I literally get goosebumps at this scene every time I rewatch. Everything is so well done: the directing, acting, musical score and the cinematography is just top tier.
This was lost in its prime. Look at the writing, these cats were also great actors, very good chemistry. Just take a look at the way they filmed this scene; when desmond sees hes accidentally killed the man, he knows hes alone and must get back incase its real. The shot of him running from the rock area let's the viewer feel how far away from the hatch he is, it has a bad dream like quality. Then that immediate cut shot from inside the hatch showing desmond entering with that added sound effect that sounds like *DSHHHHOOON* with concrete dust falling on his head, everything shaking and a voice saying SYSTEM FAILURE.... The camera man running up and then back, the wet floor was also a fantastic touch, showing how some pipes may have burst from the shaking. I also love the frustration trying to open the door with the wheel, we see desmond opening it as if his internal dialogue is saying "CMON YOU FUCKING DOOR OPEN, I HATE THIS DOOR, NOWS NOT THE TIME FOR A DOOR LIKE THIS!!" When this show wanted to, it could make unforgettable magic.
I always wondered, when John was working so hard on getting into the hatch, why didn’t ever think to just look around for another door? With the layout of the station, that main door couldn’t be more than 50 yards from the mysterious hatch.
There’s a ton of plot holes. For example at S4 E9 John Locke and Ben say they need Hugo to find Jacob’s cabin becasue John doesn’t know how to get there, but shouldn’t Ben know how to get there if he’s been there many times before and he’s lives on the island for so long. Ben then takes them there so they didn’t need Hugo. Well at least that’s what I think becasue I’m about to start episode 11 right now becasue they might need Hugo for another reason or soemthing
@@lllsquatlll1406 I’m wondering if it’s one of those instances of retconning where the writers changed their minds later. Or, perhaps Ben was just lying before, but I’m not sure what that motivation would be. Or also, mayhe Ben knew something about Hugo’s importance as a candidate and needed a reason to make sure he’d come along. I forget, was that during the time when Hurly was struggling with his mental health and beliefs around the island? Maybe Ben wanted him to be there to make sure he was a believer.
@@zainahmed6502 And even if they had found the main door under all that vegetation, it wouldn't have helped since they would still need dynamite to blow it open. In fact, they would have needed even more dynamite since that entrance has multiple doors you need to pass through.
This scene is amazing and one of my favorites in Lost. Desmond's reaction to seeing Kelvin dead isn't just because he's realized he's killed him, but also that there truly is no one left besides him to push the button now and he has to carry it alone now.
In part one of this episode, he explains to Desmond how we used to work for the army and get people to torture others. After his deployment ended, he joined the Dharma Initiative. Sure enough, back in Season 1 during I think Sayid’s third flashback (when he first tortures someone for the CIA to learn where a pilot is) this is the man who recruits him.
Desmond could have learnt some automation from Homer Simpsons and rigged up something like that bird that tapped the ANY key in that episode where he got really fat. Some Rube-Goldberg-esque machine that every 108 minutes pressed all the keys in sequence. Or the dunces at Dharma could have put in automation from the beginning.
the Pearl station was made as an experiment on the guys in there observing the Hatch station, to monitor the wellbeing and behaviour of the people pushing the button, so they didn't want the computer to be automated. Though it is odd that they didn't have a way for it to be automated as backup in case something happened with the Hatch staff where the button wasn't pushed, like if they were both somehow locked outside the station so that even the fail-safe wasn't accessible.
When I was younger watching this show I used to think it was unrealistic that they didn't do this, but now having worked at dysfunctional organizations it's entirely believable to me that the DHARMA Initiative threw together this haphazard solution in a crisis assuming it would be automated later, but then no-one wanted to risk touching it afterwards because they didn't want to be the one responsible for fucking it up.
@@AndorianBlues That is the best explanation I've ever seen for a plothole on Lost lol. If I ever get around to making a Lost analysis like I want to I'm quoting you on that.
@@AndorianBlues Plus automation makes people complacent. The Swan crew would just say fuck it and leave the station days at a time or abandon it altogether since it's all automated anyway... Until the day the system fails and no one's there to push the button manually.
That could be an error. But at the same time, this moment is the only time we ever see Desmond leave the Hatch. Even after this, he’s inside the hatch for another 16 or so days while the Oceanic 815 survivors were out and about. Desmond probably kept taking the vaccine because it’s better to be safe than sorry. After all, he had been taking it daily for 3 years beforehand.
@@RadagonTheRedhe may not have done much cardio too since he never went outside during the first three years on the island so it makes since why he got tired so easily (tho desmond did some lifting)
I literally get goosebumps at this scene every time I rewatch. Everything is so well done: the directing, acting, musical score and the cinematography is just top tier.
This was lost in its prime. Look at the writing, these cats were also great actors, very good chemistry. Just take a look at the way they filmed this scene; when desmond sees hes accidentally killed the man, he knows hes alone and must get back incase its real. The shot of him running from the rock area let's the viewer feel how far away from the hatch he is, it has a bad dream like quality. Then that immediate cut shot from inside the hatch showing desmond entering with that added sound effect that sounds like *DSHHHHOOON* with concrete dust falling on his head, everything shaking and a voice saying SYSTEM FAILURE.... The camera man running up and then back, the wet floor was also a fantastic touch, showing how some pipes may have burst from the shaking. I also love the frustration trying to open the door with the wheel, we see desmond opening it as if his internal dialogue is saying "CMON YOU FUCKING DOOR OPEN, I HATE THIS DOOR, NOWS NOT THE TIME FOR A DOOR LIKE THIS!!"
When this show wanted to, it could make unforgettable magic.
Are you feeling it now Mr Krabs?
feels bad mr krabs
2:57 me to my wife every Sunday morning
I thought it was going to be Desmond yelling “you stole my life!”
@@drysplash196Thats a good one too lmao
My dad just started watching Lost again after like 13 years. This scene came to mind and I had the sudden realization that Mr. Crabs was in this show
I always wondered, when John was working so hard on getting into the hatch, why didn’t ever think to just look around for another door? With the layout of the station, that main door couldn’t be more than 50 yards from the mysterious hatch.
There’s a ton of plot holes. For example at S4 E9 John Locke and Ben say they need Hugo to find Jacob’s cabin becasue John doesn’t know how to get there, but shouldn’t Ben know how to get there if he’s been there many times before and he’s lives on the island for so long. Ben then takes them there so they didn’t need Hugo. Well at least that’s what I think becasue I’m about to start episode 11 right now becasue they might need Hugo for another reason or soemthing
@@lllsquatlll1406 I’m wondering if it’s one of those instances of retconning where the writers changed their minds later. Or, perhaps Ben was just lying before, but I’m not sure what that motivation would be.
Or also, mayhe Ben knew something about Hugo’s importance as a candidate and needed a reason to make sure he’d come along. I forget, was that during the time when Hurly was struggling with his mental health and beliefs around the island? Maybe Ben wanted him to be there to make sure he was a believer.
@@lllsquatlll1406 It was pretty clearly explained in that scene that the cabin moves and not everyone is able to find it.
If you find a hatch on a middle of a tropical island inn middle of nowhere, i dont think you would assume
theres probably another way into this thing.
@@zainahmed6502 And even if they had found the main door under all that vegetation, it wouldn't have helped since they would still need dynamite to blow it open.
In fact, they would have needed even more dynamite since that entrance has multiple doors you need to pass through.
Hank went off the deep end once Connor was killed.
A spook for 10 years leads you to an island, in which to push a button a computer. Then you end up dying on that island, why be a spook....
Desmond- “ You stole my life” imagine it being basically your whole life and it was manipulated!
I love how Desmond says the place going to shit right in from of him but yet doesn't believe it's real later in the timeline.
Because he was literally going crazy
So this entire show happened because Kelvin accidentally tore his suit like 20 feet from the door.
This scene is amazing and one of my favorites in Lost. Desmond's reaction to seeing Kelvin dead isn't just because he's realized he's killed him, but also that there truly is no one left besides him to push the button now and he has to carry it alone now.
So the cause of this whole show was a torn hazmat suit?
Desmond : I crashed your plan 😮😮😮😮
@@SamirKhan-te6zuhow did you manage to do that?
@@SamirKhan-te6zu Plane or plan or both?
Same actor who played Desmond’s partner played the man who gave sayid torture tools.
It's the same man.
@@Liaros_ how
@@bryan6434 In lost the secondary characters are recurring in the stories of various survivors. It's the same guy in the story.
@@Liaros_ like Jack father ? U still not explaining how he ended up on the island before Desmond ?
In part one of this episode, he explains to Desmond how we used to work for the army and get people to torture others. After his deployment ended, he joined the Dharma Initiative. Sure enough, back in Season 1 during I think Sayid’s third flashback (when he first tortures someone for the CIA to learn where a pilot is) this is the man who recruits him.
Desmond could have learnt some automation from Homer Simpsons and rigged up something like that bird that tapped the ANY key in that episode where he got really fat. Some Rube-Goldberg-esque machine that every 108 minutes pressed all the keys in sequence. Or the dunces at Dharma could have put in automation from the beginning.
the Pearl station was made as an experiment on the guys in there observing the Hatch station, to monitor the wellbeing and behaviour of the people pushing the button, so they didn't want the computer to be automated.
Though it is odd that they didn't have a way for it to be automated as backup in case something happened with the Hatch staff where the button wasn't pushed, like if they were both somehow locked outside the station so that even the fail-safe wasn't accessible.
Desmond killed the Kurgen😂
There Can Be Only One
@@ZuluRomeoone constant
Couldn't they program the Apple ][ to do it automatically?
In the Swan station orientation film, it is implied that no attempt at automation should be made.
When I was younger watching this show I used to think it was unrealistic that they didn't do this, but now having worked at dysfunctional organizations it's entirely believable to me that the DHARMA Initiative threw together this haphazard solution in a crisis assuming it would be automated later, but then no-one wanted to risk touching it afterwards because they didn't want to be the one responsible for fucking it up.
@@AndorianBlues That is the best explanation I've ever seen for a plothole on Lost lol. If I ever get around to making a Lost analysis like I want to I'm quoting you on that.
@@joelpetersmedia feel free to!
@@AndorianBlues Plus automation makes people complacent. The Swan crew would just say fuck it and leave the station days at a time or abandon it altogether since it's all automated anyway... Until the day the system fails and no one's there to push the button manually.
resetting the BNWAS really do be like that
Just someone please remind me, how Desmond end up doing that in the hatch
I noticed an error in the story, if he knew that you can't get sick from going outside then why did he ask the survivors if they got sick?
He didn't know, he still used the vaccines just in case, he probably had a doubt and used that question to make sure
That could be an error. But at the same time, this moment is the only time we ever see Desmond leave the Hatch. Even after this, he’s inside the hatch for another 16 or so days while the Oceanic 815 survivors were out and about.
Desmond probably kept taking the vaccine because it’s better to be safe than sorry. After all, he had been taking it daily for 3 years beforehand.
Why is he sweating
Because he just ran a mile through jungle on a hot tropical island to get back to the station.
@@RadagonTheRedhe may not have done much cardio too since he never went outside during the first three years on the island so it makes since why he got tired so easily (tho desmond did some lifting)
@@mayaherar8685he cycled dumby