinking, personal freedom, etc.
And her dad is a minister!
that’s her dad??
I think it happened at 4:53
Well honestly if people educated themselves on religion, many religions, the history of religion they would realize how similar they are to each other and how many times the Christian story alone has been done, there are at least 2 previous religions with the exact same story, one from east Africa, during the Egyptian era, and an Asian religion hundreds of years before the Egyptian one, they are literally the same story, god sent his son to sacrifice himself for his children of Earth and he was betrayed by close friend, and rose 3 days later to prove himself the son of god.
@@k_t530 The story of Jesus can be directly correlated to Horus on the hieroglyphs in the pyramids of Egypt but you can’t tell that to a Christian.
I really wish you were my youth pastor growing up. You’re very open minded and you also accept and incourage youth to think for themselves even tho you’re Christian. That’s very admirable and you’re doing it right my man 🙌🏼