Why Full Manual Controls Won't Work in EAFC 24
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 янв 2024
- Hey guys,
Today we are discussing whether or not full manual controls can work in EAFC 24. In my opinion, they won't fix the biggest problems at hand, nor will they actually make the game better. I believe that full manual controls will only work in very specific and easy situations, and will cause more of a blurred line between the actions of a user and the stats of a player. If the game were to go more manual, that's one thing, but going full manual is a different story.
TWITTER - / dagnaldiagonal
EMAIL - DagnalBusiness@gmail.com
Want to become a member? Join Here! --- / @dagnaldiagonal
PLEASE LIKE AND SUBSCRIBE!
THANKS FOR WATCHING!
#fc24 #eafc24 #fifa24 
Игры
![Eminem - The Death of Slim Shady [Album Trailer]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/X0HIrS6kUYI/mqdefault.jpg)
Forget about Manual controls, i wants my free TOTY Messi
bro last year or 2 years ago i bitched all year long about the 25k pack with a hero inside it and nothing :(. i couldve done that free messi if i wasnt at work :(
Snooze u lose
@@Oyabin20dw i did it in time and got bruno
@@CERWINVEGAredRINGpeople do other things in life other than sit in front of a screen waiting for content drop
Keep crying kid
International update:Morocco have been knocked out by South Africa 2-0,the game could have been tied in the 84’ minute but Hakimi missed the penalty
Reading this from Cape Town South Africa at 3:23am haha. Cheers!!!
I want my free TOTY Messi too btw
Assisted controls assist every aspect of the game.. Power, direction, contextual curve (even without curve button enabled), switching. The settings in the game even state that assisted passes AVOID opponents, you can't get much more assistance than that. As for stats, it is more than doable to play good passes with even 1 star teams. Me and my manual pro club team mates played a 1 star tournament recently and it was fine. The videos of some of the matches are on my channel so you can see for yourself. We have won about 30 division 1 titles in pro clubs as a manual club also. It is a much more rewarding way to play the game and even comes with some perks, as in different ways of scoring (not just the shoot button).
@pelnapkins4379 I'm about to watch your channel.
@@IsaacNavarro-dr5fr ok mate, the 1 star maches are videos titled Founders and PJ.
@@pelnapkins4379 You guys are the real deal 🫡 I played with the Manual 11 some time back and we played against you guys. I remembered your jerseys as soon as I clicked on your channel. That's awesome that you play with that team. There's a league starting in a couple of weeks. You guys aren't in it . I would love you guys to participate if you are still a team. I'm playing with the Manual 11 again but we need Real Manual FC in the league ✊.
Kingodastix PSN
What's your Gamertag ?
Good stuff man. I am an old school manual player ever since they introduced it in Fifa.
@@bkhan19 nice man. What is your PSN ID? Chances are we might have crossed swords in manual seasons at one point, if you played it that is. Used to play manual seasons alot between 2014-2018.
The only way FIFA becomes better is by everyone not buying games and Fifa points,just stop funding EA until its fixed.Sadly this is a dream and not reality
too many content creators thrive on dumping thousands to fifa, its sad
Your username describes EA Sports quite well.
Applaud you for making this video, I like and subscribe just on this kind of content. And by that I mean you’re not opening packs, talking about the best meta this or that, or hawking coin sellers.
That being said in the example with Sanchez not running into the acres of space. That’s actually good AI and the player with the ball is what changed his decision. The ball player is running to the same space, if he did that he’d bring a defender with him so instead he took the width leaving the space for the man with the ball.
Great vid will watch the rest
Those were my opinions. Gnight
You should talk of this toty event so far
There's nothing to talk about apart from how fucking shit it is/was lol
As an eFootball player we have this debate on Reddit all the time and all of your arguments work on that game too.
I'm not sure I agree. If both play on FUMA it equal. But is if people play level 1-3 it's too easy to win over a FUMA player. Unless he's very good.
@@SneakersDK in a perfect world.... Sure. But most players are casual and they won't go through the process of learning FUMA.
I just want the gameplay of fifa 15-17 with updated squats.
another great video
Your point about scoring and passing when the actual person holding the control hasn’t made a mistake is perfect. Striker or CB if I shoot a normal shot and aim it correctly it should score.
Don’t even get me started on 5 yard passes.
Player stats from 1-99 should be purely physical. I.e pace, strength, agility, jumping etc
Technical stats should be replaced with tiered traits like in FC24 but more comprehensive and reliable and should cover actual scenarios in game i.e defensive heading, Tier 1,2 & 3.
Where actual human player timing is equal, physical stats and tiered traits will determine the outcome between two players on the pitch.
A 6ft 5 strong and aggressive CB with defensive heading tier 3 who hasn’t made a clear error in play will NEVER lose a header to a 5ft3 winger with poor power stats.
Shit dude. Did you come up with this yourself I like it a lot
I was here at 4k hope u blow up brother
Maunual Controls are too difficult for 99% of people. But fc/fifa Manual Controls is the most Realistic sports simulation ive ever played. So it's biggest impact is the complete change of the experience. Point in a direction and press X or ⬜ and you complete a pass. That is opposite of Manual Controls. So all passes and shots are treated with much more care and are much more respected by your opponents because they know how difficult the shot/pass was. The people that play Manual are a close community. If you meet someone who plays Assisted, you forgot them before the game is over. If you meet someone who plays Manual, you still know them 10 years later and im speaking from experience.
It's not for everyone bro.
Manuel controls is a myth ea came up with to yo gaslight y'all 😂
'manual'
I played long enough to notice that precision shooting really makes interesting goals and opens up new possibilities. Semi or manual passing though, no way in this ridiculous state of game, non-assisted passing not only needs correct direction but needs correct power as well. Impossible to achieve with middle is this much choked and impossible to pull out in consistent manner.
I still use precision shooting, because it stops me trying to score impossible angles that I can at least try with assisted.
The manual shooting is hard nut to crack in FC24. efootball 24 does it better.
WE WANT LONGER VIDS WE WANT LONGER VIDS❤️❤️❤️
You forgot a thing, manual passing inputs need to be noticeably longer than assisted inputs, especially in and around the box. In assisted controls, a simple tap of pass button is enough for even 15-20 yards short passes but on manual, it takes slightly longer, like a couple of hundred milliseconds. This can worsen the already delayed and inconsistent gameplay that we get in most of our games. Because even such slight additional delay to the player's expected action is enough in already poorly responsive gameplay to significantly affect the experience.
This balances out on both players sides if they are both on manual controls, yes, but I think we can agree that it worsens the gameplay experience in tight situations.
Like you said, manual controls can theoretically increase skill gap and bypass a couple of issues, but doesn't really solve anything or mean better experience for players in current state of the game, with the fundamental problems it is plagued with. In fact, it can cause new problems.
I always use r1 triangle when I shoot in a situation like that Horan one, it’s actually insane that a threaded through ball input is better to shoot than actually green timing a shot input but that’s ea for ya
I play manual on FC24 seasons as single player. Unfortunatley the matchup is broken and often I get matched up against assisted/semi assisted or players who have no clue how to play manual. Very very rarely do I get a solid manual player.
Dagnal Diagonal, your videos are always very, illuminating. ❤️
You understand my pain😮💨😭
lmao just got the vid in my recommandation in the second she went out
ONCE in my life since the start of this game, like actually one match, i had a GOOD GAMEPLAY and it was like my ping was 0 like i was playing squad battles. My players did everything instantly, instant turns, good touches etc. I instantly thought, we are actually suffering daily from the gameplay, when it can actually feel good but we still deal with delayed inputs, inconsistent gameplay. I dont think i had any internet boosts just for that specific match so i have no idea why we have to play with this deep code error type of thing, i guess they cant fix it or improve servers or whatever mistake i have no knowledge talk much about
My guy looks like jack grealish💀💀
Talk about the Messi situation
6th video of urs i am asking you to make a video about the most fun and not at all rage inducing part of the game of the century defending!!
N maybe that they didnt improved the AI but actually made it worse!!
Someone count how many times he said inconsistent gameplay 🙏
My new favourite youtuber
TAJIKISTAN MENTIONED RAAA 🇹🇯
it would be actually amazing if there would be a competitor to EA. Manual passing for example the flat pass and high passes plus lobs it is just much more fun!!!
Is that not the most important thing? No instead railway passing system, tricks tricks tricks tricks and lots of money making by selling cards. It is almost arcade level.
The hugh problem with fifa 24 is that the manual passing for high balls is the poorest every invented in this game and the worst the high lob.
Compared to other passes it rather goes way too far too quickly or not at all. The flat pass in the opposite is too lame.
It could be all solved still having player stats. The ball would have a higher range arrival points with worse stats or what would be much better, worse players give you less time to find the right dosage.
The controvertial opinion - If you want to make game more realistic, just get rid of stats in some way, and stick more towards playstyles
Just leave the crucial stats, that couldnt be determine by aiming like pace, def stats, physicality etc. - delete finishing, pass stats and stick more to the "AI" stats
Then passes and shots would only be depending where you gonna aim, all depends how skilled player is
If positioning, ability to make creative runs in attack, marking players would be determine by stats it would make much more sense [even tho now we see "Att positioning", its not doing much tbf xD ]
With well working playstyles this can help so much, without needing the stats point
Just like you show with that Tomiyasu scenario - if he would have something like Long Ball Pass and you would aim correctly, then by this playstyle your pass should deliver all the time
Without the playstyle it shouldnt be consistent - sometimes you gonna hit it, sometimes you not
Add some other playstyles for Long shots, driven shots etc. and it would look great
Seeing pros in tournaments with manual settings would be so fun to watch and it would show who is aiming the best out of them - the skill gap would be there
Overall manual settings should work by the rule "High risk, high reward"
But just like you said, with thats sheeeeet gameplay, with AI of the players being low AF, with cheaters on PC being everywhere this cannot be done...
Yh ngl I just want my Toty messi
My idea about fc 24 is
I don’t think is that the animations are bad but they need to categorise them and implement these animations to the worst player at something to the best player at something, then they would need to remove dda as it’s just stupid and makes the game un fun and they need to improve more on the inputs so it can work, this game has been horrible
I just want to play manager mode and I can't even do that....but EA don't care about guys like me who don't put in loads of money in UT....
I noticed with manual sometimes my player won’t even know I’m passing to him and it won’t lock on to him and he won’t go for the ball and it won’t let me switch to him to get it.
Just nerf VVD .. Everyteam I face has some form of VVD .. just feel awful to even kickoff after seeing tat at start of the game.
terrible fifa this year im definitely not buying 25
so you want player stats to determine every outcome? im sorry but having everything on assisted just removes all that is football from these games. its like playing shooter game where aiming was automated, where stats of your gun and timing of firing determines the outcome. you are also wrong why manual controls wont on current fifa´s. back in the day playing full manual controls was the best fifa experience. it got progressively worse over time. because they made the controls more assisted and to compensate that they made the AI defending much better. where nothing but inc perfect passes would get through. it just became too difficult to enjoy. also if they wanted they could still very easily make the player stats matter even if it was full manual.
Tbh I play better with manual options
Assisted is for unskilled noobs
This game is TERRIBLE, EA do something!
Hi
Hello
Your profile pic is goated 😎...but maybe not kill them 😅
This effed up community should understand this whole game is effed up. No excuses should be made for them.
Not realistic at for all its BS animations. I want to play a football game with my own tactics and not a forced pattern. Trash of a game.
I hope UFL drops sooner than later, for the sake of the online community and the sport of football itself.
SO BASICALLY YOU ARE COMPLAINING THE SLOW PACE OF THE GAME CUZ IS MORE REALISTIC?
YOU K KNOW NOTHING
I'M FULL MANUAL CONTROL SINCE 2011 AND I PROMISE YOU, YOU ARE NOT GOING TO SEE THE DIFERENCE BETWEEN ME AS A MANUAL CONTROLLER PLAYER AND OTHER VERY GOOD ASISSTED PLAYER
DONT ASSURE THE THING THAT DON'T KNOW
Who even takes this game serious? It's not like we had a fifa game that wasn't scripted in the last 10 years. You can talk "improving gameplay" how much you want, it's not like it will matter when the games result is predetermined.